New Zealand general election, 1984
The 1984 New Zealand general election was a nationwide vote to determine the shape of the 41st Parliament of New Zealand. It marked the beginning of the Fourth Labour Government, with David Lange's Labour Party defeating long-serving Prime Minister Robert Muldoon of the National Party. It was also the last election in which the Social Credit Party won seats as an independent entity. The election was also the only one in which the New Zealand Party, a protest party, played any substantial role.
Before the election, the National Party governed with 47 seats, a small majority. The opposition Labour Party held 43 seats, and the Social Credit Party held two. Although National theoretically commanded a two-seat lead over the other parties, dissent within the National caucus (particularly by Marilyn Waring and Mike Minogue) resulted in serious problems for National leader Robert Muldoon.
The 1984 election was called when Marilyn Waring told Muldoon that she would not support his government in the vote over an opposition-sponsored anti-nuclear bill. Muldoon, visibly drunk, announced a snap election on national television. There is debate over whether the election was necessary — Waring had not threatened to block confidence and supply, meaning that the government could still have continued on even if it had lost the anti-nuclear vote. Nevertheless, Muldoon appears to have wanted an election to reinforce his mandate (just as Sidney Holland sought and won a mandate to oppose striking dock-workers with the 1951 snap election).
Muldoon's government, which had been growing increasingly unpopular in its third term, was seen as rigid, inflexible, and increasingly unresponsive to public concerns. The Labour Party had actually gained a plurality of the vote in the previous two elections, but had narrowly missed out on getting a majority of the seats. Labour's primary campaign message was one of change — Muldoon's government, which employed wage and price controls in an attempt to "guide" the economy, was widely blamed for poor economic performance. Labour also campaigned to reduce government borrowing.
The New Zealand Party, founded by property tycoon Bob Jones, was launched primarily to oppose the Muldoon government (although it did not support Labour). A right-wing liberal party, it promoted less government control over markets, in contrast to the paternalist and somewhat authoritarian policies of National, the other significant right-wing party.
The election was held on 14 July. There were 2,111,651 registered voters. Turnout was 93.7%, the highest turnout ever recorded in a New Zealand election. Most political scientists attribute the high turnout to a desire by voters for change.
Immediately after the election there was a constitutional crisis when Muldoon initially refused to follow the advice of the incoming Labour government and devalue the New Zealand Dollar.
Summary of results
The 1984 election saw the Labour Party win 56 of the 95 seats in parliament, a gain of 13. This was enough for it to hold an outright majority and become the fourth Labour government. The National Party won only 37 seats, a loss of ten. The New Zealand Party, despite winning 12.2% of the vote, failed to gain any seats at all. Social Credit managed to win two seats, the same number as it had held previously. The Values Party, an environmentalist group, gained fifth place, but no seats.
There were 95 seats being contested in the 1984 election, three more than in the previous parliament. All but two of these seats were won by one of the two major parties.
The Labour Party, previously in opposition, won 56 seats, an outright majority. Most of the seats won by Labour were in urban areas, following the party's typical pattern. Exceptions to this general trend include the eastern tip of the North Island and the western coast of the South Island. Labour's strongest regions were the Wellington area (where the party won every seat), as well as Auckland, Christchurch and Dunedin (cities in which it won most seats). Smaller cities such as Hamilton, Nelson, Napier, Hastings and Palmerston North were also won by Labour. As expected, Labour also won all four Māori seats, maintaining its traditional strength there.
The National Party, the incumbent government, was (as expected) strongest in rural areas. Most of the rural North Island was won by National, as were a most of the rural areas on the South Island's eastern coast. In the larger cities, the party fared poorly, with Auckland and Christchurch being the only places that the party won seats. It was more successful in smaller cities, however, winning Rotorua, Tauranga, Invercargill, New Plymouth and Whangarei. It was placed second in two Māori electorates, and third in the other two.
The only minor party to win electorates was the Social Credit Party, which won East Coast Bays and Pakuranga (both in Auckland). It had held East Coast Bays before the election, but won Pakuranga for the first time. It did not manage to retain Rangitikei, which it had also held before the election. Social Credit candidates were placed second in six electorates, including Rangitikei.
The New Zealand Party, despite gaining more votes than Social Credit, did not win any seats. Some commentators have suggested that the party was not seeking to do so, and instead was merely acting as a spoiler for National. This impression has been backed up by comments by Bob Jones himself. The party was, however, placed second in the electorates of Remuera (an affluent part of Auckland), Kaimai (a region in the Bay of Plenty), and Tauranga.
The Values Party, an environmentalist group, managed to win 0.2% of the vote, substantially below previous efforts. The party, which was in slow decline, would eventually vanish, but its ideals and goals would be reborn in the Green Party.
In two of the Māori electorates, the Mana Motuhake party gained second place, but the party did not gain a substantial number of votes elsewhere.
No independent candidates won seats, but one independent candidate, Mel Courtney, was placed second in the electorate of Nelson.
|Party||Total votes||Percentage||Seats won|
The tables below shows the results of the 1984 general election:
|Social Credit||Mana Motuhake||Independent|
|Ashburton||Rob Talbot||472||G Stone (Labour)|
|Auckland Central||Richard Prebble||8,876||M Eardley-Wilmot (National)|
|Avon||Mary Batchelor||7,771||A P Cowie (National)|
|Awarua||Rex Austin||384||B G Raitt (Labour)|
|Bay of Islands||Neill Austin||3,298||L W Hunter (Social Credit)|
|Birkenhead||Jim McLay||1,717||J E T Course (Labour)|
|Christchurch Central||Geoffrey Palmer||8,508||A A P Willy (National)|
|Christchurch North||(new electorate)||Mike Moore||5,728||D J L Dumergue (National)|
|Clutha||Robin Gray||4,522||M J Sheppard (Labour)|
|Dunedin North||Stan Rodger||5,129||B Henderson (National)|
|Dunedin West||(new electorate)||Clive Matthewson||6,011||D G P Russell (National)|
|East Cape||Duncan MacIntyre||Anne Fraser||755||Duncan MacIntyre (National)|
|East Coast Bays||Gary Knapp||2,020||Murray McCully (National)|
|Eastern Hutt||Trevor Young||6,005||M J McLauchlan (National)|
|Eden||Aussie Malcolm||Richard Northey||2,306||Aussie Malcolm (National)|
|Fendalton||Philip Burdon||1,457||M J Dobson (Labour)|
|Franklin||(new electorate)||Bill Birch||5,210||R Haywood (Labour)|
|Glenfield||(new electorate)||Judy Keall||809||D L Schnauer (National)|
|Gisborne||Bob Bell||Allan Wallbank||1,100||Bob Bell (National)|
|Hamilton East||Ian Shearer||Bill Dillon||2,168||Ian Shearer (National)|
|Hamilton West||Mike Minogue||Trevor Mallard||809||Mike Minogue (National)|
|Hastings||David Butcher||4,273||P D Brown (National)|
|Hauraki||Graeme Lee||3,432||A D T Thompson (Social Credit)|
|Hawkes Bay||Richard Harrison||Bill Sutton||974||Richard Harrison (National)|
|Heretaunga||Bill Jeffries||4,537||A J MacFarlane (National)|
|Horowhenua||Geoff Thompson||Annette King||447||Geoff Thompson (National)|
|Invercargill||Norman Jones||1,279||D E H Soper (Labour)|
|Island Bay||Frank O'Flynn||6,007||J Kananghinis (National)|
|Kaimai||Bruce Townshend||3,696||L J B Dickson (NZ Party)|
|Kaipara||Peter Ian Wilkinson||Lockwood Smith||5,564||W J Campbell (Social Credit)|
|Kapiti||Margaret Shields||4,514||I J Oakley (National)|
|King Country||Jim Bolger||5,617||J E Simons (Labour)|
|Lyttelton||Ann Hercus||4,963||D G Graham (National)|
|Manawatu||Michael Cox||420||D C Alton (Labour)|
|Mangere||David Lange||8,375||P L Saunders (National)|
|Manurewa||Roger Douglas||4,933||S Leenstra (National)|
|Marlborough||Doug Kidd||612||G MacDonald (Labour)|
|Matamata||Jack Luxton||5,785||R I Clow (Labour)|
|Miramar||Peter Neilsen||3,499||D Crosbie (National)|
|Mt Albert||Helen Clark||6,207||R O Cavanagh (National)|
|Napier||Geoff Braybrooke||6,399||M P Liddell (National)|
|Nelson||Philip Woollaston||3,459||Mel Courtney (Independent)|
|New Lynn||Jonathan Hunt||6,340||R A Hanson (National)|
|New Plymouth||Tony Friedlander||269||Ida Gaskin (Labour)|
|North Shore||George Gair||3,710||P J Harris (Labour)|
|Ohariu||Hugh Templeton||Peter Dunne||1,371||Hugh Templeton (National)|
|Onehunga||Fred Gerbic||4,508||C A Freeman (National)|
|Otago||Warren Cooper||1,375||J D Polson (Labour)|
|Otara||(new electorate)||Colin Moyle||6,519||M M M Tahia (National)|
|Pahiatua||John Falloon||5,478||M Brazendale (Labour)|
|Pakuranga||Pat Hunt||Neil Morrison||172||Pat Hunt (National)|
|Palmerston North||Trevor de Cleene||3,033||C G Singleton (National)|
|Panmure||(new electorate)||Bob Tizard||5,979||C Tedesco (National)|
|Papakura||Merv Wellington||1,447||D L John (Labour)|
|Papatoetoe||Eddie Isbey||2,996||P F O'Brien (National)|
|Pencarrow||Fraser Colman||5,418||K J B Cranston (National)|
|Porirua||Gerard Wall||5,418||A L Gadsby (National)|
|Raglan||(new electorate)||Simon Upton||1,976||L Holmes (Labour)|
|Rangiora||Derek Quigley||Jim Gerard||346||B C Tomlinson (Labour)|
|Rangitikei||Bruce Beetham||Denis Marshall||5,799||Bruce Beetham (Social Credit)|
|Remuera||Allan Highet||Doug Graham||3,483||K L Sandford (NZ Party)|
|Rodney||(new electorate)||Don McKinnon||3,876||B R Dent (Labour)|
|Roskill||Phil Goff||4,208||C N Knowles (National)|
|Rotorua||Paul East||811||B D Arps (Labour)|
|St Albans||David Caygill||6,172||I G B Wilson (National)|
|St Kilda||Michael Cullen||5,594||J S Clark (National)|
|Selwyn||Ruth Richardson||3,829||C E Manning (Labour)|
|Sydenham||John Kirk[nb 1]||Jim Anderton||7,255||E L Bonisch (National)|
|Tamaki||Robert Muldoon||3,758||R Tulloch (Labour)|
|Taranaki||David Thomson||Roger Maxwell||6,013||G N Waters (Labour)|
|Tarawera||Ian McLean||3,377||M R Moore (Labour)|
|Tasman||Bill Rowling||Ken Shirley||1,854||G H Hunt (National)|
|Tauranga||Keith Allen||Winston Peters||4,912||D J Parlour (NZ Party)|
|Te Atatu||Michael Bassett||4,991||F W G Diment (National)|
|Timaru||Basil Arthur||2,219||Maurice McTigue (National)|
|Titirangi||(new electorate)||Ralph Maxwell||3,954||J C McIntosh (National)|
|Tongariro||(new electorate)||Noel Scott||3,870||N F Rangi (National)|
|Waikaremoana||(new electorate)||Roger McClay||1,737||J N Harré (Labour)|
|Waikato||Simon Upton||Rob Storey||1,658||P J Cleave (Labour)|
|Waipa||Marilyn Waring||Katherine O'Regan||5,667||A H Allen (Labour)|
|Wairarapa||Ben Couch||Reg Boorman||394||Ben Couch (National)|
|Waitakere||Ralph Maxwell||4,474||J C McIntosh (National)|
|Waitaki||Jonathan Elworthy||Jim Sutton||561||Jonathan Elworthy (National)|
|Waitotara||Venn Young||3,314||S C Perry (Social Credit)|
|Wallace||Derek Angus||5,663||C J Fisher (Labour)|
|Wanganui||Russell Marshall||3,918||Terry Heffernan (Social Credit)|
|Wellington Central||Fran Wilde||4,116||R A Young Rouse (National)|
|West Auckland||(new electorate)||Jack Elder||2,229||Dail Jones (National)|
|West Coast||Kerry Burke||4,293||J W Bateman (National)|
|Western Hutt||John Terris||4,348||J W Tanner (National)|
|Whangarei||John Banks||2,003||B C Manger (Labour)|
|Yaldhurst||Mick Connelly||Margaret Austin||2,970||H Joseph (National)|
|Eastern Maori||Peter Tapsell||11,230||B R Kiwara (National)|
|Northern Maori||Bruce Gregory||7,688||Matiu Rata (Mana Motuhake)|
|Southern Maori||Whetu Tirikatene-Sullivan||10,495||N A Reedy (Mana Motuhake)|
|Western Maori||Koro Wētere||10,110||W S Katene (National)|
- In July 1983 Kirk said he would not stand in 1984: when Anderton was selected for Sydenham Kirk (a Lange supporter) withdrew from the Labour caucus and was suspended by Labour, becoming an independent
Summary of changes
- Eleven new seats were created, of which seven (Christchurch North, Dunedin West, Glenfield, Otara, Panmure, Tongariro and West Auckland) were won by Labour, and four (Franklin, Raglan, Rodney and Waikaremoana) by National.
- A further ten seats were won by Labour from National: East Cape, Eden, Hamilton East, Hamilton West, Hawkes Bay, Horowhenua, Ohariu, Rangitikei, Wairarapa and Waitaki. National also lost Pakuranga to Social Credit.
- Nine electorates had incumbent MPs retire and replaced them with MPs from the same party, six National and three Labour. Kaipara, Rangiora, Taranaki, Tauranga, Waikato and Waipa remained National, while Sydenham, Tasman and Yaldhurst remained Labour. In Rangiora, National MP Derek Quigley's decision not to stand for re-election followed serious clashes with Muldoon over economic policy, while in Sydenham, John Kirk had resigned from the Labour Party.