Closed list

Closed list describes the variant of party-list proportional representation where voters can (effectively) only vote for political parties as a whole and thus have no influence on the party-supplied order in which party candidates are elected. If voters have at least some influence then it is called an open list.

In closed list systems, each political party has pre-decided who will receive the seats allocated to that party in the elections, so that the candidates positioned highest on this list tend to always get a seat in the parliament while the candidates positioned very low on the closed list will not.

However, the candidates "at the water mark" of a given party are in the position of either losing or winning their seat depending on the number of votes the party gets. "The water mark" is the number of seats a specific party can be expected to achieve. The number of seats that the party wins, combined with the candidates' positions on the party's list, will then determine whether a particular candidate will get a seat.

List of locations with closed list proportional representation

• Albania
• Angola
• Argentina
• Andorra
• Croatia before 2015
• Guatemala
• Hong Kong
• Iceland
• Israel
• Italy
• Montenegro
• Portugal
• Russia
• Serbia
• South Africa
• Spain
• Sri Lanka
• Turkey
• UK MEPs (except Northern Ireland)
• Uruguay

(Countries that have electoral systems that are only partly closed list i.e. mixed-member proportional representation have been excluded.)

Criticism

Voting systems using a closed list employ a listing of candidates selected by the party. Whoever controls this list is in a crucial power-brokering role. Members (candidates) elected from the list are essentially in thrall to the list maker—their political survival depends on how high up the list their name appears, or whether it appears at all.

The party executive or party leaders generally control the list; consequently closed-list systems transfer political power to the un-elected persons (strategists, delegates, party officials, etc.) who author the party's list of candidates. However, parties can mitigate this by using an internal vote of their members or an open primary to determine the ordering of the lists.

See also

• Open list
• Ley de Lemas
• List of democracy and elections-related topics

External links

• Open, Closed and Free Lists at Ace Project