Eco-terrorism is defined by the Federal Bureau of Investigation as "the use or threatened use of violence of a criminal nature against people or property by an environmentally oriented, subnational group for environmental-political reasons, or aimed at an audience beyond the target, often of a symbolic nature." The FBI credited eco-terrorists with 200 million dollars in property damage between 2003 and 2008, and a majority of states within the USA have introduced laws aimed at eco-terrorism.
Application of the term
Eco-terrorism is a form of radical environmentalism that arose out of the same school of thought that brought about deep ecology, ecofeminism, social ecology, and bioregionalism. Eco-terrorism is a controversial term.
Eco-terrorism is closely related to civil disobedience and sabotage in the name of the environment causes, and there is a debate on where to draw the lines between the three. Some of those who are labeled as eco-terrorists do not perpetrate violence against humans, but only against property. This has led to a debate that touches on whether or not to classify these actions as "terrorist". In the United States, the FBI’s definition includes acts of violence against property, which makes most acts of sabotage fall in the realm of domestic terrorism.
Sabotage involves destroying, or threatening to destroy, property, and in this case is also known as monkeywrenching or ecotage. Many acts of sabotage involve the damage of equipment and unmanned facilities using arson.
Another type of ecoterrorism also exists in which people use violence against people or property for environmental reasons. With this type of ecoterrorism people fight to preserve their environment, not just for the sake of keeping it pristine, but also to preserve their livelihood, hereby allowing them to continue living their day-to-day life. Examples of such "ecoterrorists" include some ethnic minorities as the Waorani.
Philosophy of eco-terrorism
The thought behind eco-terrorism rises from the radical environmentalism movement, which gained popularity during the 1960s. Ideas that arose from radical environmentalism are "based on the belief that capitalism, patriarchal society, and the Judeo-Christian tradition were responsible for the despoliation of nature". Radical environmentalism is also characterized by the belief that human society is responsible for the depletion of the environment and, if current society is left unchecked, will lead to the ultimate complete degradation of the environment.
Like deep ecologists, eco-terrorists subscribe to the idea of biocentrism, which is described as "a belief that human beings are just an ordinary member of the biological community" and that all living things should have rights and deserve protection under the law. Some eco-terrorists are motivated by other aspects of deep ecology, like the goal to return the environment to its "natural", i.e., pre-industrial, state.
Despite these generalizations, it should be noted that eco-terrorism encompasses a broad array of organizations, goals, and philosophies.
Examples of tactics
There are a wide variety of tactics that have been used by eco-terrorists and groups associated with eco-terrorism. Examples include:
- Tree spiking is a common tactic that was first used by members of Earth First! in 1984. Tree spiking involves hammering a small spike into the trunk of a tree that may be logged with the intention of damaging the chainsaw or mill blades and may seriously injure the logger. Only one case of serious injury has been widely reported.
- Arson is a tactic most associated with recent activity in the Earth Liberation Front (ELF). The ELF has been attributed with arsons of sites such as housing developments, SUV dealerships, and chain stores.
Individuals accused of eco-terrorism
- Wiebo Ludwig - accused several times for sabotaging oil and gas wells in Alberta, Canada
- Tre Arrow
- James Lee
- Jeff Luers
- Marie Mason
- David Lukas MacNeil – Convicted of conspiracy to commit what the FBI labeled an eco-terrorist plot.
- Daniel McGowan – Convicted of participation in an arson at a lumber company.
- Paul Watson – For his direct action against whale and seal hunters Watson was labeled a terrorist by Japanese and Canadian politicians as well as Greenpeace.
Groups accused of eco-terrorism
Stefan Leader characterizes these groups, namely ELF, with having "leaderless resistance" which he describes as "a technique by which terrorist groups can carry out violent acts while reducing the risk of infiltration by law enforcement elements. The basic principal [sic] of leaderless resistance is that there is no centralized authority or chain-of-command." Essentially this consists of independent cells which operate autonomously, sharing goals, but having no central leaders or formal organizational structure. Those who wish to join are typically encouraged to start their own cell, rather than seek out other members and jeopardize their secrecy.
Organizations in the USA
Organizations that have been accused of eco-terrorism in the United States include the Animal Liberation Front (ALF), the Earth Liberation Front (ELF), Greenpeace, the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA), Earth First!, The Coalition to Save the Preserves, and the Hardesty Avengers. In 2010, the FBI was criticized in U.S. Justice Department reports for unjustified surveillance (and placement on the Terrorism Watchlist) between 2001 and 2006 of members of animal-rights groups such as Greenpeace and PETA.
In a 2002 testimony to the US Congress, an FBI official mentioned the actions of Sea Shepherd Conservation Society in the context of eco-terrorism. The Sea Shepherd Conservation Society intervenes against whaling, seal hunting, and fishing operations with direct action tactics. In 1986, the group caused nearly 1.8 million dollars' worth of damage to equipment used by whalers in Iceland. In 1992, they sabotaged two Japanese ships that were drift-net fishing for squid by cutting their nets and throwing stink bombs on board the boats. Inspired by Edward Abbey, Earth First! began in 1980. Although the group has been credited with becoming more mainstream, its use of tree spiking during campaigns has been associated with the origins of eco-terrorism. In 1990, Earth First! organizers Judi Bari and Darryl Cherney were injured when a motion-detecting pipe bomb detonated beneath Bari's driver seat. Authorities alleged that the bomb was being transported and accidentally detonated. The pair sued investigators, alleging false arrest, illegal search, slanderous statements and conspiracy. In 2002, a jury found that FBI agents and Oakland police officers violated constitutional rights to free speech and protection from unlawful searches of Earth First! organizers.
The Earth Liberation Front, founded in 1992, joined with the Animal Liberation Front, which had its beginnings in England in 1979. They have been connected primarily with arson but claim that they work to harm neither human nor animal. A recent example of arson that was attributed to the ELF was in March 2008 concerning the "torching of luxury homes in the swank Seattle suburb of Woodinville". A banner was left at the scene that claimed the housing development was not green as advertised, and was signed ELF. In September 2009 ELF claimed responsibility for the destruction of two radio towers in Seattle. The FBI in 2001 named the ELF as "one of the most active extremist elements in the United States", and a "terrorist threat." The Coalition to Save the Preserves was mentioned in FBI testimony as a group that was responsible for a series of arsons in Arizona. Using similar tactics to the ELF, they have caused more than $5 million in damages.
Media reports have tied Theodore Kaczynski, also known as the Unabomber, to environmental activists, and say that the 23 injuries and three deaths through letter-bombs were the acts of an independent Eco-terrorist. Among those making such accusations were ABC, The New York Times, Time magazine, and USA Today.
A number of "local" organizations have also been indicted under US Federal laws related to Eco-terrorism. These include, among others, the group "Stop Huntingdon Animal Cruelty." Another example is the Hardesty Avengers who spiked trees in the Hardesty Mountains in Willamette National Forest in 1984.
In 2008 the Federal Bureau of Investigation said eco-terrorists represented "one of the most serious domestic terrorism threats in the U.S. today" citing the sheer volume of their crimes (over 2,000 since 1979); the huge economic impact (losses of more than $110 million since 1979); the wide range of victims (from international corporations to lumber companies to animal testing facilities to genetic research firms); and their increasingly violent rhetoric and tactics (one recent communiqué sent to a California product testing company said: "You might be able to protect your buildings, but can you protect the homes of every employee?").
In the USA
Spiking trees became a federal offense in the United States when it was added to the Drug Act in 1988.
Under the Animal Enterprise Protection Act of 1992 it became a federal crime to "cause more than $10,000 in damage while engaged in "physical disruption to the functioning of an animal enterprise by intentionally stealing, damaging, or causing the loss of any property […] used by the animal enterprise." In 2006, this was updated and renamed the Animal Enterprise Terrorism Act by the 109th congress. The updated act included causing personal harm and the losses incurred on "secondary targets" as well as adding to the penalties for these crimes.
In 2003, a conservative legislative lobbying group, the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC), proposed the "Animal and Ecological Terrorism Act" which defined an "animal rights or ecological terrorist organization" as "two or more persons organized for the purpose of supporting any politically motivated activity intended to obstruct or deter any person from participating in an activity involving animals or an activity involving natural resources." The legislation was not enacted.
The FBI has stated that "since 2005…investigations have resulted in indictments against 30 individuals." In 2006, an FBI case labeled ‘Operation Backfire’ brought charges of domestic terrorism to eleven people associated with the ELF and ALF. "The indictment includes charges related to arson, conspiracy, use of destructive devices, and destruction of an energy facility."
However, the Bush Justice Department, including the FBI, was criticized in 2010 for improper investigations and prosecutions of left-leaning U.S. protest groups such as Greenpeace. The Washington Post reports that the "FBI improperly opened and extended investigations of some U.S. activist groups and put members of an environmental advocacy organization on a terrorist watch list, even though they were planning nonviolent civil disobedience, the Justice Department said Monday."
A report, filed by Inspector General Glenn A. Fine, found the FBI to be not guilty of the most serious charge—according to the Post, that "agents targeted domestic groups based on their exercise of First Amendment rights." The investigation was conducted in response to allegations that the FBI had targeted groups on such grounds during the Bush Administration. The Post has more:
"But the report cited what it called other "troubling" FBI practices in its monitoring of domestic groups in the years between the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks and 2006. In some cases, Fine said, agents began investigations of people affiliated with activist groups for "factually weak" reasons and "without adequate basis" and improperly kept information about activist groups in its files. Among the groups monitored were the Thomas Merton Center, a Pittsburgh peace group; People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals; and Greenpeace USA. Activists affiliated with Greenpeace were improperly put on a terrorist watch list, the report said.
In 2008, Eric McDavid was convicted of plotting to attack several targets including a fish hatchery, a dam, power stations, and cell phone towers. An undercover FBI agent exposed the plan. In addition to McDavid, two others were also convicted for aiding with the plot. On March 6, 2008 Eric McDavid was sentenced to 20 years in prison for "conspiracy to damage or destroy property by fire and explosive." United States Attorney McGregor Scott stated: "Today’s severe punishment of nearly 20 years in federal prison should serve as a cautionary tale to those who would conspire to commit life-threatening acts in the name of their extremist views."
- Earth Liberation Prisoners Support Network
- Ecoterrorism in fiction
- Environmental terrorism
- Green Scare
- Operation Backfire – FBI operation
- THERMCON – FBI operation against the "Evan Mecham Eco-Terrorist International Conspiracy" (EMETIC)
- Tree spiking
- Direct action
- Green anarchism
- Radical environmentalism
- Komp, Catherine. "Vilified as 'Terrorists,' Eco-activists Face New Offensive by Business* - The NewStandard". Newstandardnews.net. Retrieved 2010-10-02.
- "ecoterrorism - definition of ecoterrorism by the Free Online Dictionary, Thesaurus and Encyclopedia". Thefreedictionary.com. Retrieved 2010-10-02.
- "Ecoterrorism - Definition and More from the Free Merriam-Webster Dictionary". Merriam-webster.com. 2010-08-13. Retrieved 2010-10-02.
- James F. Jarboe (February 2002), "Testimony of James F. Jarboe, Domestic Terrorism Section Chief, Counterterrorism Division, FBI before the House Resources Committee, Subcommittee on Forests and Forest Health at February 12, 2002 "The Threat of Eco-Terrorism"", Congressional Testimony, Federal Bureau of Investigation, archived from the original on March 11, 2008, retrieved March 2008 Check date values in:
- Brent Baldwin (February 6, 2008), "Wade's War", Style Weekly, archived from the original on March 24, 2008
- Long, Douglas. Ecoterrorism (Library in a Book). New York: Facts on File, 2004. Print. Page 19-22, 5, 5, 6, 6, 7, 154, 154, 48, 49-55.
- Plows, A., Wall, D. & Doherty, B., (2004) ‘Covert Repertoires: ecotage in the UK’ in Social Movement Studies, vol. 3, iss. 2, pp. 199 – 219
- Woarani fighting against oil companies
- Dunlap. "Deep Ecology and Radical Environmentalism." American environmentalism the U.S. environmental movement, 1970-1990. Philadelphia: Taylor & Francis, 1992. Print.
- Eagan, S.P. 1996. 'From spikes to bombs: The rise of eco-terrorism'. Studies in Conflict & Terrorism 19: 1-18
- Leader, Stefan H.; Peter Probst (2003). "The Earth Liberation Front and Environmental Terrorism". Terrorism and Political Violence. 15 (4): 37–58. doi:10.1080/09546550390449872. Retrieved 14 December 2012.
- "Background Report: Discovery Communications Building Hostage-Taking" (PDF). Start. p. 1. Retrieved 4 September 2010.
- "Man Convicted Of Plotting To Blow Up Nimbus Dam". cbs13.com. 2007-09-27. Retrieved 2010-10-02.
- Grigoriadis, Vanessa (2007-06-18). "Daniel McGowan Becomes the First New Yorker Convicted of Ecoterrorism - New York Magazine". Nymag.com. Retrieved 2010-10-02.
- "Paul Watson: Sea Shepherd eco-warrior fighting to stop whaling and seal hunts". The Daily Telegraph. London. April 17, 2009. Retrieved July 15, 2009.
- "Hardline warrior in war to save the whale". The New Zealand Herald. The Observer. January 11, 2010. Retrieved November 2, 2011.
- "Williams assails anti-sealing activist Watson as 'terrorist'". Canada: CBC. April 14, 2008. Retrieved October 31, 2009.
- Leader & Probst, 2005
- Jarboe, James F. (February 12, 2002). "Testimony of James F. Arbores, Domestic Terrorism Section Chief, Counter terrorism Division, FBI Before the House Resources Committee, Subcommittee on Forests and Forest Health". Federal Bureau of Investigation. Archived from the original on August 27, 2010. Retrieved 2 October 2010.
- Wyant, Dan. "Spike Hunt is Battling a Deadline." The Register-Guard [Eugene, Oregon] 28 Oct. 1984. Print.
- Cloherty, Jack; Ryan, Jason (September 20, 2010). "FBI Spied on PETA, Greenpeace, anti-war activists". ABC News. Retrieved 11 October 2010.
- Savage, Charlie (January 21, 2006). "Justice Dept. accuses 11 of US eco-terrorism". The Boston Globe. Retrieved January 27, 2010.
- Zamora, Jim Hermon (June 12, 2002). "After 11 years, jury vindicates Earth First pair FBI, Oakland officers must pay $4.4 million for civil rights abuses". San Francisco Chronicle. Retrieved January 27, 2010.
- "FBI: Eco-Terrorism Remains No. 1 Domestic Terror Threat". FoxNews.com. 31 March 2008. Retrieved 14 December 2012.
- Yardley, William (4 March 2008). "Ecoterrorism Suspected in House Fires in Seattle Suburb". The New York Times. Retrieved 14 December 2012.
- "Activists topple towers, claim dangers of AM radio waves". CNN. 4 September 2009. Retrieved 1 August 2012.
- ""Exploding ABC's Uni bomber Hoax." Fairness and Accuracy in Media (FAIR), June 1996". FAIR. Retrieved 2012-03-21.
- Putting Intel to Work Against ELF and ALF Terrorists, Federal Bureau of Investigation, June 2008.
- Crime in the Name of Animal Rights : List of animal rights and eco-criminal acts since 1983, National Animal Interest Alliance, May 2014
- "18 USC Chapter 91 - Public Lands". US Code. Retrieved 14 December 2012.
- "S. 3880 (109th): Animal Enterprise Terrorism Act". Govtrack.us. Retrieved 14 December 2012.
- "Putting Intel to Work". The Federal Bureau of Investigation. 30 June 2008. Retrieved 14 December 2012.
- "ALEC - Animal and Ecological Terrorism Act". Web.archive.org. 2005-12-25. Archived from the original on October 24, 2007. Retrieved 2012-12-10.
- "Eco-Terror Indictments: 'Operation Backfire' Nets 11". The Federal Bureau of Investigation. 20 January 2006. Retrieved 14 December 2012.
- Markon, Jerry (21 September 2010). ""FBI probes were improper, Justice says" Washington Post, Monday, September 20, 2010". Washingtonpost.com. Retrieved 2012-03-21.
- O'Callaghan, John (8 May 2008). "U.S. man jailed for 20 years for eco-bombing plot". Reuters. Retrieved 14 December 2012.
- Scott, McGregor W. "Eco-terrorist given nearly twenty years in prison" (PDF). United States Department of Justice. Retrieved 2 October 2010.[dead link]
- Gagliano Giuseppe, Problemi e prospettive dell'ecologia radicale e dell'ecoterrorismo (Aracne Press, 2012)
- Govern, Kevin (2009). "Agroterrorism and Ecoterrorism: A Survey of Indo- American Approaches Under Law and Policy to Prevent and Defend Against the Potential Threats Ahead" (PDF). Fl. Coastal L. Rev. 10: 223–261.