Jump to content

Controversial literature (Library of Congress Subject Headings)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by BigFrank100 (talk | contribs) at 02:02, 14 February 2007 (→‎R). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Controversial Literature is any written work that has been challenged or banned. Through out history religious, historical, scientific text and stories have caused controversy in a society due to a conflict of morals beliefs and politics. They have been challenged by politicians and special interest groups with an agenda. In the United States woks of literature are not banned by the Federal government because they are protected by the 1st Amendment. However they are removed from schools and libraries because by State government because of peruse form interest groups. Countries in Europe don’t necessarily ban books because of free speech laws with the exception with nations with anti-Nazi laws in such as Germany.

Why Controversial

There are reasons why certain works of literature have became controversial. It has gain the controversy when it was published first or many years later because of poltical changes in the time. Their are several reasons why a work of liture becomes controversial.

  • Racsim - Recently elements or content of racism has become common among controversial literature. This type of controversy comes up when a work of literature potrays a certain ethnic group in a derogatory war or for the use of ethnic sluers. Recently certain works that were writin to critize the Jim Crow Laws have came under attack for using the word "Nigger".
  • Religous - Religon has been a key factor in controversial literature. Works that have contain blasphemy have creat controversy among religous groups. Many works have been banned or dystoyed for passgaes that cotain elements of blasphemy towards God or a symbolic figure in a faith. Other works have contained content that is offinsive to a certain faith.
  • Sexual Conten - Works containing sexual content have always caused controversy, espcially in the United States. Many cultures are not open about sexuality and is never allowed to be talked about open. In certain works the sexual content involves minors which many see offensive. Sometimes the sexual content may be a character sexuality and it causes an uproar towards anti-homosexuals.
  • Inaccuracy - Historical and biographical works cause controversy. This happens when certain elements are edited or fabricated.
  • Politics - Works of liture about poltics have caused controversy when the work has critisied a goverment or politician. Other times it could be critising a poltical action or goverment law.

List of Controversial literature

This is a list of literature that has been challenged or banned. It inculeds novels, short stories, historical, and religous text.

#

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
The 9/11 Commission Report National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States Senate Report Criticized for alleged inaccuracies and for having important details edited out due to the pressure from lobbyists. [1]
The 95 Theses Martin Luther Document Pope Leo X condemned it for heresy against the Catholic Church and had Martin Luther excommunicated.

A

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
The Adventures of Captain Underpants Dav Pilkey Novella Banned in schools because of the use of toilet humor.
The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn Mark Twain Novel Challenged and banned in schools for the use of the word "Nigger" [2]
The Adventures of Tom Sawyer Mark Twain Novel Challenged and banned in schools for the use of the word "Nigger"
The Age of Reason Thomas Paine Philosophical Treaties Banned in UK for blasphemy in the 18th Century
All Quiet on the Western Front Erich Maria Remarque Anti-war Novel Banned in Nazi Germany for demoralizing and insulting the Wehrmacht.
America (The Book) The Daily Show with Jon Stewart Humor Removed from Walmart due to images of nudity. [3]
An Inconvenient Truth Al Gore Environmental Treaties Opponents of the global warming criticized it as propaganda. Schools have limited the use of the book in classrooms.
The Anarchist Cookbook William Powell Guide Book Banned outside of the US because security reasons. Sale of the book is prohibited to any one under 21.
Animal Farm George Orwell Novella Publication delayed in UK because of anti-Stalin theme. Confiscated in Germany by Allied troops. Banned in Malaysia for religious reasons.
Are You There, God? It's Me, Margaret Judy Blume Novel Banned in schools for its sexual and religious themes.
The Autobiography of Malcolm X Alex Haley Biography Challenged by the Nation of Islam for historical inaccuracy.

B

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
Bible Religious Text Has been edited over time. Banned in Communist countries that support Atheism. Banned in Saudi Arabia for not being of the Muslim faith. [4]
Biko Donald Woods Biography Banned in South Africa for its criticism of the apartheid system and white government.
Black Beauty Anna Sewell Novel Was banned in South Africa because of the use of the word 'black' in the title.[5]
The Blue Lotus Hergé Graphic Novel Banned in the PRC for its pro Kuomintang view and support. Criticized by Japanese diplomats to the Belgian Foreign Ministry for its portrayal of Japan's involvement in China.
The Book of One Thousand and One Nights Collection Banned in Muslim countries for its depiction of strong women.
Brave New World Aldous Huxley Novel Challenged in schools because of its negative views.
Bridge to Terabithia Katherine Paterson Novel Challenged in schools because of death involved in the theme and the use of the word Lord outside of a prayer.

C

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
The Call of Cthulhu H.P. Lovecraft Short Story Elements of racism towards Southeast Asians. [6]
The Call of the Wild Jack London Novella Banned in schools for its dark theme and violent imagery.
Carrie Stephen King Novel Banned in schools for depicting the death of teens and fundamentalism.
Catch-22 Joseph Heller Novel Challenged in schools for its sexual content and violent imagery.
The Catcher in the Rye J. D. Salinger Novel Reasons for banning have been the use of offensive language, premarital sex, alcohol abuse, and prostitution. [7]
Civil Disobedience Henry David Thoreau Essay Removed from libraries during McCarthyism. Banned in South Africa
A Clockwork Orange Anthony Burgess Novel Challenged for its depiction of rape and violence by a pre-teen.
The Communist Manifesto Karl Marx Economic Treaties Banned in anti-Communist countries and the US during the Red Scare. Challenged in libraries for political reasons.
The Confessions of Nat Turner William Styron Historical Novel Challenged by the NAACP for its sexual imagery of Nat Turner.

D

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
Daddy's Roommate Michael Willhoite Novella Banned in schools. Challenged by fundamentalists for its positive view on homosexuality.
The Diary of a Young Girl Anne Frank Diary Challenged by Holocaust deniers of its historical accuracy.
Doctor Zhivago Boris Pasternak Novel Banned by the USSR for its criticism of the Bolsheviks Party.

F

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
Fahrenheit 451 Ray Bradbury Sci-Fi Novel Banned in schools for political reason and depiction of violence.
The Fellowship of the Ring J. R. R. Tolkien Fantasy Novel Challenged by fundamentalists for its use of wizards and paganry. Also challenged by Atheists for its religious theme.
Fight Club Chuck Palahniuk Novel Challenged for its depiction of violence and presenting underground street fighting in a positive light.
For Whom the Bell Tolls Ernest Hemingway Novel Banned in Spain during Francisco rule for its pro-Republican views.

G

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
The Giver Lois Lowry Novel Challenged over certain ethical issues.
Go Ask Alice Anonymous Novel Banned in schools for its drug content and authenticity.
Gone with the Wind Margaret Mitchell Novel Challenged by feminist groups and the NAACP for depicting the racism and rape in a positive view.
The Grapes of Wrath John Steinbeck Novel Banned in schools located in southern California because of political preasure from Associated Farmers.
The Great Gatsby F. Scott Fitzgerald Novel Challenged because of its adultrist theme.

H

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
Hamlet William Shakespeare Play Challenged by fundamentalist for its content of incest and blasphemy.
The Handmaid's Tale Margaret Atwood Novel Challenged for its feminist theme and sexual content.
Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone J. K. Rowling Novel Challenged by fundamentalists for paganry and alleged support for witchcraft.
Heart of Darkness Joseph Conrad Novella Critisied by Chinua Achebe for its racist bias and negative depiction of Africans. [8]
Heather Has Two Mommies Lesléa Newman Novel Banned for its LGBT theme.
Hells Angels Hunter S. Thompson Investigative Journalism Criticized by feminist for its depiction of gang rape in a positive view.
Helter Skelter Vincent Bugliosi True Crime The factual accuracy has been questioned by Manson's followers and admirers.
How to Talk Dirty and Influence People Lenny Bruce Autobiography Challenged by fundamentalists for its encouragement to use profanity and obscurity.

I

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings Maya Angelou Autobiography Banned in schools for graphic explicit descriptions of rape and sexual content.
If I Did It O.J. Simpson Canceled Canceled due to public outcry and pressure from the Goldman family. [9]

J

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
James and the Giant Peach Roald Dahl Children's Novel Challenged for its content of child abuse.
The Jungle Upton Sinclair Novel Edited before its release. Challenged by the meat industry.

K

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
The King Never Smiles Paul M. Handley Biography Banned in Thailand for its criticism of King Bhumibol Adulyadej
The Kingdom of God Is Within You Leo Tolstoy Religious Treaties Banned in Czarist Russia for its Christian anarchist content.

L

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
Lady Chatterley's Lover D. H. Lawrence Novel Temporarily banned in the United States and UK until it was overturned for violation of obscurity laws. Banned in Australia.
The Last Battle C. S. Lewis Fantasy Novel Challenged by Atheists for its religious theme. Challenged by Feminists for the actions of one character.
A Light in the Attic Shel Silverstein Poetry Collection Banned from libraries for encouraging children to misbehave.
The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe C. S. Lewis Fantasy Novel Criticized by Atheist for its religious theme.
Live and Let Die Ian Fleming Spy Novel Criticized for its racist depiction of African-Americans and Afro-Caribbean. Edited to remove the word "Nigger".
Lolita Vladimir Nabokov Novel Challenged for its content of pedophilia.

M

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
The Malay Dilemma Mahathir bin Mohamad Political ideology Banned in Malaysia for its criticism of UMNO and the May 13th Incident.
The Manchurian Candidate Richard Condon Political Novel Banned in Communist states for political reason. Condemned by the American Legion.
Mein Kampf Adolf Hitler Political ideology Possession and sale is illegal in Germany and Austria due to anti-Nazi laws.

N

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
Nickel and Dimed Barbara Ehrenreich Investigative Journalism Critizised for its lack of realism related to people paid minimum wage.
Nineteen Eighty-Four George Orwell Sci-Fi Novel Banned in the USSR for political reasons. Accused of anti-semitism. Challenged in Florida for pro communist and sexual theme.

O

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
Of Mice and Men John Steinbeck Novella Challenged and banned in schools for the use of the word "Nigger". Accused of sexism and mistreatment of people with Down syndrome.
One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn Novel Banned in the USSR for political reasons. Author was sent into exile.
The Origin of Species Charles Darwin Biology Text Banned in schools and challenged by fundamentalist for questioning Creation. See: Scopes Monkey Trial
The Outsiders S. E. Hinton Novel Challenged in schools for depiction of gangs and violence.

P

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
Palestine Peace Not Apartheid Jimmy Carter Political Science Criticized by pro-Israeli groups claiming the book is anti-semetic and for the use of the word "Apartheid"
The Pigman Paul Zindel Novel Challenged in schools for sexual content and depicting teens drinking and smoking.
Private Parts Howard Stern Autobiography Criticized by fundamentalists and feminists for sexual content, use of profanity, and sexism.

Q

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
Quotations from Chairman Mao Zedong Mao Zedong Collection Banned in South Vietnam and anti-Communist nations in Asia.
Qur'an Religious Text Challenged by fundamentalist and anti-Islamic activists claiming that it promotes violence. Banned in Communist states that promote Atheism.

R

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
The Return of the King J. R. R. Tolkien Fantasy Challenged by fundamentalists for its use of wizards and paganry. Also challenged by Atheists for its religious theme.
Rights of Man Thomas Paine Political Treatise Banned in the UK for supporting the French Revolution. Banned in Czarist Russia after the Decembrist revolt.
Roots: The Saga of an American Family Historical Fiction Alex Haley Accusations of plagiarism and historical inaccuracy.

S

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
The Satanic Verses Salman Rushdie Magic Realism Banned in India and Muslim nations for blasphemy. Book stores refuse to sell it out of fear. Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini issued a fatwa calling for the death of Rushdie.
Scary Stories Alvin Schwartz Collection of Horror Stories and Urban Myths Libraries had it removed for its gruesome images.
Silent Spring Rachel Carson Environmentalism Publication was delayed and has been challenged by the chemical industries.
Sixth Column Robert A. Heinlein Sci-Fi Novel Criticized for its racist depiction of Asians [10]
Slaughterhouse-Five Kurt Vonnegut Sci-Fi Novel Challenged and banned in schools for sexual content and profanity.
Starship Troopers Robert A. Heinlein Sci-Fi Novel Accused by critics of having a pro-militant and pro-facist theme along with elements of racism.
Stupid White Men Michael Moore Political Criticism Publication delayed because of political reasons. Challenged by conservatives for its alleged liberal bias. [11]

T

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
Talmud Religous Text Criticized by Reform Judaism. [12] Banned in Nazi Germany and the USSR.
That Was Then, This Is Now S. E. Hinton Novel Challenged for its drug content.
Tiger Eyes Judy Blume Novel Banned in schools for its theme of death.
Tintin in America Hergé Graphic Novel Criticized for racial depiction of Native Americans and African Americans. [13]
Tintin in the Congo Hergé Graphic Novel Criticized for its pro-imperialist and racist depiction of Africans. [14]
The Turner Diaries William Luther Pierce Novel Book stores and libraries refuse to distribute it because of its racist theme. Banned in Germany for its Nazi ideolgy theme and Pierce leadership in the American Nazi Party. [15] Blamed for a number of hate crimes inspired by the novel including the Oklahoma City bombing. [16]
The Two Towers J. R. R. Tolkien Novel Challenged by fundamentalists for its use of wizards and paganry. Also challenged by Atheists for its religious theme.

U

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
Ulysses James Joyce Novel Challenged and temproy banned in the US for its sexual content. Ban overturn in United States v. One Book Called Ulysses [17].
Uncle Tom's Cabin Harriet Beecher Stowe Novel Banned in the Southern States and Czarist Russia. Challenged by the NAACP for its racist portrayal of African Americans and the use of the word "Nigger".
Understanding Islam through Hadis Ram Swarup Philosophical Treaties Banned in India under 153A and 295A of the Indian Penal Code.
United States-Vietnam Relations, 1945-1967 United States Department of Defense Report Classified at the time it was published. Attempts were made to suspend publication. [18] See: New York Times Co. v. United States.

W

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
We Yevgeny Zamyatin Novel Banned in the USSR for political reason.
We All Fall Down Robert Cormier Novel Challenged and banned in schools for sexual and violent content.
The Wealth of Nations Adam Smith Economic Treaties Banned in the UK and France for criticizing Mercantilism. Banned in communist nations for its capitalist content.
Where's Waldo? Martin Handford Picture Book Removed from libraries and banned from schools for breif nudity
Winds of Change Reza Pahlavi Political Science Banned in Iran for political reasons.

Z

Title Author Type of Literature Reason
Zweites Buch Adolf Hitler Transcript Possession and sale is illegal in Germany and Austria because of anti-Nazi laws.


References