Jump to content

Same-sex marriage status in the United States by state: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
I made a few minor changes with changing colors from teal to blue. Looks more neat.
Line 133: Line 133:
| <!-- Marriage Recognition? --> Not legal
| <!-- Marriage Recognition? --> Not legal
| bgcolor=black |
| bgcolor=black |
| <!-- Civil Unions Def? --> No
| <!-- Civil Unions Def? --> As Civil Unions Effective 6/1/11
| bgcolor=#bbffee | <!-- Civil Unions Status? --> [[Civil unions in Delaware|Yes (Effective 1/1/2012)]]
| bgcolor=#bbeeff | <!-- Civil Unions Status? --> [[Civil unions in Delaware|Yes (Effective 1/1/2012)]]
| <!-- Domestic Partnership Def? --> No
| <!-- Domestic Partnership Def? --> No
| <!-- Domestic Partnerships Status? --> [[Domestic partnership in Delaware|None]]
| <!-- Domestic Partnerships Status? --> [[Domestic partnership in Delaware|None]]
Line 416: Line 416:
| <!-- Notes --> Does not contain any public policy explicitly banning same-sex marriage nor defining marriage as between a man and a woman (effectively making the state neutral).
| <!-- Notes --> Does not contain any public policy explicitly banning same-sex marriage nor defining marriage as between a man and a woman (effectively making the state neutral).
|- valign=top
|- valign=top
| [[Image:Flag of New York.svg|20px]] [[New York]] <!-- State -->
| bgcolor=#bbeeff | [[Image:Flag of New York.svg|20px]] [[New York]] <!-- State -->
| <!-- Constitution? --> Yes
| <!-- Constitution? --> Yes
| <!-- Statute? --> [[Same-sex marriage legislation in the United States by state#New York|Yes]]
| <!-- Statute? --> [[Same-sex marriage legislation in the United States by state#New York|Yes]]
| bgcolor=#bbffee | <!-- Marriage Licenses? --> [[Same-sex marriage in New York|Legal]]* Approved June 24, 2011
| bgcolor=#bbeeff | <!-- Marriage Licenses? --> [[Same-sex marriage in New York|Legal]]* Approved June 24, 2011
| bgcolor=#bbeeff | <!-- Marriage Recognition? --> Yes, by governmental entities; see [[Same sex marriage in New York#Official_recognition_of_unions_performed_in_other_states|Same sex marriage in New York]].
| bgcolor=#bbeeff | <!-- Marriage Recognition? --> Yes, by governmental entities; see [[Same sex marriage in New York#Official_recognition_of_unions_performed_in_other_states|Same sex marriage in New York]].
| bgcolor=black |
| bgcolor=black |
Line 426: Line 426:
| <!-- Domestic Partnership Def? --> No
| <!-- Domestic Partnership Def? --> No
| <!-- Domestic Partnership Status? --> [[Domestic partnership in New York|None]]
| <!-- Domestic Partnership Status? --> [[Domestic partnership in New York|None]]
| <!-- Notes --> ''Main article:<br> [[Same-sex marriage in New York]] http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/25/nyregion/gay-marriage-approved-by-new-york-senate.html''
| <!-- Notes --> ''Main article:<br> [[Same-sex marriage in New York]]
|- valign=top
|- valign=top
| [[Image:Flag of North Carolina.svg|20px]] [[North Carolina]] <!-- State -->
| [[Image:Flag of North Carolina.svg|20px]] [[North Carolina]] <!-- State -->

Revision as of 05:31, 25 June 2011

Status of same-sex marriage in the United States
  Performed and recognized
  Recognized when performed elsewhere
  Recognized by state and federal governments, but not by tribal government
  (mixed jurisdiction; not performed by tribal government)
  (mixed jurisdiction; not performed or recognized by tribal government)

Same-sex unions have been on the political radar in the United States since the Hawaii Supreme Court ruled in 1993 that denying licenses to same-sex partners violated the Hawaii constitution unless there is a "compelling state interest." Since Massachusetts became the first state to legalize same-sex marriage in 2004, other states have redefined their own marriage laws, both for and against same-sex marriage.

This article tracks the status of those laws. It is intended only as a resource for the bottom line current legal status of same-sex unions right now regardless of pending litigation. See same-sex marriage legislation in the United States for the outcome of specific legislation and same-sex marriage law in the United States by state for detailed descriptions.

Marriage is defined as the union of one man and one woman in at least 42 states.[1] Currently, 30 states have added defense of marriage amendments to their constitutions. There are five states that recognize or will soon recognize same-sex marriages, and a total of six (plus the District of Columbia) that recognize some form of same-sex civil unions or domestic partnerships.[2]

State-by-state listing

Below is the status of the law in each of the 50 states, plus the District of Columbia.

  • The Marriage Defined column tells whether that state contains any statutes or constitutional language that defines marriage as between a man and a woman or otherwise bans same-sex marriages.
    • The Constitution sub-column gives links to the constitutional amendment story, if existing.
    • The Statute leads to the corresponding section of Same-sex marriage legislation in the United States by state to afford full legislation about constitution and statutes. (Under construction, if not afforded, see HRC and Domawatch links below that page).
  • The other links (licenses - Civil unions status - domestic partnership status - provides for appropriate page denominations according to marriage - civil unions - domestic partnership and shows the existing pages if the link is active. Civil unions denomination is left in the plural form because it is the rule used for other countries (see Category:Marriage, unions and partnerships by country below )
    • The details for the marriage recognition (Recogn.) are to be found with the marriage license link when active. Since constitutional bans are more difficult to overturn, the marriage license and recognition columns have been merged in such cases for relevant states.
    • Def. means constitutional definition amendment for the corresponding unions or partnership. When it happens to be the same constitutional definition amendment as the link in the Marriage Defined - Constitution column, the Def. and Status columns have been merged. Otherwise another link is proposed to the other relevant amendment in the Def. column in relevant cases.
  • The blue squares show what is allowed and green ones, potential changes in the near future.
  • The notes column gives better detail and recent possibilities.
State Marriage Same-sex unions Notes
Defined Result Civil Unions Domestic
Partnership
Constitution Statute Licenses Recogn. Def. Status Def. Status
Alabama Yes Yes Banned Banned No None
Alaska Yes Yes Banned No None No None Petitions are made to start a ban ballot on civil unions too.
Arizona Yes Yes Banned No None No None
Arkansas Yes Yes Banned Banned No None
California Yes Yes (°) Banned
Ban upheld by California Supreme Court.[3]
Ban overturned by the District Court for Northern California, ruling stayed pending appeal.
Yes; Conditional No None
No Yes Main article:
Same-sex marriage in California

Originally granting only hospital visitation rights, the scope of domestic partnerships was gradually expanded over a three-year period. Taking effect on January 1, 2005, A.B. 205 extended to domestic partnerships virtually all the legal rights and responsibilities of marriage in California. Thus, domestic partnership in California has been effectively transformed into a civil union status.

Colorado Yes Yes Banned No Failed (Still Proposed) Yes On November 2006 ballot, Colorado banned marriage but rejected a referendum to allow a "civil union"-like domestic partnership, sustained by a constitutional amendment. See also this table
Connecticut No No Legal* by
Supreme
Court
decision, then by legislation.
Yes Expires on 1 October 2010 Expires on 1 October 2010 None None Main article:
Same-sex marriage in Connecticut

Connecticut allows full civil marriage licences to same-sex couples. Civil unions expire from 1 October 2010.

Delaware No Yes Not legal Not legal As Civil Unions Effective 6/1/11 Yes (Effective 1/1/2012) No None
District of Columbia No No Legal Yes No None No Legal* Main article: Same-sex marriage in the District of Columbia

Domestic partnerships were enacted in 1992; implemented from 2002 and then expanded from 2003 to 2009. Same-sex marriages were legalized on December 18, 2009 and marriages began on March 9, 2010.

Florida Yes Yes Banned Banned No None
Georgia Yes Yes Banned Banned No None
Hawaii Yes Yes Ban
permitted
Not legal.
As Civil Union Effective 1/1/12 Yes None
(Effective 1/1/12)
No Legal* Minimal benefits, available to all adults, including relatives; official terminology is reciprocal beneficiary relationship*.[2]

Civil Union Bill 2010 has been approved in the 2010 Senate, vote pending in the Hawaii House Committee.

Idaho Yes Yes Banned Banned No None
Illinois No Yes Not legal As Civil Unions Effective 6/1/11 No Yes Effective 6/1/11 No None Petitions are made to start a ban ballot. Marriage or civil union proposition, heading rather to civil unions.
Indiana No Yes Not legal Not legal No None No None Legislative initiative to start a ban ballot.
Iowa No No Legal* by
Supreme
Court
decision
Yes No None No None Main article:
Same-sex marriage in Iowa

In August 2007, Polk County judge ruled Iowa's statutory ban on same-sex marriage was unconstitutional, but ruling was quickly stayed and appealed. On appeal, the Iowa Supreme Court upheld the Polk County ruling in the case of Varnum v. Brien.

Legislative initiative to begin constitutional ban ballot process was unsuccessful in 2009. Republicans in opposition vow to push the issue in 2010 legislative session.

Kansas Yes Yes Banned Banned Uncertain
Kentucky Yes Yes Banned Banned No None
Louisiana Yes Yes Banned Banned No None
Maine No (but proposed by Republicans) Banned by statute since 1997 and was rejected by "the people's veto" in 2009. No (rejected by "the people's veto" in 2009) No (rejected by "the people's veto"in 2009) No None Yes (both opposite sex and same sex) Legal* Main article:
Domestic partnership in Maine

The Maine Domestic Partnership Act came into effect on July 30, 2004.[1]
Same-sex couple who married elsewhere may register their marriage as a domestic partnership. The "people's veto" won by 52.9 percent in November 2009.

Maryland No Yes Not legal* Same-Sex Marriage Postponed until 2012 Not legal No None Few rights, unregistered domestic partnerships provide certain limited legal rights - just like Wisconsin, Hawaii and Colorado. Legal* Main article:
Same-sex marriage in Maryland

"The first state law defining marriage as a union between a man and woman was adopted by Maryland in 1973."[1]

Massachusetts No No Legal* by
Supreme
Court
decision
Yes. No None No None Main article:
Same-sex marriage in Massachusetts
Michigan Yes Yes Banned Banned Banned* by
Supreme
Court
decision
Minnesota No Yes Not legal Not legal No None No None Legislative initiative and petitions are made to start a ban ballot.
Mississippi Yes Yes Banned No None No None
Missouri Yes Yes Banned No None No None
Montana Yes Yes Banned No None No None
Nebraska Yes Yes Banned Banned Banned
Nevada Yes Yes Banned No No Yes Yes Domestic partnership legislation in Nevada is similar to the Californian/Oregon models.
New Hampshire No No Legal Yes No Legal - Expires on midnight 1/1/2011. No None New Hampshire allows full civil marriage licences to same-sex couples, civil unions to expire and convert into marriage from 1 January 2011.
New Jersey Proposal
rejected
No* None As civil
unions
No Legal No No more
but
present
valid
ones
allowed.
Main article:
Same-sex marriage in New Jersey

The state of New Jersey has neither allowed nor recognized marriages between couples of the same-sex. However, the New Jersey Supreme Court, in Lewis v. Harris, required the New Jersey Legislature to change state law by April 24, 2007 to afford same-sex couples the same rights as heterosexual couples.[4] A bill now allows civil unions that will supersede domestic partnerships. These are no more applied but may remain for the present ones.

New Mexico No No None None No None No None Does not contain any public policy explicitly banning same-sex marriage nor defining marriage as between a man and a woman (effectively making the state neutral).
New York Yes Yes Legal* Approved June 24, 2011 Yes, by governmental entities; see Same sex marriage in New York. Yes None No None Main article:
Same-sex marriage in New York
North Carolina No Yes Not legal Not legal No None No None Legislative initiative to start a ban ballot.
North Dakota Yes Yes Banned Banned No None
Ohio Yes Yes Banned Banned No None
Oklahoma Yes Yes Banned Banned No None
Oregon Yes No Banned* No Legal
No Yes Main article:
Same-sex marriage in Oregon

Domestic partnership legislation in Oregon is very similar to the California and Nevada model.

Pennsylvania No Yes Not legal Not legal No None No None Petitions are made to start a ban ballot.
Rhode Island No No Proposed Yes No Proposed No None Does not contain any public policy explicitly banning same-sex marriage nor defining marriage as between a man and a woman (effectively making the state neutral). Does not award marriage licenses, but does extend limited rights to same-sex couples.[2] Now this is the basis on which RI will recognize the same-sex couples married in Massachusetts according to the Attorney General.
South Carolina Yes Yes Banned Banned Yes None
South Dakota Yes Yes Banned Banned Banned
Tennessee Yes Yes Banned No None No None
Texas Yes Yes Banned Banned No None
Utah Yes Yes Banned Banned No None
Vermont No No Legal[5] Yes No No more
but
present
valid
ones
allowed.
No None Vermont allows full civil marriage licences to same-sex couples. Civil unions still recognised before 31 August 2009, but can not be performed after that date - also there is no "conversion into civil marriage" (as CT and NH have done).
Virginia Yes Yes Banned Banned Banned
Washington No Yes Not legal
*
As domestic partners No None Yes (same-sex only) Legal Main article:
Same-sex marriage in Washington

Same-sex couple who married elsewhere may register their marriage as a domestic partnership. The 2009 reforms called the "all-but-marriage" law will come into effect from December 3, 2009, since it was approved by voters by 53 percent.

West Virginia No Yes Not legal Not legal No None No None Petitions are made to start a ban ballot.
Wisconsin Yes Yes Banned Banned Yes Yes Domestic partnerships provide certain limited legal rights - just like Hawaii, Maryland and Colorado.
Wyoming No Yes Not legal Not legal No None No None State law pre-dates DOMA.[1]
State Marriage Same-sex unions Notes
Defined Result Civil Unions Domestic
Partnership
Constitution Statute Licenses Recogn. Def. Status Def. Status

See also

In general

In USA

References

  1. ^ a b c d Stateline.org 50-state rundown on gay marriage laws Accessed November 4, 2008
  2. ^ a b c Human Rights Campaign State by State Information Accessed November 14, 2006
  3. ^ "California high court upholds same-sex marriage ban - CNN.com". CNN. May 27, 2009. Retrieved 2010-05-23.
  4. ^ http://www.judiciary.state.nj.us/opinions/supreme/a-68-05.pdf
  5. ^ "Vermont Legalizes Gay Marriage". WCAX-TV. 2009-04-07. Retrieved 2009-04-07.