Allen Telescope Array
The Allen Telescope Array (ATA-42), October 11, 2007.
|Named after||Paul Allen|
|Observatory||Hat Creek Radio Observatory|
Radio Astronomy Laboratory|
|Altitude||986 m (3,235 ft)|
|Wavelength||60, 2.7 cm (500, 11,100 MHz)|
|Number of telescopes||42|
|Diameter||6.1 m (20 ft 0 in)|
|Secondary diameter||2.4 m (7 ft 10 in)|
|Collecting area||1,227 m2 (13,210 sq ft)|
The Allen Telescope Array (ATA), formerly known as the One Hectare Telescope (1hT), is a radio telescope array dedicated to astronomical observations and a simultaneous search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI). The array is situated at the Hat Creek Radio Observatory, 290 miles (470 km) northeast of San Francisco, California.
The project was originally developed as a joint effort between the SETI Institute and the Radio Astronomy Laboratory (RAL) at the University of California, Berkeley (UC Berkeley), with funds obtained from an initial US$11.5 million donation by the Paul G. Allen Family Foundation. The first phase of construction was completed and the ATA finally became operational on 11 October 2007 with 42 antennas (ATA-42), after Paul Allen (co-founder of Microsoft) had pledged an additional $13.5 million to support the construction of the first and second phases.
Although overall Allen has contributed more than $30 million to the project, it has not succeeded in building the 350 6.1 m (20 ft) dishes originally conceived, and the project suffered an operational hiatus due to funding shortfalls between April and August 2011, after which observations resumed. Subsequently, UC Berkeley exited the project, completing divestment in April 2012. The facility is now managed by SRI International (formerly Stanford Research Institute), an independent, nonprofit research institute. As of 2016, the SETI Institute performs observations with the ATA between the hours of 6 pm and 6 am each day, 7 days a week.
In August 2014, the installation was threatened by a forest fire in the area and was briefly forced to shut down, but ultimately emerged largely unscathed.
First conceived by SETI pioneer Frank Drake, the idea has been a dream of the SETI Institute for years. However, it was not until early 2001 that research and development began, after a donation of $11.5 million by the Paul G. Allen Family Foundation. In March 2004, following the successful completion of a three-year research and development phase, the SETI Institute unveiled a three-tier construction plan for the telescope. Construction began immediately, thanks to the pledge of $13.5 million by Paul Allen (co-founder of Microsoft) to support the construction of the first and second phases. The SETI Institute named the telescope in Allen's honor. Overall, Paul Allen has contributed more than $30 million to the project.
The ATA is a centimeter-wave array which pioneers the Large-Number Small-Diameter concept of building radio telescopes. Compared to a large dish antenna, large numbers of smaller dishes are cheaper for the same collecting area. However, to get similar sensitivity, the signals from all telescopes must be combined. This requires high-performance electronics, which had been prohibitively expensive. However, due to the declining cost of electronic components, the required electronics became practicable, resulting in a large cost-saving over telescopes of more conventional design. This is informally referred to as "replacing steel with silicon".
The ATA has four primary technical capabilities that make it well suited for a range of scientific investigations: a very wide field of view (2.45° at λ = 21 cm), complete instantaneous frequency coverage from 0.5 to 11.2 gigahertz (GHz), multiple simultaneous backends, and active interference mitigation. The area of sky which can be instantaneously imaged is 17 times that obtainable by the Very Large Array telescope. The instantaneous frequency coverage of more than four octaves is unprecedented in radio astronomy, and is the result of a unique feed, input amplifier and signal path design. Active interference mitigation will make it possible to observe even at the frequencies of many terrestrial radio emitters.
All-sky surveys are an important part of the science program,[clarification needed] and the ATA will have increased efficiency through its ability to conduct extraterrestrial intelligence searches (SETI) and other radio astronomy observations simultaneously. The telescope can do this by splitting the recorded signals in the control room prior to final processing. Simultaneous observations are possible because for SETI, wherever the telescope is pointed, several target stars will lie within the large field of view afforded by the 6 m dishes. By agreement between the UC Berkeley Radio Astronomy Laboratory (RAL) and the SETI Institute, the needs of conventional radio astronomy determined the pointing of the array up until 2012.
The ATA is planned to comprise 350 6 m dishes and will make possible large, deep radio surveys that were not previously feasible. The telescope design incorporates many new features, including hydroformed antenna surfaces, a log-periodic feed covering the entire range of frequencies from 500 megahertz (MHz) to 11.2 GHz, and low-noise, wide-band amplifiers with a flat response over the entire band, thus making it possible to amplify the sky signal directly. This amplified signal, containing the entire received bandwidth, is brought from each antenna to the processing room via optical fiber cables. This means that as electronics improve and wider bandwidths are obtainable, only the central processor needs to change, and not the antennas or feeds.
The instrument was operated and maintained by RAL until development of the array was put on hold in 2011. RAL worked hand in hand with the SETI Institute during design and prototyping and was the primary designer of the feed, antenna surfaces, beamforming, correlator, and imaging system for radio astronomy observations.
The panel for the Astronomy and Astrophysics Decadal Survey in its report, Astronomy and Astrophysics in the New Millennium, endorsed SETI and recognized the ATA (then called the 1-Hectare Telescope) as an important stepping stone towards the building of the Square Kilometer Array telescope (SKA). The most recent Decadal report recommended ending the US's financial support of the SKA, although US participation in SKA precursors such as MeerKAT, the Hydrogen Epoch of Reionization Array and the Murchison Widefield Array.
Although cost estimates of unbuilt projects are always dubious, and the specifications are not identical (conventional telescopes have lower noise temperature, but the ATA has a larger field of view, for example), the ATA has potential promise as a much cheaper radio telescope technology for a given effective aperture. For example, the amount spent on the first ATA-42 phase, including technology development, is roughly one third of the cost of a new copy of a Deep Space Network 34 m antenna of similar collecting area. Similarly, the estimated total cost of building the remaining 308 dishes was estimated (as of October 2007[update]) at about $41 million. This is about two times cheaper than the $85 million cost of the last large radio astronomy antenna built in the US, the Green Bank Telescope, of similar collecting area. The contractor filed for a $29 million overrun, but only $4 million of this was allowed.
The ATA aspires to be among the world's largest and fastest observing instruments, and to permit astronomers to search many different target stars simultaneously. If completed as originally envisioned, it will be one of the largest and most powerful telescopes in the world.
The ATA was originally planned to be constructed in four stages, ATA-42, ATA-98, ATA-206 and ATA-350, each number representing the number of dishes in the array at a given time. (See Table 1). The ATA is planned to comprise 350 dishes with a diameter of 6 m each.
Regular operations with 42 dishes started on 11 October 2007. Funding for building additional antennas is currently being sought by the SETI Institute from various sources, including the United States Navy, Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA), National Science Foundation (NSF) and private donors.
Simultaneous astronomical and SETI observations are performed with two 32-input dual polarization imaging correlators. Numerous articles reporting conventional radio astronomy observations have been published.
Three phased array beamformers utilizing the Berkeley Emulation Engine 2 (BEE2) were deployed in June 2007 and have been integrated into the system to allow for simultaneous astronomical and SETI observations. As of April 2008, the first pulsar observations were conducted using the beamformer and a purpose-built pulsar spectrometer.
The workhorse SETI search system (SETI on ATA or SonATA) performs fully automated SETI observations. SonATA follows up on detected signals in real time and continues to track them until 1) the signal is shown to have been generated on Earth or rarely, 2) the source sets, which triggers follow up the next day. As of 2016, more that two hundred million signals have been followed up and classified using the ATA. Not one of these signals had all the characteristics expected for an ETI signal. The results of SETI Institute's observations are published in a number of papers.
In April 2011, the ATA was put into hibernation owing to funding shortfalls, meaning that it was no longer available for use. Operation of the ATA resumed on 5 December 2011. Efforts are now led by Dr. Andrew Siemion.
In 2012, the ATA was funded by a $3.6 million philanthropic donation by Franklin Antonio, cofounder and Chief Scientist of Qualcomm Incorporated. This gift supports upgrades of all the receivers on the ATA dishes to have dramatically greater sensitivity (2 − 10× from 1–8 GHz) than before and support sensitive observations over a wider frequency range, from 1–15 GHz, when initially the radio frequency electronics went to only 11 GHz. By July 2016, the first ten of these receivers had been installed and proven. Full installation on all 42 antennas is planned as of June 2017[update].[needs update]
In November 2015, the ATA studied the anomalous star KIC 8462852. And in autumn 2017 the Allen Telescope Array examined the interstellar asteroid 'Oumuamua for signs of technology, but detected no unusual radio emissions.
Key science goals
The science goals listed below represent the most important projects to be conducted with the ATA. Each of these goals is associated with one of the four stages of development mentioned earlier. (See Table 1). Also listed is some of the science that it is hoped each will produce.
- Determine the hydrogen line (HI) content of galaxies out to z ∼ 0.2 over 3π steradians, in order to measure how much intergalactic gas external galaxies are accreting; to search for dark, starless galaxies; to lay the foundation for dark energy detection by the Square Kilometer Array.
- Classify 250,000 extra-galactic radio sources as active galactic nuclei or starburst galaxies, in order to probe and quantify star formation in the Local Universe; to identify high redshift objects; to probe large-scale structure in the Universe; to identify gravitational lens candidates for dark matter and dark energy detection.
- Explore the transient sky, in order to probe accretion onto black holes; to find orphan gamma ray burst afterglows; to discover new and unknown transient phenomena.
- Survey 1,000,000 stars for SETI-related emission with enough sensitivity to detect an Arecibo radar out to 300 parsecs within the range of 1–10 GHz.
- Survey the 4×1010 stars of the inner galactic plane from 1.42–1.72 GHz for very powerful transmitters.
- Measure the magnetic fields in the Milky Way and other Local Group galaxies, in order to probe the role of magnetic fields in star formation and galaxy formation and evolution.
- Detect the gravitational wave background from massive black holes through pulsar timing.
- Measure molecular cloud and star formation properties using new molecular tracers, in order to map star formation conditions on the scale of entire giant molecular clouds (GMCs); to determine the metallicity gradient of the Milky Way.
|Array||Status||Beam size (arcsec)||Srms (mJy)||Speed (deg²s−1)||Key science|
|ATA-42||Dish construction complete; commissioning in progress with 32 input, dual polarization (64 total inputs) correlator||245 x 118||0.54||0.02||FiGSS: 5 GHz Continuum Survey, Galactic Plane Molecular Spectroscopy, SETI Galactic Center Survey|
|ATA-98||Awaiting results ATA-42 for funding||120 x 80||0.2||0.11||ATHIXS† Trial Surveys, HI Stellar Outflows Survey, SETI Targeted Survey: 100 stars|
|ATA-206||Development phase not completed||75 x 65||0.11||0.44||ATHIXS, Map The Magnetized Galactic ISM, Pulsar Timing Array, Deep continuum and transient surveys, SETI Targeted Surveys|
|ATA-350||Development phase not completed||77 x 66||0.065||1.40||ATHIXS, Map The Magnetized Galactic ISM, Pulsar Timing Array Deep continuum and transient surveys, SETI Targeted Surveys|
|Note: Beam size and continuum sensitivity (Srms are estimated for a 6-minute, 100 MHz continuum snapshot observation at transit of a source at 40° declination at a wavelength of 21 cm. Speed is given for a survey at 21 cm observations with a bandwidth of 100 MHz that reaches 1 mJy rms.
†ATHIXS is an all-sky deep HI extragalactic HI survey.
Since construction of the array began, a few science goals not specifically drawn up for it have been suggested.
For example, the Allen Telescope Array has offered to provide the mooncast data downlink for any contestants in the Google Lunar X Prize. This is practical, since the array, with no modifications, covers the main space communications bands (S-band and X-band). A telemetry decoder would be the only needed addition.
Also, the ATA was mentioned as a candidate for searching for a new type of radio transient. It is an excellent choice for this owing to its large field of view and wide instantaneous bandwidth. Following this suggestion, Andrew Siemion and an international team of astronomers and engineers developed an instrument called "Fly's Eye" that allowed the ATA to search for bright radio transients, and observations were carried out between February and April 2008.
The ATA-42 configuration will provide a maximum baseline of 300 m (and ultimately for the ATA-350, 900 m). A cooled log-periodic feed on each antenna is designed to provide a system temperature of ~45K from 1–10 GHz, with reduced sensitivity in the ranges of 0.5–1.0 GHz and 10–11.2 GHz. Four separate frequency tunings (IFs) are available to produce 4 x 100 MHz intermediate frequency bands. Two IFs support correlators for imaging; two will support SETI observing. All tunings can produce four dual polarization phased array beams which can be independently pointed within the primary beam and can be used with a variety of detectors. The ATA can therefore synthesize up to 32 phased array beams.
The wide field of view of the ATA gives it an unparalleled capability for large surveys (Fig. 4). The time required for mapping a large area to a given sensitivity is proportional to (ND)2, where N is the number of elements and D is the diameter of the dish. This leads to the surprising result that a large array of small dishes can outperform an array with a smaller number of elements but considerably greater collecting area in the task of large surveys. As a consequence, even the ATA-42 is competitive with much larger telescopes in its capability for both brightness temperature and point source surveys. For point source surveys, the ATA-42 is comparable in speed to Arecibo and the Green Bank Telescope (GBT), but three times slower than the Very Large Array (VLA). The ATA-350, on the other hand, will be one order of magnitude faster than the Very Large Array for point source surveys, and is comparable to the Expanded Very Large Array (EVLA) in survey speed. For surveys up to a specified brightness temperature sensitivity, the ATA-98 will exceed the survey speed of even the VLA-D configuration. The ATA-206 should match the brightness temperature sensitivity of Arecibo and the GBT. The ATA, however, provides better resolution than either of these single-dish telescopes.
The antennas for the ATA are 6.1 x 7.0 metres (20.0 ft x 23.0 ft) hydroformed offset Gregorian telescopes, each with a 2.4 meter sub-reflector with an effective focal length/diameter (f/D) ratio of 0.65. (See DeBoer, 2001). The offset geometry eliminates blockage, which increases efficiency and decreases the side lobes. It also allows for the large sub-reflector, providing good low frequency performance. The hydroforming technology used to make these surfaces is the same as that used by Andersen Manufacturing of Idaho Falls, Idaho to generate low-cost satellite reflectors. The unique interior frame rim-supported compact mount allows excellent performance at low cost. The drive system employs a spring-loaded passive anti-backlash azimuth drive train.
As with other arrays, the huge amount of incoming sensory information requires real-time array processing capability in order to reduce data volume for storage. For ATA-256, the average data rates and total data volume for the correlator are estimated to be 100 Mbyte/s and 15 Pbytes for the five-year survey period. Experiments such as transient surveys will exceed this rate significantly. The beamformers produce data at a much higher rate (8 gigabytes per second (Gb/s)) but only a very small fraction of this data is archived. In 2009, the signal detection hardware and software was called Prelude, which was composed of rack-mounted PCs augmented by two custom accelerator cards based on digital signal processing (DSP) and field-programmable gate array (FPGA) chips. Each Programmable Detection Module (one of 28 PCs) can analyze 2 MHz of dual-polarization input data to generate spectra with spectral resolution of 0.7 Hz and time samples of 1.4 seconds.
In 2009, the array had a 40 Mbit/s internet connection, adequate for remote access and transferring of data products for ATA-256. An upgrade to 40 Gbit/s was planned, which would enable direct distribution of raw data for offsite computing.
Computational complexity and requirement
Like other array systems the ATA has a computational complexity and cross-connect which scales as O(N2) with the number of antennas . The computation requirement, for example, for correlating the full ATA bandwidth ( = 11 GHz) for the proposed = 350 dual-polarization antenna build-out, using an efficient frequency-multiply (FX) architecture and a modest 500 kHz channel width (with number of channels = 2200), is given by:
where is an operation. Note that since each dish has a dual polarization antenna, each signal sample is actually a two data set, hence .
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Allen Telescope Array.|
- Daniel Terdiman (12 December 2008). "SETI's large-scale telescope scans the skies". CNET News. Retrieved 2008-12-12.
- John Johnson Jr. (1 June 2008). "Aliens get a new switchboard: a SETI radio telescope in Northern California". The Los Angeles Times. Archived from the original on 4 October 2008. Retrieved 2008-09-29.
- Dennis Overbye (11 October 2007). "Stretching the Search for Signs of Life". The New York Times. Retrieved 2009-04-14.
- Staff writers (12 October 2007). "Skies to be swept for alien life". BBC News. Archived from the original on 12 October 2007. Retrieved 2007-10-12.
- Shostak, Seth (2009). "When Will We Find the Extraterrestrials?" (PDF). SETI.org. Engineering & Science. Archived from the original (PDF) on 15 April 2015. Retrieved 20 February 2015.
- Hardy, Michael (2011-04-29). "Federal Computer Week". Fcw.com. Retrieved 2011-09-19.
- Pierson, Tom (22 April 2011). "Status of the Allen Telescope Array" (PDF). SETI.org. SETI Institute. Archived from the original (PDF) on 3 March 2016. Retrieved 20 February 2015.
- John Cook (August 7, 2011). "Search for ET continues as Paul Allen-backed telescope hits short-term funding goal". Retrieved 29 December 2012.
- "SETI Search Resumes at Allen Telescope Array, Targeting New Planets" (Press release). SETI Institute. December 5, 2011. Retrieved 29 December 2012.
- Robert Sanders (April 13, 2012). "UC Berkeley passes management of Allen Telescope Array to SRI". UC Berkeley NewsCenter. Retrieved 29 December 2012.
- Harp, Gerald R. "SETI Signal Searching". SETI.org. SETI Institute. Retrieved 7 July 2016.
- Shostak, Seth (8 August 2014). "Forest Fires in Vicinity of Allen Telescope Array". SETI.org. SETI Institute. Retrieved 20 February 2015.
- Shannon McConnell (2005). "Deep Space Network Adds a 34m Beam Wave Guide Antenna in Madrid, Spain". Deep Space Network Home. JPL. Archived from the original on 16 April 2009. Retrieved 2009-04-14.
- Senior Review Committee (22 October 2006). "From the Ground UP: Balancing the NSF Astronomy Program" (PDF). National Science Foundation Division of Astronomical Sciences: 220.127.116.11. Archived (PDF) from the original on 18 April 2009. Retrieved 2009-04-14.
- Welch, Jack; et al. (2009-08-01). "The Allen Telescope Array: The first widefield, panchromatic, snapshot radio camera for radio astronomy and SETI". Proceedings of the IEEE. 97 (8): 1438–1447. arXiv: . Bibcode:2009IEEEP..97.1438W. doi:10.1109/jproc.2009.2017103.
- W.L. Urry; M. Wright; M. Dexter; D. MacMahon (16 February 2007). "The ATA Correlator ATA Memo 73" (PDF). University of California, Berkeley: 3. Retrieved 2016-07-07.
- Bower, Geoffrey C.; et al. (2010). "The Allen Telescope Array Pi GHz Sky Survey. I. Survey Description and Static Catalog Results for the Boötes Field" (pdf). The Astrophysical Journal. 725 (2): 1792. arXiv: . Bibcode:2010ApJ...725.1792B. doi:10.1088/0004-637x/725/2/1792.
- Diaz-Wimberley, Rosamaria; Harp, G. R. (January 2016). "Time-Resolved Spectral Analysis of Blazar 0716+714". American Astronomical Society Meeting Abstracts. 227: 339.03. Bibcode:2016AAS...22733903D.
- Heldmann, Jennifer L; Colaprete, Anthony; Wooden, Diane H; Ackermann, Robert F; Acton, David D; Backus, Peter R; Bailey, Vanessa; Ball, Jesse G; Barott, William C; Blair, Samantha K; Buie, Marc W; Callahan, Shawn; Chanover, Nancy J; Choi, Young-Jun; Conrad, Al; Coulson, Dolores M; Crawford, Kirk B; Dehart, Russell; De Pater, Imke; Disanti, Michael; Forster, James R; Furusho, Reiko; Fuse, Tetsuharu; Geballe, Tom; Gibson, J. Duane; Goldstein, David; Gregory, Stephen A; Gutierrez, David J; Hamilton, Ryan T; et al. (2011). "LCROSS (Lunar Crater Observation and Sensing Satellite) observation campaign: Strategies, implementation, and lessons learned". Space Sci. Rev. 167 (1–4): 93–140. Bibcode:2012SSRv..167...93H. doi:10.1007/s11214-011-9759-y.
- Croft, Steve; et al. (2010). "The Allen Telescope Array Twenty-centimeter Survey: A 690 deg^2, 12 Epoch Radio Data Set. I. Catalog and Long-duration Transient Statistics". The Astrophysical Journal. 719 (1): 45. arXiv: . Bibcode:2010ApJ...719...45C. doi:10.1088/0004-637x/719/1/45.
- Barott, W. C.; et al. (2011-02-24), "Real-time beamforming using high-speed FPGAs at the Allen Telescope Array", Radio Science, 46: RS1016, Bibcode:2011RaSc...46.1016B, doi:10.1029/2010RS004442
- "BEE2: A modular, scalable FPGA-based computing platform". Bee2.eecs.berkeley.edu. Retrieved 2011-09-19.
- Harp, G. R (2013-09-13). "Using Multiple Beams to Distinguish Radio Frequency Interference from SETI Signals". Radio Science. 40 (5). arXiv: . Bibcode:2013arXiv1309.3826H.
- "Berkeley ATA Pulsar Processor (BAPP)". Center for Astronomy Signal Processing and Electronics Research (CASPER). University of California, Berkeley. 29 December 2008. Retrieved 2009-04-14.[permanent dead link]
- Results from the Allen Telescope Array: SETI Survey of the Galactic Center Region 
- Harp, G. R.; Ackermann, R. F.; Astorga, Alfredo; Arbunich, Jack; Hightower, Kristin; Meitzner, Seth; Barott, W. C.; Nolan, Michael C.; Messerschmitt, D. G.; Vakoch, Douglas A.; Shostak, Seth; Tarter, J. C. (2015-05-15). "A Radio SETI Campaign for microsec-sec Periodic Signals". arXiv: [astro-ph.IM].
- Tarter, J. C.; et al. (2011), "The first SETI observations with the Allen telescope array", Acta Astronautica, 68 (3): 340–346, Bibcode:2011AcAau..68..340T, doi:10.1016/j.actaastro.2009.08.014
- John Matson (24 April 2011). "Budget crunch mothballs telescopes built to search for alien signals". Scientific American. Archived from the original on 27 April 2011. Retrieved 2011-04-25.
- "Andrew Siemion Named Bernard M. Oliver Chair of SETI at the SETI Institute". April 9, 2018. Retrieved June 5, 2018.
- Damon Arthur. "New Hat Creek receivers will let SETI delve deeper into space". Archived from the original on 2014-03-30.
- Diamond, Bill (August 2015). "The SETI Institute needs your help". SETI. Retrieved 2015-09-15.
- Harp, G. R.; Richards, Jon; Shostak, Seth; Tarter, J. C.; Vakoch, Douglas A.; Munson, Chris (2016). "Radio SETI Observations of the Anomalous Star KIC 8462852". Astrophysical Journal. 825 (2): 155. arXiv: . Bibcode:2016ApJ...825..155H. doi:10.3847/0004-637X/825/2/155.
- Billings, Lee (11 December 2017). "Alien Probe or Galactic Driftwood? SETI Tunes In to ʻOumuamua". Scientific American. Retrieved 2017-12-12.
So far limited observations of ‘Oumuamua, using facilities such as the SETI Institute’s Allen Telescope Array, have turned up nothing.
- Marina Koren (11 December 2017). "Astronomers to Check Mysterious Interstellar Object for Signs of Technology". The Atlantic.
- "Google Sponsors Lunar X PRIZE to Create a Space Race for a New Generation" (Press release). X PRIZE Foundation and Google Inc. 13 September 2007. Archived from the original on 11 May 2009. Retrieved 2009-04-14.
- Berardelli, Phil (27 September 2007). "Big Radio from the Stars". ScienceNOW. Retrieved 2009-04-14.
- "ATA "Fly's Eye" Pulse Finder". Center for Astronomy Signal Processing and Electronics Research (CASPER). University of California, Berkeley. 29 December 2008. Retrieved 2009-11-08.
- A Radio Sky Surveys Project with the Allen Telescope Array - Response to the Request for Information Part 2 Geoffrey C. Bower, October 15, 2009
- Aaron Parsons; et al. (Oct 29, 2006). "PetaOp/Second FPGA Signal Processing for SETI and Radio Astronomy". Signals, Systems and Computers: 2031–2035. doi:10.1109/ACSSC.2006.355123. ISBN 1-4244-0784-2.
- Official website
- "Radio Astronomy Laboratory's ATA site". Archived from the original on 2006-09-02. Retrieved 2015-11-16.
- The Search Continues with the Allen Telescope Array. Mountain View, CA: SETI Institute. March 25, 2004.[dead link]
- Radio Astronomy Laboratory, University of California, Berkeley: NSF proposal, June 15, 2005.