Why We Can't Wait
Why We Can't Wait is a book by Martin Luther King, Jr. about the nonviolent movement against racial segregation in the United States, and specifically the 1963 Birmingham campaign. The book describes 1963 as a landmark year in the Civil Rights Movement, and as the beginning of America's "Negro Revolution".
The seed of the book is King's "Letter from Birmingham Jail". The letter became nationally known and received interest from the New York publishing world, which Stanley Levison relayed to King in May 1963. Soon after, Levison made a deal with New American Library publisher Victor Weybright, who suggested that the theme of not waiting be used for the title. Weybright also gave permission for "Letter from Birmingham Jail" to be republished in national newspapers and magazines; it appeared in July 1963 as "Why the Negro Won't Wait".
King began working on the book later in 1963, with assistance from Levison and Clarence Jones. Some early work on the text was done by Al Duckett (also a participant in the movement). King and Levison eventually dismissed Duckett and then Nat Lamar, and Levison did some work on the text himself. Bayard Rustin also contributed, as did editor Hermine I. Popper.
Rustin said: "I don't want to write something for somebody where I know he is acting like a puppet. I want to be a real ghost and write what the person wants to say. And that is what I always knew was true in the case of Martin. I would never write anything that wasn't what he wanted to say. I understood him well enough."
The book largely reproduces the text of "Letter from Birmingham Jail", with some editorial changes. King writes in a footnote: "Although the text remains in substance unaltered, I have indulged in the author's prerogative in polishing it for publication."
Why We Can't Wait was published by Harper & Row in July 1964. The paperback edition cost 60¢.
The book describes 1963 as the beginning of "the Negro revolution". It seeks to describe the historical events that led up to this revolution, and to explain why this revolution was non-violent. King seeks to describe this history because of how quickly it has become visible to America at large, and because of its importance in events to come. He writes:
Just as lightning makes no sound until it strikes, the Negro Revolution generated quietly. But when it struck, the revealing flash of its power and the impact of its sincerity and fervor displayed a force of a frightening intensity. Three hundred years of humiliation, abuse, and deprivation cannot be expected to find voice in a whisper. [...]
Because there is more to come; because American society is bewildered by the spectacle of the Negro in revolt; because the dimensions are vast and the implications deep in a nation with twenty million Negroes, it is important to understand the history that is being made today.
King gives several reasons why the Negro Revolution erupted in 1963:
- Disillusionment with the slow speed of school desegregation after Brown v. Board (1954).
- Lack of confidence in politicians and government, particularly after the perceived failures of the Kennedy administration. These included a weak stance on housing discrimination and a lack of support for Black voting rights in the South.
- Decolonization of Africa (and of Asia), and the international perception of the American Negro as downtrodden and powerless. (See also: Year of Africa.)
- The centennial of the 1863 Emancipation Proclamation reminded Blacks that they remained oppressed in spite of their nominal legal freedom.
- The Great Depression never ended for African Americans; while others enjoyed an economic recovery, Black unemployment rose. King says that economic inequality in America became particularly obvious in 1963.
- The rise to prominence of nonviolent direct action as a means for demanding change.
King goes on to describe why nonviolent resistance was so powerful. One of its major strengths involved changing the function of jails in society. Previously, jail was used as an element of intimidation: authorities used the threat of pain and isolation in jail to control many separate individuals. Large groups of demonstrators, however, had the power to fill up jails—and to politicize the act of being jailed, thereby making jail less of a punishment. He condemns tokenism as an act of deception that offers false pride without real power: "The Negro wanted to feel pride in his race? With tokenism, the solution was simple. If all twenty million Negroes would keep looking at Ralph Bunche, the one man in so exalted a post would generate such a volume of pride that it could be cut into portions and served to everyone." King distinguishes between tokenism and a "modest start" to equality, writing that tokenism serves to stifle dissent and protest, not to start a process.
He criticizes other approaches to social change for Blacks, including the quietism of Booker T. Washington, the elitism of W. E. B. Du Bois's appeal to The Talented Tenth, the Pan-Africanism of Marcus Garvey, and the litigation of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP). King argues that none of these leaders and philosophies held the promise of real mass change for all African Americans.
King describes "Bull Connor's Birmingham" as an anachronistic city whose social order resembled colonial-era slavery. He writes that Blacks lack basic human rights, and are ruled by violence and terror.
He chronicles preliminary demonstrations held by the Alabama Christian Movement for Human Rights (ACHR) and then describes Bull Connor's attempts to intimidate the SCLC. He tells about how the SCLC nevertheless planned the Birmingham campaign, believing that if segregation could be overcome in Birmingham it could have effects across the entire United States.
King describes the alliance between the SCLC and the ACHR, and reproduces the text of a "Commitment Card" used for recruiting. (Volunteers who signed the card pledged to meditate on the life of Jesus, pray daily, observe the interests of the community, and to seek "justice and reconciliation—not victory".) He tells the story of how he was imprisoned in the course of demonstrations and then reproduces his (already and thereafter) famous "Letter from Birmingham Jail".
The city government became increasingly willing to negotiate as demonstrations continued. King describes mass participation by young people, full jails, and international media attention fueled by powerful photographs. Negotiators reached an agreement on Friday, May 10, 1963: the city promised desegregation within 90 days, jobs for Blacks in local industry, release of those jailed during the campaign, and ongoing formal diplomacy between Black and White leaders.
The agreement triggered an assassination attempt on King, orchestrated by the local Ku Klux Klan. The bombing at King's hotel room triggered a civil disturbance in Birmingham which brought in the police forces and then the National Guard.
Thousands of student demonstrators were expelled from school by the Birmingham Board of Education. The decision was challenged by the NAACP and overruled by Judge Elbert P. Tuttle in the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals.
King advocates continued action in Birmingham, comparing the campaign to the Battle of Bunker Hill—the beginning of organization in a revolutionary army. He warns against complacency in the wake of the Birmingham demonstrations, suggesting that revolt is only the beginning of revolution.
He calls for multi-racial unity, suggesting that Africans were not the only group oppressed in America: "Our nation was born in genocide when it embraced the doctrine that the original American, the Indian, was an inferior race. Even before there were large numbers of Negroes on our shores, the scar of racial hatred had already disfigured colonial society." He argues that the summer of 1963 has made most Whites in America more receptive to the idea of legal equality for Blacks.
He describes the August 1963 March on Washington for Jobs and Freedom, praising the participation of White churches but frustrated by the neutrality of the AFL–CIO. He notes that millions of Americans watched scenes from the March on television and expresses hope for the future of this medium.
The conclusion provides an explanation of "why we can't wait": that Blacks must no longer move towards freedom, but assert their freedom. King writes: "It is because the Negro knows that no person—as well as no nation—can truly exist half slave and half free that he has embroiders upon his banners the significant word now." He calls for a Bill of Rights for the Disadvantaged, including reparations for unpaid wages. He holds out hope for a coalition with poor Whites and organized labor. He suggests that the civil rights movement may be able to work with President Lyndon Johnson, cautioning that political work is dangerous but necessary. He ends by saying that if the civil rights revolution succeeds it may spread nonviolence worldwide, ending the nuclear arms race and bringing world peace.
Reception and effect
Why We Can't Wait was an important part of the effort to make the civil rights struggle known to national and international audiences. Describing Birmingham as "the most segregated city in America" transformed it into a symbol for segregation and inequality at large.
The book has received much contemporary critical acclaim, and was ranked #78 on Modern Library's list of the 100 best non-fiction books written in English.
- Branch, Parting the Waters (1989), p. 804.
- Bass, Blessed Are The Peacemakers (2002), p. 144.
- "Why We Can't Wait", Encyclopedia (Martin Luther King, Jr., Research and Education Institute), accessed 14 November 2012.
- Mieder, Making a Way Out of No Way (2010), p. 21. "Al Duckett, another ghostwriter, was involved in preparing the manuscript of King's third book Why We Can't Wait (1964), and while Rustin had asked not to be acknowledged for his labor, Duckett's help is mentioned by King before the introduction to the book. (Garrow 1986: 280 and 299)."
- Branch, Parting the Waters (1989), p. 910.
- Garrow, Bearing the Cross (1986), p. 649; quoted in Mieder "Making a Way Out of No Way" (2010), p. 22.
- Bass, Blessed Are The Peacemakers (2002), p. 136–137.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), p. 76.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 15–18. "Why did a thousand cities shudder almost simultaneously and why did the whole world—in gleaming capitals and mud-hut villages—hold its breath during those months? Why was it the year that the American Negro, so long ignored, so long written out of the pages of history books, tramped a declaration of freedom with his marching feet across the pages of newspapers, the television screens, and the magazines?"
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), p. 16.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 18–19. "In order, then, to understand the deep disillusion of the Negro in 1963, one must examine his contrasting emotions at the time of the decision and during the nine years that followed. One must understand the pendulum swing between the elation that arose when the edict was handed down and the despair that followed the failure to bring it to life."
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 19–21. "The Negro felt that he recognized the same old bone that had been tossed to him in the past—only now it was being handed to him on a platter."
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 21–22.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 22–25. "In 1963, the Negro, who had realized for many years that he was not truly free, awoke from a stupor of inaction with the cold dash of realization that 1963 meant one hundred years after Lincoln gave his autograph to the cause of freedom."
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 23–24.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 25–26. "Tested in Montgomery during the winter of 1955–56, and toughened throughout the South in the eight ensuing years, nonviolent resistance has become, by 1963, the logical force in the greatest mass-action crusade that has ever occurred in American history."
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 27–30.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 30–31.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 31–32.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 33–34.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 47–50.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 51–52.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), p. 53.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 54–58.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 59–64.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 65–75.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 76–95.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 96–106.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 106–107.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 107–108.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 113–117.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 119–120.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 121–122. "The summer of our discontent, far from alienating America's white citizens, brought them closer into harmony with its Negro citizens than ever before."
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 123–125.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 123–129.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 137–138.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 141–142.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), pp. 146–151.
- King, Why We Can't Wait (1964), p. 152. "In measuring the full implications of the civil-rights revolution, the greatest contribution may be in the area of world peace."
- Garrow, Bearing the Cross (1986), p. 325.
- Davi Johnson, "Martin Luther King Jr.'s 1963 Birmingham Campaign as Image Event", Rhetoric & Public Affairs 10(1), Spring 2007, accessed via Project Muse.
- "Why We Can't Wait: Some inspiration from Martin Luther King, Jr. for Occupy Wall Street", Adbusters 96, 13 September 2011.
- George Pyle, "Obama, like King, should know why we can't wait", Salt Lake Tribune, 5 November 2011.
- Bass, S. Jonathan (2002). Blessed Are The Peacemakers: Martin Luther King Jr., Eight White Religious Leaders, and the "Letter from Birmingham Jail". Louisiana State University Press. ISBN 9780807128008
- Branch, Taylor (1989). Parting the Waters (America in the King Years). New York: Simon & Schuster. ISBN 9780671687427
- Garrow, David (1986). Bearing the Cross: Martin Luther King, Jr., and the Southern Christian Leadership Conference. William Morrow and Company. ISBN 0-688-04794-7
- King, Martin Luther, Jr (1964). Why We Can't Wait. New York: New American Library (Harper & Row). ISBN 0451527534
- Mieder, Wolfgang (2010). "Making a Way Out of No Way": Martin Luther King's Sermonic Proverbial Rhetoric. New York: Peter Lang. ISBN 9781433113031
- Why We Can't Wait on Google Books
- Quotations and video relating to Fred Shuttlesworth and Why We Can't Wait
Resources from The King Center
- Scan of a hand-edited draft of the introduction
- Scan of a hand-edited outline of the book's central photographs
- Publication notice in Publisher's Weekly, 25 May 1964
- Advertisement in the Christian Herald, June 1964
- and more resources relating to Why We Can't Wait
- Olsen, Douglas. Why We Can't Wait. Counter-Currents, 2 January 2011.
- Samad, Anthony Assadulah. "The 'Promised Land': Why We're Still Waiting". Black Commentator 166, 12 January 2006.
- Wharton, Billy. "Why We Can’t Wait: Reading Dr. King in the Age of Obama". Dissident Voice, 18 January 2010.