National Labour Organisation

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
This article is about the political party that existed from 1931-1945. For the party that existed in the late 1950s, see National Labour Party (UK, 1957). For other uses of the name, see National Labour Party.
National Labour Organisation
Leader Ramsay MacDonald 1931–37
Malcolm MacDonald 1937–45
Founded 1931
Dissolved 14 June 1945
Split from Labour Party
Headquarters London
Newspaper News-Letter
Ideology Social democracy
Pro-National Government
Pro-Coalition

The National Labour Organisation, also known as the National Labour Committee, was a British political group formed after the 1931 creation of the National Government to co-ordinate the efforts of the supporters of the government who had come from the Labour Party. The most prominent Labour Party member involved in the Government was the Prime Minister, Ramsay MacDonald. National Labour sponsored Parliamentary candidates but did not consider itself a full political party as it had no policy distinctive from that of the Government which it supported. After MacDonald's death, the group continued in existence until winding up on the eve of the 1945 general election; its newsletter ceased publication two years later.

1931 election[edit]

The sudden decision to call a general election in October 1931 left MacDonald and the other Labour supporters with the difficult job of organising their own re-elections without any form of organisation. Preparations had been started on 19 September,[1] and by early October National Labour supporters had a list of 34 seats which they wanted to fight: 14 out of 15 sitting National Labour MPs wished to fight for re-election, and a further ten candidates were ready to stand in other seats. The group thought that a further ten candidates could easily be found.[2]

Finance and organisation[edit]

MacDonald was adamant that National Labour should be separate and not connected to Conservative Central Office. An offer of £100,000 funding from Lord Beaverbrook seems to have been declined, but Sir Alexander Grant gave £250 and the Duke of Westminster gave £2,000 through Maundy Gregory.[2] National Labour had collected £20,000 in total for election expenses.[3] At the start of the election MacDonald denied Labour Party claims that the funds had come from the Conservative Party.[4] Frank Markham (MacDonald's Parliamentary Private Secretary) and the junior minister Earl De La Warr set up a National Labour Committee to run the election.[3] De La Warr became chairman.

Candidates[edit]

Negotiations with Conservative Central Office began after a meeting on 25 September, when the Conservatives had reassured MacDonald that it would not be difficult to come to agreement. Frank Markham then drafted a list of 35 constituencies in which National Labour wanted to stand for election and wanted the Conservatives to support them. However the Conservatives objected to many of the entries, such as Kensington North and Birmingham Erdington which were marginal former Conservative seats that had only narrowly gone to Labour in 1929. Local Conservatives refused to withdraw their candidates, as they did in Liverpool Everton, where sitting MP Derwent Hall Caine found himself opposed (and eventually beaten) by a Conservative. By 14 October, with the close of nominations imminent, persistent Conservative associations and candidates had forced National Labour candidates to withdraw in four constituencies, and there were only 25 candidates confirmed, 10 of whom had Conservative opposition.[5]

MacDonald himself tried to intervene. On the day after the election was announced, he complained that Attorney-General Sir William Jowitt had been forced out of Preston, and the Conservatives could not find a local association willing to accept him. Conservative Party chairman Lord Stonehaven complained back to MacDonald about his promotion of "unknown candidates introduced at the very last moment by yourself" competing against Conservatives who had promised him their support, which risked handing the seats to the opposition.[6]

Of the 20 candidates actually nominated, six faced a rival Conservative candidate and one a rival Liberal National. Three more candidates withdrew before polling day.[5] The general organisation of National Labour, during the election, was run by Benjamin Musgrave.[7]

Creation of the organisation[edit]

In December, MacDonald's private secretary Herbert Usher wrote a long memorandum asking key questions about what type of ongoing organisation was needed. Usher stated that MacDonald needed to answer three crucial questions: first, whether he wanted to form a new party; second, whether he envisaged returning to the Labour Party, and third, whether the National Government would continue for a long time and produce a single party of the centre. Usher argued that it was not possible to create a distinctive National Labour Party because any distinctive policy would threaten the unity of the National Government coalition. He also contended that MacDonald could not return to the Labour Party which harboured extreme bitterness about the manner in which the National Government was formed. Usher concluded that the public favoured a large centrist party but that existing political organisations would not permit it.[8]

Early in 1932 a constitution and organisation was established and the monthly "News-Letter" set up for supporters which was edited by Clifford Allen.[7] An editorial in the first edition written by Allen emphasised that the News-Letter was "intended to be a means of contact between Labour supporters of the National Government" but also "begs the attention of public opinion."[9] The editorship was later taken by Godfrey Elton; both Allen and Elton received peerages from MacDonald. In September 1932, William Spofforth (formerly the Labour Party agent in Westhoughton) was appointed as secretary.[7]

Philip Snowden, who as Chancellor of the Exchequer had been second only to MacDonald in becoming a prominent Labour member of the National Government, remained nominally one of the National Labour cabinet members after the election, having received a Peerage. However Snowden rejected an invitation from Clifford Allen to write for the News-Letter, replying scathingly and declaring that "I really do not understand this National Labour Party". When Snowden resigned from the Government in opposition to the protectionist outcome of the Ottawa Conference in September 1932, he declared that he no longer had any party allegiance.[10]

Relations with the Conservatives[edit]

After the election MacDonald persisted in trying to find a seat for Jowitt. All that Stonehaven would offer was Nottingham South, where the Conservative Association might be persuaded to support Jowitt if the sitting National Labour member George Wilfrid Holford Knight stood down. Unexpectedly, Holford Knight refused to comply; MacDonald was angry with not him but the Conservatives for not offering a seat that they held. In July 1932 a by-election arose in Wednesbury, a seat that Labour had held at every election except 1931. De La Warr expressed to Stonehaven the hope that the local Conservatives would accept a National Labour candidate, but Stonehaven wrote back that the suggestion amazed him. He had tried, but the Wednesbury Conservative Association were obdurate in refusing to have a National Labour candidate, which would mean handing over their organisation and funding the campaign. MacDonald may have considered resigning, but he decided only to refuse to send a message of support to the Conservative, who ended up losing the seat to Labour anyway.[11]

In its publicity, National Labour was concerned to stress that although Parliament was heavily dominated by the Conservatives, the cabinet was much more evenly balanced between the parties.[12]

In 1933 a local electoral pact was agreed in Finsbury between National Labour and the Municipal Reform Party in advance of the London County Council election in 1934. The Parliamentary constituency had a National Labour MP, but the two LCC seats were held by Labour, and the pact agreed that Kenneth Lindsay would run in conjunction with one Municipal Reform candidate in the election.[13] In the event Michael Franklin of National Labour and Fordham Flower of Municipal Reform stood as 'National Municipal' candidates, but they failed to win seats.[14]

Policy and publicity[edit]

While National Labour could not advocate any policy in opposition to the National Government, its members gave policy suggestions and argued in support of Government policy. A pamphlet, called "On the Home Front" published in April 1934, outlined the National Labour argument in support of the National Government's domestic policy; it argued that the agricultural policy followed by the Government had "the characteristic Conservative policy of a tariff" as well as "the characteristic Socialist State organisation of industry" and therefore showed what the Government "owes to the traditional doctrines of not one, but all, Parties in the State".[15] The pamphlet asserted that returning to the old party system would mean weak government and that it was weak government that had led other European countries to dictatorship.[16]

Looking back on the politics of the 1930s in a 1964 article, Professor Arthur Marwick regarded National Labour's significance as being "a central point around which people who desired political agreement could cohere". He noted that National Labour could attract to collectivist socialism some who were put off by the resolutely working-class character of the Labour Party and cited Harold Nicolson as a case in point.[17]

In April 1935 a volume of essays by five leading National Labour politicians was published, under the title "Towards a National Policy: being a National Labour Contribution". MacDonald contributed a preface in which he argued that the Labour opposition "is as little guided by Socialist opinion and inspired by the fine human spirit of our British Socialism as any other political party of pure expediency striving for a majority".[18] Lord Elton argued that trade unions should not affiliate to the Labour Party because they could achieve more by bargaining for support when not tied to one political party.[19]

1935 election[edit]

MacDonald remained Prime Minister as the head of a coalition government until June 1935, when he gave way to Stanley Baldwin and became instead Lord President of the Council. At the 1935 general election the party sponsored 20 candidates, eight of whom were elected. Immediately after the election, the News-Letter argued that Labour supporters of the National Government were hidden "thanks to the trade union 'terror'" and that the party ought to appeal for the votes of all socialists and trade unionists opposed to being herded into the political wilderness.[20] When Ramsay MacDonald's son, Malcolm, fought the Ross and Cromarty by-election of 1936, he found himself opposed by Randolph Churchill standing as a Conservative and arguing that 'National Labour' was a "sham device" with no real support.[21] After learning of his son's success, Ramsay MacDonald corrected a correspondent who had referred to "Labour's defeat" by asserting, "Labour was victorious, and a queer mixture which had neither principle nor political policy, now known as Opposition Labour, was defeated".[22]

Later years[edit]

On 18 October 1937, Ramsay MacDonald officially opened the new headquarters of the National Labour Organisation at 57 Tufton Street.[23]A month later MacDonald was dead. The National Labour Organisation continued, although it postponed its conference until March 1938.[24] When the conference happened, The Times greeted it with a leader commending the party for striking "deeper roots than a group formed around a particular personality".[25] Malcolm MacDonald took the leadership of the group in Parliament and National Labour members retained office; the party issued a declaration of support for Neville Chamberlain over the Munich Agreement.[26]

In the first edition of the News-Letter for 1939, a declaration from National Labour was printed. It pledged support for a united Empire, a strong League of Nations ("for bringing about constructive schemes of world appeasement, economic as well as political"), the national planning of our economic life, preservation of the countryside and the improvement of social services.[27] When Germany invaded the whole of Czechoslovakia in March 1939, an editorial called for "a Government of national concentration" which would have to include "the trusted leaders of the trade unions and the Opposition parties".[28] A Parliamentary motion from Anthony Eden and Winston Churchill calling for a National government "on the widest possible basis" was given support from the News-Letter in the following issue.[29]

In the run-up to an expected general election in autumn 1939, several National Labour candidates were adopted and the party attracted some high-profile figures to defect to it (including former MP Michael Marcus). The outbreak of war, delaying the election, forced the group to reconsider. In February 1940 it was announced that the party would not be holding an annual conference that year, and had suspended publication of "News Letter". In February 1942 Stephen King-Hall resigned from the Parliamentary Party, stating that he wanted to oppose the involvement of party political considerations in wartime.[30] In May 1943 he was followed by Kenneth Lindsay reducing the Parliamentary group to only five in number.[31] Earl De La Warr resigned in August 1943,[32] succeeded as chairman by Richard Denman.

Dissolution[edit]

A special conference of the National Labour Organisation on 14 June 1945 decided to dissolve the party. Malcolm Macdonald chose not to defend his seat and retired from front-line politics. The other former National Labour MPs adopted were redesignated to run as 'National' Parliamentary candidates. The organisation issued a closing statement that praised the Labour Party for joining the Coalition in 1940 and condemned it for breaking up the Coalition immediately after victory in Europe. It called "all men and women of progressive outlook" to vote to re-elect the Churchill government.[33] The "Election Diary" in The Observer in recording the dissolution, considered the surprising thing to be that it took place in a year as late as 1945.[34]

All five of the candidates were defeated in the election, but Kenneth Lindsay was re-elected as an Independent after moving constituencies from Kilmarnock to Combined English Universities. The News-Letter continued, with an editorial line critical of the post-war Labour Government. In September 1946, it urged progressive members of the Conservative Party to discard their name and join with the Liberal Party under another name; the editorial believed "the struggle for the future will be for individual rights against the omnipotent State, democracy against despotism".[35] The last edition of the News-Letter was dated April–July 1947.[36]

Subsequently Harold Nicolson joined the Labour Party and stood as its candidate in the 1948 Croydon North by-election, which he lost. Sir Frank Markham joined the Conservatives and returned to the House of Commons in 1951 as the MP for Buckingham at the 1951 General Election. Markham retired from parliament in 1964.

Candidacies[edit]

The candidates sponsored by the National Labour committee and the subsequent National Labour Organisation were as follows. Those listed in bold were successful in at least one election.

Colour Key:   Seat gained   Seat held (in 1931, seat held by sitting MP)

Constituency Candidate 1931
gen. election
By-elections 1935
gen. election
By-elections
Votes  % Date Votes  % Votes  % Date Votes  %
Bassetlaw Malcolm James MacDonald 27,136 66.6 20,764 48.7 Elected for Ross and Cromarty
Bristol East Archibald George Church 15,126 40.7 Contested Derby
Cardiff Central Sir Ernest Nathaniel Bennett 24,120 69.2 16,954 51.6
Colne Valley Michael Arthur Ernest Franklin 202 0.5
Combined English Universities Rt Hon Sir William Allen Jowitt 2,759 20.1
Combined Scottish Universities Rt Hon James Ramsay MacDonald 27–31 Jan. 1936 16,393 56.5
Derby Rt Hon James Henry Thomas 39,688 35.4 37,566 30.1
Archibald George Church 9 July 1936 25,666 47.5
Dewsbury John Fennell 8,798 29.5
Essex South East Felix Greene 6,539 11.5
Finsbury Sir George Masterman Gillett 17,292 63.1 10,600 44.2
Forest of Dean Dr John Vigers Worthington 14,815 52.7 12,337 42.4
Gateshead John Fennell 187 0.3
Ilkeston Abraham John Flint 17,587 50.0
Kilmarnock Rt Hon Craigie Mason Aitchison 21,803 59.6
Kenneth Martin Lindsay 2 Nov. 1933 12,577 34.8 19,115 50.9
Lambeth North Sydney Frank Markham 23 Oct. 1934 2,927 15.0
Leeds Central Hon Richard Douglas Denman 26,496 71.4 17,747 56.4
Leek Leslie Montagu Thomas 17,419 42.6
Leicester West Hon Harold George Nicolson 15,821 43.7
Lichfield James Alexander Lovat-Fraser 26,669 62.8 23,489 53.8
George Beresford Craddock 5 May 1938 22,760 49.1
Liverpool Everton Derwent Hall Caine 4,950 19.9
Middlesbrough West William Arthur Spofforth 11,387 30.1
Newcastle upon Tyne Central William Henry Dashwood Caple 94 0.3
Nottingham South George Wilfred Holford Knight 22,852 68.3
Sydney Frank Markham 15,559 52.3
Ormskirk Samuel Thomas Rosbotham 30,368 75.0 27,624 58.5
William Stephen Richard King-Hall 27 Oct. 1939 unopposed
Peckham Ernest James Titler 1,442 4.3
Ross and Cromarty Rt Hon Malcolm James MacDonald 10 Feb. 1936 8,949 49.5
Seaham Rt Hon James Ramsay MacDonald 28,978 55.0 17,882 31.8 Elected for Comb. Scottish Univs.
Southwark Central Ernest Stanford 9,735 46.7
South Shields Frederick Frank Arthur Burden 10,784 23.6
Tottenham South Francis Noel Palmer 17,824 58.6 15,834 41.5
Wednesbury Rev Herbert Dunnico 19,883 46.7

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Andrew Thorpe, "The British General Election of 1931", Oxford University Press, 1991, p. 104.
  2. ^ a b Andrew Thorpe, "The British General Election of 1931", Oxford University Press, 1991, p. 117.
  3. ^ a b David Marquand, "Ramsay MacDonald", Jonathan Cape, 1977, p. 675.
  4. ^ "No Funds from Unionists", The Times, 14 October 1931, p. 12.
  5. ^ a b Andrew Thorpe, "The British General Election of 1931", Oxford University Press, 1991, pp. 172–4.
  6. ^ Tom Stannage, "Baldwin Thwarts the Opposition", Croom Helm, 1980, pp. 17–18.
  7. ^ a b c "National Labour Party", The Times, 14 September 1932, p. 10.
  8. ^ David Marquand, "Ramsay MacDonald", Jonathan Cape, 1977, p. 675-6.
  9. ^ News-Letter, vol. 1 no. 1 (2 April 1932), p. 8.
  10. ^ Colin Cross, "Philip Snowden", Barrie and Rockliff, 1966, p. 329-30.
  11. ^ Tom Stannage, "Baldwin Thwarts the Opposition", Croom Helm, 1980, pp. 34–36.
  12. ^ "On the Home Front", issued by the National Labour Committee, April 1934, p. 5.
  13. ^ "Anti-Socialist Alliance For L.C.C. Election", The Times, 19 January 1933, p. 9.
  14. ^ Alan Willis and John Woollard, "Twentieth Century Local Election Results" vol 1, Local Government Chronicle Elections Centre, 2000, p. 30.
  15. ^ "On the Home Front", National Labour Committee, 1934, p. 17-18.
  16. ^ "On the Home Front", National Labour Committee, 1934, p. 18-19.
  17. ^ Arthur Marwick, "Middle Opinion in the Thirties: Planning, Progress and Political 'Agreement'", The English Historical Review vol 79 no 311 (April 1964), Oxford University Press, pp. 289–90.
  18. ^ "Towards a National Policy", Longmans & Co., 1935, p. xii.
  19. ^ Towards a National Policy", Longmans & Co., 1935, p. 27-8.
  20. ^ "Election of a Speaker", The Times, 22 November 1935, p. 14.
  21. ^ "Ross Candidates' Addresses", The Times, 3 February 1936, p. 9.
  22. ^ David Marquand, "Ramsay MacDonald", Jonathan Cape, 1977, p. 782.
  23. ^ "New National Labour Headquarters", The Times, 19 October 1937, p. 18.
  24. ^ The Times, 20 December 1937, p. 14.
  25. ^ "National Labour", The Times, 19 March 1938, p. 13.
  26. ^ "National Labour and Mr. Chamberlain", The Times, 4 October 1938, p. 16.
  27. ^ News-Letter, vol. 2 (new series) no. 23 (14 January 1939), p. vi.
  28. ^ News-Letter, vol. 3 no. 28 (25 March 1939), p. 30.
  29. ^ News-Letter, vol. 3, no. 29 (8 April 1939), p. 58.
  30. ^ "Cdr. King-Hall to sit as Independent M.P.", The Times, 24 February 1942, p. 2.
  31. ^ "Mr. K. Lindsay as Independent", The Times, 29 May 1943, p. 2.
  32. ^ "Lord De La Warr's Resignation", The Times, 20 August 1943, p. 4.
  33. ^ "National Labour and the Election", The Times, 15 June 1945, p. 8.
  34. ^ "Election Diary", The Observer, 17 June 1945, p. 5.
  35. ^ "A Democratic Party", News-Letter, vol. 9 no. 5 (September 1946), pp. 133–4.
  36. ^ News-Letter, vol. 10, no. 2.