Canada–Holy See relations
Although the Roman Catholic Church has been territorially established in Canada since the founding of New France in the early 17th century, Holy See–Canada relations were only officially established during the pontificate of Pope Paul VI in 1969.
In part, this is because the Holy See had lost its territorial sovereignty over the Papal States during the pontificate of Pope Pius IX and that territorial sovereignty over Vatican City State was only established by the Lateran Treaty of 1929. Also, relations with neighbouring Italy were poor during the Mussolini regime and were only re-established in the post-1945 era.
Areas of cooperation between Ottawa and Rome have traditionally included education, health care, the struggle against poverty and international diplomacy. Before the establishment of the welfare state, Church involvement was evident in many sectors of Canadian society. Today, Canada's international preoccupations in favor of justice and peace are often in line with those of Rome which favors dialogue on a global level.
Pope John Paul II was the first pope to visit Canada in 1984 and re-visted Canada in 1987 and 2002.
17th and 18th centuries
After the British conquest of 1759, relations with Rome were temporarily frozen and Jesuits were forbidden from entering the country. However, religious tolerance was quickly re-established under the 1774 Quebec Act, owing to the anti-American sentiment of colonial administrators. Before the 1774 Quebec Act, Lower Canada's remaining bishops began to die as they succumbed to old age, and new bishops and cardinals were blocked from entering by British Administrators. After the last death in 1768, the British colonial governor reversed his decision and began to allow limited numbers of Catholic Administrator to enter, paving the way for the Quebec Act 1774. As a result of the religious freedoms it granted to Catholics, Colonial Americans in the 13 colonies (because of their anti-Catholic stance) labeled it as one of the "Intolerable Acts" an influence to the start of the American Revolution.
John A. Macdonald, Canada's first prime minister, is thought to have had problematic relations with the Church, as it was manifest by the anger of many Catholics against Macdonald during the Louis Riel affair, a conflict which had many sectarian undertones.
In the 19th century, Pope Leo XIII did have an apostolic delegation and did send diplomatic envoys to important socio-political events. Pope Leo took a strong interest in Canadian affairs and wrote the encyclical Affari Vos on the Manitoba Schools Question.
Wilfrid Laurier, Canada's first francophone prime minister, had genuinely good relations with Pope Pius X, and during his time as PM the Church went though a relatively prosperous period in terms of vocations and social influence.
Pierre Trudeau, another Quebec Catholic PM, was raised as a strict Catholic, but later cooled to the institution after the publication of Humanae Vitae in 1968. After 1968, Trudeau passed a number of liberal laws on divorce, adultery, homosexuality and abortion, laws which have profoundly liberalized and secularized Canadian society.
Governors General of Canada have sometimes been very Catholic. Jules Léger was the brother of Cardinal Paul-Émile Léger. Jeanne Sauvé was a former member of the Catholic Action movement. Georges Vanier was a servant of God who has been proposed for beatification.
In practice, abortion was only completely legalized under the government of Conservative Catholic Brian Mulroney, who personally objected to it but could not prevent a 1988 Supreme Court decision removing all previous restrictions to the procedure.
Canada and the Holy See have split over civil rights and moral issues in the 21st century, with nationwide recognition of same-sex marriage in Canada, along with other progressive legislation which stands contrary to the Catholic Church's position.
Stephen Harper is said to have played on this dissatisfaction with Catholic voters in the 2006 election, and managed to win the Catholic vote, something that other Protestant PMs were not always able to do.
In the Provinces of Ontario, New Brunswick and to a now more limited extent Quebec the "Catholic Vote" is seen as a key demographic. In the 2007 Ontario general election the Progressive Conservatives under John Tory lost the Catholic vote when, during campaign he suggested giving public funding to non-Catholic faith-based schools. In Ontario, only Public and Catholic school receive public funding. His party never recovered from this grave mistake, gaining only two additional seats (from 24 to 26) in the Ontario legislature, and failed to win the election.
According to the 2001 Canadian Census, 43.6% of all Canadians identify themselves as Catholic (This includes Roman Catholics, Eastern Catholics, the Polish National Catholic Church, and Old Catholics).
- Ciani, Adriano Ercole. "The Establishment of Diplomatic Relations Between Canada and the Holy See, 1945-1969 (MA Thesis, University of New Brunswick, 2005)