Talk:Cabinet of Israel
|WikiProject Politics||(Rated Start-class, Mid-importance)|
Surely Tzipi Livni is the Vice Prime Minister, not the Acting Prime Minister- her personal article says so? If there is no reason for the mix I'll change it.
Oh, the confusion
Whoever wrote the above posted it as I was writing what appears below. Please note that if this person has indeed changed the article as suggested above, the description of what this article says is based on what it said before it was changed. Also please note that the reason Tzipi Livni's article describes her as "Vice Prime Minister" is because I added that title on the day the new Cabinet was sworn in, based on the information on one of the sites described below. I have now discovered that this information is not necessarily correct, but I have not changed it again because there appears to be a genuine conflict in sources that needs to be cleared up.
In reading various articles on the Internet (including Wikipedia) about the new Israeli government, including some that have links to various portions of the Israeli government web site, I have become aware that the government web site has at least three different versions of who has what title immediately subordinate to the Prime Minster.
This article (Cabinet of Israel) lists the following:
- Tzipi Livni, Acting Prime Minster
- Shimon Peres, Vice Prime Minister
- Amir Peretz, Deputy Prime Minister
- Eli Yishai, Deputy Prime Minister
- Shaul Mofaz, Deputy Prime Minister
(I will not mention Peretz, Yishai or Mofaz again, as all of the sources list them as Depty Prime Ministers.)
This article has an external link to Official government list and updates, however, that article (from the Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs official site) does not list Livni as "Acting Prime Minister." It lists her as "Vice Prime Minister," while listing Shimon Peres above her as "Vice Premier."
The section of Israel's government web site covering the Knesset also has a page listing the Cabinet , but this page lists Livni as "Vice Prime Minister" without mentioning Peres as having any title other than his Ministry portfolio.
The section of Israel's government web site that is apparently under the Prime Minister's Office has yet another page listing the Cabinet  and this page lists Peres as Vice Prime Minister and then Livni as Acting Prime Minister. (Which is what this article currently says.)
Which of course leads one to ask:
- Which is correct?
- Why does an official government web site have three different versions of the same facts?
- Is there really a title of "Acting Prime Minister" when the Prime Minister is not incapacitated? Or does it simply mean that Peres and Livni are both Vice Prime Ministers but that Livni is the one designated to take over as Acting Prime Minister should the need arise? And if this is correct, does Livni "rank higher" than Peres, even though two of the three "official" lists mention Peres first?
- Is there a distinction between Vice Prime Minister and Vice Premier?
My suggestion is that until this is cleared up, the various articles about these individuals (and the one on Deputy Leader of Israel) be left as they are now, because anyone who edits them to conform to something on the official web site, or another Wikipedia article, has as good a chance of changing a correct statement into an incorrect statement, as the reverse. 6SJ7 16:44, 8 May 2006 (UTC)
One person's solution
After receiving advice to "quote all the sources," I have edited the articles on Livni and Peres to indicate that there is some confusion, with 2 of the 3 sources cited in a footnote in the article on Livni, and all 3 cited in a footnote in the article on Peres. I am not going to change what appears in this article until some corroboration of one of the possible answers is found. At least now, this article and the one on Livni are not directly at odds with each other, as the anonymous editor who beat me to the punch correctly observed was the case previously. However, I suppose I should go fix up the Deputy Leader of Israel article now. I will probably put in the same footnote as I did in the Peres article. 6SJ7 01:20, 9 May 2006 (UTC)
- Done. This article, Deputy Leader of Israel, Tzipi Livni and Shimon Peres are all now, I believe, reasonably consistent with each other in terms of who holds which of the "honorary" positions in the Cabinet. If there are any other articles that have the same issue, I don't know about them (nor, given the amount of time I have spent on this today, do I necessarily want to know right now.) 6SJ7 01:38, 9 May 2006 (UTC)
Official Prime Minister's office website
I looked at the Hebrew version of the Israeli prime minister's office website. I will give the most literal translation i can and in the order listed on the website
- Ehud Olmert - Prime Minister and Minister of Social Welfare
- Shimon Peres - The second in command to the Prime Minister and the Minister for the development of the Negev and the Galilee who will be in charge of regional economic development
- Tzipi Livni - The one who fills the spot of the Prime Minister and Foreign Minister
Does anybody know if there are any non-Jewish (e. g. Christian or Muslim) members in the current Israeli cabinet or if there have been ministers in past governments who were not Jewish? Thanks a lot in advance! —Preceding unsigned comment added by 22.214.171.124 (talk) 12:32, 14 April 2009 (UTC)
- Ayoob Kara (Druze) is currently a deputy minister, but there are no non-Jewish ministers at the moment. There have been two (Raleb Majadele and Salah Tarif) in the past though - see this page on the Knesset website. Regards, пﮟოьεԻ 57 12:36, 14 April 2009 (UTC)
The name of the article should be the government of Israel
The cabinet in israel is small furom of few senior ministers wich decides about secret or importment decisions (like nagotiation withe the plisteniens, war and peace). The government of israel is the complete forum of all ministers and vice ministers togather, wich is the subject of this article. sorry for the bad english. Edensmoolandme (talk) 20:06, 26 March 2010 (UTC)
Move discussion in progress
There is a move discussion in progress on Talk:Cabinet of Albania which affects this page. Please participate on that page and not in this talk page section. Thank you. —RM bot 19:46, 21 May 2011 (UTC)