The 2016 Buffalo Bills season was the franchise’s 57th overall season as a football team, 47th in the National Football League, fourth under leadership of general manager Doug Whaley and second under head coachRex Ryan. The Bills hoped to improve on their 8-8 record from 2015, the team’s first since 2002, but a 34-31 overtime loss to the Miami Dolphins in Week 16 eliminated the Bills from playoff contention for a 17th-straight season, extending the longest active drought among all four North American major professional sports leagues. It would be Rex’s final season as head coach of the Bills, as he and his twin brother, Rob, were fired with one game remaining in the regular season.[1]
The Bills traded their 2016 seventh-round selection (240th overall), later revealed to be Alex McCalister, along with their 2015 fifth-round selection (137th overall), later revealed to be Grady Jarrett, to the Minnesota Vikings in exchange for quarterbackMatt Cassel and the Vikings’ 2015 sixth-round selection (188th overall), later revealed to be Tony Steward. The Bills traded their 2016 second-round pick (49th overall) and fourth-round pick (117th overall), later revealed to be Jarran Reed and Pharoh Cooper, respectively, to the Chicago Bears in return for Chicago’s 2016 second-round pick (41st overall), later revealed to be Reggie Ragland.
On January 10, 2016, one week after the 2015 season ended, Doug Whaley signed a three-year contract extension to remain the Bills general manager. That same day, it was announced that Rex had hired his twin brother, Rob, to the Bills coaching staff to serve as an assistant head coach and will also work with the defense. Three days later, Ryan hired former NFL standout Ed Reed to be an assistant defensive backs coach. On January 20, 2016, the Bills promoted Kathryn Smith to special teams quality control coach, making her the first female full-time coach in NFL history. On September 16, 2016, less than 24 hours after losing 37-31 to the New York Jets in their home opener in a game in which the defense failed to stop Jets running back Matt Forte, instead of firing defensive coordinator Dennis Thurman, Ryan pretty much sealed his own fate by firing offensive coordinator Greg Roman and promoting running backs coach Anthony Lynn to the position (Lynn would later be promoted to interim head coach on December 27, 2016 after the Ryan brothers were fired after the 34-31 overtime loss to the Dolphins eliminated the team from the playoffs).[33]
Tyrod Taylor made his first return to Baltimore since signing with the Bills in the 2014-2015 offseason after Kyle Orton retired. Sadly, despite LeSean McCoy’s 1-yard run in the second quarter, the Bills couldn’t muster any serious offense and thus opened the season at 0-1.
The Bills saw the return of their red Color Rush uniforms from 2015 in this game. Sadly, with the loss, not only did the Bills drop to 0-2 in their first regular season game since Ralph Wilson Stadium became New Era Field during the summer, but instead of firing defensive coordinator Dennis Thurman (since it was the defense failing to stop running back Matt Forte from rushing for 100 yards and three touchdowns), head coach Rex Ryan decided to fire offensive coordinator Greg Roman instead, promoting running backs coach Anthony Lynn to offensive coordinator the next day. As if the loss wasn’t bad enough, the team also lost wide receiver Greg Salas for the season to a groin injury and Sammy Watkins for several weeks to a foot injury.
With the win, the Bills improved to 1-2 in Lynn’s first game as offensive coordinator and Rex’s job is not in as much jeopardy as it would have been had the team lost.
With the win, not only did the Bills improve to 2-2, but Ryan got his first career victory at Gillette Stadium (he was 0-7 as head coach coming in, including six straight losses as New York Jets head coach from 2009-2014).
With the win, the Bills improved to 3-2 and their first three-game winning streak since 2011 (the team started that season 3-0 before ultimately losing nine of their final 12 games).
With the win, the Bills improved to 4-2 and their first four-game winning streak since 2008 (the team started that season 4-0 in Dick Jauron’s last full season as head coach before ultimately losing nine of their final 12 games).
The Bills led 17-6 with 5:51 remaining in the third quarter, but running back Jay Ajayi’s 204-yard rushing game proved to be the difference as the Dolphins outscored them 22-8 after that, dropping the Bills to 4-3. As if the loss wasn’t bad enough, the team also lost safety Aaron Williams for the season with a neck injury sustained after a hit from Dolphins wide receiver Jarvis Landry.
Chris Hogan made his first return to Buffalo since signing with the Patriots in the offseason to catch the second of quarterback Tom Brady’s four touchdown passes, proving that not even Deflategate can slow Brady down, dropping the Bills to 4-4.
Tight end Jimmy Graham’s two touchdown catches proved to be the difference as the Seahawks dropped the Bills to 4-5 heading into the bye week. As if the loss wasn’t bad enough, they also lost center Eric Wood for the season to a leg injury.
[52][53]
With the win, the Bills improved to 5-5, but it came at a price when running back LeSean McCoy, wide receiver Robert Woods and safety Robert Blanton all left the game with injuries.
With the win, the Bills improved to 6-5, but it came at a devastating price when they lost defensive tackle Corbin Bryant and wide receiver Walt Powell for the season with a shoulder and ankle injury, respectively.
The Bills led 24-9 just 5:59 into the third quarter, but the Raiders outscored them 29-0 after that, including a pair of 1-yard touchdown runs from Latavius Murray to drop the Bills to 6-6.
Week 14: vs. Pittsburgh Steelers
Week Fourteen: Pittsburgh Steelers at Buffalo Bills
Period
1
2
3
4
Total
Steelers
7
7
7
6
27
Bills
0
7
0
13
20
at New Era Field, Orchard Park, New York
Date: December 11
Game time: 1:00pm ET
Game weather: 27 °F (−3 °C), snow showers
Game attendance: 69,657
Referee: Pete Morelli
TV announcers (CBS): Jim Nantz, Phil Simms and Tracy Wolfson
For the second time this season, the Bills’ defense gets owned for three touchdowns, as Le’Veon Bell carried the ball—and his team, for that matter—for 298 total yards, 236 of which on the ground, dropping the Bills to 6-7 heading into the most important game of the season, a matchup with the still-winless Cleveland Browns the following week.
With the win, not only did the Bills improve to 7-7 and keep their slim playoff chances alive, but they set a new franchise record for rushing touchdowns in a season (27) with running back LeSean McCoy’s second rushing touchdown of the game, an 8-yarder in the fourth quarter.
After the Bills took the lead with an 18-yard touchdown catch by Charles Clay with 1:20 remaining, the Dolphins took the game to overtime with a 55-yard field goal by kicker Andrew Franks with 0:06 remaining, then secured the win with 0:47 left in the extra period with a second field goal, this one from 27 yards out. With the loss, not only did the Bills drop to 7-8, but for the second time in three seasons, they were also eliminated from playoff contention with one game remaining (they were eliminated from playoff contention in 2014 with a 26-24 loss to the Oakland Raiders in Week 16). Three days later, the Rex and Rob experiment in Buffalo was over after nearly two seasons as the team fired the Ryan brothers and promoted Lynn to interim head coach for the season finale.
Lynn served as interim head coach and EJ Manuel made his only start of the season in what would later become his final game with the team. Sadly, with the loss, the Bills closed out the season at 7-9 for the first time since 2008 (the team started that season 5-1 before ultimately losing eight of their final ten games).
^ abKansas City clinched the AFC West division over Oakland based on head-to-head sweep.
^ abHouston clinched the AFC South division title over Tennessee based on record vs. division opponents.
^ abTennessee finished ahead of Denver based on head-to-head victory.
^ abBaltimore finished ahead of Indianapolis based on record vs. conference opponents.
^ abThe New York Jets finished ahead of San Diego based record vs. common opponents — the Jets' cumulative record against Cleveland, Indianapolis, Kansas City and Miami was 1–4, while San Diego's cumulative record against the same four teams was 0–5.
^When breaking ties for three or more teams under the NFL's rules, they are first broken within divisions, then comparing only the highest ranked remaining team from each division.