Talk:Truist Park

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
(Redirected from Talk:SunTrust Park)

Location[edit]

CLOSED
The editorial consensus is the baseball park is located in Cumberland, Georgia which is a notable place backed by WP:RS.

The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

@Nemov I am looking to open this back up to a friendly debate. Cumberland, GA doesn't exist anywhere outside of it's Wiki page. In addition, Cumberland isn't a city, CDP like Paradise, NV, or Borough like Bronx, NY. Cumberland only references an area surrounding Cumberland Mall (which is ITP). Being across 285, that area was never associated with Cumberland until recently. It was always the Galleria or even Smyrna where the city limit is literally the other side of Cobb Parkway from the entrance to the Galleria. This is technically a neighborhood like Fenway for Fenway Park and Wrigleyville for Wrigley Field. In addition, I worked at the Galleria as well as for several other places in the area. On my business cards, they all had on them Atlanta GA. Truist Park is not in the Atlanta city limits. It is 2.5 miles away and the closest high school to Truist Park is part of Atlanta City Schools. Before the Battery, the area was considered Atlanta as every business there had an Atlanta address. Most locals referred to the area as the Galleria. Now they refer to it as the Battery. If you want to be technical, I would argue the location should match the mailing address like Wrigley and Fenway. Otherwise, I would argue the location should be a real place like Cobb County, GA. 24.125.213.59 (talk) 06:19, 6 November 2021 (UTC)[reply]

The park isn't in the Atlanta city limits. Mailing address doesn't determine location. Cumberland, Georgia is notable enough to be on Wikipedia and that's where the ball park is located. What was on your business cards is irrelevant. The other examples don't make sense either since Wrigley Field is in Chicago and Fenway Park is in Boston. Truist Park is not in Atlanta. The park is in the unincorporated community of Cumberland, in Cobb County, Georgia. - Nemov (talk) 13:28, 6 November 2021 (UTC)[reply]
Your 'assertive' tone is becoming laughable. I am trying to have a friendly debate. Correct, the park is not in Atlanta city limits. If you read what I wrote I typed that. But Cumberland, GA is not a real place. In terms of notoriety, there are also 100s of 1000s of fictional places notable enough to be on Wikipedia. That justification is irrelevant if that is the term we are using. In terms of relevance, the mailing addresses, location, opinion of locals, etc are more relevant than what you consider irrelevant. If you use UPS, FedEx, DHL, or any courier service they will revise the city to Atlanta. I actually had things mailed to the 'irrelevant' address on my business cards. My point is Cumberland, GA is not a city, edge city, borough, CDP, etc. It is simply a neighborhood, and a neighborhood where few who live there use as a reference. How do I know? I lived there for a couple of years a couple of miles from the park. Nobody who has ever been there is saying they are going to Cumberland outside of going to the Mall. If anything it would be referencing the Cumberland Improvement District which is one of 25 CIDs in the State and it was established in the 80s. Even then, folks referred to the area as the Galleria. The area where the battery is used to be trees and a lake with a walking path around it. Nobody ever associated that area with the mall. Based on your response, you've obviously never been to the area other than maybe visiting the park. To be factually correct, it should be changed to Atlanta to match what USPS thinks or what their address says, or Cobb County, GA to reference what locals think and not a place that is similar to my subdivision. 24.125.213.59 (talk) 15:42, 6 November 2021 (UTC)[reply]
There was a lively debate on this subject today on a Facebook group consisting of Atlanta natives. I now understand where the confusion comes from. Unless you are from Atlanta, you probably don't understand this. Every zip code in the Metro Area that starts with 303 is considered Atlanta regardless of the county it is in. If you lived within city limits then you voted for Mayor. Outside of city limits you didn't. Only ~9% of the population of Metro Atlanta lives within the city limits. Because of some historically racist ideas, when the GOP took over the Georgia Legislature in 2004 they were able to push forward cityhood for Sandy Springs. This is when counties started to claim parts of unincorporated areas and give them their own names (See Sandy Springs, Dunwoody, Johns Creek, Brookhaven). It was all racially motivated and this is when you started to see folks try to limit Atlanta to within city limits. There has historically been animosity towards the City of Atlanta by other Metro areas and residents. So technically, the city limits are irrelevant because that is the term we are using. This is the NATIVE ATLANTA RESIDENT viewpoint and the viewpoint that should drive the narrative. I noticed in this original talk thread we were missing that point of view. Cumberland is not a city, it is a mall. Nobody says they live in Cumberland. Nobody says they are going to a restaurant in Cumberland unless they are going to one of the ones attached to the mall. People who live there do not tell people they live in Cumberland. It is not a valid place and that is why it needs to be changed. I would recommend listening to an Atlanta native on this one. 24.125.213.59 (talk) 05:29, 8 November 2021 (UTC)[reply]
Wikipedia is not a place to argue "local viewpoints", as they are considered original research. Locals have no special status on Wikipedia. What matters is published reliable sources. Period. As long as such sources state that Truist (I still hate that name! Ugh!) Park is located in the unincorporated community of Cumberland, that's what the article will say. Please note that this is not a unique issue. I've seen similar arguments on dozens of talk pages. In the end, it often comes down to an editorial judgment based on what a majority of reliable sources state. Even then, the decision is usually controversial to somebody.
As an aside, postal addresses are often confusing, and even inaccurate. I used to live in Chattanooga, Tennessee. East Ridge, Tennessee, is a smaller city adjacent to Chattanooga. Even though East Ridge is an incorporated city of over 20,000, it's official USPS address is Chattanooga. So if you want to write to city hall, the "correct" address would be "East Ridge City Hall, Chattanooga, Tennessee 37412"! BilCat (talk) 21:26, 9 November 2021 (UTC)[reply]
I agree with published reliable sources. I am actually ALL FOR IT! Please provide a published reliable source that references Cumberland, GA as a real place(The wiki page does not count because I also question the validity of that). There is no such thing as Cumberland, GA. Cumberland is a neighborhood. Not a city, edge city, CDP, made up city, factual city, fictional city, none of that. It is simply a neighborhood and shouldn't be referenced as the Geographic referenced place where Truist Park is. We can look no further than the Truist Park Website: https://www.mlb.com/braves/ballpark/transportation. It reads, "Truist Park is located 10 miles northwest of downtown Atlanta in the Cumberland neighborhood of Cobb County." It does not say it is located in Cumberland, GA. It does not say Cumberland community in unincorporated Cobb County. It then lists the mailing address which lists Atlanta as the city it is in. Cumberland Mall says it is in Atlanta. This is the mall the area is named after: https://www.cumberlandmall.com/en.html. The Roxy Theater labels itself as Atlanta's premier concert venue with an Atlanta address. It is in The Battery: https://www.cocacolaroxy.com/venueinfo. The new Thyssenkrupp HQ says they are in Cobb County, GA (I'm actually fine with that). https://www.areadevelopment.com/newsItems/7-30-2018/thyssenkrupp-elevator-headquarters-cobb-county-georgia.shtml#:~:text=One%20of%20the%20world%27s%20largest%20elevator%20companies%20and,Georgia%2C%20in%20collaboration%20with%20the%20Braves%20Development%20Company. I could list hundreds of references and not one will say they are in Cumberland, GA. and close to 100% of them will say they are in Atlanta. Cumberland, GA IS NOT A CITY! And that has always been the point. 24.125.213.59 (talk) 01:00, 10 November 2021 (UTC)[reply]
In Atlanta, the history of the zip codes in the city was that anything 303 was considered Atlanta. Then you had inside the city limits vs outside the city limits. If you were inside the city limits then you voted for mayor and paid higher taxes. In 2004, when the GOP took over the legislature, you started to see cities break away from this designation and form their own cities starting with the City of Sandy Springs. That is why the Galleria area (Where Truist Park is) is considered Atlanta by locals. That is why you see an Atlanta address on everything. There was always an inside vs outside the city limits designation. 24.125.213.59 (talk) 01:00, 10 November 2021 (UTC)[reply]
You do realize I'm not Nemov? Your uncivil comments about "Your Napoleon-complex inspired assertiveness" do not apply to me, and should not be made about anyone. Please stop. BilCat (talk) 01:14, 10 November 2021 (UTC)[reply]
My apologies. He came at me like that first and I should have left it at that. I will modify. 24.125.213.59 (talk) 02:08, 10 November 2021 (UTC)[reply]

When this was discussed originally when the park was being built I thought it should be an Atlanta address. However, after it was discussed and I researched it further I found that I was wrong and accepted the consensus position. The hostility to opposing opinions isn't warranted. Those who have discussed this topic did so in good faith. I would suggest that 24.125.213.59 brush up on the WP:GUIDELINE. If you "question the validity" of Cumberland, GA being a real and notable place then you should proceed to the Talk:Cumberland, Georgia to discuss there. - Nemov (talk) 18:36, 10 November 2021 (UTC)[reply]

Let the record show that I was threatened first and the condescending tone wasn't initiated by me. Check my talk entries. Check the history of the entries. I question the validity of Truist Park being located in the City of Cumberland, GA where there is no such thing as a City(edge city, unincorporated city, etc) of Cumberland, GA. The Cumberland, GA wiki is irrelevant to this discussion. I propose it at a minimum get changed to Cobb County, GA(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cobb_County,_Georgia) since it is in an unincorporated part of the county. It is actually in Atlanta based on its mailing address but I'm willing to let that go. Truist not being in Atlanta is a political position by people who didn't understand the business aspect of the Braves leaving downtown, Atlanta and not one that has consensus locally from those outside of the Progressive Left. I have provided multiple examples including that from the homepage of Truist Park and none reference the Park being in Cumberland, GA. They say the Cumberland Neighborhood of Cobb County. A neighborhood usually isn't considered and edge city, CDP, etc. Hence, my reference to Wrigleyville and Fenway as examples of parks in notable neighborhoods. I even supplied the history of how the zip codes in Atlanta were derived(we were taught that as youngsters when we would take field trips to the Post Office). LOL! I am not the enemy here. I come in 100% TRUTH and Peace. 24.125.213.59 (talk) 19:29, 10 November 2021 (UTC)[reply]

Is there a reason the contributor's viewpoint was ignored? They made valid points. There is no such thing as Cumberland, GA. I recommend changing the location to Cobb County, GA. Is there a way it can be changed without incident? That area is home to multiple landmarks and corporate headquarters and they all list Atlanta as where they are located. RaceTrac, Synovous, Genuine Parts, Aarons, HD Supply, ThyssenKrupp, Cumberland Mall, Cobb Energy Center, Galleria Conference Center, The Weather Channel, Randstad, Sprint, Assurant, and a few others all have major corporate presence there and they all, even on Wikipedia if applicable, list their location as Atlanta, GA. The entire reason this is even a debate was that it was made political when the Braves left Turner field. What needs to be done to get the debate started again? I would say go by the city Truist Park lists as their address on the website. If people disagree with the Truist Park website then the 2nd best location is Cobb, County GA. Byoungjr (talk) 05:42, 3 March 2022 (UTC)[reply]

How was the viewpoint ignored? Cumberland, GA is notable, it does exist, and that's the location of the ballpark. I've been editing this article from the very beginning. The location of the park is the location. It doesn't have anything to do with politics. Nemov (talk) 14:56, 19 March 2022 (UTC)[reply]
As someone who has both grown up in and frequented the area for over 50yrs, worked at Cumberland mall as a teenager, lived in the Cortland at the Battery(Apartment complex next door to Truist Park), and worked at the Galleria, I can convey to you that "Cumberland, GA" is not a "Notable" place and the notion of "Cumberland, GA" where it is assumed that Cumberland is a city in Georgia doesn't exist. "Cumberland" is never used in any geographic terms when someone is referencing the area. That is why it is better to say it is in Cobb County, GA. This is political because living here, it didn't become a debate until the Braves announced they were leaving Turner Field. Before then, nobody had any problems referring to the area as Atlanta, like 99.9% of the companies and businesses based there do without incident. However, since this is Wikipedia, we have a duty to the public to give them factual information. Suggesting a business is in Cumberland, GA is not accurate. @Nemov As a life-long resident of the area who has been going to Cumberland Mall since it opened in 1973 as a toddler, I would ask that you respectfully consider my viewpoint and not be dismissive of it, which is the tone your reply is conveying.   Byoungjr (talk) 18:53, 26 March 2022 (UTC)[reply]
Wikipedia article talk pages aren't for "debates", but for discussing improvements to the article itself. As such, you need to focus on presenting reliable sources that support your position, not personal experience, anecdotes, and opinion. These are totally irrelevant to the article, and will be rightly dismissed. I suggest you focus on citing reliable published sources, not business cards. BilCat (talk) 19:38, 26 March 2022 (UTC)[reply]
I totally agree with that @BilCat. Let us please cite published sources. I don't understand the Business Card reference, but let me explain. Every address I have had living and working in the area listed Atlanta, GA as the city. If you were to take into account the companies inside of the Cumberland CID, you will find the published proof of their location. If you go to the contact us at the following companies: TravelPort, Racetrac, Randstad USA, Genuine Parts, The Weather Channel, and TK Elevator (In the Battery) all list Atlanta and none list Cumberland, GA as where they are located. Another item I would consider a reliable published resource is the actual property tax bill. Here is the property tax bill for the Atlanta Braves, the Omni Hotel next to the stadium, and the Roxy theater. None of them reference being in Cumberland, GA. In fact, the only place you see Cumberland, GA referenced is on Wikipedia and the Cobb Visitor's website as a neighborhood. There are a lot more but I can start with those. I can supply as many published references as needed. Since Atlanta is so controversial because of politics, the best representation would be Cobb County, Georgia. Byoungjr (talk) 06:35, 31 March 2022 (UTC)[reply]
The postal service doesn't determine location. If you want to learn about what Wikipedia considers reliable sources I suggest researching WP:RS. This park location is consistent with other parks outside the city limits throughout the country. So I don't see the political angle, so you should set that aside because it's not a factor here. Nemov (talk) 12:28, 31 March 2022 (UTC)[reply]
@Nemov I would say you have to be a resident to understand the political angle. Beyond that, the postal service says Atlanta as the address. Now, we could go into the history of why but that is irrelevant here. My point is you will not find any reliable source that says Truist Park (Or any business in the Cumberland CID) is in Cumberland, GA. There is not one source beyond Wikipedia. The source I listed above was the actual property tax bill of the property. In the location that is on the property tax bill, it does not say it is in Cumberland, GA. On the source page you referenced, it read "A source is where the material comes from. For example, a source could be a book or a webpage. " I have provided websites and property tax bills as sources. Those are not my personal opinion or experience. It then reads, "When editors talk about sources that are being cited on Wikipedia, they might be referring to any one of these three concepts:". Concept 1(The piece of work itself) - See the websites I provided as reference. Concept 2(The creator of the work) - Truist Park was built by Mortenson construction who lists the location as Cobb County, GA. In each of those concepts, you will not find Cumberland, GA referenced. You do see Cobb County, GA referenced which is my recommendation. Byoungjr (talk) 15:00, 31 March 2022 (UTC)[reply]
If you don't believe Cumberland, GA is a valid location and shouldn't be on Wikipedia you can go to that article and request for it to be deleted. I don't believe that's gonna find much support though. You might also take it up with the Braves who mention Cumberland on their own website.[1]. Nemov (talk) 15:16, 31 March 2022 (UTC)[reply]
@Nemov On the Braves Website you link it reads, "Truist Park is located 10 miles northwest of downtown Atlanta in the Cumberland neighborhood of COBB COUNTY." It does not say it is in the edge community of Cumberland, GA. To compare, the old Turner Field was in the Summerhill neighborhood of Atlanta. Turner Field isn't listed on Wikipedia as being in Summerhill, GA. The Florida Aquarium is in the Channel District. It's location isn't listed on Wikipedia as Channel District, Fl. Those are two direct comparisons to the example you posted. Byoungjr (talk) 00:59, 2 April 2022 (UTC)[reply]
There's nothing left here for me to add. I've outlined the next steps you'll have to take. Good luck. Thanks! Nemov (talk) 01:08, 2 April 2022 (UTC)[reply]
@Byoungjr: There's a big difference between being a part of an incorporated city (within its city limits), and being in an unincorporated area of a county. All of your examples given above (as far as I can tell) are of the former, where Wikipedia generally defaults to the city. In the end, it comes down to a matter of editorial preference in those latter cases. Given that we do have a Wikipedia article on Cumberland, we went with it, and for the other reasons we've given. At this point, that's the consensus here. Continuing to ramble on for months about how unfair Atlanta politics is and what's on your business cards isn't going to persuade anyone. You are welcome to pursue the next steps as Nemov has suggested. BilCat (talk) 01:21, 2 April 2022 (UTC)[reply]
@BilCat I think you are confusing me with someone else as I have no idea what you are referring to with Business cards or rambling for months. Also, I am not suggesting you change the location to Atlanta. I am suggesting it be changed to Cobb County, GA. I understand the difference between inside city limits vs. outside city limits. All of my examples proved that you wouldn't find anywhere a legal entity refers to themselves as being in Cumberland, GA. It had nothing to do with Atlanta. I recommend Cobb County, GA. I also don't understand the animosity towards myself, as I have been nothing but professional in all of my statements. In addition, I never typed anything about Atlanta politics being unfair. I informed you why there is controversy whenever Truist Park's location comes up. All of my points are that you will not see "Cumberland, Georgia" referenced anywhere outside Wikipedia. But as you typed, it comes down to editorial preference based on the opinion of people who are not familiar with the area. Byoungjr (talk) 07:00, 2 April 2022 (UTC)[reply]


@Byoungjr: My apologies for confusing you with the IP. However, my patience on this issue is exhausted, whether it's your fault or not. Please pursue the next steps. Thanks. BilCat (talk) 07:28, 2 April 2022 (UTC)[reply]
@BilCat Continue to ramble? We should be above personal attacks. Especially considering it has been five months since I have typed anything on this topic. I have just written this off as an article edited by people who aren't familiar with Atlanta. 24.125.213.59 (talk) 23:36, 6 April 2022 (UTC)[reply]
That's not a personal attack. I'm familiar with Atlanta, I just disagree with you POV. BilCat (talk) 00:18, 7 April 2022 (UTC)[reply]
Agree with BilCat. I was born in Atlanta and I'm very familiar with the area. The argument that this is as an article edited by people who aren't familiar with Atlanta a) not relevant in regards to Wikipedia policy and b) not even true to begin with... you are basically making assumptions because you don't agree. Nemov (talk) 01:52, 7 April 2022 (UTC)[reply]
Not familiar with the Galleria/Cobb County area would probably be more accurate. But there is no need to continue the negative attacks. All I wanted was to have a friendly debate and to start the dialog of getting it changed to properly reflect it's location. One can read the above reply's and see the tone that was used towards me. I just went to meet a friend at Yardhouse yesterday and I asked a few people what city I was in. Not one person said Cumberland. That was the point but I was trying to make in that nobody ever refers to that area as Cumberland. At this point it is just useless as I am not a part of the Wikipedia insider group so that POV will never stand a chance of being read. Byoungjr (talk) 15:34, 19 April 2022 (UTC)[reply]
Please let us know if you need help taking the next steps. Happy editing! Nemov (talk) 15:46, 19 April 2022 (UTC)[reply]
The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

Redirects[edit]

Are the redirects on this article necessary? I realize there's other Truist sponsored stadiums and parks, but none of them are as high profile as the ballpark in Atlanta. It seems like overkill, but I could always be wrong. - Nemov (talk) 02:41, 10 November 2021 (UTC)[reply]

I would say so. Someone who wants info on the professional baseball stadium in Charlotte or High Point but doesn't know which one is which will benefit from the hat notes. – Muboshgu (talk) 02:48, 10 November 2021 (UTC)[reply]
The hatnote is a bit long. If it can't be shortened a little, then a DAB page might be a better option. If we get a fourth professional baseball stadium with the horrible name "Truist", then a DAB page would be a best. BilCat (talk) 06:40, 3 March 2022 (UTC)[reply]
Since there are now four other stadiums/ballparks named "Truist X", if created Truist (disambiguation), and added hatnotes to it on all the related articles. Truist currently redirects to Truist Financial. I'm not sure the bank qualifies as the primary topic, but I haven't checked the page views. BilCat (talk) 01:26, 12 July 2022 (UTC)[reply]
I checked the page views, and most are a few hundred to a.couple of thousand views a month. Both Truist Park and Truist Financial average about 25,000 views a month, so there is no primary topic. As such, I'll move the DAB page to Truist. BilCat (talk) 01:34, 12 July 2022 (UTC)[reply]
I agree the change is an improvement now that there's a fourth sports venue with Truist in the name. Nemov (talk) Nemov (talk) 17:53, 12 July 2022 (UTC)[reply]

Concerts[edit]

@BilCat I don't have an objection to future concerts (assuming they're sourced). However, should every concert be listed here anyway? I could see mentioning notable concerts similar to how it's covered at Shea Stadium. On the flipside, would any of the concerts listed on this article pass a ten year test? I don't think think any concert listed is that notable. Should we just remove the entire table and just mention the football game and few of the concerts in a small paragraph in "other events." What do you think? Nemov (talk) 19:25, 18 March 2023 (UTC)[reply]

WP:NOTEVERYTHING that happens should be included. Listing all concerts held at this venue would violate WP:NOTDIRECTORY. There has to be something specifically noteworthy about the concert to merit mentioning. – Muboshgu (talk) 19:43, 18 March 2023 (UTC)[reply]
I've removed the table and much of the unnecessary detail from that section. Thanks! Nemov (talk) 20:04, 18 March 2023 (UTC)[reply]

SunTrust Park[edit]

Ab editor has made a series of changes regarding the old name of the park, SunTrust Park. One was made in the lead, they also changed the image of the park to an outside of the park shot featuring the logo, and then added the logo. These are all unnecessary, but if people disagree by all means included it. I've rolled this back to the status quo until there's support for the changes. Thanks!. Nemov (talk) 15:18, 13 March 2024 (UTC)[reply]

I disagree with you Nemov on this. Even if stadiums have new names, former logos should be kept for history. Abhiramakella (talk) 15:19, 13 March 2024 (UTC)[reply]
Instead of finding consensus for the change Abhiramakella has gone ahead and made the change again without any support. Nemov (talk) 16:17, 17 March 2024 (UTC)[reply]
@Abhiramakella are you just going to ignore this process and force your change? Please revert and find consensus. Nemov (talk) 18:47, 19 March 2024 (UTC)[reply]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Truist_Park&oldid=1214625468"