Jump to content

Wade–Giles

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by PalaceGuard008 (talk | contribs) at 12:58, 26 April 2016 (System features: correction from internet name to actual name of script). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Wade–Giles
Traditional Chinese韋氏拼音
Simplified Chinese韦氏拼音
Transcriptions
Standard Mandarin
Hanyu PinyinWéi Shì Pīnyīn
Bopomofoㄨㄟˊ ㄕˋ ㄆㄧㄣ ㄧㄣ
Gwoyeu RomatzyhWei Shyh Pin'in
Wade–GilesWei2-shih4 P'in1-yin1
Tongyong PinyinWéi Shìh Pinyin
MPS2Wéi Shr̀ Pīnyīn
Alternative name
Traditional Chinese威妥瑪拼音
Simplified Chinese威妥玛拼音
Transcriptions
Standard Mandarin
Hanyu PinyinWēituǒmǎ Pīnyīn
Bopomofoㄨㄟ ㄊㄨㄛˇ ㄇㄚˇ ㄆㄧㄣ ㄧㄣ
Gwoyeu RomatzyhUeituoomaa Pin'in
Wade–GilesWei1-t'o3-ma3 P'in1-yin1
Tongyong PinyinWeituǒmǎ Pinyin
MPS2Wēituǒmǎ Pīnyīn

Wade–Giles (/ˌwd ˈlz/), sometimes abbreviated Wade, is a romanization system for Mandarin Chinese. It developed from a system produced by Thomas Wade, during the mid-19th century, and was given completed form with Herbert Giles's Chinese–English Dictionary of 1892.

Wade–Giles was the system of transcription in the English-speaking world for most of the 20th century, used in standard reference books and in English language books published before 1979. It replaced the Nanjing-based romanization systems that had been common until the late 19th century, such as the Postal romanization (still used in some place-names). In mainland China it has been entirely replaced by the pinyin system approved in 1958. Outside mainland China, it has mostly been replaced by pinyin, even though Taiwan still implements a multitude of romanization systems in daily life. Additionally, its usage can still be seen in the common English names of certain individuals and locations such as Chiang Ching-kuo.

History

Wade–Giles was developed by Thomas Francis Wade, a scholar of Chinese and a British ambassador in China who was the first professor of Chinese at Cambridge University. Wade published in 1867 the first textbook on the Beijing dialect of Mandarin in English, the Yü-yen tzu-erh chi (traditional: 語言自邇集; simplified: 语言自迩集),[1] which became the basis for the Romanization system later known as Wade–Giles. The system, designed to transcribe Chinese terms for Chinese specialists, was further refined in 1912 by Herbert Allen Giles, a British diplomat in China and his son, Lionel Giles, a curator at the British Museum.[2]

Taiwan has used Wade–Giles for decades as the de facto standard, co-existing with several official but obscure romanizations in succession, namely, Gwoyeu Romatzyh (1928), Mandarin Phonetic Symbols II (1986), and Tongyong pinyin (2000). With the election of the Kuomintang party in Taiwan in 2008, Taiwan officially switched to Hanyu pinyin. However, people in Taiwan, both native and overseas, use or transcribe their legal names in the Wade–Giles system.

Initials and finals

The tables below show the Wade–Giles representation of each Chinese sound (in bold type), together with the corresponding IPA phonetic symbol (in square brackets), and equivalent representations in zhuyin fuhao and hanyu pinyin.

Initials

Bilabial Labiodental Dental/Alveolar Retroflex Alveolo-palatal Velar
Voiceless Voiced Voiceless Voiceless Voiced Voiceless Voiced Voiceless Voiceless
Nasal m [m]
ㄇ m
n [n]
ㄋ n
Plosive Unaspirated p [p]
ㄅ b
t [t]
ㄉ d
k [k]
ㄍ g
Aspirated p' [pʰ]
ㄆ p
t' [tʰ]
ㄊ t
k' [kʰ]
ㄎ k
Affricate Unaspirated ts [ts]
ㄗ z
ch [ʈʂ]
ㄓ zh
ch [tɕ]
ㄐ j
Aspirated ts' [tsʰ]
ㄘ c
ch' [ʈʂʰ]
ㄔ ch
ch' [tɕʰ]
ㄑ q
Fricative f [f]
ㄈ f
s [s]
ㄙ s
sh [ʂ]
ㄕ sh
hs [ɕ]
ㄒ x
h [x]
ㄏ h
Liquid l [l]
ㄌ l
j [ɻ]
ㄖ r

For variant representations (ts, ts', ss, tz, tz', sz) used before the "empty rime", see the Empty rime section, below.

Finals

Coda
/i/ /u/ /n/ /ŋ/ /ɻ/
Medial ih/û
[ɨ]
-i
ê/o
[ɤ]
ㄜ e
a
[a]
ㄚ a
ei
[ei̯]
ㄟ ei
ai
[ai̯]
ㄞ ai
ou
[ou̯]
ㄡ ou
ao
[au̯]
ㄠ ao
ên
[ən]
ㄣ en
an
[an]
ㄢ an
ung
[ʊŋ]
ㄨㄥ ong
êng
[əŋ]
ㄥ eng
ang
[aŋ]
ㄤ ang
êrh
[aɚ̯]
ㄦ er
/i/ i
[i]
ㄧ i
ieh
[i̯e]
ㄧㄝ ie
ia
[i̯a]
ㄧㄚ ia
iu
[i̯ou̯]
ㄧㄡ iu
iao
[i̯au̯]
ㄧㄠ iao
in
[in]
ㄧㄣ in
ien
[i̯ɛn]
ㄧㄢ ian
iung
[i̯ʊŋ]
ㄩㄥ iong
ing
[iŋ]
ㄧㄥ ing
iang
[i̯aŋ]
ㄧㄤ iang
/u/ u
[u]
ㄨ u
o/uo
[u̯o]
ㄨㄛ uo
ua
[u̯a]
ㄨㄚ ua
ui
[u̯ei̯]
ㄨㄟ ui
uai
[u̯ai̯]
ㄨㄞ uai
un
[u̯ən]
ㄨㄣ un
uan
[u̯an]
ㄨㄢ uan
uêng
[u̯əŋ]
ㄨㄥ ueng
uang
[u̯aŋ]
ㄨㄤ uang
/y/ ü
[y]
ㄩ ü
üeh
[y̯e]
ㄩㄝ üe
ün
[yn]
ㄩㄣ ün
üan
[y̯ɛn]
ㄩㄢ üan

System features

Consonants and initial symbols

A feature of the Wade–Giles system is the representation of the unaspirated-aspirated stop consonant pairs using apostrophes: p, p', t, t', k, k', ch, ch'. The use of apostrophes preserves b, d, g, and j for the romanization of Chinese varieties containing voiced consonants, such as Shanghainese (which has a full set of voiced consonants) and Min Nan (Hō-ló-oē) whose century-old Pe̍h-ōe-jī (POJ, often called Missionary Romanization) is similar to Wade–Giles. POJ, Legge romanization, Simplified Wade, and EFEO Chinese transcription use the letter ⟨h⟩ instead of an apostrophe to indicate aspiration (this is similar to the superscript ʰ used in IPA). The convention of the apostrophe or ⟨h⟩ to denote aspiration is also found in romanizations of other Asian languages, such as McCune–Reischauer for Korean and ISO 11940 for Thai.

People unfamiliar with Wade–Giles often ignore the apostrophes, sometimes omitting them when copying texts, unaware that they represent vital information. Hanyu Pinyin addresses this issue by employing the Latin letters customarily used for voiced stops, unneeded in Mandarin, to represent the unaspirated stops: b, p, d, t, g, k, j, q, zh, ch.

Partly because of the popular omission of the apostrophe, the four sounds represented in Hanyu pinyin by j, q, zh, and ch all become ch in many literature and personal names. However, were the diacritics to be kept, the system reveals a symmetry that leaves no overlap:

  • The non-retroflex ch (Pinyin j) and ch' (pinyin q) are always before either i or ü.
  • The retroflex ch (Pinyin zh) and ch' (pinyin ch) are always before a, e, ih, o, or u.

Vowels and final symbols

Syllabic consonants

Wade–Giles shows precisions not found in other major Romanizations in regard to the rendering of the two types of syllabic consonant (simplified Chinese: 空韵; traditional Chinese: 空韻; pinyin: kōngyùn):

  • -u (formerly û) after the sibilants written in this position as tz (ts), tz' (ts') and sz (ss) (pinyin z, c and s).
  • -ih after the retroflex ch, ch', sh, and j (pinyin zh, ch, sh, and r).

These finals are both written as -i in Hanyu pinyin (hence distinguishable only by context from true i as in li), and as -ih in Tongyong pinyin. They are typically omitted in Zhuyin (Bopomofo).

IPA ʈ͡ʂɻ̩ ʈ͡ʂʰɻ̩ ʂɻ̩ ɻɻ̩ t͡sɹ̩ t͡sʰɹ̩ sɹ̩
Wade–Giles new chih ch'ih shih jih tzu tz'u szu
old tsû ts'û ssû
Zhuyin
Pinyin zhi chi shi ri zi ci si

Vowel o

Final o in Wade–Giles has two pronunciations in modern Mandarin: [u̯o] and [ɯ̯ɤ]. What is pronounced today as a close-mid back unrounded vowel is written usually as ê as in pinyin, but sometimes as o, depending on historical pronunciation (at the time Wade–Giles was developed). Notably, after velar initials k-, k'- and h- (and a historical ng-, which has been dropped by the time Wade–Giles was developed), o is used for characters like "哥" (Wade–Giles ko, pinyin ge), though ê also exists after velars, like in "刻" (Wade–Giles k'ê, pinyin ke). Ê is used in other environments. By modern Mandarin, -o after velars (and what used to be ng-) have shifted to -ê, thus they are written as ge, ke, he and e in pinyin.

What is pronounced today as -uo is virtually always written as -o in Wade–Giles, except for characters like "說" (pronounced shuo even back at the time Wade–Giles was developed) and the three syllables of kuo, k'uo, and huo (as in 過, 霍, etc.), which contrasted with ko, k'o, and ho that correspond to pinyin ge, ke, and he. This is because characters like 羅, 多, etc. (Wade–Giles: lo, to; pinyin: luo, duo) did not originally carry the medial -u-. By modern Mandarin, the phonemic distinction between -o and -uo has been lost (except in interjections when used alone), and the medial -u- is added in front of -o, creating the modern -uo.

IPA pu̯o pʰu̯o mu̯o fu̯o tu̯o tʰu̯o nu̯o lu̯o kʰɤ ʈʂu̯o ʈʂʰu̯o ʐu̯o ʦu̯o ʦʰu̯o su̯o
Wade–Giles po p'o mo fo to t'o no lo ko k'o ho cho ch'o jo tso ts'o so
Zhuyin ㄨㄛ ㄨㄛ ㄨㄛ ㄨㄛ ㄨㄛ ㄨㄛ ㄨㄛ ㄨㄛ ㄨㄛ ㄨㄛ
Pinyin bo po mo fo duo tuo nuo luo ge ke he zhuo chuo ruo zuo cuo suo

Tones

Tones are indicated in Wade–Giles using superscript numbers (1–4) placed after the syllable; the neutral tone is denoted either by the super-script number '5' or '0' or, sometimes, by the absence of tone number. This contrasts with the use of diacritics to represent the tones in pinyin. For example, the pinyin qiàn (fourth tone) has the Wade–Giles equivalent ch'ien4. The tone numbers are generally omitted except in textbooks.

Punctuation

Wade–Giles uses hyphens to separate all syllables within a word (whereas pinyin separates syllables only in ambiguous cases, using apostrophes, as in Xi'an).

If a syllable is not the first in a word, its first letter is not capitalized, even if it is part of a proper noun. The use of apostrophes, hyphens, and capitalization is frequently not observed in place names and personal names. For example, the majority of overseas Taiwanese write their given names like "Tai Lun" or "Tai-Lun", whereas the Wade–Giles is actually "Tai-lun". (See also Chinese name.)

For the apostrophes used in Wade–Giles to denote aspirated consonants, Giles's original dictionary used left apostrophes (‘) consistently. This orientation was followed in Sinological works until the 1950s or 60s, when it started to be gradually replaced by right apostrophes (’) in academic literature. Online publications almost invariably use the plain apostrophe ('). Apostrophes are not included in Taiwanese passports, and are absent in overseas Chinese names.

Comparison with other systems

Pinyin

  • Wade–Giles chose the French-like j to represent a Northerner's [clarification needed] pronunciation of what is represented as r in Pinyin.
  • Ü always has a trema (diaeresis) above, while pinyin only employs it in the cases of , , nüe and lüe, while leaving it out in -ue, ju-, qu-, xu-, -uan and yu- as a simplification because u cannot otherwise appear in those positions. Because (as in 玉 "jade") must have a diaeresis in Wade, the diaeresis-less yu in Wade–Giles is freed up for what corresponds to you (有) in Pinyin.
  • The pinyin vowel cluster ong is ung in Wade–Giles. (Compare Kung Fu to Gong Fu as an example.)
  • After a consonant, both the Wade–Giles and Pinyin vowel cluster uei is written ui. Furthermore, both Romanizations use iu and un instead of the complete syllables: iou and uen.
  • Single i is never preceded by y, as in pinyin. The only exception is in placenames, which are hyphenless, so without a y, syllable ambiguity could arise.
  • The isolated syllable eh is written as ê, like in pinyin. (Schwa is occasionally written as ê as well.) But unlike Pinyin, which uses -e if there is a consonant preceding the sound, Wade–Giles uses -eh. (See circumflex)
  • In addition to being the schwa, ê also represents the pinyin er as êrh.

Chart

Vowels a, e, o
IPA a ɔ ɛ ɤ ai ei au ou an ən əŋ ʊŋ
Pinyin a o ê e ai ei ao ou an en ang eng ong er
Tongyong Pinyin
Wade–Giles eh ê/o ên êng ung êrh
Bopomofo ㄨㄥ
example
Vowels i, u, y
IPA i je jou jɛn in jʊŋ u wo wei wən wəŋ y ɥe ɥɛn yn
Pinyin yi ye you yan yin ying yong wu wo/o wei wen weng yu yue yuan yun
Tongyong Pinyin wun wong
Wade–Giles i/yi yeh yu yen yung wên wêng yüeh yüan yün
Bopomofo ㄧㄝ ㄧㄡ ㄧㄢ ㄧㄣ ㄧㄥ ㄩㄥ ㄨㄛ/ㄛ ㄨㄟ ㄨㄣ ㄨㄥ ㄩㄝ ㄩㄢ ㄩㄣ
example
Non-sibilant consonants
IPA p m fəŋ tjou twei twən tʰɤ ny ly kʰɤ
Pinyin b p m feng diu dui dun te ge ke he
Tongyong Pinyin fong diou duei nyu lyu
Wade–Giles p fêng tiu tui tun tʻê ko kʻo ho
Bopomofo ㄈㄥ ㄉㄧㄡ ㄉㄨㄟ ㄉㄨㄣ ㄊㄜ ㄋㄩ ㄌㄩ ㄍㄜ ㄎㄜ ㄏㄜ
example
Sibilant consonants
IPA tɕjɛn tɕjʊŋ tɕʰin ɕɥɛn ʈʂɤ ʈʂɨ ʈʂʰɤ ʈʂʰɨ ʂɤ ʂɨ ɻɤ ɻɨ tsɤ tswo tsɨ tsʰɤ tsʰɨ
Pinyin jian jiong qin xuan zhe zhi che chi she shi re ri ze zuo zi ce ci se si
Tongyong Pinyin jyong cin syuan jhe jhih chih shih rih zih cih sih
Wade–Giles chien chiung chʻin hsüan chê chih chʻê chʻih shê shih jih tsê tso tzŭ tsʻê tzʻŭ ssŭ
Bopomofo ㄐㄧㄢ ㄐㄩㄥ ㄑㄧㄣ ㄒㄩㄢ ㄓㄜ ㄔㄜ ㄕㄜ ㄖㄜ ㄗㄜ ㄗㄨㄛ ㄘㄜ ㄙㄜ
example
Tones
IPA ma˥ ma˧˥ ma˨˩˦ ma˥˩ ma
Pinyin ma
Tongyong Pinyin ma
Wade–Giles ma1 ma2 ma3 ma4 ma
Bopomofo ㄇㄚ ㄇㄚˊ ㄇㄚˇ ㄇㄚˋ ˙ㄇㄚ
example (Chinese characters)

Note: In Hanyu pinyin the so-called fifth accent (neutral accent) is written leaving the syllable with no diacritic mark at all. In Tongyong Pinyin a ring is written over the vowel instead.

Bastardized Wade-Giles (Intuitiveness Issues with Wade-Giles)

Due to the system's use of the apostrophe, or the ayn, to distinguish voiceless and voiced consonants, such as in "p'a" and "pa" respectively, rather than using separate letters like in Pinyin and many other romanisations, such as in "pa" and "ba" respectively, many Western scholars have omitted the apostrophe in transcribing Chinese words and names, assuming that it was an optional diacritic, thus leading to many Westerners mispronouncing many Chinese words and adding difficulty to Westerners trying to learn how to speak Mandarin. [3] Examples of Mandarin Chinese words that have been frequently mispronounced are tai chi (which is actually pronounced more like "tai ji"), Tao ("Dao"), Peking ("Beijing"), Taichung ("Taizhong"), kung fu ("gong fu"), tofu ("dou fu"), and several others. [4] Due to the unintuitiveness of the spelling system misleading Westerners, the Communist Party of China (CPC) made Pinyin the official romanization system of mainland China in the 1970s, which uses separate letters instead of apostrophes and tends to more accurately reflect modern Mandarin pronunciation for certain phonemes, like using the letter "j" as in "Beijing" instead of "k" as in "Peking".

See also

References

  1. ^ Kaske, Elisabeth (2008). The Politics of Language in Chinese Education: 1895 - 1919. BRILL. p. 68. ISBN 90-04-16367-0.
  2. ^ "Chinese Language Transliteration Systems – Wade–Giles". UCLA film and television archive. Archived from the original on 28 January 2007. Retrieved 4 August 2007. (Web archive)
  3. ^ Swofford, Mark. "problems with Wade-Giles". www.pinyin.info. Retrieved 26 February 2016.
  4. ^ "Some Mandarin Mispronunciations_Learn Chinese Hujiang". cn.hujiang.com. Retrieved 26 February 2016.