Electric smoking system
This article contains paid contributions.
An electrically-heated smoking system, also known as a heated tobacco product or heat-not-burn tobacco product (HNB), uses an electric heating element to char tobacco, at a lower temperature than a conventional cigarette. The result is a smoke that contains nicotine, other chemicals, and particulates.:Table 1 These products may match some of the behavioral aspects of smoking. Some tobacco companies claim these products are less harmful to consumers than other types of cigarettes, but there is no reliable evidence to support these claims.
Some of these products take loose-leaf tobacco in a heated chamber; others require product-specific cigarettes. Products heating cigarettes using an external heat source first came to market in 1988, however they were not a commercial success. These products are currently being re-introduced by large tobacco companies.
There is not enough research to evaluate the level of harm of these products. A 2016 Cochrane review found that it was unclear whether using these products instead of conventional cigarettes would "substantially alter the risk of harm". Also in 2016, the WHO noted that some scientists believe these products to be as harmful as traditional cigarettes, and stated that no convincing evidence had been presented for industry claims of lowered risk and health benefits. Independent research is not available to support these claims; they are based on industry-funded research. Independent 2018 reanalysis of data from industry research has found deficiencies and omissions in the evidence used to support the industry's claims.
Action on Smoking and Health stated in 2016 that due to "the tobacco industry's long record of deceit" regarding the health risks involving smoking, it is important to conduct independent studies into the health effects of these products. Carlos Jiménez, director of research on smoking at the Spanish Society of Pneumonology and Thoracic Surgery, criticized the industry data available in 2017.
The effects of second-hand exposure are unknown.
Addiction and quitting
Such products are believed to be just as addictive as conventional cigarettes. Nearly half of people using these products had never used conventional cigarettes, according to a small survey done in Italy. This has caused concern that the products might cause nicotine addiction rather than reduce harm to those who already smoke.
There is not enough evidence to know if HnB products help with quitting smoking. In one manufacturer-led study, smokers using Hnb products mostly did not stop using regular cigarettes; they mostly used both, although the HnB products were supplied to them for free.
There is no information on the effects of smoking HnB devices during pregnancy, as of 2018. However, they are nicotine-containing products. It is unsafe to use any product containing nicotine during pregnancy and breastfeeding, as nicotine harms the fetus. Nicotine use during pregnancy increases the child's risk of respiratory problems, neurobehavioral defects, obesity, type 2 diabetes, hypertension, and infertility.
Nature and function
Nicotine is released from tobacco heated above 140°C. Heating tobacco causes pyrolysis; organic material breaks down, releasing most of the substances found in regular cigarette smoke. At higher temperatures, the carbon increasingly combines with atmospheric oxygen, releasing carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide. It is possible to heat to a temperature hot enough to cause pyrolysis, but not hot enough to oxidize and release the carbon. This ancient process is called charring, and the carbon-rich residue is called char.
HnB products vary, but can heat to these charring temperatures. The composition of the smoke is changed by lower temperatures: levels of some substances fall, while levels of others rise. While the nicotine is the main addictive component in tobacco, some pyrolysis products of tobacco are thought to reinforce addiction (such as acetaldehyde, norharman, and harman), some of which have been found in lower levels in the smoke of HnB products.
These products are marketed as "heat-not-burn" and "smoke-free". However, independent researchers who tested a common "heat-not-burn" device explicitly disagreed with the claim that they are smokeless, arguing that the emitted aerosol is smoke, as it contains pyrolysis products. Independent researchers studying the aerosols produced by heat-not-burn products commonly call those aerosols "smoke". Independent research has also disputed the claim that the products are "heat-not-burn" devices.
The first commercial heat-not-burn product was the R.J. Reynolds Premier, a smokeless cigarette launched in 1988 and described as difficult to use. Many smokers disliked the taste. It was shaped like a traditional cigarette, and when heated the smoldered charcoal moved past processed tobacco containing more than 50 percent glycerin to create a smoke including aerosolized nicotine. It did require some combustion. In 1989, after spending $325 million, R.J. Reynolds pulled it from the market months later after organisations recommended to the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to restrict it or classify it as a drug.
The Premier product concept went on to be further developed and re-launched as Eclipse in the mid-1990s, and was available in limited distribution as of 2015. Reynolds American stated that the Revo was a "repositioning" of its Eclipse. R.J. Reynolds' Revo was withdrawn in 2015.
Philip Morris International (PMI) launched a cigarette in 1998 that was placed into an electronic heating device as Accord. The battery-powered product was the size of a pager. The product was marketed as "low-smoke". Ads claiming reduced risk were drafted, but never released; an attempt was made to get the Surgeon General of the United States to endorse it without requiring long-term studies on its health effects. Few people started using the Accord, and almost all users also continued to use regular cigarettes. The Accord was discontinued in 2006, eight years after it came on the market.
In 2007 PMI launched the Heatbar, which was nearly identical to the Accord. The Heatbar was around the size of a mobile phone and was said to heat specifically designed cigarettes rather than burning them. The only benefit was to lower second-hand smoke, which lead to Heatbar being discontinued. Heatbar did not obtain any significant user reception. Accord and Heatbar are predecessors of PMI's current heat-not-burn tobacco products.
The ubiquitousness of electronic cigarettes and growing dissatisfaction with not providing a throat-hit may present an opportunity for heat-not-burn tobacco products. These products are currently being introduced by large tobacco companies. PMI anticipates a future without traditional cigarettes, but campaigners and industry analysts call into question the probability of traditional cigarettes being dissolved, by either e-cigarettes or other products like iQOS.
The products are designed to be similar their conventional counterparts. A tobacco stick along with a heating element will provide the user a choice across the different heat-not-burn tobacco products available.[clarification needed] Another type of heat-not-burn tobacco product is the loose-leaf tobacco vaporizer that entails putting loose-leaf tobacco into a chamber, which is electrically heated using an element.
The 3T from Vapor Tobacco Manufacturing was launched in December 2014. The product employs a patented, aqueous system whereby desired components are extracted into water. The liquid is mixed with glycerin and aerosolized producing a smoke without combustion by an electronic heating system. Their organic liquids are made from organic tobacco, organic glycerin, and water.
In 2016 British American Tobacco (BAT) launched a heat-not-burn product called glo in Japan. glo is battery-powered. It uses a heating element with a tobacco stick. In May 2017 they released i-glo in Canada. The glo iFuse debuted in Romania by BAT in 2015. It uses a cartridge with a tobacco stick and a flavored nicotine liquid. Bonnie Herzog, a senior analyst at Wells Fargo Securities stated that the proposed acquisition of R. J. Reynolds by BAT in 2016 would let them catch up in the technology competition.
The introduction of IQOS was announced on 26 June 2014. Although it is marketed as a novel product, it is very similar to the "Accord" product released by the same company in 1998; however, the IQOS cigarettes have more nicotine, more tar, and less tobacco. They are heated to a lower temperature, and the kit costs about US$40 more in 2018 dollars. The product is marketed by Philip Morris International (PMI) under the Marlboro and Parliament brands.
Initially launched in 2014 in Nagoya, Japan and Milan, Italy, IQOS is being gradually rolled out to other countries. By end of 2016 it was available in over 20 countries, with expansion plans into several more in 2017 as manufacturing capacity increases. PMI has projected that when 30 billions units are sold, iQOS would increase profits by $700 million. To date, the company claims that total investments made in the development and assessment of these products have exceeded $3 billion. Phillip Morris spent €500 million on iQOS in 2016 alone.
iQOS consists of a charger around the size of a mobile phone and a holder that looks like a pen. The disposable tobacco stick, which looks somewhat like a short cigarette, has been dipped in propylene glycol, is inserted into the holder which then heats it to temperatures up to 350 °C. The smoke released contains nicotine and other chemicals. The amount of nicotine provided may be a little strong for light cigarette smokers. Users have reported less smell and odour on clothing. The smoke generated by iQOS contains substances from pyrolysis and thermogenic degradation that are identical to the constituents found in traditional tobacco cigarette smoke. A 2017 review found "little research on what substances are released after the device heats the tobacco-based paste. The physical effects on users are also not yet known."
One independent study of the iQOS criticized Phillip Morris, saying "Dancing around the definition of smoke to avoid indoor-smoking bans is unethical" and called for more independent research, saying "Smokers and non-smokers need accurate information about toxic compounds released in IQOS smoke. This information should come from sources independent of the tobacco industry". After the study was published, the heads of the three Swiss universities where the authors worked received letters from Phillip Morris, accusing the authors of faulty methodology, and subsequently the researchers were not willing to talk to a journalist. JAMA Internal Medicine, which published the study, described the letters as unusual and smacking of intimidation. Phillip Morris also published an online academic counter-argument.
In December 2016, PMI submitted a multi-million page application to the US FDA for iQOS to be authorized as a modified risk tobacco product. The FDA reviewed Phillip Morris's data, some independent studies, including the May 2017 Swiss paper about toxic compounds in iQOS smoke mentioned above, a December 2017 amendment to the application by Phillip Morris on the same topic, and the FDA's own laboratory testing data.
In January 2018, the FDA advisory panel ruled that Phillip Morris had not shown that their product cut health risks; the panel also "expressed concerns about the lack of data" on risk relative to cigarettes. The Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids criticized the product, saying that it looks like the e-cigarettes which children use the most. IQOS is marketed in stores and packaging which resemble those of high-end smartphones, a strategy expected to appeal to youth by associating it with their interests in new technology.
PMI intends to convert its customers in Japan to using heat-not-burn products. iQOS is sold as an alternative to cigarettes. PMI states that they understand that its iQOS product will be as addictive as tobacco smoking. iQOS is sold with a warning that the best option is to avoid tobacco use altogether.
Korea Tobacco & Ginseng Corporation
PAX Labs, formerly known as Ploom, sells PAX vaporizers. In 2010 they launched Ploom, a butane-powered product used for the heating tobacco or botanical products. Later models replaced butane heating with an electric system. After its initial partnership with Japan Tobacco was abandoned, the company became known as Pax Labs. The Pax 2 uses loose-leaf tobacco. The surface of the Pax 2 remains cool, while the oven heats to temperatures up to 455 °F. It has four temperature options.
In January 2016 Japan Tobacco (JT) released Ploom TECH. JT's Ploom has been withdrawn from the US. The Ploom brand, however, remained with JT and the product itself has been replaced with a different product called Ploom Tech, in which an aerosol passes through a capsule of granulated tobacco leaves. Sales are being expanded throughout Japan in 2017. They intend to spend $500 million to increase their heated tobacco manufacturing capacity by late 2018.
V2 originally released their vaporizer line named V2 Pro in July 2014. The initial product was named Series 3. Series 3 comes with 3 cartridges including a loose-leaf cartridge, which heats the material by conduction. It comes with a battery and USB changer, among other things. Pro Series 3X also by V2 can be used with dry material. It has three different air flow options that can be adjusted with a slight turn of the mouthpiece. Series 7 comes with a loose-leaf cartridge, among other things. Series 7 lets the user change the temperature by using a single button.
In the United States, these products fall under the jurisdiction of the Food and Drug Administration. As of 2016[update], 19 countries have permitted the sale of iQOS. Advertisement for the iQOS, but not iQOS' tobacco stick, is not regulated under the European Union Tobacco Products Directive. Heat-not-burn tobacco products are not restricted for sale in Israel by the Ministry of Health. Ploom and iQOS are governed by the Tobacco Industries Act regulations as tobacco products in Japan. The Liberal Democratic Party will deliberate over increasing the tax rate for heat-not-burn tobacco products in April 2018. iQOS's refill sticks are not legal for sale in New Zealand by the Ministry of Health. Emerging tobacco products are banned in Singapore by the Ministry of Health. Electronic tobacco products using dry material are regulated as e-cigarettes in South Korea by the Ministry of Health and Welfare. Korea regulates e-cigarettes differently than traditional cigarettes for tax reasons. As a result, iQOS are taxed at a decreased rate, compared to the 75% incurred on normal cigarettes.
Action on Smoking and Health stated in 2016 that "unless and until independent evidence shows that IQOS and similar products are substantially less harmful than smoking then these products should be regulated in the same way as other tobacco products." Tobacco control activist Stanton Glantz stated that the US FDA should halt new tobacco products until tobacco companies stop selling traditional cigarettes. "There is concern that heat-not-burn tobacco will skirt local ordinances that prevent smoking in public areas," Mitchell H. Katz, director of the Los Angeles County Health Agency, wrote in 2017.
- "Heated tobacco products (HTPs) information sheet". World Health Organization. 2018.
In order to produce the nicotine-infused vapor, HTPs heat tobacco up to 350°C (lower than 600°C as in conventional cigarettes) using battery-powered heating-systems... Currently, there is also insufficient evidence on the potential effects of second-hand emissions produced by HTPs.
- Davis, Barbara; Williams, Monique; Talbot, Prue (2018). "IQOS: Evidence of pyrolysis and release of a toxicant from plastic". Tobacco Control: tobaccocontrol-2017–054104. doi:10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2017-054104 (inactive 2018-10-31). PMID 29535257. Lay summary – BMJ.
Charring due to pyrolysis (a form of organic matter thermochemical decomposition) was observed in the tobacco plug after use. When the manufacturer’s cleaning instructions were followed, both charring of the tobacco plug and melting of the polymer-film filter increased. Headspace analysis of the polymer-film filter revealed the release of formaldehyde cyanohydrin at 90°C, which is well below the maximum temperature reached during normal usage.
- Caputi, TL (24 August 2016). "Heat-not-burn tobacco products are about to reach their boiling point". Tobacco Control. 26 (5): 609–610. doi:10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2016-053264. PMID 27558827.
- St.Helen, Gideon; Jacob Iii, Peyton; Nardone, Natalie; Benowitz, Neal L. (2018). "IQOS: Examination of Philip Morris International's claim of reduced exposure". Tobacco Control. 27 (Suppl 1): s30–s36. doi:10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2018-054321. PMID 30158205.
- Bentley, Guy (15 March 2017). "Heat-Not-Burn Tobacco: The Next Wave Of A Harm-Reduction Revolution". Forbes.
- "Further development of the partial guidelines for implementation of Articles 9 and 10 of the WHO FCTC" (PDF). World Health Organization. 12 July 2016. pp. 5–6.
As previously discussed, products that heat rather than burn are claimed to be less harmful than traditional cigarettes, although these claims of risk reduction are based on industry-funded studies. Independent studies should be conducted to investigate these claims. Convincing evidence has yet to be provided for the claims of risk reduction and health benefits of products that heat rather than burn tobacco . Some scientists consider these heated tobacco products to be just as harmful as conventional cigarettes.
- Lopez, Alexa A.; Hiler, Marzena; Maloney, Sarah; Eissenberg, Thomas; Breland, Alison B. (2016). "Expanding clinical laboratory tobacco product evaluation methods to loose-leaf tobacco vaporizers". Drug and Alcohol Dependence. 169: 33–40. doi:10.1016/j.drugalcdep.2016.10.005. PMC 5140724. PMID 27768968.
- Neo Chai Chin (2 March 2017). "Heated tobacco products just as bad as cigarettes: Amy Khor". Today (Singapore newspaper). Mediacorp.
- "Alternatieve tabaksproducten: harm reduction?" (PDF). Netherlands National Institute for Public Health and the Environment. 2016. pp. 1–66.
- Lindson-Hawley, Nicola; Hartmann-Boyce, Jamie; Fanshawe, Thomas R.; Begh, Rachna; Farley, Amanda; Lancaster, Tim (2016). "Interventions to reduce harm from continued tobacco use". Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 10: CD005231. doi:10.1002/14651858.CD005231.pub3. PMID 27734465.
- McKelvey, Karma; Popova, Lucy; Kim, Minji; Lempert, Lauren Kass; Chaffee, Benjamin W.; Vijayaraghavan, Maya; Ling, Pamela; Halpern-Felsher, Bonnie (2018). "IQOS labelling will mislead consumers". Tobacco Control. 27 (Suppl 1): s48–s54. doi:10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2018-054333. PMID 30158208.
- Moazed, Farzad; Chun, Lauren; Matthay, Michael A.; Calfee, Carolyn S.; Gotts, Jeffrey (2018). "Assessment of industry data on pulmonary and immunosuppressive effects of IQOS". Tobacco Control. 27 (Suppl 1): s20–s25. doi:10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2018-054296. PMID 30158203.
- "ASH reaction to new Philip Morris IQOS 'heat not burn' product". Action on Smoking and Health. 30 November 2016.
- Conquero, Belén V. (20 January 2017). "¿Es posible conseguir un tabaco menos nocivo?" (in Spanish). Larazon.es.
- Pieper, Elke; Mallock, Nadja; Henkler-Stephani, Frank; Luch, Andreas (2018). "Tabakerhitzer als neues Produkt der Tabakindustrie: Gesundheitliche Risiken". Bundesgesundheitsblatt - Gesundheitsforschung - Gesundheitsschutz. 61 (11): 1422–1428. doi:10.1007/s00103-018-2823-y. PMID 30284624.
- Liu, Xiaoqiu; Lugo, Alessandra; Spizzichino, Lorenzo; Tabuchi, Takahiro; Gorini, Giuseppe; Gallus, Silvano (2018). "Heat-Not-Burn Tobacco Products Are Getting Hot in Italy". Journal of Epidemiology. 28 (5): 274–275. doi:10.2188/jea.JE20180040. PMC 5911679. PMID 29657258.
These trends may be of concern, since we have previously shown that nearly half of Italian IQOS users (45%) and over half of the people interested in IQOS (51%) are never smokers. Therefore, such a product may represent, at least in Italy, a gateway for nicotine addiction among never smokers rather than a harm reduction substitution for current smokers
- Liu, Xiaoqiu; Lugo, Alessandra; Spizzichino, Lorenzo; Tabuchi, Takahiro; Pacifici, Roberta; Gallus, Silvano (26 January 2018). "Heat-not-burn tobacco products: concerns from the Italian experience". Tobacco Control: tobaccocontrol-2017–054054. doi:10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2017-054054.
- Li, Gerard; Saad, Sonia; Oliver, Brian G.; Chen, Hui (1 August 2018). "Heat or Burn? Impacts of Intrauterine Tobacco Smoke and E-Cigarette Vapor Exposure on the Offspring's Health Outcome". Toxics. 6 (3): 43. doi:10.3390/toxics6030043. ISSN 2305-6304. PMC 6160993. PMID 30071638.
There is insufficient evidence on the efficacy of heat-not-burn tobacco on smoking cessation. Neither is there information on the potential impact of maternal inhalation of heat-not-burn tobacco smoke during pregnancy on fetal outcomes, all of which require urgent attention.
- Bruin, Jennifer E.; Gerstein, Hertzel C.; Holloway, Alison C. (2010-04-02). "Long-Term Consequences of Fetal and Neonatal Nicotine Exposure: A Critical Review". Toxicological Sciences. 116 (2): 364–374. doi:10.1093/toxsci/kfq103. ISSN 1096-6080. PMC 2905398. PMID 20363831.
Overall, the evidence provided in this review overwhelmingly indicates that nicotine should no longer be considered the ‘‘safe’’ component of cigarette smoke. In fact, many of the adverse postnatal health outcomes associated with maternal smoking during pregnancy may be attributable, at least in part, to nicotine alone.
- England, Lucinda J.; Kim, Shin Y.; Tomar, Scott L.; Ray, Cecily S.; Gupta, Prakash C.; Eissenberg, Thomas; Cnattingius, Sven; Bernert, John T.; Tita, Alan Thevenet N.; Winn, Deborah M.; Djordjevic, Mirjana V.; Lambe, Mats; Stamilio, David; Chipato, Tsungai; Tolosa, Jorge E. (31 December 2010). "Non-cigarette tobacco use among women and adverse pregnancy outcomes". Acta Obstetricia et Gynecologica Scandinavica. 89 (4): 454–464. doi:10.3109/00016341003605719. ISSN 1600-0412. PMC 5881107. PMID 20225987.
The use of any products containing nicotine likely will have adverse effects of fetal neurological development.
- Schraufnagel DE, Blasi F, Drummond MB, Lam DC, Latif E, Rosen MJ, Sansores R, Van Zyl-Smit R (September 2014). "Electronic cigarettes. A position statement of the forum of international respiratory societies" (PDF). American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine. 190 (6): 611–8. doi:10.1164/rccm.201407-1198PP. PMID 25006874.
- Forster, Mark; Liu, Chuan; Duke, Martin (16 April 2015). "An experimental method to study emissions from heated tobacco between 100-200°C". Chemistry Central Journal. 9: 20. doi:10.1186/s13065-015-0096-1. PMC 4418098. PMID 25941536.
- St.Helen, Gideon; Jacob Iii, Peyton; Nardone, Natalie; Benowitz, Neal L (2018). "IQOS: Examination of Philip Morris International's claim of reduced exposure". Tobacco Control. 27 (Suppl 1): tobaccocontrol–2018–054321. doi:10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2018-054321. PMID 30158205.
PMI’s MRTP application fails to address the important question of whether the aerosol generation process for IQOS produces toxic substances not found in the smoke of combustible cigarettes, which could have been answered through non-targeted chemical analysis. Combustible tobacco cigarettes reach about 900°C during a puff and smoulder at about 400°C between puffs. The burning process, substances emitted and their levels vary at different temperatures. Distillation, the process during which nicotine and aromas are transferred from tobacco to smoke, occurs below 300°C; pyrolysis occurs at about 300°C–700°C, entails the decomposition of biopolymers, proteins, and other organic materials and generates the majority of substances emitted in smoke; and combustion occurs above 750°C and results in the generation of carbon dioxide, CO and water. HeatSticks are heated to a maximum of 350°C, a temperature sufficient to enable pyrolytic decomposition of some organic materials. Formation of toxic volatile organic compounds, including formaldehyde, acetaldehyde and acrolein, via dehydration and oxidation of the humectants, propylene glycol and glycerin, have been reported in e-cigarette aerosols at similar temperatures as IQOS.[39–42] In addition, flavouring chemicals in e-cigarettes undergo thermal degradation and contribute significantly to levels of toxic aldehydes emitted in e-cigarette aerosol. Since the constituents of HeatSticks may be different from that of combustible cigarettes, including flavourants and additives, it is plausible that the IQOS aerosol may contain substances not present in tobacco smoke.
- Sharma, Ramesh K.; Wooten, Jan B.; Baliga, Vicki L.; Martoglio-Smith, Pamela A.; Hajaligol, Mohammad R. (13 February 2002). "Characterization of char from the pyrolysis of tobacco". Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry. 50 (4): 771–783. ISSN 0021-8561. PMID 11829644.
- Bruijnzeel, Adrie W. (2012). "Tobacco addiction and the dysregulation of brain stress systems". Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews. 36 (5): 1418–1441. doi:10.1016/j.neubiorev.2012.02.015. PMC 3340450. PMID 22405889.
- Hoffman, A. C.; Evans, S. E. (2013). "Abuse Potential of Non-Nicotine Tobacco Smoke Components: Acetaldehyde, Nornicotine, Cotinine, and Anabasine". Nicotine & Tobacco Research. 15 (3): 622–632. doi:10.1093/ntr/nts192. PMID 22990226.
- Farsalinos, Konstantinos E.; Yannovits, Nikoletta; Sarri, Theoni; Voudris, Vassilis; Poulas, Konstantinos; Leischow, Scott J. (2018). "Carbonyl emissions from a novel heated tobacco product (IQOS): Comparison with an e-cigarette and a tobacco cigarette". Addiction. 113 (11): 2099–2106. doi:10.1111/add.14365. PMID 29920842.
- Staal, Yvonne CM; van de Nobelen, Suzanne; Havermans, Anne; Talhout, Reinskje (28 May 2018). "New Tobacco and Tobacco-Related Products: Early Detection of Product Development, Marketing Strategies, and Consumer Interest". JMIR Public Health and Surveillance. 4 (2): 60–6. doi:10.2196/publichealth.7359. ISSN 2369-2960. PMC 5996176. PMID 5996176.
- "Tobacco company charged over importing prohibited product". NZ Herald. 2017-05-18. ISSN 1170-0777. Retrieved 2018-06-06.
- Wan, William (2017-08-11). "Big Tobacco's new cigarette is sleek, smokeless — but is it any better for you?". Washington Post. ISSN 0190-8286. Retrieved 2018-05-27.
- "FDA Panel Gives Qualified Support To Claims For 'Safer' Smoking Device". NPR.org. Retrieved 2018-06-04.
- Auer, Reto; Cornuz, Jacques; Berthet, Aurélie (2017). "Perplexing Conclusions Concerning Heat-Not-Burn Tobacco Cigarettes—Reply". JAMA Internal Medicine. 177 (11): 1699–1700. doi:10.1001/jamainternmed.2017.5861. PMID 29114801.
- Mallock, Nadja; Böss, Lisa; Burk, Robert; Danziger, Martin; Welsch, Tanja; Hahn, Harald; Trieu, Hai-Linh; Hahn, Jürgen; Pieper, Elke; Henkler-Stephani, Frank; Hutzler, Christoph; Luch, Andreas (2018). "Levels of selected analytes in the emissions of "heat not burn" tobacco products that are relevant to assess human health risks". Archives of Toxicology. 92 (6): 2145–2149. doi:10.1007/s00204-018-2215-y. ISSN 0340-5761. PMC 6002459. PMID 29730817., and sources therein
- Bialous, Stella A.; Glantz, Stanton A. (2018). "Heated tobacco products: Another tobacco industry global strategy to slow progress in tobacco control". Tobacco Control. 27 (Suppl 1): s111–s117. doi:10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2018-054340. PMC 6202178. PMID 30209207.
- Mcgill, Douglas C (19 November 1988). "'Smokeless' Cigarette's Hapless Start". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331.
- Haig, Matt (2003). Brand Failures: The Truth about the 100 Biggest Branding Mistakes of All Time. Kogan Page Publishers. ISBN 978-0-7494-4433-4.
- Parker-Pope, Tara (10 February 2001). ""Safer" Cigarettes: A History". PBS.
- Hilts, Philip J. (27 November 1994). "Little Smoke, Little Tar, but Full Dose of Nicotine". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331.
- O'Connell, Dominic (30 November 2016). "Philip Morris could stop making conventional cigarettes". BBC News.
- Anderson, S J; Ling, P M (2008). ""And they told two friends...and so on": RJ Reynolds' viral marketing of Eclipse and its potential to mislead the public". Tobacco Control. 17 (4): 222–229. doi:10.1136/tc.2007.024273. ISSN 0964-4563. PMC 2845302. PMID 18332064.
- Haig, Matt (2005). Brand Failures: The Truth about the 100 Biggest Branding Mistakes of All Time. Kogan Page Publishers. pp. 51–. ISBN 978-0-7494-4433-4.
- Fisher, Daniel (29 May 2014). "Is This The Cigarette Of The Future, And Will The FDA Let You Buy It?". Forbes.
- "New heat-not-burn brand from RAI". Tobacco Journal International. 5 January 2015.
- Craver, Richard (28 July 2015). "Reynolds ends Revo test market in Wisconsin". Winston-Salem Journal.
- Harlay, Jérôme (9 November 2016). "What you need to know about Heat-not-Burn (HNB) cigarettes". VapingPost.
- Rossel, Stefanie (1 June 2016). "All eyes on iQOS". Tobacco Reporter.
- Pollack, Juddan (27 October 1997). "Philip Morris tries smokeless Accord: tobacco marketer, cautious about brand, doing 'consumer research'". Ad Age.
- Elias, Jesse; Dutra, Lauren M.; St. Helen, Gideon; Ling, Pamela M. (2018). "Revolution or redux? Assessing IQOS through a precursor product". Tobacco Control. 27 (Suppl 1): s102–s110. doi:10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2018-054327. PMID 30305324.
- "Anti-smoking body attacks smokeless cigarette device". Tobacco Journal International. 11 December 2007.
- Houston, Cameron (27 June 2007). "Revealed: tobacco giant's secret new weapon in the age of smoking bans". The Age.
- Cooper, Ted (1 February 2014). "Why Philip Morris International's New Heated Products Will Do Better Than Its Last Attempt". The Motley Fool.
- Lubin, Gus (25 June 2012). "Philip Morris Is Releasing A Bunch Of Crazy New Cigarettes". Business Insider.
- MacGuill, Shane (23 January 2014). "Has Philip Morris Learned from Heat-not-Burn Tobacco's Past?". Euromonitor International.
- Davies, Rob; Monaghan, Angela (30 November 2016). "Philip Morris's vision of cigarette-free future met with scepticism". The Guardian.
- Tuinstra, Taco (16 December 2014). "Certified organic e-liquids being launched by VTM". Tobacco Reporter.
- O'Connell, Thomas (9 July 2013). "Method for preparing tobacco extract for electronic smoking devices".
- "BAT finds strong Japan demand for its Glo smokeless tobacco device". The Japan Times. Reuters. 22 March 2017.
- Caplinger, Dan (31 May 2017). "Here's Why the Worst Might Be Yet to Come for Philip Morris International". The Motley Fool.
- "Innovation Drives BAT's $47 Billion Bid -- WSJ". ADVFN. 24 October 2016.
- Felberbaum, Michael (26 June 2014). "Philip Morris Int'l to Sell Marlboro HeatSticks". Salon (website). Associated Press.
- Caplinger, Dan (23 November 2015). "5 Things Every Philip Morris Investor Should Know". The Motley Fool.
- Nathan, Ralph (12 October 2016). "Why Philip Morris's iQOS Sales in Japan Are Promising". marketrealist.com. Market Realist.
- "Philip Morris looks beyond cigarettes with alternative products". Reuters. 30 November 2016.
- Mulier, Thomas; Thesing, Gabi (26 June 2014). "Philip Morris Sees $700 Million Boost From iQOS Smoking Device". Bloomberg News.
- "Philip Morris's Cigarette Alternative Could Hit U.S. in 2017". Bloomberg News. 5 October 2016.
- Hendlin, Yogi Hale; Elias, Jesse; Ling, Pamela M. (2017). "The Pharmaceuticalization of the Tobacco Industry". Annals of Internal Medicine. 167 (4): 278–280. doi:10.7326/M17-0759. PMC 5568794. PMID 28715843.
- Lee Hyo-sik (17 May 2017). "Philip Morris unveils smoke-free cigarette in Korea". The Korea Times.
- Auer, Reto; Concha-Lozano, Nicolas; Jacot-Sadowski, Isabelle; Cornuz, Jacques; Berthet, Aurélie (2017). "Heat-Not-Burn Tobacco Cigarettes". JAMA Internal Medicine. 177 (7): 1050–1052. doi:10.1001/jamainternmed.2017.1419. PMC 5543320. PMID 28531246.
- Tai, Mariko (31 August 2015). "Philip Morris rolls out iQOS smokeless smokes". Nikkei Asian Review.
- Drope, Jeffrey; Cahn, Zachary; Kennedy, Rosemary; Liber, Alex C.; Stoklosa, Michal; Henson, Rosemarie; Douglas, Clifford E.; Drope, Jacqui (2017). "Key issues surrounding the health impacts of electronic nicotine delivery systems (ENDS) and other sources of nicotine". Ca: A Cancer Journal for Clinicians. 67 (6): 449–471. doi:10.3322/caac.21413. PMID 28961314.
- Trefis Team (30 December 2016). "FDA Approval For iQOS To Be A Game Changer For Altria". Forbes.
- January 24–25, 2018 Meeting of the Tobacco Product s Scientific Advisory Committee (TPSAC), Modified Risk Tobacco Product Application s (MRTPAs) MR0000059 -MR00000 61 Philip Morris Products S.A. (PDF), retrieved 2018-06-01
- "FDA panel rejects 'heat-not-burn' cigarette safety claims". The Mercury News. 2018-01-25. Retrieved 2018-08-16.
- Chambers, Sam. "Big Tobacco spending billions to develop products that could move industry beyond cigarettes — but regulators are skeptical". chicagotribune.com. Archived from the original on 2018-06-21. Retrieved 2018-05-28.
- "FOOD AND DRUG ADMINISTRATION, Center for Tobacco Products (CTP), Tobacco Products Scientific Advisory Committee (TPSAC), meeting minutes, January 24-25, 2018" (PDF). FDA. Retrieved 2018-06-01.
- McKelvey, Karma; Popova, Lucy; Kim, Minji; Chaffee, Benjamin W.; Vijayaraghavan, Maya; Ling, Pamela; Halpern-Felsher, Bonnie (2018). "Heated tobacco products likely appeal to adolescents and young adults". Tobacco Control. 27 (Suppl 1): s41–s47. doi:10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2018-054596. PMID 30352843.
- Yui, Monami (28 August 2016). "Big Tobacco Wants to Turn Japan's Smokers Into Vapers". Bloomberg News.
- "Smoke signals". The Economist. 23 April 2016.
- Mulier, Thomas; Chambers, Sam; Liefgreen, Liefgreen (24 March 2016). "Marlboro Kicks Some Ash". Bloomberg News.
- "The iSmoke OneHitter, iSmoke "3-in-1" and iSmoke Oven join portfolio". Convenience Store News. 2017.
- "Consumer-Centric Vaping". Convenience Store Decisions. Harbor Communications. 4 March 2015.
- "KT&G to release heat-not-burn tobacco amid iQOS growing popularity". The Korea Herald. 8 June 2017.
- Yakowicz, Will (10 June 2015). "This Silicon Valley Company Just Raised $47 Million to Smoke Cigarette Makers". Inc.
- Dawson, Freddie (31 July 2015). "Pax Labs Looking At International Expansion". Forbes.
- Biggs, John (17 June 2012). "Smoke Up: An Interview With The Creator Of The Ultracool Pax Vaporizer". TechCrunch.
- Lavrinc, Damon (1 July 2013). "Review: Ploom Model Two". Wired.
- Lawler, Ryan (11 March 2015). "The Pax 2 Improves Upon One Of The Best Vaporizers On The Market". TechCrunch.
- Stenovec, Tim (12 March 2016). "How two guys from Stanford built the 'iPhone of vaporizers'". Business Insider.
- Rossel, Stefanie (1 July 2016). "Blending nature and technology". Tobacco Reporter.
- Tuinstra, Taco (26 January 2016). "JT announces launch of next-generation Ploom". Tobacco Reporter.
- "JT to expand Ploom TECH sales". Tobacco Reporter. 2016-10-10.
- Taiga Uranaka; Himani Sarkar (29 May 2017). "Japan Tobacco plans to quadruple smokeless tobacco output capacity by 2018: CEO". Channel NewsAsia. Reuters.
- Monkeyshines (1 April 2015). "High Buy: V2 Pro Series 7". High Times.
- Kahn, Steven (11 March 2016). "V2 Pro Series 3 Vaporizer Review – Updated for 2017". Bloomberg News.
- Silver, Curtis (19 May 2017). "V2 Pro Series 3X Is The Highly Versatile Vape You've Been Looking For". Forbes.
- Craft, Scott (16 June 2015). "V2 Pro Series 7 Review: Premium Vapor Quality From A Surprisingly Affordable Vaporizer". iDigitalTimes.
- Siegel-Itzkovich, Judy (2 March 2017). "Orgs slam Litzman for allowing sale of iQOS heated, smokeless cigarettes". The Jerusalem Post.
- Tabuchi, Takahiro; Kiyohara, Kosuke; Hoshino, Takahiro; Bekki, Kanae; Inaba, Yohei; Kunugita, Naoki (2016). "Awareness and use of electronic cigarettes and heat-not-burn tobacco products in Japan". Addiction. 111 (4): 706–713. doi:10.1111/add.13231. PMID 26566956.
- "Tax hike on heat-not-burn tobacco products under consideration as LDP begins review of tax reforms". The Japan Times. 8 September 2017.
- Caruana, Diane (3 February 2017). "iQos heatsticks declared illegal in NZ". VapingPost.
- "Singapore Enhances Tobacco Control Measures". Ministry of Health (Singapore). 28 July 2016.
- Park Jae-hyuk (26 May 2017). "IQOS available in Seoul Saturday". The Korea Times.
- Trefis Team (13 September 2017). "Why Is Korea Easier To Conquer For iQOS Than Europe?". NASDAQ.
- Fisher, Daniel (16 June 2014). "Philip Morris International Bets Big On The Future Of Smoking". Forbes.
- Rapaport, Lisa (26 May 2017). "'Heat-not-burn' cigarettes still release cancer-causing chemicals". Reuters.