Wikipedia:WikiProject Stub sorting/Proposals/Archive/December 2006

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

This is an archive of discussions from Wikipedia:WikiProject Stub sorting/Proposals for the month of December 2006. Please move completed December discussions to this page as they occur, add discussion headers to each proposal showing the result, and leave incomplete discussions on the Proposals page. After December, the remainder of the discussions will be moved to this page, whether stub types have been created or not.

Those who create a stub template/cat should be responsible for moving the discussion here and listing the stub type in the archive summary.

Stub proposers please note: Items tagged as "nocreate" or "no consensus" are welcome for re-proposal if and when circumstances are auspicious.

Contents

Vojvodina stubs

Category:Canadian non-fiction writer stubs

Olympic Year Stubs

Category:Architectural history stubs

Record label stubs by country

{{mmo-stub}}


More Asian -bios

Category:Currency unit stubs - {{money-unit-stub}}

Category:Japanese nobility stubs

Category:Italian nobility stubs

Category:Zhejiang geography stubs

Category:Airport stubs

Poet stubs

Korea university stubs

Category:Ceramics stubs – clearer ordering needed

California county geo stub categories

Album Project:Proposed {{alt-country-album-stub}}

Redundant Hong Kong geography stubs

Change wikipedia-stub to wiki-stub

Somalian and other African -bios (templates only)

University of Minnesota

Drum and Bass Stub Proposals

{{cartridge-stub}}

{{US-state-gov-stub}} / Category:State government of the United States stubs

{{Oregon-gov-stub}}

{{Pakistan-university-stub}}

SaintPetersburg-stub

{{Africa-footy-bio-stub}} split(templates only for now)

Catholic-Encyclopedia-stub

A few more country-geo-stubs (templates only)

Possible Star Trek split?


Amusement park stubs

{{Texas-airport-stub}}

{{Malaysia-rail-stub}}

{{Mech-eng-stub}} / Category:Mechanical engineering stubs

Singapore law stub

{{fly-stub}} (Category:Diptera stubs) and {{bug-stub}} (Category:Hemiptera stubs)

{{child-novel-stub}} / Category:Children's novel stubs

Category:Japanese martial arts biography stubs

{{Nicaragua-bio-stub}} / Category:Nicaraguan people stubs

Hungary-geo-stub split

New football bios

Category:US Marine Corps Personnel

Canada-footy-bio-stub

Various novel stubs

Category:Portuguese sports venue stubs

Category:Lake Macquarie geography stubs

Category:Lunar geological feature stubs or Category:Lunar crater stubs

{{Marsu-stub}} | Category:Marsupial stubs

1970 and prior MLB pitchers

{{US-gov-bio-stub}}

Energy stubs:Proposed United states naval reactors stub

Asian American WikiProject stubs

{{Medal-stub}}, Category:Orders and medals stubs

===Asian American WikiProject stubs===

{{Medal-stub}}, Category:Orders and medals stubs

{{Africa-artist-stub}}/Cat:African artist stubs


Another NZ-geo subcat

New Films By Country stub needed in (2.2.5.3 By Country): {{South-Africa-film-stub}} (South African Films)

Category:Tanzanian politician stubs

Category:European rapid transit stubs

Dutch actor stubs

New Mexico Broadcasting stubs

Major breakdown on Military personnel stubs

This category is definitely undersorted, however, it is near 800. Currently, no continents have their individual stubs and for this reason, I am proposing {{Africa-mil-bio-stub}}, {{Euro-mil-bio-stub}}, {{Asia-mil-bio-stub}}, {{NorthAm-mil-bio-stub}}, {{SouthAm-mil-bio-stub}} and their corresponding categories.--Thomas.macmillan 03:33, 9 December 2006 (UTC)

  • Unsorted, and uncategorised too; only 322 are in a "by nationality" category. (One of these days I'm going to create and populate a "people without a nationality category" maint-cat, and it'll be a doozy...) So pending that, your plan seems a good one. Alai 03:55, 9 December 2006 (UTC)
  • Don't forget {{Oceania-mil-bio-stub}}, even if only as an upmerged template! :) Grutness...wha? 05:02, 9 December 2006 (UTC)
    • And NorhtAm-mil-bio-stub might not be a great idea, since the US and Canada each already have their own mil-bio-stubs.--Carabinieri 08:39, 10 December 2006 (UTC)
    • I think, if we include the Caribbean and Central America in it, it can be useful. Perhaps we can just upmerge it at first.--Thomas.macmillan 16:53, 10 December 2006 (UTC)
      • This is kind of related to this subject. I recently just went through and created pages for most of the Army and Air Force Korean War Medal of Honor recipients (Navy and Marines had already been done), and I've noticed that under "United States military personnel stubs" there is a "United States Air Force personnel stubs", "United States Coast Guard personnel stubs" and "United States Navy personnel stubs". The Army folks are all categorized under the parent stub, and I think it might be better 'categorization' to to break them out under their own stub, "Category:United States Army personnel stubs".wbfergus 13:43, 12 December 2006 (UTC)
        • A bit late but while looking through some of the archives it appears that Euro- and Asia- have already been approved (Archive 26 if anyone is interested) so can probably be speedied. Waacstats 22:49, 12 December 2006 (UTC)
          • WB, actually that's already been proposed, here; I've just been goldbricking on actually doing it, as it's slipped off the "oversized and urgent" list. (There was also some discussion on how many subcats, and what they should be called.) So feel free to go ahead... Alai 04:34, 13 December 2006 (UTC)

{{Sikh-bio-stub}}, Category:Sikh people stubs

various novel stubs

{{Insectivora-stub}}, Category:Insectivore stubs

{{terrorist-stub}} → Category:Terrorist stubs, {{terrorism-stub}} / {{terrorism-org-stub}} → Category:Terrorism stubs

{{sport-event-stub}} / Category:Sports event stubs

{{US-rail-bridge-struct-stub}}

Category:Wellington Region geography stubs

Category:film festival stubs


{{Netherlands-sport-bio-stub}} / Category:Dutch sportspeople stubs

{{NewYork-road-stub}} / Category:New York road stubs

Further Olympics subcats

Category:Russian sports venue stubs

Category:Haitian painter stubs

Category:United States fiction writer stubs

Category:Chinese royalty stubs

Category:Haitian writer stubs

Category:English politician stubs

New athletics bios

Record labels by... continent?

{{Canada-comedian-stub}} / Category:Canadian comedian stubs

{{Liberal-UK-MP-stub}}

{{Sudan-ethno-group-stub}} / Category:Sudanese ethnicity stubs / {{Kenya-ethno-group-stub}} / {{Ethiopia-ethno-group-stub}}

{{DeStijlMovement}}

Category:South West England school stubs

{{Zimbabwe-bio-stub}} and corresponding category

Category:Fann Wong film stubs

{{Zambia-bio-stub}} / Category:Zambian people stubs

Category:Television network stubs

{{Computer-Video-Game-Character-Stub}} / Cat:Computer Video Game Stubs