DUI laws in California: Difference between revisions
Undid revision 817063292 by 172.58.20.43 (talk) per WP:DOREVERT. Please discuss your changes on the article talk page to establish a consensus for them. |
I too agree with the others. I am a DUI attorney, and every fact that EENG is removing, happens to be factual, and these deletions are obviously an EGO issue, that does not belong on this site!! Tag: review edit |
||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
<noinclude>{{User:RMCD bot/subject notice|1=DUI laws in California|2=Talk:DUI in California#Requested move 21 December 2017 }} |
<noinclude>{{User:RMCD bot/subject notice|1=DUI laws in California|2=Talk:DUI in California#Requested move 21 December 2017 }} |
||
</noinclude>Compared to those of other states, California's penalties for "driving under the influence"{{Explain|date=December 2017}} (DUI) are relatively severe.{{Citation needed|date=December 2017}} |
|||
The state of [[California]] is in the moderate range at number 31 on the list of places with the harshest penalties in the [[United States]] for [[driving under the influence]] of alcohol, with [[Arizona]], its neighbor, being the strictest, and [[South Dakota]] being the most lenient.<ref name="wallethub">{{cite web|last1=Comoreanu|first1=Alina|title=Strictest And Most Lenient States On DUI|url=https://wallethub.com/edu/dui-penalties-by-state/13549/|website=WalletHub|accessdate=1 August 2017|date=10 August 2016}}</ref> |
|||
⚫ | |||
Moderate does not mean getting a DUI in California is without serious consequences, on the contrary, the penalties are severe. The driver, if found over the legal limit of .08 [[blood alcohol]], will certainly be handcuffed, locked into the back seat of a police cruiser, and taken to a lock-up facility, booked, and detained until those in charge deem the offender to be completely [[sobriety|sober]]. The average time is 10 hours behind bars. If the offender is found guilty by the court, the minimum time to serve in lock-up is 2 days, of which the judge can, at his discretion, allow one of those days to be ''time served'' because of the original roadside detention, and subsequent lock-up.<ref name="wallethub"/> |
|||
The license of a driver charged with DUI in California is revoked, and a 30-day temporary license issued in its place. The driver may ask for a hearing by the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) for extension of the temporary license or authorization to apply for a new permanent license; in most cases the outcome of such a hearing is a determination that thetemporary license may be used only in traveling to and from work until the case is resolved. (If no hearing is requested then all driving privileges expire at the end of the 30 days, until the judge in the criminal case determines the driver's final disposition.)<ref>{{cite web|title=Arrest for Driving Under the Influence DUI General Information|url=https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/dmv/detail/dl/driversafety/dsalcohol|website=California Department of Motor Vehicles|accessdate=1 August 2017}}</ref> Separate from the DMV's determination are any criminal charges; in conjunction with sentencing the presiding judge will determine any restriction, revocation, or restoration of the accused driving privileges. Attorney's fees for a DUI case typically from from $2,000 to $6,000.|date=December 2017}} |
|||
==Criminal vs DMV penalties== |
|||
In California, an offender has two separate entities to deal with, each with its own penalties and hearings. The first to deal with after release from the holding cell, is the [[Department of Motor Vehicles|DMV]] (Dept. of Motor Vehicles). The drivers license that was previously in the possession ot the offender, is now the property of the [[district attorney]], and never to be used by the offender again. When the entire affair is over the offender will have to apply for a new one.<ref>{{cite web|title=Arrest for Driving Under the Influence DUI General Information|url=https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/dmv/detail/dl/driversafety/dsalcohol}}</ref> |
|||
Before being released from the holding facility, the [[defendant]] is given a 30-day temporary license. The DMV is notified, and the accused has 10 days to contact them to arrange for a DMV hearing with a H.O. (Hearing Officer), or after the 30-day period the defendant is without a license to get anywhere. The accused is notified by mail within 10 days of his hearing as to the outcome. If the accused loses the DMV hearing (which 9 out of 11 do), a restricted printed license is also in the envelope, allowing the offender to drive to and from work and, or, an alcohol treatment program for 90 days, or until disposition of the criminal case, which ever comes first. Should the criminal proceedings be continued from postponement, the DMV will honor the temporary license until the criminal proceedings are completed. If the defendant wins the DMV hearing, the victor can apply for a new California driver's license the same day.<ref>{{cite web|title=Arrest for Driving Under the Influence DUI General Information|url=https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/dmv/detail/dl/driversafety/dsalcohol|website=California Department of Motor Vehicles|accessdate=1 August 2017}}</ref> |
|||
If the accused does win the DMV hearing, there are still the criminal charges to face with the DA, and if that case is lost, the defendant's driving privileges will be determined by the Judge presiding over the criminal case. However, statistically, if a defendant wins the DMV case, the DA may eventually drop the charges to a lesser degree (such as a [[wet reckless]] charge). These negotiations for a lesser charge are almost always conducted by an attorney for the defendant, and not the defendant himself. The fees for a DUI attorney in California range from $2,000 - $6,000.00. |
|||
<ref>{{cite web|title=Free Legal Advice|url=https://criminal-law.freeadvice.com/criminal-law/drunk_driving/dui-attorney-cost.htm}}</ref> |
|||
==Non-alcohol-related California DUI offenses== |
|||
DUI arrests are not necessarily alcohol related. Being under the influence of any drug that hinders one's driving skills, may cause a suspect to fail a California roadside sobriety test that may lead to an arrest, and a subsequent blood or urine test at booking. |
|||
Mark Cantrell, a DUI defense attorney located in [[Riverside, California]], was quoted as saying that one of the most difficult cases in his career, involved a middle aged man intoxicated on [[prescription drugs]], and subsequently becoming the cause of the death of a cyclist. "Difficult, sad, and frustrating because the offender was so [[substance intoxication|intoxicated]], he just kept driving, and didn't even remember the incident".<ref>{{cite news|last1=Wesson|first1=Gail|title=Driver jailed in cyclist’s death|url=http://www.pe.com/2015/03/20/the-pass-driver-jailed-in-cyclist8217s-death/|accessdate=1 August 2017|agency=The Press-Enterprise|date=20 March 2015}}</ref> |
|||
The [[California Highway Patrol]] (CHPS) officers, as well as most sheriff and local police agencies in California, are trained to identify, and test for non alcohol related symptoms when screening detained drivers suspected of ''driving under the influence''. A suspect may be arrested if the officer is convinced the perpetrator is under the influence of any drug (prescription or otherwise) that is impairing the driver's ability to control the vehicle. A blood, or urine test (depending on the drug being screened) at booking is given to either confirm or deny the allegation. The suspect may be detained at a holding facility until the testing laboratory's results are completed. A Judge then decides the suspect's criminal liability if any. These cases are complex and difficult for all parties involved, especially when the suspect may not have intended to break the law, and was taking his legal medication as prescribed. However, in California it is illegal to drive a motor vehicle when driving is impaired by any substance. |
|||
⚫ | |||
===Minimum penalties for first conviction=== |
===Minimum penalties for first conviction=== |
||
*Approximately $1800 in fines |
*Approximately $1800.00 in fines |
||
*Average time for first offense: 48 hours, less time served at initial arrest until release on own cognizance.{{cn|date=August 2017}} |
*Average time for first offense: 48 hours, less time served at initial arrest until release on own cognizance.{{cn|date=August 2017}} |
||
*90-day restricted license to go to and from work, and or to a Certified 3-month alcohol treatment program |
*90-day restricted license to go to and from work, and or to a Certified 3-month alcohol treatment program |
||
*Attend a 3-month mandatory California sanctioned alcohol treatment program costing $500 |
*Attend a 3-month mandatory California sanctioned alcohol treatment program costing $500.00 |
||
*Driving privileges suspended after 30 days from the arrest date (imposed by the DMV) |
*Driving privileges suspended after 30 days from the arrest date (imposed by the DMV) |
||
*Auto insurance must now carry an [[SR-22 (insurance)|SR-22]] insurance certificate for 3 years. Additional insurance fees will be required |
*Auto insurance must now carry an [[SR-22 (insurance)|SR-22]] insurance certificate for 3 years. Additional insurance fees will be required |
||
*3 - 5 years [[probation]] |
*3 - 5 years [[probation]] |
||
*Possible installation of an ignition interlock device on the offender's vehicle<ref>{{cite web|last1=Burglin|first1=Paul|last2=Simons|first2=Barry|title=California Drunk Driving Punishment Chart|url=http://www.jameseducationcenter.com/articles/ca-drunk-driving-punishments/|website=James Education Center|publisher=James Publishing|accessdate=1 August 2017}}</ref> |
*Possible installation of an ignition interlock device on the offender's vehicle<ref>{{cite web|last1=Burglin|first1=Paul|last2=Simons|first2=Barry|title=California Drunk Driving Punishment Chart|url=http://www.jameseducationcenter.com/articles/ca-drunk-driving-punishments/|website=James Education Center|publisher=James Publishing|accessdate=1 August 2017}}</ref> |
||
*Average total fines, fees, alcohol treatment program, increased auto insurance, and cost of a DUI [[defense attorney]] $7,000-$11,000<ref name="nolodl">{{cite web|last1=Stim|first1=Rich|title=California DUI: What are the Penalties?|url=http://dui.drivinglaws.org/resources/dui-laws-state/penalties-dui-california.htm|website=DrivingLaws|publisher=Nolo|accessdate=1 August 2017}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|title=How much does a DUI cost - from courtinfo.ca.gov|url=http://www2.courtinfo.ca.gov/stopteendui/parents/cost/how-much-does-a-dui-cost.cfm}}</ref> |
*Average total fines, fees, alcohol treatment program, increased auto insurance, and cost of a DUI [[defense attorney]] $7,000.00-$11,000.00<ref name="nolodl">{{cite web|last1=Stim|first1=Rich|title=California DUI: What are the Penalties?|url=http://dui.drivinglaws.org/resources/dui-laws-state/penalties-dui-california.htm|website=DrivingLaws|publisher=Nolo|accessdate=1 August 2017}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|title=How much does a DUI cost - from courtinfo.ca.gov|url=http://www2.courtinfo.ca.gov/stopteendui/parents/cost/how-much-does-a-dui-cost.cfm}}</ref> |
||
===Minimum penalties for a second offense=== |
===Minimum penalties for a second offense=== |
||
(''note: It is considered a second offense if the accused is arrested for a DUI within 10 years of the first offense'') |
(''note: It is considered a second offense if the accused is arrested for a DUI within 10 years of the first offense'') |
||
*10 days in jail |
*10 days in jail |
||
*$1,800 in fines |
*$1,800.00 in fines |
||
*18-30 month California State sanctioned alcohol treatment program costing an additional $1,800 |
*18-30 month California State sanctioned alcohol treatment program costing an additional $1,800.00 |
||
*installation of an [[ignition interlock device|interlock device]] on all vehicles owned by the offender |
*installation of an [[ignition interlock device|interlock device]] on all vehicles owned by the offender |
||
*Driving privileges revoked for one year from the arrest date (imposed by the DMV) |
*Driving privileges revoked for one year from the arrest date (imposed by the DMV) |
||
Line 29: | Line 44: | ||
===Minimum penalties for a third offense=== |
===Minimum penalties for a third offense=== |
||
*120 days in jail |
*120 days in jail |
||
*$1,800 in fines (may go up to $18,000) |
*$1,800.00 in fines (may go up to $18,000.00) |
||
*Revocation of driver's license for 3 years |
*Revocation of driver's license for 3 years |
||
*Completion of a 30-month alcohol multi-offender program |
*Completion of a 30-month alcohol multi-offender program |
||
Line 43: | Line 58: | ||
==External links== |
==External links== |
||
{{Commons category|Drunk driving}} |
{{Commons category|Drunk driving}} |
||
*[http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/impaireddriving.html Impaired driving] on [[MedlinePlus]] |
|||
{{Alcohealth}} |
{{Alcohealth}} |
Revision as of 21:43, 25 December 2017
A request that this article title be changed to DUI laws in California is under discussion. Please do not move this article until the discussion is closed. |
The state of California is in the moderate range at number 31 on the list of places with the harshest penalties in the United States for driving under the influence of alcohol, with Arizona, its neighbor, being the strictest, and South Dakota being the most lenient.[1]
Moderate does not mean getting a DUI in California is without serious consequences, on the contrary, the penalties are severe. The driver, if found over the legal limit of .08 blood alcohol, will certainly be handcuffed, locked into the back seat of a police cruiser, and taken to a lock-up facility, booked, and detained until those in charge deem the offender to be completely sober. The average time is 10 hours behind bars. If the offender is found guilty by the court, the minimum time to serve in lock-up is 2 days, of which the judge can, at his discretion, allow one of those days to be time served because of the original roadside detention, and subsequent lock-up.[1]
Criminal vs DMV penalties
In California, an offender has two separate entities to deal with, each with its own penalties and hearings. The first to deal with after release from the holding cell, is the DMV (Dept. of Motor Vehicles). The drivers license that was previously in the possession ot the offender, is now the property of the district attorney, and never to be used by the offender again. When the entire affair is over the offender will have to apply for a new one.[2]
Before being released from the holding facility, the defendant is given a 30-day temporary license. The DMV is notified, and the accused has 10 days to contact them to arrange for a DMV hearing with a H.O. (Hearing Officer), or after the 30-day period the defendant is without a license to get anywhere. The accused is notified by mail within 10 days of his hearing as to the outcome. If the accused loses the DMV hearing (which 9 out of 11 do), a restricted printed license is also in the envelope, allowing the offender to drive to and from work and, or, an alcohol treatment program for 90 days, or until disposition of the criminal case, which ever comes first. Should the criminal proceedings be continued from postponement, the DMV will honor the temporary license until the criminal proceedings are completed. If the defendant wins the DMV hearing, the victor can apply for a new California driver's license the same day.[3]
If the accused does win the DMV hearing, there are still the criminal charges to face with the DA, and if that case is lost, the defendant's driving privileges will be determined by the Judge presiding over the criminal case. However, statistically, if a defendant wins the DMV case, the DA may eventually drop the charges to a lesser degree (such as a wet reckless charge). These negotiations for a lesser charge are almost always conducted by an attorney for the defendant, and not the defendant himself. The fees for a DUI attorney in California range from $2,000 - $6,000.00. [4]
Non-alcohol-related California DUI offenses
DUI arrests are not necessarily alcohol related. Being under the influence of any drug that hinders one's driving skills, may cause a suspect to fail a California roadside sobriety test that may lead to an arrest, and a subsequent blood or urine test at booking.
Mark Cantrell, a DUI defense attorney located in Riverside, California, was quoted as saying that one of the most difficult cases in his career, involved a middle aged man intoxicated on prescription drugs, and subsequently becoming the cause of the death of a cyclist. "Difficult, sad, and frustrating because the offender was so intoxicated, he just kept driving, and didn't even remember the incident".[5]
The California Highway Patrol (CHPS) officers, as well as most sheriff and local police agencies in California, are trained to identify, and test for non alcohol related symptoms when screening detained drivers suspected of driving under the influence. A suspect may be arrested if the officer is convinced the perpetrator is under the influence of any drug (prescription or otherwise) that is impairing the driver's ability to control the vehicle. A blood, or urine test (depending on the drug being screened) at booking is given to either confirm or deny the allegation. The suspect may be detained at a holding facility until the testing laboratory's results are completed. A Judge then decides the suspect's criminal liability if any. These cases are complex and difficult for all parties involved, especially when the suspect may not have intended to break the law, and was taking his legal medication as prescribed. However, in California it is illegal to drive a motor vehicle when driving is impaired by any substance.
Penalties
Minimum penalties for first conviction
- Approximately $1800.00 in fines
- Average time for first offense: 48 hours, less time served at initial arrest until release on own cognizance.[citation needed]
- 90-day restricted license to go to and from work, and or to a Certified 3-month alcohol treatment program
- Attend a 3-month mandatory California sanctioned alcohol treatment program costing $500.00
- Driving privileges suspended after 30 days from the arrest date (imposed by the DMV)
- Auto insurance must now carry an SR-22 insurance certificate for 3 years. Additional insurance fees will be required
- 3 - 5 years probation
- Possible installation of an ignition interlock device on the offender's vehicle[6]
- Average total fines, fees, alcohol treatment program, increased auto insurance, and cost of a DUI defense attorney $7,000.00-$11,000.00[7][8]
Minimum penalties for a second offense
(note: It is considered a second offense if the accused is arrested for a DUI within 10 years of the first offense)
- 10 days in jail
- $1,800.00 in fines
- 18-30 month California State sanctioned alcohol treatment program costing an additional $1,800.00
- installation of an interlock device on all vehicles owned by the offender
- Driving privileges revoked for one year from the arrest date (imposed by the DMV)
- Drastically increased auto insurance rates, and extended SR-22 insurance certificate required
- 10 years probation[7]
Minimum penalties for a third offense
- 120 days in jail
- $1,800.00 in fines (may go up to $18,000.00)
- Revocation of driver's license for 3 years
- Completion of a 30-month alcohol multi-offender program
- Drastically increased insurance coverage ranging in the thousands of dollars, if and when driving privileges are restored
- If charged as felony: forfeiture of the offender's vehicle indefinitely.[7]
See also
References
- ^ a b Comoreanu, Alina (10 August 2016). "Strictest And Most Lenient States On DUI". WalletHub. Retrieved 1 August 2017.
- ^ "Arrest for Driving Under the Influence DUI General Information".
- ^ "Arrest for Driving Under the Influence DUI General Information". California Department of Motor Vehicles. Retrieved 1 August 2017.
- ^ "Free Legal Advice".
- ^ Wesson, Gail (20 March 2015). "Driver jailed in cyclist's death". The Press-Enterprise. Retrieved 1 August 2017.
- ^ Burglin, Paul; Simons, Barry. "California Drunk Driving Punishment Chart". James Education Center. James Publishing. Retrieved 1 August 2017.
- ^ a b c Stim, Rich. "California DUI: What are the Penalties?". DrivingLaws. Nolo. Retrieved 1 August 2017.
- ^ "How much does a DUI cost - from courtinfo.ca.gov".