William Forbes-Sempill, 19th Lord Sempill
The Right Honourable
The Lord Sempill
William Francis Forbes-Sempill
24 September 1893
|Died||30 December 1965 (aged 72)|
|Occupation||Aeronautical engineer, pilot, diplomat, spy|
|Organization||President of the Royal Aeronautical Society|
Spy for Japan
|Predecessor||John Forbes-Sempill, 18th Lord Sempill|
|Successor||Lords seat: Ann Forbes-Sempill|
Baronetcy: Sir Ewan Forbes, 11th Baronet
|Spouse(s)||Eileen Lavery (1919-1935)|
Cecilia Alice Dunbar-Kilburn (1941-1965)
|Children||Ann Moira, June Mary (by 1st marriage)|
Janet Cecilia, Kirstine Elizabeth, Brigid Gabriel (by 2nd)
|Awards||Order of the Rising Sun, Japan|
Order of the Polar Star, Sweden.
William Francis Forbes-Sempill, 19th Lord Sempill AFC, AFRAeS, (24 September 1893 – 30 December 1965) was a Scottish peer and record-breaking air pioneer who was later shown to have passed secret information to the Imperial Japanese military before the Second World War. Educated at Eton, he began his career as a pilot in the Royal Flying Corps and then served in the Royal Naval Air Service and Royal Air Force during the First World War. In 1921, Sempill led an official military mission to Japan that showcased the latest British aircraft. In subsequent years he continued to aid the Imperial Japanese Navy in developing its Navy Air Service.
In the 1920s, Sempill began giving military secrets to the Japanese. Although his activities were uncovered by British Intelligence, Sempill was not prosecuted for spying and allowed to continue in public life. He was eventually forced to retire from the Royal Navy in 1941 after being discovered passing on secret material to Tokyo shortly before Japan declared war in the Pacific.
Military and civil aviation
At the outbreak of World War I, Sempill joined Royal Flying Corps, being granted a probationary commission as a second lieutenant on 15 August 1914, which was confirmed less than four months later. In the meantime Sempill was appointed to flying duties. The following year, in February, Sempill took up a position as an "experimental officer" at the Central Flying School and he received a promotion to lieutenant in April. Less than four months later he was appointed a flight commander with the temporary rank of captain. In August 1915, he was appointed to instructional duties. Sempill's time at the Central Flying School was not to last as he relinquished his Army commission at the end of the year on being accepted for temporary service in the Royal Naval Air Service. Sempill's rapid rise through the ranks continued in the Navy and at the close of 1916 he was promoted to squadron commander. On 1 April 1918, with the amalgamation of both flying services into the Royal Air Force, Sempill was transferred and appointed one of several deputy directors in the RAF's personnel department with the temporary rank of colonel. He was awarded the Air Force Cross in the 1918 Birthday Honours. Sempill stayed at the Air Ministry until 8 October 1918 when he was seconded to the Ministry of Munitions. On the cessation of hostilities, he became a test pilot and he retired from military service in 1919.
On 4 September 1930, he set a new record by flying a de Havilland DH.60 Moth seaplane (G-AAVB) 1,040 miles non-stop from Brent Reservoir in London to Stockholm, Sweden in 12 hours. On 26 March 1936 he made a record-breaking flight in a BAC Drone ultra-light aircraft (G-ADPJ) 570 miles from Croydon Airport direct to Berlin Tempelhof Airport in 11 hours. He flew back a day or so later in 9 hours though he interrupted the flight with a stop at Canterbury, Kent.
In 1920 he led a civilian British deputation of former naval airmen to Japan – the Air Ministry and the Foreign Office saw the prospect for lucrative arms contracts with Japan – to help develop aircraft carriers, and to assist the Japanese navy in setting up its new air base, after the Japanese had bought three Supermarine Channel flying boats. Sempill was well respected within Japanese circles, and received a personal letter from Prime Minister Tomosaburo Kato (1922–1923), thanking him for his work with the Imperial Japanese Navy, which he described as "almost epoch-making."
With the termination of the Anglo-Japanese Alliance in 1921, Sempill should have ended close military contact and discussions regarding naval aviation technology and tactics. But on his return to the United Kingdom in 1923, Sempill kept in contact with the Japanese Foreign Ministry through the Japanese Embassy in London.
Suspicion and questioning
In 1925 Sempill accompanied a mission of foreign air officials to the Blackburn Aircraft factory at Brough, East Yorkshire. The Japanese had previously asked questions about aircraft being developed. Sempill later asked the same questions, in his official position, about the then secret Blackburn Iris.
The Directorate of Military Intelligence had kept Sempill's communications with the Japanese intelligence officer/Naval attaché in London, Captain Teijirō Toyoda, under surveillance from 1922. This led to the knowledge that Sempill was passing classified information to the Japanese, which Toyoda's communications indicated had been paid for. MI5 tapped Sempill's phone, and noted that his servant was a Japanese naval rating.
In March 1926, Sempill was proposed by the Aviation Ministry for an appointment as Greece's aeronautical adviser. At this point the Directorate of Military Intelligence advised the Foreign Office and the British Embassy in Athens that Britain could not be seen to endorse Sempill's appointment because of his past activities.
Sempill was called into the Foreign Office for an interview. The questions directed to him were intended to assess his loyalty to the British Government, his attachments to the Japanese, and the amount of information that he had passed to the Japanese.
During the meeting, the investigating officer could not reveal that the British had broken Japanese codes and were monitoring the Japanese communications systems.
On a trip to Brough, Sempill had openly talked about the Iris with the foreign air officials on the train trip from London. This was witnessed by a British Air Ministry civil servant, who reported the incident. Confronted with this information, Sempill admitted that he had broken the Official Secrets Act.
A subsequent meeting, chaired by the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs Austen Chamberlain, decided it was not in the interests of the British government to prosecute Sempill. Firstly Sempill's father was then aide-de-camp to King George V; any public trial would be a grave embarrassment to both the Crown and the British establishment. Secondly a prosecution would have revealed to the Japanese that British Intelligence had cracked the cypher codes of its diplomatic service.
Reprieve and inter-war activities
Six years after admitting he had breached the UK's Official Secrets Act, Sempill became a technical and business consultant to the Mitsubishi Heavy Industries; from 1932 to 1936 he represented the Japanese company in Europe. He also became chairman and then president of the Royal Aeronautical Society. In this capacity he advised overseas governments, such as Australia, on the creation of their naval air services.
In October 1933 Sempill was seriously injured in an accident while riding as a passenger in the Dymaxion three-wheel car in the United States. Sempill had been invited, in his capacity as an aviation expert, to review the aerodynamic experimental vehicle at Chicago World's Fair. But when he was being rushed to an airport to catch a plane to Akron, Ohio to meet the Graf Zeppelin for its return trip from New York to Europe, the Dymaxion was struck by another vehicle and overturned, killing the driver.
In 1934 he succeeded his father, John Forbes-Sempill, 18th Lord Sempill to the titles of Lord Sempill and Baronet of Craigevar, taking his seat in the House of Lords as a Conservative peer. His wife, who had accompanied him on many of his air tours, died in July 1935.
Sempill had "an affinity with militarist right-wing regimes". During the 1930s he developed extreme right-wing political opinions and was active in several anti-Semitic organizations such as the Anglo-German Fellowship, the pro-Nazi Link organisation and The Right Club led by Archibald Ramsay.
On the outbreak of war in 1939, Sempill was given a position in the Department of Air Materiel at the Admiralty. This gave him access to both sensitive and secret information about the latest British aircraft.
By June 1941, MI5 had intercepted messages between London and Mitsubishi and Field Marshal Yamagata's Tokyo headquarters indicating payments were being made to Sempill: "In light of the use made of Lord Sempill by our military and naval attaches in London, these payments should continue". On further investigation, MI5 suspected that Sempill was passing on top secret information about Fleet Air Arm aircraft. The matter was passed to the Attorney General and Director of Public Prosecutions. But again the Attorney General advised against prosecution. On 5 September 1941, Sempill attended a meeting with the Fifth Sea Lord and given "a strict private warning".
In 1941, Special Branch arrested a Japanese businessman called Makahara on suspicion of espionage. On discovering that this representative of a large Japanese firm was in custody, Sempill telephoned and then called at Paddington police station to assure the police of Makahara's innocence and character. The Japanese man was released after two days.
Sempill was also probably passing on detailed information about the British government. In August 1941, Winston Churchill and President Franklin D. Roosevelt held a meeting in Newfoundland aboard HMS Prince of Wales to discuss the military threat posed by the Japanese. Soon after, communications between the Japanese embassy in London and Tokyo were deciphered by the Bletchley Park code breakers. The decrypted messages were transcripts of the conference notes. When passed to an alarmed Churchill, he called them "pretty accurate stuff". Three months later, more notes from Churchill's personal agenda and inner circle were intercepted as they were being sent by the Japanese Embassy in London to the Foreign Ministry in Tokyo. Privately Churchill concluded with Anthony Eden that only two men could be the source of such leaks: Commander McGrath or Lord Sempill.
On 9 October 1941, a signed note from Churchill read: "Clear him out while time remains." The following week the Admiralty told Sempill he must either resign or be sacked.
After Sempill made an official protest, Churchill backtracked. The Prime Minister told the Admiralty: "I had not contemplated Lord Sempill being required to resign his commission, but only to be employed elsewhere in the Admiralty." A subsequent note from Churchill's aide Desmond Morton, dated 17 October 1941, outlined the new position: "The First Sea Lord ... proposes to offer him a post in the North of Scotland. I have suggested to Lord Swinton that MI5 should be informed in due course so they may take any precautions necessary."
On 13 December 1941, six days after the attack on Pearl Harbor, Sempill's office was raided. A search revealed various secret documents that he should have handed back to the Admiralty over three weeks earlier. Two days later Sempill was discovered making phone calls to the Japanese Embassy. Despite the evidence of treason in wartime (see Treachery Act 1940), no arrest or prosecution was ordered; Sempill agreed to retire from public office.
In 1919 Sempill married Eileen Marion Lavery, daughter of the Irish painter Sir John Lavery. Their first daughter, Ann Moira, was born in 1920. Their second daughter, June Mary, was born in c.1923, and was killed aged 18 as a result of enemy action on 11 May 1941 – the last day of the Blitz – at 15 Basil Street, London. She had been serving with the WVS Mobile Canteen Service.
Later years and death
In 1963 he gave Craigievar Castle to the National Trust for Scotland. He died in Edinburgh on 30 December 1965. His daughter, Ann, inherited the Sempill peerage, as it was one that could go to a female heir. However, the baronetcy, which could only be inherited in the male line, controversially passed to his younger sibling, Ewan Forbes, who had been brought up as a woman but was found by the courts to be "of indeterminate sex".
It was not until the release of intelligence records by the Public Record Office in 1998 and 2002 that Sempill's activities as a spy during the war and in the 1920s respectively became common knowledge.
Sempill's motives remain unclear. The National Archives states that "on the evidence of these [1920s] files", Sempill's activities on behalf of the militaristic Japanese and Fascist contacts were less from any desire to help the enemy but more motivated by his own impetuous character, obstinacy, and flawed judgement.
In various correspondence of the early 1940s, between Churchill's office, the Attorney General and the Director of Public Prosecutions, it is noted that Sempill had debts and an overdraft in excess of £13,000 (equivalent to £750,000 in 2012).
- Air Force Cross (AFC)
- 3rd Class of Commander in the Order of the Rising Sun, Japan.
- Order of the Polar Star, Sweden.
- British naval aviator and Japanese spy, Frederick Rutland
- Japanese spy in Hawaii, Takeo Yoshikawa
- German spy in Hawaii, Kuehn Family
- "R.Ae. Society Inaugural Lecture, 66th Session" (PDF), Flight: 1104, 3 October 1930
- Mckillop, James (3 January 2002). "Air pioneer revealed as traitor who sold secrets to Japanese". The Herald.
- Brooks, Richard (20 May 2012). "Traitor peer aided Pearl Harbor raid". Sunday Times.
- Paul Lashmar and Andrew Mullins (24 August 1998). "Churchill protected Scottish peer suspected of spying for Japan Second World War". The Independent. Retrieved 21 May 2012.
- "No. 28876". The London Gazette. 21 August 1914. p. 6596.
- "No. 29001". The London Gazette (Supplement). 9 December 1914. p. 10552.
- "No. 29009". The London Gazette (Supplement). 15 December 1914. p. 10793.
- "No. 29079". The London Gazette (Supplement). 19 February 1915. p. 1822.
- "No. 29162". The London Gazette. 14 May 1915. p. 4659.
- "No. 29267". The London Gazette (Supplement). 17 August 1915. p. 8240.
- "No. 29283". The London Gazette. 3 September 1915. p. 8730.
- "No. 29466". The London Gazette (Supplement). 4 February 1916. p. 1471.
- "No. 29434". The London Gazette. 11 January 1916. p. 450.
- "Obituary". Flight (flightglobal.com). 6 January 1966. p. 3.
- "No. 29886". The London Gazette (Supplement). 29 December 1916. p. 13.
- "The Royal Air Force". Flight (flightglobal.com). 4 April 1918. p. 379.
- "No. 30722". The London Gazette (Supplement). 31 May 1918. p. 6520.
- "No. 30958". The London Gazette. 18 October 1918. p. 12257.
- Peter C Smith, Fist from the Sky[page needed]
- Lewis (1970)[page needed]
- "An Ultra-Light Record". Flight (flightglobal.com). 9 April 1936. p. 375.
- Elston, Paul (Producer); Pigott-Smith, Tim (Narrator) (2012). The Fall of Singapore: The Great Betrayal. Brave New Media for BBC2 (Television production). All3Media International. Retrieved 14 October 2017.
- Cheesman, Frank Prelude to Pearl Harbour article in Aircraft Annual 1964 UK Ian Allan 1963 pp24-29
- Will Hollingworth (5 January 2002). "British lord was spy for Japan". Japan Times. Retrieved 21 May 2012.
- "R. (Richard) Buckminster Fuller 1895-1983". coachbuilt.com. Retrieved 29 May 2012.
- "Obituary". Flight (flightglobal.com). 25 July 1935. p. 96.
- "Lord Sempill". Spartacus.Schoolnet.co.uk. Archived from the original on 20 May 2012. Retrieved 21 May 2012.
- "William Forbes-Sempill". The National Archives. Retrieved 21 May 2012.
- "Forbes-Sempill, The Hon. June Mary". Commemorating the Fallen. Commonwealth War Graves Commission. Retrieved 5 January 2018.
- "Canada at War: Nova Scotia: The Baron Wants to Buy". Time. 20 March 1944. Retrieved 1 May 2018.
- Day, Peter (3 January 2002). "British aviation pioneer was a spy for Japan". Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 21 May 2012.
- Aldrich, Richard James (2000). Intelligence and the War Against Japan: Britain, America and the Politics of Secret Service. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0521641861.
- Anon. (2010) . "Sempill, William Francis Forbes-, nineteenth Lord Sempill (1893–1965)". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/33195.(Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
- Cortazzi, Hugh (2002). Britain & Japan: Biographical Portraits. 4. London: Japan Library. ISBN 9781903350140.
- Lewis, Peter (1970). British Racing and Record-Breaking Aircraft. London: Putnam. ISBN 0370000676.
- Polmar, Norman (2008). Aircraft Carriers: a history of carrier aviation and its influence on world events. 2 (2nd ed.). Washington, D.C.: Potomac Books. ISBN 1574886657.
- Saga, Jun'ichi (1990). Memories of Silk and Straw: a self-portrait of small-town Japan. Tokyo: Kodansha International. ISBN 4770014880.
- Smith, Peter C. (2006). Fist from the Sky: Japan's dive-bomber ace of World War II. Mechanicsburg, Pa.: Stackpole Books. ISBN 0811733300.
- West, Nigel; Tsarev, Oleg (2009). Triplex: secrets from the Cambridge spies. New Haven: Yale University Press. ISBN 0300123477.
- The Fall of Singapore: The Great Betrayal (2012 TV documentary) on IMDb
- National Portrait Gallery website
- 1935 account of passage over India as part of his world flight
- Report of auto crash at 1933 Chicago World's Fair
|Peerage of Scotland|
| Lord Sempill
|Baronetage of Nova Scotia|