Gulliver's nightclub fire
|Gulliver's Nightclub Fire|
|Location||Port Chester, New York|
June 30, 1974 |
|Perpetrator||Peter J. Leonard|
|Motive||To cover up burglary at adjacent bowling alley|
The Gulliver's nightclub fire occurred on the early morning of June 30, 1974 on the border of Port Chester, New York and Greenwich, Connecticut. The fire killed 24 patrons and injured 19 patrons and 13 firemen. The fire was caused by arson in an adjacent bowling alley that had been set to cover up a minor burglary there.
The restaurant was formally known as Gulliver's Restaurant Inc. and opened in 1971. It attracted crowds of young people, particularly Connecticut residents, since the drinking age at the time was lower in New York than Connecticut.  The restaurant was originally the Old Post Grill, but that burned in 1962; then it was Lucy's, which had a fire in 1968. The building was owned by the Port Chester Electrical Construction Corporation.
The building housing Gulliver's was on the border of Port Chester and Greenwich and so spanned the county and state line between Westchester County, New York and Fairfield County, Connecticut. Gulliver's was a restaurant and bar with its entrance on the Greenwich side. Most of Gulliver's was considered on the New York side, and had been inspected by Port Chester fire authorities two months before the fire. The other businesses in the building were considered to be in Greenwich and had not been inspected since 1964 when the last equipment was installed.
On the main floor of Gulliver's was a dining room, main bar and the kitchen. Down a short but fairly narrow flight of stairs was the lower level where the lounge was. In this area was a sunken dance floor. It was in this lower level where the late night discotheque took place.
There were about 200 young people in the lower level lounge at the time of the fire, just before 1 a.m. The band was The Creation, and included Paul Caravello (who would later be part of Kiss under the name Eric Carr). They stopped playing the song "I Wanna Know Your Name" after a waitress told them she smelled smoke. They announced "There's a fire. Please walk out quietly." Within minutes, the sunken dance floor was enveloped in heavy smoke and the lights went out. At this point there was a panic, with patrons unable to get up the stairs to the main floor of the club and the main entrance where they had come in.
19 fire companies responded to the incident, mainly from the Port Chester and Greenwich Fire Departments, but from other Westchester and Connecticut municipalities as well. Initial attempts to enter the building were hampered by intense heat and smoke. Various reports claim it took about 90 minutes to four hours to get the fire under control.
Most of the 24 victims were found at the foot of the stairs, with some others on the sunken dance floor.
The county medical examiner reported that many of the bodies were so charred that dental work was the only way of identifying the victims.
Autopsies revealed that all the victims died from asphyxiation. This quashed rumors that victims had been trampled to death. Also, some electric clocks were found in the rubble stopped at 1:50 showing that power had been on during the fire and that a total blackout had not occurred.
The source of the fire initially appeared to be the nursery of the bowling alley, which was located in the basement under the clothing store. The exact location of the start of the fire proved to be very important, since it determined whether New York or Connecticut authorities had responsibility for the final investigation.
Peter J. Leonard of Greenwich, an unemployed laborer and high school dropout who was 22 years old, was arrested by Connecticut authorities on July 12, 1974 on charges of setting the fire. Authorities stated that he was a frequent patron of the bowling alley and had been there early in the evening and then left when the alleys closed, returning later through a roof-top skylight with the intention of burglarizing the business. On July 16, it was announced that final building surveys revealed that the part of the nursery where the fire was set as well as the skylight where Leonard entered the alleys were both in New York State.
The bowling alley where the fire started had gone without government fire inspections for five years before the fire. The cause of this lapse appeared to be an agreement written in 1961 from the Connecticut State Fire Marshal to both municipalities involved that was forgotten about after the retirement of a Port Chester fire inspector in 1969. The agreement stated that Port Chester would take responsibility for inspecting the bowling alley because most of it was in New York State. Officials in Port Chester questioned the legality of the agreement after the fire, saying the parties who drew it up had no legal authority to do so.
The legal process
Once it was determined that the fire was set in New York, extradition was sought to bring the suspect from Connecticut to New York. Leonard waived extradition and was indicted by a Westchester County Grand Jury on July 30 on 28 counts, consisting of 24 murder charges (one for each victim), arson, burglary and two counts of petit larceny. The theory of the crime was that Leonard had burglarized some cigarette vending machines in the bowling alley and set the fire to cover up the burglary.
Leonard pleaded guilty just before his trial was due to start on June 16, 1975. Then, on his sentencing hearing on July 16, he tried to withdraw the plea. The judge refused the request to withdraw the plea and sentenced Leonard to 15 years to life imprisonment. The judge commented that Leonard had performed "stupid actions in attempting to cover up a third-rate burglary by arson, resulting in Westchester's worst tragedy." He also said "You're certainly not an all American boy, but you're not a vicious killer either."
On July 19, 1977, the guilty verdict for murder was overturned by the Appellate Court, because his confession was found to be coerced.
He was then convicted by a jury on September 7, 1978 after 81⁄2 hours of deliberation on all 28 counts of the indictment. This guilty verdict was overturned on December 16, 1985 because the Appellate Division found that self-incriminating statements had been made without a lawyer present.
On March 25, 1986, prosecutors allowed Leonard to plead guilty to second degree manslaughter. On April 9, 1986, he was sentenced to 15 years. Under New York law, inmates with good records were released after serving two thirds of their sentence, therefore he qualified for release soon afterwards.
The first civil lawsuit began July 5, 1974 when a lawyer representing the husband of one of the victims, Jonetta Horsey, who perished in the fire, filed papers starting a $2 million suit. The filing asked that the attorney be included in the fire investigation.
By July 8, 1974, nine families had retained counsel for possible lawsuits.
On July 9, 1974, an attorney representing six families who lost loved ones filed a notice of claim for $12 million with the Village of Port Chester. The notice contended that Port Chester "was negligent and careless in failing to make proper and sufficient inspections" of both the restaurant and bowling alley. Even though the bowling alley was almost entirely in Connecticut, the attorney filing the papers said the fact that it adjoined the restaurant (which was mostly in New York) made it Port Chester's responsibility.
On July 15, 1974, it was reported that Greenwich would be served with a notice of claim for $16 million on behalf of 8 victims of the fire.
Due to most victims not being local, there is little commemoration of the tragedy.
- Berger, Joseph (July 1, 1999). "25 Years Later, Disco Fire Haunts Its Survivors". New York Times. Retrieved July 7, 2013.
- Teichgraeber, Kathleen (July 1, 1974). "24 die in blaze at Gulliver's; D.A. launches full-scale probe". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. pp. 1, 12.
- "Fire crossed border?". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. July 1, 1974. p. 2.
- Montgomery, Paul L. (July 1, 1974). "Terror-Stricken Throng Rushes for Narrow Stairway to Exit". New York Times.
- Plunkett, R.B. Jr. (July 2, 1974). "Inspections late". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. pp. 1, 14.
- Kelly, Tom (July 1, 1974). "Fire in N.Y. Discotheque Fatal to 24 Persons". Unknown newspaper. Associated Press. Retrieved July 7, 2013.
- Stanton, Sydney; Bissel, Elaine (July 1, 1974). "Band warned of fire". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. p. 3.
- Stevenson, H.L. (July 1, 1974). "New York Suburban 'Disco' Fire Kills 24 Merrymakers". Unknown Newspaper. United Press International. Retrieved July 7, 2013.
- "Only teeth can tell ID". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. July 1, 1974. pp. 2B.
- Greenhouse, Linda (July 3, 1974). "Inquiry Indicates Fire Fatal to 24 Started in Nursery". New York Times.
- Moss, Brian (July 15, 1974). "N.Y., Conn. await report of surveyors". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. p. 1.
- Carmody, Deirdre (July 17, 1974). "Westchester to Charge Man With Murder in Bar Fire That Killed 24 on New York-Connecticut Border". New York Times.
- Moss, Brian (July 12, 1974). "Arson in Gulliver's tragedy?". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. pp. 1, 12.
- "Leonard charged with murder". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. July 16, 1974. p. 1.
- Moss, Brian (July 16, 1974). "Snarl in fire check?". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. pp. 1, 10.
- "Greenwich Suspect Indicted in Deaths Of 24 at Gulliver's". New York Times. July 31, 1974.
- "A Connecticut Man Gets 15-Year Term For Fire Killing 24". New York Times. July 17, 1975.
- Seigel, Max H. (July 20, 1977). "Appeals Court Upsets Conviction In Port Chester Fire Fatal to 24". New York Times.
- "Murder Guilt Ruled". The Spokesman-Review. Spokane, Washington. Associated Press. September 8, 1978. p. 12. Retrieved July 8, 2013.
- "Appeal Is Planned In Arson Murders". The New York Times. December 18, 1985. Retrieved July 8, 2013.
- "Sentenced man to be freed". Record-Journal. Meriden, Connecticut. United Press International. April 10, 1986. p. 38. Retrieved July 8, 2013.
- "Lawsuit looms in Gulliver's fire". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. July 6, 1974. p. 1.
- Moss, Brian (July 9, 1974). "Possible fire lawsuits spreading". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. p. 1.
- Moss, Brian (July 10, 1974). "$12 million claim hits village". The Daily Item. Port Chester, New York. pp. 1, 12.