Isaac b. Eliashib

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

R. Isaac b. Eliashib (or Isaac b. Eliashab,[1] or Yizhak b. Eliashib;[2] Hebrew: יצחק בן אלישיב) was a fourth generation Amora sage of the Land of Israel, who lived at the time of Abaye and Rava. It is possible that he belonged to a family of Bar Eliashib - a rich and respected family. Only mentioned a few times in the Talmud.

He was known to be a man who works salvations. In that conjunction, it is storied in the Talmud,[3] that one of his pupils Rabbi Mana II complained to him, that the rich members of the family of his father-in-law are annoying him, and so R. Isaac exclaimed: "May they become poor!", and indeed they became poor, and their great wealth taken from them, and they became miserably poor begging for alms. However, from that moment on, they started to upset him by pressing him to help them financially, something that ailed him as before, and when he reported this to his teacher, R. Isaac replied: "If so, let them become rich as before!", and so it was.

A similar story is told of the same Amora Mana II, who complained before his teacher R. Isaac that he has an ugly wife, and that he can no longer tolerate her, and R. Isaac made a blessing that she will become beautiful. However, when the master's blessing materialized and his wife turned to be pretty, she began to dress up and domineering over him, and was no longer subservient to him. When R. Isaac heard this, he responded: "let Hannah revert to her former ugliness!", and so it was.

When two other students of R. Isaac heard of these two stories, they asked him to pray that they may become very wise. R. Isaac replied: "That power that I have possessed, that all I ask is accepted before God, was taken from me, and my prayers are no longer accepted much"


  1. ^ Bavli Taanit,
  2. ^ Yerushalmi Berakhot,
  3. ^ Babylonian Talmud, Tractate Ta'anit, 23b