Free-market healthcare: Difference between revisions
m →See also: rmv. link to deleted article |
added a source and example on how free market health care improved LASIK while lowering the cost. Tag: possible conflict of interest |
||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
{{Libertarianism sidebar}} |
{{Libertarianism sidebar}} |
||
'''Free-market health care''' is a [[health care system|health care proposal]] in which all health care is bought and sold without government regulation, oversight, approval, and licensing.<ref>[http://blog.mises.org/archives/002383.asp Medical Economics: The Austrian point of view (lecture 24 of 32) ]</ref> Proponents state that this system increase health care quality and lower [[medical insurance]] costs.<ref>{{cite web|title=The Relentless Process of Socializing Health Care|url=http://mises.org/story/2946}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|title=Mises Daily Index - Canadian Health Care|url=http://mises.org/story/496}}</ref> They contend that systems like [[single-payer health care]] and [[publicly-funded health care]] result in higher costs, inefficiency, longer waiting times for care, denial of care to some, and overall mismanagement.<ref name=stossel/> |
'''Free-market health care''' is a [[health care system|health care proposal]] in which all health care is bought and sold without government regulation, oversight, approval, and licensing.<ref>[http://blog.mises.org/archives/002383.asp Medical Economics: The Austrian point of view (lecture 24 of 32) ]</ref> Proponents state that this system increase health care quality and lower [[medical insurance]] costs.<ref>{{cite web|title=The Relentless Process of Socializing Health Care|url=http://mises.org/story/2946}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|title=Mises Daily Index - Canadian Health Care|url=http://mises.org/story/496}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|title=Obamacare Will Lead to Loss of Millions of US Healthcare Jobs|url=http://medibid.com/blog/?p=1525}}</ref> [[LASIK]] eye surgery is just one of many examples in which free-market health care improved the quality while decreasing the price. Ralph Weber, who participated in a 2006 health care forum with presidential hopeful, Rudy Giuliani, created his website to allow free-market health care to thrive, because he feels that "when doctors compete based on cost, quality and value, patients win."<ref>{{cite web|title=Obamacare Will Lead to Loss of Millions of US Healthcare Jobs|url=http://medibid.com/blog/?p=1525}}</ref> They contend that systems like [[single-payer health care]] and [[publicly-funded health care]] result in higher costs, inefficiency, longer waiting times for care, denial of care to some, and overall mismanagement.<ref name=stossel/> |
||
Skeptics argue that health care as an unregulated commodity invokes market failures not present with government regulation and that selling health care as a commodity leads to both unfair and inefficient systems with poorer individuals being unable to afford preventive care.<ref name=scott/> It has also been contended that such a system is inherently selfish, and leads to unnecessary death.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-usmvYOPfco|title=Alan Grayson on the GOP Health Care Plan: "Don't Get Sick! And if You Do Get Sick, Die Quickly!"'|date=2009-09-29|author=[[Alan Grayson]]}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=__hvbEJkXyg|title=Congressman Alan Grayson Says Don't Get Sick|date=2009-10-02|publisher=[[Brave New Films]]}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCAPX0RKwDU|title=Rep. Alan Grayson: "I apologize to the dead and their families"|date=2009-09-30|author=[[Alan Grayson]]}}</ref> |
Skeptics argue that health care as an unregulated commodity invokes market failures not present with government regulation and that selling health care as a commodity leads to both unfair and inefficient systems with poorer individuals being unable to afford preventive care.<ref name=scott/> It has also been contended that such a system is inherently selfish, and leads to unnecessary death.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-usmvYOPfco|title=Alan Grayson on the GOP Health Care Plan: "Don't Get Sick! And if You Do Get Sick, Die Quickly!"'|date=2009-09-29|author=[[Alan Grayson]]}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=__hvbEJkXyg|title=Congressman Alan Grayson Says Don't Get Sick|date=2009-10-02|publisher=[[Brave New Films]]}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCAPX0RKwDU|title=Rep. Alan Grayson: "I apologize to the dead and their families"|date=2009-09-30|author=[[Alan Grayson]]}}</ref> |
||
Revision as of 00:25, 21 December 2010
| This article is part of a series on |
| Healthcare reform in the United States |
|---|
 United States portal Health care portal |
| Part of a series on |
| Libertarianism |
|---|
Free-market health care is a health care proposal in which all health care is bought and sold without government regulation, oversight, approval, and licensing.[1] Proponents state that this system increase health care quality and lower medical insurance costs.[2][3][4] LASIK eye surgery is just one of many examples in which free-market health care improved the quality while decreasing the price. Ralph Weber, who participated in a 2006 health care forum with presidential hopeful, Rudy Giuliani, created his website to allow free-market health care to thrive, because he feels that "when doctors compete based on cost, quality and value, patients win."[5] They contend that systems like single-payer health care and publicly-funded health care result in higher costs, inefficiency, longer waiting times for care, denial of care to some, and overall mismanagement.[6]
Skeptics argue that health care as an unregulated commodity invokes market failures not present with government regulation and that selling health care as a commodity leads to both unfair and inefficient systems with poorer individuals being unable to afford preventive care.[7] It has also been contended that such a system is inherently selfish, and leads to unnecessary death.[8][9][10]
Positions
Free-market health care advocates assert that:
- Patents on pharmaceuticals make medication more expensive and encourages excessive advertising of their drugs, compared to non-patented remedies. Therefore, they oppose patents on pharmaceuticals.[11]
- Medical schools and public education teach conventional medicine and disregards alternative medicine. Therefore, they detract government funding of medical schools and education.[12][13]
- Medical licensing of medical doctors, hospitals, and pharmacies drive up health care prices because it produces a scarcity in health practitioners. Therefore, they want to eliminate government licensing and instead advocate market-based certification.[11][14][15]
- Tariffs on imported drugs and herbs raise the price while producing no economic benefit. Abolishing all tariffs will result in a comparative advantage, thus benefit both parties.[11]
Debates and arguments
Critics of a free market based system such as Eben Harrell of Time argue that the evidence is that in the United Kingdom, which operates a truly socialized health care system, many health outcomes are as good as and sometimes better than in the US where health care has a much lower involvement by government. They concede that the U.S. ranks better on some criteria such as cancer mortality rates. They also argue based on the fact that the cost of health care in the UK is $2,500 per annum compared to $6,000 per annum in the US, although people in the US with comprehensive medical insurance can face shorter waiting lists.[16] Dr. Arthur Kellermann, Associate Dean for health policy at Emory University, has stated that allocating health care by ability to pay rather than by anticipated medical benefits in the US makes its system more unproductive, with poor people avoiding preventive care and eventually using expensive emergency treatment.[7]
John Stossel, an investigative reporter and a supporter of a unbundled commodity system, has remarked that "Insurance invites waste. That's a reason health care costs so much, and is often so consumer-unfriendly. In the few areas where there are free markets in health care -- such as cosmetic medicine and Lasik eye surgery -- customer service is great, and prices continue to drop."[6] Republican Senator and medical doctor Tom Coburn has stated that the healthcare system in Switzerland should serve as a model for U.S. reform. He wrote for New York Sun that reform should involve a market-based method transferring health care tax benefits to individuals rather than employers as well as giving individuals extra tax credits to afford more coverage.[17]
Movements
The health freedom movement supports free choice in health care. The libertarian Ludwig von Mises Institute argues in favor of deregulation of the medical profession and health care sector.[18] Some activists are politically left-wing, whilst the Republican congressman and 2008 U.S. presidential candidate Ron Paul, who supports a free-market health care system,[19] calls himself a free market libertarian. A leading supporter of the movement,[20] Paul introduced the Health Freedom Protection Act in the U.S. Congress in 2005.[21][22]
See also
References
- ^ Medical Economics: The Austrian point of view (lecture 24 of 32)
- ^ "The Relentless Process of Socializing Health Care".
- ^ "Mises Daily Index - Canadian Health Care".
- ^ "Obamacare Will Lead to Loss of Millions of US Healthcare Jobs".
- ^ "Obamacare Will Lead to Loss of Millions of US Healthcare Jobs".
- ^ a b John Stossel (October 16, 2006). "Health Insurance Isn't All It's Cracked Up to Be". ABC News. Retrieved September 27, 2009.
- ^ a b Horsley, Scott (July 1, 2009). "Doctors Say Health Care Rationing Already Exists". National Public Radio: All Things Considered. Retrieved September 7, 2009.
{{cite news}}: Italic or bold markup not allowed in:|publisher=(help) - ^ Alan Grayson (2009-09-29). "Alan Grayson on the GOP Health Care Plan: "Don't Get Sick! And if You Do Get Sick, Die Quickly!"'".
- ^ "Congressman Alan Grayson Says Don't Get Sick". Brave New Films. 2009-10-02.
- ^ Alan Grayson (2009-09-30). "Rep. Alan Grayson: "I apologize to the dead and their families"".
- ^ a b c "The Free Market: Four-Step Health Care Solution, A".
- ^ Health Care in Prison
- ^ http://www.lewrockwell.com/shaffer/shaffer149.html
- ^ How Medical Boards Nationalized Health Care
- ^ "Socialized Healthcare Is Not Cheaper Than Free Market Healthcare".
- ^ Harrell, Eben (August 18, 2009). "Is Britain's Health-Care System Really That Bad?". Time. Retrieved September 27, 2009.
{{cite news}}: Italic or bold markup not allowed in:|publisher=(help) - ^ Tom Coburn (March 10, 2008). "Competition Solves Health Care". New York Sun. Retrieved September 27, 2009.
{{cite news}}: Italic or bold markup not allowed in:|publisher=(help) - ^ How Medical Boards Nationalized Health Care - Henry Jones - Mises Institute
- ^ Ron Paul candidate platform, The Boston Herald Published 27 December 2007. Accessed 5 December 2008.
- ^ "Ron Paul 2008 Hope for America" Accessed 28 September 2007.
- ^ Health Freedom Protection Act Introduced in US Congress
- ^ Free Speech and Dietary Supplements