United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
Makecat-bot (talk | contribs)
(5 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 85: Line 85:
[[Image:Dublin UK.PNG|thumb|left|[[O'Connell Street|Sackville Street]] in [[Dublin]] in the United Kingdom, c. 1908]]
[[Image:Dublin UK.PNG|thumb|left|[[O'Connell Street|Sackville Street]] in [[Dublin]] in the United Kingdom, c. 1908]]


Despite losing its own parliament, much of the [[Dublin Castle administration in Ireland|system of government in Ireland]] remained in place after the union: the offices of Lord Lieutenant and Chief Secretary remained (although the latter came to eclipse the former), as well as the [[Privy Council of Ireland]] and the various government departments. Ireland retained also its own legal system, and its own courts; the Irish courts became subordinate to the House of Lords once again, though, after [[Irish Appeals Act 1783|briefly achieving judicial independence in the 1780s]]. While the retention of laws and courts was paralleled with the position of [[Scotland]] under the union, the continuation of a separate system of government was unique to Ireland.
Ireland was never fully integrated into the British state or political culture.<ref>Jenkins, 8.</ref> Despite losing its own parliament, much of the [[Dublin Castle administration in Ireland|system of government in Ireland]] remained in place after the union: the offices of Lord Lieutenant and Chief Secretary remained (although the latter came to eclipse the former), as well as the [[Privy Council of Ireland]] and the various government departments. Ireland retained also its own legal system, and its own courts; the Irish courts became subordinate to the House of Lords once again, though, after [[Irish Appeals Act 1783|briefly achieving judicial independence in the 1780s]]. While the retention of laws and courts was paralleled with the position of [[Scotland]] under the union, the continuation of a separate system of government was unique to Ireland. The other main difference from Scotland was in religious policy and demography: The majority of the Irish were not members of the [[established church]], the [[Anglican]] [[Church of Ireland]].

The question over how the British state should respond to Irish demands, called "the [[Irish question]]" was a major influence on British politics throughout the [[long nineteenth century]]. In 1844, future British prime minister [[Benjamin Disraeli]] described the situation in Ireland:
{{quote|A dense population, in extreme distress, inhabit an island where there is an Established Church, which is not their Church, and a territorial aristocracy the richest of whom live in foreign capitals. Thus you have a starving population, an absentee aristocracy, and an alien Church; and in addition the weakest executive in the world. That is the Irish Question.'|Hansard<ref>The State of Ireland, Hansard, 16 February 1844</ref>}}

== Early Irish opposition to the Union ==
In the context of rising [[national awareness]] in Ireland, there were several inter-related popular campaigns against British policy in Ireland in the first half of the nineteenth century.


[[Catholic Emancipation]] was finally brought about in 1829, following a campaign led by [[Daniel O'Connell]]. O'Connell had been elected as [[Member of Parliament]] for [[Clare (UK Parliament constituency)|County Clare]], but had been prevented from taking his seat in the [[British House of Commons|House of Commons]] at Westminster because of the requirement to swear the [[Oath of Supremacy]]; the oath had been expressly worded to prevent Roman Catholics from entering parliament.
[[Catholic Emancipation]] was finally brought about in 1829, following a campaign led by [[Daniel O'Connell]]. O'Connell had been elected as [[Member of Parliament]] for [[Clare (UK Parliament constituency)|County Clare]], but had been prevented from taking his seat in the [[British House of Commons|House of Commons]] at Westminster because of the requirement to swear the [[Oath of Supremacy]]; the oath had been expressly worded to prevent Roman Catholics from entering parliament.


O'Connell had also campaigned for "Repeal", i.e. for the repeal of the Acts of Union and a return to Ireland's position under the [[Constitution of 1782]]. Similar demands from Ireland for the re-establishment of its own parliament in Ireland were to be repeated through the course of the 19th century, building up until the Home Rule movement came to dominate Irish politics from the late 1870s onwards.
O'Connell had also campaigned for "Repeal", i.e. for the repeal of the Acts of Union and a return to Ireland's position under the [[Constitution of 1782]]. O'Connell was an early leader of [[Irish nationalism]] He wrote in 1842, "I am not British", and also declared Ireland a "separate nation".<ref>Quoted in Jenkins, 43.</ref>

British thinkers tried to respond to these demands, but philosopher [[John Stuart Mills]] struggled to think of the Irish as a separate nation, and feared any such recognition's implications for Britain.<ref>Jenkins, 47-48</ref> Most English elites assumed [[egocentrism|their ways were superior]] and [[chauvinism|the Irish were not their equals]] but merely as "degraded caste".<ref>Jenkins, 49</ref>

The British political elites acted as if the United Kingdom were a [[mono-national state]], despite the fact that Ireland was run by Dublin Castle but Westminster. Ireland was in the Union, but still separate. British [[ministers of the Crown]] rarely visited Ireland, and delegated their authority to the [[Irish secretary]], Ireland's sole voice in the cabinet.<ref>Jenkins, 10</ref>

More demands from Ireland for the re-establishment of its own parliament in Ireland were to be repeated through the course of the 19th century, building up until the Home Rule movement came to dominate Irish politics from the late 1870s onwards.

==The campaign for Irish "home rule" and the British response ==
Irish demands ranged from the "repeal" of O'Connell, the "federal scheme" of [[William Sharman Crawford]] (actually devolution, not federalism as such), to the "home rule" of [[Issac Butt]]. Despite the [[Great Irish Famine]] of 1845 to 1852, Ireland was not any closer to "home rule" by mid-century with rebellions being easily crushed by the British state in [[Young Irelander Rebellion of 1848|1848]] and [[Fenian Rising|1867]].

O'Connell's moderate parliamentary campaign was blocked by the limited scope of the [[franchise]] in Ireland.<ref>Biagini, 2.</ref> The wider the frachise was expanded, the better anti-Union parties were able to do in Ireland.<ref>Hoppen, 567</ref> Running on a platform that advocated something like [[self-rule]] that have been given to Canada under the ''[[British North America Act, 1867]]'', the Home Rulers won a majority of both county and borough seats in Ireland in 1874.<ref>Morton, 79</ref><ref>Hoppen, 567</ref>. By 1882, leadership of the [[Irish Home Rule movement]] had passed to [[Charles Stewart Parnell]] of the [[Irish Parliamentary Party]].

A wider franchise also changed the ideological mix among non-Irish MPs, making them more receptive to Irish demands. The [[1885 election]] resulted in a "[[hung parliament]]" in which the Irish Parliamentary Party holding the [[balance of power (parliamentary)]]. They initially supported the [[Conservatives (UK)|Conservatives]] in a [[minority government]], but when news leaked that [[Liberal Party (UK)|Liberal Party]] leader [[William Ewart Gladstone]] was considering Home Rule, they ousted the Conservatives and brought the Liberals to office.<ref>Biagini, 9</ref>

Galdstone's [[First Home Rule Bill]] was closely modelled on the self-government given to British [[settler colonies]], starting with the ''[[Act of Union of 1840]]'' (also called the "Canada Act"), and especially the ''British North America Act, 1867'''.<ref>Kendle, 44</ref><ref> Irish MPs would no longer have a vote in Westminster but in a separate Dublin parliament, which would control all areas except foreign and military affairs, which would remain with Britain.<ref>Kendle, 45</ref> Gladstone's proposals did not go as far as [[Irish nationalism|Irish nationalist]] opinion desired, but were too radical for [[Irish unionism|unionists]] in both Ireland and Great Britain: his First Home Rule Bill was defeated in the House of Commons following a split in his own party. Gladstone took the issue to the people in [[United Kingdom general election, 1886|the 1886 election]], but the Unionists (Conservatives plus Liberal dissenters) held a majority over the Home Rule coalition (Liberals and Irish nationalists). Significantly, pro-Home Rule parties won majorities in Ireland, Scotland, and Wales, but not in England, where most seats were contested.<ref>Biagini, 10</ref>

With the Conservatives opposed to Home Rule, it slipped from the mainstream of British politics once they came into power in the 1890s. However, the Conservative government also felt that the demands for Home Rule were essentially [[materialist]] in origin, and that to improve conditions in Ireland would satisfy opinion there; this has been described as "killing home rule with kindness". Reforms passed as a result included the [[Local Government (Ireland) Act 1898]] and the [[Irish Land Acts#Wyndham Land (Purchase) Act 1903|Wyndham Land Act]].

Before the 1892 election, Parnell was caught in one of the "one of the most celebrated sex scandals of the century"<ref>Boyce, 38-39</ref> which caused Gladstone to disavow him, and splitting the Irish Parliamentary Party. Nevertheless, the 1892 election gave the pro-Home Rule forces a narrow majority, and again the Liberals had done better in Scotland and Wales than in England.<ref>Boyce, 39</ref> Gladstone introduced a [[Second Home Rule Bill]] in 1893, which this time would have kept Irish MPs in the British parliament, but it was defeated (as was expected) in the [[Conservative Party (UK)|Conservative]]-dominated House of Lords.<ref>Boyce, 28</ref>


Outside of constitutional change, the British state tried other methods to placate Ireland. Between 1868 and 1908: spending on Ireland was generally increased, huge tracts of land were purchased from landlords and redistributed to smallholders, local government was democratised, and the franchise widely extended. The ending of so many social and economic grievances did not end Irish disenchantment, however. What this ''did'' accomplish was a simplification of the issues. No longer could British governments fool themselves into thinking that something other than satisfying Irish demands for national recognition and self-determination would answer the Irish question.<ref>Boyce, 47-48</ref>
==Irish Home Rule==
Amongst others, [[Isaac Butt]] and [[Charles Stewart Parnell]] headed an increasingly organised campaign for [[Devolution#Irish home rule|Home Rule]], or self-government for Ireland. Parnell's [[Irish Parliamentary Party]] held most of the seats in the House of Commons for constituencies in Ireland, and the party became a significant factor in British politics even though it never formed part of a British government.


Some Britons were beginning to be able to accept Irish nationalism as legitimate. British liberal support for home rule rested on the premise that the Irish people had withdrawn their [[consent of the governed|consent to be governed]] by the United Kingdom by electing the Nationalists to repeated majorities, and the popular consent was a basic prerequisite for [[legitimacy|morally legitimate government]].<ref>Biagini, 51</ref> In other words, for liberals it was immoral to hold the Irish in the Union against their will.
The British [[Liberal Party (UK)|Liberal]] [[Prime Minister of the United Kingdom|Prime Minister]], [[William Ewart Gladstone]], became convinced of the necessity of addressing the "Irish question" by establishing a parliament at [[Dublin]], albeit one with quite limited powers. Gladstone's proposals did not go as far as [[Irish nationalism|Irish nationalist]] opinion desired, but were too radical for [[Irish unionism|unionists]] in both Ireland and Great Britain: his [[First Home Rule Bill]] was defeated in the House of Commons following a split in his own party, while his [[Second Home Rule Bill]] failed (as was expected) in the [[Conservative Party (UK)|Conservative]]-dominated House of Lords.


The competing idea among unionists was that it was impossible to give Ireland independence or it would be used as base from which Continental powers could attack Britain. Writing much later, after Irish independence, [[Winston Churchill]] stated that this this idea had taken on the status of [[dogma]] and had fossilized in British minds longer after it had ceased to have any basis in fact and that only the "large outside shock" of the First World War had changed this.<ref>Quoted in Fanning, 105</ref>
With the Conservatives opposed to Home Rule, it slipped from the mainstream of British politics once they came into power in the 1890s. However, the Conservative government also felt that the demands for Home Rule were essentially materialist in origin, and that to improve conditions in Ireland would satisfy opinion there; this has been described as "killing home rule with kindness". Reforms passed as a result included the [[Local Government (Ireland) Act 1898]] and the [[Irish Land Acts#Wyndham Land (Purchase) Act 1903|Wyndham Land Act]].


The Liberals regained power in 1905. Following a confrontation with the House of Lords over the "[[People's Budget]]", a wider constitutional conflict developed, resulting in two general elections during 1910 and the passage of the [[Parliament Act 1911]]. The 1910 elections saw the Liberals lose seats in the Commons, necessitating the support of the Irish Parliamentary Party (now led by [[John Redmond]]). The Irish party expected their support to be repaid by the introduction of Home Rule, which with the removal of the House of Lords' veto power by the Parliament Act became a clear possibility for the first time.
The Liberals regained power in 1905. Following a confrontation with the House of Lords over the "[[People's Budget]]", a wider [[constitutional conflict]] developed, resulting in two general elections during 1910 and the passage of the [[Parliament Act 1911]]. The 1910 elections saw the Liberals lose seats in the Commons, necessitating the support of the Irish Parliamentary Party (now led by [[John Redmond]]). The Irish party expected their support to be repaid by the introduction of Home Rule, which with the removal of the House of Lords' veto power by the Parliament Act became a clear possibility for the first time.


The Third Home Rule Bill, introduced in 1912, provoked increasingly bitter opposition from Unionists, particularly those in [[Ulster]]. The Bill finally passed into law as the [[Government of Ireland Act 1914]] a few weeks after the start of the [[World War I|First World War]], but its implementation was [[Suspensory Act 1914|simultaneously suspended]] for the duration of the war. The situation in Ireland had deteriorated severely, with both unionist [[Ulster Volunteers]] and nationalist [[Irish Volunteers]] openly drilling, and with both groups having imported arms. The war exacerbated tensions further, with unionists urging loyalty to the King by volunteering in the [[British Army]], but with nationalists much more ambivalent about a war that was seen by many as Britain's and not Ireland's fight.
The [[Third Home Rule Bill]], introduced in 1912, provoked increasingly bitter opposition from Unionists, particularly those in [[Ulster]]. The Bill finally passed into law as the [[Government of Ireland Act 1914]] a few weeks after the start of the [[World War I|First World War]], but its implementation was [[Suspensory Act 1914|simultaneously suspended]] for the duration of the war. The situation in Ireland had deteriorated severely, with both unionist [[Ulster Volunteers]] and nationalist [[Irish Volunteers]] openly drilling, and with both groups having imported arms. The war exacerbated tensions further, with unionists urging loyalty to the King by volunteering in the [[British Army]], but with nationalists much more ambivalent about a war that was seen by many as Britain's and not Ireland's fight.


The 1916 [[Easter Rising]] in favour of an independent [[Irish Republic]] was suppressed without great difficulty by the British, but the severe measures taken by them in its aftermath further alienated nationalist opinion. An attempt to introduce a modified form of Home Rule was made by the Prime Minister [[Lloyd George]] in 1917 when he called together all parties within Ireland to an [[Irish Convention]]; however, after six months the Convention failed to reach agreement on the important question of whether Ulster was to be under the authority of any new Dublin parliament. The [[Irish Parliamentary Party#Europe intervenes|European situation]] with the [[Conscription Crisis of 1918|threat of conscription]] (which had been operating in Great Britain but had not yet been introduced into Ireland) changed the political climate further, such that in the [[Irish general election, 1918|1918 general election]], the Irish Party lost most of its seats to the more radical [[Sinn Féin]] party.
The 1916 [[Easter Rising]] in favour of an independent [[Irish Republic]] was suppressed without great difficulty by the British, but the severe measures taken by them in its aftermath further alienated nationalist opinion. An attempt to introduce a modified form of Home Rule was made by the Prime Minister [[Lloyd George]] in 1917 when he called together all parties within Ireland to an [[Irish Convention]]; however, after six months the Convention failed to reach agreement on the important question of whether Ulster was to be under the authority of any new Dublin parliament. The [[Irish Parliamentary Party#Europe intervenes|European situation]] with the [[Conscription Crisis of 1918|threat of conscription]] (which had been operating in Great Britain but had not yet been introduced into Ireland) changed the political climate further, such that in the [[Irish general election, 1918|1918 general election]], the Irish Party lost most of its seats to the more radical [[Sinn Féin]] party.

Revision as of 20:53, 24 November 2012

United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland1
1801–1922²
Motto: Dieu et mon droit  (French)3
"God and my right"
Anthem: God Save the King (Queen)
Location of United Kingdom
StatusSovereign state
CapitalLondon
Common languagesEnglish (de facto official). Irish Gaelic, Scottish Gaelic, Scots and Welsh widely spoken in parts while Norn and Cornish survived into this period
GovernmentParliamentary democracy and constitutional monarchy
Monarch 
• 1801–1820
George III
• 1820–1830
George IV
• 1830–1837
William IV
• 1837–1901
Victoria
• 1901–1910
Edward VII
• 1910–1927 (cont. as King of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland)
George V
Prime Minister 
• 1801, 1804–1806
William Pitt the Younger
• 1924–1927 (In name-cont.)
Stanley Baldwin
LegislatureParliament
House of Lords
House of Commons
History 
1 January 1801
6 December 1922
12 April 1927
Area
1801315,093 km2 (121,658 sq mi)
1921315,093 km2 (121,658 sq mi)
Population
• 1801
16,345,646
• 1921
42,769,196
CurrencyPound sterling
ISO 3166 codeGB
Preceded by
Succeeded by
Kingdom of Great Britain
Kingdom of Ireland
United Kingdom
Irish Republic
Irish Free State
Today part of United Kingdom
 Republic of Ireland
1Cornish: Rywvaneth Unys Breten Veur ha Iwerdhon; Irish: Ríocht Aontaithe na Breataine Móire agus Éireann; Scots: Unitit Kinrick o Great Breetain an Irland; Scottish Gaelic: Rìoghachd Aonaichte na Breatainne Mòire is Èireann; Welsh: Teyrnas Unedig Prydain Fawr ac Iwerddon.
2 The Irish Free State seceded from the United Kingdom in 1922 as a result of the Irish War of Independence and the subsequent Anglo-Irish Treaty, but this fact was not reflected in the long-form name of United Kingdom until the Royal and Parliamentary Titles Act in 1927.
3 The Royal motto used in Scotland was [Nemo Me Impune Lacessit] Error: {{Lang}}: text has italic markup (help) (Latin for "No-one provokes me with impunity").

The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland was the formal name of the United Kingdom between 1801 and 1927. In 1922, the majority of Ireland seceded to form the Irish Free State. The Royal and Parliamentary Titles Act 1927 amended the name of the Parliament of the United Kingdom to reflect the change in the country's boundaries, and the Act is conventionally considered to mark the point when the name of the state changed as well.

The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland came into being on 1 January 1801 under the terms of the Acts of Union 1800, by which the formerly separate kingdoms of Great Britain and Ireland were united. The Kingdom of Great Britain had itself been formed in 1707 by the union of the formerly separate kingdoms of England and Scotland.

The present-day United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland is a continuation of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland, with the same constitutional and parliamentary systems but covering only a portion of the previous territory. The southern part of Ireland that seceded from the union is now the Republic of Ireland. It covers the same territory as the old Irish Free State, but adopted a new constitution in 1937.

The Acts of Union

Despite being a kingdom in its own right, Ireland before 1801 did not have full sovereignty. The Kingdom of Ireland was a settler state, with the King of Ireland being the same person as the King of England (and, since the 1603 ascension of the Stewart dynasty, the King of Scotland). Its government was headed by a Lord Lieutenant and his Chief Secretary, who were responsible to the government of Great Britain rather than to the Parliament of Ireland. Before 1782 the Irish parliament was also severely fettered, and the Irish courts were subordinated to the jurisdiction of the British House of Lords in London.

Ireland gained a degree of independence in the 1780s thanks to Henry Grattan. During this time the effect of the penal laws on the majority Catholic population was reduced, and Catholics were given the vote in 1794; however, they were still excluded from becoming members of the Irish House of Commons. This brief period of limited independence came to an end following the Irish Rebellion of 1798; occurring during the British war with revolutionary France, the British government's fear of an independent Ireland siding against them with the French resulted in the decision to unite the two countries. This was brought about by legislation in the parliaments of both kingdoms, and came into effect on 1 January 1801.

The Irish had been led to believe by the British that their loss of legislative independence would be compensated for with Catholic Emancipation, i.e. by the removal of civil disabilities placed upon Roman Catholics in both Ireland and Great Britain. However, King George III was bitterly opposed to Catholic Emancipation, and blocked his government from introducing it into the Parliament of the United Kingdom. This meant that an initial popularity in Ireland for the union soon waned, with even Protestant leaders such as Grattan being critical.[citation needed]

Ireland under the Union

Sackville Street in Dublin in the United Kingdom, c. 1908

Ireland was never fully integrated into the British state or political culture.[1] Despite losing its own parliament, much of the system of government in Ireland remained in place after the union: the offices of Lord Lieutenant and Chief Secretary remained (although the latter came to eclipse the former), as well as the Privy Council of Ireland and the various government departments. Ireland retained also its own legal system, and its own courts; the Irish courts became subordinate to the House of Lords once again, though, after briefly achieving judicial independence in the 1780s. While the retention of laws and courts was paralleled with the position of Scotland under the union, the continuation of a separate system of government was unique to Ireland. The other main difference from Scotland was in religious policy and demography: The majority of the Irish were not members of the established church, the Anglican Church of Ireland.

The question over how the British state should respond to Irish demands, called "the Irish question" was a major influence on British politics throughout the long nineteenth century. In 1844, future British prime minister Benjamin Disraeli described the situation in Ireland:

A dense population, in extreme distress, inhabit an island where there is an Established Church, which is not their Church, and a territorial aristocracy the richest of whom live in foreign capitals. Thus you have a starving population, an absentee aristocracy, and an alien Church; and in addition the weakest executive in the world. That is the Irish Question.'

— Hansard[2]

Early Irish opposition to the Union

In the context of rising national awareness in Ireland, there were several inter-related popular campaigns against British policy in Ireland in the first half of the nineteenth century.

Catholic Emancipation was finally brought about in 1829, following a campaign led by Daniel O'Connell. O'Connell had been elected as Member of Parliament for County Clare, but had been prevented from taking his seat in the House of Commons at Westminster because of the requirement to swear the Oath of Supremacy; the oath had been expressly worded to prevent Roman Catholics from entering parliament.

O'Connell had also campaigned for "Repeal", i.e. for the repeal of the Acts of Union and a return to Ireland's position under the Constitution of 1782. O'Connell was an early leader of Irish nationalism He wrote in 1842, "I am not British", and also declared Ireland a "separate nation".[3]

British thinkers tried to respond to these demands, but philosopher John Stuart Mills struggled to think of the Irish as a separate nation, and feared any such recognition's implications for Britain.[4] Most English elites assumed their ways were superior and the Irish were not their equals but merely as "degraded caste".[5]

The British political elites acted as if the United Kingdom were a mono-national state, despite the fact that Ireland was run by Dublin Castle but Westminster. Ireland was in the Union, but still separate. British ministers of the Crown rarely visited Ireland, and delegated their authority to the Irish secretary, Ireland's sole voice in the cabinet.[6]

More demands from Ireland for the re-establishment of its own parliament in Ireland were to be repeated through the course of the 19th century, building up until the Home Rule movement came to dominate Irish politics from the late 1870s onwards.

The campaign for Irish "home rule" and the British response

Irish demands ranged from the "repeal" of O'Connell, the "federal scheme" of William Sharman Crawford (actually devolution, not federalism as such), to the "home rule" of Issac Butt. Despite the Great Irish Famine of 1845 to 1852, Ireland was not any closer to "home rule" by mid-century with rebellions being easily crushed by the British state in 1848 and 1867.

O'Connell's moderate parliamentary campaign was blocked by the limited scope of the franchise in Ireland.[7] The wider the frachise was expanded, the better anti-Union parties were able to do in Ireland.[8] Running on a platform that advocated something like self-rule that have been given to Canada under the British North America Act, 1867, the Home Rulers won a majority of both county and borough seats in Ireland in 1874.[9][10]. By 1882, leadership of the Irish Home Rule movement had passed to Charles Stewart Parnell of the Irish Parliamentary Party.

A wider franchise also changed the ideological mix among non-Irish MPs, making them more receptive to Irish demands. The 1885 election resulted in a "hung parliament" in which the Irish Parliamentary Party holding the balance of power (parliamentary). They initially supported the Conservatives in a minority government, but when news leaked that Liberal Party leader William Ewart Gladstone was considering Home Rule, they ousted the Conservatives and brought the Liberals to office.[11]

Galdstone's First Home Rule Bill was closely modelled on the self-government given to British settler colonies, starting with the Act of Union of 1840 (also called the "Canada Act"), and especially the British North America Act, 1867'.[12]Cite error: A <ref> tag is missing the closing </ref> (see the help page). Gladstone's proposals did not go as far as Irish nationalist opinion desired, but were too radical for unionists in both Ireland and Great Britain: his First Home Rule Bill was defeated in the House of Commons following a split in his own party. Gladstone took the issue to the people in the 1886 election, but the Unionists (Conservatives plus Liberal dissenters) held a majority over the Home Rule coalition (Liberals and Irish nationalists). Significantly, pro-Home Rule parties won majorities in Ireland, Scotland, and Wales, but not in England, where most seats were contested.[13]

With the Conservatives opposed to Home Rule, it slipped from the mainstream of British politics once they came into power in the 1890s. However, the Conservative government also felt that the demands for Home Rule were essentially materialist in origin, and that to improve conditions in Ireland would satisfy opinion there; this has been described as "killing home rule with kindness". Reforms passed as a result included the Local Government (Ireland) Act 1898 and the Wyndham Land Act.

Before the 1892 election, Parnell was caught in one of the "one of the most celebrated sex scandals of the century"[14] which caused Gladstone to disavow him, and splitting the Irish Parliamentary Party. Nevertheless, the 1892 election gave the pro-Home Rule forces a narrow majority, and again the Liberals had done better in Scotland and Wales than in England.[15] Gladstone introduced a Second Home Rule Bill in 1893, which this time would have kept Irish MPs in the British parliament, but it was defeated (as was expected) in the Conservative-dominated House of Lords.[16]

Outside of constitutional change, the British state tried other methods to placate Ireland. Between 1868 and 1908: spending on Ireland was generally increased, huge tracts of land were purchased from landlords and redistributed to smallholders, local government was democratised, and the franchise widely extended. The ending of so many social and economic grievances did not end Irish disenchantment, however. What this did accomplish was a simplification of the issues. No longer could British governments fool themselves into thinking that something other than satisfying Irish demands for national recognition and self-determination would answer the Irish question.[17]

Some Britons were beginning to be able to accept Irish nationalism as legitimate. British liberal support for home rule rested on the premise that the Irish people had withdrawn their consent to be governed by the United Kingdom by electing the Nationalists to repeated majorities, and the popular consent was a basic prerequisite for morally legitimate government.[18] In other words, for liberals it was immoral to hold the Irish in the Union against their will.

The competing idea among unionists was that it was impossible to give Ireland independence or it would be used as base from which Continental powers could attack Britain. Writing much later, after Irish independence, Winston Churchill stated that this this idea had taken on the status of dogma and had fossilized in British minds longer after it had ceased to have any basis in fact and that only the "large outside shock" of the First World War had changed this.[19]

The Liberals regained power in 1905. Following a confrontation with the House of Lords over the "People's Budget", a wider constitutional conflict developed, resulting in two general elections during 1910 and the passage of the Parliament Act 1911. The 1910 elections saw the Liberals lose seats in the Commons, necessitating the support of the Irish Parliamentary Party (now led by John Redmond). The Irish party expected their support to be repaid by the introduction of Home Rule, which with the removal of the House of Lords' veto power by the Parliament Act became a clear possibility for the first time.

The Third Home Rule Bill, introduced in 1912, provoked increasingly bitter opposition from Unionists, particularly those in Ulster. The Bill finally passed into law as the Government of Ireland Act 1914 a few weeks after the start of the First World War, but its implementation was simultaneously suspended for the duration of the war. The situation in Ireland had deteriorated severely, with both unionist Ulster Volunteers and nationalist Irish Volunteers openly drilling, and with both groups having imported arms. The war exacerbated tensions further, with unionists urging loyalty to the King by volunteering in the British Army, but with nationalists much more ambivalent about a war that was seen by many as Britain's and not Ireland's fight.

The 1916 Easter Rising in favour of an independent Irish Republic was suppressed without great difficulty by the British, but the severe measures taken by them in its aftermath further alienated nationalist opinion. An attempt to introduce a modified form of Home Rule was made by the Prime Minister Lloyd George in 1917 when he called together all parties within Ireland to an Irish Convention; however, after six months the Convention failed to reach agreement on the important question of whether Ulster was to be under the authority of any new Dublin parliament. The European situation with the threat of conscription (which had been operating in Great Britain but had not yet been introduced into Ireland) changed the political climate further, such that in the 1918 general election, the Irish Party lost most of its seats to the more radical Sinn Féin party.

Anglo-Irish War

The section in red left the UK in 1922.

In 1919, Sinn Féin MPs elected to Westminster formed a unilaterally independent Irish parliament in Dublin, the first Dáil Éireann with an executive under the President of Dáil Éireann, Éamon de Valera. A War of Independence was fought between 1919 and 1921. The island of Ireland was partitioned on 3 May 1921 under the Government of Ireland Act 1920 into two distinct autonomous United Kingdom regions, Northern Ireland and the short-lived Southern Ireland.[20] On 6 December 1922, a year after the Anglo-Irish Treaty was signed, the entire island of Ireland effectively seceded from the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland and formed a new dominion, the Irish Free State. As was widely expected, however, Northern Ireland immediately exercised its right under the Anglo-Irish Treaty, to opt out of the Irish Free State. On 7 December 1922 (the day after the establishment of the Irish Free State) the Parliament of Northern Ireland resolved to make an address to the King so as to opt out of the Irish Free State.[21] If Northern Ireland had not done so it would have become an autonomous part of the Irish Free State. With the King's acceptance of the petition, the Irish border became an international frontier.

The surviving Union of Great Britain with part of Ireland continued to be called the "United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland" until 1927, when it was renamed the "United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland" by the Royal and Parliamentary Titles Act 1927. One reason for this was that there was confusion as to whether the Irish Free State was a self-governing part of the United Kingdom. For instance, the Irish Free State Constitution Act 1922 refers to "the Irish Free State or... any other part of the United Kingdom".[22]

Partition of Ireland

The Anglo-Irish Treaty was given effect in the whole of the British Isles through the Irish Free State Constitution Act 1922. That Act established a new Dominion for the whole island of Ireland but also allowed Northern Ireland to opt out of it. Under Article 12 of the Treaty, Northern Ireland could exercise its opt out by presenting an address to the King requesting not to be part of the Irish Free State. Once the Treaty was ratified, the Houses of Parliament of Northern Ireland had one month to exercise this opt out during which month the Irish Free State Government could not legislate for Northern Ireland, holding the Free State’s effective jurisdiction in abeyance for a month.

On 7 December 1922 (the day after the establishment of the Irish Free State) the Houses of Parliament demonstrated its lack of hesitation by resolving to make the following address to the King so as to opt out of the Irish Free State:

”MOST GRACIOUS SOVEREIGN, We, your Majesty's most dutiful and loyal subjects, the Senators and Commons of Northern Ireland in Parliament assembled, having learnt of the passing of the Irish Free State Constitution Act, 1922, being the Act of Parliament for the ratification of the Articles of Agreement for a Treaty between Great Britain and Ireland, do, by this humble Address, pray your Majesty that the powers of the Parliament and Government of the Irish Free State shall no longer extend to Northern Ireland.”[23]

On 13 December 1922 Prime Minister James Craig addressed the Parliament of Northern Ireland, informing them that the King had responded to the Parliament’s address as follows (the King having received it on 8 December 1922):[24]

“I have received the Address presented to me by both Houses of the Parliament of Northern Ireland in pursuance of Article 12 of the Articles of Agreement set forth in the Schedule to the Irish Free State (Agreement) Act, 1922, and of Section 5 of the Irish Free State Constitution Act, 1922, and I have caused my Ministers and the Irish Free State Government to be so informed.”

Legacy

A passport from the Realm.

Despite increasing political independence from each other from 1922 and complete political independence since the new constitution of 1937, the union left the two countries intertwined with each other in many respects. Ireland used the Irish pound from 1928 until 2001 when the euro replaced it. Until it joined the ERM in 1979, the Irish pound was directly linked to the pound sterling. Decimalisation of both currencies occurred simultaneously on Decimal Day in 1971. Coins of equivalent value had the same dimensions and size until the introduction of the British twenty pence coin in 1982, the first new coin to be issued since the break with sterling. British coinage, therefore, although technically not legal tender in the Republic of Ireland was in wide circulation and usually acceptable as payment, and vice versa. The new British twenty pence coin and later British one pound coin were the notable exceptions to this, as there was initially no equivalent Irish coin value, and when subsequently, Irish coins of these values were introduced, their designs differed significantly, thereby not allowing for 'stealth' passing of the coins in change.

Irish citizens in the UK have a status almost equivalent to British citizens. They can vote in all elections and even stand for Parliament. As well as this, some people born in the Republic of Ireland before 1949, but after 3 March 1922, are British subjects. British citizens have similar rights to Irish citizens in the Republic of Ireland and can vote in all elections apart from presidential elections and referendums. Under the Irish nationality law anyone born on the island of Ireland to a British or Irish parent can have Irish citizenship and so most children born in Northern Ireland can have a British or an Irish passport (or both). Before 2005 there was no requirement for one parent to be a British or Irish citizen and so all persons born on the island of Ireland before then are entitled to be Irish citizens.[25]

George V, the last King to be styled as King of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland

List of monarchs

Until 1927, part of the monarch's royal title included the words King of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland. In 1927, the words United Kingdom were removed from the royal title so that the monarch was instead styled as King/Queen of Great Britain, Ireland...[and other places]. The words United Kingdom were restored to the monarch's title in 1953 with the reference to Ireland replaced with a reference to Northern Ireland.

See also

Footnotes

  1. ^ Jenkins, 8.
  2. ^ The State of Ireland, Hansard, 16 February 1844
  3. ^ Quoted in Jenkins, 43.
  4. ^ Jenkins, 47-48
  5. ^ Jenkins, 49
  6. ^ Jenkins, 10
  7. ^ Biagini, 2.
  8. ^ Hoppen, 567
  9. ^ Morton, 79
  10. ^ Hoppen, 567
  11. ^ Biagini, 9
  12. ^ Kendle, 44
  13. ^ Biagini, 10
  14. ^ Boyce, 38-39
  15. ^ Boyce, 39
  16. ^ Boyce, 28
  17. ^ Boyce, 47-48
  18. ^ Biagini, 51
  19. ^ Quoted in Fanning, 105
  20. ^ Order in Council of 3 May 1921 (SR&O 1921, No. 533). Their constitutional roots remained the Act of Union, two complimentary Acts, one passed by the Parliament of Great Britain, the other by the Parliament of Ireland.
  21. ^ Northern Ireland Parliamentary Report, 7 December 1922 and Anglo-Irish Treaty, sections 11, 12.
  22. ^ Irish Free State Constitution Act 1922, Section 2 (1)
  23. ^ Northern Ireland Parliamentary Report, 7 December 1922
  24. ^ Northern Ireland Parliamentary Report, 13 December 1922, Volume 2 (1922) / Pages 1191 – 1192, 13 December 1922
  25. ^ Emma Quinn; Emma Quinn, John Stanley, Corona Joyce, Philip J. O’connell (2008). Handbook on Immigration and Asylum in Ireland 2007. ESRI. pp. 26–. ISBN 978-0-7070-0274-3. Retrieved 4 November 2012.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)

External links

Preceded by:
Kingdom of Great Britain
1707–1801
Kingdom of Ireland
1541–1801
United Kingdom of
Great Britain and Ireland

1801–1922
Succeeded by:
United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland
1922–present
Irish Free State
1922–1937