Symphony No. 29 (Haydn)
The work is in four movements:
In the slow movement, the melody is passed back and forth between the first and second violin parts.
The trio of the Minuet has an "oompah accompaniment in the strings" and horns sustaining Es in octaves, but apparently no melody. The harpsichordist would have to provide a melody, but "no keyboard player has dared to provide such a thing for a quarter of a century" between Loibner's recording and the writing of Hodgson's book. H. C. Robbins Landon also notes the "weird atmosphere" and lack of melody, but says it has a "sombre and secretive beauty" and has a "strongly Balkan" character due to an E minor to B minor modulation.
In the LP era, neither Antal Doráti with the Philharmonia Hungarica nor Leslie Jones with the Little Orchestra of London provide a tune for the trio of the Minuet. Loibner has the Vienna Academy Chamber Orchestra's harpsichordist Christa Fuhrmann give "the outline of a melody—a convincing example of improvisation which suits the music well."
Moving on to the CD era, on Naxos Records, Nicholas Ward and the Northern Chamber Orchestra pair No. 29 with Nos. 22 and 60. Ward's recording has no tune in the trio of the minuet. Neither has that of Adam Fischer conducting the Austro-Hungarian Haydn Orchestra in Haydn's complete symphonies . The recording by Christopher Hogwood conducting the Academy of Ancient Music also omits a harpsichord melody in the third movement. 
- Antony Hodgson, The Music of Joseph Haydn: The Symphonies. London: The Tantivy Press (1976): 202. The chart places "29" in boldface in the year 1765, indicating an autograph score survives.
- Brown, A. Peter, The Symphonic Repertoire (Volume 2). Indiana University Press (ISBN 025333487X), pp. 96–99 (2002).
- Hodgson, 1976: 65–66
- Hodgson, 1976: 66
- HC Robbins Landon, Haydn: Chronicle and Works, 5 vols., (Bloomington and London: Indiana University Press, 1976–) v. 1, Haydn: the Early Years, 1732-1765
- Hodgson, 1976: 172
- Haydn: Complete Symphonies, Brilliant Classics, Adam Fischer, Austro-Hungarian Haydn Orchestra
- Joseph Haydn: Symphonies volume 4, Polygram Records, Christopher Hogwood, The Academy of Ancient Music
|This article about a symphony is a stub. You can help Wikipedia by expanding it.|