Seven Second Summits
The Seven Second Summits are the second-highest mountains of each of the seven continents. All of these mountain peaks are separate peaks rather than a sub-peak of the continents' high point. The Seven Second Summits are considered by many mountaineers and geographers as a much harder challenge than the traditional Seven Summits.[2]
Austrian mountaineer Christian Stangl became the first person to successfully climb the Second Seven Summits.[3] Stangl climbed all possible candidates for the Second Seven Summits quest (K2, Mt. Logan, Ojos del Salado, Batian, Mt. Tyree, Dych Tau, Dufourspitze, Sumantri, Ngga Pulu, Puncak Trikora, Puncak Mandala and Mt. Townsend) to exclude any errors and to satisfy all geographers. He finished the quest on 15 January 2013 and was certified by Guinness World Records on 17 September 2013. Later, he also completed the Challenge for the Seven Third Summits.[4][5][6]
In 2012 the Italian mountaineer Hans Kammerlander claimed to be the first person to complete the Seven Second Summits, but doubts were raised about his ascent of Mount Logan. Kammerlander also climbed Puncak Trikora, which is now believed to be slightly lower than Puncak Mandala.[7]
Seven Second Summits definitions
The definition of what constitutes a continent is a matter of some dispute among mountaineers seeking to complete this challenge. The main ridge of the Greater Caucasus range is generally considered to form the boundary between Europe and Asia. In that case, Mount Elbrus, (5,642 m (18,510 ft)) situated some 10 km north of the continental divide, is the highest mountain in Europe. Excluding the Caucasus Mountains, Mont Blanc (4,808 m (15,774 ft)) would be Europe's highest mountain.
The Australian continent is defined as comprising the mainland of Australia and proximate islands on the same continental shelf, including Tasmania and New Guinea. In the convention of the seven continents, one of the continents is the region of Australasia, which includes, for example, the mountainous islands of New Zealand. For both the geological and conventional continent, New Guinea's Carstensz Pyramid (4,884 m (16,024 ft)) is the highest summit. When considering a continent as a continuous landmass surrounded by oceans, mainland Australia would be its own continent, with Mount Kosciuszko (2,228 m (7,310 ft)) as its highest summit.
The Bass and Messner lists
The Seven Second Summits list follows the Seven Summits list created by Richard Bass,[8] who chose the highest mountain of mainland Australia, Mount Kosciuszko (2,228 m), to represent the Australian continent's highest summit. Reinhold Messner proposed another list (the Messner or Carstensz list), replacing Mount Kosciuszko with Western New Guinea's Carstensz Pyramid, which is part of Indonesia (4,884 m). Following the Bass list, Mount Townsend is the second-highest summit (2,209 m) in Australia. According to the Messner list, Puncak Mandala (4,760 m) on New Guinea is the second highest of the Australian continent.[1][9] Heights of mountain peaks in West Papua are poorly established, and Puncak Trikora has been listed as the second-highest summit on the island, but SRTM data do support a higher elevation for Mandala.
Both lists count Mount Elbrus as the highest peak in Europe. This makes Dykh-Tau (5,205 m), located in Russia, the second-highest summit in Europe. Those who consider Mont Blanc to be the highest mountain in Europe would consider Monte Rosa (4,634 m), located in Switzerland, to be the second-highest summit.
| Seven Second Summits (sorted by elevation) | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Peak | Bass list | Messner list | Elevation | Prominence | Continent | Range | Country |
| K2 | ✔ | ✔ | 8,611 m (28,251 ft) | 4,017 m (13,179 ft) | Asia | Karakoram | Pakistan / China |
| Ojos del Salado | ✔ | ✔ | 6,893 m (22,615 ft) | 3,688 m (12,100 ft) | South America | Andes | Argentina / Chile |
| Mount Logan | ✔ | ✔ | 5,959 m (19,551 ft) | 5,250 m (17,224 ft) | North America | Saint Elias | Canada |
| Dykh-Tau | ✔ | ✔ | 5,205 m (17,077 ft) | 2,002 m (6,568 ft) | Europe | Caucasus | Russia |
| Mount Kenya | ✔ | ✔ | 5,199 m (17,057 ft) | 3,825 m (12,549 ft) | Africa | – | Kenya |
| Mount Tyree | ✔ | ✔ | 4,852 m (15,919 ft) | 1,152 m (3,780 ft) | Antarctica | Sentinel | – |
| Puncak Mandala | ✔ | 4,760 m (15,617 ft) | 2,760 m (9,055 ft) | Australia (continent) | Jayawijaya | Indonesia | |
| Mount Townsend | ✔ | 2,209 m (7,247 ft) | 189 m (620 ft) | Australia | Snowies | Australia | |
Difficulty versus Seven Summits
The presentation of the Second Seven Summits concept and its relative difficulty was first published in January 1997 by Rock and Ice Magazine (#77) in the article The Second Seven Summits written by mountaineer and writer David D. Keaton. Later that year, the author Jon Krakauer in his book Into Thin Air echoed those sentiments by writing that it would be a bigger challenge to climb the second-highest peak of each continent instead of the highest.[10] In the climbing community, mountaineers such as Rob Hall had previously discussed the idea.
In Asia, K2 (8,611 m (28,251 ft)) demands greater technical climbing skills than Everest (8,848 m (29,029 ft)), while altitude-related factors such as the thinness of the atmosphere, high winds, and low temperatures remain much the same.
In Africa, the summit of Mount Kenya (5,199 m (17,057 ft)) is a rock climb, while Mount Kilimanjaro (5,895 m (19,341 ft)) can be ascended without any technical difficulty.
In North America, some sources[who?] consider Mount Logan a more difficult climb than Denali, although the climbing and outdoor recreation website Summitpost considers Logan no more difficult than Denali because it is neither technical nor steep.[11] Mountaineer Mark Horrell, in a 2012 post on his blog, considered Mount Logan to be no more difficult technically than Denali, but much more difficult to approach. Denali's base camp, at 2,200 m (7,200 ft) elevation, is regularly served by air, while climbers without the means to charter a plane face must tow their supplies by sledge for over 100 km (62 mi) to reach Mount Logan.[2]
In South America, Ojos del Salado involves a short scramble while Aconcagua is just a walk.[12] Horrell acknowledged that Ojos del Salado was more technically difficult, but considered Aconcagua a greater challenge because of physical demands. Aconcagua's base camp, at 4,500 m (14,800 ft), is accessible by mule, but from that point on, climbers must carry all of their supplies to as many as three higher camps before the final ascent. By contrast, Ojos del Salado is accessible by four-wheel-drive vehicles up to 5,200 m (17,100 ft); from that point on, climbers need only carry supplies to a mountain hut at 5,800 m (19,000 ft) before making their final push to the summit.[2]
In Europe, Dykh-Tau is a considerably harder climb than Mount Elbrus.[13] According to Horrell, the main route on Elbrus is "long and physically tiring, but it’s not technically difficult," while Dykh-Tau's "easiest is graded at Russian alpine 4B, which involves steep rock sections and 55 degree snow and ice slopes."[2]
In Australasia, the continent's Second Summit on the Bass list, Mount Townsend, is more challenging than Mount Kosciuszko, but still just a walk-up.[14] The normal route on the highest peak of the Messner list, Carstensz Pyramid, is technically difficult (UIAA grade V+). Puncak Mandala, however, is extremely challenging with respect to the approach route, which is arguably the more significant problem in climbing the New Guinea peaks. There have been perhaps only two successful approaches (and climbs) reported.[15]
In Antarctica, Mount Vinson presents little difficulty beyond normal challenges of Antarctica (the guiding company Adventure Peaks rates the ascent at PD/AD on the Alpine scale), but Mount Tyree requires technical climbing, and it has been climbed by a total of fifteen people since its discovery.
See also
- Seven Summits
- Seven Third Summits
- Volcanic Seven Summits
- Three Poles Challenge
- Explorers Grand Slam, also known as The Adventurers Grand Slam
- Eight-thousander
References
- ^ a b See for example the lists at peaklist, peakbagger.com, and gunungbagging.com
- ^ a b c d Horrell, Mark (February 8, 2012). "Which is harder, the Second Seven Summits or the first one?". Footsteps on the Mountain. Retrieved January 28, 2017.
- ^ Jurgalski, Eberhard. "Kammerlander/Stangl: "Seven Second" and "Third" Facts". www.8000ers.com.
- ^ British Mountaineering Council: Christian Stangl completes the Triple Seven Summits (english)
- ^ skyrunning.at: Three records for Austrian Alpinist Christian Stangl Archived 2013-12-31 at the Wayback Machine (english)
- ^ climbing.com: Stangl Completes Triple Seven Summits by Dougald MacDonald, Climbing (USA) 8/28/13
- ^ "Kammerlander/Stangl: "Seven Second" and "Third" Facts". 8000ers.com. Retrieved 12 January 2018.
- ^ Bass, Dick; Frank Wells; Rick Ridgeway (1986). Seven Summits. Warner Books. ISBN 0-446-51312-1.
- ^ Several other summits of Mount Carstensz besides Carstensz Pyramid, like Ngga Pulu (4,862 m) and Carstensz East (4,820 or 4,840 m) are higher than both Mandala and Trikora, but because of their low prominence (200–300 m) and isolation (2.2–2.6 km) these are usually not regarded as separate mountains.
- ^ Krakauer, Jon (1997). Into Thin Air. Villard. ISBN 0-385-49208-1.
- ^ "Logan Massif". Summitpost.org. Retrieved 16 April 2017.
- ^ John Biggar: The Andes – A Guide for Climbers, ISBN 0-9536087-2-7
- ^ Bender: Classic Climbs of the Caucasus
- ^ Geehi Bushwalking Club: Snowy Mountains Walks ISBN 0-9599651-4-9
- ^ Puncak Mandala at the gunung bagging website