Iowa's 8th congressional district

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

Iowa's 8th congressional district existed from 1873 to 1963. The district was configured five times. Although the district encompassed four different areas of Iowa in its ninety-year existence, it was always predominantly rural, and elected a Republican lawyer to the United States House of Representatives in all but one of 46 elections.

Phase one: Southwestern Iowa (1873-1883)[edit]

Based on the 1870 census, Iowa’s U.S. House delegation increased from six to nine members, requiring the Iowa General Assembly to reapportion the districts. The Assembly divided the Fifth District into two districts – the relocated Sixth District (which included the easternmost ten counties in the old Fifth, with the capital city of Des Moines) and the new Eighth District (including the remaining thirteen counties, with Council Bluffs its largest city). In this phase, the Eighth District included Union, Ringgold, Audubon, Cass, Adams, Taylor, Shelby, Pottawattamie, Montgomery, Page, Harrison, Mills, and Fremont counties.

During this period, the district was represented by Republican lawyers James W. McDill (of Union County), William Fletcher Sapp (of Pottawattamie County) and William P. Hepburn (of Page County).

Phase two: Far Southern Iowa (1883 to 1885)[edit]

The 1880 census caused Iowa to receive two more seats in the House, requiring reapportionment of the state into eleven districts. The new Eighth District was made up of ten counties in Iowa’s southernmost two tiers of counties.[1] It was perhaps the most purely rural congressional district in the state, lacking any major city, and any county with more than 21,000 residents.[1] It included Appanoose, Lucas, Wayne, Clarke, Decatur, Union, Ringgold, Adams, Taylor, and Page counties.

Only two elections were held under this configuration (in 1882 and 1884). Each time, incumbent Republican William P. Hepburn was re-elected.

Phase three: Far Southern Iowa (1886 to 1933)[edit]

In early 1886 the Republican-controlled General Assembly readjusted the boundaries of the 11-district map, allegedly to increase the number of Republican victories.[2][3] The immediate effect in the Eighth District, however, was an unpleasant surprise to Republican Party regulars. The General Assembly kept the boundaries of the Eighth District the same except that Fremont County was moved from the Ninth District to the Eighth.[2] However, Fremont County resident Albert R. Anderson, a longtime Republican, ran in the general election without the Party’s endorsement and on a populist, anti-Railroad platform, defeating incumbent Congressman (and Republican nominee) Hepburn in a stunning upset.[4]

The 1886 boundaries of the district would remain in place for 45 years.[5] Until 1900, the population of the district continued to grow gradually with the population of its county-seat small towns. However, because the district lacked any major city, it avoided the sociopolitical changes that occurred in most other Iowa congressional districts in the early twentieth century due to urban migration. The Eighth District became a relatively safe seat for incumbent Republicans.

After Hepburn’s 1886 defeat, the Republican Party nominee won every general election in this district except one. Hepburn waited several years before attempting to return to Congress. However, a different winner of the Republican endorsement process, James Patton Flick (of Taylor County), defeated Anderson in the next general election. In 1892, after Flick declined to run for a third term, Hepburn recaptured his former seat. Hepburn won his party's nomination and the general election, and was re-elected seven more times. Hepburn was upset a final time in 1908, by Democrat William Darius Jamieson of Page County. After Jamieson declined to be a candidate for renomination in 1910,[6] Republican nominee Horace Mann Towner won the seat. Following Towner’s appointment as Governor of Puerto Rico in 1923 early into his sixth term, Hiram Kinsman Evans (of Wayne County) was elected to serve out the rest of the term but did not seek re-election, and was succeeded by Lloyd Thurston (of Clarke County). After re-election landslides in 1926 and 1928, Thurston survived a close challenge in 1930.

Residents of Eighth District counties had greater per capita influence because of the Iowa General Assembly's failure to redistrict in response to population shifts reflected in 1910 and 1920 censuses. The population of every Eighth District county except Appanoose declined between 1900 and 1920, while Iowa's overall population increased.[7] As a result, the Eighth District's total population in 1920 was approximately 185,000, while a perfectly balanced reapportionment plan in 1921 would have created eleven districts with about 218,000 residents each.[8]

Phase four: North Central Iowa (1933 to 1943)[edit]

Due to the 1930 census, Iowa lost seats in Congress for the first time. It lost two seats, forcing the Republican-dominated 1931 General Assembly to adopt a nine-district plan.[9]

With one minor change, the old Tenth District in north central Iowa was relabeled as the new Eighth District.[9] One county (Worth) was shifted into a different district, but the new Eighth District included all of the remaining Tenth District counties: Boone, Calhoun, Carroll, Crawford, Emmet, Greene, Hamilton, Humboldt, Kossuth, Palo Alto, Pocahontas, Winnebago, and Webster counties. Like the old Eighth District, the new Eighth District was one of the most rural districts in the state. Since 1856, the area had elected only Republicans to the House. As the Eighth, that tradition continued. The area’s incumbent representative, Republican Fred C. Gilchrist of Pocahontas County, won every election during this phase, and was one of only two Republican incumbents in Iowa to survive both Roosevelt-era landslides in 1932 and 1934.

Phase five: Northwestern Iowa (1943 to 1963)[edit]

The 1940 census cost Iowa one of its nine seats in the House, and forced the 1941 General Assembly to adopt the state’s first eight-district plan. Republicans again dominated the General Assembly after a rare period of Democratic power in the mid-1930s, and adopted a plan that made it especially difficult for the state’s two Democratic congressmen to keep their seats. The former Ninth District, in Iowa’s northwestern corner and held by Democrat Vincent Harrington, was relabeled as the new Eighth District, but with one politically significant change. The new Eighth included Sac, Buena Vista, Clay, Dickinson, Osceola, O'Brien, Cherokee, Ida, Monona, Woodbury, Plymouth, Sioux, and Lyon counties of the former Ninth District. However, the General Assembly moved into the Seventh District Monona County, which had put Harrington over the top in his close 1940 re-election race. This change left Harrington especially vulnerable to defeat. Harrington enlisted in the U.S. Army Air Corps, then resigned from Congress and quit the 1942 race, which Republican Charles B. Hoeven (of Sioux County) won in a landslide.

The Eighth District’s 1941 configuration remained in place for ten elections. Hoeven won every one. When the 1960 census cut Iowa’s House delegation to seven members, the former Eighth District became the western end of the new Sixth District, which in 1962 elected Hoeven to his eleventh and final term in the House.

List of representatives[edit]

Representative Party Term District Residence (County) Note
District created
March 4, 1873
James W. McDill - Brady-Handy.jpg James W. McDill Republican March 4, 1873 – March 3, 1877 Union
William Fletcher Sapp.jpg William F. Sapp Republican March 4, 1877 – March 3, 1881 Pottawattamie
Lt.-Col. William P. Hepburn - History of Iowa.jpg William P. Hepburn Republican March 4, 1881 – March 3, 1887 Page
No image.svg Albert R. Anderson Independent Republican March 4, 1887 – March 3, 1889 Fremont
No image.svg James P. Flick Republican March 4, 1889 – March 3, 1893 Taylor
Lt.-Col. William P. Hepburn - History of Iowa.jpg William P. Hepburn Republican March 4, 1893 – March 3, 1909 Page
WilliamDariusJamieson.jpg William D. Jamieson Democratic March 4, 1909 – March 3, 1911 Page
TOWNER, HORACE M. HONORABLE.jpg Horace M. Towner Republican March 4, 1911 – April 1, 1923 Adams Resigned after becoming Governor of Puerto Rico
April 1, 1923 - June 4, 1923
No image.svg Hiram K. Evans Republican June 4, 1923 – March 3, 1925 Wayne
LloydThurston.jpg Lloyd Thurston Republican March 4, 1925 – March 3, 1933 Clarke Redistricted to the 5th district
FredCGilchrist.jpg Fred C. Gilchrist Republican March 4, 1933 – January 3, 1943 Pocahontas Redistricted from the 10th district, Redistricted to the 6th district
No image.svg Charles B. Hoeven Republican January 3, 1943 – January 3, 1963 Sioux Redistricted to the 6th district
District eliminated
January 3, 1963

The district was eliminated as a result of the 1960 census. The district added Calhoun, Pocahantas, Palo Alto, Emmet, Kossuth, and Humboldt counties and was renamed the 6th district.

See also[edit]


  1. ^ a b "Congressional Map of the State of Iowa - Official Census 1885" (Iowa Official Register 1886 at pp. 12-13).
  2. ^ a b "The Congressional Districts," Waterloo Courier, 1886-04-14.
  3. ^ Editorial from Davenport Democrat, reprinted in "Iowa Press Pointers," Cedar Rapids Evening Gazette, 1886-04-13 at p. 2.
  4. ^ Cyrenus Cole, "A History of the People of Iowa," p. 395 (Torch Press, Cedar Rapids: 1921).
  5. ^ Iowa Official Register 1929-30 at p. 3.
  6. ^ "Jamieson Not to Run; Poor Health Reason," Cedar Rapids Evening Gazette, 1910-03-01 at p.10; Editorial, "The Next Reform," Waterloo Semi-Weekly Courier, 1910-03-08 at p.4.
  7. ^ Richard L. Forstall, Population of Counties by Decennial Census: 1900 to 1990, accessed 2009-07-04.
  8. ^ Editorial, “A Brilliant Idea,” Waterloo Evening Courier, 1921-01-26 at 6.
  9. ^ a b Iowa Official Register 1933-34 at p. 6.