1886–87 United States Senate elections

United States Senate elections, 1886 and 1887
25 of the 76 seats in the U.S. Senate; (as well as special elections); 39 seats needed for a majority
Majority Party before election; Republican;	Elected Majority Party ; Republican;

The United States Senate elections of 1886 and 1887 were elections that had the Republican Party lose two seats in the United States Senate. At the beginning of the 50th Congress, therefore, Republicans had the slimmest possible majority due to a vacant Democratic seat: 38 out of 75 seats. Once that vacancy was filled, Republicans maintained control as the single Readjuster Senator caucused with them.

As these elections were prior to ratification of the seventeenth amendment, Senators were chosen by State legislatures.

Results summary

Colored shading indicates party with largest share of that row.

Parties		Democratic	Readjuster	Republican	Total
Parties		style="background-color:Template:Democratic Party (United States)/meta/color" \|	style="background-color:Template:Readjuster Party (United States)/meta/color" \|	style="background-color:Template:Republican Party (United States)/meta/color" \|	Total
Before these elections		34	2	40	78
Not up		25	1	25	51
	Class 2 (1886/87 → 1892/93)	13	1	12	26
	Class 3 (1884/85 → 1890/91)	11	—	13	24
Up		11	1	16	28
	General: Class 1	9	1	15	25
	Special: Class 1	1	—	—	1
	Special: Class 2	1	—	—	1
	Special: Class 3	—	—	1	1

General election only
Incumbent retired		1	—	2	3
	Held by same party	—	—	1	1
	Gained by other party	1	—	1	1
	No elected successor	1	—	—	1
	Result	1	—	1	2
Incumbent ran		6	1	12	19
	Won re-election	4	—	7	11
	Held by same party	1	—	3	4
	Gained by other party	1	—	1	4
		2	—	2
		1	1	—
	No elected successor	—	—	—	—
	Result	8	—	11	19
Incumbent's action unknown		2	—	1	3
	Held by same party	2	—	1	3
	No elected successor	—	—	—	—
	Gained by other party	—	—	—	—
	Result	2	—	1	3

Total elected		11	—	13	24
Net change		2	1	2	1

Result		36	1	38	75

Change in Senate composition

Before the elections

After August 4, 1886 special election in California.

R₂₉ Ran	R₃₀ Ran	R₃₁ Ran	R₃₂ Ran	R₃₃ Ran	R₃₄ Ran	R₃₅ Ran	R₃₆ Ran	R₃₇ Ran	R₃₈ Unknown
D₈	D₇	D₆	D₅	D₄	D₃	D₂	D₁
D₉	D₁₀	D₁₁	D₁₂	D₁₃	D₁₄	D₁₅	D₁₆	D₁₇	D₁₈
D₂₈ Ran	D₂₇ Ran	D₂₆ Ran	D₂₅	D₂₄	D₂₃	D₂₂	D₂₁	D₂₀	D₁₉
D₂₉ Ran	D₃₀ Ran	D₃₁ Ran	D₃₂ Unknown	D₃₃ Unknown	D₃₄ Retired	RA₂ Ran	RA₁	R₄₀ Retired	R₃₉ Retired
Majority →									R₃₉ Retired
R₂₈ Ran	R₂₇ Ran	R₂₆ Ran	R₂₅	R₂₄	R₂₃	R₂₂	R₂₁	R₂₀	R₁₉
R₉	R₁₀	R₁₁	R₁₂	R₁₃	R₁₄	R₁₅	R₁₆	R₁₇	R₁₈
R₈	R₇	R₆	R₅	R₄	R₃	R₂	R₁

After the elections

R₂₉ Re-elected	R₃₀ Re-elected	R₃₁ Re-elected	R₃₂ Re-elected	R₃₃ Hold	R₃₄ Hold	R₃₅ Hold	R₃₆ Hold	R₃₇ Hold	R₃₈ Gain from D
D₈	D₇	D₆	D₅	D₄	D₃	D₂	D₁
D₉	D₁₀	D₁₁	D₁₂	D₁₃	D₁₄	D₁₅	D₁₆	D₁₇	D₁₈
D₂₈ Re-elected	D₂₇ Re-elected	D₂₆ Re-elected	D₂₅	D₂₄	D₂₃	D₂₂	D₂₁	D₂₀	D₁₉
D₂₉ Re-elected	D₃₀ Hold	D₃₁ Hold	D₃₂ Hold	D₃₃ Gain from RA	D₃₄ Gain from R	D₃₅ Gain from R	D₃₆ Gain from R	V₁ D Loss	RA₁
Majority due to vacancy→									R₃₈ Gain from D
R₂₈ Re-elected	R₂₇ Re-elected	R₂₆ Re-elected	R₂₅	R₂₄	R₂₃	R₂₂	R₂₁	R₂₀	R₁₉
R₉	R₁₀	R₁₁	R₁₂	R₁₃	R₁₄	R₁₅	R₁₆	R₁₇	R₁₈
R₈	R₇	R₆	R₅	R₄	R₃	R₂	R₁

At the beginning of the first session, December 7, 1887

D₈	D₇	D₆	D₅	D₄	D₃	D₂	D₁
D₉	D₁₀	D₁₁	D₁₂	D₁₃	D₁₄	D₁₅	D₁₆	D₁₇	D₁₈
D₂₈	D₂₇	D₂₆	D₂₅	D₂₄	D₂₃	D₂₂	D₂₁	D₂₀	D₁₉
D₂₉	D₃₀	D₃₁	D₃₂	D₃₃	D₃₄	D₃₅	D₃₆	D₃₇ Gain from V	RA₁
Majority with Readjuster in caucus →									R₃₈
R₂₉	R₃₀	R₃₁	R₃₂	R₃₃	R₃₄	R₃₅	R₃₆	R₃₇	R₃₈
R₂₈	R₂₇	R₂₆	R₂₅ Hold	R₂₄	R₂₃	R₂₂	R₂₁	R₂₀	R₁₉
R₉	R₁₀	R₁₁	R₁₂	R₁₃	R₁₄	R₁₅	R₁₆	R₁₇	R₁₈
R₈	R₇	R₆	R₅	R₄	R₃	R₂	R₁

Key:

D_#	Democratic
RA_#	Readjuster
R_#	Republican
V_#	Vacant

Race summaries

Elections during the 49th Congress

In these elections, the winners were seated during 1886 or in 1887 before March 4; ordered by election date.

State	Incumbent			Results	Candidates
State	Senator	Party	Electoral history	Results	Candidates
Mississippi (Class 2)	Edward C. Walthall	Democratic	1885 (Appointed)	Interim appointee elected January 20, 1886.^[2]	√ Edward C. Walthall (Democratic) [data missing]
California (Class 1)	George Hearst	Democratic	1886 (Appointed)	Unknown if interim appointee retired or lost election to finish the term. New senator elected August 4, 1886. Republican gain. Winner did not run for election to the next term, see below.	√ Abram P. Williams (Republican) [data missing]
Illinois (Class 3)	John A. Logan	Republican	1870 or 1871 1877 (Lost re-election) 1879 1885	Incumbent died December 26, 1886. New senator elected January 19, 1887. Republican hold.	√ Charles B. Farwell (Republican) [data missing]

Races leading to the 50th Congress

In these general elections, the winners were elected for the term beginning March 4, 1887; ordered by state.

All of the elections involved the Class 1 seats.

State	Incumbent			Results	Candidates
State	Senator	Party	Electoral history	Results	Candidates
California	Abram Williams	Republican	1886 (Special)	Incumbent retired. New senator elected in 1887. Democratic gain.	√ George Hearst (Democratic) [data missing]
Connecticut	Joseph Roswell Hawley	Republican	1881	Incumbent re-elected in 1887.	√ Joseph Roswell Hawley (Republican) [data missing]
Delaware	George Gray	Democratic	1885 (Special)	Incumbent re-elected in 1887.	√ George Gray (Democratic) [data missing]
Florida	Charles W. Jones	Democratic	1881	Incumbent retired. Legislature failed to elect. Democratic loss.	[data missing]
Indiana	Benjamin Harrison	Republican	1880 or 1881	Incumbent lost re-election. New senator elected in 1887. Democratic gain.	√ David Turpie (Democratic) Benjamin Harrison (Republican) [data missing]
Maine	Eugene Hale	Republican	1881	Incumbent re-elected in 1887.	√ Eugene Hale (Republican) [data missing]
Maryland	Arthur P. Gorman	Democratic	1880	Incumbent re-elected in 1886.	√ Arthur P. Gorman (Democratic) [data missing]
Massachusetts	Henry L. Dawes	Republican	1857 1881	Incumbent re-elected in 1887.	√ Henry L. Dawes (Republican) [data missing]
Michigan	Omar D. Conger	Republican	1881	Incumbent lost renomination. New senator elected in 1887. Republican hold.	√ Francis B. Stockbridge (Republican) [data missing]
Minnesota	Samuel J. R. McMillan	Republican	1881	Incumbent retired. New senator elected in 1886. Republican hold.	√ Cushman Davis (Republican) [data missing]
Mississippi	James Z. George	Democratic	1880	Incumbent re-elected in 1886.	√ James Z. George (Democratic) [data missing]
Missouri	Francis Cockrell	Democratic	1874 1881	Incumbent re-elected in 1887.	√ Francis Cockrell (Democratic) [data missing]
Nebraska	Charles Van Wyck	Republican	1880	Incumbent lost re-election. New senator elected in 1886. Republican hold.	√ Algernon Paddock (Republican) Charles Van Wyck (Republican) [data missing]
Nevada	James Graham Fair	Democratic	1881	Incumbent lost re-election. New senator elected in 1887. Republican gain.	√ William Morris Stewart (Republican) James Graham Fair (Democratic) [data missing]
New Jersey	William Joyce Sewell	Republican	1881	Incumbent lost re-election. New senator elected in 1886. Democratic gain.	√ Rufus Blodgett (Democratic) William Joyce Sewell (Republican) [data missing]
New York	Warner Miller	Republican	1881 (Special)	Incumbent lost renomination. New senator elected January 20, 1887. Republican hold.	√ Frank Hiscock (Republican) Levi P. Morton (Republican) Smith M. Weed (Democratic) Francis Kernan (Democratic)
Ohio	John Sherman	Republican	1861 (Special) 1866 1872 1877 (Resigned) 1881	Incumbent re-elected in 1886.	√ John Sherman (Republican) [data missing]
Pennsylvania	John I. Mitchell	Republican	1881	Unknown if incumbent retired or lost re-election. New senator elected January 18, 1887. Republican hold.	√ Matthew Quay (Republican) 65.74% Simon P. Wolverton (Democratic) 31.87%
Rhode Island	Nelson W. Aldrich	Republican	1881 (Special)	Incumbent re-elected in 1886.	√ Nelson W. Aldrich (Republican) [data missing]
Tennessee	Washington C. Whitthorne	Democratic	1886 (Appointed)	Unknown if interim appointee retired or lost re-election. New senator elected in 1887. Democratic hold.	√ William B. Bate (Democratic) [data missing]
Texas	Samuel B. Maxey	Democratic	1875 1881	Incumbent lost re-election New senator elected in 1887. Democratic hold.	√ John Henninger Reagan (Democratic) [data missing]
Vermont	George F. Edmunds	Republican	1866 (Appointed) 1866 (Special) 1868 1874 1880	Incumbent re-elected in 1886.	√ George F. Edmunds (Republican) [data missing]
Virginia	William Mahone	Readjuster	1881	Incumbent lost re-election. New senator elected in 1887. Democratic gain.	√ John W. Daniel (Democratic) [data missing]
West Virginia	Johnson N. Camden	Democratic	1880 or 1881	Incumbent lost renomination.^[3] Legislature failed to elect. Democratic loss. A new senator was elected late, see below.	Johnson N. Camden (Democratic)
Wisconsin	Philetus Sawyer	Republican	1881	Incumbent re-elected in 1887.	√ Philetus Sawyer (Republican) [data missing]

Elections during the 50th Congress

In these elections, the winners were elected in 1887 after March 4; ordered by date.

State	Incumbent			Results	Candidates
State	Senator	Party	Electoral history	Results	Candidates
West Virginia (Class 1)	Vacant			Legislature had failed to elect, see above. New senator elected May 5, 1887. Democratic gain.	√ Charles J. Faulkner (Democratic) 48 votes Flick (Republican) 31 votes Barbee (Greenback) 6 votes Johnson N. Camden (Democratic) 1 vote B. S. Brown 1 vote Whittaker 2 votes^[4]
Florida (Class 1)	Vacant			Legislature had failed to elect, see above. New senator elected late May 19, 1887. Democratic gain.	√ Samuel Pasco (Democratic) [data missing]
New Hampshire (Class 2)	Person C. Cheney	Republican	1886 (Appointed)	Interim appointee retired when successor elected. New senator elected June 14, 1887. Republican hold.	√ William E. Chandler (Republican) [data missing]
Virginia (Class 2)	Harrison H. Riddleberger	Readjuster	1881	Incumbent retired. New senator elected December 20, 1887 for the term beginning in 1889.^[5] Democratic gain.	√ John S. Barbour Jr. (Democratic) [data missing]

New York

The election in New York was held from January 18 to 20, 1887. Republican Warner Miller had been elected to this seat in a special election in 1881 to succeed Thomas C. Platt who had resigned. Miller's term would expire on March 3, 1887. At the State election in November 1885, 20 Republicans and 12 Democrats were elected for a two-year term (1886-1887) in the State Senate. At the State election in November 1886, 74 Republicans and 54 Democrats were elected for the session of 1887 to the Assembly. The 110th New York State Legislature met from January 4 to May 26, 1887, at Albany, New York.

The caucus of Republican State legislators met on January 17, President pro tempore of the State Senate Edmund L. Pitts presided. 20 State senators and 71 assemblymen attended. Ex-Speaker of the Assembly George Z. Erwin (a Morton man) moved that a majority of all Republican legislators should be necessary to nominate, not only a majority of those present, meaning that 48 votes were required instead of 46, which was carried by a vote of 52 to 39. The incumbent U.S. Senator Warner Miller (Half-Breed faction) failed to be nominated by only four votes. Levi P. Morton (Stalwart faction) was rejected by the caucus, like in 1885. A small faction voted for Congressman Frank Hiscock. After the second ballot, Erwin moved to adjourn, which was carried by 48 to 43. The caucus met again on the next day, no choice was made in another two ballots. The caucus met again on January 19 after the joint ballot of the State Legislature, and after twelve more ballots, Erwin withdrew Morton's name and urged the Morton men to vote for Hiscock. On the next ballot Hiscock received one vote more than Miller (47 to 46), but was one short of the previously established majority of 48. On the 18th and last ballot, Hiscock received 50 votes and was nominated. On the next day, Hiscock was elected on the second joint ballot of the State Legislature. Thus, by blocking Miller's re-election, the Republican boss Thomas C. Platt took his revenge for his defeat at the special election in 1881.

**1887 Republican caucus for United States Senator**
Ballot	Date	Warner Miller	Levi P. Morton	√ Frank Hiscock
1st	January 17	44	35	12
2nd	January 17	44	36	11
3rd	January 18
4th	January 18
5th	January 19	46	36	11
6th	January 19	46	36	11
7th	January 19	46	36	11
8th	January 19	46	36	11
9th	January 19	46	36	11
10th	January 19	46	36	11
11th	January 19	46	36	11
12th	January 19	46	36	11
13th	January 19	46	36	11
14th	January 19	46	36	11
15th	January 19	46	36	11
16th	January 19	46	36	11
17th	January 19	46	Withdrew	47
18th	January 19	43		50

The Democratic caucus nominated Smith Mead Weed (1834-1920), a lawyer and businessman of Plattsburgh, New York. Weed had been a member of the New York State Assembly from Clinton County, New York in 1865, 1866, 1867, 1871, 1873 and 1874; and a delegate to the 1876 and 1884 Democratic National Conventions.

**1887 general election for United States Senator**
House	Democratic		Republican		Republican		Republican
State Senate (32 members) January 18	Smith M. Weed	11	Warner Miller	10	Levi P. Morton	9	Frank Hiscock	1
State Assembly (128 members) January 18	Smith M. Weed	41	Warner Miller	32	Levi P. Morton	26	Frank Hiscock	10
Joint ballot (160 members) January 19	Smith M. Weed	61	Warner Miller	43	Levi P. Morton	33	Frank Hiscock	11
Second joint ballot (160 members) January 20	Smith M. Weed	62					√ Frank Hiscock	91

Pennsylvania

The election in Pennsylvania was held January 18, 1887. Matthew Quay was elected by the Pennsylvania General Assembly to the United States Senate.^[6] The General Assembly, consisting of the House of Representatives and Senate voted as follows:

State Legislature Results^[6]^[7]
Party		Candidate	Votes	%
	Republican	Matthew Quay	165	65.74
	Democratic	Simon P. Wolverton	80	31.87
	N/A	Not voting	6	2.39
Totals			251	100.00%

Notes

^ The Readjusters caucused with the Republicans.
^ Byrd, p. 130.
^ "STILL FIGHTING OVER CAMDEN" (PDF).
^ "WEST VIRGINIA'S SENATOR.; A SUCCESSOR TO CAMDEN CHOSEN AT LAST" (PDF).
^ "Barbour, John S. (1820–1892)". www.encyclopediavirginia.org.
^ ^a ^b "U.S. Senate Election - 18 January 1887" (PDF). Wilkes University. Retrieved December 23, 2012.
^ "PA US Senate - 1887". OurCampaigns. Retrieved December 22, 2012.

References

Byrd, Robert C. (October 1, 1993). Wolff, Wendy (ed.). "The Senate, 1789-1989: Historical Statistics, 1789-1992". United States Senate Historical Office (volume 4 Bicentennial ed.). Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
Cox, Harold (January 31, 2007). "Pennsylvania Election Statistics: 1682-2006". The Wilkes University Election Statistics Project. Wilkes University.
"HISCOCK WINS THE PRIZE; MORTON WITHDRAWN FROM THE SENATORIAL FIGHT" (PDF). The New York Times. January 20, 1887.
"Members of the 50th United States Congress" (PDF). U.S. Government Printing Office.
"MILLER LEADS IN CAUCUS; BUT WANTS FOUR VOTES OF A NOMINATING MAJORITY" (PDF). The New York Times. January 18, 1887.
"MR. HISCOCK'S ELECTION" (PDF). The New York Times. January 21, 1887.
"Party Division in the Senate, 1789-Present". Senate.gov. United States Senate.
"SMITH M. WEED DIES IN PLATTSBURG" (PDF). The New York Times. June 8, 1920.

[caucus-1] The Readjusters caucused with the Republicans.

[Byrd130-2] Byrd, p. 130.

[3] "STILL FIGHTING OVER CAMDEN" (PDF).

[4] "WEST VIRGINIA'S SENATOR.; A SUCCESSOR TO CAMDEN CHOSEN AT LAST" (PDF).

[5] "Barbour, John S. (1820–1892)". www.encyclopediavirginia.org.

[results-6] "U.S. Senate Election - 18 January 1887" (PDF). Wilkes University. Retrieved December 23, 2012.

[7] "PA US Senate - 1887". OurCampaigns. Retrieved December 22, 2012.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]