Richard D. Ryder
|Richard D. Ryder|
Rempstone Hall, Corfe Castle, Dorset
|Education||MA (experimental psychology)
University of Cambridge, 1963
Diploma (clinical psychology)
University of Edinburgh
PhD (Social and Political Sciences)
University of Cambridge, 1993
|Occupation||Writer, psychologist, animal rights advocate|
|Known for||Animal rights, opposition to animal research, coining of the term "speciesism"|
|Parents||Major Douglas Claud Dudley Ryder, and Vera Hamilton-Fletcher (née Cook)|
Richard Hood Jack Dudley Ryder (born 1940) is a British writer, psychologist, and animal rights advocate.
Ryder became known in the 1970s as a member of the Oxford Group, a group of intellectuals loosely centred on the University of Oxford who began to speak out against animal use, in particular factory farming and animal research. He was working at the time as a clinical psychologist at the Warneford Hospital in Oxford, and had himself been involved in animal research in the United Kingdom and United States.
In 1970, he coined the term speciesism to describe the exclusion of nonhuman animals from the protections available to human beings. In 1977 he became chairman of the RSPCA Council, serving until 1979, and helped to organise the first academic animal rights conference, held in August 1977 at Trinity College, Cambridge. The conference produced a "Declaration against Speciesism", signed by 150 people.
Ryder is the author of a number of books about animal research, animal rights, and morality in politics, including Victims of Science (1975), Animal Revolution (1989), and Painism: A Modern Morality (2001).
Ryder was born in Purbeck, Dorset, to Major Douglas Claud "Jack" Dudley Ryder, and his second wife, Vera Hamilton-Fletcher (née Cook). Jack Dudley Ryder was the great-grandson of the Honourable Granville Ryder (1799–1879), second son of Dudley Ryder, 1st Earl of Harrowby (1762–1847). Ryder was raised on the family estate, Rempstone Hall, in Corfe Castle.
He obtained his bachelor's degree in experimental psychology from the University of Cambridge (1960–1963), followed by a period of research into animal behaviour at Columbia University, and a diploma in clinical psychology from the University of Edinburgh. After Edinburgh, he worked as a clinical psychologist at the Warneford psychiatric hospital in Oxford. In 1980 he ran unsuccessfully for Parliament, and founded the Liberal Democrat's Animal Protection Group. He later went back to Cambridge, and was awarded his PhD in Social and Political Sciences in 1993. He held an Andrew W. Mellon visiting professorship at Tulane University in New Orleans in 1996.
Animal rights advocacy
Ryder first became involved with animal rights in 1969, when he protested against an otter hunt in Dorset. He was working at the time in the Warneford psychiatric hospital, and in April and May that year had three letters to the editor published in The Daily Telegraph, the first one headed "Rights of Non Human Animals," in which he criticised experiments on animals based on his own experiences in universities as an animal researcher. There was an increase in interest in animal rights during this period, following the publication of Ruth Harrison's Animal Machines (1964), a critique of factory farming, and a long article, "The Rights of Animals" (10 October 1965), by the novelist Brigid Brophy in The Sunday Times.
Brophy saw Ryder's letters in the Telegraph, and put him in touch with three philosophy postgraduate students at Oxford—Roslind Godlovitch, Stanley Godlovitch, and John Harris—who were editing a collection of essays about animal rights, published as Animals, Men and Morals: An Inquiry into the Maltreatment of Non-humans (1971). Ryder became involved with the group—which he later called the "Oxford Group"—and became an activist for animal rights, organising meetings and printing and handing out leaflets. He also became a contributor to the Godlovitches/Harris book. He was interviewed several times on the radio, and in December 1970 took part in a televised debate in Scotland on animal rights with Brophy.
He first used the term "speciesism" in a privately printed leaflet by the same name, which he distributed in Oxford in 1970 in protest against animal experimentation – he wrote that he thought of the word while lying in the bath in the Old Manor House in Sunningwell, Oxfordshire. Paul Waldau writes that Ryder used the term in the pamphlet to address experiments on animals that he regarded as illogical, and which, he argued, a fully informed moral agent would challenge. Ryder was also addressing the general attitude that excluded all nonhumans from the protections offered to humans, now known as the anti-speciesism critique. Waldau writes that this original definition of the term – in effect, human-speciesism – has been extended by others to refer to the assignment of value to any being on the basis of species membership alone, so that, for example, prioritising the value of chimpanzees over other animals (human-chimpanzee speciesism) might be seen as similarly illogical.
Ryder used the term again in his contribution to the Godlovitches/Harris book, in an essay called "Experiments on Animals" (1971). He wrote in the essay that animal researchers seek to have it both ways: they defend the scientific validity of animal experiments on the grounds of the similarity between humans and nonhumans, while defending the morality of it on the grounds of the differences. He argued that speciesism is as illogical as racism, writing that "species" and "race" are both vague terms, and asked: "If, under special conditions, it were one day found possible to cross a professor of biology with an ape, would the offspring be kept in a cage or in a cradle?"
The book was reviewed by Peter Singer in 1973 in The New York Review of Books, in which he argued that it was a call for the foundation of an animal liberation movement. The article led the New York Review to commission a book from Singer, published as Animal Liberation (1975). Singer used the term "speciesism" in the book, attributing it to Ryder, and included it the title of his fifth chapter – "Man's Dominion ... a short history of speciesism." Writing that it was not an attractive word, he defined it as "a prejudice or attitude of bias in favour of the interests of members of one's own species and against those of members of other species," and argued that it was a prejudice similar to racism and sexism:
Racists violate the principle of equality by giving greater weight to the interests of members of their own race when there is a clash between their interests and the interests of those of another race. Sexists violate the principle of equality by favouring the interests of their own sex. Similarly, speciesists allows the interests of their own species to override the greater interests of members of other species. The pattern is identical in each case.
Singer's use of the term popularised it, and in 1985 it became an entry in the Oxford English Dictionary, described as "discrimination against ... animal species by human beings, based on an assumption of mankind's superiority."
RSPCA Reform Group
The RSPCA Reform Group was founded in 1970 by members of the British RSPCA. Their aim was to change the direction of the RSPCA from an organisation that dealt mostly with companion animals into one that would oppose what the reformers saw as the key issues: factory farming, animal research, hunting, and bloodsports. They sought to secure the election of reformers – including Ryder and Andrew Linzey, the Oxford theologian – to the RSPCA's ruling council. As a result, Ryder was elected to the council in 1971, became its vice-chairman in 1976, then chairman from 1977 to 1979.
Ryder coined the term "painism" in 1990 to describe his position that all beings who feel pain deserve rights. He argues that painism can be seen as a third way between Peter Singer's utilitarian position and Tom Regan's deontological rights view. It combines the utilitarian view that moral status comes from the ability to feel pain with the rights-view prohibition on using others as a means to an end. He has criticised Regan's criterion for inherent worth, arguing that all beings who feel pain have inherent value. He has also criticised the utilitarian idea that exploitation of others can be justified if there is an overall gain in pleasure. He wrote in The Guardian in 2005: "One of the problems with the utilitarian view is that, for example, the sufferings of a gang-rape victim can be justified if the rape gives a greater sum total of pleasure to the rapists." Ryder was featured in the 2012 speciesism movie, The Superior Human? in which he describes his coining of the word "speciesism," and the principle of painism.
Oxford animal laboratory
Ryder is a supporter of VERO (Voice for Ethical Research at Oxford), a group of Oxford members and graduates formed in 2006 to protest the construction by the university of a new animal laboratory, the Biomedical Sciences Building, completed in 2008.
- (1970). Speciesism[dead link], privately printed leaflet, Oxford.
- (1971). "Experiments on Animals," in Stanley and Roslind Godlovitch and John Harris. Animals, Men and Morals. Grove Press, Inc.
- (1974). Speciesism: The Ethics of Vivisection. Scottish Society for the Prevention of Vivisection.
- (1975). Victims of Science: The Use of Animals in Research. Davis-Poynter Ltd.
- with W. Lane-Petter et al (September 1976). "The Ethics of Animal Experimentation", Journal of Medical Ethics. Vol. 2, No. 3, pp. 118–126.
- with David Paterson (eds.) (1979). Animals' Rights – A Symposium. Centaur Press Ltd.
- (1989). Animal Revolution: Changing Attitudes Towards Speciesism. McFarland & Co Inc.
- (ed.) (1992). Animal Welfare and the Environment. Gerald Duckworth & Co Ltd, in association with the RSPCA
- (1991). "Animal Experimentation: Sentientism," The Psychologist, vol 4, 1991.
- (1992). "Painism: Ethics, Animal Rights and Environmentalism," UWCC Centre for Applied Ethics.
- (ed.) (1992). The Duty of Mercy by Humphrey Primatt (first published 1776). Open Gate Press.
- (1998). The Political Animal: The Conquest of Speciesism. McFarland & Co Inc.
- (2001). Painism. A Modern Morality. Open Gate Press.
- (2005). The Calcrafts of Rempstone Hall: The Intriguing History of a Dorset Dynasty. Halsgrove.
- (2006). Putting Morality Back into Politics. Imprint Academic.
- (2009). Nelson, Hitler and Diana: Studies in Trauma and Celebrity. Imprint Academic.
- (2009). "Painism versus Utilitarianism", Think, vol 8, pp 85–89.
- (2011). Speciesism, Painism and Happiness. Imprint Academic.
- Ryder, Richard D. (2009). "The Oxford Group," in Marc Bekoff (ed.). The Encyclopedia of Animal Rights and Animal Welfare. Greenwood, pp. 261–262.
- Notes on the Contributors, in Stanley and Roslind Godlovitch and John Harris (eds.) (1971). Animals, Men and Morals. Grove Press.
- "A Declaration against Speciesism", in David Paterson and Richard D. Ryder (1979). Animals' Rights – A Symposium. Centaur Press Ltd.
- Ryder, Richard D. (1979). "The Struggle Against Speciesism," in Paterson and Ryder, op cit.
- Ryder, Richard D. (March 2006). "A Purbeck squire", Dorset Life.
- Ryder, Richard D. (2011). Speciesism, Painism and Happiness: A Morality for the 21st Century. Imprint Academic, pp. 38ff, 152–153.
- "Richard D. Ryder", richardryder.com
- Ryder, Richard D. (2000) . Animal Revolution: Changing Attitudes Towards Speciesism. Berg, p. 6.
- Garner, Robert (2004). Animals, Politics and Morality. Manchester University Press, p. 3ff.
- Waldau, Paul (2001). The Specter of Speciesism: Buddhist and Christian Views of Animals. Oxford University Press, pp. 5, 23–29.
- Ryder, Richard D. (Spring 2010). "Speciesism Again: The Original Leaflet", Critical Society, Issue 2.
- Ryder, Richard D. (1971). "Experiments on Animals", in Stanley and Roslind Godlovitch and John Harris. Animals, Men and Morals. Grove Press, Inc.
- Singer, Peter (1990) . Animal Liberation. New York Review/Random House, pp. 6, 9.
- For Singer's attributing the term to Ryder, see Singer, Peter. (1990) . Animal Liberation. New York Review Books, p. 269, footnote 4.
- For the OED, see Wise, Steven M. (2004). "Animal Rights, One Step at a Time," in Cass Sunstein and Martha Nussbaum. Animal Rights: Current Debates and New Directions. Oxford University Press, p. 26
- That Singer popularized the term, see Diamond, Cora (2004). "Eating Meat and Eating People," in Sunstein and Nussbaum, op cit, p. 93.
- Ryder, Richard (2009). "Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (RSPCA) Reform Group," in Bekoff, op cit, p. 307–308.
- Ryder, Richard D. (6 August 2005). "All beings that feel pain deserve human rights", The Guardian.
- Ryder defines pain as "any form of suffering or negative experience, including fear, distress and boredom, as well as corporeal pain itself. Such things as injustice, inequality and loss of liberty naturally cause pain": see "Painism", richardryder.co.uk.
- "The Superior Human?", official movie website.
- Bekoff, Marc. "The Superior Human? Who Do We Think We Are?", Psychology Today, 2 April 2012.
- "Who We Are", Voice for Ethical Research at Oxford.
- "Open Letter to the New Vice-Chancellor", Voice for Ethical Research at Oxford, Noughth week, Michaelmas term, 2009.
Websites and articles
- Official website
- Selection of writings by Ryder on animal rights
- Belshaw, Christopher (21 July 2011). "Speciesism, Painism and Happiness: A Morality for the Twenty-First Century", Times Higher Education.
- Dawkins, Richard (10 September 1979). "Brute Beasts," New Statesman (review of Animals' Rights – A Symposium).
- Hull, David L. (March 1991). "Review. Animal Revolution: Changing Attitudes Toward Speciesism", The Quarterly Review of Biology Vol. 66, No. 1, pp. 69–71.
- Mitra, Amit (31 March 1993). "Barbarism to animals has a hoary pedigree", Down to Earth.
- Ryder, Richard D. (8 August 1995). "Obituary: Brigid Brophy", The Independent.
- Ryder, Richard D. (15 November 1995). "Letter: Philosophising about the rights of animals", The Independent.
- Ryder, Richard D. (21 June 2001). "Letter: RSPCA and the hunt", The Independent.
- Ryder, Richard D. (1989). "Does the Animal Kingdom Need a Bill of Rights?' on YouTube, Royal Institute of Great Britain.