The Cardinals are one of Major League Baseball's oldest teams, having played in the National League in St. Louis since they were formed as the Brown Stockings in 1882. The Royals joined the majors in 1969 as one of the American League's first expansion teams. Because there was no interleague play until 1997, the only opportunity for the Cardinals and Royals to meet was in the World Series, which occurred in 1985. The two teams had gone through several periods of prolonged success (and several notable droughts) leading up to the 1985 World Series. The Cardinals fell on hard times in the 1970s after winning the 1964 World Series and the 1967 World Series and appearing in the 1968 World Series. The Kansas City Royals had become one of the best teams in baseball by the late 1970s, reaching the American League playoffs six times in nine years between 1976 and 1984, including the 1980 World Series. After several down years, the Cardinals emerged as a pennant contender in the early 1980s, winning the 1982 World Series.
The first official meeting between the Cardinals and Royals was in the 1985 World Series. This marked only the second time in baseball history that two teams from the state of Missouri met in the World Series. The first time was in 1944, when the Cardinals played the St. Louis Browns. That series also marked the last time to date that a World Series was held entirely in one ballpark, as the Cardinals and Browns shared Sportsman's Park at the time.
Notably, the Cardinals manager in 1985, Whitey Herzog, had formerly been the Royals manager and had led Kansas City to the franchise's first three playoff appearances – in 1976, 1977, and 1978 – before being fired after the Royals missed the playoffs in 1979.
The Royals lost the first two games of the World Series at home and were on the verge of elimination, down 1-0 in the bottom of the 9th in game 6, when umpire Don Denkinger made a controversial call, ruling runner Jorge Orta safe at first. Orta was later thrown out at third on a botched sacrifice attempt and did not score. The Royals would go on to win the game 2-1 in the bottom of the 9th following the put-out of Orta (the only out recorded in the inning). The Royals then went on to win game 7 the following day 11-0 for their first and thus far only World Series title. The Royals became the first team ever to win the World Series after dropping games 1 and 2 at home. The Royals would not return to the MLB postseason for 29 years, until their wildcard entrance in 2014.
Interleague play in 1997 allowed the I-70 Series to be revived in non-exhibition games. The first few seasons of the series were rather even, with the Cardinals holding a slight advantage with a 14–13 record through the 2003 season. Through the 2014 season, the Cardinals held the series advantage 46–34, with each team having a winning record at the other's home field (Cardinals 30-16 at Kauffman Stadium, Royals 18-16 at Busch Stadiums). The Royals took two out of three from the Cardinals in 2010 behind victories from starting pitchers Zack Greinke and Bruce Chen. In 2011, the Cardinals won four of the six matchups, three of them in the eighth inning or later. The last four games in the series were one-run games. In 2012, the Cardinals again won four of the six games, on the strength of a three-game sweep in Kansas City over June 22–24. The Royals won the season series for the first time since 2010 in 2014, taking 3 out of 4. They won the first two games in St. Louis 6-0 and 8-7 respectively, and after losing Game 3 5-2 in 11 in Kansas City, won the final game 3-2 after being down 2-0 late.