Jump to content

42nd National Hockey League All-Star Game

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

42nd NHL All-Star Game
123 Total
Wales 122 5
Campbell 254 11
DateJanuary 19, 1991
ArenaChicago Stadium
MVPVincent Damphousse (Toronto)
← 1990 1992 →

The 42nd National Hockey League All-Star Game took place in Chicago Stadium, home of the Chicago Blackhawks, on January 19, 1991.

Commissioner's Choice[edit]

The 1991 game saw much controversy in team selection, as Wales head coach Mike Milbury included enforcer Chris Nilan and checker Brian Skrudland ahead of scorer Kirk Muller and retiring legend Guy Lafleur. However, Nilan and Skrudland would both be sidelined due to injury. As a result of criticism of Milbury's picks, the league's board of governors quickly stated that future teams would be chosen by committee.

One immediate effect of this was the ability for the league president (after 1993, the commissioner) to appoint two "senior" players to honor their years in the game (one for each team) - Guy Lafleur and Bobby Smith were the first two stars appointed in this manner. Previously, while the NHL president often selected soon-to-be retiring stars to the game (for instance, the 1980 game featured Gordie Howe, Phil Esposito, and Jean Ratelle at the request of coach Scotty Bowman), this became a tradition starting in 1991.

The other change, which would not happen until a year later, was because only two goaltenders were selected for the all-star game: as Edmonton Oilers coach John Muckler also coached the Campbell squad, many were considerably irked when Oilers goalie Bill Ranford was chosen over Chicago's own Ed Belfour, who was at the time the best goaltender that season, leading to the Chicago fans booing Ranford when he replaced starter Mike Vernon in the second period. To avoid this, Muckler suggested that three goaltenders should be selected in the future, with each goaltender playing a period - and the league made it so.

The War on Fighting[edit]

The 42nd classic was broadcast not only in the U.S. and Canada, but for soldiers abroad fighting in Operation Desert Storm, and players wore decals on their helmets as a symbolic gesture of support. However, some, like Wayne Gretzky (whose grandfather was a veteran of World War I and whose cousin was abroad at the time), called for the game to be canceled.

American broadcaster NBC broke away[1][2] from the telecast in the third period[3] to televise a briefing from The Pentagon involving the Gulf War. SportsChannel America[4][5] included the missing coverage in a replay of NBC's telecast (NBC owned 50%[6][7][8][9] of Rainbow Enterprises, the parent of SportsChannel America).[10]

Heroes' Fall[edit]

Unlike the previous year, the Heroes of Hockey game was contested between Blackhawks alumni and the "best of the rest", akin to the all-star games of old. However, it was without its boycotters. Joining Gordie Howe were some of the greatest players of all, including Bobby Orr, Ted Lindsay, and Frank Mahovlich (Bobby Hull was also notably opposed, but played anyway due to the game being in Chicago). At the center of this argument, however, were pensions: the National Hockey League Alumni Association believed that there was a $12 million pension surplus in which they were entitled to, and one of the more convincing arguments to support their case was that 26-year veteran Howe was being paid only $1200 per month from this pension fund - noticeably below what he would have gotten if he had pursued a career elsewhere, as he noted.

Super Skills Competition[edit]

The Wales Conference won its first Super Skills competition in All-Star Game history, although the majority of the individual events was won by Campbell Conference participants. Even though Al MacInnis won the Hardest Shot event he was 3 mph off of breaking Al Iafrate's mark that was set in the 1990 Super Skills. However, Mark Messier and Patrick Roy would establish new individual events records.

Individual Event winners[edit]

The game[edit]

Toronto Maple Leafs' left winger Vincent Damphousse scored four goals as the Campbell Conference defeated the Wales Conference 11–5 in front of a sell-out crowd at Chicago Stadium and a worldwide television audience that was the largest in All-Star Game history. Damphousse tallied three of his four goals in the third period to be named All-Star M.V.P. and would become just the third player in All-Star Game history to record 4 goals in a game, which is shared by Wayne Gretzky and Mario Lemieux. Damphousse's performance also overshadowed a five-point performance by St. Louis Blues center Adam Oates who recorded one goal and four assists in the game.


Campbell Conference Wales Conference
Final score 11 5
Scoring summary
  • Gagner (Roenick, Larmer) 6:17 first
  • Damphousse (Oates, S. Smith) 11:36 first
  • Suter (unassisted) 5:23 second
  • Gretzky (Sandstrom) 9:10 second
  • Oates (Yzerman) 9:48 second
  • Fleury (Messier, Chelios) 14:40 second (GWG)
  • Roenick (S. Smith, Oates) 17:07 second
  • Chelios (Roenick, Larmer) 5:23 third
  • Damphousse (Oates, Housley) 8:54 third
  • Damphousse (Housley, Oates) 11:40 third
  • Damphousse (unassisted) 17:16 third
  • LaFontaine (Turcotte) 9:14 first
  • LaFontaine (Hatcher) 1:33 second
  • Tocchet (Verbeek, Sakic) 15:36 second
  • MacLean (Cullen, Bourque) 2:29 third (PPG)
  • Stevens (Tocchet) 13:56 third (PPG)
  • Housley, holding 0:57 third
  • Housley, tripping 12:26 third
Shots on goal 15–15–11–41 10–9–22–41
Win/Loss W - Bill Ranford L - Andy Moog


Campbell Conference Wales Conference
Head coach CanadaJohn Muckler (Edmonton Oilers) United StatesMike Milbury (Boston Bruins)
Honorary captain CanadaStan Mikita CanadaJean Beliveau
Lineup Starting lineup:

Commissioner's selection:


Starting lineup:

Commissioner's selection:


See also[edit]


  • Brett Hull was voted as a starter, but was unable to play due to injury. Adam Oates was his replacement.
  • Chris Nilan and Brian Skrudland were named to the Wales team, but did not play.
  • Larry Robinson was named to the Campbell team, but did not play.
  • It was at this game, where the tradition of cheering during the United States National Anthem prior to every Chicago Blackhawks game was introduced to the Nation. The practice had been a Hawks tradition at Chicago Stadium since the 1985 semi-finals against the heavily-favored Edmonton Oilers during the Wayne Gretzky dynasty. This tradition carried over to the United Center and is still done today before all Blackhawks' home games. Blackhawks' fans also kept with this tradition for their 2 home Bridgestone Winter Classic and Stadium Series games (2009 at Wrigley Field and 2014 at Soldier Field).[1]


  1. ^ Steve Berkowitz (January 20, 1991). "Bush Endorses Playing of NFL Championship Games". The Washington Post.
  2. ^ Herb Gould (January 20, 1991). "Hawks'all-stars all stars Roenick, Larmer, Chelios on target". Chicago Sun-Times. Sun-Times Media Group. p. 1.
  3. ^ 1991 NHL All-Star Game, Chicago Stadium (second intermission, third period) on YouTube
  4. ^ Helene Elliot (February 17, 1989). "INSIDE THE NHL U.S. Coach Has Mellowed". Newsday. Cablevision Systems Corporation. p. 163.
  5. ^ Rudy Martzke (March 16, 1989). "NBC to replace baseball with a few NHL games". USA Today. Gannett Company. p. 3C.
  6. ^ Rudy Martzke (January 31, 1989). "NBC plans innovative ways to fill baseball void". USA Today. Gannett Company. p. 3C.
  7. ^ Robert Fachet (March 14, 1989). "NOTEBOOK; Best of the West Enter Media Twilight Zone". The Washington Post. p. C08.
  8. ^ Larry Jackson (April 7, 1989). "IS RISING SON SET FOR A TV FALL?". The Palm Beach Post. p. 2C.
  9. ^ Steve Nidetz (April 18, 1989). "NHL providing SportsChannel with a Cupful of riches". Chicago Tribune. Tribune Publishing. p. 3.
  10. ^ Jack Craig (February 12, 1989). "WILL THE NHL PINCH HIT? WITH SHIFT OF BASEBALL TO CBS, NBC NEEDS TO FILL HOLE IN ITS LINEUP". Boston Globe. p. 58.