Jump to content

Wikipedia:Naming conventions (Chinese): Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
→‎Political NPOV: edited to be inclusive of different views from talk
Line 273: Line 273:
Wikipedia entries should avoid taking sides on controversial sovereignty issues such as the status of Taiwan and Tibet. Although the [[United Nations]] and most sovereign states in the world have recognized the People's Republic of China as the sole government of China, Wikipedia should reflect the neutral reality and not use the term "China" to coincide with any particular state or government. In particular, the word "China" should not be used to be synonymously with areas under the current administration of the [[People's Republic of China]] or with [[Mainland China]]. As a general rule of thumb, the official political terms "People's Republic of China" or "PRC" and "Republic of China" or "ROC" should be used in political contexts (i.e., to describe the existing regimes or governments) rather than the imprecise and politically charged terms "China" and "Taiwan." For example, "[[Hu Jintao]] is the [[President of the People's Republic of China]]" is preferred over "Hu Jintao is the President of China." Likewise, one should write "one must be an ROC citizen to vote in the ROC presidential election" as opposed to "one must be a Taiwanese citizen to vote in the Taiwanese presidential election."
Wikipedia entries should avoid taking sides on controversial sovereignty issues such as the status of Taiwan and Tibet. Although the [[United Nations]] and most sovereign states in the world have recognized the People's Republic of China as the sole government of China, Wikipedia should reflect the neutral reality and not use the term "China" to coincide with any particular state or government. In particular, the word "China" should not be used to be synonymously with areas under the current administration of the [[People's Republic of China]] or with [[Mainland China]]. As a general rule of thumb, the official political terms "People's Republic of China" or "PRC" and "Republic of China" or "ROC" should be used in political contexts (i.e., to describe the existing regimes or governments) rather than the imprecise and politically charged terms "China" and "Taiwan." For example, "[[Hu Jintao]] is the [[President of the People's Republic of China]]" is preferred over "Hu Jintao is the President of China." Likewise, one should write "one must be an ROC citizen to vote in the ROC presidential election" as opposed to "one must be a Taiwanese citizen to vote in the Taiwanese presidential election."


Taiwan should not be described either as an independent nation or as a part of the People's Republic of China. Wikipedia should merely state the ''de facto'' situation that Taiwan is administered by a government/state/regime called the "Republic of China." When it is necessary to describe the [[political status of Taiwan]], special note should be made of Taiwan's complex position. Thus, the term "Taiwan" is used only when referring to the island. Furthermore, the term "province of Taiwan" can be offensive and should only be used when attributed to its source or referring specifically to the existing division under the ROC (e.g. "[[James Soong]] was the only popularly elected governor of [[Taiwan Province]]").
Taiwan should not be described either as de jure independent or as a part of the People's Republic of China. Wikipedia should merely state the ''de facto'' situation that Taiwan is an independent state currently administered by the "Republic of China." It should be noted that Taiwan and ROC are not necessarily equivalent with: 1) The PRC viewing the ROC as a defeated and illegitimate regime and 2) Some Taiwanese independence supporters arguing that the ROC is illegitimate and that a new Republic of Taiwan should be established. When it is necessary to describe the [[political status of Taiwan]], special note should be made of Taiwan's complex position. Thus, the term "Taiwan" is used when referring to the place while the ROC is used when referring to the government. Furthermore, the term "province of Taiwan" can be offensive and should only be used when attributed to its source or referring specifically to the existing division under the ROC (e.g. "[[James Soong]] was the only popularly elected governor of [[Taiwan Province]]").


For organizations and international events, such as the [[Olympic Games]] or [[APEC]], official terms should be used. In the case of the Olympics, one refers to the [[Chinese Taipei]] team, instead of the "Taiwanese team" or the "ROC team." Special care should be taken to put these terms in context - the "China" team in the 1952 Olympics, for example, should not be called the "Chinese Taipei" team as the latter term did not exist yet.
For organizations and international events, such as the [[Olympic Games]] or [[APEC]], official terms should be used. In the case of the Olympics, one refers to the [[Chinese Taipei]] team, instead of the "Taiwanese team" or the "ROC team." Special care should be taken to put these terms in context - the "China" team in the 1952 Olympics, for example, should not be called the "Chinese Taipei" team as the latter term did not exist yet.
Line 282: Line 282:
Also note that there are potential landmines when using the term "Chinese." In particular, some find a distinction between "Chinese" and "Tibetans" or between "Chinese" and "Taiwanese" to be objectionable and the terms "[[Han Chinese]]"/"Tibetans" and "Mainland Chinese"/"Taiwanese" are more politically neutral and use will depend on the context. For example, "Mainland Chinese businessmen look forward to meeting their Taiwanese counterparts" is more accurate and acceptable than with the word "Mainland" left out.
Also note that there are potential landmines when using the term "Chinese." In particular, some find a distinction between "Chinese" and "Tibetans" or between "Chinese" and "Taiwanese" to be objectionable and the terms "[[Han Chinese]]"/"Tibetans" and "Mainland Chinese"/"Taiwanese" are more politically neutral and use will depend on the context. For example, "Mainland Chinese businessmen look forward to meeting their Taiwanese counterparts" is more accurate and acceptable than with the word "Mainland" left out.


The term "Mainlander" poses some issues. It is sometimes ambiguous whether this is refering to a resident of Mainland China or a member of the group that fled with the KMT to Taiwan in 1949. In refering to the latter group, the name is mildly objectionable when used in English and strongly objectionable when translated literally in Chinese. Preferred unambigous names for the two groups are "mainland Chinese" and "wai sheng ren".
The term "Mainlander" poses some issues. It is used both when refering to a resident of Mainland China or a member of the group that fled with the KMT to Taiwan in 1949. In refering to the latter group, the name is mildly objectionable when used in English and strongly objectionable when translated literally in Chinese. Preferred unambigous names for the two groups are "mainland Chinese" and "wai sheng ren".


Hakka is the preferred name for that group even though the Mandarin word for that is something completely different phonetically.
Hakka is the preferred name for that group even though the Mandarin word for that is something completely different phonetically.

Revision as of 18:47, 24 March 2005

These guidelines mainly deal with the systematic naming of China-related articles. Please follow the conventions below. If you disagree with any of the conventions, please discuss in the talk page. Also

Please refer to the talk page for discussion before setting these conventions as standards.


Characters

Any encyclopedia entries whose titles is a Chinese names SHOULD include both the Chinese characters and the Hanyu Pinyin representation for its name in the first sentence.

Chinese characters on the English Wikipedia should be encoded using HTML entities with Unicode numbers. Big5 and GB encoded characters are acceptable as a draft for people who have no other means of entering characters but should be converted to Unicode in HTML character entities when it is possible. After a Chinese text has been converted to Unicode, the Big5 or GB versions should be removed.

Romanization

Main discussion: Talk:Transcription of Chinese

Romanization presents some difficult issues in that it is a highly political issue. The most often used romanization is pinyin. Though many outside of the People's Republic of China dislike it because of its association with that government, pinyin is the most standard way of romanizing Mandarin Chinese words.

In general, Chinese entries should be in Hanyu Pinyin except when there is a more popularly used form in English (such as Taoism) or when the subject of the entry is likely to object to romanization in pinyin. When an entry is not in pinyin form, there should be a redirect to the article from the pinyin form.

Apostrophes

Apostrophes are crucial in both Hanyu Pinyin and Wade-Giles.

The Library of Congress Guidelinesgive the following rules for using the apostrophe in Hanyu Pinyin:

  1. Whenever a syllable begins with "a", "o", or "e", and follows another syllable: Bei'an (北安), Chang'e (嫦娥), Jian'ou (建瓯).
  2. Whenever a syllable ends with "-n" and the next syllable begins with "g-": Jian'guo (建国).

However, the second rule isn't consistently applied on Wikipedia or elsewhere. For example, Anguo gives many more results than An'guo on Google. For now, just follow the first rule, and ignore the second. Discussion is welcome on the talk page.

Don't use the apostrophe in any other case: Henan (河南).

Hyphens

Copied from talk page

According to the Library of Congress Guidelines for Hanyu Pinyin:

Names

Personal names in Chinese, unlike Western names, present the family/clan name first. Unlike other instances where this occurs, it is standard practice in English to also present a Chinese name last name first (e.g., Mao Zedong, Deng Xiaoping). Chinese names should be in Hanyu Pinyin unless there is a more common name used in English (e.g., Chiang Kai-shek, Sun Yat-sen) or when the subject of the article is likely to prefer a non-pinyin phonetization as is likely the case with personages from Taiwan, Hong Kong, etc. (i.e. Lee Teng-hui, Tung Chee Hwa).

The encyclopedia should reference the name more familar to most English readers. For most historical figures the means that encyclopedia entry should reference the Chinese name rather than the English name, with a redirect from the English name. However, there are exceptions for figures whose English name is more familar (e.g. Confucius) and for figures who were raised in non-Chinese societies and whose Chinese names are unfamilar (e.g. Vera Wang and Maya Lin).

Another special case is for a figure whose Chinese name is familar but used English ordering (e.g. Wen Ho Lee). In this case, the primary entry should be under the English ordering with a redirect from the Chinese ordering.

When using pinyin for a Chinese name, pinyin spacing and capitalization conventions should be used. This includes keeping the last name separate and the given name capitalized with the different characters not indicated by spacing, hyphenization, or capitalization. There should be no space between the first and second given names. There are suitations when two pinyin syllables are joined together, they become ambiguous e.g. jingao can be jing ao or jin gao; xian can be xian or xi an. The pinyin convention adds a ' symbol to resolve ambiguity, e.g. jin'gao vs jing'ao. When using Wade-Giles, a dash should be put between the first and last given names, and the second given name should not be capitalised. (e.g. Lee Teng-hui, not Lee Teng Hui)

Names of groups

The main entry for a Chinese group should be under the name most familar to English speakers. In some cases, this will be the translated name (e.g. Communist Party of China). In other cases, this will be the transliterated name (Kuomintang and Falun Gong). When the name is transliterated, the name should use the spelling conventionally used by English speakers (e.g. Kuomintang). Where this is not the pinyin transliteration there should be a link from the article from the pinyin name.

When a group uses a translated name, the Chinese characters should always be included. For example, this is especially needed in the entry for President of the People's Republic of China because the name used for President (zhuxi) is not the standard term used for President.

Similarly Chinese characters should be included for the Democratic Progressive Party because the standard term used for the party (min-jin-dang) is a contraction of the full name (min-zhu jin-bu dang). Characters should also be included for National People's Congress because there are a number of different Chinese terms to translate Congress, and the entry should identify which one is used.

Names of emperors

Please see Wikipedia:History standards for China-related articles.

The general principle is to use the name which is most familar to Chinese readers. This violates the Wikipedia principle that the name most familiar to English readers should be used, because English readers are not usually familiar with any of the emperors.

Summary of principles used:

  1. Emperors before the Tang dynasty: use posthumous names, e.g. Emperor Wu of Han China (漢武帝)
  2. Emperors between Tang dynasty and Ming dynasty: use temple names, e.g. Emperor Taizong of Tang China (唐太宗)
  3. Emperors of the Ming and Qing dynasty: use era names (same as reign names), e.g. Kangxi Emperor (康熙帝)

The above is a rough guide and there are many exceptions. See Table of Chinese monarchs for a complete list of all Chinese monarchs, and follow the conventions given there.

Because these are reign names are not personal names, the correct phrasing for emperors of the Ming and Qing dynasty is the "Kangxi Emperor" rather than "Emperor Kangxi".

Place names

Mainland China place names should be in Hanyu Pinyin. Place names in Hong Kong, Macau, Taiwan, and overseas (e.g. Singapore) should be romanized in whatever way is commonly used for those places. Same goes for non-Han Chinese place names. So use Hohhot, Kashgar, and Shigatse, not Huhehaote, Kashi, and Rikaze. (呼和浩特、喀什、日喀则)

These conventions are guidelines only, and there are examples of exceptions, so please use your discretion. As always, all discussion is welcome on the talk page.

Topographical

Type char. Normal Disambiguate
by location by type
Mountain Range
山脉 山脈
1 Qinling Mountains 秦岭 no example yet no example yet
>1 Taihang Mountains 太行山
Daxingan Mountains 大兴安岭
no example yet no example yet
Mountain Peak
山峰
1 Mount Taishan 泰山 Mount Hengshan (Shanxi) 恒山 Mount Huangshan 黄山
Mount Hengshan (Hunan) 衡山 Huangshan City 黄山市
>1 Mount Emei 峨嵋山
Mount Wutai 五台山
no example yet Mount Wuzhi 五指山
Wuzhishan City 五指山市
River 河流 1 Huaihe River 淮河
Xiangjiang River 湘江
Minjiang River (Sichuan) 岷江 Lijiang River 漓江
Minjiang River (Fujian) 闽江 Lijiang 丽江市
>1 Jinsha River 金沙江 no example yet Mudan River 牡丹江
Mudanjiang 牡丹江市
Lake 湖泊 1 Lake Taihu 太湖 Lake Tianchi (Changbai) 长白山天池 Lake Chaohu 巢湖
Lake Tianchi (Tianshan) 天山天池 Chaohu City 巢湖市
>1 Lake Hongze 洪泽湖 no example yet Lake Poyang 鄱阳湖
Poyang County 鄱阳县

Jurisdictional

Type char. Normal Disambiguate
by location by type
Province 省 >1 Zhejiang 浙江省
Rehe 热河省
no example yet Heilongjiang 黑龙江省
Heilong River 黑龙江
Aut. Region 自治区 >1 Ningxia 宁夏回族自治区 no example yet Tibet Autonomous Region 西藏自治区
Tibet 藏区 / 吐蕃 (see Talk:Tibet)
Municipality / City
(plc / clc / pc / ccc)
直辖、地级、县级市
直轄、省轄、縣轄市
>1 Beijing 北京市
Nanjing 南京市
Yiwu 义乌市
ROC: Taipei 台北市
ROC: Keelung 基隆市
ROC: Banciau 板橋市
Yichun, Heilongjiang 伊春市 Jilin City 吉林市
Yichun, Jiangxi 宜春市 Jilin 吉林省
League / Banner
盟旗
>1 Yeke Juu League 伊克昭盟
Harqin Banner 喀喇沁旗
no example yet Naiman Banner 奈曼旗
Naiman (people) 奈曼部
(Aut.) Prefecture
地区 / 自治州
>1 Haidong Prefecture 海东地区
Yanbian Korean Autonomous Prefecture 延边朝鲜族自治州
no example yet Shigatse Prefecture 日喀则地区
Shigatse 日喀则市
(Aut.) County
县 / 自治县
1 Pan County 盘县 She County, Anhui 歙县 no example yet
She County, Hebei 涉县
>1 Fugou County 扶沟县
Dachang Hui Autonomous County 大厂回族自治县
ROC: Hsinchu County 新竹縣
no example yet Poyang County 鄱阳县
Lake Poyang 鄱阳湖
District 区 區 1 Dongqu District, Panzhihua 攀枝花市东区 Jiaoqu District, Jiamusi 佳木斯市郊区 no example yet
Jiaoqu District, Yangquan 阳泉市郊区
>1 Chongwen District 崇文区
but also: Pudong 浦东新区
ROC: Beitou 北投區
Chaoyang District, Beijing 北京市朝阳区 Hebei District 天津市河北区
Chaoyang District, Changchun 长春市朝阳区 Hebei 河北省
Town / Township
乡镇
鄉鎮
>1 Zhouzhuang Town 周庄镇
Chengguan Town, Fugou County 扶沟县城关镇 Huairou Town 怀柔镇
Chengguan Town, Taikang County 太康县城关镇 Huairou District 怀柔区

Historical

Type char. Normal Disambiguate
by location by type
states of Zhou Dynasty
東周列國
  state of Qin 秦國
state of Chu 楚國
no example yet state of Zhongshan 中山國
Zhongshan City 广东省中山市
Commandery 1 Nan Commandery 南郡 no example yet no example yet
>1 Lelang Commandery 樂浪郡 no example yet no example yet
Province or zhou (up to Sui)
州(漢至隋)
1 Yizhou Province 古益州 Liangzhou Province (Hanzhong) 古梁州 Yangzhou Province 古揚州(今江浙闽)
Liangzhou Province (Gansu) 古涼州 Yangzhou 今扬州市
>1 Nanxuzhou Province 古南徐州 no example yet no example yet
Prefecture or zhou / fu / ting (up to Qing)
府州廳(唐至清)
no need for separate articles
Circuit 道 / 路 >1 Jingxinan Circuit 京西南路 no example yet Hebei Circuit 河北道(唐)
Hebei 今河北省

Established translations elsewhere

Here are some established translations, officially used in China or frequently employed in Sinology literature.

Transportation

As expressways and railways follow the {abr.[1]abr.[2] Expressway/Railway} format, ex (Jingshi Expressway for 京石高速公路), use abbreviations of the first and second cities as one word, followed by Expressway/Railway, please use first capital letter format.

Major railways follow the same format:

As do major Highways:

National Highways that are numbered simply follow the format {China National Highway [number]}:

Railway Station articles should have the city's name (or in some cases the station's unique name - ie. 北京丰台火车站) followed by a direction if applicable(North, South etc.), then [Railway Station]:

Airport articles should have the city's name followed by the [airport's name] if applicable, followed by [International Airport] or [Airport] for domestic:

Culture

For the cuisine of China, use established terms that are understandable. Try to avoid abbreviations.

For the various Chinese operas or other performance arts, use an established translation, or, if that is not available (which is usual), use pinyin.

And as always, work individual articles out on a case by case basis rather than let these conventions constrain you!

For the various spoken varieties of Chinese, simply use the name itself if there is no ambiguity. If there is, then use "xxx (linguistics)" if there's dispute over whether to call it a language or dialect — this includes all the first-level divisions, the second-level divisions of Min, and Taiwanese. Use "xxx dialect" otherwise:

Political NPOV

Wikipedia entries should avoid taking sides on controversial sovereignty issues such as the status of Taiwan and Tibet. Although the United Nations and most sovereign states in the world have recognized the People's Republic of China as the sole government of China, Wikipedia should reflect the neutral reality and not use the term "China" to coincide with any particular state or government. In particular, the word "China" should not be used to be synonymously with areas under the current administration of the People's Republic of China or with Mainland China. As a general rule of thumb, the official political terms "People's Republic of China" or "PRC" and "Republic of China" or "ROC" should be used in political contexts (i.e., to describe the existing regimes or governments) rather than the imprecise and politically charged terms "China" and "Taiwan." For example, "Hu Jintao is the President of the People's Republic of China" is preferred over "Hu Jintao is the President of China." Likewise, one should write "one must be an ROC citizen to vote in the ROC presidential election" as opposed to "one must be a Taiwanese citizen to vote in the Taiwanese presidential election."

Taiwan should not be described either as de jure independent or as a part of the People's Republic of China. Wikipedia should merely state the de facto situation that Taiwan is an independent state currently administered by the "Republic of China." It should be noted that Taiwan and ROC are not necessarily equivalent with: 1) The PRC viewing the ROC as a defeated and illegitimate regime and 2) Some Taiwanese independence supporters arguing that the ROC is illegitimate and that a new Republic of Taiwan should be established. When it is necessary to describe the political status of Taiwan, special note should be made of Taiwan's complex position. Thus, the term "Taiwan" is used when referring to the place while the ROC is used when referring to the government. Furthermore, the term "province of Taiwan" can be offensive and should only be used when attributed to its source or referring specifically to the existing division under the ROC (e.g. "James Soong was the only popularly elected governor of Taiwan Province").

For organizations and international events, such as the Olympic Games or APEC, official terms should be used. In the case of the Olympics, one refers to the Chinese Taipei team, instead of the "Taiwanese team" or the "ROC team." Special care should be taken to put these terms in context - the "China" team in the 1952 Olympics, for example, should not be called the "Chinese Taipei" team as the latter term did not exist yet.

The term "mainland China" is a term which can be used when a comparison is to be made with Taiwan for non-political purposes. Hong Kong and Macau are generally not considered part of Mainland China, though under the jurisdiction of the PRC. Thus, it is more appropriate to write "many tourists from Hong Kong and Taiwan are visiting mainland China" than "many tourists from Hong Kong and Taiwan are visiting China" as the latter could imply that Hong Kong and Taiwan are not part of China. "China proper" is used refer to parts of Mainland China except Tibet, Xinjiang, and other regions associated with non-Han ethnicities. Although the use of the term "Manchuria" is considered by some to be somewhat objectionable when used in Chinese, it is largely considered a non-political and non-objectionable term when used in English.

Also note that there are potential landmines when using the term "Chinese." In particular, some find a distinction between "Chinese" and "Tibetans" or between "Chinese" and "Taiwanese" to be objectionable and the terms "Han Chinese"/"Tibetans" and "Mainland Chinese"/"Taiwanese" are more politically neutral and use will depend on the context. For example, "Mainland Chinese businessmen look forward to meeting their Taiwanese counterparts" is more accurate and acceptable than with the word "Mainland" left out.

The term "Mainlander" poses some issues. It is used both when refering to a resident of Mainland China or a member of the group that fled with the KMT to Taiwan in 1949. In refering to the latter group, the name is mildly objectionable when used in English and strongly objectionable when translated literally in Chinese. Preferred unambigous names for the two groups are "mainland Chinese" and "wai sheng ren".

Hakka is the preferred name for that group even though the Mandarin word for that is something completely different phonetically.

In general, one should avoid using the term "Chinese" to be synonymous with the spoken Mandarin Chinese.