Illyrians: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
Undid revision 497443756 by Alexikoua (talk) Robert Elsie, and all foreign expert including the Academy of Sciences of Albania.
no scholarly consensus on this
Line 5: Line 5:
These tribes, or at least a [[List of Illyrian tribes|number of tribes]] considered "Illyrians proper", are assumed to have been united by a common [[Illyrian language]],<ref>{{harvnb|Bideleux|Jeffries|2007|loc="Albania", p. 24}}.</ref> of which only small fragments are attested enough to classify it as a branch of [[Indo-European languages|Indo-European]], while it was extinct by the 5th century AD.<ref>[http://linguistlist.org/forms/langs/LLDescription.cfm?code=xil Eastern Michigan University Linguist List: The Illyrian Language]: "An ancient language of the Balkans. Based upon geographical proximity, this is traditionally seen as the ancestor of Modern Albanian. It is more likely, however, that Thracian is Modern Albanian's ancestor, since both Albanian and Thracian belong to the satem group of Indo-European, while Illyrian belonged to the centum group. 2nd half of 1st Millennium BC - 1st half of 1st Millennium AD."</ref> However, the name "Illyrians" as applied by the ancient [[Greek people|Greeks]] to their northern neighbors may have referred to a broad, ill-defined group of peoples, and it is today unclear to what extent they were linguistically and culturally homogeneous. In fact, an Illyric origin was and still is attributed also to a few ancient peoples in Italy, in particular the [[Iapyges]], [[Dauni]] and [[Messapi]], as it is thought that, most likely, they had shored to the Peninsula, coming from the geographic "Illyria". The Illyrian tribes never collectively regarded themselves as 'Illyrians', and it is unlikely that they used any collective nomenclature for themselves.<ref name=Roisman/> However, the name ''Illyrians'' seems to be the name of a specific Illyrian tribe, which was the first to come in contact with the ancient Greeks during the [[Bronze Age]],<ref name=Boardman629>{{harvnb|Boardman|1982|p=629}}.</ref> causing the name Illyrians to be applied to all people of similar language and customs.<ref name="Wilkes 1995 92"/>
These tribes, or at least a [[List of Illyrian tribes|number of tribes]] considered "Illyrians proper", are assumed to have been united by a common [[Illyrian language]],<ref>{{harvnb|Bideleux|Jeffries|2007|loc="Albania", p. 24}}.</ref> of which only small fragments are attested enough to classify it as a branch of [[Indo-European languages|Indo-European]], while it was extinct by the 5th century AD.<ref>[http://linguistlist.org/forms/langs/LLDescription.cfm?code=xil Eastern Michigan University Linguist List: The Illyrian Language]: "An ancient language of the Balkans. Based upon geographical proximity, this is traditionally seen as the ancestor of Modern Albanian. It is more likely, however, that Thracian is Modern Albanian's ancestor, since both Albanian and Thracian belong to the satem group of Indo-European, while Illyrian belonged to the centum group. 2nd half of 1st Millennium BC - 1st half of 1st Millennium AD."</ref> However, the name "Illyrians" as applied by the ancient [[Greek people|Greeks]] to their northern neighbors may have referred to a broad, ill-defined group of peoples, and it is today unclear to what extent they were linguistically and culturally homogeneous. In fact, an Illyric origin was and still is attributed also to a few ancient peoples in Italy, in particular the [[Iapyges]], [[Dauni]] and [[Messapi]], as it is thought that, most likely, they had shored to the Peninsula, coming from the geographic "Illyria". The Illyrian tribes never collectively regarded themselves as 'Illyrians', and it is unlikely that they used any collective nomenclature for themselves.<ref name=Roisman/> However, the name ''Illyrians'' seems to be the name of a specific Illyrian tribe, which was the first to come in contact with the ancient Greeks during the [[Bronze Age]],<ref name=Boardman629>{{harvnb|Boardman|1982|p=629}}.</ref> causing the name Illyrians to be applied to all people of similar language and customs.<ref name="Wilkes 1995 92"/>


The term "Illyrians" last appears in the historical record in the 7th century AD, referring to a Byzantine garrison operating within the former province.<ref name="Schaefer2008">{{harvnb|Schaefer|2008|p=130}}.</ref> All the remaining tribes except perhaps the Romanized [[Vlachs]]<ref name="Bowden 2003 211">{{harvnb|Bowden|2003|p=211}}; {{harvnb|Kazhdan|1991|p=248}}.</ref> were [[Slavicisation|Slavicised]] in the course of the [[Middle Ages]], while modern [[Albanian language|Albanian]] is descended from a southern Illyrian dialect.<ref>{{harvnb|Ceka|2005|pages=40–42, 59}}.</ref><ref>{{cite web|title=Albania|publisher=Encyclopædia Britannica|url=http://www.britannica.com/eb/article-42640/Albania#476150.hook|accessdate=30 September 2005|location=London}} According to alternative hypotheses, the Albanians may be descendants of [[Thracians]] or more specifically [[Dacians]]; cf. {{cite journal|first=Vladimir|last=Georgiev|title=Albanisch, Dakisch-Mysisch und Rumänisch|journal=Linguistique balkanique|year=1960|volume=2|pages=1–19}}, and {{cite book|first=Gottfried|last=Schramm|title=Anfänge des albanischen Christentums: Die frühe Bekehrung der Bessen und ihre langen Folgen|place=Freiburg|year=1994}}</ref>
The term "Illyrians" last appears in the historical record in the 7th century AD, referring to a Byzantine garrison operating within the former province.<ref name="Schaefer2008">{{harvnb|Schaefer|2008|p=130}}.</ref> All the remaining tribes except perhaps the Romanized [[Vlachs]]<ref name="Bowden 2003 211">{{harvnb|Bowden|2003|p=211}}; {{harvnb|Kazhdan|1991|p=248}}.</ref> were [[Slavicisation|Slavicised]] in the course of the [[Middle Ages]], while modern [[Albanian language|Albanian]] might have descended from a southern Illyrian dialect.<ref>{{harvnb|Ceka|2005|pages=40–42, 59}}.</ref><ref>{{cite web|title=Albania|publisher=Encyclopædia Britannica|url=http://www.britannica.com/eb/article-42640/Albania#476150.hook|accessdate=30 September 2005|location=London}} According to alternative hypotheses, the Albanians may be descendants of [[Thracians]] or more specifically [[Dacians]]; cf. {{cite journal|first=Vladimir|last=Georgiev|title=Albanisch, Dakisch-Mysisch und Rumänisch|journal=Linguistique balkanique|year=1960|volume=2|pages=1–19}}, and {{cite book|first=Gottfried|last=Schramm|title=Anfänge des albanischen Christentums: Die frühe Bekehrung der Bessen und ihre langen Folgen|place=Freiburg|year=1994}}</ref>


==Illyrians in Greek mythology==
==Illyrians in Greek mythology==

Revision as of 18:04, 14 June 2012

File:HallstattIllyrianCeltic.jpg
Hallstatt culture depiction of Illyrian warriors: reproduction of the bronze Vače belt-plate found in Vače, Slovenia, and dated to the 5th century BC.

The Illyrians (/ɪˈlɪəriəns/; Ancient Greek: Ἰλλυριοί; Latin: Illyrii or Illyri) were a group of tribes who inhabited part of the western Balkans in antiquity and the south-eastern coasts of the Italian peninsula (Messapia).[1] The territory the Illyrians covered came to be known as Illyria to Greek and Roman authors, corresponding to parts of the former Yugoslavia and Albania, between the Adriatic Sea in the west, the Drava river in the north, the Morava river in the east and the mouth of the Vjosë river in the south.[2][3] The first account of Illyrian peoples comes from Periplus or Coastal Passage, an ancient Greek text of the middle of the 4th century BC.[4]

These tribes, or at least a number of tribes considered "Illyrians proper", are assumed to have been united by a common Illyrian language,[5] of which only small fragments are attested enough to classify it as a branch of Indo-European, while it was extinct by the 5th century AD.[6] However, the name "Illyrians" as applied by the ancient Greeks to their northern neighbors may have referred to a broad, ill-defined group of peoples, and it is today unclear to what extent they were linguistically and culturally homogeneous. In fact, an Illyric origin was and still is attributed also to a few ancient peoples in Italy, in particular the Iapyges, Dauni and Messapi, as it is thought that, most likely, they had shored to the Peninsula, coming from the geographic "Illyria". The Illyrian tribes never collectively regarded themselves as 'Illyrians', and it is unlikely that they used any collective nomenclature for themselves.[7] However, the name Illyrians seems to be the name of a specific Illyrian tribe, which was the first to come in contact with the ancient Greeks during the Bronze Age,[8] causing the name Illyrians to be applied to all people of similar language and customs.[2]

The term "Illyrians" last appears in the historical record in the 7th century AD, referring to a Byzantine garrison operating within the former province.[9] All the remaining tribes except perhaps the Romanized Vlachs[10] were Slavicised in the course of the Middle Ages, while modern Albanian might have descended from a southern Illyrian dialect.[11][12]

Illyrians in Greek mythology

Illyrius and siblings.

In Greek mythology, Illyrius was the son of Cadmus and Harmonia who eventually ruled Illyria and became the eponymous ancestor of the whole Illyrian people.[13] Illyrius had multiple sons (Encheleus, Autarieus, Dardanus, Maedus, Taulas and Perrhaebus) and daughters (Partho, Daortho, Dassaro and others). From these, sprang the Taulantii, Parthini, Dardani, Enchelaeae, Autariates, Dassaretae and the Daors. Autareius had a son Pannonius or Paeon and these had sons Scordiscus and Triballus.[2] A later version of it is having as parents Polyphemus and Galatea that give birth to Celtus, Galas, and Illyrius.[14] The second myth could stem perhaps from the similarities to Celts and Gauls.

Origins

Ethnogenesis of the Illyrians.

The historical beginning of the peoples we later know as Illyrians is placed at approximately 1000 BC.[15] The origin of the Illyrians remains a problem for modern prehistorians. The consensus of the primordialists[16] is that the ethno-linguistic ancestors of the Illyrians, labelled Proto-Illyrians, branched off from the main linguistic Proto-Indo-European trunk before the Iron Age. Current theories of Illyrian origin are based on ancient remnants of material culture found in the area, but archaeological remains alone have so far proven insufficient for a definite answer to the question of the Illyrian ethnogenesis.[17]

When the Proto-Illyrians became a distinct group remains unclear. They emerge out of the wider Paleo-Balkans group by the Iron Age, although, since the language is not known in any detail, it is uncertain which populations should be classed as "Illyrian" on ethno-linguistic grounds, and many tribes formerly classed as Illyrian are now considered Venetic.[18]

An autochthonous model, assuming an Illyrian ethnogenesis in the Balkans, was proposed by Alojz Benać and B. Čović, archaeologists from Sarajevo, who hypothesize that during the Bronze Age there was a progressive Illyrianization of peoples dwelling in the lands between the Adriatic and the Sava river. This theory was also proposed and supported by Albanian archaeologists for the southern Illyrian tribes,[19] while Aleksandar Stipčević says that the most convincing model of Illyrian ethnogenesis was that of autochthony, excluding Liburnians.[20]

Identity and distribution

Illyrian sites.

The name of Illyrians as applied by the ancient Greeks to their northern neighbours may have referred to a broad, ill-defined group of peoples, and it is today unclear to what extent they were linguistically and culturally homogeneous. The Illyrian tribes never collectively regarded themselves as 'Illyrians', and it is unlikely that they utilized any collective nomenclature for themselves.[7] The term Illyrioi may originally have designated only a single people, that came to be widely known to the Greeks due to proximity.[18] This occurred during the Bronze Age, when Greek tribes were neighboring the Illyrii proprie dicti, the southernmost Illyrian tribe of that time, in Zeta plain, Montenegro.[8] Indeed, such a people known as the Illyrioi have occupied a small and well-defined part of the south Adriatic coast, around Skadar Lake astride the modern frontier between Albania and Montenegro. The name may then have expanded and come to be applied to ethnically different peoples such as the Liburni, Delmatae, Iapodes, or the Pannonii. In any case, most modern scholars are certain that the Illyrians constituted a heterogeneous entity.[21]

Pliny, in his work Natural History, applies a stricter usage of the term Illyrii, when speaking of Illyrii proprie dicti ("Illyrians properly so-called") among the native communities in the south of Roman Dalmatia.[22] A passage within Appian's Illyrike (stating that the Illyrians lived beyond Macedonia and Thrace, from Chaonia and Thesprotia to the Danube River) is also representative of the broader usage of the term.[23]

History

Hellenistic period

Central and northern Illyrian tribes and neighbours during the Roman period.
Southern Illyrian and northwestern Greek tribes, 4th-3rd centuries BC.

Illyria appears in Greco-Roman historiography from the 4th century BC. The Illyrians formed several kingdoms in the central Balkans, and the first known Illyrian king was Bardyllis. Illyrian kingdoms were often at war with ancient Macedonia, and the Illyrian pirates were also a significant danger to neighbouring peoples. At the Neretva Delta, there was a strong Hellenistic influence on the Illyrian tribe of Daors. Their capital was Daorson located in Ošanići near Stolac in Herzegovina, which became the main center of classical Illyrian culture. Daorson, during the 4th century BC, was surrounded by megalithic, 5 meter high stonewalls (as large as those of Mycenae in Greece), composed out of large trapeze stones blocks. Daors also made unique bronze coins and sculptures. The Illyrians even conquered Greek colonies on the Dalmatian islands. Queen Teuta was famous for having waged wars against the Romans.

In the Illyrian Wars of 229 BC, 219 BC and 168 BC Rome overran the Illyrian settlements and suppressed the piracy that had made the Adriatic unsafe for Italian commerce.[24] There were three campaigns, the first against Teuta the second against Demetrius of Pharos[25] and the third against Gentius. The initial campaign in 229 BC marks the first time that the Roman Navy crossed the Adriatic Sea to launch an invasion.[26]

The Roman Republic subdued the Illyrians during the 2nd century BC. An Illyrian revolt was crushed under Augustus, resulting in the division of Illyria in the provinces of Pannonia in the north and Dalmatia in the south.

Roman rule

The Roman province of Illyricum.
File:BalkanPlate.jpg
Gradistë belt-plate- 280 BC.

The Roman province of Illyricum or Illyris Romana or Illyris Barbara or Illyria Barbara replaced most of the region of Illyria.[27] It stretched from the Drilon river in modern Albania to Istria (Croatia) in the west and to the Sava river (between Bosnia and Herzegovina and northern Croatia) in the north.[27] Salona (Solin near modern Split in Croatia) functioned as its capital. The regions which it included changed through the centuries though a great part of ancient Illyria remained part of Illyricum as a province while south Illyria became Epirus Nova.

Under Byzantine rule, there was again a prefecture of Illyricum, which was overrun by the Slavic incursions in the 7th century and was ultimately absorbed into the following Slavic states: 1) the First Bulgarian Empire, 2) the Serb Archonty, 3) the Croat Duchy, and 4) parts of the early Bosnian Kingdom.

War

The history of Illyrian warfare spans from ca. 10th century BC up to the 1st century AD in the region defined by Ancient Greek and Latin historians as Illyria. It concerns the armed conflicts of the Illyrian tribes and their kingdoms in the Balkans in Italy as well as pirate activity in the Mediterranean and Adriatic seas. Apart from conflicts between Illyrians and neighboring nations and tribes, numerous wars were recorded among Illyrian tribes too.

Depiction in Greco-Roman ethnography

Illyrians were regarded as an bloodthirsty, unpredictable, turbulent, and warlike peoples by Greeks and Romans.[28] They were seen as savages on the edge of their world.[29]

It was a stereotypical view of all northern "barbarians" and could represent a fearful impression of the Illyrians and their tenacity after fighting them.[30] Polybius (3rd century BC) writes that "the Romans had freed the Greeks from the enemies of all mankind".[31]

According to the Romans, the Illyrians were tall and well-built.[32] Herodianus writes that "Pannonians are tall and strong always ready for a fight and to face danger but slow witted".[33] Of course, this could also be considered a stereotype of the Romans used for identifying barbarians. The Roman historian Livy writes:[34]

"...the coasts of Italy destitute of harbours, and, on the right, the Illyrians, Liburnians, and Istrians, nations of savages, and noted in general for piracy, he passed on to the coasts of the Venetians"

Religion

The Illyrian town of Rhizon (Risan, Montenegro) had its own protector called Medauras depicted as carrying a lance and riding on horseback.[35] Human sacrifice also played a role in the lives of the Illyrians.[36]

Arrian records the chieftain Cleitus the Illyrian as sacrificing three boys, three girls and three rams just before his battle with Alexander the Great. The most common type of burial among the Iron Age Illyrians was tumulus or mound burial. The kin of the first tumuli was buried around that, and the higher the status of those in these burials the higher the mound. Archaeology has found many artifacts placed within these tumuli such as weapons, ornaments, garments and clay vessels. Illyrians believed these items were necessary for a dead person's journey into the afterlife.

Extinction of ethnicity and language

File:Central and Eastern Europe mid 4th century BC.png
Ethno-linguistic groups in southeastern Europe c. 4th century.

The Illyrians were subject to varying degrees of Celticization,[37] Hellenization,[38] Romanization,[10] and later Slavicization.

Little more can be said of the languages of Illyria than that they were Indo-European. It is not clear whether the Illyrian languages belonged to the centum or the satem group. The vast majority of our knowledge of Illyrian is based on Messapian, if the latter is considered an Illyrian dialect. The non-Messapic testimonies of Illyrian are too fragmentary to allow any conclusions whether Messapian should be considered part of Illyrian proper. Nonetheless, it is widely thought that Messapian was in some way related to Illyrian.

Messapian (also known as Messapic) is an extinct Indo-European language of south-eastern Italy, once spoken in Messapia (modern Salento). It was spoken by the three Iapygian tribes of the region: the Messapians, the Daunii and the Peucetii.

The Illyrian languages were once connected to the Venetic language but this view was later abandoned.[39] Other scholars have linked them with the adjacent Thracian language supposing an intermediate convergence area or dialect continuum, but this view is also not generally supported.

All these languages were likely extinct by the 5th century AD[40] although the Albanian language is traditionally seen as a descendant of Illyrian dialects that survived in remote areas of the Balkans during the Middle Ages.[41] The ancestor dialects of Albanian would have survived somewhere along the boundary of Latin and Greek linguistic influence (the Jireček Line). An alternative hypothesis favoured by some linguists is that Albanian is descended from Thracian.[40] Not enough is known of the ancient language to completely prove or disprove either hypothesis (see Origin of Albanians).[42]

Famous individuals

Archaeology

Walls of ancient Daorson, located at Ošanići near Stolac in Bosnia and Herzegovina.

There are few remains to connect with the Bronze Age with the later Illyrians in the western Balkans. Moreover, with the notable exception of Pod near Bugojno in the upper valley of the Vrbas River, nothing is known of their settlements. Some hill settlements have been identified in western Serbia, but the main evidence comes from cemeteries, consisting usually of a small number of burial mounds (tumuli). In eastern Bosnia in the cemeteries of Belotić and Bela Crkva, the rites of exhumation and cremation are attested, with skeletons in stone cists and cremations in urns. Metal implements appear here side-by-side with stone implements. Most of the remains belong to the fully developed Middle Bronze Age.

During the 7th century BC, the beginning of the Iron Age, the Illyrians emerge as an ethnic group with a distinct culture and art form. Various Illyrian tribes appeared, under the influence of the Halstatt cultures from the north, and they organized their regional centers.[48] The cult of the dead played an important role in the lives of the Illyrians, which is seen in their carefully made burials and burial ceremonies, as well as the richness of the burial sites. In the northern parts of the Balkans, there existed a long tradition of cremation and burial in shallow graves, while in the southern parts, the dead were buried in large stone, or earth tumuli (natively called gromile) that in Herzegovina were reaching monumental sizes, more than 50 meters wide and 5 meters high. The Japodian tribe (found from Istria in Croatia to Bihać in Bosnia) have had an affinity for decoration with heavy, oversized necklaces out of yellow, blue or white glass paste, and large bronze fibulas, as well as spiral bracelets, diadems and helmets out of bronze. Small sculptures out of jade in form of archaic Ionian plastic are also characteristically Japodian. Numerous monumental sculptures are preserved, as well as walls of citadel Nezakcij near Pula, one of numerous Istrian cities from Iron Age. Illyrian chiefs wore bronze torques around their necks much like the Celts did.[49] The Illyrians were influenced by the Celts in many cultural and material aspects and some of them were Celticized, especially the tribes in Dalmatia[50] and the Pannonians.[51] In Slovenia, the Vače situla was discovered in 1882 and attributed to Illyrians.

Prehistoric remains indicate no more than average height, male 165 cm, female 153 cm.[33]

Legacy

Middle Ages

The Illyrians were mentioned for the last time in the Miracula Sancti Demetrii during the 7th century.[52][53] With the disintegration of the Roman Empire, Gothic and Hunnic tribes raided the Balkan peninsula, making many Illyrians seek refuge in the highlands. With the arrival of the Slavs in the 6th century, most Illyrians were Slavicized.[54][55] A few of the Romanised Illyrians from the Adriatic coast did manage to preserve their blended culture. Many fled to the mountains, surviving as shepherds, and kept speaking their Romance language. They are referred to as Morlachs.[55] Others took refuge inside the defended cities of the coast, where they kept Roman culture alive for many centuries, but were also eventually assimilated by the expanding Slavic population of the mainland.

The first historical mention of the Albanians appears in an account of the resistance by a Byzantine emperor, Alexius I Comnenus, to an offensive by the Vatican-backed Normans from southern Italy into the Albanian-populated lands in 1081. The earliest reference to a Lingua Albanesca is from a 1285 document of Ragusa and the earliest accepted document in the Albanian language is from the 15th century. The origins of the Albanians are not definitely known, but a certain amount of Illyrian-Albanian continuity is generally assumed to be plausible.[56]

Early modern usage

During the late Middle Ages and the Renaissance, the term "Illyrian" was used to describe Croats living within the territories of Croatia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Italy, Austria, Hungary and Serbia (and in other countries abroad). However, on the territory of Venetian Albania (possessions of the Republic of Venice on the territory of Montenegro) and further southward, that term has been used to designate Albanians.[57]

The term Illyrians was utilized in late medieval texts such as in Mazaris' Journey to Hades (a work written by Byzantine author Mazaris between January 1414 and October 1415). In Mazaris' case, the term was used to designate "Albanians" (i.e. Arvanites).[58]

The term was revived again during the Habsburg Monarchy, but it was designated towards South Slavs.

In Nationalism

When Napoleon conquered part of the South Slavic lands in the beginning of the 19th century, these areas were named after ancient Illyrian provinces. Under the influence of Romantic nationalism, a self-identified "Illyrian movement" (Croatian: Ilirski pokret) in the form of a Croatian national revival, opened a literary and journalistic campaign that was initiated by a group of young Croatian intellectuals during the years of 1835-1849.[59] This movement, under the banner of Illlyrism, aimed to create a Croatian national establishment under Austro-Hungarian rule, through linguistic and ethnic unity among South Slavs. It was repressed by the Habsburg authorities after the failed Revolutions of 1848.

The possible continuity between the Illyrian populations of the Western Balkans in antiquity and the Albanians has also played a significant role in Albanian nationalism from the 19th century until the present day. For example, Ibrahim Rugova, the first president of UN-administered Kosovo introduced the "Flag of Dardania" on October 29, 2000, Dardania being the name for a Thraco-Illyrian region roughly coterminous with modern Kosovo.[60]

See also

References

Citations

  1. ^ Frazee 1997, p. 89: "The Balkan peninsula had three groups of Indo-Europeans prior to 2000 B.C. Those on the west were the Illyrians; those on the east were the Thracians; and advancing down the southern part of the Balkans, the Greeks."
  2. ^ a b c Wilkes 1995, p. 92.
  3. ^ Boardman & Hammond 1982, p. 261; Wilkes 1995, p. 6.
  4. ^ Wilkes 1995, p. 94.
  5. ^ Bideleux & Jeffries 2007, "Albania", p. 24.
  6. ^ Eastern Michigan University Linguist List: The Illyrian Language: "An ancient language of the Balkans. Based upon geographical proximity, this is traditionally seen as the ancestor of Modern Albanian. It is more likely, however, that Thracian is Modern Albanian's ancestor, since both Albanian and Thracian belong to the satem group of Indo-European, while Illyrian belonged to the centum group. 2nd half of 1st Millennium BC - 1st half of 1st Millennium AD."
  7. ^ a b Roisman & Worthington 2010, p. 280: "The Illyrians certainly never collectively called themselves Illyrians, and it is unlikely that they had any collective name for themselves."
  8. ^ a b Boardman 1982, p. 629.
  9. ^ Schaefer 2008, p. 130.
  10. ^ a b Bowden 2003, p. 211; Kazhdan 1991, p. 248.
  11. ^ Ceka 2005, pp. 40–42, 59.
  12. ^ "Albania". London: Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved 30 September 2005. According to alternative hypotheses, the Albanians may be descendants of Thracians or more specifically Dacians; cf. Georgiev, Vladimir (1960). "Albanisch, Dakisch-Mysisch und Rumänisch". Linguistique balkanique. 2: 1–19., and Schramm, Gottfried (1994). Anfänge des albanischen Christentums: Die frühe Bekehrung der Bessen und ihre langen Folgen. Freiburg.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  13. ^ Grimal & Maxwell-Hyslop 1996, p. 230; Apollodorus & Hard 1999, p. 103 (Book III, 5.4).
  14. ^ Grimal & Maxwell-Hyslop 1996, p. 168.
  15. ^ Wilkes 1995, p. 39.
  16. ^ In The Ethnic Origins of Nations (Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1966, p. 12), Anthony D. Smith coined the term primordialists to separate these thinkers from those who view ethnicity as a situational construct, the product of history, rather than a cause, influenced by a variety of political, economic, and cultural factors. The issue of ethnicity remains intractable even millennia later (see Walter Pohl, "Conceptions of Ethnicity in Early Medieval Studies" in Debating the Middle Ages: Issues and Readings, ed. Lester K. Little and Barbara H. Rosenwein, Blackwell Publishing, 1998, pp. 13-24).
  17. ^ Wilkes 1995, p. 81.
  18. ^ a b Wilkes 1995, pp. 81, 183.
  19. ^ Anamali & Korkuti 1969; Korkuti 2003; Stipčević 1977, p. 18.
  20. ^ Stipčević 1989.
  21. ^ Wilkes 1995, p. 38: "Just as ancient writers could discover no satisfactory general explanation for the origin of Illyrians, so most modern scholars, even though now possessed of a mass of archaeological and linguistic evidence, can assert with confidence only that Illyrians were not a homogeneous entity, though even that is today challenged with vigour by historians and archaeologists working within the perspective of modern Albania."
  22. ^ By implication, a broader usage was current when Pliny wrote his work.
  23. ^ Appian. Roman History, "The Illyrian Wars", §1.
  24. ^ a b Wilkes 1995, p. 158.
  25. ^ Boak & Sinnigen 1977, p. 111.
  26. ^ Gruen 1986, p. 76.
  27. ^ a b Smith 1874, p. 218.
  28. ^ Whitehorne 1994, p. 37; Eckstein 2008, p. 33; Strauss 2009, p. 21; Everitt 2006, p. 154.
  29. ^ Wilkes 1995, p. 4.
  30. ^ Hingley 2005, pp. 61–62.
  31. ^ Champion 2004, p. 113.
  32. ^ Juvenal 2009, p. 127.
  33. ^ a b Wilkes 1995, p. 219.
  34. ^ Titus Livius. The History of Rome.
  35. ^ Wilkes 1995, p. 247.
  36. ^ Wilkes 1995, p. 123.
  37. ^ Bunson 1995, p. 202; Mócsy 1974.
  38. ^ Pomeroy et al. 2008, p. 255.
  39. ^ Wilkes 1995, p. 183.
  40. ^ a b Eastern Michigan University Linguist List: The Illyrian Language.
  41. ^ Ammon et al. 2006, p. 1874: "Traditionally, Albanian is identified as the descendant of Illyrian, but Hamp (1994a) argues that the evidence is too meager and contradictory for us to know whether the term Illyrian even referred to a single language."
  42. ^ Mallory & Adams 1997, p. 9; Fortson 2004.
  43. ^ Harding 1985, p. 93.
  44. ^ Wilkes 1995, p. 129.
  45. ^ Wilkes 1995, p. 72.
  46. ^ Wilkes 1995, p. 216.
  47. ^ Bury 1889, p. 309.
  48. ^ Wilkes 1995, p. 140.
  49. ^ Wilkes 1995, p. 233.
  50. ^ Bunson 1995, p. 202; Hornblower & Spawforth 2003, p. 426.
  51. ^ Hornblower & Spawforth 2003, p. 1106.
  52. ^ The compilation Miracula Sancti Demetri contains the legendary acta of Saint Demetrius of Thessaloniki.
  53. ^ Juka 1984, p. 60: "Since the Illyrians are referred to for the last time as an ethnic group in Miracula Sancti Demetri (7th century AD), some scholars maintain that after the arrival of the Slavs the Illyrians were extinct."
  54. ^ Gjonaij 2001.
  55. ^ a b 1911 Encyclopedia - Illyria.
  56. ^ Encyclopædia Britannica, s.v. "Albania": "The origins of the Albanian people are not definitely known, but data drawn from history and from linguistic, archaeological, and anthropological studies have led to the conclusion that Albanians are the direct descendants of the ancient Illyrians. ... Some scholars, however, dispute such theses, arguing that Illyrians were not autochthonous to Albania and that Albanian derives from a dialect of the now-extinct Thracian language."
  57. ^ "Hrvatska revija", br. 2/2007.
  58. ^ Mazaris 1975, pp. 76–79.
  59. ^ Despalatovic 1975.
  60. ^ "Kosovo (Province, Serbia) - Dardania (Flag of Uncertain Status)". Flags of the World. 2008-02-23. Retrieved 2008-08-14.

Sources

External links