Death by coconut

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Bilingual warning sign in Honolulu, written in English and Japanese.

Coconuts can cause death, typically as a result of the fruit falling from trees and striking people on the head. Following a 1984 study on "Injuries Due to Falling Coconuts", exaggerated claims spread concerning the number of deaths by falling coconuts. Falling coconuts, according to urban legend, kill a few people a year. This legend gained momentum after the 2002 work of a noted expert on shark attacks was characterized to say that falling coconuts kill 150 people worldwide each year.[1] The claim has often been compared with the number of shark-caused deaths per year, which is approximately five.[2]

Concern about the (remote) fatal risk posed by gravity's pull on coconuts caused local officials to remove coconut trees from local beaches in Queensland, Australia in 2002. One newspaper dubbed coconuts as, "the killer fruit."[3] Historical reports of actual deaths by coconut do date back to the 1770s.[4] But coconuts did play a lethal role in the South Pacific during World War II according to published accounts of Japanese forces weaponizing the tropical fruit by turning them into "coconut bombs" filled with acid and a hand grenade. [5]

Background[edit]

The range of the natural habitat of the coconut palm tree delineated by the red line (based on information in Werth 1933[6])

Coconut fruit comes from the coconut palm (Cocos nucifera) which can grow up to 30 m (98 ft) tall, with pinnate leaves 4–6 m (13–20 ft) long, and pinnae 60–90 cm long. Older leaves will break away cleanly from the tree leaving a smooth trunk.[7] While a mature and thriving tree can yield up to 75 fruits per year it's more common to get less than 30.[8] A full-sized coconut weighs about 1.44 kg (3.2 lb).[9] Coconut palms are cultivated in more than 80 countries of the world, with a total nut production of 61 million tonnes per year.[10]

The origin of the death by coconut legend was a 1984 research paper by Dr. Peter Barss, titled "Injuries Due to Falling Coconuts,: published in the Journal of Trauma (now known as the Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery).[11] In his paper, Barss observed that in Papua New Guinea (where he was based), over a period of four years, 2.5% of trauma admissions were for those injured by falling coconuts, with at least two fatalities.[12] That figure went onto be misquoted as 150 worldwide, which as based on the assumption other places would suffer a similar rate of falling coconut deaths.[13] In March 2012, Barss received an "Ig Nobel Award" from the Annals of Improbable Research in recognition of research that "cannot or should not be replicated." In response to the dubious distinction, Barss told the Canadian Medical Association Journal, "when you're treating these injuries daily, it's not funny at all."[14]

Following the publication of Barss' study, exaggerated claims about the number of deaths by coconut began to spread. Reports of death by coconut became so widespread that The Straight Dope, a newspaper column devoted to exposing myths, reported that it had become an urban legend.[15] Another writer, Joel Best, described the claim of widespread deaths as a "journalistic equivalent of a contemporary legend."[16] An analysis by the Shark Research Institute cites a press release from Club Travel, a U.K.-based travel insurance company, as helping to spread the urban legend. In an attempt to market travel insurance to individuals traveling to Papua New Guinea, the release stated that coconuts were "ten times more dangerous than sharks".[13] In May 2002, the legend gained new momentum when George H. Burgess, director of the International Shark Attack File, claimed that "[f]alling coconuts kill 150 people worldwide each year."[1]

Concerns about death by coconut have been reported extensively in mainstream media sources. Such reports include:

  • In February 1985, The New York Times reported on the hazards posed by coconut trees and noted that "falling coconuts could strike a person on the ground with a force of almost 2,000 pounds."[17]
  • In August 2001, the Toledo Blade reported that "a check with the experts" found that a human was more likely to be killed by a pig or a falling coconut than by "a shark on the prowl for dinner."[18]
  • In February 2002, The Daily Telegraph reported that coconut trees were being removed from beaches in Queensland, Australia, to guard against "death by coconut."[19]
  • In April 2002, the Boston Herald ran an op-ed piece titled "Travelers should watch out for coconuts – the killer fruit." The piece reported on the removal of palm trees bearing coconuts in Queensland and noted that local officials were "advising campers not to pitch their tents under coconut trees."[3]
  • In June 2002, The New York Times reported Burgess' claim that "the chances of being killed by a shark are less than those of being killed by a coconut that falls from a tree."[20]
  • In March 2003, The Morning Call in Pennsylvania reported, "You are 30 times more likely to be killed by a falling coconut than by a shark."[21]
  • In July 2005, Richard Roeper in the Chicago Sun-Times cited a 2001 report from the London Times for the proposition that, "You're more likely to be killed by a falling coconut than a shark."[22]
  • In February 2009, CBS News reported: "You have a better chance of being killed by a falling coconut than by a shark."[23]
  • Following shark sightings off the Massachusetts coast, The Boston Globe in September 2009 quoted a local resident as saying, "You're less likely to get killed by a shark than by a coconut falling on your head."[24]
  • In November 2010, The Guardian reported that the Indian government removed coconuts from the trees at Mumbai's Gandhi museum "for fear that a nut would descend on to the head of President Obama" who had recently visited the city. The article cited the Barss study and observed: "Thanks to Indian officials and perhaps also to Barss, Obama's recent visit to Mumbai was devoid of coconut trauma."[25]
  • In October 2011, the Australian Broadcasting Corporation broadcast a story in which Christopher Neff from the University of Sydney claimed that "while people may not pay attention to the statistics, you are more likely to be killed by a coconut than eaten by a shark."[26]

Documented occurrences[edit]

Death by falling coconut[edit]

Coconuts on tree near Cancún, Mexico

In order for a falling coconut to indeed kill somebody, the coconut must be heavy enough and the tree it drops from must be tall enough.[27] Documented instances of death by coconut include the following:

  • In approximately 1777, King Tetui of Mangaia in the Cook Islands had a concubine who died after being struck by "a falling green nut"[4]
  • In 1833, four people died from falling coconuts on the island of Ceylon[28]
  • In January 1943, a U.S. Marine was killed in his sleep when struck in the head by a falling coconut near Henderson Field on Guadalcanal[29]
  • On 26 August 1952, a seven-month-old baby died when it was struck in the head by a coconut while being held by its mother in Singapore[30]
  • In 1966, a resident of Rabaul, Papua New Guinea, was killed while eating lunch beneath a coconut tree when struck in the face by a falling coconut[31]
  • In July 1973, a two-year-old girl was killed, and her aunt injured, in Waikiki, Hawaii when "a hail of coconuts" fell from a 15-metre (49 ft) palm; the police reported 57 coconuts had fallen[32][33]
  • In November 1991, a mourner was killed by a falling coconut while attending a funeral at a cemetery in southern Sri Lanka[34]
  • On 17 January 1995, in Kota Baru, Malaysia Mat Hussin Sulaiman, 76, was killed when the monkey he used to pick coconuts from trees hurled a coconut, splitting his owner's skull open[35]
  • In April 2001, a resident of Vanuatu was killed by a falling coconut while seeking shelter from adverse weather conditions relating to Cyclone Sose[36]
  • On 15 August 2001, in Kampung Tanjung Badang, Malaysia, Mamat Kundur, age 59, was killed when a monkey used to harvest coconuts from trees dropped a coconut on his head[37]
  • On 1 August 2002, in Raub, Pahang, Malaysia, 6-month-old Nurul Emilia Zulaika Nasaruddin, died after a coconut fell into the child's crib and struck the child[38]
  • On 22 September 2003, in Raub, Pahang Malaysia, Deraman Ghomat, 65, was waiting to catch a bus, the wind became stronger and it started to rain just before a coconut fell[39]
  • In March 2009, 48-year-old Luelit Janchoom, in the Nakhon Si Thammarat province of Thailand, was killed when a monkey used to harvest coconuts furiously kicked them down to his master, hitting his head[40]
  • In May 2010, a one-and-a-half-month-old girl was killed when a falling coconut struck her in the head during a religious ceremony outside the family's home in Thiruvananthapuram, India[41]
  • In August 2010, a 69-year-old man was killed by a coconut that fell out of a 12-meter (39 ft) palm tree as he sat in a rocking chair outside his home in Melgar, Colombia[42]
  • In 2013, Buddika Priyanjana Perera of Wellampitiya, Sri Lanka, was walking when a coconut fell on his head[43]

Variations[edit]

While the typical form of death by coconut is by trauma resulting from a coconut falling from a tree under the force of gravity, variations on the phenomenon have also been reported.

One of the most unusual variations occurred in India in the 1930s. Newspapers across the world reported that a schoolboy in India had been killed by a "magic" or "enchanted" coconut.[44] In an effort to determine who had taken a book from a classroom, an elementary school teacher at Harnahalli required each of his students to touch a coconut bearing a namam, a religious symbol. The teacher claimed that the one who took the book would face "divine wrath" upon touching the coconut. One student resisted, but was forced to touch the coconut.[45] He reportedly contracted a high fever, fell into delirium, and died within an hour.[44][45]

In April 1983, a coconut was cited as the cause of death for a female goose-beaked whale. The husk from a coconut became lodged in its intestine, and the whale beached itself on a sandbar at Siesta Key, Florida.[46]

In May 1997, a report of death by coconut oil was published. The production line manager at a factory in Kiev, Ukraine, drowned in a vat of coconut oil. His body was discovered after he was reported as missing, and police were investigating to determine whether he fell or was pushed into the coconut oil.[47]

Other occurrences involve coconuts being used as deadly weapons. These include:

  • In 1944, reports were published that Japanese troops were using "coconut bombs" in defending against the American invasion of Leyte. Col. Allan Feldman reported that the bombs were created by placing hand grenades and picric acid inside hollowed-out coconuts. The coconuts were then sealed with wax, attached to a string, and thrown at the American troops.[5]
  • In July 2004, a 55-year-old Sri Lankan man was killed when he was struck on the head by a coconut. Police concluded that the blow was not the result of a coconut falling from a tree, but rather had been sustained in a fight that developed after the victim invited "a group of friends to his hut to enjoy a hooch party."[48]

There have also been reports of deaths resulting from the collapse of coconut palm trees. These include:

  • In April 1992, an 81-year-old man was killed in Malaysia when he was pinned under the trunk of a coconut tree that had been uprooted by high winds. His family noted that he had been employed as a "coconut plucker" and had previously survived a fall from a coconut tree.[49]
  • In May 2006, a man and a boy were killed by falling coconut palm trees during a tropical storm in the Philippines.[50]
  • In August 2011, a 56-year-old man was killed after an entire coconut tree toppled onto him while he was motorcycling in Kampung Baru Seberang Takir, Kuala Terengganu, Malaysia.[51]
  • Also in August 2011, the CEO of Milestone Capital, Ved Prakash Arya, was crushed and killed when a coconut palm tree fell on him in Mumbai. Following the incident, the local municipal authority resisted proposals to cut down the trees, noting, "We don't allow chopping down of coconut trees. The possibility of coconut trees falling down is very rare. The tree sustains huge wind velocity and suits the weather condition of city."[52]

Other reports credit the strength of the coconut palm trees with saving the lives of persons who have been tied to the trees for safety during high wind or tsunami events.[53][54][55]

Coconuts and the law[edit]

Deaths and injuries resulting from falling coconuts have been the subject of several legal proceedings that have been covered in the media.

In 1956, the City of Miami paid $300 to a woman after a coconut fell from a city-owned tree and struck her in the foot. In justifying the award, the city attorney explained that the city was allegedly on notice of the danger, because "a reasonable man would assume it was about to fall when it turns brown."[56]

In 1977, a jury in Hawaii awarded $39,000 to a police officer who was struck by a falling coconut. The officer was hit in the head while removing fronds from a public sidewalk in Lahaina. The property owner was sued for failing to maintain the trees.[57]

In December 2004, an English hotel guest by the surname of Brown was killed when a coconut from a tree near him dropped and hit his head as he ate breakfast. His spouse subsequently filed a lawsuit against the Dominican Republic-based hotel, as well as the tour agency Funtours which planned the couple's trip.[58] The latter was ruled to have been negligent in Brown's death and was ordered by the judge to pay $55 million in compensation. However, this did not transpire, as the agency went bankrupt.[59]

Popular culture[edit]

The American poet Frederick Seidel wrote a poem titled "Coconut", which included the following lines:

A coconut can fall and hit you on the head,
And if it falls from high enough can kind of knock you dead
Dead beneath the coconut palms, that's the life for me![60]

On their 1995 CD Makin' A Mess, the writing/singing team of Bob Gibson and Shel Silverstein included a song on this subject, entitled "Killed By A Coconut", which humorously describes a series of men and their fatal encounters with coconuts.[61]

Falling coconut injuries were featured in the American television series Gilligan's Island. A June 1965 episode revolved around an injury sustained by Gilligan after a falling coconut hit him in the nose.[62] Actor Bob Denver explained the success of the series as follows: "Little kids seem to love it. It doesn't take a great intellect or reasoning power to be able to laugh at a monkey running off with Gilligan's dinner or a guy getting conked on the head by a coconut."[63] When Denver died, the show's creator Sherwood Schwartz said that Denver didn't get enough credit for his talent as a slapstick actor: "A lot of people don't think it's hard to be an actor where all you have to do is react to a falling coconut."[64] In the film Cast Away, the stranded character played by Tom Hanks is alarmed several times by loud thuds, which he cannot identify. He finally sees a coconut fall, making the sound.

In March 2006, Newsweek ran a satirical article on former Enron CEO Kenneth Lay, stating he testified that he had sustained amnesia after being struck in the head by a falling coconut and as a result of the injury, was unable to recall the events that occurred during his time at Enron.[65]

When Keith Richards of The Rolling Stones underwent surgery and hospitalization for a brain injury in April 2006, some press reports erroneously blamed the injury on Richards' having been "conked by coconuts".[66] Falling coconuts had not caused the injury as Richards had climbed a coconut tree to collect the fruits and had then fallen from the tree.[67]

The video game Donkey Kong 3 has the antagonist Donkey Kong throwing coconuts from overhead at the player, trying to kill him. A hit causes a missed turn.[68]

In the Spongebob Squarepants Episode, "Rock-a-Bye Bivalve", Patrick Star is addicted to a show where nothing happens except a man gets hit in the head by a coconut.[69]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ a b Michael Perkins (1 October 2006). Surviving Paradise. Lulu.com. pp. 241–. ISBN 978-1-84728-935-3. 
  2. ^ "International Shark Attack File". Shark Research Institute. Archived from the original on 29 July 2013. Retrieved 9 January 2014. 
  3. ^ a b Beverly Beckham (7 April 2002). "Travelers should watch out for coconuts – the killer fruit". Boston Herald. 
  4. ^ a b MobileReference (2008). The Illustrated Encyclopedia of Trees and Shrubs: An Essential Guide to Trees and Shrubs of the World. pp. 1225–. ISBN 978-1-60501-487-6. 
  5. ^ a b "'Coconut Bomb' Used by Japs in Battle on Leyte". The Evening Independent. 20 December 1944. 
  6. ^ Werth, E. (1933). Distribution, Origin and Cultivation of the Coconut Palm.Ber. Deutschen Bot. Ges., vol 51, pp. 301–304. (article translated into English by Dr. R. Child, Director, Coconut Research Scheme, Lunuwila, Sri Lanka).
  7. ^ T. Pradeepkumar, B. Sumajyothibhaskar, and K.N. Satheesan. (2008). Management of Horticultural Crops (Horticulture Science Series Vol.11, 2nd of 2 Parts). New India Publishing. pp. 539–587. ISBN 978-81-89422-49-3.
  8. ^ Grimwood 1975, p. 18.
  9. ^ Bourke, R. Michael and Tracy Harwood (Eds.). (2009). Food and Agriculture in Papua New Guinea. Australian National University. p. 327. ISBN 978-1-921536-60-1.
  10. ^ Food And Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. Economic And Social Department. Statistics Division. (2 September 2010). Retrieved 14 April 2011 from the FAOSTAT Database.
  11. ^ William Hartston (August 2006). Mr. Hartston's Most Excellent Encyclopedia of Useless Information: The Supreme Miscellany of Fantastic Facts. John Blake. pp. 100–. ISBN 978-1-84358-160-4. 
  12. ^ Barss, P. (1984). Injuries due to Falling Coconuts. Journal of Trauma-Injury Infection & Critical Care. 24. 
  13. ^ a b "Mis quoted statistics". Shark Research Institute. Archived from the original on 29 July 2013. Retrieved 25 July 2013. 
  14. ^ Susan Pinker (March 2012). "The truth about falling coconuts". Canadian Medical Association Journal. 
  15. ^ "Are 150 people killed each year by falling coconuts?". The Straight Dope. 19 July 2012. 
  16. ^ Joel Best (7 August 2004). More Damned Lies and Statistics: How Numbers Confuse Public Issues. University of California Press. pp. 19–. ISBN 978-0-520-93002-5. 
  17. ^ Bayard Webster (5 February 1985). "Coconuts and Palm Trees Are Hazards in Paradise". The New York Times. 
  18. ^ "'Shark bites man' a non-story". Toledo Blade. 28 August 2001. 
  19. ^ Ben Westwood (23 February 2002). "Trees must go as Queensland guards against death by coconut". The Daily Telegraph. 
  20. ^ "How It Works: When Sharks Don't Bite". The New York Times. 13 June 2002. 
  21. ^ Randy Kraft (9 March 2003). "Shark Quest' is the new lure at the Baltimore aquarium". Morning Call – Allentown, Pa. 
  22. ^ Richard Roeper (11 July 2005). "One word describes latest episode of Hurricane TV". Chicago Sun-Times. 
  23. ^ "Most Lethal: Shark or Falling Coconut". CBS News. 11 February 2009. 
  24. ^ "Sharks spotted off Chatham coast; but officials say threat is small". Boston Globe. 5 September 2009. 
  25. ^ Marc Abrahams (15 November 2010). "Improbable research: mind your head! Coconuts can be responsible for nasty head injuries, as a study in The Journal of Trauma reveals". The Guardian. 
  26. ^ "Perfect Predators". Australian Broadcasting Corporation. 25 October 2011. 
  27. ^ Suriani Kitchen. Westland. 2009. pp. 42–. ISBN 978-93-80032-91-7. 
  28. ^ J. Ferguson (1904). All About the 'Coconut Palm'. A.M. & J. Ferguson. p. xci. 
  29. ^ Fancis Fox Parry (2010). Three-War Marine: The Pacific – Korea – Vietnam. Pacifica Military History. p. 92. ISBN 1890988383. 
  30. ^ "Baby Killed By Coconut". The Mercury (Hobart TAS). 27 August 1952. Retrieved 6 June 2011. 
  31. ^ "Man killed by falling coconut". The Age. 11 November 1966. 
  32. ^ "Coconut Shower Fatal to Infant". Reading Eagle (UPI story). 29 July 1973. 
  33. ^ Bakutis Bunky (15 January 1999). "'Aina? Falling Coconuts". Honolulu Advertiser. 
  34. ^ "Coconut kills mourner at cemetery". New Straits Times. 19 November 1991. 
  35. ^ "Monkey hurls coconut at man – and kills him!". Weekly World News. 21 March 1995. Retrieved 2014-11-20. 
  36. ^ Steve Newman (15 April 2001). "Earthwatch: Diary of a Planet". The Edmonton Journal. 
  37. ^ "Monkey kills man with coconut". Living Media India Ltd. New Straits Times. Retrieved 8 Apr 2011. 
  38. ^ "Infant killed by bouncing coconut". Living Media India Ltd. New Straits Times. Retrieved 4 August 2011. 
  39. ^ "Falling coconut kills man". Living Media India Ltd. New Straits Times. 23 September 2003. Retrieved 2014-11-20. 
  40. ^ Anupan, Chat (9 March 2009). "'Abused' monkey kills its owner". Samui Express. Retrieved 25 November 2014. 
  41. ^ "Baby dies as coconut falls on head". The Times of India. 17 May 2010. 
  42. ^ "Falling coconut kills Colombian man". Mid Day. 28 August 2010. 
  43. ^ Daily News, Sri Lanka, Man was killed by a falling coconut
  44. ^ a b "Schoolboy Killed by Magic Coconut". The Calgary Herald. 17 March 1934. 
  45. ^ a b ""That Coconut": Sick Boy's Cry Before Death". The Indian Express. 1933. 
  46. ^ Jack Gurney (30 April 1983). "Coconut Blamed In Whale's Death". Sarasota Herald-Tribune. 
  47. ^ "Coconut oil death". The Victoria Advocate. 21 May 1997. 
  48. ^ Cyril Wimalasurendre (3 July 2004). "Party end in tragedy". The Island. 
  49. ^ "Falling trees kill man, injure three". New Strait Times. 17 April 1992. 
  50. ^ "At least 29 people killed in RP storm". The China Post. 14 May 2006. 
  51. ^ "Falling coconut tree kills 56-year-old boatman". AsiaOne. 11 August 2011. 
  52. ^ "Felling coconut trees against BMC policy". DNA India. 27 August 2011. 
  53. ^ "A Roar, Then Blackness: 'I Have Lost Everything'". The New York Times. 3 May 1991. (report on a Kutubdia Island man who lost six family members to a cyclone but saved one son by tying him to a coconut tree)
  54. ^ "Rescue efforts all at sea". Brisbane Times. 7 April 2007. ("Stories are told of how during cyclones people in Kiribati would tie themselves to coconut trees so they would not be blown into the ocean.")
  55. ^ "First body flown in as mother tells of miracle". The Observer. 1 January 2005. (report of man saving his family from the 2004 Indian Ocean earthquake and tsunami by tying them to a coconunt tree)
  56. ^ "Miami Pays Damages For Falling Coconut". Ocala Star-Banner. 4 October 1956. 
  57. ^ "Damages collected for falling coconut". The Spokesman-Review (AP story). 1 June 1977. 
  58. ^ Del Monté 2013, p. 1.
  59. ^ Del Monté 2013, p. 5.
  60. ^ Frederick Seidel (2009). Poems 1959–2009. Macmillan. p. 15. ISBN 0374126550. 
  61. ^ Gibson, Bob (1995). Makin' A Mess (CD). Asylum Records. 
  62. ^ "Gilligan's Island on CBS". TV Guide. Retrieved 26 July 2013. 
  63. ^ "Bob Denver & Co. Will Glow More Brightly This Season on 'Gilligan's Island'". The Milwaukee Journal. 5 September 1965. 
  64. ^ Bill Keveney (6 September 2005). "Bob Denver, classic TV's Gilligan, dead at age 70". USA Today. 
  65. ^ "Ken Lay Claims Amnesia After Coconut Fell on His Head". Newsweek. 14 March 2006. 
  66. ^ "Keith Richards Conked By Coconuts". Pop Blend. 30 April 2006. 
  67. ^ "Keith Richards 'tree fall' injury". BBC News. 
  68. ^ "Review: Donkey Kong 3 (Wii U eShop / NES)". nintendo life. Retrieved 22 October 2014. 
  69. ^ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0707297/?ref_=ttpl_pl_tt

Bibliography[edit]