Talk:Aristotle

Archives 2001 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

Logic

I believe we could improve the section about logic. It did not icluded what he did The "History" part is ok, and I don't really know anything about the topic to make comments on it. I believe, though, that the section called "Analytics and Organon" should be renamed "The Logical Treatises". Also, I think we should supress the word "aristotelian" in the sentence What we call today Aristotelian logic, Aristotle himself would have labelled analytics, for it just confuses: wouldn't Aristotle label as analytics any other philosophy of this kind? After listing the books of the Organon, we could mention that this corpus is called Organon.

Then, we could include a paragraph about syllogisms and another about dialetics, but not go to much into details, since this is the subject of the article about the Organon. Bhvilar 11:01, 7 May 2006

Bias

The following line is unsubstantiated and untrue:

"Near the end of his life, Alexander became paranoid and wrote threatening letters to Aristotle."

The following line makes an unsubstantiated implication, that Callisthenes was executed because of Aristotle's contempt for Alexander's "pretense at divinity:"

"Aristotle had made no secret of his contempt for Alexander's pretense of divinity and the king had executed Aristotle's grandnephew Callisthenes as a traitor."

That phrase, "pretense at divinity," by the way, is also misleading.

My suggestion is to delete those two sentences. Thoughts?

--Mattfwbooks (talk) 14:23, 4 May 2014 (UTC)

I agree that the letters between Aristotle and Alexander (we're talking the Secret of Secrets, right?) do not imply any threats toward Aristotle, but I'm not sure the sources, particularly Plutarch, would support that Alexander didn't start to become paranoid in general.

Again, I didn't find a statement regarding Callistenes, but I do know of a section of one of Aristotle's letters to Alexander that criticizes him for treating Persians as if not better than Greeks. "For Alexander did not follow Aristotle’s advice to treat the Greeks as if he were their leader, and other peoples as if he were their master... That seems to support a mention of the falling out, though the nature of it should be amended. The Cap'n (talk) 06:51, 5 May 2014 (UTC)

As far as substantiation, I just looked up the source, Peter Green's Alexander of Macedon. It mentions that Alexander killed Callisthenes as a traitor, but merely hints that Aristotle was uncomfortable with this or Alexander's letter informing he and Antipater of the execution. Aristotle is referenced at having issues with Alexander, but mostly over his "Orientalism" and not his deification, which most bothered Antipater. I agree with you, this whole section is misleading, but I think it'd be better to adjust it to fit the facts rather than delete it, as Green is an authority of Alexander and the falling out is a significant occurrence. The Cap'n (talk) 07:06, 5 May 2014 (UTC)

Yes, I agree, it does seem clear that the falling out with Aristotle was over Alexander's "Persianizing," and Aristotle's stated view that Persians were fit only to be slaves, a view that Alexander doesn't seem to have shared. Callisthenes's execution seems to have less to do with Aristotle than with the conspiracy of Hermolaos. --Mattfwbooks (talk) 13:46, 5 May 2014 (UTC)

The page is semi-protected, and I don't have the rights to edit it. Would someone else change the paragraph? Here's my suggestion, but feel free to change it. "Near the end of his life, Alexander and Aristotle became estranged over Alexander's relationship with Persia and Persians. A widespread tradition in antiquity suspected Aristotle of playing a role in Alexander's death, but there is little evidence. --Mattfwbooks (talk) 18:36, 10 May 2014 (UTC)

Please change "Near the end of his life, Alexander became paranoid and wrote threatening letters to Aristotle. Aristotle had made no secret of his contempt for Alexander's pretense of divinity and the king had executed Aristotle's grandnephew Callisthenes as a traitor." to "Near the end of his life, Alexander and Aristotle became estranged over Alexander's relationship with Persia and Persians." --Mattfwbooks (talk) 04:41, 18 August 2014 (UTC)

Done This section appears to show a consensus concerning these details. -- ferret (talk) 20:00, 20 August 2014 (UTC)

incomplete citation - Cicero quotation

I put a tag on the citation of Cicero saying "river of gold" about Aristotle's prose style. A correspondent asked me to explain. When I clicked on the citation, I was directed to an online text of Cicero's Academica. I expected that there would be a location within that work. Anyway, I tried to search the Academica for the quote, and I was not able to find it. That is, no doubt, a failure on my part, so I didn't make a stronger claim that the citation did not support the quote. But anyway, the citation as given does not precisely locate the quotation. What I would expect, at the least, more than a link, but also author, title and location - enough to look it up in a library or other printed edition - even if (as is not the case here) the link directs one to the exact passage. TomS TDotO (talk) 08:30, 22 May 2014 (UTC)

The link (http://www.gutenberg.org/files/14970/14970-h/14970-h.htm#BkII_119) does link to the passage for me, it goes to Book II, section 119, which reads "veniet flumen orationis aureum fundens Aristoteles"; "flumen aureum" is plainly translated as "golden river" or "river of gold". --Atethnekos (Discussion, Contributions) 09:13, 22 May 2014 (UTC)

Semi-protected edit request on 23 August 2014

Please change "Aristotle (/ˈærɪˌstɒtəl/;[1] Greek: Ἀριστοτέλης [aristotélɛːs], Aristotélēs; 384–322 BCE)[2] was a Greek philosopher and scientist born in Stagirus, northern Greece, in 384 BCE. His father, Nicomachus, died when Aristotle was a child, whereafter Proxenus of Atarneus became his guardian.[3]" to "Aristotle (/ˈærɪˌstɒtəl/;[1] Greek: Ἀριστοτέλης [aristotélɛːs], Aristotélēs; 384–322 BCE)[2] was a Greek philosopher and scientist born in the the central Macedonian city Stagirus, in 384 BCE. His father, Nicomachus, died when Aristotle was a child, whereafter Proxenus of Atarneus became his guardian.[3]"

Reason for change is that Greece in the ancient period was not colonized as a single nation, therefore it is incorrect to say Aristotle was born in 'Northern Greece' politically. Instead, it should be written that he was born in the Macedonian state which is now politically 'Northern Greece'.

121.211.42.26 (talk) 07:41, 23 August 2014 (UTC)

Done Cannolis (talk) 08:54, 24 August 2014 (UTC)

Hmm

I am using this page for some information in a essay I have to write, (oh goody *obvious sarcasm*) the focus is on biology, and while detailed. That part of the page seems...lacking. (Just saying! I'm 14 and stressed, please don't rage :c) 76.205.190.251 (talk) 23:34, 17 September 2014 (UTC)

Missing chunk of information

i am new to wiki... and this is my first suggestion/post so please be merciful regardless of my editing or suggesting skills... i was getting help from this page, and found out that this page is missing a chunk of info about Aristotle's relation or his principals related to tragedy for instance Sophocles's Oedipus was said to be praised by Aristotle and said to be categorized with these 3 categories(?) hamartia,anagnorisis,peripeteia i had hard time looking for this deep stuff which i consider to be important. there is very little said about this in "Rhetoric and poetics" section but this needs to be specified and be said in this section due to it's importance. and also for wiki's sake :) (i don't know if i did this right....)

Incorrect dates

It now says, "tutored Alexander the Great between 356 and 323 BCE", which is obviously wrong. The exact dates are unknown but 343-340 is a good guess (see the Standford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). — Preceding unsigned comment added by Arvidbave (talk • contribs) 23:25, 8 October 2014 (UTC)

Of course, 356-323 BCE is the life of Alexander. Anyway, this should be fixed. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Arvidbave (talk • contribs) 23:28, 8 October 2014 (UTC)

Scientist?

As far as I know Aristotle didn't employ the scientific method then why is he listed as Scientist.Mohammed al-Bukhari (talk) 18:26, 23 October 2014 (UTC)