Corruption in Canada

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

The Corruption Perceptions Index ranks Canada in the top 10 most corrupt countries in the world.[1] In recent years, corruption is increasingly a problem in government, industry and non-governmental organizations. For instance, in 2013, the World Bank blacklisted SNC-Lavalin and its subsidiaries from "bidding on its global projects under its fraud and corruption policy" due to the Padma Bridge scandal.[2] Canada also ranks at the bottom of the bribery-fighting rankings, "with little or no enforcement of anti-bribery measures".[3] The 2014 Ernst & Young global fraud survey found that "twenty percent of Canadian executives believe bribery and corruption are widespread in this country".[4] According to a study by the Graduate School of Public Policy at the University of Saskatchewan, "a large proportion of Canadians see their politicians and their institutions as fundamentally corrupt".[5]

Corruption in the Canadian government has become rampant which has lead to prolonged unemployment for Ontario's residents.

Corruption by region[edit]

Ontario[edit]

Corruption in Ontario is increasingly a major issue in government, civil service, business and non-profit sectors.[citation needed] In the last decade[when?], the Ontario Liberal government has faced serious and high-profile corruption cases including eHealth Scandal, Ontario power plant scandal, and Ornge scandal. These cases have implicated the leadership of the Ontario Liberal party in corruption, including former three-time premier Dalton McGuinty. The Kathleen Wynne-led Liberal government that succeeded him is facing several corruption cases including bribery during elections.[6] Prominent Liberal Party fundraiser Gerry Lougheed Jr. has been criminally charged by the Ontario Provincial Police.[7] Wynne stood by Lougheed even after the police filed charges.[7]

Ontario's Liberal government has been accused of corruption for its dealings with teachers' unions (Ontario Secondary School Teachers' Federation, Ontario English Catholic Teachers' Association, Elementary Teachers' Federation of Ontario). According to accusations[who?], the Liberal government offers "rich contracts, special treatment, secret agreements and generous payoffs with public dollars" for the teachers' unions, and other unions in return for helping the Liberal government get elected and stay in power.[8] A Globe and Mail investigation found that the Ontario government has offered[clarification needed] more than $3.7 million in secret payments to teachers' unions.[9]

The RCMP has alleged that Ontario Provincial Police Association leaders, including President James (Jim) Christie, Vice-president Martin Bain and chief administrative officer Karl Walsh have committed fraud, and guilty of money laundering and corruption. The charges include "unusual investment of union money in condos in the Bahamas", "formation of a company to provide exclusive travel services for both union business and personal travel by members", "formation of a consulting company" that billed the union $5000 per month, and for "questionable vacation and travel expenses billed to the union".[10]

Québec[edit]

The Charbonneau Commission established in 2011 to investigate corruption in Québec, has uncovered long running, widespread corruption including "price-fixing schemes among construction companies bidding on municipal governments", "illegal donations to the province’s major political parties from some of its biggest engineering firms" and links between the Fédération des travailleurs et travailleuses du Québec, the Quebec Federation of Labour (FTQ), the province’s biggest federation of unions, and organized crime.[11]

On January 26, 2017, the former mayor of Montreal Michael Applebaum was found guilty of 8 corruption-related charges.[12] Applebaum was found guilty in relation to cash kickbacks related to real estate development projects and a municipal contract for the management and maintenance of the NDG Sports Centre.

In 2015, employees of EBR Information Technology firm, IBM Canada and Revenu Québec were arrested for fraud, conspiracy and breach of trust in relation to computer equipment and services contracts to the provincial government.[13] There are widespread "financial and management irregularities with the Québec government's computer networks."[14]

Corruption by sector[edit]

Health[edit]

Dr. Shiv Chopra, a former employee of Health Canada and a whistle-blower, has criticized Health Canada for circumventing safety and efficacy regulations to please product manufacturers, for systematic collusion with corporations in "extra-parliamentary decisions involving the imposition of new risks on society" and for overlooking the responsibility to protect health and humans, in pursuit of capital-making profits".[15] Dr. Michele Brill-Edwards previously issued similar warnings and expressed the same concerns earlier.

Some doctors and clinics have been found to overbill and/or double bill the Canadian Health System.[16][17] Some walk-in clinics intake regular patients at a higher cost to the system without informing the patients about the cost or other options that might be available.[18] In Canada, doctors do not disclose the costs of visits or procedures to the patients. That information can only be obtained through a freedom of information request. This lack of transparency contributes to the proliferation of this form of corruption.

Some dentists overcharge, change the codes for the procedures, waiving co-payment[clarification needed] or treat patients other than the insurance holder.

In Alberta, a medical inquiry established the existence of queue-jumping and illegal fast-tracking of private clinic referrals.[19] Alberta's former head of Health Services, Stephen Duckett, noted that "preferential access to care was a common practice when he took over and politicians had fixers who could get valued constituents faster treatment."[19]

Education[edit]

Some private high schools have been found to illegally and unethically aid students earn inflated grades, credits and credentials.[20][21] Thus, those with financial means are able to access top university programs and scholarships at the expense of merit students.[20][22] These schools are referred to as "credit mills" or “credit shops”.[22] Lax governmental oversight is a major cause of this corruption.[20]

A report in 2007 said that the majority of students at Canadian universities are engaged in cheating.[23] Among the cheaters, a disproportionate number are international students.[24] "Students who cheat are unlikely to be caught and face few penalties when they are."[23][25]

Research and Scholarly Publishing[edit]

Two of Canada's leading medical journal publishers Andrew John Publishing and Pulsus Group have been purchased by OMICS Publishing Group, which is considered a predatory and junk science publisher.[26] OMICS is being sued by FTC. FTC has alleged that OMICS "misrepresented the legitimacy of its publications, deceived researchers, and obfuscated sizeable publication fee."[27] Pulsus Group has been on Jeffrey Beall's list of "Potential, possible, or probable" predatory open-access publishers.[28]

Tax[edit]

Canada has a very high rate of tax evasion.[29] Individuals and companies with high net worths use offshore tax havens to illegally avoid paying tax. Canadians have $170 billion sitting in the world's top ten tax-haven countries.[30] Canadian federal and provincial governments lose an estimated $8 billion a year to tax havens alone.[30] Black market or under-the-table commercial activity also contributes to tax avoidance losses. The full cost of tax evasion is an estimated $80 billion per year.[29] Tax evasion and corruption are facilitated by lawyers, administrative corruption and inefficiency in the Canada Revenue Agency,[31] Canadian and foreign banks.[32]

Canada's lax regulations make it one of the top[clarification needed] countries for anonymous shell companies,[33] which are often used for tax evasion, money laundering, terrorist financing and organized crime. Canadians for Tax Fairness calculate that legal tax avoidance by corporations alone costs the Canadian treasury almost $8 billion Canadian a year.[34] When it calculated the 2015 numbers, they found that corporations and individuals combined sent CAN$40 billion of declared assets to tax havens, and the ten most popular alone now held $270 billion Canadian in assets.[35]

Highly reputed multinational accounting firm KPMG has been accused by the Canada Revenue Agency of offering tax evasion schemes as products to its clients. It alleged that the KPMG tax structures were in reality a "sham" intended to deceive the tax authorities.[36] KPMG offered a "no tax" scheme in return for a fee of 15%[clarification needed] and in one case before the courts, it earned $300,000 in fees.[36]

Law Enforcement[edit]

The RCMP's own study found 330 internal corruption cases between 1995 and 2005.[37] "Improperly giving out police information was the most common type of corrupt behaviour, followed by fraud, misuse of police officer status, theft and interference with the judicial process."[37] These numbers are likely an understatement of true levels as the RCMP has admitted not tracking "hundreds of cases of serious misconduct committed by Mounties across the country for years".[38] Also, in 2013 nearly 300 current and former female Mounties joined a class-action lawsuit alleging harassment[39]

CBSA which was formed out of the merger of the 3 legacy border protection agencies, in 2004, including, Immigration Canada, Canadian Food Inspection Agency, and Canada Customs and currently has no oversight body what so ever.[citation needed] It is widely believed there is a considerable amount of questionable activity has gone largely unnoticed, unreported or suppressed according to complaints from former and current Border Service Officers, (BSO's). Most of the few cases, have been in the media only briefly, and had little to no follow up.[citation needed] The CBSA, normally distances itself from liability by blaming "rogue employees", other departments and outside contractors. The complaint process is nearly impossible to navigate for both the public and employees. Many of those employees who have spoken out, have stated they were in fear of reprisals. Despite legislation known as ATIP, or Access to Information Policy, acquiring statistics, or reports is also a complex process, that can take months despite the standard 60-day law to comply and appeals to the Public Service Integrity Commission are often "Well Founded." Early retirements are a common remedy for offenses involving management.[citation needed]

As noted above, Ontario Provincial Police Association leadership has allegedly committed fraud, money laundering and corruption.[10]

In 2016, Toronto Police Service faced several high-profile cases of corruption and disproportionate use of force. Constable James Forcillo was found guilty of attempt of murder in the death of 18-year-old Sammy Yatim.[40] Four police officers were arrested and charged with "nine counts of obstructing justice and eight counts of perjury".[41]

Non-profit sector[edit]

In Canada, donations to recognized charities receive tax refunds. This system has been abused extensively. "Typically, tax-shelter firms hook up with a little-known charity that becomes a sort of tax receipt mill, suddenly writing millions of dollars in bogus receipts and making grandiose claims of saving the world. Some $3.2 billion in receipts given in the last few years to 100,000 Canadians have either been disallowed or soon will be".[42]

Many charities have been found to be shell organizations for profit based schemes.[43] A Toronto Star investigation revealed that "self-reported information is so riddled with inaccuracies as to be absolutely useless to a donor" and federal government does not verify the claims by charities of their area of "good works".[43] Further more, "The Star found the primary regulator, the federal Charities Directorate, is virtually powerless to deal with problem charities."[43]

Several charities in Canada have been found to be front organizations for terrorist organizations or organized crime.[citation needed]

Insurance[edit]

Auto insurance fraud involving scammers, auto repair shops, paralegals and medical clinics is widespread in Ontario. It is estimated that the auto insurance fraud costs Ontario drivers $1.3 billion per year.[44] Other forms of insurance fraud are also relatively common, including that related to homes and property, and disability and workers' compensation which anecdotal evidence, at least, suggests is rife with abuse and fraud.

Investigation into insurance scams in Peel Region revealed that police officers colluded with the tow truck drivers and fraudsters in staging accidents. "Fraudulent accident reports" were provided by a veteran officer. Other officers were involved in tipping off the tow trucks of the accident locations.[45]

Drivers licensing[edit]

Canadian provinces mandate written and road tests (graduated licensing) to obtain license to drive automobiles. Truck drivers must undergo specialized training and obtain a commercial license. Some provinces such as Ontario has privatized drivers licensing, while others offer it as a public service. There exist corruption at various levels of drivers licensing.

A dangerous corruption is when non-qualified people obtain drivers licenses by bribing licensing officers.[46][47] Issuing of fake in-class driving lesson certificates is another scam related to obtaining licensing. In-class driver lesson certificates are used to get discount rates from insurance companies.

A Toronto Star investigation found that "truck-driver testing centre is letting learners earn their licences without being required to drive on a major expressway".[48] Further more, many driving schools offer in-vehicle "lessons even though they are not authorized by the province to do so".[48][49]

Another fraud associated with drivers licensing is issuance of fake drivers licenses. In many cases, drivers licensing officers have been bribed to issue fake licenses which are then used for various illegal purposes such as to obtain credit, make insurance claims etc.[47]

Real estate[edit]

Fraud and corruption is committed by all parties at all levels in the real estate sector. Buyers, sellers, realtors, developers, lawyers, mortgage brokers and banks have been implicated in various fraud and corruption cases.[50] Money laundering, lying about income and occupation, fake bids, value falsification, title fraud and falsely claiming as owner-occupied are common real estate frauds in Canada.[51][52]

Money laundering is likely in the real estate sector of major Canadian cities. Chinese buyers are suspected of laundering money through the Vancouver real estate market in large numbers, with the help of major Canadian banks.[53] According to a Globe and Mail investigation, "some Canadian banks allow wealthy Asian investors to skirt Chinese law by helping them bring in large amounts of money, which is then often used to buy real estate in Vancouver."[54] A report by the Financial Transactions and Reports Analysis Centre of Canada indicates "dramatic under-reporting of large cash transactions and suspicious transactions" in the Vancouver real estate sector.[53]

In 2012, Equifax uncovered $400 million of mortgage fraud in Canada, which experts suspect represents only a fraction of the cheating taking place in the country’s real estate market".[55]

The Panama Papers leak of documents from the law offices of Mossack Fonseca brought to light a rather high level of referrals by Canadian banks to the Panamanian offshore specialist. The Royal Bank of Canada (RBC) sent 370+ clients to Mossack Fonseca over the years, for example, but they underlined that the bank did not help its customers to avoid taxes or hide income. "We have an extensive due diligence process... RBC works within the legal and regulatory framework of every country in which we operate," said a bank spokesman.[56] RBC CEO David McKay said the bank will review the documentation for those four decades in order to address any problems.[57][58] CEO Bill Downe of the Bank of Montreal said "Canadian banks have 'dramatically' beefed up anti-money-laundering control over the last seven to 10 years,"[59] He added that any link between Canadian businesses and the Panama Papers offshore companies must have originated a long time ago, before Canadian banks took action to stop money laundering.[57]

Government and civil service[edit]

Employment insurance overcharges[edit]

In the late 1990s and 2000s, the Government of Canada illegally overcharged Canadians with respect to employment insurance premiums. The overcharges exceeded $40 billion. As noted by the Auditor General of Canada in her 2004 report:

Parliament did not intend, in my view, that the Account would accumulate a surplus beyond what could reasonably be spent for employment insurance purposes, given the existing benefit structure, while also providing for an economic downturn. Accordingly, in my opinion, the Government did not observe the intent of the Employment Insurance Act.[60]

On December 11, 2008, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled the overcharges were unlawful. As stated by the Supreme Court of Canada in Confédération des syndicats nationaux v. Canada (Attorney General):

[96] For these reasons, I would therefore allow the appeals in part and declare that the versions of ss. 66.1 and 66.3 of the Employment Insurance Act that applied in 2002, 2003 and 2005 are invalid and that employers’ and employees’ premiums for 2002, 2003 and 2005 were collected unlawfully. [61]

Nepotism and cronyism[edit]

Nepotism and cronyism is a major issue in Canadian public service. Awarding summer student experience positions, internships and University research assistant positions to children of employees is a common practice.

The liberal government pays extra to advertise it's business development while conveniently leaving out the truth. [1]

Notable corruption cases[edit]

Panama Papers[edit]

No Canadian politicians' names from the national government have surfaced in the Panama Papers as of the end of May 2016. The Globe and Mail did ask Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, whose name did not appear in either of the document releases, about this, for the record. He told reporters that he does not have any money in offshore accounts, and had "entirely and completely been transparent about mine and my family's finances. That is something I learned early on that Canadians expect from their leaders."[62]

Some names of Canadian individuals did appear in the leaked documents, according to ICIJ investigation partner the Toronto Star.[63]

  • John Mark Wright, a mutual fund broker, had three shell companies in the British Virgin Islands for handling profits from a mine in the Democratic Republic of Congo.
  • Eric Van Nguyen, a Montreal resident with registered companies in Samoa and another in the British Virgin Islands, also faces fraud charges in the New York in a penny stock scheme.[64]
  • Brian Shamess, a sports physician from Sault Ste Marie, used a Mossack Fonseca company to buy a condo on Panama Bay in 2011.
  • Eric Marc Levine, who operates fitness clubs in Asia and has registered at least 15 companies in the BVI through Mossack Fonseca. The Thai Anti-Money Laundering Office froze some of his business assets following fraud allegations; Levine responded with a defamation suit.
  • Former Newfoundland Cabinet minister Chuck Furey incorporated in Panama to buy a condo in 2008. He no longer has overseas holdings, he said.
  • Mixed martial arts trainer Dave Feser of Vancouver set up a business in British Anguilla with an office in Switzerland. "There's nothing even associated with this company," Feser told the Star.

Canadians for Tax Fairness[who?] has calculated that legal tax avoidance by corporations alone cost the Canadian treasury almost $8 billion (Canadian) a year.[65] When it calculated the 2015 numbers, the group found that corporations and individuals combined sent CAN$40 billion of declared assets to tax havens, and the ten most popular tax havens alone now held $270 billion (Canadian) in assets.[35]

Anti-corruption mechanisms[edit]

Public Service Commission[edit]

Canada's public service is set up to work independently from the political party in power. The mandate of the Public Service Commission is to protect the public service from political interference and "ensure professional, non-partisan public service".[66] The Office of Public Service Values and Ethics is tasked with implementing values, ethics and policies to prevent corruption.[67]

The Conservative Party government of Stephen Harper defeated in the last election, has been criticized for political interference in an array of administrative bodies including Statistics Canada, Elections Canada, the Canadian Military Complaints Commission, the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission, Public Works and the Supreme Court.[68]

Auditor General, Ombudsman[edit]

Canada's federal and provincial governments have independent and strong Auditor General offices. The Auditor-General reports to the Parliament, not to the cabinet, and conducts annual and special audits to examine the government's activities and hold it to account. Auditor-General reports have brought to light major scandals, corruption, waste and inefficiencies, and led to changes in governments.

Ombudsman offices are tasked with investigating public complaints about government. Special ombudsmans or commissioners are tasked with investigating and reporting to Parliament about key areas. The Privacy Commissioner of Canada, Environment and Sustainable Development Commissioner and Information Commissioner of Canada are examples of these special offices.

Civilian oversight bodies[edit]

Civilian oversight bodies are used to hold account, to check power and provide input for government and industry bodies. They are specially used to hold account the police, RCMP, military and CSIS.

In 2012, Office of the Inspector General, which was a key oversight body for the Canada's spy agency CSIS was abolished by the Conservative government.[69] The government said the oversight functions were consolidated within the civilian Security Intelligence Review Committee.

Access to Information Act[edit]

Canada's Access to Information Act came into force in 1983. However, in recent years the legislation has been severely criticized to be outdated and in-effective. Centre for Law and Democracy ranks Canada 56th out of 95 countries in terms of the strength of the Access to Information legislation.[70] Both Federal and various Provincial and Territorial access to information systems are overburdened, in part, by the refusal of many governments and agencies to informally release various data either as a matter of routine course or upon informal request, instead demanding that written requests be made pursuant to relevant access to information legislation, subsequently triggering a cumbersome and time consuming formal process for frequently trivial and even obviously public information. As of 2015 there are thousands of individuals employed full-time throughout all levels of government and their agencies tasked with processing formal requests for access to information; this represents a cost to the Canadian taxpayer of hundreds of millions of dollars annually and does not include additional expenses including outside legal and other professional opinions, tribunal hearings, motions and appeals in courts, multiple access to information commissions and tribunals across the country, and various other expenses that likely bring the annual cost to the taxpayer into the billions of dollars.

An investigation by the Information Commissioner of Canada has found that the conservative government's staff have systematically interfered with the processing of access to information requests.[71]

Conflict of Interest laws[edit]

All levels of governments enforce conflict of interest laws for civil servants and politicians. The laws generally require disclosure of actual or perceived conflict of interests and appropriate measures, such as recusal from decisions.[72]

Conflict of interest laws have been used to highlight an array of improper dealings by politicians. For instance, in 2015 an Ethics Commissioner report found "Government Services Minister Diane Finley breached conflict-of-interest rules by giving preferential treatment and federal funding to a project" that received "one of its lowest ratings" in an assessment done by the Department of Human Resources and Skills Development.[73] The project proposal was submitted by the Canadian Federation of Chabad Lubavitch by Ottawa rabbi Chaim Mendelsohn, who had close ties to the Conservative party, the Prime Minister’s Office and then-foreign affairs minister John Baird."[73]

Federal Accountability Act[edit]

Federal Accountability Act is a major anti-corruption legislation passed in 2006 by the Harper Conservative government. It introduced several mechanisms to combat corruption including Commissioner of Lobbying, Parliamentary Budget Officer, Public Sector Integrity Commissioner, Ethics Commissioner, limits to election donations and enhancement of lobbying rules.

Public Servants Disclosure Protection Act[edit]

Public Servants Disclosure Protection Act is a whistleblower protection act. The act "provides a confidential process for employees in Canada’s federal public sector to come forward with any information about possible wrongdoing within the federal government and state corporations", except Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS), Communications Security Establishment Canada (CSEC) and the Canadian Forces.

Corruption of Foreign Public Officials Act[edit]

Canada signed and agreed to implement the OECD Anti-Bribery Convention and the OECD Convention on Combating Bribery of Foreign Public Officials in International Business Transactions. The Corruption of Foreign Public Officials Act (CFPOA) was enacted in 1999. The CFPOA applies to persons and companies, aiming to prevent and punish the acts of bribery of foreign public officials to obtain or retain a business advantage. Companies have to develop effective compliance programs with focus on specific areas relevant for the CFPOA.

The aim of the law is to monitor, punish and prevent bribery and other criminal acts being committed by Canadians and Canadian companies in foreign countries. In 2014, Ottawa consultant Nazir Karigar was the first person to be convicted under this law. He was convicted for the Air India bribery scheme.

A 2013 progress report indicates that Canada has failed to implement many of the recommendations and earns an overall score of "Moderate". OECD criticized Canada for lack of prosecutions and lack of resource allocation to address corruption.

Opendata, open government, and transparency initiatives[edit]

Canadian governments at all levels and citizen organizations have undertaken various Open data, Open government and transparency initiatives. The Open Government Strategy was launched by the federal government in March 2011. Various datasets have been released under municipal open data initiatives such as Toronto Open Data. Sharing of MP/MPP/Councilor expenses online, sunshine lists, posting detail program budgets and expenditures online and crime statistics are some examples of open data being released online. Open data has increased public scrutiny of abuses, helping monitor, prosecute and prevent corruption.

International conventions and transparency initiatives[edit]

Canada has ratified United Nations Convention against Corruption and the OECD Anti-Bribery Convention.

The government of Canada is part of the multilateral Open Government Partnership initiative. Canada joined the International Aid Transparency Initiative (IATI) in 2011. Canada was a supporting country to the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative, and it intends to implement the EITI.

First Nations Financial Transparency Act[edit]

The First Nations Financial Transparency Act was created in 2013 by the Harper Conservative government, with the purpose of increasing financial transparency in First Nations Communities.[74] The First Nations Financial Transparency Act requires First Nation bands to publicly disclose their financial statements, including salary information of their councillors. Disclosure of this information has highlighted relatively high salaries of many chiefs, in comparison to extreme poor living conditions of their members. For instance, Shuswap band has 87 on-reserve members. Its Chief Paul Sam earned $202,413 tax free salary while many band members endured winters without water or electricity.[75] First Nations Financial Transparency Act has promoted higher vigilance regarding band leadership's activities and financial management by members and fellow councilors.

On December 18, 2015, Minister of Indigenous and Northern Affairs Carolyn Bennett announced that the Liberal government will stop enforcing the Act, and will "suspend any court actions against First Nations who have not complied with the Act", releasing funds withheld from First Nations communities that have not complied with the Act.[76]

Integrity Regime[edit]

Government of Canada's Integrity Regime prohibits the federal government from doing business with any company if "they, or members of their board of directors have been convicted or absolutely/conditionally discharged in the last three years" of various corruption and malpractice related offenses including income and excise tax evasion, secret commissions and bribing a foreign public official.[77]

Gallery[edit]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ "CPI 2011 table". Transparency International. Retrieved July 19, 2012. 
  2. ^ "Canada now dominates World Bank corruption list, thanks to SNC-Lavalin". Financial Post.com. Retrieved May 1, 2014. 
  3. ^ "Anti-Corruption Policy in Canada and Kazakhstan: Bottom-Up Vs. Top-Down Agenda Setting". ujaen.es. Revista de Estudios Jurídicos no 13/2013 (Segunda Época). Universidad de Jaén (España). 2013. Retrieved June 6, 2014. 
  4. ^ "Canada not immune from corruption, E&Y study finds". theglobeandmail.com. The Globe and Mail. 2014. Retrieved June 11, 2014. 
  5. ^ "Discrepancies in Corruption Perceptions, or Why is Canada So Corrupt?" (PDF). School of Public Policy - University of Saskatchewan. Retrieved May 1, 2014. 
  6. ^ "Ontario politics hits rock bottom with byelection allegations". torontosun.com. Toronto Sun. 2015. Retrieved March 19, 2015. 
  7. ^ a b "Alleged Ontario Liberal bribery scandal shines light on world of political patronage". theglobeandmail.com. The Globe and Mail. 2015. Retrieved October 23, 2015. 
  8. ^ "Kelly McParland: ‘Corrupt’ is the word to describe Ontario government’s ties to teachers’ unions". nationalpost.com. National Post. 2015. Retrieved October 27, 2015. 
  9. ^ "Ontario government’s payments to teacher unions top $3.7-million". theglobeandmail.com. The Globe and Mail. 2015. Retrieved October 27, 2015. 
  10. ^ a b "OPP union leaders stole and laundered funds, RCMP allege". cbc.ca. CBC. 2015. Retrieved March 19, 2015. 
  11. ^ "Quebec’s corruption problem". Macleans Magazine. Retrieved May 1, 2014. 
  12. ^ Jaela Bernstien (January 26, 2017). "Ex-Montreal mayor Michael Applebaum found guilty of 8 corruption-related charges". Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved January 26, 2017. 
  13. ^ "Seven arrests in $24M Revenue Quebec contract fraud: Cops". torontosun.com. Toronto Sun. 2015. Retrieved March 19, 2015. 
  14. ^ "Seven arrests in $24M Revenue Quebec contract fraud: Cops". theobserver.ca. The Observer. 2015. Retrieved March 19, 2015. 
  15. ^ "Book Review: Corrupt to the Core". preventcancernow.ca. Prevent Cancer Now. 2011. Retrieved May 9, 2014. 
  16. ^ "Some doctors overbilling medicare without penalty". CBC. Retrieved May 1, 2014. 
  17. ^ "Private B.C. hospital told to stop extra billing". Toronto Star. Retrieved May 1, 2014. 
  18. ^ "Filling a gap: Ontario’s walk-in clinics". HealthyDebate. Retrieved May 1, 2014. 
  19. ^ a b "Queue-jumping a fact, Alberta medical inquiry finds". cbc.ca. CBC. 2013. Retrieved May 2, 2014. 
  20. ^ a b c "Star Investigation: Cash for marks gets kids into university". thestar.com. Toronto Star. 2014. Retrieved May 9, 2014. 
  21. ^ "Some students are buying high marks at private schools, VSB warns (UPDATED)". macleans.ca. Macleans. 2012. Retrieved May 9, 2014. 
  22. ^ a b "Can high school grades be trusted?". macleans.ca. Macleans. 2009. Retrieved May 9, 2014. 
  23. ^ a b "The great university cheating scandal". macleans.ca. Macleans. 2007. Retrieved May 9, 2014. 
  24. ^ "Why many international students get a failing grade in academic integrity". theglobeandmail.com. The Globe and Mail. 2011. Retrieved May 9, 2014. 
  25. ^ "Cheating students punished by the 1000s, but many more go undetected". cbc.ca. CBC. 2014. Retrieved May 9, 2014. 
  26. ^ Marco Chown Oved & Favaro & Elizabeth St. Philip (September 29, 2016). "Canadian medical journals hijacked for junk science". The Toronto Star. Retrieved September 29, 2016. 
  27. ^ Megan Molteni (September 19, 2016). "The FTC Is Cracking Down on Predatory Science Journals". Wired. Retrieved September 29, 2016. 
  28. ^ Beall, Jeffrey. "LIST OF PUBLISHERS". Scholarly Open Access. Retrieved September 21, 2016. 
  29. ^ a b "Huge Cost of Tax Evasion Revealed as Campaign to Tackle Tax Havens Launches". taxfairness.ca. Canadian for Tax Fairness. 2012. Retrieved May 2, 2014. 
  30. ^ a b "Canadians’ offshore tax-haven holdings rise 10 per cent, to $170-billion". theglobeandmail.com. The Globe and Mail. 2014. Retrieved May 2, 2014. 
  31. ^ "RCMP lays charges in alleged Canada Revenue Agency fraud scheme". theglobeandmail.com. The Globe and Mail. 2014. Retrieved May 2, 2014. 
  32. ^ "How Canada's banks help money move in and out of tax havens". www.cbc.ca. CBC. 2013. Retrieved May 2, 2014. 
  33. ^ "Canada among top countries for anonymous shell companies". financialpost.com. The Financial Post. 2012. Retrieved May 2, 2014. 
  34. ^ Thomas Walkom (April 6, 2016). "Homegrown loopholes cost Canada more than Panama tax havens: Walkom". The Star. Retrieved April 30, 2016. 
  35. ^ a b Marco Chown Oved (April 27, 2016). "Canadians put $40 billion in tax havens last year: The Panama Papers revelations of widespread use of tax havens are corroborated by Statistics Canada data". Toronto Star. Retrieved April 30, 2016. 
  36. ^ a b "KPMG Offshore 'Sham' Deceived Tax Authorities, CRA Alleges". cbc.ca. September 10, 2015. Retrieved September 11, 2015. 
  37. ^ a b "RCMP study finds 322 incidents of corruption within force during 11-year period". ottawacitizen.com. Ottaw Citizen. 2014. Retrieved May 19, 2014. 
  38. ^ "RCMP failed to track internal misconduct for years". cbc.ca. CBC. 2013. Retrieved May 19, 2014. 
  39. ^ "282 join RCMP sexual harassment class-action lawsuit". cbc.ca. CBC. 2013. Retrieved May 19, 2014. 
  40. ^ Alyshah Hasham (January 25, 2016). "Forcillo guilty of attempted murder in shooting death of Sammy Yatim". Retrieved January 28, 2016. 
  41. ^ "4 Toronto police officers charged with perjury, obstructing justice". CBC News. January 28, 2016. Retrieved January 28, 2016. 
  42. ^ "Charity rules beefed up". thestar.com. The Toronto Star. 2007. Retrieved May 2, 2014. 
  43. ^ a b c "Charity scams bust public trust". thestar.com. The Toronto Star. 2007. Retrieved May 2, 2014. 
  44. ^ "Car insurance scam: 37 arrested in Project Whiplash raids". Toronto Star. Retrieved May 1, 2014. 
  45. ^ Jesse McLean Investigative News reporter, Jayme Poisson News reporter (December 21, 2015). "Police caught colluding with tows". Peel Region. thestar.com. Retrieved December 21, 2015. 
  46. ^ "Immigrant who bribed driving examiner pleads for leniency". canada.com. Vancouver Sun. 2008. Retrieved October 31, 2015. 
  47. ^ a b "DriveTest employees charged with fraud". ctvnews.ca. CTV News. 2009. Retrieved October 31, 2015. 
  48. ^ a b "Provincial crackdown needed on truck driver training, critics say". thestar.com. The Toronto Star. 2014. Retrieved October 31, 2015. 
  49. ^ "Star investigation: Toronto driving schools bending the rules to make a buck". thestar.com. The Toronto Star. 2014. Retrieved October 31, 2015. 
  50. ^ "Mortgage Fraud the Ideal Crime?". thecanadianencyclopedia.ca. The Canadian Encyclopedia. 2013. Retrieved October 29, 2015. 
  51. ^ "Mortgage Fraud" (PDF). lsuc.on.ca. The Law Society of Upper Canada. 2005. Retrieved October 29, 2015. 
  52. ^ "Mortgage Fraud". cmhc-schl.gc.ca. Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation. 2015. Retrieved October 29, 2015. 
  53. ^ a b "Cash buys and illicit money: Federal audit probes Vancouver’s real estate industry for money-laundering". nationalpost.com. National Post. 2015. Retrieved October 29, 2015. 
  54. ^ "Canadian banks helping clients bend rules to move money out of China". theglobeandmail.com. The Globe and Mail. 2015. Retrieved October 29, 2015. 
  55. ^ "Mortgage fraud on the rise". financialpost.com. Financial Post. 2012. Retrieved October 29, 2015. 
  56. ^ "RBC t wrongdoing after being named in Panama Papers:'There are a number of legitimate reasons' to set up foreign holding companies, bank spokesman says". CBC News. April 4, 2016. Retrieved April 18, 2016. 
  57. ^ a b "Royal Bank and BMO defend Canada's banking sector amid Panama Papers and Fintrac fine". CBC News. CBC/Radio-Canada. April 7, 2016. Retrieved April 9, 2016. Canadian banks have "dramatically" beefed up anti-money laundering controls over the last seven to 10 years 
  58. ^ Scuffham, Matt (April 6, 2016). "Royal Bank of Canada sets up team to scrutinize data exposed in Panama Papers leak". Financial Post. O Canada. Retrieved April 9, 2016. 
  59. ^ "Archivo no encontrado"[permanent dead link]. abc.com.py.
  60. ^ Auditor General of Canada. "2004 Public Accounts of the Government of Canada" (PDF). pp. 2. 29 to 2. 30. Retrieved January 26, 2017. 
  61. ^ "Confédération des syndicats nationaux v. Canada (Attorney General)". Paragraph 96: Supreme Court of Canada. Retrieved January 26, 2017. 
  62. ^ Fife, Robert (April 7, 2016). "Trudeau says he does not have money in offshore accounts". The Globe and Mail. The Globe and Mail Inc. Retrieved April 9, 2016. 
  63. ^ Robert Cribb; Marco Chown Oved (April 4, 2016). "How offshore banking is costing Canada billions of dollars a year: An unprecedented leak of secretive offshore tax-haven data contains stunning new revelations about the diversion of wealth from government coffers to hidden bank accounts". Retrieved May 2, 2016. 
  64. ^ Chris Dolmetsch (September 11, 2014). "Eight Charged by N.Y. in $290 Million Pump-and-Dump Plot". Bloomberg. Retrieved April 30, 2016. 
  65. ^ Thomas Walkom (April 6, 2016). "Homegrown loopholes cost Canada more than Panama tax havens: Walkom". The Star. Retrieved April 30, 2016. 
  66. ^ "The 100 years of the Public Service Commission of Canada 1908–2008". psc-cfp.gc.ca. Public Service Commission of Canada. 2008. Retrieved June 6, 2014. 
  67. ^ ""Best Practices to Fight Corruption" Canada: Selected Programs - The Government of Canada" (PDF). unodc.org. UNODC. Retrieved June 6, 2014. 
  68. ^ "The Puzzle of Independence for Administrative Bodies" (PDF). law.yale.edu. Yale Law School. 2008. Retrieved June 6, 2014. 
  69. ^ "Ottawa abolishes spy overseer’s office". nationalpost.com. National Post. 2012. Retrieved June 6, 2014. 
  70. ^ "Canadians’ rightful access to public information being blocked, experts say". thestar.com. The Toronto Star. 2014. Retrieved June 6, 2014. 
  71. ^ "Three Tory staffers interfered in releasing government information, watchdog says". theglobeandmail.com. The Globe and Mail. 2014. Retrieved June 6, 2014. 
  72. ^ "Conflict of Interest". thecanadianencyclopedia.ca. The Canadian Encyclopedia. 2006. Retrieved June 6, 2014. 
  73. ^ a b "Conservative minister Diane Finley broke conflict-of-interest rules funding Toronto-area group: ethics watchdog". nationalpost.com. PostMedia News. 2015. Retrieved March 10, 2015. 
  74. ^ "First Nations financial transparency act becomes law; reserve audits, chiefs' salaries to be publicized". Retrieved August 24, 2016. 
  75. ^ "Chief, ex-wife of small B.C. First Nations band pocket $200K in tax-free salaries". calgarysun.ca. The Calgary Sun. 2014. Retrieved November 5, 2014. 
  76. ^ "Statement by the Honourable Carolyn Bennett on the First Nations Financial Transparency Act". Government of Canada. Government of Canada. December 18, 2015. Retrieved August 23, 2016. 
  77. ^ "Government of Canada's Integrity Regime". www.tpsgc-pwgsc.gc.ca. Government of Canada. 2015. Retrieved October 23, 2015. 
A world map of the 2016 Corruption Perceptions Index by Transparency International