Classification of swords
This article possibly contains original research. (October 2012)
The English language terminology used in the classification of swords is imprecise and has varied widely over time. There is no historical dictionary for the universal names, classification or terminology of swords; a sword was simply a double edged knife.
Historical terms without a universal consensus of definition (i.e. "arming sword", "broadsword", "long sword", etc.) were used to label weapons of similar appearance but of different historical periods, regional cultures and fabrication technology. These terms were often described in relation to other unrelated weapons, without regard to their intended use and fighting style. In modern history, many of these terms have been given specific, often arbitrary meanings that are unrelated to any of their historical meanings.
Some of these terms originate contemporaneously with the weapons which they describe. Others are modern or early modern terms used by antiquarians, curators, and modern-day sword enthusiasts for historical swords.
Terminology was further complicated by terms introduced or misinterpreted in the 19th century by antiquarians and in 20th century pop culture, and by the addition of new terms such as "great sword", "Zweihänder" (instead of Beidhänder), and "cut-and-thrust sword". Historical European Martial Arts associations have turned the term spada da lato into "side-sword". Furthermore, there is a deprecation of the term "broadsword" by these associations. All these newly introduced or redefined terms add to the confusion of the matter.
The most well-known systematic typology of blade types of the European medieval sword is the Oakeshott typology, although this is also a modern classification and not a medieval one. Elizabethans used descriptive terms such as "short", "bastard", and "long" which emphasized the length of the blade, and "two-handed" for any sword that could be wielded by two hands.
Classification by hilt type
The term two-handed sword, used as a general term, may refer to any large sword designed to be used primarily with two hands:
- the European longsword, popular in the Late Middle Ages and Renaissance.
- the Scottish late medieval claymore (not to be confused with the basket-hilted claymore of the 18th century)
- the Bidenhänder sword favoured by the Landsknechte of 16th-century Germany.
The term "hand-and-a-half sword" is modern (late 19th century). During the first half of the 20th century, the term "bastard sword" was used regularly to refer to this type of sword, while "long sword" or "long-sword", if used at all, referred to the rapier (in the context of Renaissance or Early Modern fencing).
The term "single-handed sword" (or "one-handed sword") is a retronym coined to disambiguate from "two-handed" or "hand-and-a-half" specimens. "Single-handed sword" is used by Sir Walter Scott. It is also used as a possible gloss of the obscure term tonsword by Nares (1822); "one-handed sword" is somewhat later, recorded from c. 1850.
Apparently, many swords were designed for left-hand use, although left-handed swords have been described as "a rarity".
Great swords or greatswords are related to the long swords of the Middle Ages.[dubious ] The great sword proper was developed during the Renaissance, but its earlier cousin, the Scottish Claymore, was very similar in size and use, like the "outsized specimens" between 160 cm and 180 cm (approx. the same height as the user) such as the Oakeshott type XIIa or Oakeshott type XIIIa. These swords were too heavy to be wielded one-handed and possessed a large grip for leverage. The point would be to hold the grip with one hand at the top of the grip, and one hand at the bottom. The top hand would push, and the bottom hand would pull; this gave extra leverage thus the sword would be easier to swing, ignoring much of its weight.
The Scottish name "claymore" (Scottish Gaelic: claidheamh mór, lit. "large/great sword") can refer to either the longsword with a distinctive two-handed grip, or the basket-hilted sword. The two handed claymore is an early Scottish version of a greatsword.
The Zweihänder ("two-hander") or Beidhänder ("both-hander") is a true two-handed sword, in the sense that it cannot be wielded in only one hand. It was a specialist weapon wielded by certain Landsknechte (mercenary soldiers), so-called Doppelsöldners.
Classification by blade type
Double-edge and straight swords
These are double-edged, usually straight bladed swords, designed for optimized balance, reach and versatility.
Jian (simplified Chinese: 剑; traditional Chinese: 劍; pinyin: jiàn; Cantonese: Gim) is a double-edged straight sword used during the last 2,500 years in China. The first Chinese sources that mention the jian date to the 7th century BC during the Spring and Autumn period; one of the earliest specimens being the Sword of Goujian. Historical one-handed versions have blades varying from 45 to 80 centimeters (18 to 31 inches) in length. The weight of an average sword of 70-centimeter (28-inch) blade-length would be in a range of approximately 700 to 900 grams (1+1⁄2 to 2 pounds). There are also larger two-handed versions used by ancient and medieval armies and for training by many styles of Chinese martial arts. Two handed jians from the time of the Chu (state) and Han Dynasty were up to 150 cm (58 in) long.
These days, the term longsword most frequently refers to a late Medieval and Renaissance weapon designed for use with two hands. The German langes Schwert ("long sword") in 15th-century manuals did not necessarily denote a type of weapon, but the technique of fencing with both hands at the hilt.
The French épée bâtarde and the English bastard sword originate in the 15th or 16th century, originally having the general sense of "irregular sword or sword of uncertain origin". Qui n'était ni Française, ni Espagnole, ni proprement Lansquenette, mais plus longue que ces fortes épées. ("[a sword] which was neither French, nor Spanish, nor properly Landsknecht [German], but longer than any of these sturdy swords.") Espée bastarde could also historically refer to a single-handed sword with a fairly long blade compared to other short swords.
Joseph Swetnam states that the bastard sword is midway in length between an arming sword and a long sword, and Randall Cotgrave's definition seems to imply this, as well. The French épée de passot was also known as épée bâtarde (i.e., bastard sword) and also coustille à croix (literally a cross-hilted blade). The term referred to a medieval single-handed sword optimized for thrusting. The épée de passot was the sidearm of the franc-archers (French or Breton bowmen of the 15th and 16th centuries). The term passot comes from the fact that these swords passed (passaient) the length of a "normal" short sword.
The "Masters of Defence" competition organised by Henry VIII in July 1540 listed two hande sworde, bastard sworde, and longe sworde as separate items (as it should in Joseph Swetnam's context).
Antiquarian usage in the 19th century established the use of "bastard sword" as referring unambiguously to these large swords. However, George Silver and Joseph Swetnam refer to them merely as two hande sworde. The term "hand-and-a-half sword" is modern (late 19th century). During the first half of the 20th century, the term "bastard sword" was used regularly to refer to this type of sword.
The Elizabethan long sword (cf. George Silver and Joseph Swetnam) is a single-handed "cut-and-thrust" sword with a 1.2-meter-long (4 ft) blade similar to the long rapier. "Let thy (long) Rapier or (long) Sword be foure foote at the least, and thy dagger two foote." Historical terms (15th to 16th century) for this type of sword included the Italian spada longa (lunga) and French épée longue.
The term longsword has been used to refer to different kinds of sword depending on historical context:
- Zweihänder or two-hander, a late Renaissance sword of the 16th century Landsknechte, the longest sword of all;
- the long "side sword" or "rapier" with a cutting edge (the Elizabethan long sword).
The Spatha was a double-edged longsword used by the Romans. The idea for the Spatha came from the swords of ancient Celts in Germany and Britain. It was longer than the gladius, and had more reach, so the Spatha was most popular with soldiers in the cavalry. The blade could range between 0.5 and 1 m (1 ft 8 in and 3 ft 3 in) long while the handle was usually between 18 and 20 cm (7 and 8 in).
The term broadsword was never used historically to describe the one-handed arming sword. The arming sword was wrongly labelled a broadsword by antiquarians as the medieval swords were similar in blade width to the military swords of the day (that were also sometimes labeled as broadswords) and broader than the dueling swords and ceremonial dress swords.
Knives such as the seax and other blades of similar length – between 30 and 60 cm (1 and 2 ft) – are sometimes construed as swords. This is especially the case for weapons from antiquity, made before the development of high quality steel that is necessary for longer swords, in particular:
- Iron Age swords:
- Certain Renaissance-era sidearms:
- Certain fascine knives:
- Model 1832 Foot Artillery Sword, a blade of about 64 cm (25 in) in length designed after the Roman gladius. Also known as a coupe-chou (literally a cabbage cutter) in France.
Oversized two-handers used as parade swords or ceremonial weapons often exceeded the length and weight of practical weapons of war.
Edgeless and thrusting swords
The edgeless swords category comprises weapons which are related to or labelled as “swords” but do not emphasise "hacking or slashing techniques" or have any "cutting edges" whatsoever. The majority of these elongated weapons were designed for agility, precision and rapid thrusting blows to exploit gaps in the enemy's defences; some are capable of piercing iron or steel armour.
The basket-hilted sword is a sword type of the early modern era characterised by a basket-shaped guard that protects the hand. The basket hilt is a development of the quillons added to swords' crossguards since the Late Middle Ages. In modern times, this variety of sword is also sometimes referred to as the broadsword.
The Spartiatēs were always armed with a xiphos as a secondary weapon. Among most Greek warriors, this weapon had an iron blade of about 60 centimetres. The Spartan version was typically only 30-45 centimetres. The Spartan's shorter weapon proved deadly in the crush caused by colliding phalanx formations – it was capable of being thrust through gaps in the enemy's shield wall and armour, where there was no room for longer weapons. The groin and throat were among the favourite targets.
The term "rapier" appeared in the English lexicon via the French épée rapière which either compared the weapon to a rasp or file; it may be a corruption of "rasping sword" which referred to the sound the blade makes when it comes into contact with another blade. There is no historical Italian equivalent to the English word "rapier".
Panzerstecher and koncerz
The Panzerstecher is a German and East European weapon with a long, edgeless blade of square or triangular cross-section for penetrating armour. Early models were either two-handers or “hand-and-half” hilted, while later 16th and 17th century models (also known as koncerz) were one-handed and used by cavalry.
Tuck and verdun
The "tuck" (French estoc, Italian stocco) is an edgeless blade of square or triangular cross-section used for thrusting. In French, estoc also means thrust or point; and estoc et taille means cut and thrust.
The tuck may also get its name from the verb "to tuck" which means "to shorten".
The small sword or smallsword (also court sword, fr: épée de cour or dress sword) is a light one-handed sword designed for thrusting which evolved out of the longer and heavier rapier of the late Renaissance. The height of the small sword's popularity was between the mid-17th and late 18th century. It is thought to have appeared in France and spread quickly across the rest of Europe. The small sword was the immediate predecessor of the Épée de Combat from which the Épée developed and its method of use—as typified in the works of such authors as Sieur de Liancour, Domenico Angelo, Monsieur J. Olivier, and Monsieur L'Abbat—developed into the techniques of the French classical school of fencing. Small swords were also used as status symbols and fashion accessories; for most of the 18th century anyone, civilian or military, with pretensions to gentlemanly status would have worn a small sword on a daily basis.
Single-edge and curved swords
These are single-cutting edged, usually thick or curved construction bladed swords, typically designed for slashing, chopping, severing limbs, tripping or broad sweeping techniques; but were often very poorly designed for stabbing. Swordsmen were trained to use the dulled side for defensive and blocking techniques.
The backsword was a single-edged, straight-bladed sword, typically for military use. This type of sword had a thickened back to the blade (opposite the cutting edge), which gave the blade strength. The backsword blade was cheaper to manufacture than a two-edged blade. This type of sword was first developed in Europe in the 15th century and reflected the emergence of asymmetric guards, which made a two-edged blade somewhat redundant. The backsword reached its greatest use in the 17th and 18th century when many cavalry swords, such as the British 1796 Heavy Cavalry Sword, were of this form.
Dao are single-edged Chinese swords, primarily used for slashing and chopping. The most common form is also known as the Chinese sabre, although those with wider blades are sometimes referred to as Chinese broadswords. In China, the dao is considered one of the four traditional weapons, along with the gun (stick or staff), qiang (spear), and the jian (sword). It is considered "The General of All Weapons".
The hook sword, twin hooks, fu tao or shuang gou (simplified Chinese: 钩; traditional Chinese: 鈎 or 鉤; pinyin: Gou) also known as hu tou gou (tiger head hook) is a Chinese weapon traditionally associated with northern styles of Chinese martial arts and Wushu weapons routines, but now often practiced by southern styles as well.
Unlike the xiphos, which is a thrusting weapon, the kopis was a hacking weapon in the form of a thick, curved single edged iron sword. In Athenian art, Spartan hoplites were often depicted using a kopis instead of the xiphos, as the kopis was seen as a quintessential "villain" weapon in Greek eyes.
Historically, katana (刀) were one of the traditionally made Japanese swords (日本刀, nihontō) that were used by the samurai of feudal Japan. Modern versions of the katana are sometimes made using non-traditional materials and methods. The katana is characterized by its distinctive appearance: a curved, slender, single-edged blade usually with a round guard and long grip to accommodate two hands.
Falchion and cutlass
The cutlass or curtal-axe also known as a falchion (French badelaire, braquemart, coutelas, malchus Italian coltellaccio, storta, German messer, dussack, malchus) is a broad-bladed curved hanger or long knife. In later usage, the cutlass referred to the short naval boarding sabre.
The sabre (US saber) or shable (French sabre, Spanish sable, Italian sciabola, German Säbel, Russian sablya, Hungarian szablya, Polish szabla, Ukrainian shablya) is a single-edged curved bladed cavalry sword.
The scimitar (French cimeterre, Italian scimitarra) is a type of saber that came to refer in general to any sabre used by the Turks or Ottomans (kilij), Persians (shamshir) and more specifically the Stradioti (Albanian and Greek mercenaries who fought in the French-Italian Wars and were employed throughout Western Europe). The scimitar proper was the Stradioti saber, and the term was introduced into France by Philippe de Commines (1447 – 18 October 1511) as cimeterre, Italy (especially the Venetian Republic who hired the stradioti as mercenaries) as scimitarra, and England as cimeter or scimitar via the French and Italian terms.
- e.g., "hand-and-a-half sword", "single-handed sword", "Pappenheimer"["Pappenheimer Sword". myArmoury.com. Retrieved 2015-10-08. "Pappenheimer | Define Pappenheimer at Dictionary.com". Dictionary.reference.com. Retrieved 2015-10-08.] "Walloon sword", "Sinclair Sabre", "Mortuary sword", "spada da lato", "town sword", etc.
- e.g., bastard sword, broadsword ["Broadswords". Thearma.org. Retrieved 2015-10-08.
- "SOCIETY :: WEAPONS :: THRUSTING AND CUTTING WEAPONS  image - Visual Dictionary Online". Visual.merriam-webster.com. 2008-10-29. Retrieved 2015-10-08.] rapier
- "The rapier revisited". Salvatorfabris.org. 1970-01-01. Retrieved 2015-10-08., estoc, flamberge, etc.
- sword and sorcery fiction, role playing games, fighting games, etc.
- "cut-and-thrust sword"
- A term that was coined by Italian curators
- New Gallery (London, England) (1890). Exhibition of the Royal House of Tudor. Retrieved 2015-10-08 – via Google Books.
- Cox, Trenchard (2009-02-23). A General Guide to the Wallace Collection - Wallace Collection (London, England). Retrieved 2015-10-08 – via Google Books.
- in Death of the Laird's Jock (1831).
- Robert Nares, A glossary; or, Collection of words ... which have been thought to require illustration, in the works of English authors (1822).
- Tony Willis, "A Pair of Scottish Swords", Page One, Page Two, Page Three, Page Four.
- Ewart Oakeshott (1994). The Sword in the Age of Chivalry. Woodbridge: Boydell Press. pp. 42–46. ISBN 978-0-85115-715-3. OCLC 807485557. OL 26840827M. Wikidata Q105271484.
- Oakeshott, Ewart. Records of the Medieval Sword. Boydell Press 1991. Page 89 and 95.
- Du Fresne Du Cange, C.; Henschel, G.A.L.; Carpentier, P.; Adelung, J.C.; Favre, L.; Freher, M.; Scaliger, J.J.; Welser, M. (1887). Glossarium mediae et infimae latinitatis: Indices (pp. v-ccxvi) & "Extraits des observations sur l'Histoire de Saint Louis". L. Favre.
- "Search Chambers - Free English Dictionary". chambers.co.uk. Archived from the original on 2013-09-28. Retrieved 2014-05-27.
- "Claymore". jacobites.info. Archived from the original on 2013-09-15. Retrieved 2014-05-27.
- Ebrey 1999, p. 41
- Rodell 2003, p. 19
- (Écrivain), François Rabelais (1741). Oeuvres - François Rabelais (écrivain), César de Missy, Jacob Le Duchat, Louis-Fabricius Dubourg, Bernard Picart, Pieter Tanjé, Balthasar Bernaerts, Jacob Folkema. p. 129. Retrieved 2015-10-08 – via Google Books.
- Dictionnaire historique de l'ancien langage françois: ou Glossaire de la ... - Sainte-Palaye (M. de La Curne de, Jean-Baptiste de La Curne). 1879. Retrieved 2015-10-08 – via Google Books.
- "A Perfect Length II: The Longsword | Encased in Steel". Historical-academy.co.uk. 2011-07-29. Archived from the original on 2013-12-03. Retrieved 2015-10-08.
- Notes and Queries. 1890. p. 116. Retrieved 2015-10-08 – via Google Books.
- Ménage, Gilles (1750). Dictionnaire étymologique de la langue françoise - Gilles Ménage, Pierre Borel, Auguste François Jault, Pierre de Caseneuve, H. P. Simon de Val-Hébert. p. 129. Retrieved 2015-10-08 – via Google Books.
- Noël, François-Joseph-Michel (1857). Dictionnaire étymologique, critique, historique, anecdotique et littéraire ... - François-Joseph-Michel Noël. p. 563. Retrieved 2015-10-08 – via Google Books.
- "Sword types in prize playing - The Association for Renaissance Martial Arts". Thearma.org. Retrieved 2015-10-08.
- Joseph Strutt The sports and pastimes of the people of England from the earliest period: including the rural and domestic recreations, May games, mummeries, pageants, processions and pompous spectacles, 1801, p. 211.
- "London Masters of Defense". Iceweasel.org. 1998-05-29. Retrieved 2015-10-08.
- "The London Masters of Defense". Iceweasel.org. Retrieved 2015-10-08.
- Oakeshott (1980).
- Pennant, T. (1776). A Tour in Scotland and Voyage to the Hebrides, 1772. B. White.
- "Forms of European Edged Weaponry -- myArmoury.com". myarmoury.com. Retrieved 2014-05-27.
- Abel Boyer; William Bentley Fowle (1835). Boyer's French Dictionary: Comprising All the Additions and Improvements of ... p. 225. Retrieved 2015-10-08 – via Google Books.
- "Broadswords". thearma.org. Retrieved 2014-05-27.
- Ewart Oakeshott (2012). European Weapons and Armour: From the Renaissance to the Industrial Revolution. pp. 156, 173, 175. ISBN 978-1-84383-720-6. OL 28477865M. Wikidata Q105271714.
- "Rapier | Define Rapier at Dictionary.com". Dictionary.reference.com. Retrieved 2015-10-08.
- "Le Monde De D Artagnan" (in French). Lemondededartagnan.fr. Retrieved 2015-10-08.
- "dictionary :: Panzerstecher [Blankwaffe] :: German-English translation". Dict.cc. Retrieved 2015-10-08.
- "English Tuck (Estoc)". myArmoury.com. Retrieved 2015-10-08.
- "What's a Panzerstecher?". Swordforum.com. Retrieved 2015-10-08.
- "Philadelphia Museum of Art - Collections Object : Tuck (Panzerstecher)". Philamuseum.org. Retrieved 2015-10-08.
- "Hermann Historica - Internationales Auktionshaus für Antiken, Alte Wa…". Archived from the original on 6 February 2013.
- Evangelista, Nick. The Encyclopedia of the Sword. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1995. p. 208
- "Spartan Weapons". Ancientmilitary.com. Retrieved 2015-10-08.
- Manouchehr Moshtagh Khorasani (2008). The Development of Controversies: From the Early Modern Period to Online Discussion Forums. Peter Lang. p. 150. ISBN 978-3-03911-711-6. OL 22696617M. Wikidata Q105271716.
- Evans Lansing Smith; Nathan Robert Brown (2008). The Complete Idiot's Guide to World Mythology. Alpha Books. p. 144. ISBN 978-1-59257-764-4. OL 12378846M. Wikidata Q105271719.
- Kokan Nagayama, trans. Kenji Mishina (1997). The Connoisseur's Book of Japanese Swords. Tokyo, Japan: Kodansha International Ltd. ISBN 978-4-7700-2071-0. OL 20652347M. Wikidata Q105271721.
- Howard L. Blackmore (January 2000). Hunting Weapons: From the Middle Ages to the Twentieth Century. p. 14. ISBN 9780486409610. Retrieved 2015-10-08 – via Google Books.
- "European Hanger". myArmoury.com. Retrieved 2015-10-08.
- "Glossaire archéologique du Moyen Age et de la Renaissance". Paris, Société bibliographique. Retrieved 2015-10-08.
- "Glossaire archéologique du Moyen Age et de la Renaissance". Paris, Société bibliographique. Retrieved 2015-10-08.
- "Les Guerriers d'Avalon". Guerriers-avalon.org. Retrieved 2015-10-08.
- "Glossaire archéologique du Moyen Age et de la Renaissance". Paris, Société bibliographique. Retrieved 2015-10-08.
- "Historical Messer Drawings". Albion-swords.com. Retrieved 2015-10-08.
- "Ethnographic Arms & Armour - Article: Notes on development of modern sabers - Role of Eastern Europe & the Hussars". Vikingsword.com. Retrieved 2015-10-08.
- "Stradioti: Balkan Mercenaries In Fifteenth And Sixteenth Century Italy". Shsu.edu. Archived from the original on 2015-09-24. Retrieved 2015-10-08.
- "estradiot : définition de estradiot, citations, exemples et usage pour estradiot dans le dictionnaire de français Littré adapté du grand dictionnaire de la langue française d'Emile Littré". Littre.reverso.net. Retrieved 2015-10-08.
- Jacques-Bénigne Bossuet (1863). Oeuvres complčtes de Bossuet. p. 267. Retrieved 2015-10-08 – via Google Books.
- Auguste Racinet (1876). Le costume historique: Cinq cents planches, trois cents en couleurs, or et ... Retrieved 2015-10-08 – via Google Books.
- Levasseur, Michel. Des princes français, rois de Sicile, rois de Naples. p. 190. ISBN 9782748377675. Retrieved 2015-10-08 – via Google Books.