SEPTA Regional Rail

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
     SEPTA Regional Rail
SEPTARegionalRail.svg
SEPTA map.png
SEPTA Regional Rail system map
Reporting mark SEPA (revenue equipment), SPAX (non-revenue and MOW equipment)
Locale Delaware Valley
Dates of operation 1983–present
Predecessor Conrail
Track gauge 4 ft 8 12 in (1,435 mm) standard gauge
Headquarters 1234 Market Street
Philadelphia, PA 19107

The SEPTA Regional Rail system (reporting marks SEPA, SPAX) consists of commuter rail service on 13 branches to more than 150 active stations in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, and its suburbs. Service on most lines operates from 5:30 a.m. to midnight.

The core of the Regional Rail system is the Center City Commuter Connection, composed of three Center City stations in the "tunnel" corridor: the above-ground upper level of 30th Street Station, the underground Suburban Station, and Jefferson Station (formerly Market East Station). All trains stop at these Center City stations; most also stop at Temple University station on the campus of Temple University in North Philadelphia. Operations are handled by the SEPTA Railroad Division.[1]

Of the 13 branches, seven were originally owned and operated by the Pennsylvania Railroad (PRR) (later Penn Central), and six by the Reading Company (RDG). The PRR lines terminated at Suburban Station; the RDG lines at Reading Terminal. In November 1984, the Center City Commuter Connection united the two systems, turning the two terminal stations (Reading Terminal having been replaced by the Jefferson Station) into through-stations. Most inbound trains from one line continue on as outbound trains on another line. (Some limited or express trains terminate on one of the stub-end tracks at Suburban Station.)

Lines[edit]

Diagram of SEPTA Regional Rail service

Each PRR line was once paired with a RDG branch and numbered from R1 to R8 (except for R4), so that one route number described two lines, one on the PRR side and one on the RDG side. This was ultimately deemed more confusing than helpful, so on July 25, 2010, SEPTA dropped the R-number and color-coded route designators and changed dispatching patterns so fewer trains follow both sides of the same route.[2]

Former Pennsylvania Railroad lines
Former Reading Company lines

Stations[edit]

SEPTA Regional Rail logo

There are 156 active stations on the Regional Rail system (as of 2006), including 51 in the city of Philadelphia, 41 in Montgomery County, 29 in Delaware County, 16 in Bucks County, 10 in Chester County, and six outside the state of Pennsylvania. In 2003, passengers boarding in Philadelphia accounted for 61% of trips on a typical weekday, with 45% from the three Center City stations and Temple University station.

County Stations Boardings in 2003 Boardings in 2001
Philadelphia 51 60 967 61 970
Montgomery County 41 17 228 18 334
Delaware County 29 8 310 8 745
Bucks County 16 5 332 5 845
Chester County 10 5 154 5 079
Outside Pennsylvania 6 2 860 3 423
total 153 99 851 103 396

Rolling stock[edit]

SEPTA uses a mixed fleet of General Electric and Hyundai Rotem "Silverliner" electric multiple unit (EMU) self-operated cars, used on all Regional Rail lines. SEPTA also uses push-pull equipment: coaches built by Bombardier and Pullman Standard, hauled by AEM-7 or ALP-44 electric locomotives identical to those used by Amtrak and New Jersey Transit (NJT). The push-pull equipment is used exclusively for Wilmington/Newark Line, West Trenton Line, Paoli/Thorndale Line, and Trenton Line peak express service because it accelerates more slowly than the EMU equipment, making it less suitable for local service with close station spacing and frequent stops and starts.

As of 2012, all cars have a blended red-and-blue SEPTA window logo and "ditch lights" that flash at grade crossings and when "deadheading" through stations, as required by Amtrak for operations on the Northeast and Keystone Corridors. SEPTA's railroad reporting mark SEPA is the official mark for their revenue equipment, though it is rarely seen on external markings. SPAX can be seen on non-revenue work equipment, including boxcars, diesel locomotives, and other rolling stock.

The "Silverliner" coaches, built by Budd in Philadelphia and first used by the PRR in 1958 as the "Pioneer III" for a prototype intercity EMU alternative to the GG1-hauled trains, were purchased by SEPTA in 1963 as "Silverliner II" units. In 1967, the PRR took delivery of the St. Louis-built "Silverliner III" cars, which featured left-hand side controls (railroad cars traditionally have right-hand side controls) and flush toilets (since removed), and were used primarily for Harrisburg-Philadelphia service. The Silverliner II and III cars were designated under the PRR MP85 class. Some "Silverliner III" cars were converted for exclusive Airport Line use; they featured special luggage racks where the old toilet closets were located, yellow window paintings, and the Philadelphia International Airport's "PHL" logo. The bulk of the fleet are "Silverliner IV" coaches built by General Electric in Erie with carshells from Avco and Canadian Vickers; these were delivered in 1973–76, before the formation of Conrail.

SEPTA retired the "Silverliner II" and "Silverliner III" cars in June 2012 and replaced them with the "Silverliner V" model. A total of 120 new "Silverliner V" cars were built, with the first three entering service on October 29, 2010.[4] The cost for all 120 cars is $274 million, and they are being constructed in facilities located in South Philadelphia and South Korea by Hyundai Rotem.[4][5] As of March 2013, all 120 cars have been delivered, and are in service

All Silverliner models are compatible with one another, now that the "Pioneer III" (Silverliner I) coaches have been scrapped. (One survived on display at the Railroad Museum of Pennsylvania in nearby Strasburg.)

SEPTA also owns two "Arrow II" EMU cars built by GE in 1974 and once operated by New Jersey Transit for its electrified service to and from New York City and Hoboken Terminal (formerly NJT 1236 and 1237). The "Arrow II" car is nearly identical to that of the "Silverliner IV", but lacks the distinctive dynamic brake roof "hump" on the car, and has a "diamond" pantograph instead of the "T" pantograph used on the "Silverliner". The "Arrow II" are used as part of work trains, such as catenary inspection and leaf removal.

The entire system uses 12,000-volt/25 Hz overhead catenary lines that were erected by the PRR and RDG railroads between 1915 and 1938. All current SEPTA equipment is compatible with the power supplies on both the ex-PRR (Amtrak-supplied) and ex-RDG (SEPTA-supplied) sides of the system; the "phase break" is at the northern entrance to the Center City commuter tunnel between Jefferson Station and Temple University Station.

SEPTA passenger rolling stock includes:

Electric multiple units[edit]

Main article: Silverliner
Year Make Model Numbers[6] Total Hp Tare
(Ton/t)
Seats Remarks
1973–76 GE Silverliner IV 101–188, 306–399,
417–460 (married pairs)
276–305, 400–416
(single cars)
231 of 232 active Not known 62.5/56.8 125 101–188 Series Former Reading Married Pairs. 306–399 Series Former Penn Central Married Pairs. 400-series units are cars renumbered from lower series or from Reading Railroad cars 9018–9031 when PCB transformers were replaced with silicone transformers.
2010–13 Rotem Silverliner V 701–738 (single cars)
801–882 (married pairs)
120 of 120 active 62.5/56.8 110 Replacements for 70 older cars; will also add capacity.[5] First three cars entered revenue service October 29, 2010; delivery completed as of March 21, 2013.

Push-pull passenger cars[edit]

Year Make Model Numbers[6] Total Tare
(Ton/t)
Seats Remarks
1970 Pullman Standard Comet I 2460–2461(cab cars)
2590–2595 (trailers)
2 cabs, 6 coaches 50/45.4 118
(cab car)
131
(trailers)
Cars originally built for NJDOT for service on the Erie Lackawanna's commuter trains. Purchased from NJ Transit 2008 for added seating. As of August 2013 they were put in storage.
1987 Bombardier SEPTA I 2401–2410 (cab cars)
2501–2525 (trailers)
10 cab cars
25 trailers
50/45.4 118
(cab cars)
131
(trailers)
1999 Bombardier SEPTA II 2550–2559 10 trailers 50/45.4 117 These cars have a center door, and are used in push-pull service.

Locomotives[edit]

Year Make Model Numbers[6] Total Hp Tare
(Ton/t)
Remarks
1987 EMD AEM-7 2301–2307 7 7,000 101/91.9
1995 ABB ALP-44 2308 1 7,000 99.2/90.2 Delivered as a result of a settlement agreement for late delivery of N-5 cars.

Electrification[edit]

All lines used by SEPTA are electrified with overhead catenary supplying alternating current at 12 kV with a frequency of 25 Hz. The system on the former PRR side is owned and operated by Amtrak, part of the electrification of the Northeast Corridor. The electrification on the RDG side is owned by SEPTA. The Amtrak system was originally built by the PRR between 1915 and 1938. The SEPTA-owned system was originally built by the RDG starting in 1931.

Yards and maintenance facilities[edit]

SEPTA has four major yards and facilities for the storage and maintenance of regional rail trains:

History[edit]

SEPTA was created to prevent passenger railroads and other mass transit services from disappearing or shrinking in the region. Passenger rail service was previously provided by for-profit companies, but by the 1960s the profitability had eroded, not least because huge growth of automobile use over the previous 30 years had reduced ridership. SEPTA's creation provided government subsidies to such operations and thus kept them from closing down. For the railroads, at first it was a matter of paying the existing railroad companies to continue passenger service. In 1966 SEPTA had contracts with the PRR and RDG to continue commuter rail services in the Philadelphia region.[7]

The Pennsylvania Railroad and the Reading Company[edit]

The PRR and RDG operated both passenger and freight trains along their tracks in the Philadelphia region. Starting in 1915, both companies electrified their busiest lines to improve the efficiency of their passenger service. They used an overhead catenary trolley wire energized at 11,000 volts single-phase alternating current at 25 Hertz (Hz).[8] The PRR electrified the Paoli line in 1915, the Chestnut Hill West line in 1918, and the Media/West Chester and Wilmington lines in 1928. Both railroads continued electrifying lines into the 1930s, replacing trains pulled by steam locomotives with electric multiple unit cars and locomotives. PRR electrification reached Trenton and Norristown in 1930. RDG began electrified operation in 1931 to West Trenton, Hatboro (extended to Warminster in 1974) and Doylestown; and in 1933 to Chestnut Hill East and Norristown. The notable exception was the line to Newtown, the RDG's only suburban route not electrified. While the PRR expanded electrification throughout the northeast (ultimately stretching from Washington, D.C. to New York City), the RDG never expanded electric lines beyond the Philadelphia commuter district.[9]

By the late 1950s, commuter service had become a drag on profitability for the PRR and RDG, like most railroads of the era. Commuter service requires large amounts of equipment, large numbers of employees to operate equipment and station sites, and large amounts of maintenance on track that see extremely heavy usage for only six hours a day, five days a week.[7] Meanwhile, the rise in automobile ownership and the building of the Interstate Highway System chipped away at the steady patronage as population in the suburbs grew. When the Philadelphia suburbs were small towns, people lived close enough to a train station to walk to and from the trains. When the suburbs expanded into what had been fields and pastures, the trip to the station required an automobile, leading commuters to remain in their cars and drive all the way into the city as a matter of convenience.[7]

Both railroads shed a few minor money-losing routes, but more major pruning efforts ran into public opposition and government regulation.[9] Ending a major line involved hearings before the Interstate Commerce Commission (ICC), the predecessor to the Surface Transportation Board, which moved at a glacial pace and was capricious in the matter of approval, requiring one railroad to continue operating a local train on a route covered by four other trains while allowing another to discontinue a well-patronized train that had no competing lines.[7] In response, the railroads made commuting unpleasant for passengers by neglecting the upkeep of equipment.[7]

Faced with the possible loss of commuter service, local business interests, politicians, and the railroad unions in Philadelphia pushed for limited government subsidization.[9] In 1958, the city enacted the Philadelphia Passenger Service Improvement Corporation (PSIC), which consisted of a partnership with the RDG and PRR to subsidize service on both Chestnut Hill branches.[9] This was not enough to reverse the deterioration of the railroad infrastructure. By 1960, the PSIC assisted with services reaching as far as the city border in all directions. PSIC subsidized trains to Manayunk on the PRR's Schuylkill Branch[9] (service beyond Manayunk to Norristown was then discontinued on October 29, 1960 and de-electrified);[10] to Shawmont on the RDG Norristown line, to Fox Chase on the RDG Newtown line, and as far as Torresdale on the PRR's northeast corridor to New York City.[9] Subsequently, the city purchased new trains. The success of the PSIC subsidy program resulted in its expanding throughout the five-county suburban area under the Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Compact (SEPACT) in 1962.[9]

Still, the subsidies could not save the big railroads. The PRR attempted to stay solvent by merging with the New York Central Railroad on February 1, 1968, but the resulting company, Penn Central, went bankrupt on June 21, 1970. The RDG filed for bankruptcy in 1971.[7]

Conrail[edit]

In 1976, Conrail took over the railroad-related assets and operations of the bankrupt PRR and RDG railroads, including the commuter rail operations. Conrail provided commuter rail services under contract to SEPTA until January 1, 1983, when SEPTA assumed operations.[7]

SEPTA takeover and strike[edit]

The transition from Conrail to SEPTA, overseen by General Manager David L. Gunn (who later became President of the New York City Transit Authority and Amtrak), was a turbulent one.[7] SEPTA attempted to impose lower transit (bus and subway driver's) pay scales and work rules, which was met by resistance by the BLE (an experiment was already in place on the diesel-only Fox Chase Rapid Transit Line, which used City Transit Division employees instead of traditional railroad employees as a bargaining chip). As the January 1, 1983 deadline approached, the unions stated they agreed to work even if new union contracts were not in place by the new year.[9] SEPTA had spent most of December 1982 preparing riders for the likelihood of no train service come the new year.[9] Even with the unions' offers to continue working, SEPTA insisted that a brief shutdown of service would still be necessary, arguing that it would not know until the eleventh hour how many Conrail employees would actually come to work for SEPTA.[9] In addition, SEPTA claimed that these employees would have to be qualified to work on portions of the system unfamiliar to them.[9]

A lawyer who regularly commuted from Newtown on the Fox Chase Rapid Transit line filed a class action lawsuit against SEPTA to force the agency to keep trains running.[9] The judge who heard the case, while agreeing that SEPTA probably would not be able initially to operate a full schedule, ordered the agency to keep as much train service running as possible.[9] This resulted in limited service after January 1, 1983 on all the RDG lines and the heavily patronized PRR Paoli line.[9] Full service was gradually restored over the next several weeks.[9]

The unions then surprised SEPTA on March 15, 1983 by going on strike, still without contracts, in an action timed to coincide with an expected City Transit Division strike.[9] At the time, the City Transit Division was chafing at SEPTA for discontinuing diesel service on the Fox Chase Rapid Transit Line on January 14, 1983, as personnel were paid higher salaries for traveling a considerable distance to operate trains based in Newtown.[9] SEPTA, however, settled with the transit union shortly before its strike deadline, a move that rail unions took as a betrayal.[9] The rail unions had hoped that with both the railroads and City Transit shut down, the unions could extract whatever settlement they desired.[7] The railroad strike lasted 108 days, and service did not resume until July 3, 1983, when the last holdout union agreed to a contract to settle from the other rail unions.[9]

In the end, SEPTA would treat the unions as proper railroad workers vs. transit operators, but their pay scale remains lower than that of other Northeast commuter railroads, such as NJ Transit and the Long Island Railroad. The strike resulted in lower ridership, which took over 10 years to rebuild.

The end of diesel routes[edit]

Main article: SEPTA diesel service
Flyer produced by the Delaware Valley Association of Railroad Passengers, urging passengers to contact elected officials

SEPTA's current regional rail system is entirely run with electric-powered multiple unit cars and locomotives. This situation is unique in North America, as all other commuter rail agencies throughout the continent operate with either a combination of diesel and electric motive power, or entirely diesel trains.

Under contract to SEPTA, Conrail operated four routes throughout the 1970s on the former Reading lines. These services originated from Reading Terminal:

Most train equipment was either Budd Rail Diesel Cars, or locomotive-hauled push-pull trains with former RDG FP7s.

The Pennsylvania Department of Transportation (PennDOT) eliminated funding to operate trains that operated outside of SEPTA's service area (the 5-county region), diverting the funds instead to highway projects.[11] Coupled with the Reagan Administration's policy abolishing federal operating subsidies for mass transit,[12] SEPTA was not allowed to allocate any funding outside of the 5-county region, resulting in public hearings held during the week of January 26, 1981.

Via a flyer distributed to soon-to-be-displaced riders, the Delaware Valley Association of Railroad Passengers (DVARP) urged passengers to contact Governor Dick Thornburgh, who ordered PennDOT to eliminate train service. Thornburgh later fired PennDOT Deputy Secretary of Transportation Ed Tennyson for refusing to carry out the governor's order.[13] Tennyson stated that such a move was illegal on Thornburgh's part, as the elimination of such extensive passenger service would result in additional automobile combustion and pollution and no Environmental Impact Statement has been filed.[14]

DVARP also argued that the only reason SEPTA had to eliminate diesel service was "further reduce the number of riders using these trains so they can justify replacement bus service. A train rider is not a bus rider." DVARP added that SEPTA needed to "work out a solution to the funding problem rather than just quit! It's hard to improve a train after it's gone".[11]

Another factor was the omission of ventilation fans in the design of the Center City Commuter Tunnel that opened in 1984. DVARP advocated for the inclusion of ventilation fans that would allow diesel exhaust fumes to exit tunnels and stations. SEPTA deemed the option unfeasible throughout the planning process.[12]

DVARP later characterized the termination of the diesels as "SEPTA's worst railroad mistake."[15] The end of diesel service resulted in over 150 route miles lost, much of it through regions whose populations exploded throughout the 1980s and 1990s.[15]

Expansion and cuts in the 1980s[edit]

Crises[edit]

The 1980s and 1990s were not kind to SEPTA. While the agency has spent most of its 50-year history staggering from crisis to crisis, the 1980s were a particularly low point. The era was defined by crippling strikes, engineer shortages, drastic service cuts and an abundance of mismanagement. State and local officials, commuters, and general observers were quick to brand SEPTA as the most inept of all the major transit agencies, though getting a handle on exactly was the cause of its ills was historically difficult.[16]

Railpace Newsmagazine contributor Gerry Williams commented that understanding what routinely transpires in SEPTA upper management rarely made itself clearly known to the general public. Frequently, there were various hidden agendas working in the background, often working at cross purposes with one another. This was often the result of the City (Philadelphia)/Suburban (Bucks, Delaware, Chester, Montgomery) split. The city government has historically been Democratic, the four suburban counties Republican. This factor is regularly influenced by the changing political winds at the state capital in Harrisburg.[16]

In addition, unlike all other U.S. railroad commuter agencies which are a state agency operated as a leg of its corresponding Department of Transportation, SEPTA is not a state agency and is beholden primarily to the five local governments which comprise it. Williams questioned why there has never been any massive public push to force SEPTA to "clean up its act." He concluded that the crisis within SEPTA "merely reflects the broader problems of local provincialism and petty political squabbles which are so rampant within the region."[16] Williams later commented that "unfortunately, there does not seem to be any group out there influential enough to bring shame on SEPTA, and SEPTA just may be beyond shaming anyway."[16]

Expansion[edit]

In November 1984, the Center City Commuter Connection opened for service. The tunnel, first proposed in the 1950s, is an underground connection between PRR and RDG lines; previously, PRR commuter trains terminated at Suburban Station and RDG at Reading Terminal. The connection converted Suburban Station into a through-station and rerouted RDG trains down a steep incline and into a tunnel that turns sharply west near the new Market East Station (now Jefferson Station). The conversion was meant to increase efficiency and reduce the number of tracks needed.[7]

On April 28, 1985, the Airport Line opened, providing service from Suburban Station via 30th Street Station to Philadelphia International Airport. This line runs along Amtrak's NEC, then crosses over onto Reading tracks that pass close to the airport. At the airport, a new bridge carries it over Interstate 95 and into the airport terminals between the baggage claim in arrivals and the check-in counters in departures.[7]

Shrinking service[edit]

Dotted gray lines represent former SEPTA-sponsored Conrail commuter rail service before July 1981. The Fox Chase-Newtown section was discontinued in January 1983. The electrified West Chester and Ivy Ridge lines were truncated in 1986.

Between 1979 and 1983, diesel locomotives were phased out. With insufficient operating funds and a desire to avoid maintaining deteriorating lines, SEPTA cut various services throughout the 1980s:[17]

  • R3 West Chester service was truncated to Elwyn on September 19, 1986, due to unsatisfactory track beyond.
  • R6 Ivy Ridge service was truncated to Cynwyd on May 17, 1986, due to concerns about the Manayunk Bridge over the Schuylkill River. Service to Cynwyd ended altogether in 1988; fierce political pressure brought resumed service.
  • R8 diesel service between Fox Chase and Newtown ended on January 14, 1983, after SEPTA decided not to repair failing diesel train equipment. The service was initially terminated on July 1, 1981 (along with diesel services to Allentown and Pottsville) and reinstated on October 5, 1981, using operators from the city transit division. This experimental Fox Chase Rapid Transit Line caused a rift in unions within the organization, adding to the March 1983 strike that lasted 108 days.[18]

SEPTA management was criticized for the cuts. Vukan Vuchic, the transit expert and University of Pennsylvania professor who designed the former R-numbering system for SEPTA, said he had never seen a city the size of Philadelphia "cut transit services quite as drastically as SEPTA. For a system that is already obsolete, any more cutbacks would be disastrous—and likely spell doom for transit in the Philadelphia region."[19]

DVARP said that SEPTA purposely truncated service and that while other commuter railroad counterparts "in North America expand their rail services, SEPTA is the only one continuing to cut and cut and cut. The only difference between SEPTA and its railroad and transit predecessors is that SEPTA eliminates services to avoid rebuilding assets, while its predecessors (PRR, RDG and Conrail) kept service running while deferring maintenance."[17]

RailWorks[edit]

As a result of decades of deferred maintenance on the Reading Viaduct between the Center City Commuter Connection and Wayne Junction, SEPTA undertook a 10-month, $354 million project to overhaul the viaduct in 1992 and 1993.[9] Labeled "RailWorks" by SEPTA, the project, spurred by an emergency bridge repair project in 1984-5 shortly after the tunnel opened, resulted in the replacement of several dilapidated bridges, the installing of new continuous welded rail and overhead catenary, the construction of new rail stations at Temple University and North Broad Street, and the upgrading of signals.[9]

Built by the Reading Company in 1911 to replace street-level running north of Reading Terminal, the Reading Viaduct is a series of bridges and embankments that allows trains to run on elevated railroad tracks, separated from road traffic and pedestrians. The 1911 bridge over Columbia (now Cecil B. Moore) Avenue near Temple University was in such poor condition that the bridge inspector actually saw the structure sag every time a train passed over the bridge; further inspection revealed that the bridge was in imminent danger of collapsing.[9] The viaduct was completely shut down during each phase, with the R6 Norristown, R7 Chestnut Hill East, and R8 Fox Chase lines suspended during the shutdown.[9] Other Reading lines only came as far into the city as the Fern Rock Transportation Center, where riders had to transfer to the Broad Street Subway.[9] The number of subway trains needed to carry both regular Broad Street Subway riders, as well as passengers transferring to the subway because of RailWorks, exceeded the capacity of the above-ground two-track stub-end Fern Rock Station of the Broad Street line.[9] In 1993 a loop track was added around the Fern Rock Yard which northbound trains use to approach the station from the rear.[9] The loop avoids a switch which had caused the bottleneck.

During RailWorks, SEPTA ran several diesel trains during peak-hours from the Reading side branches, along non-electrified Conrail trackage, to 30th Street Station.[9] Upon the completion of RailWorks, the Reading Viaduct became the "newest" piece of railroad owned by SEPTA, although other projects have since allowed improved service on the ex-Reading side of the system.[9]

Original route numbering plan[edit]

The original Regional Rail plan with R1 to R7

From 1984 to 2010, the regional rail lines were numbered from R1 to R8, with the notable omission of R4. The reasons for this were rather complicated, going back to the original planning stages.

Part of the planning for the Center City Commuter Connection was to decide on how trains would be routed through the tunnel and which branches would be paired up.[9] The original plan for the system was made by University of Pennsylvania professor Vukan Vuchic, based on the S-Bahn commuter rail systems in Germany.[9] Numbers were assigned to the PRR-side lines in order from south (Airport) to northeast (Trenton), and the RDG-side matches were chosen to roughly balance ridership, to attempt to avoid trains running full on one side and then running mostly empty on the other. The following lines were recommended:[20]

  • R1 Airport to West Trenton
  • R2 Marcus Hook to Warminster
  • R3 Media/West Chester to Chestnut Hill West
  • R4 Bryn Mawr (on the same tracks as the R5 Paoli) to Fox Chase
  • R5 Paoli to Lansdale/Doylestown – express from Center City to Bryn Mawr, with R4 running local
  • R6 Ivy Ridge to Norristown
  • R7 Trenton to Chestnut Hill East

In addition to the Center City Commuter Connection, it was assumed that SEPTA would build one more connection, the Swampoodle Connection. This would allow PRR-side trains from Chestnut Hill West to join the RDG Norristown line instead of the PRR mainline at North Philadelphia station. The Chestnut Hill West line and the Norristown line run adjacent to each other at that point, in the Philadelphia neighborhood of Swampoodle. The Swampoodle Connection was never built, leading (among other factors) to the following changes:

  • R3 could not go to Chestnut Hill West, so R3 trains from Media/West Chester instead went to West Trenton along the R1. Service to Chestnut Hill West was picked up by the R8.
  • R4 was dropped; The R5 Paoli runs local along its entire length most of the time, and Fox Chase became half of the R8.
  • R8 was added for Fox Chase to Chestnut Hill West service, using the former R4-Fox Chase and R3-Chestnut Hill West halves.

One of the assumptions in this plan was that ridership would increase after the connection was open. Instead, ridership dropped after the 1983 strike. While recent rises in oil prices have resulted in increased rail ridership for daily commuters, many off-peak trains run with few riders. Pairing up the rail lines based on ridership is less relevant today than it was when the system was implemented.

At a later time, R1 was applied to the former RDG side, shared with the R2 and R5 lines to Glenside, and R3 to Jenkintown, and R1-Airport trains ran to Glenside rather than becoming R3 trains to West Trenton. In later years, SEPTA became more flexible in order to cope with differences in ridership on various lines. After the original service patterns were introduced, the following termini changed:

  • R2 – Marcus Hook was extended to Wilmington and Newark
  • R3 – West Chester was cut back to Elwyn
  • R5 – Paoli was extended to Downingtown and Parkesburg, then later cut back to Downingtown, and later re-extended to Thorndale
  • R6 – Ivy Ridge was cut back to Cynwyd

Ridership[edit]

SEPTA Regional Rail Division Ridership

When Conrail handled operations on SEPTA's behalf, overall ridership peaked in 1980 with over 373 million unlinked trips per year. The Regional Rail Division carried over 32 million passengers in 1980, a level which was not to be exceeded again for decades. Regional Rail ridership subsequently declined in 1982 after SEPTA ceased operating diesel service. It then sharply declined by half after SEPTA assumed operations in 1983, hitting a new low of just under 13 million passengers. There were several factors that contributed to this severe drop:

  • a drawn-out strike by the railroad unions
  • discontinuing service to many stations (over 60) and outlying points
  • increased fares during a period of decreasing gasoline prices increasing automobile usage
  • SEPTA management's unfamiliarity with operating a commuter railroad (a point loudly promoted by displaced Conrail employees after the 1983 takeover)

In 1992, ridership dipped again due to economic factors and due to SEPTA's RailWorks project, which shut down half of the railroad over two periods of several months each in 1992 and 1993. A mild recession in 1992–94 also dampened ridership, but a booming economy in the late 1990s helped increase ridership to near the peak level of 1980.

In 2000, ridership started a slight decline due to the slow economy, but in 2003 ridership started increasing again. The average weekday passenger counts have not increased at the same rate as the total annual passenger counts, which may mean that weekend ridership is increasing.

In 2008, Regional Rail ridership hit an all-time high of over 35 million. In 2009, it was down 1% of this high, but by fiscal year 2013 ridership reached a new high of over 36 million.[21]

The ridership on the Railroad Division per fiscal years 1979–2008:

Fiscal year Ridership [22]
1979 31,539,688
1980 32,194,460
1981 27,109,824
1982 21,826,854
1983 12,856,207
1984 15,960,307
1985 18,788,437
1986 22,522,596
1987 22,932,834
1988 23,797,289
1989 24,143,591
1990 24,381,416
1991 23,312,199
1992 21,128,888
1993 19,185,111
1994 20,875,493
1995 22,558,492
1996 22,545,896
1997 23,012,000
1998 24,805,000
1999 25,088,000
2000 29,437,000
2001 28,671,000
2002 28,300,000
2003 28,058,200
2004 28,234,986
2005 28,632,658
2006 30,433,000
2007 31,712,000
2008 35,454,000 [23]
2009 35,443,000 [24] [25]
2010 34,913,000 [24] [26]
2011 35,387,000 [24] [27]
2012 35,255,000 [24] [28]
2013 36,023,000 [29] [30]

2014 strike[edit]

On June 14, 2014, a strike shut down SEPTA's Regional Rail service after negotiations failed between SEPTA and the Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers and Trainmen and the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers. A total of 400 workers walked off the job.[31][32] As a result of the strike, SEPTA planned to add additional capacity on bus, subway, and trolley routes along with the Norristown High Speed Line during off-peak hours.[32] On the first day of the strike, Governor Tom Corbett asked President Barack Obama to appoint a presidential emergency board to attempt to end the labor dispute and force employees back to work.[32] A short time after 7 p.m. on June 14, President Obama signed an executive order forcing workers to return and continue negotiations through the presidential emergency board. SEPTA Regional Rail service resumed on June 15.[33]

Criticisms[edit]

The transfer between Conrail electric trains (left) and SEPTA RDC diesels (right) at Fox Chase Station on November 24, 1981. The Fox Chase/Newtown trains utilized City Transit personnel instead of members of the Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers and Trainmen (BLET).

"SEPTA has several techniques for sandbagging unwanted projects — raise concerns over safety, estimate costs unrealistically high, or push for rail trail conversions to stave off repeated calls for service restoration."

- Gerry Williams, Railpace Newsmagazine columnist[34]

Transit mindset[edit]

SEPTA made it clear they were, at best, a reluctant railroad operator following the withdrawal of Conrail from regional rail operations in 1983. The regional rail network is viewed as a stepchild within the SEPTA organization, which explained the lengthy delays associated with the opening the Center City tunnel and Airport line.[16] SEPTA never wanted to get directly involved in railroad operations, with upper management historically viewing the regional rail division as a competitor rather than an ally of city-based operations (subway, trolley, etc.). SEPTA management also continues to willfully have little understanding of traditional railroad operations or ridership trends.[35]

In 1998, DVARP commented that SEPTA tends to view its commuter rail operations in transit terms rather than something different. Indeed, stations on SEPTA's regional rail lines tend to be closer together than stations on systems belonging to SEPTA's counterparts such as Metra, New Jersey Transit, MARC Train, Virginia Railway Express and Metro-North Railroad. Coupled with short route mileage of most lines, no onboard bathrooms, and the lack of diesel trains serving stations outside of SEPTA's electrified territory gives the railroad division more of an interurban feel and look than a traditional commuter operation.[35]

The operation of the dormant Fox Chase-Newtown segment of the Fox Chase Line as a transit operation from 1981–1983—utilizing City Transit personnel instead of members of the Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers and Trainmen (BLET)—was the most notable example of "transitizing" (i.e. lower pay scale, frequent headways) a traditional railroad line.[36]

In the late 1990s, SEPTA resisted the commuter rail model used throughout North America when designing the Schuylkill Valley Metro project, initially preferring a light rail alternative for the 62-mile (100 km) line and then shifting to an unprecedented "Metrorail" model when fatal flaws were found in the light rail plan. DVARP called SEPTA's notion of bypassing traditional commuter rail "radical."[37] SEPTA's bias against conventional commuter rail on shared track — long the standard operating scenario for all other commuter railroads in North America — forced project costs over $2 billion and led to the rejection by the Federal Transit Administration as being too costly.[38]

Prior to the 1983 takeover of commuter operations, SEPTA considered running the former RDG side of the system from traditional railroad operations to transit-type operations, but dismissed it as unfeasible for the short term.[35] If converted to a transit-like operation, the regional rail system would operate outside of the U.S. railroad network, freeing it from most railroad-oriented federal regulations, including railroad work rules, federal safety equipment inspection requirements, and Railroad Retirement.[35]

Rail trails[edit]

Beginning in 2005, SEPTA began an aggressive campaign to rid themselves of maintaining derelict railroad lines under their ownership by leasing them to local townships or counties for use as interim recreational trails. SEPTA still retains the right to convert the leased trail back to active railroads should the need arise.[39] Rail proponents, such as the Pennsylvania Transit Expansion Coalition (PA-TEC) commented in 2010 that the trails were hastily constructed — such as the Pennypack Trail Extension (gravel vs. pavement, single access points) — in order to erase any presence of a railway.[39] As of 2014, the following former routes are acting as interim rail trails:

Rail line Trackage type Former stations affected Township Dismantled Electrified/Diesel Trail name Length Service suspension date Notes
Fox Chase/Newtown single Walnut Hill, Huntingdon Valley (planned), Bryn Athyn (planned), Woodmont (planned) Abington Township, Lower Moreland Township (planned) June 2008/Summer 2014 (planned) Diesel Pennypack Trail Extension 6.37 mi (10.3 km) All remaining trackage within Montgomery County was removed during Summer 2014[40][41]
Cynwyd double Barmouth, Manayunk East, Ivy Ridge Lower Merion Township June 2009 – June 2010 Electric Cynwyd Heritage Trail[42]
Ivy Ridge Trail[43]
3.5 mi (5.6 km) October 25, 1986
Bethlehem/Quakertown double Coopersburg, Center Valley, Hellertown, Bethlehem Lower Saucon,
Upper Saucon
October 2008 Diesel Saucon Rail Trail[44][45] 8.9 mi (14.3 km) July 1, 1981
Chester Creek single Lenni, Knowlton, Chester Transportation Center Middletown Township TBD Diesel Chester Creek Rail Trail[46][47] 9.5 mi (15.3 km) June 1972 SEPTA did not operate passenger trains on this line. Trains were last operated by the Penn Central in June 1972. Ownership on the line transferred to SEPTA in 1978 for railbanking purposes
All of SEPTA's suspended commuter lines were converted in some form to trails starting in 2008. Walnut Hill Station site along Fox Chase/Newtown Line, now the site of the Pennypack Trail Extension.
Cynwyd Line: high-level station (one of SEPTA's few) at Ivy Ridge.
Bethlehem/Quakertown line in Center Valley, Pennsylvania after trackage removal for the Saucon Rail Trail.

As traffic congestion in the Delaware Valley grew throughout the 1990s, resuming passenger service on SEPTA's unused lines was seen as a tool to battle the trend.[9] No other transit agency in North American has converted their unused rail lines into trails in the capacity that SEPTA has.[48] Public transit advocates—most notably PA-TEC—voiced their opposition in 2011 to the removal of the tracks as there are no notable instances in the U.S. of a rail trail converting back to rails.[39][48]

Suggestions by PA-TEC to convert the lines into rails with trails were seen by SEPTA officials as a safety hazard,[48] despite no documented safety issues by the U.S. Department of Transportation or Federal Railroad Administration.[49] The Bicycle Coalition of Greater Philadelphia also agreed that while trails serve a good purpose, "there is sufficient right-of-way available to support both future rail service and maintain trail usage. If there is insufficient right-of-way within the corridor to do both, then a relocation or rerouting of the trail to preserve the non-motorized route is necessary."[50]

John Pawson, author of Delaware Valley Rails: The Railroads and Rail Transit Lines of the Philadelphia Area questioned in 2010 why SEPTA is heavily involved with rail trails instead of public transit. Pawson, who was head of the Delaware Valley Regional Planning Commission Regional Citizens Committee until February 2011, stated that the creation of the Pennypack Trail on the Fox Chase/Newtown line is a "relatively cheap and quick process" but that "cheapness is its only advantage."[51] Pawson added that "the trail as built essentially runs from nowhere to nowhere. A relatively high-grade piece of infrastructure has been diverted (temporarirly, one would hope) to a relatively low-grade purpose. It's like taking over an expressway to use for someone's driveway."[51] Pawson concluded by saying "there is no need to pull up any more track. This real creek-side Pennypack Trail through Montgomery County and the restoration of the rail line in that county and beyond could be considered as a single valid political issue. Various groups including rail and trail proponents and others should work together for a joint project."[51]

Timeline[edit]

  • 1966: SEPTA begins contracts with the Pennsylvania Railroad and the Reading Company to subsidize commuter lines.
  • 1974–1976: SEPTA orders and takes delivery of Silverliner IV M.U.s
  • 1976: Conrail takes over bankrupt railroads and continues providing commuter services for SEPTA.
  • 1979: Diesel service between Bethlehem-Allentown is discontinued.[9] R2 Naamans Road Station closes.
  • 1980: 52nd Street Station closes. Service extended from Cynwyd to new high-level station at Ivy Ridge.
  • July 1, 1981: Diesel service from Fox Chase-Newtown, Quakertown-Bethlehem and Norristown-Pottstown/Reading/Pottsville is discontinued due lack of funding from PennDOT, approved by Governor Dick Thornburgh.[9] R2 Baldwin Station closes. R5 Exton Station opens. Fares increased.
  • July 29, 1981: Lansdale-Quakertown diesel shuttle discontinued.[9]
  • October 5, 1981: Diesel service between Fox Chase-Newtown resumes as the Fox Chase Rapid Transit Line.[9]
  • January 1, 1983: SEPTA assumes full operation of commuter lines from Conrail.[9]
  • January 14, 1983: Diesel service from Fox Chase-Newtown—SEPTA's last diesel operated line—is discontinued due to failing train equipment; service replaced with busses until electrification is completed (as of 2010, electrification has not occurred).[9] R5 Downingtown Station opens. R8 Westmoreland Station closes.
  • March 15, 1983: BLET calls a strike that lasts 108 days.
  • July 3, 1983: Strike ends: normal rail service resumes.
  • November 6, 1984: Service to Reading Terminal ends in anticipation of the opening of the Center City Commuter Connection six days later.[52]
  • November 12, 1984: The Center City Commuter Connection opens.[52]
  • November 16, 1984: The Columbia Avenue (now Cecil B. Moore Avenue) bridge near old Temple University Station found to be unsafe, putting all four tracks out of service north of Market East Station.[52]
  • December 1984: Temporary bridge opens, allowing service to resume north of Market East Station.[52]
  • April 28, 1985: R1 service to Philadelphia International Airport begins.[52]
  • May 17, 1986: R6 service between Cynwyd-Ivy Ridge is discontinued.[9]
  • September 16, 1986: R3 service between Elwyn-West Chester is discontinued.[9]
  • 1990: R5 service extended from Downingtown to Coatesville and Parkesburg.
  • 1990: Reading-era "Blueliner" and PRR-era Pioneer III/Silverliner I M.U.s retired.
  • March 12, 1992: New Fern Rock Station opens, replacing both the old Fern Rock and Tabor stations.
  • 1992: First phase of RailWorks, a project to reconstruct several bridges and viaducts on the former Reading Company's main line in North Philadelphia, shuts down the railroad between Market East and Fern Rock stations for six months.
  • 1992–1996: Fellwick, Fishers, Fulmor, and Shawmont Stations close.
  • May 2, 1993: Second and last phase of Railworks begins.
  • September 9, 1993: Second and last phase of Railworks ends.
  • November 10, 1996: R5 service to Parkesburg is truncated to Downingtown.
  • March 21, 1997: Parking added to Exton Station, adding 116 spaces at a cost of $300,000.
  • 1997: Eastwick Station opens on the R1 Airport line.
  • 2002: SEPTA announces the planned building of 104 new "Silverliner V" m.u. cars to replace aging Budd-built "Silverliner II" and St. Louis Company-built "Silverliner III" cars. New cars, identical to the GE-built "Silverliner IV" cars, will have wider seats and a center-opening door for easier boarding or departing at high-level platform stations in Center City.
  • 2003: R2 Lamokin and R7 Wissinoming stations close.
  • 2006: SEPTA approves contract for Hyundai Rotem to build 104 new "Silverliner V" cars. SEPTA also started negotiations with Wawa Food Markets to purchase land in Wawa, Pennsylvania to build a new Park-and-Ride facility for a planned restoration of service between Elwyn and Wawa on Media/Elwyn Line.
  • July 2008: all track in Abington Township section of former Fox Chase-Newtown line is removed for Pennypack Trail Extension.
  • October 2008: all track between Coopersburg and Hellertown section of former Quakertown-Bethlehem line is removed for Saucon Valley Rail Trail.
  • June 2009: all track between Cynwyd and Pencoyd Viaduct section of former Cynwyd-Ivy Ridge line is removed for Cynwyd Heritage Trail.[42]
  • February 2010: First three Silverliner V cars arrive in Philadelphia, as well as nine shells to be assembled at the Hyundai Rotem plant.
  • June 2010: all track between Pencoyd Viaduct and Ivy Ridge Station along former Cynwyd-Ivy Ridge line is removed for Ivy Ridge Trail.[43]
  • July 25, 2010: R-numbering system is dropped and each branch is named after its primary termini.[53]
  • October 29, 2010: First set of Silverliner V cars begin revenue service, following a press event at Suburban Station.[54]
  • June 14, 2014: BLET calls a strike that lasts less than 24 hours before a PEB is implemented.[55]
  • July-September 2014: all track in Lower Moreland Township section of former Fox Chase-Newtown line is removed for Pennypack Trail Extension.

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ 2008 SEPTA Railroad Division employee timetable accessed August 16, 2011
  2. ^ "SEPTA to Change Regional Rail designations". PlanPhilly. 3 February 2010. Retrieved 5 March 2010. 
  3. ^ septa.org/reports
  4. ^ a b "SEPTA's new railcar model makes inaugural trip". The Philadelphia Inquirer. 30 October 2010. Retrieved 3 November 2010. 
  5. ^ a b "SEPTA unveils first Silverliner V train". Progressive Railroading. 3 November 2010. Retrieved 3 November 2010. 
  6. ^ a b c Philadelphia Transit Vehicles: Regional Rail roster
  7. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Drury, George H. (1992). The Train-Watcher's Guide to North American Railroads: A Contemporary Reference to the Major railroads of the U.S., Canada and Mexico. Waukesha, Wisconsin: Kalmbach Publishing. pp. 19, 150, 201–202, 267. ISBN 0-89024-131-7. 
  8. ^ This is uncommon today; the vast majority of American households use double-phase, 60 Hz alternating current.
  9. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z aa ab ac ad ae af ag ah ai aj ak al am Williams, Gerry (1998). Trains, Trolleys and Transit: A Guide to Philadelphia Area Rail Transit. Piscataway, New Jersey: Railpace Company, Inc. pp. 13–16, 46–47, 95–98. ISBN 0-9621541-7-2. 
  10. ^ Pawson, John R. (1979). Delaware Valley Rails: The Railroads and Rail Transit Lines of the Philadelphia Area. Willow Grove, Pennsylvania: John R. Pawson. p. 52. ISBN 0-9602080-0-3. 
  11. ^ a b DVARP flyer "SEPTA is Giving You the Boot", January 1981
  12. ^ a b phillytrolley.org
  13. ^ pentrans.org/tennyson
  14. ^ "SEPTA and DVRPC Giving the 'Boot' to Citizens that speak Truth to Corrupt Power"
  15. ^ a b Pawson, John (January 1993). "SEPTA Regional Rail: Progress in 10 years?". The Delaware Valley Association of Railroad Passengers. 
  16. ^ a b c d e Williams, Gerry (September 1984). "SEPTA Scene". Railpace Newsmagazine (Piscataway, New Jersey: Railpace Company, Inc.) 4 (9): 16–18. 
  17. ^ a b Mitchell, Matthew (April 1992). "SEPTA Budget for Fiscal 1993: Continued Rail Retrenchment". The Delaware Valley Association of Railroad Passengers. 
  18. ^ Newtown Branch history
  19. ^ Hyland, Tim (2004-12-09). "SEPTA in need of new ideas, more funding". Penn Current. Retrieved 2010-10-26. 
  20. ^ pennways.com/[unreliable source]
  21. ^ SEPTA | SEPTA Sets New Record For Regional Rail Ridership
  22. ^ SEPTA 1997 Ridership Census, Annual Service Plans FY 2001 through 2007.
  23. ^ FY 2008 SEPTA annual report
  24. ^ a b c d PEW Charitable Trusts Philadelphia 2013: The State of the City
  25. ^ "FY 2009 SEPTA annual report". SEPTA. Retrieved 14 October 2014. 
  26. ^ "FY 2010 SEPTA annual report". SEPTA. Retrieved 13 October 2014. 
  27. ^ "FY 2011 SEPTA annual report". SEPTA. Retrieved 13 October 2014. 
  28. ^ "FY 2012 SEPTA annual report". SEPTA. Retrieved 13 October 2014. 
  29. ^ Sarah Glover, "SEPTA Sets Regional Rail Ridership Record"
  30. ^ "FY 2013 SEPTA annual report". SEPTA. Retrieved 13 October 2014. 
  31. ^ Mulvihill, Geoff (June 14, 2014). "SEPTA Commuter Rail Union on Strike". WCAU (Philadephia, Pennsylvania: NBC10.com). Retrieved June 14, 2014. 
  32. ^ a b c Nussbaum, Paul (June 14, 2014). "Regional Rail strike begins; Corbett to seek federal help". The Philadelphia Inquirer. Retrieved June 15, 2014. 
  33. ^ Dougherty, Mike, Jan Carabeo, and Andrew Kramer (June 14, 2014). "Obama Intervenes As SEPTA Regional Rail Strike Ends, Service Resumes Sunday". Philadelphia: KYW-TV. Retrieved June 15, 2014. 
  34. ^ Williams, Gerry (August 2008). "SEPTA Scene". Railpace Newsmagazine (Picataway, New Jersey: Railpace Company, Inc.) 7 (8): 49. 
  35. ^ a b c d Williams, Gerry (August 1998). "SEPTA Scene". Railpace Newsmagazine. 
  36. ^ Woodland, Dale W. (December 2003). "SEPTA's Diesels". Railpace Newsmagazine. 
  37. ^ Wimp, Marilyn (1998-03-20). "Study: Ridership there for rail project: Nonprofit group labels the SEPTA proposal 'radical'". Philadelphia Business Journal. Retrieved 2011-06-09. 
  38. ^ "Rail link to Philadelphia won't occur, Rendell says". Reading Eagle. 2006-08-24. 
  39. ^ a b c SEPTA Trail Signage letter
  40. ^ Nussbaum, Paul (March 23, 2014). "Montco plans to convert more of rail line for recreation". Philadelphia Inquirer. Retrieved April 21, 2014. 
  41. ^ http://www.septa.org/about/board/agenda-12-10-13.pdf SEPTA Board meeting minutes; December 10, 2013
  42. ^ a b Cynwyd Heritage Trail
  43. ^ a b Ivy Ridge Green
  44. ^ "Ribbon Cut on Saucon Rail Trail"
  45. ^ Saucon Rail Trail update 2010
  46. ^ chestercreektrail.org
  47. ^ delcotimes.com
  48. ^ a b c PA-TEC discussion SEPTA's rail trails
  49. ^ "Rails-with-Trails: Lessons Learned, U.S. Department of Transportation"
  50. ^ Bicycle Coalition's Position on SEPTA rail trail initiative
  51. ^ a b c dvrpc.org
  52. ^ a b c d e pennways.com[unreliable source]
  53. ^ Lustig, David (November 2010). "SEPTA makeover". Trains Magazine (Kalmbach Publishing): 26. 
  54. ^ septa.org/Silverliner V
  55. ^ "Obama Intervenes in SEPTA strike". 2014-06-14. 

Further reading[edit]

  • Pawson, John R. (1979). Delaware Valley Rails: The Railroads and Rail Transit Lines of the Philadelphia Area. Pawson. ISBN 0-9602080-0-3. 

External links[edit]

Route map: Google / Bing