Comparison of MUTCD-influenced traffic signs

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Fry1989 (talk | contribs) at 21:03, 2 January 2018 (→‎Warning). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Most road signs used by countries in the Americas are generally influenced by the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD), first released in 1935, reflecting the influence of the United States throughout the region.[1] Other non-American countries using road signs similar to the MUTCD include Australia, Indonesia, Ireland, Japan, Malaysia, and New Zealand. They are also the only countries listed here which drive on the left.

There are also a number of American signatories to the Vienna Convention on Road Signs and Signals: Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Cuba, Ecuador, French Guiana, Paraguay, and Suriname. Of those, only Chile, Cuba, and Guyana have ratified the treaty; nonetheless, nearly all countries in the Americas use MUTCD-style yellow diamond warning signs.

It is also worth noting that, unlike in Europe, considerable variation within road sign designs can exist within nations, especially in multilingual areas. A notable example of this is Quebec, which uses a substantially different symbology than the rest of Canada.

Trilingual stop sign in Mistissini, Quebec, Canada. Languages are Cree, English, and French.

Differences between MUTCD-influenced traffic signs

The main differences between traffic signs influenced by the MUTCD relate to:

  • Graphic design and symbological details
  • The use of square-bordered or circular regulatory signs
  • Local languages (signs may be bilingual or trilingual)
    • Most notable is the text on stop signs. Unlike in Europe, the text on stop signs in the Americas varies depending on language, and may be multilingual.

Languages

Below is a table of the main languages used. Note that in non-English speaking countries, English is frequently included on signs near airports and tourist areas.

  República Argentina Commonwealth of Australia República Federativa do Brasil Canada       Canada República de Chile República de Colombia Republik Indonesia Republic of Ireland 日本国 Malaysia Estados Unidos Mexicanos New Zealand República de Panamá República del Perú Republic of the Philippines United States of America República Oriental del Uruguay
Argentina Australia Brazil Anglophone Canada Québec
Quebec
Chile Colombia Indonesia Ireland Japan Malaysia Mexico New Zealand Panama Peru Philippines United States Uruguay
Drives on the… Right Left Right Right Right Right Right Left Left Left Left Right Left Right Right Right Right Right
Primary language Spanish English Portuguese English French Spanish Spanish Indonesian Gaelic and
English[2]
Japanese Malay Spanish English Spanish Spanish English English Spanish
Secondary language(s)
  • English
    On guide signs in and around popular tourist areas.
  • English
    Especially on guide signs.
  • English
    Especially on guide signs.
Typical typeface(s) Helvetica FHWA FHWA (modified) Clearview, FHWA
(varies by province)
Clearview,
formerly FHWA
Ruta CL,
formerly FHWA
Helvetica Clearview, formerly FHWA Transport 新ゴ (Shingo) (Japanese),
Vialog (English)
LLM,
formerly FHWA
FHWA FHWA Helvetica FHWA (modified) Clearview,
formerly FHWA
FHWA, Clearview
(varies by state)
Helvetica

Differences in units

Metric signage reminder in Quebec, posted near US border
Road sign used in British Columbia, Canada, near the Canada–US border to remind American drivers that Canada uses the metric system.
Note that the imperial speed limit (left) is shown using a Canadian-style sign, rather than an MUTCD-standard one as would be used in the US
  • All countries, with the exception of the United States and Great Britain, use the metric system. Some countries mark this fact by using units on various signs.
    • Brazil, Indonesia, Ireland, Mexico, Panama, Peru, and parts of Canada (British Columbia, Ontario, and Yukon) list units (km/h) on their maximum speed limit signs. In Canada and Ireland, this is a reflection of (somewhat) recent transitions from Imperial to metric.
    • Advisory speed limit signs in most countries list units, although New Zealand does not. The US lists units in mph.
    • Height, weight, and width restrictions are almost always accompanied by units (tonnes or metres); in the US, the short ton is used with no distinction from metric tonnes.
    • Signs in Canada and Mexico near the US border often include both metric and Imperial units, to remind American drivers that they are entering metric countries. No such equivalent exists in the US.[5]
  • The US was, at one time, planning a transition to the metric system. The Metric Conversion Act of 1975 started the process, but it was halted in 1982. Nevertheless, the MUTCD specifies metric versions of speed limit signs. Furthermore, Interstate 19 in Arizona is partially signed in metric.

Color differences

Warning signs

Countries in yellow use MUTCD-style diamond warning signs. Click for large image and detailed info key.
  • Nearly all MUTCD-influenced warning signs are diamond-shaped and yellow; some warning signs may be fluorescent yellow-green in order to draw extra attention. There are a few exceptions to this:
    • Pentagonal signs are used in school zones in the United States, Mexico, Malaysia and many areas in Canada. In Japan and the Philippines, pentagonal signs are used for pedestrian crossings.
    • Argentina employs European-style red-bordered triangular warning signs in certain instances where extra attention is required. The Philippines uses this style for all warning signs.
  • Warning signs may be text-only.

Road works and construction

  • Most countries use orange or yellow diamond-shaped signs for construction zones. Australia and the Philippines use rectangular signs that fit into temporary casings.

Regulatory signs

  • Prohibitory and restrictive signs are classified as regulatory signs, as per the MUTCD.
  • Almost all prohibitory signs use a red circle with a slash. Restrictive signs typically use a red circle, as in Europe. Some may be seated on a rectangular white background.
    • The original MUTCD prohibitory and restrictive signs were text-only (i.e. NO LEFT TURN).[6] Some of these signs continue to be used in the US.
  • The No Entry / Do Not Enter sign may or may not feature text. In some Latin American countries, an upwards-pointing arrow contained within a slashed red circle is used instead.
    • The Latin American-style do not proceed straight sign may take a different meaning in countries with standard No Entry signs. Typically, it indicates an intersection where traffic cannot continue straight ahead, but where cross-traffic may enter the street from the right (or left). Thus, it is distinguished from a No Entry (for all vehicles) sign.

Mandatory or permitted-action signs

Various color schemes for mandatory signs. Click for large image and detailed info key.
  • The design of mandatory signs varies widely, since the MUTCD does not specify their use.[1] Rather, the MUTCD's equivalent are classified as regulatory signs.
    • Some countries use simple arrows with the text "ONLY" or its equivalent underneath. This is the MUTCD standard.
    • Some countries use European-style white-on-blue circular signs. These are "Type A Mandatory Signs" as prescribed by the Vienna Convention.
    • Some Latin American countries use red-bordered circular signs, in the same style as regulatory signs. These are "Type B Mandatory Signs" as prescribed by the Vienna Convention. In cases relating to particular types of vehicle traffic (e.g. buses), these signs are identical to some European prohibitory signs.[a]
    • Canada uses a unique style of mandatory sign that features a green circle.

Highway and wayfinding signs

  • Most countries use white-on-green signs on highways and to indicate location, etc.
    • The exact style of these signs varies widely, although many are influenced by the MUTCD standard.
    • Chile, Ireland, Japan, and New Zealand use both white-on-green and white-on-blue guide signs, as does the Northwest Territories and Ontario in Canada.
    • Malaysia uses both black-on-yellow and white-on-green guide signs.
    • White-on-blue signs are sometimes used at airports and for rest areas.
    • White-on-brown signs are sometimes used to indicate park areas.

Gallery of Guide Signs

Table of traffic signs comparison

Warning

  República Argentina
Argentina
 
Commonwealth of Australia
Australia
 
República Federativa do Brasil
Brazil
 
Canada
Canada
 
Ontario
Canada -
Ontario
Québec
Canada -
Quebec
República de Chile
Chile
 
República de Colombia
Colombia
 
Republik Indonesia
Indonesia
 
Republic of Ireland
Ireland
 
日本国
Japan
 
Malaysia
Malaysia
 
Estados Unidos Mexicanos
Mexico
 
New Zealand
New Zealand
 
República de Panamá
Panama
 
República del Perú
Peru
 
Republic of the Philippines
Philippines
 
United States of America
United States
(Graphical and textual—
used interchangeably)
República Oriental del Uruguay
Uruguay
 
Stop ahead File:Canada - stop ahead.svg ?
Not used
Yield ahead ? ?
Not used ?
Traffic signals ahead
or
Roundabout ahead
or

[b]
Two-way traffic ahead File:Australia W4-11.svg Not used
Uncontrolled railroad crossing ahead File:Australia road sign W7-7 (L).svg
Level railroad crossing with barriers ahead
[c]
File:Australia W7-4.svg
[c]

[c]

[c]

or

[c]

[c]

or

[c]
Tram / streetcar crossing Not used Not used N/A
[d]
N/A
[d]
N/A
[d]
Not used N/A
[d]
Not used N/A
[d]
N/A
[d]
N/A
[d]

[e]
Railroad crossbuck Not used
Level crossing (multiple tracks)

[f]


[f]

[f]
Not used
Argentina Australia Brazil Canada Canada
(Ontario)
Canada
(Quebec)
Chile Colombia Indonesia Ireland Japan Malaysia Mexico New Zealand Panama Peru Philippines USA Uruguay
Crossroads ahead
Junction with a side road ahead File:Australia road sign W2-4 (L).svg
Traffic merges ahead File:Australia W5-34 (L).svg
Divided highway ahead File:Australia W4-4.svg ? Not used ?
Divided highway ends ? File:Australia W4-6.svg ? Not used ? ?
Lane ends ahead File:Australia road sign W4-9 (L).svg
Road narrows ahead File:Australia W4-3.svg
Narrow bridge ahead File:Australia W4-1.svg ? Not used
Dangerous crosswinds ? ? ? ? ?
[g]
Low-flying aircraft File:Australia W5-30.svg ? ? ? ? ?
Steep hill downwards File:Australia W5-12.svg
Steep hill upwards File:Australia W5-13.svg Not used
[h]
Not used Not used ? Not used
Argentina Australia Brazil Canada Canada
(Ontario)
Canada
(Quebec)
Chile Colombia Indonesia Ireland Japan Malaysia Mexico New Zealand Panama Peru Philippines USA Uruguay
Uneven surface ?
Bump in road File:Australia W5-10.svg
Dip in road ? [i] Not used Not used ? ?
Slippery road surface
Loose road surface
[j]

[j]

[j]

[j]

[j]

[j]
? Not used ?
Pavement ends ? File:Australia W5-19.svg ? ? ? Not used Not used ?
Gentle curve ahead File:Australia W1-3 (L).svg
Sharp curve ahead File:Australia W1-1 (L).svg
Double curve ahead File:Australia W1-4 (L).svg
Series of curves ahead File:Australia W1-5 (L).svg
Hairpin curve ahead ? File:Australia W1-7 (L).svg ?
(B.C.)
? ? Not used Not used
Argentina Australia Brazil Canada Canada
(Ontario)
Canada
(Quebec)
Chile Colombia Indonesia Ireland Japan Malaysia Mexico New Zealand Panama Peru Philippines USA Uruguay
School zone
or


or
Children / playground ahead
Pedestrians / crossing ahead ?
or
File:Australia W6-2 (fluorescent).svg

or

or

or

or
Not used
or

or
Pedestrian crossing
or

or

Cyclists crossing ? ?
Falling rocks or debris File:Australia road sign W5-42 (L).svg
[g]
Argentina Australia Brazil Canada Canada
(Ontario)
Canada
(Quebec)
Chile Colombia Indonesia Ireland Japan Malaysia Mexico New Zealand Panama Peru Philippines USA Uruguay
Opening or swing bridge File:Australia W5-2.svg ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
Emergency vehicles ? ? ? Not used Not used Not used ?
Farm vehicles File:Australia W5-50.svg ? Not used Not used ? Not used
Domestic animals ?
Wild animals ? ? ?
Equestrians ? ? ? ? Not used ? ? ? ? Not used
Tunnel ahead ? ? ? ? ? Not used Not used ? ? ? ?
Height restriction ahead Not used Not used ? ? Not used
Width restriction ahead Not used Not used Not used
[j]
Not used Not used ? Not used Not used Not used
Weight restriction ahead Not used Not used Not used Not used Not used Not used ? Not used ? ? Not used ?
Roadworks
[j]
?
or

or

or
? ?
Argentina Australia Brazil Canada Canada
(Ontario)
Canada
(Quebec)
Chile Colombia Indonesia Ireland Japan Malaysia Mexico New Zealand Panama Peru Philippines USA Uruguay

Regulatory

  República Argentina
Argentina
 
Commonwealth of Australia
Australia
 
República Federativa do Brasil
Brazil
 
Canada
Canada
 
Ontario
Canada -
Ontario
Québec
Canada -
Quebec
República de Chile
Chile
 
República de Colombia
Colombia
 
Republik Indonesia
Indonesia
 
Republic of Ireland
Ireland
 
日本国
Japan
 
Malaysia
Malaysia
 
Estados Unidos Mexicanos
Mexico
 
New Zealand
New Zealand
 
República de Panamá
Panama
 
República del Perú
Peru
 
Republic of the Philippines
Philippines
 
United States of America
United States
 
República Oriental del Uruguay
Uruguay
 
Stop
Yield / Give Way File:Canada - yield sign.svg File:Canada - yield sign.svg
or

or
Yield to oncoming traffic ? ? Not used Not used ? ? ? ? ?
No entry
or

or
File:Canada - do not enter.svg
or

or

or

or

or
Road closed ?
or
?
[j]

[j]
? ? ? ? ? ?
Argentina Australia Brazil Canada Canada
(Ontario)
Canada
(Quebec)
Chile Colombia Indonesia Ireland Japan Malaysia Mexico New Zealand Panama Peru Philippines USA Uruguay
No motor vehicles ?
or
? ?
No motorcycles ? Not used ?
No bicycles
No pedestrians
No heavy goods vehicles ? ?
Argentina Australia Brazil Canada Canada
(Ontario)
Canada
(Quebec)
Chile Colombia Indonesia Ireland Japan Malaysia Mexico New Zealand Panama Peru Philippines USA Uruguay
Maximum speed limit
(B.C., Yukon)

(rest of
Canada)
File:Ireland road sign RUS 043.svg
[k]
Minimum speed limit ? ? Not used Not used Not used ? Not used ? ?
[k]
?
Speed restriction ends ? Not used Not used Not used Not used Not used Not used Not used ? ? ?
Maximum height File:Australia R6-12.svg
Maximum width Not used Not used Not used Not used Not used
Maximum weight File:Australia R6-4.svg ?
Maximum weight per axle File:Australia R6-17.svg ? ? ? Not used ? ? ?
Argentina Australia Brazil Canada Canada
(Ontario)
Canada
(Quebec)
Chile Colombia Indonesia Ireland Japan Malaysia Mexico New Zealand Panama Peru Philippines USA Uruguay
No left turn File:Australia road sign R2-6-AS (L).svg
or
File:Australia road sign R2-6-RTA (L).svg
File:Canada - No Left Turn.svg Not used
[l]

or
No right turn File:Australia road sign R2-6-AS (R).svg
or
File:Australia road sign R2-6-RTA (R).svg
File:Canada - No Right Turn.svg Not used
[l]

or
No U-turn File:Australia road sign R2-5-AS.svg
or
File:Australia road sign R2-5-RTA.svg
File:Peru road sign R-10.svg
or
No parking
or
No stopping
No overtaking File:Canada - No Overtaking.svg ?
and

[m]

and

[m]

or

[m]
Argentina Australia Brazil Canada Canada
(Ontario)
Canada
(Quebec)
Chile Colombia Indonesia Ireland Japan Malaysia Mexico New Zealand Panama Peru Philippines USA Uruguay

Mandatory or permitted actions

  República Argentina
Argentina
 
Commonwealth of Australia
Australia
 
República Federativa do Brasil
Brazil
 
Canada
Canada
 
Ontario
Canada -
Ontario
Québec
Canada -
Quebec
República de Chile
Chile
 
República de Colombia
Colombia
 
Republik Indonesia
Indonesia
 
Republic of Ireland
Ireland
 
日本国
Japan
 
Malaysia
Malaysia
 
Estados Unidos Mexicanos
Mexico
 
New Zealand
New Zealand
 
República de Panamá
Panama
 
República del Perú
Peru
 
Republic of the Philippines
Philippines
 
United States of America
United States
 
República Oriental del Uruguay
Uruguay
 
Proceed
straight
(no turns)
File:Australia R2-7.svg Not used
[n]
Not used ?
or
Turn right
ahead
File:Australia R2-14 (R).svg Not used
[n]
Not used ?
or
Proceed
straight
or right
Not used Not used Not used Not used Not used ? Not used Not used Not used Not used
Turn right ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
Keep right
(or left)

or
Pass on
either side
Not used ?
Roundabout
entrance
Not used
or
Overtaking
permitted
[o]
File:Australia R6-29.svg File:Canada - Overtaking Permitted.svg

File:Ireland road sign P 010.svg

or
? ? ? Not used ?
Shared use path File:Australia R8-2.svg ? ? ? ? ? Not used ?
Bicycles only File:Australia R8-1.svg ? ?
Transit only ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
Argentina Australia Brazil Canada Canada
(Ontario)
Canada
(Quebec)
Chile Colombia Indonesia Ireland Japan Malaysia Mexico New Zealand Panama Peru Philippines USA Uruguay

Other (indication)

  República Argentina
Argentina
 
Commonwealth of Australia
Australia
 
República Federativa do Brasil
Brazil
 
Canada
Canada
 
Ontario
Canada -
Ontario
Québec
Canada -
Quebec
República de Chile
Chile
 
República de Colombia
Colombia
 
Republik Indonesia
Indonesia
 
Republic of Ireland
Ireland
 
日本国
Japan
 
Malaysia
Malaysia
 
Estados Unidos Mexicanos
Mexico
 
New Zealand
New Zealand
 
República de Panamá
Panama
 
República del Perú
Peru
 
Republic of the Philippines
Philippines
 
United States of America
United States
 
República Oriental del Uruguay
Uruguay
 
One-way
street
File:Australia R2-2 (L).svg ? Not used ?
Two-way
traffic
Not used Not used Not used Not used Not used
or
Not used
Freeway begins File:Australia R6-19.svg ? Not used Not used Not used ? Not used ?
or
?
Freeway ends File:Australia R6-21.svg ? ? ? ? ? Not used ? ? ?
Dead end File:Canada - Cul-de-sac (PEI).svg
or
? ? File:Ireland road sign F 350.svg Not used ? ? ?
Parking zone
or

or

or

or

or
Bus stop ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
Train station ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
Airport ? Not used ? ? ?
Hospital Not used ?
Customs
post
N/A
[p]
Not used Not used
Not used N/A
[p]
? N/A
[p]
? Not used
National
highway
shield(s)








File:N1 national IE.png









Argentina Australia Brazil Canada Canada
(Ontario)
Canada
(Quebec)
Chile Colombia Indonesia Ireland Japan Malaysia Mexico New Zealand Panama Peru Philippines USA Uruguay

See also

Notes

  1. ^ Compare Bicycles Only (Ciclovia) sign in Brazil: with No Bicycles (Verbot für Radfahrer) sign in Germany:
  2. ^ In the US, "roundabout" and "traffic circle" are used interchangeably, along with "rotary". See Roundabout terminology.
  3. ^ a b c d e f g No distinction between controlled and uncontrolled railroad crossings is made.
  4. ^ a b c d e f g There are no operating tram or streetcar systems in this jurisdiction.
  5. ^ Used in California only. Shared grade tram or streetcar crossings are typically unsigned in other jurisdictions.
  6. ^ a b c Text is superseded by graphic of tracks - red for CN-owned tracks, black for CP-owned tracks.
  7. ^ a b Text varies.
  8. ^ Not in use for road vehicles
  9. ^ Off-road tracks only
  10. ^ a b c d e f g h i j Temporary use only.
  11. ^ a b The metric version of the sign is not in general use—it is included to show the use of the more internationally recognized circle used in speed limit signs. One example of use is on the Sault Ste. Marie International Bridge, north of the Canada–US border but south of Canada Customs.
  12. ^ a b Japan only uses mandatory signs to indicate movement:
  13. ^ a b c Pennant signs are placed facing traffic in the passing lane, i.e. on the left side of the road for right-hand driving countries. They are used in conjunction with standard-shaped signs placed facing traffic in the travel lane, i.e. on the right side of the road.
  14. ^ a b Ontario only uses prohibitory signs to indicate movement:
  15. ^ In many jurisdictions, "Overtaking Permitted" is indicated solely through a change in road markings, e.g. a solid center line changing to a dashed center line. In such jurisdictions, signs in this category are only posted in locations where a change in road markings is deemed insufficient notice for drivers. This is in contrast to "No Overtaking" signs, which are almost always posted alongside changes in road markings to indicate the end of an overtaking zone.
  16. ^ a b c This country has no land borders.

References