Boy Scouts of America membership controversies

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

The Boy Scouts of America (BSA), one of the largest private youth organizations in the United States, has policies which prohibit atheists, agnostics and, until January 2014, prohibited all "open or avowed" homosexuals from membership in its Scouting program. The ban on "open or avowed" homosexual adults from membership remains in effect. BSA has denied or revoked membership status or leadership positions for violation of these foundational principles. The BSA contends that its policies are essential in its mission to instil in young people the values of the Scout Oath and Law.[1][2]

The organization's legal right to have these policies has been upheld repeatedly by both state and federal courts. In Boy Scouts of America v. Dale, the Supreme Court of the United States has affirmed that as a private organization, the BSA can set its own membership standards. The BSA's policies have been legally challenged but have not been found to constitute illegal discrimination because as a private organization in the United States, the BSA has the right to freedom of association,[3] as determined in the court case.[4] In recent years, the policy disputes have led to litigation over the terms under which the BSA can access governmental resources, including public lands.

These policies have led to various disputes and controversies. In 2012, both Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney and then President Barack Obama stated that they opposed the ban on gay Scouts.[5][6] On May 23, 2013, the BSA's National Council approved a resolution to remove the restriction denying membership to youth on the basis of sexual orientation alone effective January 1, 2014. The policy for adult leaders remains in place: "[BSA does] not grant membership to [adults] who are open or avowed homosexuals".[7][8]

Boy Scouts of America's values[edit]

According to its mission statement, the Boy Scouts of America seeks "to prepare young people to make ethical and moral choices over their lifetimes by instilling in them the values of the Scout Oath and Law".[1] All members are required, as a condition of membership, to promise to uphold and obey both of these pledges. The texts of the BSA's Scout Oath and Scout Law for Boy Scouting have remained unchanged since they were approved in 1911,[4] and every member agrees to follow them on his application form.

Scout Oath
On my honor I will do my best
To do my duty to God and my country
and to obey the Scout Law;
To help other people at all times;
To keep myself physically strong,
mentally awake, and morally straight.

Scout Law A Scout is trustworthy, loyal, helpful, friendly, courteous, kind, obedient, cheerful, thrifty, brave, clean, and reverent.

Boy Scouts salute during the playing of the national anthem as part of the Scouts' Citizen of the Year award reception and dinner in Washington, D.C., Nov 15, 2007.

Spirituality has been an integral part of the international Scouting movement since its inception. As early as 1908, Scouting founder Robert Baden-Powell wrote in the first Scout handbook that, "No man is much good unless he believes in God and obeys His laws."[9]

In reciting the Scout Oath, Scouts promise to do their duty to God and to be morally straight; the Scout Law holds that a Scout is clean and reverent. As early as 1978, the Boy Scouts of America circulated a memorandum among national executive staff stating that it was not appropriate for homosexuals to hold leadership positions in BSA.[10] Similarly, since at least 1985, the BSA has interpreted the Scout Oath and Law as being incompatible with agnosticism and atheism.[11] In both instances, the organization asserted that it was not a new policy to oppose and disfavor atheism, agnosticism and homosexuality, but rather, it was just enforcing long-held policies which had never been published or publicly challenged.[10][12]

Program differences[edit]

The Boy Scouts of America makes a division between its Scouting programs and the Learning for Life program. The traditional Scouting programs are Cub Scouting, Boy Scouting, and Venturing. Exploring is the worksite-based program of Learning for Life. Leadership positions and membership in the Learning for Life programs are open to youth and adults without restriction based on gender, sexual orientation, atheism or agnosticism.[13][14] The controversial policies which restrict membership apply only to the Scouting programs.

Position on atheists and agnostics[edit]

The Boy Scouts of America's official position is that atheists and agnostics cannot participate as Scouts or adult Scout Leaders in its traditional Scouting programs.

"The Boy Scouts of America maintains that no member can grow into the best kind of citizen without recognizing an obligation to God. In the first part of the Scout Oath or Promise the member declares, ‘On my honor I will do my best to do my duty to God and my country and to obey the Scout Law.’ The recognition of God as the ruling and leading power in the universe and the grateful acknowledgment of His favors and blessings are necessary to the best type of citizenship and are wholesome precepts in the education of the growing members."[2]

The Duty to God Award in use prior to 2002. This was presented to young male members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in conjunction with their participation in the Scouting program.

The BSA believes that atheists and agnostics are not appropriate role models of the Scout Oath and Law for boys, and thus will not accept such persons as members or adult leaders.[2] The Bylaws of the BSA contain a non-sectarian Declaration of Religious Principle which all Scouts are required to subscribe to as part of the membership application process. The Declaration of Religious Principle was adopted in the first decade of the organization to assuage the Roman Catholic Church's worries, in light of the work of the YMCA in establishing Scouting in the United States, that Scouting might be a Protestant proselytizing organization.

The BSA does not require adherence to any particular religious beliefs or ethos beyond this. The Boy Scout Handbook goes on to explain that "A Scout is Reverent" simply means that "A Scout is reverent towards God. He is faithful in his religious duties. He respects the beliefs of others." Buddhists, followers of Native American religions, Muslims, Jews, Christians of all denominations, and many others, including those who define their own spirituality, can be and are members of the BSA. The BSA recognizes religious awards for over 38 faith groups including Baha'i, Zoroastrianism, Judaism, Hinduism, and 28 varieties of Christianity.[15] Boy Scouts of America–approved religious emblems exist for most religions.

Position on homosexuality[edit]

On May 23, 2013, The Boy Scouts of America's national governing body voted to rescind the long-standing ban on homosexual youth in the program. Effective January 1, 2014, "No youth may be denied membership in the Boy Scouts of America on the basis of sexual orientation or preference alone."

Prior to this, the Boy Scouts of America's official position was to "not grant membership to individuals who are open or avowed homosexuals" as Scouts or adult Scout Leaders in its traditional Scouting programs.[8][16][17] As early as 1980, the Boy Scouts of America have denied membership from openly homosexual individuals applying for adult leadership positions.[18] In 1991 the BSA released a position statement expressing the organization's official position, stating: "We believe that homosexual conduct is inconsistent with the requirement in the Scout Oath that a Scout be morally straight and in the Scout Law that a Scout be clean in word and deed, and that homosexuals do not provide a desirable role model for Scouts.”[19] The BSA thus "believes that a known or avowed homosexual is not an appropriate role model of the Scout Oath and Law."[20]

The language used to describe the BSA's policies on homosexual individuals has evolved over time, stating in a 1993 position statement that: "We do not allow for the registration of avowed homosexuals as members or as leaders of the BSA."[21] The BSA adopted a new policy statement in 2004 which included a specific "Youth Leadership" policy stating that: "Boy Scouts of America believes that homosexual conduct is inconsistent with the obligations in the Scout Oath and Scout Law to be morally straight and clean in thought, word, and deed. The conduct of youth members must be in compliance with the Scout Oath and Law, and membership in Boy Scouts of America is contingent upon the willingness to accept Scouting’s values and beliefs. Most boys join Scouting when they are 10 or 11 years old. As they continue in the program, all Scouts are expected to take leadership positions. In the unlikely event that an older boy were to hold himself out as homosexual, he would not be able to continue in a youth leadership position."[20]

The BSA stated in a 2000 press release that, "Boy Scouting makes no effort to discover the sexual orientation of any person."[22] BSA application forms for youth membership and adult leadership positions do not inquire about the applicants' sexual orientation and do not mention the BSA's policies regarding homosexuality.[23] Membership has still been revoked in cases where an individual is found to be openly homosexual. In 2005, a high-level employee of BSA was fired by the National Council after the organization received a copy of his bill from a gay resort at which he had vacationed.[24] In 2009, the mother of a Vermont Scout and her civil-union partner were prohibited from volunteering for his pack when it was learned they were gay.[25]

The BSA once again reaffirmed its position in a press release on June 7, 2012 stating:

The BSA policy is: “While the BSA does not proactively inquire about the sexual orientation of employees, volunteers, or members, we do not grant membership to individuals who are open or avowed homosexuals or who engage in behavior that would become a distraction to the mission of the BSA. Scouting believes same-sex attraction should be introduced and discussed outside of its program with parents, caregivers, or spiritual advisers, at the appropriate time and in the right setting. The vast majority of parents we serve value this right and do not sign their children up for Scouting for it to introduce or discuss, in any way, these topics. The BSA is a voluntary, private organization that sets policies that are best for the organization. The BSA welcomes all who share its beliefs but does not criticize or condemn those who wish to follow a different path."[8][16]

On July 17, 2012, at the conclusion of a two-year review, an 11 person committee convened by the BSA reached a "unanimous consensus" recommending retaining the current policy.[26] But within the BSA National Executive Board, members James Turley, CEO of Ernst & Young, and Randall Stephenson, CEO of AT&T and who is "on track to become president of the Scout’s national board in 2014",[27] have publicly opposed the policy and stated their intention "to work from within the BSA Board to actively encourage dialogue and sustainable progress" in changing the policy.[28][29]

On January 28, 2013, the BSA said it is considering whether to remove its ban on gay leaders and members. "The policy change under discussion would allow the religious, civic, or educational organizations that oversee and deliver Scouting to determine how to address this issue," Deron Smith, public relations director, said in the statement.[30][31][32] USA Today reported the policy change could be adopted at the next National Executive Board meeting, scheduled for February 4–6, 2013.[33] On February 6, the 70 member executive Board announced that it needed "more time for a deliberate review" of its policy banning gays and have delayed a final decision until the much larger National Annual Meeting in May 2013 which will have voting representatives from all of the local councils.[34][35]

On April 19, 2013, the Boy Scouts of America announced a proposal to no longer deny membership to youth on the basis of sexual orientation, but maintain its ban on openly gay adult leaders.[36] The LDS church released a statement in support of the proposal.[37][38]

On May 23, 2013, the 1,400 voting members of the National Council of the Boy Scouts of America voted to lift the ban of letting openly-gay individuals into the scouts by 61% to 38%. Openly gay boys will be allowed to become scouts from January 2014 but openly gay adults will still be forbidden to be leaders.[39][40]

On June 12, 2013, the Southern Baptist Convention passed non-binding resolutions urging the BSA not to change their policy.[41][42]

In September 2013, a new scouting group (not affiliated with the BSA) called Trail Life USA (which will not admit openly gay youth) was created.[43][44][45] In September 2013, several Baptist congregations, as well as churches from other Christian denominations, replaced their Boy Scouts of America troops with those of Trail Life USA.[46]

Position on gender[edit]

The Boy Scouts of America's official position is that girls cannot participate in its Cub Scouting or Boy Scouting programs. "The Cub Scout and Boy Scout programs were designed to meet the emotional, psychological, physical, and other needs of boys between the ages of 8 and 14. Boys in this age range seek out and enjoy group activities with other boys."[47] However, the Venturing and Learning for Life programs are open to young men and women ages 14 through 21.[48][49]

Reaction to non-discrimination policies (2000-2013)[edit]

The United Way had ended financial support for the Great Trails Council after it refused to sign a non-discrimination policy.[50] United Way officials stated that such an agreement was not unique.[17] Also in 2001, the Boston Minuteman Council in Massachusetts approved a non-discrimination bylaw in regards to sexual orientation while also clarifying that discussions of sexual orientation were not permitted in Scouting.[51] A national Scout spokesperson explained that the council's bylaw did not conflict with national policy.[51] A spokesperson from the Cradle of Liberty Council explained that there is an unofficial "don't ask, don't tell" policy regarding sexual orientation.[52] The Scout Executive of the Minuteman Council believes that the local councils have a large amount of autonomy.[51]

However, after the Minuteman Council approved its non-discrimination bylaw, it rejected the merit badge application of an openly gay individual whose membership in the BSA had previously been revoked in New Hampshire.[51] The Minuteman Council asserted that "We will not accept anybody who has had his membership revoked by the national council."[51] The United Way ended financial support of the Minuteman Council as a result of the controversy.[50][51] As a result of unit level non-discrimination policies, charters were revoked from several Cub Scout packs in Oak Park, Illinois.[50] In 2003 the Cradle of Liberty Council in Philadelphia approved a non-discrimination policy, but the national council forced the local council to revoke the policy.[52] National ruled that local councils may not deviate from the national policy of not granting membership to openly gay kids.[52] In 2005 the Cradle of Liberty Council adopted another non-discrimination policy, but in 2006 the city of Philadelphia began asking for a more clear-cut non-discrimination policy.[52] Due to the council's refusal, the city ordered the council to pay fair-market rent for scout offices in a landmark Philadelphia building where the annual rate had been a dollar, resulting in the Cradle of Liberty Council v. City of Philadelphia lawsuit, that was ultimately decided in the Scouts' favor and a federal court decision that the city had unfairly targeted the Scouts.[52]

Nine councils from large metropolitan centers requested the right to define their own membership policies.[17][50] The proposal was taken to a national relationships committee.[17]

Other youth organization membership policies[edit]

There are affiliated Scouting organizations in other countries with less restrictive membership criteria than the BSA by choice and/or because of nondiscrimination laws in their lands, as well as organizations with similar policies. In the United States, other major youth organizations tend to have less restrictive policies.

World Organization of Scouting Movement programs[edit]

The Boy Scouts of America has belonged to the World Organization of the Scout Movement (WOSM) since its founding in 1922. WOSM has a membership of 155 National Scout Organizations with more than 28 million individuals.[53] Only one Scouting organization per country is recognized by WOSM. In about ten percent of the countries, the National Scout Organization is a federation composed of more than one Scout association; some of the associations in a federation may be for members of a specific religion (e.g., Denmark and France), ethnicity (e.g., Bosnia and Israel), or native language (e.g., Belgium).

On religion, WOSM states the following about its Fundamental Principles:[54]

Under the title "Duty to God", the first of the above-mentioned principles of the Scout Movement is defined as "adherence to spiritual principles, loyalty to the religion that expresses them and acceptance of the duties resulting therefrom". It should be noted that, by contrast to the title, the body of the text does not use the word "God", in order to make it clear that the clause also covers religions which are non-monotheistic, such as Hinduism, or those which do not recognize a personal God, such as Buddhism.

Indonesian Scouts at the 8th Indonesian National Rover Moot July 8–17, 2003, Prambanan Temple-Yogyakarta

The value system of the BSA and other Scouting associations may differ; this is evident in the different Scout promises and laws used by associations. Most other Scouting associations oaths and laws do not include the very specific wording to be "reverent" and "morally straight" which BSA added at its founding in 1910. Correspondingly, the membership policies of Scouting associations may differ as well (see Scout Promise and Scout Law).

For example, in contrast to the BSA's policy, homosexuals are not restricted from membership in Scouts Canada and most European associations, including The Scout Association in the United Kingdom, Ring deutscher Pfadfinderverbände of Germany (German Scout Federation), and the Swedish Guide and Scout Association.[55][56][57][58]

"Duty to God" is a principle of worldwide Scouting and WOSM requires its member National Scout Organizations to reference "duty to God" in their Scout Promises (see WOSM Scout Promise requirements). Scouting associations apply this principle to their membership policies in different ways. The Boy Scouts of America takes a hard-line position by excluding atheists or agnostics from membership. Scouts Canada defines "duty to God" broadly in terms of "adherence to spiritual principles" and does not have any explicit policy excluding non-theists.[59] According to the Equal Opportunities Policy of The Scout Association in the United Kingdom:

"To enable young people to grow into independent adults the Scout method encourages young people to question what they have been taught. Scouts and Venture Scouts who question God's existence, their own spirituality or the structures and beliefs of any or all religions are simply searching for spiritual understanding. This notion of a search for enlightenment is compatible with belief in most of the world's faiths. It is unacceptable to refuse Membership, or question a young person's suitability to continue to participate fully in a Section, if they express doubts about the meaning of the Promise."[60]

The membership policies of Scouting organizations also vary regarding the inclusion of girls, see Coeducational Scouting.

Litigation over the membership policies[edit]

The Boy Scouts of America has been sued because of its membership, leadership, and employment standards.[61] Some of the lawsuits dealt with the BSA's standards that require Scouts and Scouters to believe in God, those in leadership positions to not be openly homosexual, and the exclusion of girls from membership in some programs.[2][20][62]

There has been some opposition to single-sex membership programs and organizations in the United States including some programs of the BSA.[63] The Boy Scouts of America admits only boys to its Cub Scouting and Boy Scouting programs. Several lawsuits involving girls seeking admission to these programs (see Yeaw v. Boy Scouts of America) have resulted in court rulings that the BSA is not required to admit girls.[47]

During the 1980s and 1990s,several people attracted media attention when they sued the BSA, attempting to make them accept atheists as members and openly homosexual individuals in leadership positions. In 1981, Tim Curran, an openly homosexual former Scout, sued asking that he be accepted as an assistant Scoutmaster (see Curran v. Mount Diablo Council).[18] In 1991, twin brothers William and Michael Randall, who had refused to recite the "duty to God" portion of the Cub Scout Promise and Boy Scout Oath, sued to be allowed to continue in the program (see Randall v. Orange County Council and Welsh v. Boy Scouts of America).[64] In addition, there were several other lawsuits involving essentially the same issues.[65] Ultimately, the courts ruled in favor of the Boy Scouts of America in each case.

The courts have repeatedly held that the Boy Scouts of America, and all private organizations, have a right to set membership standards in accordance with the First Amendment protected concept of freedom of association. In particular, in Boy Scouts of America v. Dale, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in 2000 that the BSA's Constitutional right to freedom of association gave the organization the authority to establish its own membership and leadership standards and to expel a gay assistant Scoutmaster.[4][66]

After the Dale decision, public opinion in some communities turned against the BSA; corporations, charities, and even some local governments criticized the policy, threatening to either cut off financial support or block the Boy Scouts from using public buildings for their meetings. While some segments of the public criticized the organization, other groups became more enthusiastic in their support of the Scouts.[67]

Since the Supreme Court's ruling, the focus of lawsuits has shifted to challenging the BSA's relationship with governments in light of their membership policies. A number of lawsuits have been filed by or with the assistance of the American Civil Liberties Union over issues such as government association with the BSA and the conditions under which the BSA may access governmental resources.[68]

Governmental sponsorship of Scouting units[edit]

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) has taken legal action to stop governmental organizations from serving as the chartered organizations (sponsors) of Scouting units in violation of the establishment clause of the First Amendment. The Department of Defense announced in 2004 that it would end direct sponsorship of Scouting units in response to a lawsuit brought by the ACLU.[69][70] "The ACLU of Illinois charged that the Boy Scouts' policy violates the religious liberty of youth who wish to participate but do not wish to swear a religious oath, and that direct government sponsorship of such a program is religious discrimination."[71]

The BSA agreed in 2005 to transfer all charters it had issued to governmental entities to private entities in response to a request from the ACLU.[72] Previously, about 400 Scouting units had been sponsored by U.S. military bases and over 10,000 by other governmental entities, primarily public schools.[73]

Access to governmental resources[edit]

Historically, the BSA (and the Girl Scouts of the USA) has often been granted preferential access to governmental resources such as lands and facilities. In certain municipalities, the conditions under which the Boy Scouts of America can access public and nonpublic governmental resources have become controversial, sometimes resulting in litigation.

When a private organization such as the BSA receives access on terms more favorable than other private organizations, it is known as "special" or "preferential" access whereas "equal" access is access on the same terms. For example, state and local governments may lease property to nonprofit groups (such as the BSA) on terms that are preferential to or equal to the terms they offer to commercial groups, in other words they may give nonprofit groups either special or equal access. Special access includes access at a reduced fee (including no fee) or access to places off-limits to other groups. The categorization of access as "special" or "equal" is not always clear-cut.

Some cities, counties, and states have ordinances or policies that limit government support for organizations that practice some types of discrimination. When the BSA's membership policies are perceived as contrary to these laws, some government organizations have moved to change the terms under which the BSA is allowed to access its resources. Private individuals have filed lawsuits to prevent governmental entities from granting what they see as preferential access.[74] The BSA on the other hand has sued governmental entities for denying what it sees as equal access.[68]

In response to these changes and litigation, the federal government passed laws mandating that BSA units be given equal access to local and state-level governmental resources. The Boy Scouts of America Equal Access Act, enacted in 2002, requires public elementary and secondary schools that receive U.S. Department of Education funding to provide BSA groups equal access to school facilities.[75] The Support Our Scouts Act of 2005 requires state and local governments that receive HUD funding to provide BSA groups equal access to governmental forums (lands, facilities, etc.). State and local governments still have flexibility regarding the provision of special access to the BSA.[76]

Litigation regarding access to governmental resources[edit]

Litigation has challenged the granting of preferential or equal access of the Boy Scouts of America to governmental facilities and resources, but in the majority of cases mentioned, BSA's use of the facilities was sustained:

  • A US District Court's ruling against the BSA on the favorable terms under which the City of San Diego leases public land to the local BSA Council was overturned by Ninth US Court appeals in 2012. The court stated: “There is no evidence the city’s purpose in leasing the subject properties to the Boy Scouts was to was to advance religion, and there is abundant evidence that its purpose was to provide facilities and services for youth activities,” wrote Judge William C. Canby Jr. . See Barnes-Wallace v. Boy Scouts of America.
  • Philadelphia attempted to revoke the terms under which the City of Philadelphia leases public land to the BSA. The US District Court ruled June 2010 in favor of the Boy Scouts of America and that the city's selective actions against the council were actually designed to impinge BSA's First Amendment rights.[77][78] Under federal Civil Rights Law, the Cradle of Liberty Council is also entitled to collect its legal costs from the city's unlawful action. On March 21, 2012, the Federal judge formally ordered the city pay all of the Boy Scouts legal fees and denied the city's motion for an appeal. The Boy Scouts may also continue to occupy the building rent free as the organization has done since it had paid for construction of the building in 1929.[79] See Cradle of Liberty Council v. City of Philadelphia.
  • In July 2003, the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a decision by a U.S. District Judge that excluded the BSA from an annual workplace charitable campaign run by the state of Connecticut because of the BSA's policy on homosexuals. In March 2004, the United States Supreme Court declined to review the case.[80]
  • In March 2006, the California Supreme Court ruled in Evans v. Berkeley that the City of Berkeley did not have to continue to provide free dock space to the Sea Scouts.[81] In October 2006, the United States Supreme Court declined to review Evans v. Berkeley.[82]
  • In September 2006, the Oregon Supreme Court ruled that recruiting by BSA in public schools did not violate the state's nondiscrimination laws.[83]
  • The U.S. Army had given the BSA special access to a base, Fort A.P. Hill, for its national Scout jamboree and the U.S. Department of Defense had spent approximately $2 million per year in taxpayer funds to assist the BSA in staging it. The US Court of Appeals overturned a lower court ruling on the basis of a lack of standing to sue, thus allowing the 2010 Jamboree to go forward with continued DoD support (see Winkler v. Rumsfeld).[68][84] Despite the BSA's legal victory, the BSA Jamboree left Fort A.P. Hill—starting in 2013, the Scout Jamborees have been moved off public land to the new BSA-owned The Summit Bechtel Family National Scout Reserve.

Reaction to Boy Scouts of America's membership policies[edit]

There has been opposition to BSA's membership policies from organizations and individuals. Some within the Scouting movement, as well as long-time Scouting supporters, parents, chartered organizations, and religious organizations have expressed opposition to the policies in ways ranging from protests to forming organizations that advocate greater inclusiveness. Some push for a voluntary change within the BSA, others seek involuntary change by filing lawsuits, still others choose to disassociate themselves from the BSA or encourage others to do so.

Perhaps the most vocal opponent of the policies has been the American Civil Liberties Union, which has brought or been a participant in fourteen lawsuits against the Boy Scouts of America from 1981 to March 2006.[85] A few members of the U.S. Congress have also spoken out against the BSA's policies.[86] Since the Dale decision, some Eagle Scouts (about 100) have returned their Eagle Scout badge to the BSA in protest.[87][88]

The Unitarian Universalist Association's opposition to the BSA's membership exclusions led to a dispute between the organizations. In 2001, the Union for Reform Judaism's Commission on Social Action, citing a commitment to ending discrimination in all forms, issued a memorandum recommending that congregations stop hosting BSA troops and that parents withdraw their children from all of the Boy Scouts of America's programs.[89] Additionally, the General Synod of the United Church of Christ issued a statement urging the BSA to change policy and stated that "Discrimination against anyone based on sexual orientation is contrary to our understanding of the teachings of Christ."[90]

Some troops have ignored the ban for years. Every year when it comes time to renew its charter, troops simply cross out a promise to abide by the Boy Scouts' policies.[91]

The Secular Coalition for America has urged Congress to revoke the federal charter of the BSA, stating: "Our government must not entangle itself in religious organizations; nor should it establish, with government imprimatur, a private religious club."[92]

Loss of support[edit]

Some public entities and private institutions have ceased financial or other support of the BSA, primarily as a result of conflicts between their nondiscrimination policies and the BSA's membership policies. About 50 of the 1,300 local United Ways, including those in Cleveland, Miami, Orlando, Philadelphia, San Francisco, and Seattle, have withdrawn all funding.[93][94] The BSA has also lost all funding from several large corporations that had been regular donors, such as Chase Manhattan Bank, Levi Strauss, Fleet Bank, CVS/pharmacy, and Pew Charitable Trusts.[93] For example, Pew Charitable Trusts, which had consistently supported the BSA for over fifty years, decided to cancel a $100,000 donation and cease future donations.[93] A number of public entities (including the cities of Chicago, San Diego, Tempe, Buffalo Grove, Berkeley, and Santa Barbara, as well as the states of California, Illinois, and Connecticut) have canceled charitable donations (of money or preferential land access) that had historically been granted to the Scouts.[93][95][96] On September 22, 2012, Intel, the BSA's largest corporate donor, officially withdrew its financial support from any troop that cannot sign a statement confirming that the troop does not discriminate based on creed or sexual orientation.[97] In November 2012, the UPS Foundation, a philanthropic division of UPS, halted its financial donations, amounting to $85,000 in 2011, to the BSA because of its discrimination based on sexual orientation.[98] In 2012, Merck & Co. stopped its funding due to the policy excluding gays and lesbians.[99][100] In 2013, restaurant chain Chipotle publicly pulled support over the ban.[101]

Eagle Scout filmmaker Steven Spielberg had been a long-time supporter of Scouting, depicting a young Indiana Jones as a Boy Scout in the 1989 film Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade and helping to create the Cinematography merit badge. Spielberg resigned from the BSA Advisory Council in 2001, saying, "it has deeply saddened me to see the Boy Scouts of America actively and publicly participating in discrimination."[102]

May 2013–present[edit]

On May 23, 2013, the BSA approved a resolution to remove the restriction denying membership to gay youth, but the ban on openly gay adult leaders remains.

California considered and rejected the "Youth Equality Act, which would require that tax-exempt organizations - including student groups or sports and activity groups organized through public or private schools - would be barred from discriminating on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity." [103]

On June 14, Caterpillar Inc. cut its funding of the BSA, saying "We have inclusive policies here at Caterpillar Inc. [...] We would certainly consider a change in the future grants - if there was a change that aligned with what our non-discrimination policies are." [104] A Pennsylvania chapter of the United Way withheld funding over the decision to exclude openly gay leaders.[105]

In December 2013, Lockheed Martin announced it would end donations to the BSA over the organization's ban on openly gay adults serving as leaders.[106]

Efforts to change the membership and leadership policies[edit]

There have been numerous efforts (other than litigation) to change the BSA's membership policies regarding atheists and homosexuals.

Scouts for Equality has persuaded several United Way groups to remove funding, as well as having Intel end its $700,000 annual support of local troops.[107] The organization also maintains a list of Eagle Scouts who have renounced their Eagle awards.

At the BSA annual national meeting of local council representatives in Boston in 2001, nine local councils submitted a resolution to give more discretion for membership and leadership standards to local councils and chartered organizations; this resolution and two others also seeking to liberalize the policy towards homosexuals were considered by the BSA National Executive Board but the initiative failed in 2002.[108] The policy was revised to the current policy in 2004 and reaffirmed in 2012.

In 1991, William Boyce Mueller, a former Cub Scout and grandson of original Boy Scouts of America founder William Dickson Boyce, helped start an advocacy group of gay former Scouts called the "Forgotten Scouts".[109]

The Inclusive Scouting Network, founded in August 2000, is a group promoting an end to the membership biases. Its website, http://www.inclusivescouting.net has been used as the central hub for all of its information and is still currently being used. An award called the Inclusive Scouting Award has been promoted through them for people who are actively trying to better the scouting experience.[110]

Scouting for All sought to promote tolerance and diversity within the BSA.[111] Scouter Dave Rice co-founded Scouting for All in 1993, initially for the purpose of changing the BSA policy on sexual orientation. In 1998, the Boy Scouts of America dismissed him after 59 years of membership for "involving Scouting youth" in his effort. Rice, who is not gay, stated that he obeyed all rules and guidelines and that he never misused his leadership status or promoted an agenda during troop meetings. He maintains that the Boy Scouts of America violated its own rules by summarily dismissing him without granting him a chance to present evidence to a regional review board as is required by the BSA's "Procedures for Maintaining Standards of Membership".[112][113]

2012–present[edit]

In the US Military, the Don't Ask, Don't Tell repeal passed the House on a vote of 250 to 175 on December 15, 2010.[114] On December 18, 2010, the Senate vote was held later that same day, with the measure passing by a vote of 65–31.[115] President Obama signed the change into law on December 22, 2010.[116] The US military formally ended Don't Ask Don't Tell in September 2011.

The Democratic and Republican 2012 Presidential candidates - Barack Obama and Mitt Romney - both disagreed with the BSA's policy.[117]

At the Scouts annual meeting in April 2012, a "leader from the Northeast" presented a resolution that "would allow individual units to accept gays as adult leaders".[118][119] In July 2012, the executive committee of the executive board released a statement revealing that an "11 person committee" convened since 2010 by the BSA conducted a two-year review and reached a "unanimous consensus" recommending retaining the current policy.[26][120] Although this panel reportedly "included a diversity of perspectives" its existence "was kept secret" and the BSA "declined to reveal its membership or methods."[121] Two BSA board members, Randall Stephenson (AT&T CEO) and James Turley (Ernst & Young CEO), publicly supported ending the ban.[122]

Scouting had reported that the 2013 National Scout Jamboree would be headlined by the band Train and singer Carly Rae Jepsen.[123] In March 2013, both cited the BSA policy on gays as barrier to their performance. Train released a statement saying the group "strongly opposes any kind of policy that questions the equality of any American citizen ... We look forward to participating in the Jamboree this summer, as long as they make the right decision before then."[124] In March, entertainer Madonna made a public appearance dressed as a Scout and called for the ban to be lifted.[125]

In March 2013, Microsoft founder and former Scout Bill Gates called on the BSA to lift the ban.[126][127]

In a 2012 survey asking open-ended questions 5,800 respondents (9%) mentioned the policy in their answers. Of those who did mentioned the policy, 95 percent said the “reaffirmation of the membership policy negatively impacted their loyalty" to the BSA.[128]

In March 2013, the BSA invited its members to take an online survey about the LGBT ban.[129] The survey asked multiple questions, one of which explored the role of gay youth in Scouting:

Tom started in the program as a Tiger Cub, and finished every requirement for the Eagle Scout Award at 16 years of age. At his board of review Tom reveals that he is gay. Is it acceptable or unacceptable for the review board to deny his Eagle Scout award based on that admission?"

Accord to results released by the BSA, 78% of parents felt it was unacceptable to deny the Scout his Eagle award simply because of his orientation, while only 18% felt it was acceptable. Teens and Scouting Alumni who completed the survey responded similarly.[130]

In May 2013, the Western Los Angeles County Council, which oversees some 30,000 youth, released a statement calling for a "true and authentic inclusion policy" that would allow both gay leaders as well as gay scouts.[131] Just days before the national vote to include gay scouts (but not leaders), the Connecticut Yankee Council, which serves about 25,000[132] Scouts, issued an official statement saying "Scouting in the Connecticut Yankee Council is open to all youth and adults who subscribe to the values of the Scout Oath and Law regardless of their personal sexual orientation.".[133][134]

On May 22, the sitting president of the BSA, Wayne M. Perry, published an op-ed "Let in gay boys" urging passage of the resolution.[135]

Breakaway organizations[edit]

Several youth development organizations have formed directly in response to disagreement with BSA's membership policies.

Support for BSA and its membership policies (2000-2013)[edit]

The membership controversy and subsequent litigation, some of which has been in response to the 2000 ruling in Boy Scouts of America v. Dale, has prompted a number of expressions of support for the BSA organization, program, or policies. In 2002, the National Executive Board of Boy Scouts of America reiterated its support for the policies and affirmed that "the Boy Scouts of America shall continue to follow its traditional values and standards of leadership".

Support from federal government[edit]

The U.S. House of Representatives and the U.S. Senate have overwhelmingly passed resolutions in support of the Boy Scouts of America. In November 2004, the House passed a resolution, by a vote of 391 to 3, recognizing "the Boy Scouts of America for the public service the organization performs".[136] Then, in February 2005, the House passed a resolution by a vote of 418 to 7, stating that "the Department of Defense should continue to exercise its long-standing statutory authority to support the activities of the BSA, in particular the periodic national and world Scout jamborees."[137]

President Bush addresses the 2005 National Scout Jamboree at Fort A.P. Hill in Virginia.

The U.S. Congress has twice passed bills in response to the governmental resources access controversy. In 2001, the U.S. Congress passed the Boy Scouts of America Equal Access Act, which was included as part of the No Child Left Behind Act, and which encouraged the BSA's access to educational facilities. In July 2005, the Senate voted 98 to 0 in favor of the Support Our Scouts Act, which was included as part of the Department of Defense Appropriations Act and was enacted in December 2005, which encourages both governmental support of the Boy Scouts in general and federal support of the national Scout jamboree.

Senator Bill Frist, one of the sponsors of the Support Our Scouts Acts, spoke highly of the BSA, saying:

"This unique American institution is committed to preparing our youth for the future by instilling in them values such as honesty, integrity, and character."

Of the Act, Frist explained:

"This legislation will allow the Boy Scouts to fulfill its mission without the distraction of defending itself against senseless attacks."[138]

President of the United States William Howard Taft began serving as the first Honorary President of the Boy Scouts of America in 1911; the tradition has been followed by each succeeding U.S. President. In July 2001, President George W. Bush addressed the National Scout Jamboree and, although he did not directly discuss the controversies, reiterated his support for the organization. At the Jamboree, Bush commended the Scouts for upholding "values that build strong families, strong communities, and strong character" and said that the Scouts' values "are the values of America."[139]

In January 2009, the American Humanist Association and eighteen other nontheistic organizations sent an open letter to then President-Elect Obama urging him not to serve as the Boy Scouts' honorary president because of the Scouts' positions on religion.[140] Ignoring this, Obama accepted the position of Honorary President and has received the BSA's annual report from groups of Scouts every February from 2009 through 2013.[citation needed]

On July 29, 2010, President Obama chose not to attend the Scouts' centennial Jamboree, sending a videotaped greeting instead and doing an interview on the daytime talk show The View. This decision was met with criticism, and raised speculation that the President's absence was a subtle protest against the Scouts' policies, or deferring to groups opposed to BSA's policies. However, he did send Secretary of Defense William Gates to represent him, and other Presidents, such as Eisenhower and Reagan, had previously sent representatives to National Jamborees instead of attending personally. President Obama continues to serve as Honorary National President, and has hosted the annual Report to the Nation delegation from the BSA each year at the White House.

Support from others[edit]

Individuals, commentators, and conservative groups have spoken out in support of the Boy Scouts of America. The BSA legal website provides a list of editorials written in support of the BSA.[141]

A conservative civil libertarian group, the American Civil Rights Union (not to be confused with the ACLU), set up the Scouting Legal Defense Fund, and routinely helped with lawsuits.[142] In a legal brief filed in support of the BSA, the American Civil Rights Union argued that "To label [the BSA's membership policies] discriminatory and exclusionary, and a civil rights violation, is an assault on the very freedom of American citizens to advance, promote, and teach traditional moral values."[143] In 2000, a group of current and former members of the BSA created the group "Save Our Scouts", in order "to support and defend the principles of the Scout Oath and Law". This group has subsequently closed as a charity due to failure to file annual reports.[144]

Eagle Scout Hans Zeiger, author of Get Off My Honor: The Assault on the Boy Scouts of America, told the Washington Times, "Scouts' honor is under attack in American culture." Zeiger applauds what he sees as the BSA's courage in resisting political pressure, saying, "Regardless of what leads to homosexuality, it is a thing that has an agenda in our society and is very harmful to the traditional family and is causing a tremendous amount of harm to young men. The Boy Scouts are one of the few organizations that have the moral sense to stand against the homosexual agenda."[145]

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS Church), a longtime supporter of the Boy Scouts of America, teaches that homosexual activity is immoral.[146] The LDS Church is the largest single sponsor of Scouting units with over 30,000 units nationwide, which comprise about 13% of BSA's youth members.[147][148] In 2000, an attorney representing the LDS church stated that "The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints ... would withdraw from Scouting if it were compelled to accept openly homosexual Scout leaders".[147][149] This does not differ from the LDS Church policy of allowing "non-practicing" self professed gay members to enjoy all the same rights and privileges as any other Church member.

An LDS spokesman issued a statement "We caution others not to speculate about our position... Neither has the [LDS] Church launched any campaign either to affect or prevent a policy change."[150]

The United Methodist Church, the second-largest sponsor of Scouting units, has taken no public position on the controversy surrounding allowing openly gay leaders in Scouting, although in recent years the Church itself has had an ongoing internal debate regarding whether or not to accept LGBT clergy.[citation needed]

The BSA's ban on openly gay members has met with support from the Westboro Baptist Church, whose leader Fred Phelps was himself an Eagle Scout.[151]

In March 2013, a subgroup of the Scouting community launched "OnMyHonor.net", a self-described group "who are united in their support of Scouting’s timeless values and their opposition to open homosexuality in the Scouts."[152][153] The Boy Scouts of America general counsel described OnMyHonor as an "outside party" and requested the site cease and desist using official BSA logos on the site.[154]

BSA membership size[edit]

Annual Youth Membership
Year Tiger Cubs,
Cubs,
Webelos
Boy Scouts,
Varsity Scouts
Venturers (post-1997),
Explorers (pre-1998),
not incl. LFL (post-1989)
Total
Traditional
Scouting
1960[155] 1,865,000 1,647,000 271,000 3,783,000
1970[155] 2,438,000 1,916,000 329,000 4,683,000
1975[155] 1,997,000 1,503,000 434,000 3,933,000
1980[155] 1,696,000 1,064,000 447,000 3,207,000
1981[155] 1,643,000 1,101,000 499,000 3,244,000
1982[155] 1,693,000 1,126,000 606,000 3,425,000
1983[155] 1,693,000 1,116,000 758,000 3,567,000
1984[155] 1,638,000 1,078,000 941,000 3,657,000
1985[155] 1,668,000 1,063,000 1,024,000 3,755,000
1986[155] 1,974,000 1,042,000 1,021,000 4,037,000
1987[155] 2,110,000 1,032,000 1,037,000 4,180,000
1988[155] 2,148,000 1,025,000 1,055,000 4,228,000
1989[155] 2,156,000 1,008,000 1,083,000 4,247,000
1990[155] 2,181,000 1,011,000 741,000 3,933,000
1991[155] 2,126,000 979,000 362,000 3,467,000
1992[155] 2,111,000 976,000 367,000 3,454,000
1993[155] 2,067,000 979,000 380,000 3,426,000
1994[155] 2,031,000 978,000 394,000 3,403,000
1995[155] 2,037,000 981,000 401,000 3,419,000
1996[155] 2,095,000 1,000,000 422,000 3,419,000
1997[155] 2,153,000 1,016,000 455,000 3,624,000
1998[155] 2,171,000 1,023,000 188,000 3,382,000
1999[156] 2,181,013 1,028,353 202,486 3,411,852
2000[156] 2,114,405 1,003,681 233,828 3,351,914
2001[156] 2,043,478 1,005,592 276,434 3,325,504
2002[156] 2,000,478 1,010,791 293,323 3,304,592
2003[156] 1,914,425 997,398 288,395 3,200,218
2004[156] 1,875,752 988,995 280,584 3,145,331
2005[157] 1,745,324 943,426 249,948 2,938,698
2006[158] 1,701,861 922,836 244,256 2,868,963
2007[158][159] 1,687,986 913,588 254,259 2,855,833
2008[159][160] 1,665,635 905,879 261,122 2,832,636
2009[161] 1,634,951 898,320 257,361 2,790,632
2010[162] 1,601,994 898,852 238,846 2,739,692
2011[163] 1,583,166 909,576 231,127 2,723,869
2012[164] 1,528,421 910,163 219,453 2,658,794
2013[165] 1,417,034 888,947 192,080 2,498,061
Peak Year 1970 1970 1989 1970
Most Recent Peak 1999 1999 2008 1997
change
(since 1999)
-35.0% -13.6% -5.1% -26.8%
change
(since peak)
-41.9% -53.4% -82.3% -46.7%
change
(since recent peak)
-35.0% -13.6% -26.4% -31.1%


In popular culture[edit]

An episode of the NBC comedy The New Normal, entitled "About a Boy Scout", discusses the controversy.[166]

Historical membership controversies[edit]

There have been membership controversies in the past which have been resolved, such as those related to the exclusion of women from some leadership positions, the breakup of Exploring, and racial segregation.

Racial segregation[edit]

Segregated public schools were declared unconstitutional in 1954 by a unanimous Supreme Court ruling in Brown v. Board of Education, but the Boy Scouts of America included racially segregated units as late as 1974.[167]

In 1974, the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People sued in response to such racial discrimination in Latter-day Saints-affiliated troops. Two 12-year black scouts sought to fill the role of Senior Patrol Leader. Mormon boys enter the lowest level of the priesthood at 12, and the church's rules required that the Senior Patrol Leader be a deacon with the church.[168] Until 1978, Mormon doctrine prohibited people of African descent from being members of the priesthood, and thus black scouts were prohibited from holding the office of Senior Patrol Leader in Mormon-affiliated troops.[169] The parties ultimately reached settlement.

Role of women[edit]

Women were not allowed to be a primary unit leader such as Cubmaster or Scoutmaster. After her local troop disbanded for lack of a male Scoutmaster, Catherine Pollard applied for the post. After the BSA denied her application solely on the basis of her gender, Pollard sued in Connecticut state courts to be allowed the post of Scoutmaster. Although the court ultimately ruled against her, in 1988 the BSA's executive board voted to allow women to be primary unit leaders.[170]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ a b "Core Values". BSALegal.org. Archived from the original on October 4, 2006. Retrieved October 2, 2006. 
  2. ^ a b c d "Duty to God". BSALegal.org. Archived from the original on May 9, 2008. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  3. ^ Volokh, Eugene (May 23, 2006). "Freedom Of Expressive Association And Government Subsidies" (PDF). Stanford Law Review 58: 1919–1968. Retrieved November 12, 2008. 
  4. ^ a b c "Decision of Superior Court of New Jersey Appellate Division, A-2427-95T3, Dale v. Boy Scouts (1998)". Rutgers School of Law-Camden. Archived from the original on October 20, 2003. Retrieved September 2, 2007. 
  5. ^ "Obama opposes Boy Scouts' ban of gay members". Political Ticker (CNN). August 8, 2012. Retrieved September 25, 2012. 
  6. ^ Dinan, Stephen (August 7, 2012). "Advocates: Romney backs gay scouts, Obama is silent". The Washington Times. Retrieved September 25, 2012. 
  7. ^ "Boy Scouts of America Statement" (Press release). Boy Scouts of America. May 23, 2013. Retrieved May 25, 2013. 
  8. ^ a b c "Current Membership Policy". Boy Scouts of America. June 7, 2012. Retrieved September 13, 2013. 
  9. ^ "Robert Baden-Powell (1908) Scouting for Boys, quoted here". Faqs.org. Retrieved January 2, 2012. 
  10. ^ a b Boy Scouts of America et al. v. Dale (2000) Decision of the US Supreme Court
  11. ^ Mechling, Jay (2001). On My Honor: Boy Scouts and the Making of American Youth. University of Chicago Press. ISBN 0-226-51704-7. Retrieved July 5, 2010. 
  12. ^ "UUs Petition Boy Scouts to End Discrimination Against Gays, Agnostics". Unitarian Universalist Association. Archived from the original on September 30, 2006. Retrieved October 9, 2007. 
  13. ^ "Learning For Life". BSA Discrimination. Retrieved June 24, 2008. 
  14. ^ "What Is Exploring?" (PDF). Learning For Life. Retrieved June 24, 2008. 
  15. ^ Schubert, Rebecca (August 8, 2007). "Navajo Boy Scouts work to establish Native emblem". Navajo-Hopi Observer (Flagstaff, Arizona). Retrieved September 29, 2009.  for work on a Navajo Native American Church emblem.
  16. ^ a b "Boy Scouts of America clarifies its membership policy". Scouting. Boy Scouts of America. June 7, 2012. Retrieved June 7, 2012. 
  17. ^ a b c d Eckholm, Erik (July 17, 2012). "Boy Scouts to Continue Excluding Gay People". The New York Times. 
  18. ^ a b "Curran v. Mount Diablo Council of the Boy Scouts of America". Lambda Legal. 1998. Archived from the original on September 3, 2006. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  19. ^ "Opinion of the Supreme Court of the United States, No. 99—699, Boy Scouts v. James Dale". Legal Information Institute, Cornell University Law School. Retrieved September 3, 2007. 
  20. ^ a b c "Morally Straight". BSALegal.org. Archived from the original on February 6, 2010. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  21. ^ Boy Scouts of America and Monmouth Council, et al., Petitioners v. James Dale, No. 99—699 (Supreme Court of the United States 2000).
  22. ^ "BSA Sustained By US Supreme Court". Boy Scouts of America. Archived from the original on January 26, 2007. Retrieved July 9, 2006. 
  23. ^ "Scouting Forms from the National Council". Scouting.org. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  24. ^ "Scouted Out". Mother Jones.com. Archived from the original on December 27, 2005. Retrieved May 5, 2009. 
  25. ^ "Scouts Reject Lesbian Leaders". Rutland Herold. Retrieved February 9, 2010. 
  26. ^ a b Leitsinger, Miranda (July 17, 2012). "Boy Scouts: We're keeping policy banning gays". NBC News. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  27. ^ McGregor, Jena (July 19, 2012). "After Boy Scouts of America reaffirms exclusion of gays, the biggest leadership question remains". The Washington Post. Retrieved January 10, 2013. 
  28. ^ MSNBC: Miranda Leitsinger, "Boy Scouts board member opposes anti-gay policy," June 13, 2012. Retrieved June 16, 2012
  29. ^ Cobb, Joshua (July 17, 2012). "AT&T CEO commits to ending ban on gay Boy Scouts, leaders". Retrieved January 10, 2013. 
  30. ^ Smith, Deron (January 28, 2013). "Membership Policy Media Statement". BSA. Retrieved January 28, 2013. 
  31. ^ Dorell, Oren (January 28, 2013). "Boy Scouts may soon welcome gay scouts, leaders". USA Today. Retrieved January 28, 2013. 
  32. ^ Williams, Pete (January 28, 2013). "Boy Scouts close to ending ban on gay members, leaders". Retrieved January 28, 2013. 
  33. ^ "BSA Calendar". Boy Scouts of America. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  34. ^ "Executive Board Decision Media Statement". BSA. February 6, 2013. Retrieved February 6, 2013. 
  35. ^ "Boy Scouts: We need more time for decision on gay membership". NBC News. Retrieved February 6, 2013. 
  36. ^ "Boy Scouts proposing to lift ban on gays as youth members, keep it for adult leaders". The Washington Post. Retrieved April 29, 2013. [dead link]
  37. ^ McCombs, Brady (April 26, 2013). "Mormon Church Supports Gay Boy Scouts, Calls Proposal A 'Thoughtful, Good-Faith Effort'". Huffington Post. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  38. ^ "Church Issues Statement on Boy Scouts of America" (Press release). The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. April 25, 2013. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  39. ^ "Boy Scouts of America votes to ease ban on gay members". BBC. May 23, 2013. Retrieved May 25, 2013. 
  40. ^ "Boy Scouts vote to allow gay youth". Dallas Voice. Retrieved May 23, 2013. 
  41. ^ Gryboski, Michael (February 20, 2013). "So. Baptists Pass Resolution Urging Boy Scouts to Not Repeal Gay Ban". The Christian Post. Retrieved December 21, 2013. 
  42. ^ "Boy Scout resolution adopted by SBC". Baptist Press. June 12, 2013. Retrieved December 21, 2013. 
  43. ^ [1] Trail Life USA launches a Boy Scout alternative by Ed Payne of CNN
  44. ^ Trail Life USA, The 'Other' Boy Scouts Of America by Kathy Lohr of NPR
  45. ^ Trail Life USA: An alternative to the Boy Scouts Washington Post
  46. ^ "Boy Scouts or an alternative? Churches continue to deliberate". Baptist Press. September 16, 2013. Retrieved December 21, 2013. 
  47. ^ a b "Litigation Regarding Girls Seeking Membership". BSALegal.org. Archived from the original on May 12, 2008. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  48. ^ "Venturing BSA". Boy Scouts of America. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  49. ^ Boy Scouts of America Youth Application (PDF). Boy Scouts of America. #28-406B. Archived from the original on May 28, 2008. Retrieved October 6, 2007. "Venturers and Sea Scouts registered in a crew or ship prior to their 21st birthday may continue as members after their 21st birthday until the crew or ship recharters or until they reach their 22nd birthday, whichever comes first." 
  50. ^ a b c d Jackson, Derrick Z. (June 8, 2001). "Opening the Door to Gay Boy Scouts". Boston Globe. Archived from the original on January 18, 2006. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  51. ^ a b c d e f "Saying no to bias in BSA, or not?". Retrieved November 9, 2012. 
  52. ^ a b c d e Donaldson-Evans, Catherine (August 18, 2007). "Boy Scouts' Rent Skyrockets in Philadelphia to $200K Over Gay Ban". Fox News Channel. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  53. ^ "Census". World Organisation of the Scout Movement. Retrieved September 3, 2007. 
  54. ^ "Fundamental Principles". Elements for a Scout Program. World Scout Bureau, P.O. Box 241 1211 Geneva 4, Switzerland. 1992. Retrieved January 22, 2010.  (this appears on a web site maintained by Canadian Scouter Liam Morland but is reprinted from a WOSM publication)
  55. ^ "The key policies of The Scout Association". The Scout Association. Retrieved December 30, 2009. 
  56. ^ "Being Gay with an Adult role in Scouting". The Scout Association. Retrieved December 30, 2009. 
  57. ^ "World Scouting Movement". BSA Discrimination. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  58. ^ The Scout Association gives positive advice. It’s OK to be Gay and a Scout!Advice for young people
  59. ^ "BSA and Religious Belief". BSA Discrimination.org. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  60. ^ "Equal Opportunities Policy: Guidelines with reference to Young People: Religious belief". Policy Organisation and Rules. The Scout Association. Archived from the original on November 17, 2006. Retrieved October 5, 2007. 
  61. ^ "Litigation". BSALegal.org. Archived from the original on September 20, 2006. Retrieved July 9, 2006. 
  62. ^ "Teaching 'Boys to Do Things for Themselves and Others'". BSALegal.org. Retrieved July 9, 2006. 
  63. ^ "BSA and Girls in Scouting". Discrimination in the BSA. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  64. ^ "Randall v. Orange County Council, Boy Scouts of America" (PDF). March 23, 1998. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  65. ^ e.g. Merino v. BSA, Pool & Geller v. BSA, Welsh v. BSA, Seabourn v. BSA. See Discrimination in the BSA
  66. ^ "Boy Scouts of America v. Dale - 530 U.S. 640 (2000)". Supreme.justia.com. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  67. ^ Pierce, Jason (March 15, 2001). "Despite Controversy, Boy Scouts Say Business Continues as Usual". Cybercast News Service. Archived from the original on December 6, 2007. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  68. ^ a b c "Access to Government Forums". BSALegal.org. Archived from the original on April 17, 2009. Retrieved July 9, 2006. 
  69. ^ "Winkler v. Chicago School Reform Board". Aclu-il.org. Retrieved March 18, 2009. 
  70. ^ "Department of Defense settles part of litigation challenging its involvement with the Boy Scouts of America". Usdoj.gov. November 16, 2004. Archived from the original on May 8, 2009. Retrieved March 18, 2009. 
  71. ^ "Pentagon Agrees to End Direct Sponsorship of Boy Scout Troops in Response to Religious Discrimination Charge". American Civil Liberties Union. Retrieved March 2, 2006. 
  72. ^ "National Boy Scout Organization Agrees to End All Local Government Direct Sponsorship of Troops and Packs". American Civil Liberties Union of Illinois. Retrieved March 2, 2006. 
  73. ^ "Boy Scouts Jamboree to Stay at Army Base". The Washington Times. Archived from the original on April 19, 2006. Retrieved March 2, 2006. 
  74. ^ Winkler v. Chicago School Reform Board, et al., Evans v. Berkeley, discussed here [2]
  75. ^ "Boy Scouts of America Equal Access Act". US Dept. of Education – Office for Civil Rights. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  76. ^ "Support Our Scouts Act of 2005". US Library of Congress. March 16, 2005. 
  77. ^ "Pennsylvania: City Cannot Evict Scouts for Gay Ban". The New York Times. June 24, 2010. 
  78. ^ "Jury says Philly can't evict Boy Scouts for anti-gay policy". Philadelphia Daily News. June 24, 2010. Retrieved January 2, 2012. 
  79. ^ Campisi, Jon (March 22, 2012). "Judge orders City of Phila. to pay $877,000 in legal fees stemming from Boy Scouts discrimination suit". PennRecord.com. Retrieved October 25, 2012. 
  80. ^ Seper, Jerry (March 9, 2004). "High Court Spurns Appeal by Scouts". The Washington Times. Archived from the original on December 24, 2005. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  81. ^ "Berkeley Sea Scout Decision Appealed to United States Supreme Court". Pacific Legal Foundation Press Release. July 11, 2006. Archived from the original on August 13, 2006. Retrieved November 3, 2006. 
  82. ^ Egelko, Bob (October 17, 2006). "Top Court Rejects Sea Scouts' Appeal On Rent Subsidy". San Francisco Chronicle. p. B2. 
  83. ^ "Court OKs Boy Scout Recruiting At Schools". The Oregonian. Archived from the original on April 2, 2008. Retrieved March 18, 2009. 
  84. ^ "Prominent Chicago Religious Leaders Ask Federal Appellate Court to Protect Government Neutrality in Religion and End Pentagon's Extraordinary Funding for Boy Scout Jamboree". ACLU of Illinois Press Release. April 5, 2006. Retrieved November 3, 2006. 
  85. ^ "BSALegal.org talks to George A. Davidson, BSA National Counsel, about Winkler v. Rumsfeld". BSALegal.org. Archived from the original on May 13, 2008. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  86. ^ "Congressman Frank's Statement Supporting 'Scouting for All'". Scouting for All. Archived from the original on June 20, 2006. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  87. ^ "In Support of Values". Scouting Magazine. March–April 2001. 
  88. ^ "A Dramatic Protest By Some Eagle Scouts Dismayed That The Boy Scouts Bar Gays As Leaders, Some Members Return Their Prized Eagle Badges". Philadelphia Inquirer. July 18, 2000. Archived from the original on June 29, 2006. Retrieved November 3, 2006. 
  89. ^ "Memorandum: Boy Scouts of America". Union for Reform Judaism. Retrieved March 18, 2009. 
  90. ^ "General Synod 24 at a glance". United Church of Christ. July 1, 2003. Retrieved August 11, 2011. 
  91. ^ Reddy, Sumathi (July 26, 2012). "Some Boy Scout Troops Disregard Ban on Gays". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved October 15, 2012. 
  92. ^ "Secular Coalition for America position on federal support of the Boy Scouts of America". Secular Coalition for America. 2009. Retrieved September 27, 2009. 
  93. ^ a b c d "The Impact of the Boy Scouts of America’s Anti-Gay Discrimination". Lambda Legal. Archived from the original on June 26, 2006. Retrieved March 2, 2006. 
  94. ^ Davis, Dave (September 25, 2012). "United Way of Greater Cleveland moves to pull funding in 2013 for Boy Scouts over group's prohibition of gay members". The Plain Dealer. Retrieved December 10, 2012. 
  95. ^ "The Santa Barbara County Board of Supervisors told the BSA They Couldn't Use Its Facility Free of Charge as Long as They Had a Discriminatory Policy". Scouting for All. Archived from the original on June 26, 2006. Retrieved March 2, 2006. 
  96. ^ "The Connecticut Human Rights Organization Affirmed Its Earlier Decision to Exclude the Boy Scouts from the State Employee Fund-raising Campaign". Scouting for All. Archived from the original on June 26, 2006. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  97. ^ Shapiro, Lila (September 22, 2012). "Intel Halts Boy Scout Donations Over Anti-Gay Policy". HuffPost Gay Voices. Retrieved September 25, 2012. 
  98. ^ "UPS stops Boy Scout funding over anti-gay policy". CBS News. November 12, 2012. Retrieved November 14, 2012. 
  99. ^ "Merck Foundation Suspends Funding to Boy Scouts of America until Ban on Gay Scouts And Leaders Ends". GLAAD. December 10, 2012. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  100. ^ "Merck pulls funding over Boy Scout's ban on gay scouts, leaders". Out & About Newspaper. December 10, 2012. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  101. ^ [3][dead link]
  102. ^ "Spielberg Resigns From Boy Scouts Board". Hollywood.com. Archived from the original on January 3, 2013. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  103. ^ Cadelago, Christopher (September 12, 2013). "Capitol Alert: California lawmakers ice bill targeting Boy Scouts". The Sacramento Bee. Retrieved September 16, 2013. 
  104. ^ "Caterpillar cut funds to Boy Scouts because of discrimination". Wisconsin Gazette. Caterpillar. June 14, 2013. Retrieved June 17, 2013. 
  105. ^ "Boy Scouts And United Way Respond To Funding Cuts". WNEP.com. June 19, 2013. Retrieved June 20, 2013. 
  106. ^ Zongker, Brett (December 19, 2013). "Lockheed Martin Ends Boy Scouts Gifts Over Gay Ban". ABC News. Associated Press. Retrieved December 21, 2013. 
  107. ^ Shapiro, Lila (September 22, 2012). "Intel Halts Boy Scout Donations Over Anti-Gay Policy". Huffington Post. Retrieved October 15, 2012. 
  108. ^ Barnett, Robert. "Boy Scouts of America reaffirms position on homosexuality". Minnesota Family Council. Archived from the original on November 24, 2007. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  109. ^ Merrett, Jim. "Scout's Honor". Advocate Magazine. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  110. ^ "The Inclusive Scouting Award - You Earn It by Wearing It". Inclusive Scouting Network. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  111. ^ "About Us". Scouting for All. Archived from the original on August 15, 2006. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  112. ^ "Dave Rice". Scouting for All. Archived from the original on June 23, 2006. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  113. ^ Ness, Carol (September 13, 1998). "Scouts Expel Longtime Leader". San Francisco Gate. Archived from the original on September 10, 1999. 
  114. ^ "Final vote results for roll call 638". Clerk.house.gov. December 15, 2010. Retrieved December 19, 2010. 
  115. ^ Hulse, Carl (December 18, 2010). "Senate Repeals Ban Against Openly Gay Military Personnel". The New York Times. Retrieved December 29, 2012. 
  116. ^ Stolberg, Sheryl Gay (December 22, 2010). "Obama Signs Away 'Don't Ask, Don't Tell'". The New York Times. Retrieved December 22, 2010. 
  117. ^ Carnia, Catalina (August 8, 2012). "Obama, Romney opposed to Boy Scouts ban on gays". USA Today. Retrieved October 15, 2012. 
  118. ^ Sacramento Bee: David Crary, "http://www.sacbee.com/2012/06/06/4543635/scouts-to-review-ban-on-gays-no.html," June 6, 2012. Retrieved June 6, 2012[dead link]
  119. ^ "Boy Scouts to review ban on gays". Fox News. June 7, 2012. Retrieved November 15, 2012. 
  120. ^ "After Two-year Evaluation, Boy Scouts of America Affirms Membership Standards and Announces No Change in Policy". Boy Scouts of America. July 17, 2012. Retrieved August 18, 2012. 
  121. ^ Eckholm, Erik (July 17, 2013). "Boy Scouts to Continue Excluding Gay People". The New York Times. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  122. ^ McGregor, Jena (July 19, 2012). "After Boy Scouts of America reaffirms exclusion of gays, the biggest leadership question remains". The Washington Post. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  123. ^ Nelson, Rebecca (March 5, 2013). "Carly Rae Jepsen and Train Refuse to Perform at Boy Scout Jamboree". Time. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  124. ^ Bennett-Smith, Meredith (March 4, 2013). "Train Won't Play At Boy Scouts Jamboree Unless BSA Lifts Ban On Gay Scouts, Band Says". Huffington Post. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  125. ^ "Madonna calls on Boy Scouts to lift ban on gays". Yahoo! News. Associated Press. March 17, 2013. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  126. ^ Ford, Zack (March 15, 2013). "Bill Gates: Boy Scouts Should Stop Discriminating 'Because It's 2013'". ThinkProgress. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  127. ^ Meyers, Jessica (March 13, 2013). "Bill Gates on D.C.: 'You don’t run a business like this'". Politico.Com. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  128. ^ Israel, Josh (March 22, 2013). "Internal Survey Shows Many Boy Scouts And Parents Believe Discriminatory Policy Harms Organization". ThinkProgress. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  129. ^ [4][dead link]
  130. ^ "Boy Scouts of America Membership Standards Review". Scouting.org. April 29, 2013. Retrieved May 23, 2013. 
  131. ^ Dobuzinskis, Alex (May 8, 2013). "Los Angeles Boy Scout group calls for welcoming gay adults". Reuters. Retrieved May 23, 2013. 
  132. ^ "Connecticut Yankee Council, BSA". Kintera.org. Retrieved May 23, 2013. 
  133. ^ McNamara, Eileen (May 22, 2013). "Connecticut Boy Scout Council Will Allow Gays". East Hampton-Portland Patch. Retrieved May 23, 2013. 
  134. ^ "News - Scouting is for Everyone". Connecticut Yankee Council. May 22, 2013. Retrieved May 23, 2013. 
  135. ^ Perry, Wayne (May 22, 2013). "Boy Scouts president: Let in gay boys". USA Today. Retrieved May 23, 2013. 
  136. ^ "House Resolution 853: Recognizing the Boy Scouts of America for the Public Service the Organization Performs for Neighborhoods and Communities Across the United States". Library of Congress. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  137. ^ "House Concurrent Resolution 6". Library of Congress. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  138. ^ "Alexander, Frist Announce "Support Our Scouts Act Of 2005"". Retrieved March 18, 2009. [dead link]
  139. ^ "Bush Calls Scout Values 'America's Values'". CNSNews.com. Archived from the original on December 6, 2007. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  140. ^ "President-Elect Obama Asked to Turn Down Boy Scouts of America". American Humanist Association. Retrieved April 9, 2009. 
  141. ^ "What Others Are Saying". BSALegal.org. Archived from the original on May 13, 2008. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  142. ^ "Scouting Legal Defense Fund". defendscouting.com. Retrieved March 18, 2009. 
  143. ^ "Amicus Curie Brief in Barnes-Wallace v. Bsa" (PDF). American Civil Rights Union. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  144. ^ "Matters List of Charities with closing info". New Hampshire Department of Justice. Archived from the original on December 31, 2009. Retrieved November 8, 2009. 
  145. ^ "Defending the Scouts". The Washington Times. July 13, 2005. Archived from the original on December 6, 2006. Retrieved November 3, 2006. 
  146. ^ Hinckley, Gordon (2006). "What is the Church's Attitude Toward Homosexuality?". The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Retrieved November 2, 2006. 
  147. ^ a b "Brief of Amici Curiae, Boy Scouts of America v. James Dale" (PDF). 2000. Archived from the original on September 27, 2006. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  148. ^ France, David (August 6, 2001). "Scouts Divided". Newsweek. BSA Discrimination. Retrieved November 4, 2006. 
  149. ^ "What Happens If Scouts Must Admit Gays?". Mormon News. Retrieved May 25, 2008. 
  150. ^ Crary, David; Merchant, Nomaan (February 7, 2013). "LDS Church: 'Don't speculate about our position' on Boy Scouts gay ban". Standard-Examiner. Associated Press. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  151. ^ Goodman, Julie (November 22, 1999). "Two groups respond to the call for Boy Scouts to admit gays". Positiveatheism.org. Associates Press. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  152. ^ Davis, John W. (March 23, 2013). "Boy Scouts launching coalition to keep gays, lesbians out". Cfnews13.com. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  153. ^ "Who We Are". OnMyHonor.Net. Retrieved May 4, 2013. 
  154. ^ "BREAKING NEWS: Limited Edition Commemorative Patch available in next 48 hours". OnMyHonor.Net. Archive.constantcontact.com. 2013. Retrieved May 23, 2013. 
  155. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v "443. Boy Scouts and Girl Scouts--Membership and Units". Retrieved February 28, 2014. 
  156. ^ a b c d e f "Boy Scouts of America Membership Declines". Archived from the original on June 29, 2006. Retrieved January 2, 2012. 
  157. ^ "Annual Traditional Membership Summary (2006)". Boy Scouts of America. 2007. Retrieved June 23, 2009. 
  158. ^ a b "Annual Traditional Membership Summary (2007)". Boy Scouts of America. 2008. Retrieved June 23, 2009. 
  159. ^ a b "Learning for Life Annual Participation Summary". Boy Scouts of America. 2008. Retrieved January 15, 2010. [dead link]
  160. ^ "Annual Traditional Membership Summary (2008)". Boy Scouts of America. Archived from the original on June 12, 2009. Retrieved June 23, 2009. 
  161. ^ "Annual Report 2010". Boy Scouts of America. 2010. Retrieved March 20, 2011. 
  162. ^ "Annual Report 2011". Boy Scouts of America. 2011. Retrieved February 18, 2012. 
  163. ^ "2011 BSA Annual Report". Boy Scouts of America. 2011. Retrieved February 4, 2013. 
  164. ^ "At a Glance". Boy Scouts of America. 2012. Retrieved February 4, 2013. 
  165. ^ "2013 Report to the Nation". Boy Scouts of America. 2013. Retrieved February 28, 2014. 
  166. ^ http://blog.zap2it.com/frominsidethebox/2013/03/the-new-normal-boy-scouts-episode-is-a-loving-tribute-to-scouting-that-also-explores-the-gay-controv.html
  167. ^ Demby, Gene (January 30, 2013). "Boy Scouts' Repeal Of Gay Ban Mirrors Its Approach To Racial Integration". NPR. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  168. ^ "Black Boy Scout Ban Threatens Church". Observer-Reporter. September 11, 1974. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  169. ^ "NAACP Sues Boy Scouts Despite Policy Change". Jet. August 29, 1974. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  170. ^ Madden, Richard L. (February 17, 1988). "A Woman Wins Her 14-Year Fight To Be Scoutmaster". The New York Times. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 

External links[edit]

Sites supportive of the Boy Scouts of America's policies
Sites critical of the Boy Scouts of America's policies
Other sites
Publications