Dave Meltzer

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
  (Redirected from 5-star match)
Jump to: navigation, search
Dave Meltzer
Born David Allen Meltzer
(1959-10-24) October 24, 1959 (age 57)
New York, New York, U.S.
Occupation Author, journalist, professional wrestling historian
Nationality American
Education Leland High School
San Jose State University
Alma mater San Jose State
Subject Professional wrestling
Mixed martial arts
Notable works Wrestling Observer Newsletter; Tributes: Remembering Some of the World's Greatest Wrestlers; Tributes II: Remembering More of the World's Greatest Wrestlers
Spouse Mary Anne Meltzer[1]
Children 2[2]

David Allen Meltzer[3] (born October 24, 1959) is an American journalist covering professional wrestling and mixed martial arts.

Since 1983, he has been the publisher/editor of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter (WON). He has also written for the Oakland Tribune, the Los Angeles Times, Yahoo! Sports, and The National Sports Daily. He has extensively covered mixed martial arts since UFC 1 in 1993 and currently covers the sport for SB Nation. He has been called "the most accomplished reporter in sports journalism" by Frank Deford of Sports Illustrated.[4]

He is also a frequent lecturer on many aspects of the business of MMA, professional wrestling, and boxing at the Graduate School of Business, Stanford University.[5]

Early life[edit]

Meltzer was born in New York City, lived in upstate New York until he was ten, before his family settled in San Jose, California.[6] Meltzer earned a journalism degree from San Jose State University and started out as a sports writer for the Wichita Falls Times Record News and the Turlock Journal. He demonstrated an interest in professional wrestling and a journalistic approach to it early in life. Meltzer wrote several wrestling-related publications that predate WON, dating back to 1971. The most notable of these was the California Wrestling Report, ca. 1973–1974, which reported on the still-extant National Wrestling Alliance territories operating out of Los Angeles and San Francisco.

Wrestling Observer Newsletter[edit]

The beginnings of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter (WON) date back to 1980, when Meltzer began an annual poll amongst those with whom he corresponded regarding professional wrestling. According to Meltzer, he was just a fan at first. A short time later, he began maintaining a tape-trading list, and would occasionally send match results and news updates along with tape updates. Meltzer stated that he wanted to keep his friends in college "in the loop" for his tape trading as well as the happenings in the business, as the mainstream wrestling magazines catered to a somewhat younger demographic.[7]


Meltzer popularized the "star rating" system (devised by Jim Cornette and his childhood friend Norm M. Dooley[citation needed]), which rates matches on a scale of zero to five stars (sometimes going to negative five stars in the case of very bad matches) in a similar manner to that used by many movie critics.[6] As in the field of film, a rating is a largely subjective affair that may take into account the amount of action as opposed to restholds ("workrate"), the difficulty and variety of moves used, the history of the workers and their feud, the development of an in-match storyline based on the wrestling moves and how they affect the wrestlers, and the overall reaction of the crowd.

Five-star matches, as rated by Meltzer, are extremely rare. The latest was KUSHIDA vs. Will Ospreay on June 3, 2017, at the New Japan Pro-Wrestling (NJPW) show Best of the Super Juniors. 92 matches have received the honor since Dynamite Kid and Tiger Mask I were the inaugural "five star match". Mitsuharu Misawa has the most five-star matches with 23 (including one match wrestling as Tiger Mask II).

Meltzer has also given ratings that have exceeded five-stars, giving a six-star rating to a match between Mitsuharu Misawa and Toshiaki Kawada,[8] and to the Wrestle Kingdom 11 match between Kazuchika Okada and Kenny Omega.[9] Meltzer went even further beyond the six-star rating in June 2017, when he gave the Dominion 6.11 in Osaka-jo Hall rematch between Okada and Omega 6¼ (******1/4) stars.[10]

Despite this rating system representing only the subjective opinion of one individual, wrestlers, such as Bret Hart, have written how proud they were when their performances were praised in the WON.[11]



  • Cauliflower Alley Club
    • James Melby Historian Award (2017)[12]
  • George Tragos/Lou Thesz Professional Wrestling Hall of Fame
    • Jim Melby Award (2016)[2]

See also[edit]


  1. ^ Meltzer, Dave (2008-05-08). "Nick Bollea to be sentenced; New fight on Dream show; Match announced for TNA PPV, more". Wrestling Observer Newsletter. Retrieved 2014-02-11. 
  2. ^ a b Laprade, Patric (July 18, 2016). "Melby Award for Meltzer proper recognition for pioneering work". Slam! Sports. Canadian Online Explorer. Retrieved July 22, 2016. 
  3. ^ Wrestling Observer Newsletter trademark, Trademarkia, Accessed 2010-08-12
  4. ^ Rossen, Jake (2013-05-15). "In World of Wrestling, Trying to Keep It Real". The New York Times. Retrieved 2013-05-18. 
  5. ^ "Lecture by guest speakers Mike Church and Dave Meltzer in Prof. George Foster's class in SearchWorks". 
  6. ^ a b "Dean S. Planet's Celeb Interviews.". Dean S. Planet's. Retrieved 2007-07-11. 
  7. ^ Benaka, Lee (1991). "The Lee Benaka Interviews - Dave Meltzer.". Benaka, Lee. Death Valley Driver Video Review. Retrieved 2007-07-11. 
  8. ^ "Dave Meltzer on Twitter". 
  9. ^ Meltzer, Dave (5 January 2017). "January 9, 2017 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: Ronda Rousey loses potential final fight, NJPW Wrestle Kingdom 11 review". WON/F4W - WWE news, Pro Wrestling News, WWE Results, UFC News, UFC results. 
  10. ^ Meltzer, Dave (June 19, 2017). "June 19, 2017 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: Conor McGregor/Floyd Mayweather on, Okada/Omega classic, more". Wrestling Observer Newsletter. Campbell, California: 17–19. ISSN 1083-9593. 
  11. ^ Hart, Bret (2009). Hitman: My Real Life in the Cartoon World of Wrestling. Grand Central Publishing. p. 214. ISBN 978-0-446-54528-0. 
  12. ^ "Congratulation to Dave Meltzer, the 2017 James Melby Historian Award Winner - Cauliflower Alley Club". 

External links[edit]