BurnLounge, Inc. was a multi-level marketing online music store founded in 2004 and based in New York City. By 2006 the company reported 30,000 members using the site to sell music through its network. In 2007 the company was sued by the Federal Trade Commission for being a Pyramid Scheme. The company lost the suit in 2012, and lost appeal in June 2014. In June 2015, the FTC began returning $1.9 million to people who had lost money in the scheme.
BurnLounge was founded in 2004, with offices in New York City. Its primary business was the BurnLounge online music store, and it was associated with Orbital Publishing, which produced printed matter for the company. Former CEO Alex Arnold (formerly with Excel Communications and founder and former chairman of NuEWorld.com), was partners with Ryan Dadd and Stephen Murray.
The company's site allowed customers to preview and purchase music, and chat through a proprietary client. Customers wishing to sell music through their own custom pages were required to purchase a subscription. Subscription costs varied, and consisted of either an annual fee or an annual fee with an additional monthly charge. These fees only allowed one to redeem sales points for BurnLounge products; participants paid additional fees if they wished to exchange earned sales points for money. A Fortune article places the commission at five cents per 99-cent download.
In 2006 the company stated that nearly 30,000 people had opened BurnLounge storefronts, including several major label musicians. The service provided content supplied by Muze, with early versions of its software provided by Beatport and SocialIM. Version 0.9 of the software was introduced in October 2005, and version 1.0 was unveiled in Las Vegas on June 9 and 10, 2006. BurnLounge offered only music downloads, but other products such as audiobooks, video, ring tones, and physical merchandise were said to be planned. Burnlounge 2.0 (or BL2) launched quietly on Friday, April 27, 2007.
FTC files pyramid scheme lawsuit
Federal Trade Commission (FTC) filed a lawsuit on June 5, 2007 against specific BurnLounge participants for involvement in a pyramid scheme. The FTC claimed that BurnLounge is a pyramid scheme because the company pays more money for recruiting new store owners than for selling music. The lawsuit claimed that BurnLounge made very little money from the sale of music, and made the vast majority of its money from independent associates (named "moguls") paying between $29.95 and $429.95 a year plus fees, for the right to sell music. The lawsuit also stated that associated were paid a cash reward for recruiting others into the program.
One person named in the lawsuit, Rob DeBoer, says that he recruited about 45 other people to open their own BurnLounge sites. Those recruited would then pay a commission on their sales to DeBoer. DeBoer stated that he made almost US$300,000 from BurnLounge. The lawsuit is the result of a year-long investigation into BurnLounge by the state of South Carolina. Others named in the lawsuit include former BurnLounge CEO Alex Arnold, and two Texas men who promoted BurnLounge similarly to DeBoer. The case went before a Federal Judge in December 2008, and while many of the accusations against the company were dropped by the FTC, on February 29, 2012 an order was issued barring the defendants from operating a pyramid scheme and ordering them to pay some $17 million in damages.
In June 2014, the U.S. Court of Appeals unanimously upheld the ruling, declaring BurnLounge to be an illegal pyramid scheme. BurnLounge was considering appeal to the Supreme Court. Multi-level marketing analysts describe the ruling as being likely significant to an FTC investigation of Herbalife. Herbalife praised the ruling, saying that it clarified that its own business model does not fall under the appellate court's definition of pyramid scheme.
The company is dormant pending additional appeals. As of June 2015, the company's website hosts a teaser promoting BurnLounge 3.0 with the statement, "Get ready", which has remained unchanged for eight years.
- Reader, Ruth. "FTC will return roughly $1.9M to consumers caught up in digital music pyramid scheme". Venture Beat. Retrieved 19 June 2015.
- "FTC Returns Almost $1.9 Million to Consumers in BurnLounge Pyramid Scheme". Federal Trade Commission (press release). 15 June 2015. Retrieved 19 June 2015.
- "General information name search". Division of Corporations. State of Delaware. Retrieved 2006-07-13.
- "Contact information". BurnLounge. Retrieved 2006-07-13.[dead link]
- "Contact information". Orbital Publishing. Retrieved 2006-07-13.
- "SEC Files Lawsuit against E-commerce Network Marketing Company" (Press release). United States Securities and Exchange Commission. 2001-10-04. Retrieved 2006-07-10.
- "Nueworld.com, more than a Web site, has its Kaua'i launch". The Garden Island (Kauai Publishing Company). 2000-05-27. Retrieved 2006-07-10.
- Bruno, Antony (2005-08-20). "With BurnLounge, Everyone Is A Retailer". Billboard (VNU). Retrieved 2006-07-10. (PDF reprint)
- Meza, Hector (2006-02-01). "MYSPACE+ITUNES=AMWAY. Is BurnLounge a pyramid scheme?". New York Press. Retrieved 2006-07-10.
- ""Sell music" package descriptions". BurnLounge. Retrieved 2006-08-17.
- Tucker, Reed (2006-03-30). "Money to Burn?". Fortune. Retrieved 2006-07-10.
- "BurnLounge Launches BurnLounge 1.0 - Creating a Powerful Digital Marketplace" (Press release). BurnLounge. 2006-06-09. Retrieved 2006-08-17.
- Gonsalves, Antone (2006-06-28). "SocialIM Launches Instant Messaging App For Online Communities". InformationWeek (CMP Media). Retrieved 2006-07-11.
- Hull, Tim (2 June 2014). "9th Circuit Affirms BurnLounge Judgment". Courthouse News. Retrieved 19 June 2014.
- Gullo, Karen (2 June 2014). "BurnLounge Ruling in FTC Case Seen as Good for Herbalife". Bloomberg Business Week. Retrieved 19 June 2014.
- "Final chapter yet to be written on Columbia cases". The State. 2010-02-28. Retrieved 2010-06-02.[dead link]
- FTC Action Leads to Court Order Shutting Down Pyramid Scam Thousands of Consumers Burned by BurnLounge, Federal Trade Commission, March 14, 2012, retrieved March 14, 2012
- Burnlounge Brief (PDF), Federal Trade Commission, April 4, 2013, retrieved March 18, 2014
- Mullin, Joe (16 June 2015). "How an online music pyramid scheme conned 50,000 people". Ars Technica. Retrieved 19 June 2015.