Carnival in the Netherlands
|This article needs additional citations for verification. (October 2013)|
Carnival (Dutch: Carnaval; also called "vastenavond" - eve of the fasting or Limburgish: "vastelaovend") is originally a European Pagan spring festival, with an emphasis on role-reversal and suspension of social norms. The feast became assimilated by the christian catholic church and was celebrated in the three days preceding ash wednesday and lent.
In modern times the connection with religion has disappeared, though its date is still set before the start of the christian feast of lent. Also the core of the modern carnaval has retained its socially critical function by role reversal and temporary abandonment of social norms. The first day of carnaval is six weeks before easter Sunday. The carnaval officially begins on Sunday and lasts three days.
Though according to tradition the feast lasts from Sunday until Tuesday, in recent years the feast usually starts on Saturday. Also Friday evening (or at schools at Friday afternoon) and in some places Thursday (Ouwe Wijven) are considered the start of the carnaval, which makes it a six days celebration. The festivities last the entire day and well into the nights. Some parades and many balls and bonte avonden or other meetings are held in the weeks before the official carnaval, but never before the first official court meeting on November 11. Historically on Wednesday at midnight the 40 days of lent would start until easter. Nowadays it is still the official ending of the carnaval, though some carnaval activities like herring eating are traditionally held on Wednesday after carnaval.
From an anthropological point of view Carnaval is a reversal ritual, in which social roles are reversed and norms about desired behavior are suspended. Carnaval can also be regarded as a rite of passage from darkness to light, from winter to summer: a fertility celebration, the first spring festival of the new year.
- 1 Dates
- 2 Origin
- 3 Modern Carnaval
- 4 Carnaval Customs
- 4.1 Role Reversal and Costume
- 4.2 Key Transfer
- 4.3 Carnaval Associations
- 4.4 Carnaval Parades
- 4.5 Eleven
- 4.6 Carnaval Cabaret
- 4.7 Council of Eleven, Prince and Jester
- 4.8 Peasant Wedding
- 4.9 Music
- 5 Rhenish Carnaval
- 6 Burgundian Carnaval
- 7 Gallery
- 8 References
- 9 Sources
- 10 External links
Easter can fall at the earliest on March 22 and at the latest on April 25. As a result, the earliest possible Carnaval is on February 1, the latest possible date is March 9.
The official Carnaval dates for the coming years are:
- 2014: March 2 to 4
- 2015: February 15 to 17
- 2016: February 7 to 9
- 2017: February 26 to 28
- 2018: February 11 to 13
- 2019: March 3 to 5
- 2020: February 23 to 25
- 2021: February 14 to 16
- 2022: February 27 to 29
- 2023: February 19 to 21
- 2024: February 11 to 13
- 2025: March 2 to 4
- 2026: February 15 to 17
- 2027: February 7 to 9
- 2028: February 27 to 29
- 2029: February 11 to 13
- 2030: March 3 to 5
Traditionally a carnaval feast was the last opportunity to eat well before the time of fasting, during which one was limited to the minimum necessary. On vastenavond (the days before fasting) all the remaining winter stores of lard, butter and meat which was left would be eaten, for it would soon start to rot and decay. The selected livestock had in fact already been slaughtered in November and the meat would be no longer preservable. All the food that had survived the winter had to be eaten to assure that everyone was fat enough to survive until the new spring would provide new food resources. Traditionally the feast also applied to sexual desires, which were supposed to be suppressed during the following fasting.
The oldest word which points in the direction of the word carnaval, is listed on a certificate from the Italian Subiaco from 965 CE as a timestamp Carnelevare. Also known from the 13th century are the words Carnisprivialis, Carnis Privium and in an old Liège text the term Quarnivalle.
The origin can be traced to the Latin expression Carne Levare, or Italian Carne lavare or Carnem levare which with reasonable certainty can be translated into "farewell to the flesh" or "taking away the flesh", which was a ritual to prelude lent. Another explanation that the term would be a contraction of the Latin Carne (meat) and Paler (rule) is given as well, literally "the time that meat reigns". Also, the origin may lie with the Italian Carnueale or the French Carne Avalis. Both mean so much as "devour flesh". 
Another less likely explanation for the term is also Latin; Carrus Navalis: "ship chariot", which would refer to wandering groups in a ship-looking wagon or cart, called the ship of fools, but also can refere to the vessel in which a god of the sea of the Germanic people from the north came to participate in the winter celebrations. Several Germanic tribes celebrated the returning of the daylight. A predominant deity was during this jubilee driven around in a noisy procession on a ship on wheels. During this feast the Germans celebrated as the days grew longer again the (re-)birth of the sun. The winter would be driven out, to make sure that fertility could return in spring. A central figure was possibly the fertility goddess Nerthus. Also there are some indications that the effigy of the god Freyr was placed on a ship with wheels and accompanied by a procession of people in animal disguise and men in women's clothes. Aboard the ship would the marriage of a man and woman be consummated as a fertility ritual.
The elaborate rites involving masked figures in the Swabian-Alemannic carnaval might have had an influence on the different aspects of the feast. The Swabian-Alemannic carnaval, known as Fastnacht, takes place in Baden and Swabia (Southwestern Germany), Switzerland, Alsace and Vorarlberg (Western Austria). It traditionally represents the time of year when the reign of the cold, grim winter spirits is over and these spirits are being driven out and expelled by the Carnaval rituals.
There is evidence that the ancient Roman festivals of Saturnalia and Bacchanalia may have been absorbed into the Italian carnival. The Saturnalia, in turn, may be based on the Greek Dionysia and Oriental festivals like the Babylonical Sacaea (Marduk). The pagan carnaval was celebrated throughout Europe. In Russia, for example, this festival is known as Maslenitsa (roughly translated: butter feast).
Western Roman Empire and Early Middle Ages
In the christian tradition the fasting is to commemorate the 40 days that Jesus fasted according the new testament in the desert and also to reflect on the christian values. Like it has done with many other christian festivals such as christmas which was originally a pagan midwinter festival, easter which was a pagan spring festival, and Sinterklaas, the christian church has found it easier to turn the pagan carnaval in a catholic tradition than to eliminate it.  Unlike today, the carnaval in the Middle Ages took not just a few days, but it covered almost the entire period between christmas and the beginning of lent. In those two months, several catholic holidays were seized by the catholic population as an outlet for their daily frustrations.
In many christian sermons and texts was the example of a vessel used to explain the christian doctrine: "the nave of the church of baptism", "the ship of Mary", etc. The writings show that processions with ship-like carts were held and lavish feasts were celebrated on the eve of lent or the greeting of spring in the early Middle Ages. The catholic church condemned this "devilish debauchery" and "Pagan rituals". As early as the year 325 the council of Nicaea attempted to end these Pagan festivals.
Many synods and councils attempted to set things "right". The statements of Caesarius of Arles (470-542), which protested around 500 CE in his sermons against the Pagan practices, seemed to have formed the building blocks of the Indiculus superstitionum et paganiarum (small index of superstitious and pagan practices), which was drafted by the Synod of Leptines in 742 in which the Spurcalibus en februario was condemned.
Pope Gregory the Great (590-604) decided that fasting would start on ash wednesday. The whole carnaval event was set before the fasting, to set a clear division between the pagan and the christian custom. It was also the custom during carnaval that the ruling class would be mocked using masks and disguises.
In the year 724 the synod in Leptines (Leptines is located near Binche in Belgium) spoke out furiously against the excesses in the month of February. Also from the same period dates the phrase: "Whoever in February by a variety of less honorable acts tries to drive out winter is not a christian, but a pagan." Confession books from around 800 contain more information about how people would dress as an animal or old woman during the festivities in January and February. Noticing that on it was no small penance.
Gradually the ecclesiastical authority began to realize that the desired result could not be attained by banning the traditions, which eventually led to a degree of christianization. The festivities became part of the liturgy and the liturgical year.
High and Late Middle Ages
This change of course became more clear when at the synod of Benevento (in 1091) the beginning of lent was definitively established on the day that is called ash wednesday by pope Urban II. The duration of the fasting was already set at 40 days after centuries of discussion preceding the council of Nicaea. The carnaval, or rather shrove Tuesday, was in 1091 officially accepted by christianity and was followed by lent (the time of penance and mortification) on ash wednesday.
Within the confines of church liturgy, the old ways changed into the "Fools Feast" (Narrenfeest, Fêtes des Fous or Donkey Feast). The main roles were in the beginning played by the clergy of the minor orders, the sub-deacons. This were clerics who were in many cases illiterate and were also the local main baker or butcher. However during the carnaval they became prominent and played the role of crazy bishop or "donkey pope" as part of the role reversal function of the carnaval.
From Den Bosch is according to a document from 1383 known that public stage performances, jousting tournaments, games, cockfights and role dressing were organized. Around 1400 it was prohibited to roll dice (gambling), but an exception was made during carnaval. This appears from a letter from the council of Maastricht in 1405. The ban was temporarily lifted and people were allowed to play dice during the carnaval.
Several popes in the past were explicitly involved with the shrove Tuesday celebration. They organized synods regarding fasting and shrove Tuesday, participated with carts in the processions, and promulgated special collections. Pope Martin V, elected on November 11, 1417, is known to be nicknamed "Papa Carnavale". This was not due to the fact that he was elected on 11 November to be pope, but because he felt that the carnaval didn't last long enough.
Like now the carnaval in the Middle Ages reached the highlight in the three days before the beginning of lent. During this period, the city officially handed over the power to "Prince Carnaval" and the social revolution was complete. Because of the anonymity offered by the costumes, rank and position were no longer important and one could freely express his opinion and mock anything and anyone. In particular, the nobility, clergy and the wealthy citizens were mocked and ridiculed. This tradition is still reflected in contemporary parades and at the Brabantian tonproaten and Limburgish buutereednen, the speakers subjects include mocking and ridiculing the local administration.
The catholic church had to suffer most during carnaval. All kinds of sacred traditions and rules were ridiculed during the feast. A donkey would be put on the altar during the ezelsmis (donkey's mass) after which a civilian dressed as a priest staged a mass. During all the prayers, the "amen" would be replaced by "ia, ia, ia". A dance called the polonaise was done during which people did not follow the pastor with the hand on the shoulder, but with the nose at the bottom. Also celebrated on December 28 is the now forgotten feast of the massacre of the innocents, commemorating the infanticide in Bethlehem. On this day the children were given the power for one day and turned it against the church. The choirboys put the clergy on a cart full of manure, and then let them pass through the village. Often this gave the mass the opportunity to pelt the church ministers with shit, a phenomenon in slightly modified version to be found now in the spreading confetti from the carnaval floats.
However, in 1445 the church attacked the feast furiously. The theologians in Paris felt that the carnaval was out of control, issued a number of prohibitions and drafted a letter, which included the following: "The priests wear masks during mass, they dance in the choir dressed as women, matchmakers or minstrels and singing outrageous songs. On the altar they eat black pudding and fat sausages. They roll dices and old shoes are burned instead of incense. Also there is running and jumping by them inside the church. After this mass they go out on the streets in their disguises. With carts and wagons they roam through the city, and give shameless performances to excite the laughter of the audience, which they also further incite with filthy songs and obscene gestures." The theologians conclude their letter stating that they do not even want to mention the worst things that take place during the carnaval.
The role of the lower clergy, however, gradually got taken over by laymen. That is not to say that therefore there was no longer shrove Tuesday or fools bishops, and donkey popes and donkey bishops. The laity started to play the roles of the dignitaries they ridiculed. Later this practice developed into real titles and the roles of "Prince" or "Fürst" came into use. The feasts with jesters were in Flanders and the Netherlands very widespread.
Later the "feasts of fools" are taken over by urban carnaval associations, such as the shipping companies and guilds. The celebrations became more expensive every year, so expensive that even the Prins or Vorst candidate often fled the city to prevent being elected. Cities even increased their taxes to finance these highly elaborate feasts.
Early Modern Period
In the sixteenth century, the excessive, public and massive carnaval celebration from the Middle Ages came to an end. The council of Trent (1545-1563) and the reformation caused a complete reverse in attitude towards the carnaval. The schism within christianity as a result of the reformation, led to a religious divide in the territory of the present Netherlands. Protestantism became the dominant religion north of the rivers Meuse and Rhine. In the areas that cover today the provinces of Limburg and North Brabant the catholic religion remained dominant. In the part of the Netherlands that after the reformation became predominantly protestant, the public shrovetide celebration disappeared from the streets. The new protestant clergy found the riotous catholic carnaval sinful. In the north, the feast quickly eradicated and also in the south the carnaval was restricted. Shrove Tuesday was interpreted as a "romish superstition' and prohibited to ban it out. In 's Hertogenbosch for example the carnaval was banned in 1629 after protestants had conquered the city which had belonged to the roman catholic Spaniards. Therefore in the catholic south the feast became less celebrated as well during the seventeenth and eighteenth century. Though the celebrations were banned, they did not entirely disappear. This is clear from the fact that a new ban had to be enacted every year. It was only since 1794, the beginning of the French era, that Den Bosch would officially allow celebrating carnaval again.
By the end of the 17th century carnaval in the Netherlands had mostly disappeared, though smaller festivities before lent in the south of the Netherlands and in German Rhineland and North Rhine-Westphalia kept some carnaval traditions alive over the next 150 years. Despite the protestantism rule, the catholics in the 18th century managed to celebrate some sort of street carnaval. There were still dressing, eating and drinking feasts and all sorts of games were held like goose pulling / rooster smashing (smashing or pulling the head of the animal) cat burning or smashing and herring biting. These games were held in both the 18th and in the 19th century. In Venlo these games were banned in 1775, but in Wijnandsrade this tradition was held till 1848. Also sketches and plays were held. In Den Bosch a doll named Knillis would be burned as a typical carnaval ritual, until this was prohibited around 1853.
Also charivaris, which were folk customs that may already existed before 1600, were more often held around the carnaval time. Like in other European countries, the two main purposes of the charivari in Europe were to facilitate change in the current social structure and to act as a form of censure within the community. The goal was to enforce social standards and to rid the community of socially unacceptable relationships that threatened the stability of the whole. By the charivari's the community would punish and correct fellow citizens by public mocking and humiliation for unwanted behavior like adulterous relationships, men who let them selves be deceived by their wives, men who abused their wives, men who were not dominant in the marriage, widows who wished to remarry, women who wish to marry outside the social group (like a partner from a neighboring village) and other violators of social norms. The victims were subjected to humiliating processions with noise and music through the village, forced to do embarrassing or hard labor or their possessions and house would be marked, damaged and soiled. In the period before the carnaval, groups of men would build a carnaval float, while others painted portraits of promiscuous girls, girls of which the boys / men felt had come to age to get married, or women who behaved "wrongly". Another widespread phenomenon in the south was the Dwaze Maagd van het Jaar (foolish maid of the year). This girl was chosen because of "bad" behavior: often a maid that was sexually used by her master. A large doll to depict the girl was shown on the sunday of the carnaval after church. The men sang mocking songs on the town square around the doll. Not just "premarital sexual active" and "adulterous" girls were mocked, also girls could get criticized because of their appearance or language, for turning down suitors, for the extent to which she was kind or kept faithful to her friends. Men would write poetry parodies (often using already existing melodies) about these women. During the carnaval, the men would wear masks and go from pub to pub, to perform a play and mocking songs while the paintings were displayed as an illustration. Much more often than in southern European countries like France the Dutch charivaris showed dissatisfaction towards decisions of the authorities. This kind of "political charivaris" never questioned the authority of the government itself, but were intended to denounce abuse of power and corruption by the government. The heyday of the political charivaris was between 1820 and 1850. In North Brabant there were various forms of community charivaris around carnaval which till 1934 still often occurred.
Some of the best-known traditions, including carnival parades and masquerade balls and masquerading, were recorded in medieval Italy. The carnival of Venice was for a long time the most famous carnival (although Napoleon abolished it in 1797 and only in 1959 the tradition was restored). From Italy carnival traditions spread to the catholic nations of Spain, Portugal, and France. From France, they spread to the Rhineland of Germany, and to New France in North America (the mardi gras). From Spain and Portugal, they spread with catholic colonization to the Caribbean and Latin America. In 1823 the first modern carnaval parade took place in Cologne, Germany.
Without denying that the current carnaval contains several recognizable aspects of the past, the feast as it is held today is relatively young. With the exception of some places in Limburg and North Brabant, where in the nineteenth century the organization of carnaval celebrations was reviving again, the vast majority of the carnaval associations are established after World War II.
In the fifties of the twentieth century, with a few exceptions, the feast was still confined to the southern provinces of Limburg and North Brabant, where the majority of the population was catholic. During the sixties, the relatively strong demarcation between the catholic south on one side and the calvinist west and north on the other side of the Netherlands started to diminish. The protest generation in the making saw that her desire for looser manners was honored, at least during the carnaval days. Even mild criticism of the political and social system, until then painstakingly smothered by the authorities, suddenly appeared to be possible. For most adolescent participants the longing for personal freedom appealed most to them. Carnaval was to the South, what the provo was to the North of the Netherlands. What actually happened was exactly the opposite of what had happened during the Middle Ages: a new morality was tested, not to investigate what is not allowed, but to investigate what is allowed. Carnaval was one of the developments that gave impetus to the South to more informal manners, individualization and sexual revolution and then to ontzuiling (depillarisation) and secularization.
The carnaval exceeded in the seventies of the 20th century the border that is formed by "the Great Rivers" (the Maas, the Waal and the Rhine), lost all religious connotations and became a secular feast. Also the practice of lent became rapidly extinct in the Netherlands in the sixties and seventies of the twentieth century. The south of the Netherlands, which is mostly roman catholic by tradition is now largely secular in practice.
After the modern feast of carnaval lost the association with christian religion as a result of the rapid secularization in the Netherlands in the second half of the 20th century, the carnaval became more celebrated in parts of the country which were protestant by tradition. At the end of the twentieth century there were carnaval associations in all the provinces of the Netherlands which are active in organizing the celebrations. However in the areas which did not originally celebrate, the feast is still growing to become a tradition. As a result the carnaval in these parts of the country usually lasts only one day with te emphasis on role dressing and feasting, without the social critism, parades and months of prelude. The massive carnaval festivities, which suspend the daily life, still mainly take place in North Brabant, Limburg, Twente and the municipalities of Hulst, Sluis, Nijmegen, Over-Betuwe, Lingewaard, De Liemers and Arnhem.
Carnaval officially lasts from Sunday to Tuesday, but the current practice is that often between November 11 and the actual feast there are already numerous carnaval festivities, especially in the last weeks before carnaval. Sometimes there are also on ash wednesday some carnaval activities held. The post-christian carnaval consist of several days consecutively drinking, feasting, role-dressing, parades and music. The ridiculing and socially critical aspects of the carnaval are mostly emphasized during the parades. Southern schools often dedicate the Friday afternoon before the actual feast to the carnaval. Children are invited to come role-dressed to school, sometimes the schools even organize a school parade and choose a school prince.
On November 11 (the eleventh of the eleventh), at exactly 11:11 am, starts the carnaval season. In the Netherlands, the start of the season is celebrated in almost every carnaval celebrating town with some kind of ceremony. The reason for this date is the number 11, which is traditionally the number of fools and madmen.
The carnavals are in many ways similar, but because of their origins and unique traditions they are also easy to distinguish from each other. The Rhenish variant is usually celebrated in Limburg, the Burgundian variant in the mid, north and west of North Brabant and in parts of Zeeland and Rivierenland. The east of North Brabant has manifestations of both types of carnaval and a overlap region of the two types of carnaval, but is often classified as Burgundian. The Rhenish carnaval in the Netherlands is a derivative of the Cologne carnaval. The Burgundian carnaval originated from the traditional eating feasts during which people would ridicule one another during the carnaval in the Southern Netherlands (nowadays Belgium, Luxembourg and the Dutch Provincies North Brabant and Limburg), especially in the Duchy of Brabant.
In addition to national and provincial variations, there also is a diversity in carnaval rituals between the various cities or towns. In the many yearbooks of local carnaval groups are the local rituals described.
Role Reversal and Costume
Carnaval is not only a feast of eating and drinking, but also serves as social role reversal feast which allows people to behave outside the usual acceptable social norm. People will dress up as a character, much as seen during halloween in the Celtic and Anglo-Saxon culture which though has developed from a different origin. During the Dutch carnaval people will often dress colourful and take on roles like jesters, occupations, animals, other genders and sexes, archetypes or fairytale characters, well known people, subcultures, historical figures or foreign cultures. Masks and face paint are often used in combination with the costumes. The costumes allow people to change their identity and role in society for a few days without being judged for it by their fellowman during and after the carnaval. This also applies to feasting and drinking and other licentious behaviour which can be attributed to the temporary identity one takes on, rather than to the person him or herself. The costumes may, but are often not, meant to be political incorrect, ridiculing, taboo-breaking, politically and socially and religiously critical, insulting or self-mocking, which is part of the role reversal origins of the feast. The function of this is to mirror and exaggerate daily life, to denounce and raise awareness of every day events and put life in perspective. A proper ridiculing carnaval costume does not simply insult or mock, but makes actually a valuable point. When not used to make a point, carnaval costumes offer an opportunity to temporarily change identity and express oneself freely. Nowadays some people will have an different costume for each day they celebrate carnaval because of the lack of time to wash their clothes.
Traditionally the role dressing serves three major purposes:
- The costume allows people to become and act according an identity they can not take on or express during the rest of the year because of social standards and serves thus as an outlet for such needs.
- The costume offers a visual way of protesting or expressing criticism and mirroring by exaggeration of social circumstances, authority and daily life to break taboo's, create awareness and reflect on past and current events.
- The costume provides protection when criticizing and ridiculing others because the wearer can either not be recognized or the criticism can be attributed to the role the wearer assumes during the carnaval rather than to the wearer himself. Because of this the wearer can safely express his criticism and opinion without having to fear for consequences in his daily life.
The Prince of carnaval receives on the first day of the carnaval the symbolic key to the city / town from the hands of the mayor, who transfers to him three days of "power". This element of the carnaval is already known in the medieval carnaval. The changing of positions in power provide an opportunity to criticize the authorities without fear of retribution and are part of the role reversal function of the carnaval.
Since 1839 numerous societies were established which organized carnaval balls. In fact, these associations took on lots of activities which the guilds used to organize in the Middle Ages and Early Modern Period before the French occupation and are in that sense their successors.
More than Burgundian, the Rhenish carnaval celebrations are dominated by carnaval associations. These associations, of which there are sometimes many per city or village with each their own prince and council of eleven, organize their own festivities for both members and non-members of the association during the carnaval. At the Burgundian carnaval the main features ("bonte avonden" and "pronkzitting", key exchange, parades, etc.) are organized by a carnaval association. The associations choose a prince (and entourage) and even though a Burgundian town can have dozens of carnaval associations, there is only one prince per city or village.
Cologne had already started organizing carnaval by an association in 1823, followed in 1835 by Düsseldorf and Mainz in 1838. In Limburg the carnaval organized by an association was as common as in the German Rhineland. Momus was probably the first carnaval association in the Netherlands and was founded in 1839 in Maastricht, followed by Jocus in the city of Venlo in 1842. Momus name derives from the Greek god Momus. According to the Düsseldorfer Narrenkalender from 1841 "Carnaval the Great has three sons: Momus, Comus and Jocus". Momus, the Greek god of mockery and criticism. When in Venlo a sorority founded the carnaval association, they could thus choose between Comus (Greek god of festivity, anarchy and chaos) and Jocus (Roman god of wit and raillery). Momus is not the oldest existing carnaval association because it had faded out before the Second World War in 1939. After the war the carnaval in Maastricht was organized by the Tempeleers. The currently oldest carnaval association is Jocus.
In many places, large carnaval parades are held with large floats, organized and created by the carnaval associations. The parades have usual a particular theme whereby authorities are ridiculed, events of the past year are represented and which are often politically incorrect and used to make people think outside the box or function as a mirror to the society. Also groups or individuals on foot will participate and fill the gaps between the carnaval wagons during the parade. Fanfares and marching bands will provide for typical carnaval music. The floats are build by carnaval associations, but also often by independent groups of friends, families, neighbourhoods or other clubs. A massive ship-looking wagon is shown in every carnaval parade which is manned by the prince, his entourage and the council of eleven of the city it is held or of the carnaval association that organized the parade and is usually the last float at the parade. Carnaval parades often start at 11.11 am and end early in the afternoon. Some wil start in the afternoon to give participants the opportunity to join several parades a day and to give the public and participants the opportunity to be somewhat more sober / less hangover after the drinking of the day before. Usually a competition will be held to choose the most outstanding contribution to the parade with separate categories for floats, groups on foot and individual participants. Although a procession usually takes from a starting point to a point of arrival, it actually roams from nowhere to nowhere. What only matters is the social binding during the parade. Along the route, the crowd forms a very essential part of the parade. The crowd is not just spectator, they form living dikes along the carnaval river without which the parade would loose meaning.
The number eleven plays an undeniably important role in the carnaval. The opinions on this subject are very divergent, so much so that one explanation often has nothing to do even with the other. On the other hand the number eleven is not only central to the carnaval, but it has built up a kind of mystical and magical value through the ages.
Eleven is original the "fools number" in Germanic culture. In German it is called a Schnapszahl, and it is associated with alcohol consumption and used in numerology. Also it is a prime number. It is an imperfect number since it is one number less than the base number twelve in the duodecimal numeral system and one number more than the base number ten in the decimal numeral system.
The number eleven in Dutch and German is translated as Elf. The word originates from the Proto-Germanic: ainalibi, which is a combination of the words aina (one) and libi (left "over ten") or ain (one) + leikw (leave, remain). Other derivatives are elleovene from Old English endleofan, from Proto-Germanic *ainlif- (Saxon: elleban, Old Frisian: andlova, Dutch: elf, Old High German: einlif, German: elf, Old Norse: ellifu, Gothic: ainlif).
There is suggested that the word "elf" became associated with the words Elf, Elves, Elven or Alven. Early elves, whose description depends almost entirely on Norse mythology texts, were a race of beings with magical skills, ambivalent towards humans and capable of either helping or hindering them. But christianized societies were viewing elves in increasingly sinister light. In Anglo-Saxon England as early as the 10th century, Old English medical books attest to elves afflicting humans and livestock by "elf-shots". The German elf or alp was seen as an addler of people in medical books, but already in the High Middle Ages there were prayers warding against it as the agent causing nightmares, and eventually for the alp its identity as nightmare spirits became predominant. The ritual re-enactment of the Wild Hunt was a cultural phenomenon among many Gallic and Germanic peoples. At the head of this army of elves, the king of Elves, would have been Erlenköning Hellequin.
Although there is certain historical data on ancient meaning of the number 11, there may also be a younger explanation. It is known that the oldest Geckengesellschaft (jester group) was founded by count Adolf of Cleve in 1381 and took place on 12 November. Everything indicates that the foundation celebration of the 11th apparently got out of control, so the signing took place one day to late. Note also that the seal of the count takes the 11th place in the row of 35 stamps. The motto of this noble jester society was EyLustigh Fröhlich.
November 11, the 11th of the 11th, was an important date. November 11 is exactly 40 days before December 21, the shortest day. This happens to be the feast day of sint Maarten (st. Martin's day). This day is celebrated in some parts of Groningen, North Holland and the southern part of Limburg and to a lesser extent in South Holland and Zeeland. This feast is the beginning of the dark period before christmas and the long days of winter.
For centuries, November 11, was the day that the year's work was deemed to be done. The barns were filled for the winter, the selected livestock would been slaughtered and very important: the lease, property taxes, interests, and tithe were to be paid. These often weighed very heavily on the population. A year of scraping, frugality and putting every penny aside, would end after the payment on 11 November.
In both the Rhenish and the Burgundian carnaval 11-11 plays an important role. At 11-11 is the first of court meetings by the Council of Eleven held in preparation for the upcoming carnaval. During this meeting will also the new Prince be announced. In Brabant at the same meeting the new carnaval mottos are disclosed by the prince. Also it is the start of the building of the carnaval floats for the coming parade.
Cabaret in dialect during are held in both variants of carnaval. In North Brabant the person doing the cabaret is called a tonpraoter or sauwelaar in the Western part of North Brabant, and is actually in or on a barrel. In Limburg they are named buuttereedner or buutteredner and in Zeeland they are called an ouwoe. They all perform a cabaret speech in dialect, during which many current issues and events of the past year are reviewed. Often there are local situations and celebrities from the local and regional politics who will be mocked, ridiculed and insulted. The tonpraoter or buuttereedner is a successor of the medieval jester.
Open stages are held in the weeks before the carnaval where people from the community, mostly amateurs, can participate in carnaval related acts like music, farces, dance acts and cabaret. Such a bonte avond is free to visit for the public. One special revue (called pronkzitting) is an organized event at or before the carnaval with singing and dancing, but focuses mainly on humorous contributions by a variety of local tonpraoters / buuttereedners. During the "pronkzitting" there are also performances of carnaval orchestras and majorettes. The prince and youth prince and their councils of eleven will attend. Unlike at other carnaval events, at the pronkzitting the usual dress code for the public is evening dress.
It may be assumed that the emergence of the figure of the jester is coinciding with the development of the medieval civilization. Since the very beginning of his occurrence, the fool has been the personification of folly for centuries, as the jester was the one who tipped reality. In other words, the jester mirrors or exaggerates the everyday reality, and is way-ward or taboo-breaking. They spoke truths that others were only secretly thinking. Actual fools often lacks the ability to behave according the norms, while conscious jesters exaggerated to serve as a mirror to their public. The image of the jester is mainly shaped by its heyday. This ran from the Middle Ages to the late seventeenth century. The default image is that of the jester with fool's cap with bells, cheerful colors and oversized shoes, and marotte. In reality, some wore a jester costume, but other wore deliberately shabby clothes and some wore noble robes. Nowadays we imagine the jester often with a small deformed appearance, but this was not always the case.
There were basically two kinds of jesters. The ones with physical and especially mental disabilities (the fools) who could be mocked by their employers and the real jesters who were hired or recruited to mock others and entertain. If there were setbacks, they were the ones whom one could blame or who could take the heat, or the ones people could laugh about and determine that things could be worse. The jesters were intelligent artists, well-spoken and theatrical witty. They were aware of their duties and took a position between the ruler and the people. They could tell the king or ruler what no one else dared. A role that the contemporary tonpraoters and buuttereedners continue in a modern way.
Council of Eleven, Prince and Jester
A familiar phenomenon during the carnaval is the presence of the prince  and his entourage. The format of this custom varies by region, the prince and his jester (generally called adjutant) however, are almost universally within the carnaval traditions. The prince is traditionally a male and can be the same person for years, but often a different person is elected every year. The prince is called Prins (Prince) or sometimes Vorst (Fürst). The female Prins / Vorst, which is called Prinses (Princess) or Vorstin (Fürstin) begins to occur more frequently the last decade. Each year the (often all male) Council of Eleven of every carnaval association proclaims a prince, and one (adjutant) or more aides. Most associations also have an all-gender youth council of eleven which chooses a youth prince and youth aides. The council of eleven does not necessarily hold eleven members, often there are more than eleven, sometimes less.
Origin of the Council of Eleven
The actual origin of the name "Council of Eleven" is traced back to the Duchy of Brabant in the fifteenth century. The Netherlands and Belgium in the Middle Ages consisted of a number of duchies, counties, heerlijkheiden, etc. One of those duchies was the great and glorious Duchy of Brabant, which included the current province of North Brabant (Netherlands) and the provinces of Antwerp and Flemish Brabant (Belgium). When the Duke of Brabant Anthony of Burgundy in 1415 was killed in the battle of Anzicourt, the delegates of the seven ancient cities of Brabant and the four largest abbeys of Brabant organized a meeting to discuss the succession of the Duke. The Duchess-Widow was not eligible for the succession, because of her rights to Luxembourg. However, they had two sons, the oldest named Jan, was only eleven years. On November 4, the states decided to recognize him as Duke of Brabant, and that the day-to-day government should be looked after by the "Council of Eleven" (consisting of the seven cities of Brabant and the four abbeys). The appointment of the board members of the "Council of Eleven" is very likely to have occurred in the following week, on or around November 11.
Not everywhere in Limburg and Brabant is a boerenbruiloft (peasant's wedding) part of the carnaval. Especially in the northern and central part of Limburg and eastern part of North Brabant is the boerenbruiloft very often held during the carnaval and is an important part of the carnaval culture. Each carnaval association has its own tradition concerning choosing the spouse for a wedding. When it's a small association often the bride and groom are chosen by the council of eleven or by the couple that was married the year before. In Venlo it is not the carnaval association that chooses the participants of the peasant wedding, but an outsider group. This may be a company, a family, a football club, or as in 2013 a delegation of the hospital in Venlo. In that case, the board has determined who would become bride and groom.
It is not necessary that the newlyweds are a couple in real life. It is also not necessary that the bride and groom are single. Both the bride and groom, however, should be in love during the carnaval and they need to transfer their love to all the people who celebrate their wedding along with them. The highlight of the festival of the peasant wedding is the wedding and feast of the onecht (not-marriage) of the bride and groom. There are many aspects that can be found in a real-life marriage. First the engagement will be announced just as if it would be an officially marriage. And both the families should learn to know each other very well in organizing the party and the ceremony, like a normal wedding. The two families prepare a piece of entertainment for the wedding. And just like a real wedding, a reception and a feast is organized where guests are asked to wear appropriate clothing. The bride and groom will often dress in wedding clothing from before 1940. The bride for example will often wear a poffer, which is a traditional Brabantian headdress.
Origin of the Peasant Wedding
The first mention of a "boerenbruiloft" (peasant wedding) was in 1582, when the Saxon elector August in Dresden wedded a peasant and his wife during a large ritual ceremony d'n onech (the not-marriage). It was not a real wedding and the to-be spouse were also not real peasants, but rather the nobility. The real peasants were given the role of noblemen. It was a reversal ritual, in which the roles were deliberately reversed. This role reversal was intended to avoid the attraction of the evil eye. Within the noble circles it was believed that it was the eye of the christian god which at the beginning of the spring focused on them because of their failure in the past year. They thought they could escape this danger by dressing during this wedding celebrations and to behave as peasants, and thus appear the be the people at the bottom of the social ladder. They believed the consequence was that the peasants dressed as nobleman would be harmed by their god instead of the nobles themselves.
Carnaval songs are a relatively recent phenomenon after World War II. Intentionally amateurish marching bands (Zaate Hermeniekes or Drunken Marching Bands) traditionally perform this kind of music on the streets, mainly in Limburg. In North-Brabant the music is played mainly indoors in pubs and feast halls, which is also done in Limburg. Carnaval music is often a song written especially for the occasion and is easy to dance to. The carnaval music is used to ridicule the normal culture during the carnaval, therefore the creating and playing of carnaval music is a very seasonal happening.
Carnaval music is usual composed in 6/8 bar or 3/4 bar. Local carnaval clubs usually try to address current issues in local dialect in a carnaval song. Carnaval songs are a form of opportunity compositions. A good carnaval song has several recognizable ingredients:
- An easy, catchy "popular" melody
- A rhythm with 'leaping' character: long-short is often continuously rotated and triplets are common
- Many accents in music and lots of question-answer elements
- The harmony contains many thirds and sixths
- The text is easy to remember (thus it can be remembered when drunk), and often humorous in nature to make a point
- The text is many times sexual, vulgair and offensive in nature or totally non-sense
- The form usually consists of several verses that alternate
- Choruses with an accessible, inviting and compelling rhythm: there should be danced on
Hossen (jumping together in a group) is a way of dancing during the carnaval which is mainly found in Brabant, also the polonaise is done during the carnaval. In the southernmost part of the Netherlands in Limburg, there are three ways of carnaval dancing: sjoenkele (slowly moving back and forth, left to right, etc. while sitting or standing with ones arms on the shoulders of the person beside him or with the arms hooked together at 3/4 tact), pogo-ing (jumping up and down by oneself) and the polonaise. In Maastricht the polonaise is called the reijaloet. The polonaise is usually done spontaneous and for short moment of times, but can be done by dozens of people together. 
Dweilorkesten and Kapellen
During carnaval it is common for kapellen (Limburg) and dweilorkesten "literally: mop orchestras" (North Brabant) to provide during the feast for most of the music (in the pubs / feasting halls). In Limburg, the orchestras are more limited to playing outside. This immediately shows a big difference between the two variants: Burgundian carnaval is mainly celebrated indoors, Rhenish carnaval is mostly celebrated outdoors. Many pubs in Maastricht take their facade away during carnaval to open up to the feast on the streets. This kind of orchestra can also be seen during national sports events in the Netherlands like speed skating.
- "Het Land van Maas en Waal" (The land of Meuse and Waal) by Boudewijn de Groot (1967)
- "Drinke totteme zinke" (Drink 'till we sink) by Thijs van der Molen (1969)
- "Den Uyl is in den olie" (Den Uyl is drunk / Den Uyl is into oil) by Vader Abraham & Boer Koekoek (1974)
- "Malle Babbe" (Crazy Babbe) by Rob de Nijs (1975)
- "Als het gras twee kontjes hoog is" (When the grass stands two buttocks tall) by Hydra (1976)
- "Unne spijker in munne kop" (A nail in my head) by De Stipkes (1976)
- "Limburgs klaaglied" (Limburgish lament) by Martine Bijl (1977)
- "Het leven is goed in het Brabantse land" (Life is good in the land of Brabant) by Oh Sixteen Oh Seven (1979)
- "Brabantse nachten zijn lang" (Brabantic nights are long) by Arie Ribbens (1980)
- "Er staat een paard in de gang" (There is a horse in the hallway) by André van Duin (1981)
- "Mama, woar is mien pils" (Mother, where is my beer) by Normaal (1982)
- " 's Nachts na tweeën" (At night after two) by De Havenzangers (1983)
- "Het feest kan beginnen!" (The party can get started) by De Deurzakkers (1986)
- "Bestel mar" (Just order "some beer") by Rowwen Hèze (1987)
- "Niks stront niks" (Nothing shit nothing) by Rowwen Hèze (1988)
- "Rosamunde" by Rowwen Hèze (1992)
- " 't Dondert en 't bliksemt" (There's thunder and there's lightning) by Guus Meeuwis (1998)
- "Lauwe pis" (Lukewarm pis) by Theo Maassen (2007)
- "Zachte G, Harde L" (Soft G, Hard L / "Soft G, Hard Dick") by Jos van Oss (2010)
- "In ’t land van de Maasvallei" (In the land of the Meuse valley) by W-Dreej (2012)
The Rhenish variant, which is celebrated in the province of Limburg and the eastern part of North Brabant, is based on the carnaval celebrations in cities in the western German state of North Rhine - Westphalia. Especially Cologne, which in turn was based mostly on the carnival of Venice, has had a major impact on the nature of this carnaval. By the end of the 19th century, the carnaval in the Rhineland was used as an opportunity to protest against the imperialist (and protestant) Prussia which annexated the area at the time. Many of the current traditions can be traced back to this protest feast.
Oude Wijven / Auw Wiever
In the week before carnaval (usual Thursday) there are, so-called Oude Wijven or Limburgish: Auw Wiever (old women) days and Oudewijvenbals (old women balls). During Ouwe Wijve or Auw Wiever the pubs and streets are crowded by costumed women, usually dressed as old women. Men who dare to go out on the streets and in the pubs are at risk to be humiliated and chased away. Also in some towns it is tradition that the women are allowed to kiss every man they like to during Ouwe Wijve. The established tradition on this day is to also cut the ties and the shoelaces which the men wear when they get caught showing themselves. This tradition is especially widespread in the south of Limburg. It is believed to be a postwar invention from Rhineland, where women wanted to emphasize the independence they gained to men who had returned from the front after the years of war.
The tradition may have an older background though. The position of men compared to women in society has often been a matter of debate. In Cologne is since 1824 the so-called Weiberfastnacht known. On the Thursday before carnaval, women are wearing men's clothes, reversing the roles and thus literally "being the man". In the Dutch border village Groenstraat a precursor to the Auwwieverbal (Old women ball) or Auw Wieverdaag (old women day) was known already in the early 19th century. The people at that time earned a living by breeding goats and selling woman's hair. The Thursday before carnaval the men would sell the hair to their French buyers. After the sale, as the man had plenty of money, they would go visit the pubs. The women would not be at the sale because they were expected to stay at home. Out of fear that their men would squander the money raised by their hair, the women would go find their husbands to prevent them from wasting it on alcohol. The search along the pubs transformed later to the Oudewijvenbal. The women, this time incognito, firmly asserted themselves to their husbands and other men.
Venlo has a tradition of its own, namely Truujendaag, where the women dress in late medieval clothing. This name is probably derived from the headstrong figure Gertruid Bolwater from Venlo. According the legend during a siege of the city during the Guelderian Wars in 1499 or 1511 she defeated several enemy soldiers and tore the banner from the hands of an enemy soldier.
Traditional clothing consists of elaborate costumes. Some buy a complete themed costume in a party store, others create their costumes themselves. Because the Rhenish carnaval mostly takes place outside on the streets, the costumes are also warmer. The costumes are elaborate and consist usually out of multiple layers. Ordinary jackets are never te be worn on top of the carnaval clothing, at most underneath the costume.
The Rhenish carnaval has three official colors which appear everywhere. These are red, yellow and green. According carnavalogist Theo French from Venlo the tradition of these colors goes back several centuries, more specifically to the jester in the castle. The jester group of Kleve (1381 - Germany) wore the colors yellow/red. The jesters preferably wore green/red in France. Even before 1450 a group of French jesters in Lyon dressed in red, yellow and green. Colours used to have much more meaning than nowadays, and were very important as a means of communication. An at that time most people could not read or write and therefore used other symbols among which were colors. The symbolism of the colors of the jester was for people in the Middle Ages immediately clear.
In present day, a jester is seen as funny and humorous. At the time of the Middle Ages this was different, since the jester in fact was the personification of devil. The symbolic value each color the jester carries should be seen in that regard.
Red is the color of christian virtue and ardent love but also is the color of the devil, fire, death, conflict and war. The yellow color stands for cheerfulness and elation, but also envy, retardation, ignorance and insanity. Green represents new life, youthfulness, boldness, the joy of life, vibrancy, growth and prosperity, but on the other hand, also stands for inexperience and nescience.
The exuberant Burgundian carnaval is the variant that is traditionally seen in most places in the mid and west of North Brabant, Gelderland (Land of Maas and Waal), Flanders and some places in South Beveland.
Its origins are in the prosperous cities of the Duchy of Brabant and County of Flanders at the time of the Burgundian Netherlands. The shape of the Burgundian carnaval was originally that of a costumed eating feast during which people ridiculed each other. Because of the great poverty that prevailed in Brabant after the Golden Age until World War II, the traditional feast was characterized by (seemingly) simple costumes, of which the blue smock with bandana of mid and especially western North Brabant is perhaps the most iconic and can still be found among the costumes today.
Many, but not all, Burgundian carnavals towns have an official motto. This is often a famous saying in local dialect. It is proclaimed on November 11 by the new Prince.
Motto's of "Kielegat" (Breda) since 2000
- 2000 - De kop isser af.
- 2001 - Tis ene grote kerremus.
- 2002 - Dur wazzis… eel lang geleje.
- 2003 - Tis nie te filleme.
- 2004 - We gaon dum boot in.
- 2005 - Me zijn ut spoor bijster.
- 2006 - Me maoken'ut gèèf bont.
- 2007 - Ast mar erregus op lekt.
- 2008 - Ziedegij ut ok zitte.
- 2009 - T’Oren, zien en zwijgen.
- 2010 - Tis drop of dronder.
- 2011 - K’ebber un nuske vor.
- 2012 - K’ebb'ut licht gezien.
- 2013 - Meej tweej zevus kende nie blijve zitte.
- 2014 - Ut wor dweile of plakke.
Traditional clothing consists of old clothing, curtains, blue smocks and bandana with all kinds of accessories. This can be found especially in the western part of North Brabant. Burgundian carnaval takes place mostly inside in pubs and feasting halls. Since it is warmer in there, the clothing is also less thick and consists of fewer layers. When going to the different feasting locations, many people use old coats to keep from getting cold outside.
It is common for cities with a Burgundian carnaval tradition to change their name during carnaval (although there are some places in eastern Netherlands with the Rhenish carnaval which do this as well). During the three days of the carnaval Den Bosch will change its name to Oeteldonk, which by popular belief says "Frog Hill." This name changing tradition is especially common in the towns in and around North Brabant. The tradition to change the city names originates in North Brabant and is seldom seen in Limburg. In Limburg some towns do change their name during carnaval into a dialect version.
Some examples are;
- Ganzegat: Aarle-Rixtel
- Turftreiersriek: America
- Baek: Beek
- De Heksenketel: Beek
- Ganzendonck: Beek en Donk
- Krabbegat: Bergen op Zoom
- Eendengat (Indegat): Boxtel
- Kielegat: Breda
- Bokkenriek: Budel
- Oiverland: Eerde
- Lampegat: Eindhoven
- 't Slotgat: Empel
- Lappegat: Geldrop
- Dringersgat: Gilze
- Ballefruttersgat: Goirle
- Snevelbokkenland: Heeswijk-Dinther
- Kraaienland: Heeze
- Keiebijtersstad / Kattegat: Helmond
- Oeteldonk: 's-Hertogenbosch
- Pezerikkengat: Hilvarenbeek
- Lappelekkursland: Hoogeloon
- Dreumelrijk / Hôrs: Horst
- Blaosdonk: Leende
- Ploegersland: Liempde
- Raopersgat: Lieshout
- Mestreech: Maastricht
- 't Heidurp: Mariahout
- Vlègeldarp: Montferland
- Knotsenburg: Nijmegen
- Kneutergat: Nijnsel
- Skôn Orregat: Oirschot
- Döllekesgat: Oisterwijk
- Kaaiendonk: Oosterhout
- Ossekoppenrijk: Oss
- Boemeldonck: Prinsenbeek
- Pomperstad: Ravenstein
- 't Bremspoersengat: Riethoven
- Wringersgat: Rijen
- Tullepetaonstad: Roosendaal
- Zandhazendorp: Rosmalen
- Moesland: Schaijk
- Schorsbos: Schijndel
- Papgat: Sint-Oedenrode
- Krutjesgat: Son en Breugel
- Kruikestad: Tilburg
- Knoerissenrijk / Keienschijtersrijk: Uden
- 't Bokkeriek: Valkenburg
- Striepersgat: Valkenswaard
- Kuussegat: Veghel
- Rommelgat: Veldhoven
- Jocus Riék: Venlo
- Piëlhaazeriek: Venray
- Pieperland: Volkel
- Dommelbaorzedurp: Vught
- Schoenlapperslaand: Waalwijk
- Keiengat: Waalre
- Reigerland: Zijtaart
Fragment of the left wing of a triptych by Jheronimus Bosch, between 1494 and 1510
Prince Harrie and adjutant of "Keiengat" (Waalre), 2008
Zate Hermenie ("Drunk marching band"), in "Mestreech" (Maastricht), 2007
Group on foot at the carnaval parade in "Rogstaekersstad" (Weert)
Street carnaval, Maastricht, 2006
Youth carnaval parade, Nijswiller, 2007
Batman at the carnaval in the Netherlands
Carnaval parade "Marotteriek" (Sittard), 2008
Prince Frans and adjutant of "Keiengat" (Waalre), 2007
Jester-like orange carnaval costume during the Carnaval in the Netherlands 2013
Man dressed as green monster, in Maastricht, 2013 at the carnaval
Group dressed as Dutch gnomes (kabouters) at the carnaval in the Netherlands, 2013
Rogstaekers (Skates/Ray cutters) on the prince float in "Rogstaekersstad" or "Wieërt" (Weert)
Rogstaekers (Skates/Ray cutters) is the nickname for the inhabitants of Weert during the carnaval days, and the name of the largest carnaval association (1926) of Weert. The name is derived from the "Rogstaekers Legend". Since several years this saga is portrayed on Prince wagon in which the "preens" (prince) closes the "great Rogstaekers parade" on Carnaval Sunday.
- "Oorsprong van het Carnaval in de geschiedenis van Nederland IsGeschiedenis". Isgeschiedenis.nl. 2011-11-11. Retrieved 2013-10-29.
- "Geschiedenis van het carnavalsfeest". Members.ziggo.nl. Retrieved 2013-10-29.
- Katharine M.Briggs, An Encyclopedia of Fairies, Hobgoblins, Brownies, Boogies, and Other Supernatural Creatures, s.v. "Wild Hunt", p 437. ISBN 0-394-73467-X
- einsland, Gro (2005): Norrøn religion. Myter, riter, samfunn. Oslo
- Snorre: Heimskringla, i Snorres kongesagaer, bind I. Gyldendal 2003
- R.A. Koman, '100%Pasen: geloof, bijgeloof en volksgebruiken in Nederland'. Profiel: Bedum, 2012.
- E. Doelman, J. Helsloot (red.): De kleine Olympus: over enkele figuren uit de alledaagse mythologie. Amsterdam, 2008.
- M. Otten, Edda, (Amsterdam: ANBO, 2004), Het lied van Regin (aantekeningen) en het lied van Fafnir (aantekeningen)
- Janssen, L.M. (1993). Nicolaas, de duivel en de doden: opstellen over volkscultuur. Baarn: Ambo
- Booy, F. (2003). Op zoek naar Zwarte Piet: een speurtocht naar de herkomst, de ontwikkeling en de betekenis van de dienaar van Sinterklaas. Eindhoven: Stichting Nationaal Sint Nicolaas Comité
- Hassankhan. R. (1988). Al is hij zo zwart als roet .Den Haag: Warray.
- Heuvel, R. van den (1998). Het verhaal van Sint Nicolaas. Traditie: tijdschrift over tradities en trends, jaargang 4, nummer 4 (winter). P. 17-23.
- "Geschiedenis van carnaval in de middeleeuwen IsGeschiedenis". Isgeschiedenis.nl. Retrieved 2013-10-29.
- Geschiedenis van het persoonlijk leven. Van de renaissance tot de Verlichting. ISBN 90-5157-018-x 1989 Agon, Amsterdam
- Charivari in het oostelijk deel van Noord-Brabant, 1750-1850. Tiny Romme.Oss 1987.
- McNeill, F. Marian. Hallowe'en: its origin, rites and ceremonies in the Scottish tradition. Albyn Press, 1970. pp.29–31
- Jolly, Karen Louise (1992), "Magic, Miracle, and Popular Practice in the Early Medieval West: Anglo-Saxon England", in Neusner, Jacob; Frerichs, Ernest S.; Flesher, Paul Virgil McCracken, Religion, Science, and Magic: In Concert and in Conflict (Oxford University Press): 172, ISBN 978-0-19-507911-1
- "Boerenbruiloft: hoezo in het ‘onecht’ verbonden? | Vastelaovend en Carnaval in Limburg". Vastelaovendinlimburg.nl. 2013-04-08. Retrieved 2013-10-29.
- "De 66 grootste Carnavalskrakers ooit (3)". Muziekweb.nl. Retrieved 2013-10-29.
- "Omroep Brabant: Geschiedenis van carnaval". Omroepbrabant.nl. 2008-11-04. Retrieved 2013-10-29.
- "Omroep Brabant: Geschiedenis van carnaval". Omroepbrabant.nl. 2008-11-04. Retrieved 2013-10-29.
- A.P. Van Gilst, Vastelavond en Carnaval. De geschiedenis van een volksfeest (Veenendaal 1974)
- Th. Fransen, Carnaval ontmaskerd? (Maasbree 1981)
- D.R. Moser, Fastnacht - Fasching - Karneval (Graz/Wenen/Keulen 1986)
- Carnaval. Themanummer van volkscultuur. Tijdschrift over tradities en tijdsverschijnselen 3,1 (1986)
- C. Wijers, Prinsen en Clowns in het Limburgse narrenrijk. Het carnaval in Simpelveld en Roermond 1945-1992 (Amsterdam 1995)
- Knipselarchief Meertens Instituut