The Apple Newton MessagePad 100
|Operating system||Newton OS|
|CPU||ARM 610 RISC|
|Weight||1.4 lb (0.64 kg) W/ Battery|
|Successor||iPad (1st generation)|
The MessagePad is the first series of personal digital assistant devices developed by Apple Computer for the Newton platform in 1993. Some electronic engineering and the manufacture of Apple's MessagePad devices was undertaken in Japan by the Sharp Corporation. The devices were based on the ARM 610 RISC processor and all featured handwriting recognition software and were developed and marketed by Apple. The devices ran the Newton OS.
- 1 Details
- 2 Market reception
- 3 Newton device models
- 4 Timeline of Newton models
- 5 Other uses
- 6 See also
- 7 References
- 8 Bibliography
- 9 External links
Screen and input
With the MessagePad 120 with Newton OS 2.0, the Newton Keyboard by Apple became available, which can also be used via the dongle on Newton devices with a Newton InterConnect port, most notably the Apple MessagePad 2000/2100 series, as well as the Apple eMate 300.
Newton devices featuring Newton OS 2.1 or higher can be used with the screen turned horizontally ("landscape") as well as vertically ("portrait"). A change of a setting rotates the contents of the display by 90, 180 or 270 degrees. Handwriting recognition still works properly with the display rotated, although display calibration is needed when rotation in any direction is used for the first time or when the Newton device is reset.
In initial versions (Newton OS 1.x) the handwriting recognition gave extremely mixed results for users and was sometimes inaccurate. The original handwriting recognition engine was called Calligrapher, and was licensed from a Russian company called Paragraph International. Calligrapher's design was quite sophisticated; it attempted to learn the user's natural handwriting, using a database of known words to make guesses as to what the user was writing, and could interpret writing anywhere on the screen, whether hand-printed, in cursive, or a mix of the two. By contrast, Palm Pilot's Graffiti had a less sophisticated design than Calligrapher, but was sometimes found to be more accurate and precise due to its reliance on a fixed, predefined stroke alphabet. The stroke alphabet used letter shapes which resembled standard handwriting, but which were modified to be both simple and very easy to differentiate. Palm Computing also released two versions of Graffiti for Newton devices. Ironically, the Newton version sometimes performed better and could also show strokes as they were being written as input was done on the display itself, rather than on a silkscreen area.
Later releases of the Newton operating system retained the original recognizer for compatibility, but added a hand-printed-text-only (not cursive) recognizer, called "Rosetta", which was developed by Apple, included in version 2.0 of the Newton operating system, and refined in Newton 2.1. Rosetta is generally considered a significant improvement and many reviewers, testers, and most users consider the Newton 2.1 handwriting recognition software better than any of the alternatives even 10 years after it was introduced. Recognition and computation of handwritten horizontal and vertical formulas such as "1 + 2 =" was also under development but never released. However, users wrote similar programs which could evaluate mathematical formulas using the Newton OS Intelligent Assistant, a unique part of every Newton device.
A vital feature of the Newton handwriting recognition system is the modeless error correction. That is, correction done in situ without using a separate window or widget, using a minimum of gestures. If a word is recognized improperly, the user could double-tap the word and a list of alternatives would pop up in a menu under the stylus. Most of the time, the correct word will be in the list. If not, a button at the bottom of the list allows the user to edit individual characters in that word. Other pen gestures could do such things as transpose letters (also in situ). The correction popup also allowed the user to revert to the original, un-recognized letter shapes - this would be useful in note-taking scenarios if there was insufficient time to make corrections immediately. To conserve memory and storage space, alternative recognition hypotheses would not be saved indefinitely. If the user returned to a note a week later, for example, they would only see the best match. Error correction in many current handwriting systems provides such functionality but adds more steps to the process, greatly increasing the interruption to a user's workflow that a given correction requires.
Text could also be entered by tapping with the stylus on a small on-screen pop-up QWERTY virtual keyboard, although more layouts were developed by users. Newton devices could also accept free-hand "Sketches", "Shapes", and "Ink Text", much like a desktop computer graphics tablet. With "Shapes", Newton could recognize that the user was attempting to draw a circle, a line, a polygon, etc., and it would clean them up into perfect vector representations (with modifiable control points and defined vertices) of what the user was attempting to draw. "Shapes" and "Sketches" could be scaled or deformed once drawn. "Ink text" captured the user's free-hand writing but allowed it to be treated somewhat like recognized text when manipulating for later editing purposes ("ink text" supported word wrap, could be formatted to be bold, italic, etc.). At any time a user could also direct their Newton device to recognize selected "ink text" and turn it into recognized text (deferred recognition). A Newton note (or the notes attached to each contact in Names and each Dates calendar or to-do event) could contain any mix of interleaved text, Ink Text, Shapes, and Sketches.
While the Newton offered handwriting recognition training and would clean up sketches into vector shapes, both were unreliable and required much rewriting and redrawing. The most reliable application of the Newton was collecting and organizing address and phone numbers. While handwritten messages could be stored, they could not be easily filed, sorted or searched. While the technology was a probable cause for the failure of the device (which otherwise met or exceeded expectations), the technology has been instrumental in producing the future generation of handwriting software that realizes the potential and promise that began in the development of Newton-Apple's Ink Handwriting Recognition.
The MessagePad 100 series of devices used Macintosh's proprietary serial ports—round Mini-DIN 8 connectors. The MessagePad 2000/2100 models (as well as the eMate 300) have a small, proprietary Newton InterConnect port. However, the development of the Newton hardware/software platform was canceled by Steve Jobs on February 27, 1998, so the InterConnect port, while itself very advanced, can only be used to connect a serial dongle. A prototype multi-purpose InterConnect device containing serial, audio in, audio out, and other ports was also discovered. In addition, all Newton devices have infrared connectivity, initially only the Sharp ASK protocol, but later also IrDA, though the Sharp ASK protocol was kept in for compatibility reasons. Unlike the Palm Pilot, all Newton devices are equipped with a standard PC Card expansion slot (two on the 2000/2100). This allows native modem and even Ethernet connectivity; Newton users have also written drivers for 802.11b wireless networking cards and ATA-type flash memory cards (including the popular CompactFlash format), as well as for Bluetooth cards. Newton can also dial a phone number through the built-in speaker of the Newton device by simply holding a telephone handset up to the speaker and transmitting the appropriate tones. Fax and printing support is also built in at the operating system level, although it requires peripherals such as parallel adapters, PCMCIA cards, or serial modems, the most notable of which is the lightweight Newton Fax Modem released by Apple in 1993. It is powered by 2 AA batteries, and can also be used with a power adapter. It provides data transfer at 2400 bit/s, and can also send and receive fax messages at 9600 and 4800 bit/s respectively.
The original Apple MessagePad and MessagePad 100 used four AAA batteries. They were eventually replaced by AA batteries with the release of the Apple MessagePad 110.
The use of 4 AA NiCd (MessagePad 110, 120 and 130) and 4x AA NiMH cells (MP2x00 series, eMate 300) give a runtime of up to 30 hours (MP2100 with two 20 MB Linear Flash memory PC Cards, no backlight usage) and up to 24 hours with backlight on. While adding more weight to the handheld Newton devices than AAA batteries or custom battery packs, the choice of an easily replaceable/rechargeable cell format gives the user a still unsurpassed runtime and flexibility of power supply. This, together with the flash memory used as internal storage starting with the Apple MessagePad 120 (if all cells lost their power, no data was lost due to the non-volatility of this storage), gave birth to the slogan "Newton never dies, it only gets new batteries".
Later efforts and improvements
The Apple MessagePad 2000/2100, with a vastly improved handwriting recognition system, 162 MHz StrongARM SA-110 RISC processor, Newton OS 2.1, and a better, clearer, backlit screen, attracted critical plaudits.
Apple and third parties marketed several "wallets" (cases) for the handheld Newton devices, which would hold them securely along with the owner's credit cards, driver's license, business cards, and cash. Most also protected the LCD screen.
Fourteen months after Sculley demoed it at the May 1992, Chicago CES, the MessagePad was first offered for sale on August 2, 1993, at the Boston Macworld Expo. The hottest item at the show, it cost $900. 50,000 MessagePads were sold in the device’s first three months on the market.
The original Apple MessagePad and MessagePad 100 were limited by the very short lifetime of their inadequate AAA batteries.
Critics also panned the handwriting recognition that was available in the debut models, which had been trumpeted in the Newton's marketing campaign. It was this problem that was skewered in the Doonesbury comic strips in which a written text entry is (erroneously) translated as "Egg Freckles?", as well as in the animated series The Simpsons. However, the word 'freckles' was not included in the Newton dictionary, although a user could add it themselves. Difficulties were in part caused by the long time requirements for the Calligrapher handwriting recognition software to "learn" the user's handwriting; this process could take from two weeks to two months.
Another factor which limited the early Newton devices' appeal was that desktop connectivity was not included in the basic retail package, a problem that was later solved with 2.x Newton devices - these were bundled with a serial cable and the appropriate Newton Connection Utilities software.
Later versions of Newton OS offered improved handwriting recognition, quite possibly a leading reason for the continued popularity of the devices among Newton users. Even given the age of the hardware and software, Newtons still demand a sale price on the used market far greater than that of comparatively aged PDAs produced by other companies. In 2006 CNET compared an Apple MessagePad 2000 to a Samsung Q1, and the Newton was declared better. In 2009, CNET compared an Apple MessagePad 2000 to an iPhone, and the Newton was still declared better.
A chain of dedicated Newton only stores called Newton Source existed from 1994 until 1998. Locations included New York, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Chicago and Boston. The Westwood Village, California, near U.C.L.A. featured the trademark red and yellow lightbulb Newton logo in neon. The stores provided an informative educational venue to learn about the Newton platform in a hands on relaxed fashion. The stores had no traditional computer retail counters and featured oval desktops where interested users could become intimately involved with the Newton product range. The stores were a model for the later Apple Stores.
Newton device models
|Device||Model No.||Processor||Memory||Display||Newton OS version||Newton OS languages||Ports||PCMCIA||Power||Weight & dimensions||Introduced||Discontinued||Code name|
|OMP (Original Newton MessagePad)||H1000||ARM 610 (20 MHz)||4 MB ROM, 640 KB RAM||336 × 240 (B&W)||1.0 to 1.05, or 1.10 to 1.11||English or German||RS422, LocalTalk & SHARP ASK Infrared||1 PCMCIA-slot II, 5v or 12v||4 AAA or NiCd rechargeable or external power supply||0.41 kg, 18.42 cm H × 11.43 cm W × 1.91 cm D||August 3, 1993, in the US, December 1993 in Germany||March 1994||Junior|
|Sharp ExpertPad PI-7000||?||ARM 610 (20 MHz)||4 MB ROM, 640 KB RAM||336 × 240 (B&W)||1.0 to 1.05, or 1.10 to 1.11||English or Japanese||RS422, LocalTalk & SHARP ASK Infrared||1 PCMCIA-slot II, 5v or 12v||4 AAA or NiCd rechargeable or external power supply||182mm × 112mm × 28mm (with screen lid open)||August 3, 1993, in the US, ? in Japan||March 1994||?|
|Apple MessagePad 100||H1000||ARM 610 (20 MHz)||4 MB ROM, 640 KB RAM||336 × 240 (B&W)||1.3||English, German or French||RS422, LocalTalk & SHARP ASK Infrared||1 PCMCIA-slot II, 5v or 12v||4 AAA or NiCd rechargeable or external power supply||0.41 kg, 18.42 cm H × 11.43 cm W × 1.91 cm D||March 1994||April 1995||?|
|Apple MessagePad 110||H0059||ARM 610 (20 MHz)||4 MB ROM, 1 MB RAM||320 × 240 (B&W)||1.2 or 1.3||English or French||RS422, LocalTalk & SHARP ASK Infrared||1 PCMCIA-slot II, 5v or 12v||4 AA or NiCd rechargeable or external power supply||0.45 kg, 20.32 cm H × 10.16 cm W × 3 cm D||March 1994||April 1995||Lindy|
|Sharp ExpertPad PI-7100||?||ARM 610 (20 MHz)||4 MB ROM, 640 KB RAM||336 × 240 (B&W)||1.3||English or Japanese||RS422, LocalTalk & SHARP ASK Infrared||1 PCMCIA-slot II, 5v or 12v||4 AAA or NiCd rechargeable or external power supply||182mm × 112mm × 28mm (with screen lid open)||April 1994||late 1994||?|
|Apple MessagePad 120||H0131||ARM 610 (20 MHz)||4 MB (OS 1.3) or 8 MB (OS 2.0) ROM, 1.0 MB, or 2.0 MB RAM||320 × 240 (B&W)||1.3 or 2.0||English, German or French||RS422, LocalTalk & SHARP ASK Infrared||1 PCMCIA-slot II, 5v or 12v||4 AA or NiCd rechargeable or external power supply||0.45 kg, 20.32 cm H × 10.16 cm W × 3 cm D||October 1994 in Germany, January 1995 in the US||June 1996||Gelato|
|Digital Ocean Tarpon||?||ARM 610 (20 MHz)||4 MB (OS 1.3) or 8 MB (OS 2.0) ROM, 687 KB RAM, Flash memory||320 × 240 (B&W)||1.3 or 2.0||English||RS422, LocalTalk & SHARP ASK Infrared||1 PCMCIA-slot II, 5v or 12v||4 AA or NiCd rechargeable or external power supply||10" × 4.5" × 2.5" (3 lb. 3 oz.)||January 1995 in the US||?||?|
|Motorola Marco||?||ARM 610 (20 MHz)||4 MB (OS 1.3) ROM, 687 KB RAM, Flash memory||320 × 240 (B&W)||1.3||English||RS422, LocalTalk & SHARP ASK Infrared||1 PCMCIA-slot II, 5v or 12v||4 AA or NiCd rechargeable or external power supply||?||January 1995 in the US||?||?|
|Harris SuperTech 2000||?||ARM 610 (20 MHz)||4 MB (OS 1.3) ROM, 687 KB RAM, Flash memory||320 × 240 (B&W)||1.3||English||RS422, LocalTalk & SHARP ASK Infrared||1 PCMCIA-slot II, 5v or 12v||4 AA or NiCd rechargeable or external power supply||?||August 1995 in the US||?||?|
|Digital Ocean Seahorse||?||ARM 610 (20 MHz)||8 MB (OS 2.0) ROM, 687 KB RAM, Flash memory||320 × 240 (B&W)||2.0||English||RS422, LocalTalk & SHARP ASK Infrared||1 PCMCIA-slot II, 5v or 12v||4 AA or NiCd rechargeable or external power supply||9.5" × 4.5" × 2.5" (48 oz.)||January 1996 in the US||?||?|
|Apple MessagePad 130||H0196||ARM 610 (20 MHz)||8 MB ROM, 2.5 MB RAM||320 × 240 (B&W) w/ backlight||2.0||English or German||RS422, LocalTalk & SHARP ASK Infrared||1 PCMCIA-slot II, 5v or 12v||4 AA or NiCd rechargeable or external power supply||0.45 kg, 20.32 cm H × 10.16 cm W × 3 cm D||March 1996||April 1997||Dante|
|Apple eMate 300||H0208||ARM 710a (25 MHz)||8 MB ROM, 1 MB RAM, 2 MB Flash Memory, Expandable Internally to 2 MB Random Access Memory and 4 MB Flash Memory||480 × 320 greyscale (16 shades) w/ backlight||2.1 (2.2)||English||IrDA, headphone port, Interconnect port, LocalTalk, Audio I/O, Autodock||1 PCMCIA-slot I/II/III, 5v||NiMH battery pack (built-in) or external power supply||1.81 kg, 30.5 cm H × 29 cm W × 5.33 cm D||March 1997||February 1998||?|
|Apple MessagePad 2000||H0136||StrongARM SA-110 (162 MHz)||8 MB ROM, 1 MB RAM, 4 MB Flash memory||480 × 320 greyscale (16 shades) w/ backlight||2.1||English||Dual-mode IR; IrDA & SHARP ASK Infrared, LocalTalk, Audio I/O, Autodock, Phone I/O||2 PCMCIA-slot II, 5v or 12v||4 AA or NiMH rechargeable or external power supply||0.64 kg, 21.1 cm H × 11.94 cm W × 2.79 cm D||March 1997||February 1998||Q|
|Apple MessagePad 2100||H0149||StrongARM SA-110 (162 MHz)||8 MB ROM, 4 MB RAM, 4 MB Flash memory||480 × 320 greyscale (16 shades) w/ backlight||2.1||English or German||Dual-mode IR; IrDA & SHARP ASK Infrared, LocalTalk, Audio I/O, Autodock||2 PCMCIA-slot II, 5v or 12v||4 AA or NiMH rechargeable or external power supply||0.64 kg, 21.1 cm H × 11.94 cm W × 2.79 cm D||November 1997||February 1998||?|
Notes: The eMate 300 actually has ROM chips silk screened with 2.2 on them. Stephanie Mak on her website discusses this: If one removes all patches to the eMate 300 (by replacing the ROM chip, and then putting in the original one again, as the eMate and the MessagePad 2000/2100 devices erase their memory completely after replacing the chip), the result will be the Newton OS saying that this is version 2.2.00. Also, the Original MessagePad and the MessagePad 100 share the same model number, as they only differ in the ROM chip version. (The OMP has OS versions 1.0 to 1.05, or 1.10 to 1.11, while the MP100 has 1.3 that can be upgraded with various patches.)
Timeline of Newton models
There were a number of projects that used the Newton as a portable information device in cultural settings such as museums. For example, Visible Interactive created a walking tour in San Francisco's Chinatown but the most significant effort took place in Malaysia at the Petronas Discovery Center, known as Petrosains.
In 1995, an exhibit design firm, DMCD Inc., was awarded the contract to design a new 100,000-square-foot (9,300 m2) science museum in the Petronas Towers in Kuala Lumpur. A major factor in the award was the concept that visitors would use a Newton device to access additional information, find out where they were in the museum, listen to audio, see animations, control robots and other media, and to bookmark information for printout at the end of the exhibit.
The device became known as the ARIF, a Malay word for "wise man" or "seer" and it was also an acronym for A Resourceful Informative Friend. Some 400 ARIFS were installed and over 300 are still in use today. The development of the ARIF system was extremely complex and required a team of hardware and software engineers, designers, and writers. ARIF is an ancestor of the PDA systems used in museums today and it boasted features that have not been attempted since.
The Newton was also used in healthcare applications, for example in collecting data directly from patients. Newtons were used as electronic diaries, with patients entering their symptoms and other information concerning their health status on a daily basis. The compact size of the device and its ease of use made it possible for the electronic diaries to be carried around and used in the patients' everyday life setting. This was an early example of electronic patient-reported outcomes (ePRO)
- Graffiti Accuracy
- Read about HWR, ink text, Sketches, & Shapes in Apple's MessagePad Handbook available in Apple's Newton Manuals collection
- HWR accuracy:
- See comments in Wired's Apple Newton Just Won't Drop (four years later)
- See text under "Handwriting Recognition" in Pen Computing's First Look at Newton OS 2.0
- See "Opportunity Squandered" in Pen Computing's Why did Apple kill the Newton?
- See comments under "Software" in MacTech's MessagePad 2000 review
- Comments by Pen Computing's editor
- See user testing results discussed in part 6 of this A.I. Magazine article on Newton HWR
- MessagePad 2000 review at Small Dog Electronics
- See comments under "Note-taking" in MessagePad 2000 review at "The History and Macintosh Society"
- What's Right With The Newton: HWR
- A very large number of references on slashdot.org, here are a few: "leaps and bounds ahead of what anyone was doing then or is doing now", "recognition is out of this world" in thread attached to Newton Won't Die, "still isn't a handwriting recognition system available that's as good" in thread attached to NewtonOS Running on Linux PDA, "recognition of 3 years ago is better than anything else on the market today" in thread attached to "Inkwell No Longer From the Newton?", "excellent handwriting recognition", "awesome recognition", "great handwriting recognition" in thread attached to The Newton O.S. Creeps Toward New Hardware, "best I've ever seen" in thread attached to Apple Newton vs Samsung Q1 UMPC
- Assessment by Apple developer Archived July 17, 2012, at the Wayback Machine.
- Prof. Warden's MessagePad 130 review
- '[NTLK] Random historical thoughts...' - MARC. Marc.info (November 6, 2006). Retrieved on August 2, 2013.
- Notes on the (relatively unknown) History of Pen-based Computing
- Pen Computing's First Look at Newton OS 2.0
- "Ink: Handwriting Recognition" (PDF).
- McCracken, Harry. "Newton, Reconsidered". Technologizer. Retrieved 5 July 2014.
- "Newton steals the show at Boston Macworld Expo". Baltimore Sun. Knight-Ridder. August 9, 1993. Retrieved 5 July 2014.
- Egg freckles comic strip
- Carr, Austin. "How "The Simpsons" Fixed Apple's iPhone Keyboard" Fast Company (magazine), September 19, 2013. Retrieved: May 23, 2015. Archived on April 13, 2015.
- Apple Newton vs Samsung Q1 UMPC, Special Features at CNET.co.uk
- Reid, Rory (November 26, 2009). "Apple Newton vs Apple iPhone". CNET. Retrieved 7 July 2014.
- Other Homebrew eMate Hacks
- Tiplady B, Crompton GK, Dewar MH, Böllert FG, Matusiewicz SP, Campbell LM, Brackenridge D (1997). "The use of electronic diaries in respiratory studies". Drug Information Journal. 31: 759–764. doi:10.1177/009286159703100317.
- Apple's press release on the debut of the MessagePad 2100
- Apple's overview of features & limitations of Newton Connection Utilities
- Newton overview at Newton Source archived from Apple
- Newton FAQ
- Pen Computing's First Look at Newton OS 2.0
- Newton Gallery
- Birth of the Newton
- The Newton Hall of Fame: People behind the Newton
- Pen Computing's Why did Apple kill the Newton?
- Pen Computing's Newton Notes column archive
- A.I. Magazine article by Yaeger on Newton HWR design, algorithms, & quality and associated slides
- Info on Newton HWR from Apple's HWR Technical Lead
- on YouTube
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Apple Newton.|
Additional Resources & Information
- Defying Gravity: The Making of Newton, by Kounalakis & Menuez (Hardcover)
- Newton at Curlie (based on DMOZ)
- Complete Developer's manual for the StrongARM SA-110
- Beginner's overview of the StrongARM SA-110 Microprocessor