Social Credit System
This article needs to be updated.(February 2021)
|Social Credit System|
|Part of a series on|
|Part of a series on|
|History of the People's|
Republic of China (PRC)
|Generations of leadership|
The Social Credit System (Chinese: 社会信用体系; pinyin: shèhuì xìnyòng tǐxì) is a national blacklist being developed by the government of the People's Republic of China under General Secretary of the Chinese Communist Party Xi Jinping's administration. The program initiated regional trials in 2009, before launching a national pilot with eight credit scoring firms in 2014. It was first introduced formally by then Chinese Premier, Wen Jiabao, on October 20, 2011, during one of the State Council Meetings. In 2018, these efforts were centralized under the People's Bank of China with participation from the eight firms. By 2020,[needs update] it was intended to standardize the assessment of citizens' and businesses' economic and social reputation, or 'Social Credit'.
The social credit initiative calls for the establishment of a unified record system so that businesses, individuals and government institutions can be tracked and evaluated for trustworthiness. Initial reports suggested that the system utilized a numerical score as the reward and punishment mechanism; recent reports suggest there are in fact multiple, different forms of the social credit system being experimented with. A numerical system has been implemented only in several regional pilot programs, while the nationwide regulatory method has been based primarily on blacklisting and whitelisting. The credit system is closely related to China's mass surveillance systems such as Skynet, which incorporates facial recognition, big data analysis, and artificial intelligence.
The Social Credit System is an extension to the existing financial credit rating system in China. The origin of the system can be traced back to the 1980s when the Chinese government attempted to develop a personal banking and financial credit rating system, especially for rural individuals and small businesses that lack documented records. The Chinese government aims to enhance trust in the society with the system and regulate businesses regarding issues such as food safety, intellectual property theft, and financial fraud.
Supporters claim that the system helps to regulate social behavior, improve the "trustworthiness" of citizens (which includes paying taxes and bills on time), and promote traditional moral values. Critics of the system claim that it oversteps the rule of law and infringes the legal rights of residents and organizations, especially the right to reputation, the right to privacy as well as personal dignity, and that the system may be a tool for comprehensive government surveillance and for suppression of dissent from the Chinese Communist Party (CCP).
The origin of the Social Credit System can be traced back to the early 1990s as part of attempts to develop personal banking and financial credit rating systems in China. The credit system aims to facilitate financial assessment in rural areas, where individuals and small business entities often lacked financial documents. The initial blueprints of the Social Credit System was drafted in 2007 by government bodies. The social credit system also attempts to solve the moral vacuum problem, insufficient market supervision, and income inequality generated by the rapid economic and social changes since Chinese economic reform in 1978. As a result of these problems, trust issues emerged in Chinese society such as food safety scandals, labor law violation, intellectual property theft, and corruption. The policy of the social credit system traces its origin from both policing and work management practices, but the concept itself can trace as far back as the Warring States period to Shang Yang's Legalist meritocratic assessment and promotion system practiced by the imperial bureaucracy to improve the functioning of Chinese state.
During the rule of Mao, the work unit was the main intermediate between the individual and the CCP. The unit concept, as such, is derived from Hegelian and especially behavioural sciences. Other related examples include the neighborhood unit in developments, study of living creatures at the level of a defined ecological unit, the entity concept from accounting, the strategic business unit in commerce, the unit concept of church fellowship in the Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod, the use of individual behavior as the unit of study in radical behaviorism, and the meme in anthropology.
The government of modern China has maintained systems of paper records on individuals and households such as the dàng'àn (档案) and hùkǒu (户口) which officials might refer to, but these systems do not provide the same degree and rapidity of feedback and consequences for Chinese citizens as the integrated electronic system because of the much greater difficulty of aggregating paper records for rapid, robust analysis.
The Social Credit System also originated from grid-style social management, a policing strategy first implemented in select locations from 2001 and 2002 (during the rule of paramount leader Jiang Zemin) in specific locations across mainland China. In its first phase, grid-style policing was a system for more effective communication between public security bureaus. Within a few years, the grid system was adapted for use in distributing social services. Grid management provided the authorities not only with greater situational awareness on the group level, but also enhanced the tracking and monitoring of individuals. In 2018, sociologist Zhang Lifan explained that Chinese society today is still deficient in trust. People often expect to be cheated or to get in trouble even if they are innocent. He believes that it is due to the Cultural Revolution, where friends and family members were deliberately pitted against each other and millions of Chinese were killed. The stated purpose of the social credit system is to help Chinese people trust each other again.
In 2013, the Supreme People's Court (SPC) of China started a blacklist of debtors with roughly 32,000 names. The list has since been described as a first step towards a national Social Credit System by state-owned media. The SPC also began working with private companies. For example, Sesame Credit began deducting credit points from people who defaulted on court fines.
In 2015, the People's Bank of China licensed eight companies to begin a trial of social credit systems. Among these eight firms is Sesame Credit (owned by Alibaba Group and operated by Ant Financial), Tencent, as well as China's biggest ride-sharing and online-dating services, Didi Chuxing and Baihe.com, respectively. In general, multiple firms collaborated with the government to develop the system of software and algorithms used to calculate credit. Commercial pilots developed by private Chinese conglomerates that have the authorization from the state to test out social credit experiments. The pilots are more widespread than their local government counterparts, but function on a voluntary basis: citizens can decide to opt-out of these systems at any time on request. Users with good scores are offered advantages such as easier access to credit loans, discounts for car and bike sharing services, fast-tracked visa application, or free health check-ups and preferential treatment at hospitals. The algorithms used to assign scores in commercial pilots remain unknown, although sources say some pilots use a big-data analysis and artificial intelligence approach.
The Chinese central government originally considered having the Social Credit System be run by a private firm, but by 2017, it acknowledged the need for third-party administration. However, no licenses to private companies were granted. By mid-2017, the Chinese government had decided that none of the pilots would receive authorization to be official credit reporting systems. The reasons include conflict of interest, the remaining control of the government, as well as the lack of cooperation in data sharing among the firms that participate in the development. However, the Social Credit System's operation by a seemingly external association, such as a formal collaboration between private firms, has not been ruled out yet. In November 2017, Sesame Credit denied that Sesame Credit data was shared with the Chinese government. In 2017, People's Bank of China issued a jointly owned license to Baihang Credit valid for three years. Baihang Credit is co-owned by the National Internet Finance Association (36%) and the eight other companies (8% each), allowing the state to maintain control and oversee the creation of a new commercial pilot. As of mid 2018, only pilot schemes had been tested without any official implementation.
Private companies have also signed contracts with provincial governments to set up the basic infrastructure for the Social Credit System at the provincial level. As of March 2017, 137 commercial credit reporting companies were active on the Chinese market. As part of the development of the Social Credit System, the Chinese government has been monitoring the progress of third-party Chinese credit rating systems.
In December 2017 the National Development and Reform Commission and People's Bank of China selected "model cities" that demonstrated the steps needed to make a functional and efficient implementation of the Social Credit System. Among them are Hangzhou, Nanjing, Xiamen, Chengdu, Suzhou, Suqian, Huizhou, Wenzhou, Weihai, Weifang, Yiwu, and Rongcheng. These pilots were deemed successful in their handling of "blacklists and 'redlists'", their creation of "credit sharing platforms", and their "data sharing efforts with the other cities".
The local government Social Credit System experiments are focused more on the construction of transparent rule-based systems, in contrast with the more advanced rating systems used in the commercial pilots. Citizens often begin with an initial score, to which points are added or deducted depending on their actions. The specific number of points for each action are often listed in publicly available catalogs. Cities also experimented with a multi-level system, in which districts decide on scorekeepers who are responsible for reporting scores to higher-ups. Some experiments also allowed citizens to appeal the scores they were attributed. The government alleges these systems mean to penalize citizens generally agreed as 'untrustworthy'. They claim they will be able to "change people’s behavior by ensuring they are closely associated with it."
As of 2018, over forty different Social Credit System experiments were implemented by local governments in different Chinese provinces. The pilot programs began following the release of the 2014 "Planning Outline for the Construction of a Social Credit System" by Chinese authorities. The government oversees the creation and development of these governmental pilots by requesting they each publish a regular "interdepartmental agreement on joint enforcement of rewards and punishments for 'trustworthy' and 'untrustworthy' conduct." In April 2018, journalist Simina Mistreanu described a community where people's social credit scores were posted near the village center. As of mid-2018, it was unclear whether the national system will be an 'ecosystem' of various scores and blacklists run by both government agencies and private companies, or if it will be one unified system. It is also unclear whether there will be a single system-wide social credit score for each citizen and business.
In March 2018, Reuters reported that restrictions on citizens and businesses with low social credit ratings, and thus low trustworthiness, would come into effect on 1 May 2018. By May 2018, several million flight and high-speed train trips had been denied to people who had been blacklisted; as of March 2019, 13 million people were on the list.
In April 2019, the People's Bank of China announced that a new version of the Personal Credit Report would be put out which allows the ability to collect more personal information. State-run media has described it as "more detailed, more comprehensive and more precisely."
Hong Kong and Macau
The Social Credit System will be limited to Mainland China and thus does not apply to Hong Kong and Macau. However, at present, plans do not distinguish between Chinese companies and foreign companies operating on the Chinese market, raising the possibility that foreign businesses operating in China will be subjected to the system as well. The Hong Kong Government stated in July 2019 that claims that the social credit system will be rolled out in Hong Kong are "totally unfounded", and stated that the system will not be implemented there.
The Social Credit System is an example of China's "top-level design" (顶层设计) approach. It is coordinated by the Central Leading Group for Comprehensively Deepening Reforms. It is unclear whether the system will work as envisioned by 2020, but the Chinese government has fast-tracked the implementation of the system, resulting in the publication of numerous policy documents and plans since the main plan was issued in 2013. If the Social Credit System is implemented as envisioned, it will constitute a new way of controlling both the behavior of individuals and of businesses.
There are multiple social credit systems in China. Scholars have conceptualized four different types of systems. These four systems are not interconnected seamlessly, but relevantly independent from each other with their own jurisdictions, rules, and logic.
- Business trustworthiness system (Chinese: 商务诚信体系)
- Blacklist system for discredited business organizations. This system is regulated by People's Bank of China financial credit-rating system, and commercial credit-rating system.
- Government trustworthiness system (Chinese: 政务诚信体系)
- Evaluation system targeting civil servants and government institutions.
- Social trustworthiness system (Chinese: 社会诚信体系)
- Blacklist system for discredited individuals. Social trustworthiness system most closely relates to China's mass surveillance systems.
- Judiciary public trust system (Chinese: 司法公信体系)
- Blacklist system for discredited individuals. This system is regulated by Supreme People's Court.
Due to differences in various pilot programs and a nonunified system structure, information regarding the scoring mechanism is often conflicting. Inspired by FICO, a numerical social credit score calculated by individual behavior and activities was given to citizens in certain pilot programs. However, these practices were not widespread applications, and eventually, the numerical score was limited to private credit rating or loyalty programs. The nationwide regulatory method has been based primarily on blacklisting and whitelisting, which is triggered by specific offenses instead of a low score number. Financial credit reporting for businesses and individuals is provided by the People’s Bank of China, which does not contain any numerical scoring.
The Central Government operates a number of national and regional blacklists based on various types of violations. The court system is available for businesses, organizations, and individuals to appeal their violations. After being put on the blacklist, it typically takes 2–5 years to be removed from the blacklist, but early removal is also possible if the blacklisted person "fulfills legal obligations or remedies". Blacklist violations for businesses include not paying tax on time, being unable to maintain necessary licenses, producing low-quality goods, and disobeying environmental protection policies.
Reward and punishment
According to the Chinese government's 2015 Plan for Implementation, the Social Credit System is due to be fully implemented by 2020. Once implemented, the system will manage the rewards and punishments for businesses, institutions and individuals on the basis of their economic and personal behavior. Punishments for poor social credit include increased audits and government inspections for businesses, reduced employment prospects, travel bans, exclusion from private schools, slow internet connection, exclusion from high-prestige work, exclusion from hotels, and public shaming. Rewards for positive social credit include less frequent inspections and audits for businesses, fast-tracked approvals for government services, discounts on energy bills, being able to rent bikes and hotels without payment of a deposit, better interest rates at banks, and tax breaks.
As of June 2019, according to the National Development and Reform Commission of China, 27 million air tickets as well as 6 million high-speed rail tickets had been denied to people who were deemed "untrustworthy (失信)" (on a blacklist), and 4.4 million "untrustworthy" people had chosen to fulfill their duties required by the law. Certain personal information of the blacklisted people is deliberately made accessible to the society and is displayed online as well as at various public venues such as movie theaters and buses, while some cities have also banned children of "untrustworthy" residents from attending private schools and even universities. On the other hand, people with high credit ratings may receive rewards such as less waiting time at hospitals and governmental agencies, discounts at hotels, greater likelihood of receiving employment offers and so on.
Examples of policies
The social credit policies vary greatly from city to city.
|Cities||Some of the local government policies|
Enforcement and implications
According to the Chinese government's 2015 Plan for Implementation, the Social Credit System is due to be fully implemented by 2020. Once implemented the system will manage the rewards, or punishments, of citizens on the basis of their economic and personal behavior. Some types of punishments for poor social credit include: flight ban, exclusion from private schools, slow internet connection, exclusion from high prestige work, exclusion from hotels, and registration on a public blacklist. While some rewards for good social credit include discounts on energy bills, being able to rent bikes and hotels without payment of a deposit, better interest rates at banks, tax breaks, free use of Gyms, and Preference and Hospitals.
The Social Credit System is meant to provide an answer to the problem of lack of trust on the Chinese market. As of 2020, the corporate regulation function of the system appears to be more advanced than other parts of the system, and the "Corporate Social Credit System" has been the primary focus of government attention. As of 2020, over 73.3% of the enforcement action since 2014 is targeted toward business, the largest part of all enforcements. The social credit system is an extension of the risk assessment credit rating systems that were introduced in China in the 1980s. Proponents argue that it will help eliminate problems such as food safety issues, intellectual property theft, violation of labor law, financial infidelity, and counterfeit goods. China claims its aim is to enhance trust and social stability by creating a “culture of sincerity”.
For businesses, the Social Credit System is meant to serve as a market regulation mechanism. The goal is to establish a self-enforcing regulatory regime fueled by big data in which businesses exercise "self-restraint" (企业自我约束). The basic idea is that with a functional credit system in place, companies will comply with government policies and regulations to avoid having their scores lowered by disgruntled employees, customers or clients. For example, the central government can use social credit data to offer risk-assessed grants and loans to small and medium enterprises (SMEs), encouraging banks to offer greater loan access for SMEs.
As currently envisioned, companies with good credit scores will enjoy benefits such as good credit conditions, lower tax rates, less custom checks, and more investment opportunities. Companies with bad credit scores will potentially face unfavorable conditions for new loans, higher tax rates, investment restrictions, and lower chances to participate in publicly funded projects. Government plans also envision real-time monitoring of a business' activities. In that case, infractions on the part of a business could result in a lower score almost instantly. However, whether this will actually happen depends on the future implementation of the system as well as on the availability of technology needed for this kind of monitoring.
To improve credit score, companies need to conform the government rules such as following the COVID-19 containment guidelines.
For government institutions
Government institutions receive the second highest number of enforcement actions, accounting for 13.3% of the penalties as of 2020. The social credit system targets government agencies, assesses local governments' performance, and focuses on financial problems such as local governments' debts and contract defaults. Beijing hopes the system can improve "government self-discipline". Local governments are also encouraged and rewarded by the social credit system if they successfully implement and follow the orders from the central government.
As of 2020, individuals receive 10.3% of all enforcement actions. The social credit system primarily focuses on the financial trustworthiness of individual citizens. A Hebei court released an app showing a "map of deadbeat debtors" within 500 meters and encouraged users to report individuals who they believed could repay their debts. A spokesman of the court stated that "It's a part of our measures to enforce our rulings and create a socially credible environment." The rewards of having a high score include easier access to loans and jobs and priority during bureaucratic paperwork. Likewise, the immediate negative consequences for a low score, or being associated to someone with a low score, range from lower internet speeds to being denied access to certain jobs and loans.
In addition to dishonest and fraudulent financial behavior, there are other behaviors that some cities have officially listed as negative factors of credit ratings includes playing loud music or eating in rapid transits, violating traffic rules such as jaywalking and red-light violations, making reservations at restaurants or hotels but not showing up, failing to correctly sort personal waste, fraudulently using other people's public transportation ID cards, smoking violations etc.; on the other hand, behavior listed as positive factors of credit ratings includes donating blood, donating to charity, volunteering for community services, praising government efforts on social media, and so on.
There are various punishments for low trustworthiness. As of June 2019, according to the National Development and Reform Commission of China, 26.82 million air tickets as well as 5.96 million high-speed rail tickets had been denied to people who were deemed "untrustworthy(失信)" (on a blacklist), and 4.37 million "dishonest" people had chosen to fulfill their duties required by the law. In July 2019, additional 2.56 million flight tickets as well as 90 thousand high-speed train tickets were denied to those on the blacklist. If the parents of a child were to score below a certain threshold, their children would be excluded from the private schools in the region or even national universities. A person with a bad social credit score may be denied employment in places as banks, State-owned enterprises, or as a business executive. The Chinese Government encourages people to consult the blacklist before making hiring decisions.
Certain websites allow users to display their social credit score as a prestige symbol. For example, China's biggest matchmaking service, Baihe, allows its users to publish their own score. There's also public humiliation mechanism in certain test programs. Mugshots of blacklisted individuals are sometimes displayed on large LED screens on buildings or shown before the movie in movie theaters.
According to Sarah Cook of Freedom House, city-level pilot projects for the social credit score system have included rewarding individuals for aiding authorities in enforcing restrictions of religious practices, including coercing practitioners of Falun Gong to renounce their beliefs and reporting on Uighurs who publicly pray, fast during Ramadan, or perform other Islamic practices.
As of 2020, non-government organizations receive 3.3% of all enforcement actions. Although the enforcement remain a small group in numerical terms, but their inclusion has an important implication as it affects foreign NGOs operated within China.
- In August 2018, Professor Genia Kostka of Free University of Berlin published a research paper on China's Social Credit Systems (SCSs), based on a cross-regional internet survey of 2,209 Chinese citizens of various backgrounds. The study found "a surprisingly high degree of approval of SCSs across respondent groups" and that "more socially advantaged citizens (wealthier, better-educated and urban residents) show the strongest approval of SCSs, along with older people". Kostka explained in the paper that "while one might expect such knowledgeable citizens to be most concerned about the privacy implications of SCS, they instead appear to embrace SCSs because they interpret it through frames of benefit-generation and promoting honest dealings in society and the economy instead of privacy-violation." Although the study stated that 80% of Chinese citizens surveyed take a positive view of the social credit system in China, the legitimacy of the survey and sample size of said citizens has been questioned.
- In August 2019, assistant researcher Zhengjie Fan of China Institute of International Studies published an article, claiming that the current punishment policies such as the blacklist do not overstep the limits of law. He argued that since 2014, China's Social Credit System and the credit system of the market had grown to complement each other, forming a mutually beneficial interaction. According to Doing Business 2019 by World Bank Group which ranks "190 countries on the ease of doing business within their borders", China rose from 78th place in previous year to 46th place, and Fan claimed that the Social Credit System has played an important role.
China's Social Credit System has been implicated in a number of controversies, especially given that CCP general secretary Xi Jinping and the Chinese government have publicly opposed constitutionalism, separation of powers, and judicial independence. Of particular note is how it is applied to individuals as well as companies, whether it is lawful, and whether it leads to totalitarianism. People have already faced various punishments for violating social protocols. As of June 2019, the system has already been used to block the purchase of over 26 million domestic flight tickets from people who were deemed "dishonest". While still in the preliminary stages, the system has been used to ban people and their children from certain private schools, prevent low scorers from renting hotels, using credit cards, and blacklist individuals from being able to procure employment.
- In May 2020, Chinese investigative media group Caixin reported that business social credit systems in China were insufficient in deterring problematic business activities, and that the social credit system was easy to game in the favour of businesses.
- In October 2019, Professor Kui Shen of the Law School of Peking University published a paper in China Legal Science, suggesting that some of the current credit policies violated the "rule of law" or "Rechtsstaat": that they infringed the legal rights of residents and organizations, possibly violated the principle of respecting and protecting human rights, especially the right to reputation, the right to privacy as well as personal dignity, and overstepped the boundary of reasonable punishment.
- In June 2019, Samantha Hoffman of Australian Strategic Policy Institute argued that "there are no genuine protections for the people and entities subject to the system... In China there is no such thing as the rule of law. Regulations that can be largely apolitical on the surface can be political when the Communist Party of China (CCP) decides to use them for political purposes."
- In January 2019, George Soros criticized the social credit system, saying it would give Xi "total control over the people of China".
- In January 2019, Forbes noted that "[f]or many that live outside of China, [the social credit system] feels more like one of the creepy 'Nosedive' episode of the British science fiction TV series Black Mirror."
- In October 2018, U.S. Vice President Mike Pence criticized the social credit system, describing it as "an Orwellian system premised on controlling virtually every facet of human life."
- In August 2018, Professor Genia Kostka of Free University of Berlin stated in her published paper (also cited under "Approvals" above) that "if successful in [their] effort, the Communist Party will possess a powerful means of quelling dissent, one that is comparatively low-cost and which does not require the overt (and unpopular) use of coercion by the state."
- In May 2018, the Hill noted that "[t]he totalitarian 1984 of the future is now 2018 China."
- From 2017 to 2018, researchers argued that the credit system will be part of the government's plan to automate their authoritarian rule over the Chinese population.
- In December 2017, Human Rights Watch described the proposed social credit system as "chilling" and filled with arbitrary abuses.
- In July 2019, Wired reported that there existed misconceptions regarding the Social Credit System of China. It argued that "Western concerns about what could happen with China’s Social Credit System have in some ways outstripped discussions about what's already really occurring...The exaggerated portrayals may also help to downplay surveillance efforts in other parts of the world." The rise of misconception, according to Jeremy Daum of Yale University, is contributed by translation errors, the difference in word usage, and so on.
- In May 2019, Logic published an article by Shazeda Ahmed, who argued that "[f]oreign media has distorted the social credit system into a technological dystopia far removed from what is actually happening in China." She pointed out that common misconceptions included the beliefs that surveillance data is connected with a centralized database; that human activities online and offline are assigned with actual values that can be deducted, and that every citizen in China has a numerical score that is calculated by computer algorithm.
- In March and February, 2019, MIT Technology Review stated that, "[i]n the West, the system is highly controversial, and often portrayed as an AI-powered surveillance regime that violates human rights." However, the magazine reported that "many scholars argue that social credit scores won’t have the wide-scale controlling effect presumed...the system acts more as a tool of propaganda than a tool of enforcement", and that "[o]thers point out that it is simply an extension of Chinese culture’s long tradition of promoting good moral behavior and that Chinese citizens have a completely different perspective on privacy and freedom."
- In November 2018, Foreign Policy listed some factors which contributed to the misconception of China's credit system. The potential factors included the scale and variety of the social credit system program and the difficulties of comprehensive reporting that comes with it.
- In May 2018, Rogier Creemers of Leiden University stated that despite the Chinese government's intentions of utilizing big data and artificial intelligence, the regulatory method of SCS remained relatively crude. His research concluded that it is "... perhaps more accurate to conceive of the SCS as an ecosystem of initiatives broadly sharing a similar underlying logic, than a fully unified and integrated machine for social control."
- In March 2021, The Diplomat remarks that the assumption of Social Credit System being an Orwellian surveillance system held by Western observers exaggerates the reality and purpose of the system in real life. Despite the claim, the social credit system is "an extension of bond issuance risk assessment credit ratings introduced in China in the 1980s" and primarily serves the function of a financial risk assessment tool.
Comparison to other countries
Since 1976, a database of loan debtors (the Directory of Commercial Information, DICOM) has been implemented to evaluate the financial and commercial risk of an individual or enterprise. People listed in DICOM find it harder to find housing, start businesses, get new loans and, though not the intended usage of the system, find jobs, since employers tend to check scores as a part of the selection process. There have been legal measures taken recently to reduce the negative impact of the system on people, such as banning the usage of DICOM status in determining access to medical attention and lawmakers derogating the DICOM status for educational loans. Once the debt has been paid, renegotiated or prescript, the debtor gets out of the list. There are also law firms that offer legal mechanisms to change the nature of the debt and invalidate the DICOM status.
In February 2018, Handelsblatt Global reported that Germany may be "sleep walking" towards a system comparable to China's. Data from the universal credit rating system Schufa, geolocation, and health records are being used to determine access to credit and health insurance.
Around 80% of Russians will reportedly get a digital profile that will document personal successes and failures in less than a decade under the government's comprehensive plans to digitize the economy. Observers have compared this to China's social credit system, although Deputy Prime Minister Maxim Akimov has denied that, saying a Chinese-style social credit system is a "threat".
In 2018, the New Economics Foundation compared the Chinese citizen score to other rating systems in the United Kingdom. These included using data from a citizen's credit score, phone usage, rent payment, and so on, to filter job applications, determine access to social services, determine advertisements served, etc.
Some media outlets have compared the social credit system to credit scoring systems in the United States. According to Fast Company, "increasing number of societal "privileges" related to transportation, accommodations, communications, and the rates we pay for services (like insurance) are either controlled by technology companies or affected by how we use technology services. And Silicon Valley's rules for being allowed to use their services are getting stricter."
In 2017, Venezuela started developing a smart-card ID known as the "carnet de la patria", or "fatherland card", with the help of the Chinese telecom company ZTE. The system included a database which stores details like birthdays, family information, employment and income, property owned, medical history, state benefits received, presence on social media, membership of a political party, and whether a person voted. Many in Venezuela have expressed concern that the card is an attempt to tighten social control through monitoring all aspects of daily life.
- 国务院关于印发社会信用体系建设规划纲要（2014—2020年）的通知. Central Government of China (in Chinese). Retrieved 10 November 2019.
- "China rates its own citizens – including online behaviour". www.volkskrant.nl. 25 April 2015. Retrieved 26 December 2015.
- "SAT Boosted the Construction of Credit System and Practiced Reward and Punishment Based on "Two Measures" : Honest Taxpayer on Honor List and Illegal Taxpayers on Blacklist". www.chinatax.gov.cn. General Office of the State Administration of Taxation. 8 July 2014. Archived from the original on 27 December 2015. Retrieved 26 December 2015.
- Zhong, Yuhao (Summer 2019). "Rethinking the Social Credit System: A Long Road to Establishing Trust in Chinese Society" (PDF). Symposium on Applications of Contextual Integrity: 28–29 – via Privaci.info.
- Hornby, Lucy. "China changes tack on 'social credit' scheme plan". Financial Times. 5 July 2017. Retrieved 14 July 2017.
- "What is China's social credit system and why is it controversial?". South China Morning Post. 9 August 2020. Retrieved 8 December 2020.
- Hatton, Celia (26 October 2015). "China 'social credit': Beijing sets up huge system". BBC News. Retrieved 23 December 2015.
- Hatton, Celia (26 October 2015). "China 'social credit': Beijing sets up huge system". BBC News. Retrieved 6 March 2017.
- Chin, Josh; Wong, Gillian (28 November 2016). "China's New Tool for Social Control: A Credit Rating for Everything". Wall Street Journal. ISSN 0099-9660. Retrieved 6 March 2017.
- Mistreanu, Simina. "China is implementing a massive plan to rank its citizens, and many of them want in".
- Meissner, Mirjam (24 May 2017). "China's Social Credit System: A big-data enabled approach to market regulation with broad implications for doing business in China" (PDF). www.merics.org. Archived from the original (PDF) on 17 March 2018. Retrieved 11 July 2017.
- Nicole Kobie (7 June 2019). "The complicated truth about China's social credit system". WIRED UK.
- Stevenson, Alexandra; Mozur, Paul (22 September 2019). "China Scores Businesses, and Low Grades Could Be a Trade-War Weapon". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 11 January 2020.
- Cheng, Evelyn (4 September 2019). "China is building a 'comprehensive system' for tracking companies' activities, report says". CNBC. Retrieved 11 January 2020.
- "'Social credit score': China set to roll out 'Orwellian' mass surveillance tool". The Washington Times. 9 December 2019. Retrieved 11 January 2020.
- Marr, Bernard. "Chinese Social Credit Score: Utopian Big Data Bliss Or Black Mirror On Steroids?". Forbes. Retrieved 11 November 2019.
- Ahmed, Shazeda (1 May 2019). "The Messy Truth About Social Credit". logic magazine.
- Liu, Chuncheng (2019). "Multiple Social Credit Systems in China". Economic Sociology: The European Electronic Newsletter. 21 (1): 21–22. SSRN 3423057.
- Matsakis, Louise (29 July 2019). "How the West Got China's Social Credit System Wrong". Wired. Retrieved 11 January 2020.
- "最高法打造"天网"破解执行难 去年615万老赖被"限行"".
- ""Skynet", China's massive video surveillance network". Abacus. 4 October 2018. Retrieved 13 November 2019.
- "中国天网已建成 2亿摄像头毫秒级寻人". Phoenix New Media Limited (in Chinese). 4 May 2018.
- "How China's Surveillance State Reflects 'Black Mirror'". Fortune. 27 March 2019. Retrieved 11 January 2020.
- "How China Is Using Big Data to Create a Social Credit Score". Time. 2019. Retrieved 11 January 2020.
- Lakshmanan, Ravie (30 September 2019). "China's new 500-megapixel 'super camera' can instantly recognize you in a crowd". The Next Web. Retrieved 13 November 2019.
- "Chinese city with world's heaviest surveillance has 2.5 million cameras". South China Morning Post. 19 August 2019. Retrieved 13 November 2019.
- "China's Social Credit System: Speculation vs. Reality". The Diplomat. Archived from the original on 4 May 2021.
- Hoffman, Samantha (12 December 2017). "Programming China: The Communist Party's autonomic approach to managing state security" (PDF). MERICS CHINA MONITOR. Retrieved 15 December 2018.
- Botsman, Rachel (2017). Who Can You Trust? How Technology Brought Us Together – and Why It Could Drive Us Apart. London, UK: Portfolio Penguin.
- 中国社会信用体系建设还需借鉴国际经验，但不接受妄语抹黑. China Institute of International Studies (in Chinese). Archived from the original on 13 November 2019. Retrieved 13 November 2019.
- Kostka, Genia (23 July 2018). "China's Social Credit Systems and Public Opinion: Explaining High Levels of Approval". Rochester, NY. SSRN 3215138. Cite journal requires
- "Study: More than two thirds of Chinese take a positive view of social credit systems in their country". Freie Universität Berlin. 23 July 2018.
- Shen, Kui. 社会信用体系建设的法治之道. Public Law, Peking University (in Chinese).
- Takala, Rudy (7 May 2018). "The West could be closer to China's system of 'social credit scoring' than you think". TheHill. Retrieved 11 November 2019.
- "The Human Rights Implications of China's Social Credit System". OHRH. 6 September 2019. Retrieved 12 November 2019.
- Kostka, Genia (13 February 2019). "China's social credit systems and public opinion: Explaining high levels of approval". New Media & Society. 21 (7): 1565–1593. doi:10.1177/1461444819826402. ISSN 1461-4448.
- Mistreanu, Simina (3 April 2018). "Life Inside China's Social Credit Laboratory:The party's massive experiment in ranking and monitoring Chinese citizens has already started" (PDF). FOREIGN POLICY. Retrieved 15 December 2018.
- "Debtors in China are placed on a blacklist that prohibits them from flying, buying train tickets, and staying at luxury hotels".
- "China penalises 6.7m debtors with travel ban". Financial Times.
- 人民银行印发《关于做好个人征信业务准备工作的通知》. www.gov.cn (in Chinese). 5 January 2015. Retrieved 18 July 2017.
- Ahmed, Shazeda (24 January 2017). "Cashless Society, Cached Data Security Considerations for a Chinese Social Credit System". www.citizenlab.ca. Retrieved 13 July 2017.
- Sander, Ed (26 July 2021). "Five misconceptions about China's Social Credit System". China Talk.
- 关于百行征信有限公司(筹)相关情况的公示. www.pbc.gov.cn (in Chinese). Retrieved 11 May 2019.
- Creemers, Rogier (9 May 2018). "China's Social Credit System: An Evolving Practice of Control". Rochester, NY. doi:10.2139/ssrn.3175792. S2CID 53668075. SSRN 3175792. Cite journal requires
- "China has started ranking citizens with a creepy 'social credit' system — here's what you can do wrong, and the embarrassing, demeaning ways they can punish you".
- "China's social credit system has blocked people from taking 11 million flights and 4 million train trips". Business Insider. Retrieved 30 May 2018.
- Botsman, Rachel (21 October 2017). "Big data meets Big Brother as China moves to rate its citizens". Wired UK.
- "China's plan to organize its society relies on 'big data' to rate everyone". Washington Post. Retrieved 6 March 2017.
- "China through a glass, darkly". www.chinalawtranslate.com. 24 December 2017.
- 联合信用助力新疆社会信用体系建设 (in Chinese). 9 December 2016. Retrieved 14 July 2017.[dead link]
- 首批社会信用体系建设示范城市名单公布. www.ndrc.gov.cn (in Chinese). Retrieved 11 May 2019.
- "Wenzhou Selected as a Model City in Building a Social Credit System". Retrieved 28 April 2018.
- CCC, "The" Social Credit System, retrieved 11 May 2019
- 地方信用网址. www.creditchina.gov.cn (in Chinese). Retrieved 27 April 2018.
- Daum, Jeremy (30 March 2018). "The redlists are coming! The blacklists are coming! A concise articulation of the principle operational mechanism of Social Credit, industry-specific blacklists". Retrieved 12 May 2018.
- China to bar people with bad 'social credit' from planes, trains Reuters 2018
- "Millions in China with bad 'social credit' barred from buying plane, train tickets".
- 新版个人征信报告将上线 "上午离婚下午买房"将成过去 _光明网. legal.gmw.cn (in Chinese).
- "Government clarifies reports on social credit system". Government of Hong Kong. 9 July 2019.
- "国务院关于印发社会信用体系建设规划纲要（2014—2020年）的通知". 中国中央人民政府. Archived from the original on 3 July 2017. Retrieved 8 November 2019.
- "世界媒体看中国：老大哥来了". 美国之音 (in Chinese). Archived from the original on 6 June 2019. Retrieved 27 October 2019.
- "中国会沦入《1984》吗？ －－评中共当局互联网管理新规定（胡平）". Radio Free Asia (in Chinese). Archived from the original on 8 November 2019. Retrieved 27 October 2019.
- "最高人民法院关于公布失信被执行人名单信息的若干规定" (in Chinese). Supreme People's Court. 2 March 2017. Archived from the original on 5 April 2018. Retrieved 23 December 2018.
- Chipman Koty, Alexander (5 November 2019). "China's Corporate Social Credit System: What Businesses Need to Know". China Briefing.
- Karen Li Xan Wong and Amy Shields Dobson (2019), "We're just data: Exploring China's social credit system in relation to digital platform ratings cultures in Westernised democracies", Global Media and China, 4 (2): 220–232, doi:10.1177/2059436419856090, hdl:20.500.11937/81128
- Tom McGregor (2 March 2019), Commentary: Actually, China's social credit system isn't the first, Channel News Asia
- Ming, Cheang (16 March 2017). "FICO with Chinese characteristics: Nice rewards, but punishing penalties". CNBC.
- Horsley, Jamie (16 November 2018). "China's Orwellian Social Credit Score Isn't Real". Foreign Policy.
- 一批新规5月施行 "老赖"名单期限最长可达5年. Central Government of China (in Chinese). Retrieved 12 November 2019.
- "最高法明确"老赖"上榜期限：一般2年 最长或为5年". China News (in Chinese). 1 March 2017. Retrieved 12 November 2019.
- Mistreanu, Simina. "China is implementing a massive plan to rank its citizens, and many of them want in". Foreign Policy. Retrieved 23 February 2021.
- 2682万人次因失信被限制乘机. XinhuaNet (in Chinese). Retrieved 10 November 2019.
- "Social credit system will not stop people using public services, Beijing says". South China Morning Post. 19 July 2019. Retrieved 10 November 2019.
- 失信惩戒对象查询. www.creditchina.gov.cn (in Chinese). Archived from the original on 10 November 2019. Retrieved 10 November 2019.
- "Court names and shames debtors in warm-up to Avengers movie". South China Morning Post. 25 April 2019. Retrieved 10 November 2019.
- "加大曝光！这12名"老赖"登上了新昌影院大银幕，最高欠款2000多万元！". Sohu (in Chinese). Sohu. 22 July 2019. Retrieved 10 November 2019.
- "China could ban children from 'dishonest' families from schools under social credit system". The Independent. 13 March 2019. Retrieved 10 November 2019.
- Chan, Tara Francis (16 July 2018). "A Chinese university suspended a student's enrolment because of his dad's bad social credit score". Business Insider. Retrieved 10 November 2019.
- Song, Bing (29 November 2018). "Opinion | The West may be wrong about China's social credit system". Washington Post. Retrieved 10 November 2019.
- "高院教委出手：限制失信被执行人子女就读高收费民办学校". Sohu (in Chinese). 9 August 2018. Retrieved 10 November 2019.
- "河北衡水治理"老赖"出新招：限制其子女就读私立学校". school.ieduchina.com (in Chinese). 19 July 2018. Retrieved 10 November 2019.
- "8月1日起，广州将霸座、骗保、考试作弊等将被纳入失信信息" (in Chinese). Sohu. 12 June 2019. Retrieved 10 November 2019.
- "How China's 'social credit' system blocked millions of people from travelling". Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. 7 March 2019.
- 苏州人有自己的信用指标"桂花分"，它的高低对生活有啥影响？ (in Chinese). Sohu. Retrieved 9 November 2019.
- Ma, Alexandra. "China's controversial social credit system isn't just about punishing people — here's what you can do to get rewards, from special discounts to better hotel rooms". Business Insider. Retrieved 12 November 2019.
- 《北京市轨道交通乘客守则》今起实施 车厢内禁止进食. politics.people.com.cn (in Chinese). Retrieved 10 November 2019.
- 北京市轨道交通乘客守则. Beijing Municipal Commission of Transport (in Chinese). Retrieved 12 November 2019.
- Wang, Bin (31 January 2019). 北京将探索推行"个人诚信分". Beijing Youth Daily (in Chinese). Retrieved 1 February 2019.
- "China blacklists millions of people from booking flights as dystopian 'social credit' system introduced". The Independent. 22 November 2018.
- 行人闯红灯 路口大屏幕"直播" (in Chinese). 新京报. Retrieved 8 November 2019.
- 张倩. [及时点]行人闯红灯上"直播"，你还敢闯吗？ (in Chinese). XinhuaNet. Retrieved 8 November 2019.
- 牵好你的狗！上海推出养犬信用积分制，将纳入征信体系 (in Chinese). Sohu. Retrieved 9 November 2019.
- 牵好你的狗！上海推出养犬信用积分制，将纳入征信体系！并且... (in Chinese). The Paper. Retrieved 9 November 2019.
- Huang, Echo. "Garbage-sorting violators in China now risk being punished with a junk credit rating". Quartz. Retrieved 10 November 2019.
- 《上海市生活垃圾管理条例》全文公布 7月1日起施行 (in Chinese). Sina. Retrieved 9 November 2019.
- 上海新规：子女拒不回家看看或影响当事人信用_新浪法院频道. finance.sina.com.cn (in Chinese). Retrieved 12 November 2019.
- [东方时空]《上海市老年人权益保障条例》5月1日实施：拒不探望老人 子女将入信用黑名单. China Central Television (in Chinese). Retrieved 12 November 2019.
- 广州将出新规：高铁霸座、考试作弊纳入失信信息 (in Chinese). Credit Guangzhou. Retrieved 10 November 2019.
- 不开玩笑！11月1日起，行人闯红灯和这些违法行为将纳入征信体系 (in Chinese). Shenzhen News. Retrieved 9 November 2019.
- 提醒！深圳新交规即将实施，11月1日起重罚这些行为! (in Chinese). Sohu. Retrieved 9 November 2019.
- 新条例解读 | 11月1日起，深圳这些交通违法行为将纳入征信体系 (in Chinese). NetEase. Retrieved 9 November 2019.
- 11月1日起，深圳行人闯红灯将纳入征信体系，小孩照样罚！ (in Chinese). Sohu. Retrieved 9 November 2019.
- 深圳新交规：非机动车交通违法、一年3次违法未处理，都将纳入征信系统 (in Chinese). Shenzhen News. Retrieved 9 November 2019.
- 深圳：闯红灯就"露脸" 隐私泄漏风险引发争议 (in Chinese). XinhuaNet. Retrieved 9 November 2019.
- 深圳上人脸识别闯红灯自动拍、不仅要罚还会影响未来... (in Chinese). Sohu. Retrieved 9 November 2019.
- 新《杭州市生活垃圾管理条例》审批通过垃圾不分类乱丢乱扔将被罚款并计入信用档案_省内要闻_平安浙江网. www.pazjw.gov.cn (in Chinese). Retrieved 12 November 2019.
- 新修改的《杭州市生活垃圾管理条例》全文来啦！. Sohu (in Chinese). Retrieved 12 November 2019.
- 7月8日起 在南京一年闯红灯5次以上将记入个人信用记录 (in Chinese). Sina. 7 July 2019. Retrieved 9 November 2019.
- 南京：行人闯红灯等行为将计入个人信用档案 (in Chinese). China Central Television. Retrieved 9 November 2019.
- 南京行人年闯红灯5次将失信 是加强违法行为制约还是滥用信用？ (in Chinese). Sohu. Retrieved 8 November 2019.
- 这25条都将被列入个人征信不良，不可不知! (in Chinese). Credit China Suzhou. Archived from the original on 9 November 2019. Retrieved 9 November 2019.
- "Forget to leash your dog? In China you could lose points – and your pet". South China Morning Post. 28 October 2018. Retrieved 12 November 2019.
- Yan, Sophia (30 October 2018). "Pick up poo or we take the dog: Chinese city rolls out 'social credit' system for pet owners". The Telegraph. ISSN 0307-1235. Retrieved 12 November 2019.
- 济南"养犬计分制"实施细则公布 4种违规情况要被扣分. www.sohu.com (in Chinese). Retrieved 12 November 2019.
- Mistreanu, Simina. "China is implementing a massive plan to rank its citizens, and many of them want in". Foreign Policy. Retrieved 23 February 2021.
- "China's Social Credit System in 2021: From fragmentation towards integration". Mercator Institute for China Studies. 3 March 2021.
- "Big Brother is watching: how China is compiling computer ratings on all its citizens". South China Morning Post. 24 November 2015. Retrieved 14 July 2017.
- Cook, Sarah (27 February 2019). "'Social credit' scoring: How China's Communist Party is incentivising repression". Hong Kong Free Press HKFP. Retrieved 2 March 2019.
- Yu, Zhang (16 January 2019). "Hebei court unveils program to expose deadbeat debtors". www.chinadaily.com.cn. Retrieved 2 March 2019.
- "China's Lenders Want to Check Your Social Media". Bloomberg.com. 13 August 2015. Retrieved 15 December 2017.
- Staff, W. S. J. (21 December 2016). "China's 'Social Credit' System: Turning Big Data Into Mass Surveillance". Blogs.wsj.com. Retrieved 15 December 2017.
- "China might use data to create a score for each citizen based on how trustworthy they are". Business Insider. Retrieved 15 December 2017.
- West, Jack Karsten and Darrell M. (18 June 2018). "China's social credit system spreads to more daily transactions". Brookings. Retrieved 13 November 2019.
- 发改委：7月份全国限制购买动车高铁票9万人次 防止失信"黑名单"认定泛化、扩大化. www.3news.cn (in Chinese). Retrieved 12 November 2019.
- Botsman, Rachel (21 October 2017). "Big data meets Big Brother as China moves to rate its citizens". Wired. Retrieved 31 January 2019.
- Nittle, Nadra (2 November 2018). "Spend "frivolously" and be penalized under China's new social credit system". Vox. Retrieved 23 February 2021.
- Hatton, Celia (26 October 2015). "China 'social credit': Beijing sets up huge system". BBC News. Retrieved 30 May 2018.
- Koetse, Manya. "Zhejiang Movie Theatre Displays Blacklisted Individuals in Avengers Movie Preview".
- "Uh-oh: Silicon Valley is building a Chinese-style social credit system In China, scoring". Fast Company. 26 August 2019.
- "Doing Business 2019: A Year of Record Reforms, Rising Influence". World Bank. Retrieved 13 November 2019.
- Gao, Charlotte. "Xi: China Must Never Adopt Constitutionalism, Separation of Powers, or Judicial Independence". The Dipomat. Retrieved 12 November 2019.
- Fukuyama, Francis. "Opinion | Francis Fukuyama: China's 'bad emperor' returns". Washington Post. Retrieved 12 November 2019.
- "How the West Got China's Social Credit System Wrong". Wired. ISSN 1059-1028. Retrieved 12 November 2019.
- "China ranks citizens with a social credit system – here's what you can do wrong and how you can be punished". The Independent. 8 May 2018.
- Tailai, Zhou; Walsh, Matthew (27 May 2020). "In Depth: How Chinese Companies Can Get Off Social Credit Blacklists". Caixin. China. Retrieved 5 August 2020.
- "The 'Mortal Danger' of China's Push Into AI". Wired. 24 January 2019.
- "George Soros Warns About China's Black Mirror-esque 'Social Credit System' at Davos". Observer. 25 January 2019. Retrieved 7 December 2019.
- Campbell, Charlie (23 January 2019). "How China Is Using Big Data to Create a Social Credit Score". Time. Retrieved 7 December 2019.
- Fu, King-wa; Jiang, Min (15 November 2018). "Big Data, Big Brother, Big Profit?". Rochester, NY. SSRN 3239434. Cite journal requires
- Liang, Fan; Das, Vishnupriya; Kostyuk, Nadiya; Hussain, Muzammil M. (2018). "Constructing a Data-Driven Society: China's Social Credit System as a State Surveillance Infrastructure". Policy & Internet. 10 (4): 415–453. doi:10.1002/poi3.183. ISSN 1944-2866.
- "China's Chilling 'Social Credit' Blacklist". Human Rights Watch. 12 December 2017.
- Matsakis, Louise (29 July 2019). "How the West Got China's Social Credit System Wrong". WIRED.
- "China's social credit system stopped millions of people from buying travel tickets". MIT Technology Review. Retrieved 11 January 2020.
- "Is China's social credit system as Orwellian as it sounds?". MIT Technology Review. Retrieved 11 January 2020.
- "ᐈ🧐Qué es DICOM y Cómo saber SI ESTOY en él 【2020】". Dicom Chile (in Spanish). Retrieved 17 March 2021.
- "¿De qué se trata el DICOM? | Programa CreceMujer - BancoEstado". www.crecemujer.cl.
- "Estoy en Dicom ¿puedo dar inicio de actividades a una sociedad comercial?".
- "Chile: DICOM fue la primera aplicación de Big Data, cuando aún no existía ni el concepto. ¡Siniestro!". 19 January 2019.
- "Meganoticias - Principales noticias de Chile y el mundo". mega.cl.
- "Proyecto que prohíbe enviar a Dicom por deudas en educación avanza en el Senado". BioBioChile - La Red de Prensa Más Grande de Chile (in Spanish). 19 July 2019. Retrieved 17 March 2021.
- "▷ ¿Cómo salir de DICOM en 2021? ¡Aquí te lo contamos!". www.adiosdeudas.cl (in Spanish). Retrieved 17 March 2021.
- "¿Cómo puedo salir de Dicom?". Defensa Deudores (in Spanish). 4 April 2019. Retrieved 17 March 2021.
- "Warning: Germany edges toward Chinese-style rating of citizens". Handelsblatt Global Edition. 17 February 2018. Retrieved 31 January 2019.
- Times, The Moscow (28 September 2018). "80% of Russians Will Have State-Gathered 'Digital Profiles' by 2025, Official Says". The Moscow Times. Retrieved 22 August 2019.
- Times, The Moscow (12 November 2018). "Chinese-Style Social Credit System Is a 'Threat' to Russia, Deputy PM Says". The Moscow Times. Retrieved 22 August 2019.
- М.Акимов: Правительство не планирует создание системы социального рейтинга для граждан. www.mskagency.ru (in Russian). Retrieved 22 August 2019.
- "What's your score?". neweconomics.org.
- Williams, Zoe (12 July 2018). "Algorithms are taking over – and woe betide anyone they class as a 'deadbeat'". the Guardian.
- "America Isn't Far Off From China's 'Social Credit Score'". Observer.com. 19 February 2018.
- "China's social credit system coming towards America". Weekly Blitz. 1 June 2019.
- Reuters. "Venezuela is rolling out a new ID card manufactured in China that can track, reward, and punish citizens". Business Insider. Retrieved 22 August 2019.
- "Chinese telecom giant 'helped Venezuela develop social credit system'". ABC News. 16 November 2018. Retrieved 22 August 2019.
- News, Taiwan. "China-style social credit system comes to Ven..." Taiwan News. Retrieved 22 August 2019.