MH-1A in 1967
Location of MH-1A
|Country||United States of America|
|Construction began||August 1961|
|Decommission date||March 27, 2014|
|Nuclear power station|
|Fuel type||enriched uranium|
MH-1A was the first floating nuclear power station. Named "Sturgis" after General Samuel D. Sturgis, Jr., this pressurized water reactor built in a converted Liberty ship was part of a series of reactors in the US Army Nuclear Power Program, which aimed to develop small nuclear reactors to generate electrical and space-heating energy primarily at remote, relatively inaccessible sites. Its designation stood for mobile, high power. After its first criticality in 1967, MH-1A was towed to the Panama Canal Zone that it supplied with 10 MW electricity from October 1968 to 1975. Its dismantling was started in 2014 and it is anticipated to be completed in under four years.
The MH-1A was designed as a towed craft because it was expected to stay anchored for most of its life, making it uneconomical to keep the ship's own propulsion system.
The MH-1A had an elaborate analog-computer-powered simulator installed at Ft. Belvoir. The MH-1A simulator was obtained by Memphis State University Center for Nuclear Studies in the early 1980s, but was never restored or returned to operational service. Its fate is unknown after the Center for Nuclear Studies closed.
The reactor was built for the U.S. Army by Martin Marietta under a $17,200,000 contract (August 1961), with construction starting in 1963. The reactor was built in Sturgis, a converted Liberty ship formerly known as SS Charles H. Cugle.
Fort Belvoir, Virginia was the headquarters of the Army Corps of Engineers and, beginning in 1954, the corps' newly created Army Reactors Branch. This unit was established by the Department of Defense to develop compact nuclear power plants that could be utilized to supply heat and power at remote locations. The army's first nuclear power reactor, the SM-1 was built at Fort Belvoir in 1955-57, and was located in the southeast "corner" of the post, alongside Gunston Cove, off the Potomac River. The SM-1 reactor, also known as the Army Package Reactor Program, was used to train nuclear operations personnel for all three services. For that reason, the MH-1A was installed and tested aboard the Sturgis while it was moored in Gunston Cove, near the SM-1 facility.
Dredging of a channel between the main course of the Potomac River to the shoreline of Gunston Cove began on 30 November 1964. At the same time, construction of an access road, power lines and the pier began, just below the SM-1 reactor facility. The Sturgis arrived at the new Gunston Cove pier on 22 April 1966, having been towed from Mobile, Alabama. The MH-1A reactor first went critical on 24 January 1967 and was formally "accepted" by the Army on 25 July 1967. The Sturgis remained at the pier for another 11 months, supplying power to Fort Belvoir, while the Corps of Engineers sought a suitable permanent site. In spring 1968, the US State Department entered into negotiations with the Panama Canal Company, and the Sturgis was towed out of Gunston Cove in late July 1968, arriving Gatun Lake on 7 August.
Panama Canal Zone, 1968-1976
After testing at Fort Belvoir for five months starting in January 1967, "Sturgis" was towed to the Panama Canal Zone. The reactor supplied 10 MW (13,000 hp) electricity to the Panama Canal Zone from October 1968 to 1975.
A water shortage in early 1968 jeopardized both the efficient operation of the Panama Canal locks and the production of hydroelectric power for the Canal Zone. Vast amounts of water were required to operate the locks and the water level on Gatun Lake fell drastically during the December-to-May dry season, necessitated curtailment of operations at Gatun Hydroelectric Station.
Beginning in October 1968 the 10 MW electrical power produced by the MH-1A plant aboard the Sturgis allowed it to replace the power from the Gatun Hydroelectric Station, which freed the lake water for navigation use. To help out further, the Andrew J. Weber, a diesel-fueled power barge of 20 MW capacity was deployed to the Canal Zone in November 1968. These two barges not only contributed to meeting the Canal Zone’s power requirements, but also made possible the saving of vast quantities of water that otherwise would have been needed to operate the hydroelectric power station. The Corps of Engineers estimates that over one trillion gallons were saved (or, rather, freed-up) between October 1968 and October 1972 – enough to permit fifteen additional ships to pass through the locks of the Canal each day.
The ship was moored in Gatun Lake, between the Gatun Locks and the Chagris dam spillway. According to a power engineer who served aboard the Sturgis while it was in Panama, the ship provided augmentation power-generation capacity to the entire Canal Zone, especially during the dry season, which allowed more of the water capacity of Gatun Lake to be used for navigation purposes rather than for hydroelectric power generation. Therefore, the lake could be kept at higher levels. This was critical during this period because of the emergence and growth of the "Panamax" container ship, which tested the draft and dimensional limits of the Canal. Had the Sturgis not been in the Canal Zone, more water would have been used for power generation. This would have lowered the level of Gatun Lake and reduced the allowable draft for transiting vessels, which would have resulted in fewer vessels transiting the canal.
After one year of operations in the Canal Zone, the MH-1A reactor had to be refueled, a process which took one week (17–25 October 1969), according to a 1969 Corps of Engineers report. According to a 2001 report by the Federation of American Scientists, the MH-1A reactor had a total of five cores during its operational life. It used low-enriched uranium (LEU) in the range of 4 to 7 percent, with a total amount of uranium-235 supplied being 541.4 kilograms (for the 5 cores).
The Sturgis was replaced by two 21-MW Hitachi turbines, one on the Pacific side of the isthmus and one on the Atlantic side.
End of Life
Deactivated and Mothballed at James River, 1976-1977
The MH-1A plant was retired from service in 1976 since the Army Reactor Program had been discontinued, and, as a unique prototype, operation cost for the unit was high. Also, the Panama Canal Company acquired additional land based electrical capacity and in 1976 it was determined that the Sturgis was no longer needed. It operated at an effective annual capacity factor of 0.56 over nine years.
Between December 1976 - January 1977, the power barge was towed back to the United States, sustaining storm-related damage so severe that it had to divert to the Military Ocean Terminal at Sunny Point, North Carolina, and undergo temporary structural repairs. Following repairs, the Sturgis was towed to Fort Belvoir, arriving in March 1977. Fuel was removed from the reactor at Fort Belvoir, shipped to the Savannah River Site, and the plant was put into SAFSTOR (safe storage), with decontamination and physical barriers to prevent release of radioactivity. The Sturgis is now moored in the James River outside Fort Eustis, Virginia and is part of the James River Reserve Fleet.
Decommissioning, Dismantling and Disposal, 2014-2018
On March 27, 2014, the US Army Corps of Engineers awarded a $34,663,325.34 contract to Chicago Bridge & Iron (CB&I) for the decommissioning, dismantling and disposal of the MH-1A nuclear reactor which is installed on the Sturgis barge. The reactor had already been de-fueled, decontaminated, and sealed before being towed to the James River Reserve Fleet. According to the decommissioning plan the Sturgis will be relocated to Galveston, Texas, where CB&I will remove the residual radioactive waste materials. After that the remaining portions of the barge will be transported to Brownsville, Texas, for disposal or recycling as scrap, using standard ship breaking methods – the entire process was as of 2014 anticipated to be completed in under four years. The move to Galveston, originally planned for September, 2014, was delayed waiting for the city to issue a permit for the decommissioning. The Army started the move in April, 2015, to be completed in mid-May.
- Highly Enriched Uranium: Striking A Balance, p.4, retrieved 2010 Oct 25
- Report to Congress on Small Modular Nuclear Reactors, p.16, retrieved 2010 Oct 25
- Army Nuclear Power Program, accessed 14 March 2012.[dead link]
- See list of Liberty ships
- NBC Report, Spring/Summer 1998, Army Reactor Program,“Army Reactor Office: The Second Year”, pp.4-6; accessed 10 March 2012.
- Suid, Lawrence H. The Army's Nuclear Power Program: Evolution of a Support Agency (1990); (Greenwood Publishing: New York) page 101; accessed 13 March 2012.
- Distribution Restriction Statement; Historical Vignettes, Volume II; by Historical Division, Office of Administrative Services, Office of the Chief of Engineers, 1979; "Emergency Power: the Nuclear Power Barge Sturgis in the Canal Zone", by Kenneth J. Deacon, pp.43-44; accessed 14 March 2012.
- Letter to the Editor: Question about an old Nuke- Where was Sturgis moored?, The Panama News, February 3–16, 2008; accessed 14 March 2012
- C. Frederick, Sears (1969). Army engineer reactors group fort Belvoir va engineering div., ed. MH-1A REFUELING, 17-25 OCTOBER 1969. Defense Technical Information Center. p. 39.
- Highly Enriched Uranium: Striking a Balance - Appendix D: Military Reactors (p.146), January 2001 FAS report ; accessed 14 March 2012.
- Letters to the Editor, letter by LaMar T. Sizemore regarding his service aboard Sturgis in Panama, ENGINEER: The Professional Bulletin for Army Engineers, October 2000; accessed 14 March 2011.[dead link]
- MH-1A - First Nuclear Power Barge: Pioneer Barge Built in America, retrieved 2010 Oct 25
- Star-News - No nuclear leak on barge, January 11, 1977
- Characterization Of The Nuclear Barge Sturgis, includes diagrams and photographs, 2002, retrieved October 25, 2010
- STURGIS – US Army Corps of Engineers, Baltimore District
- CB&I Announces Nuclear Decommissioning and Dismantlement Award
- Suid, Lawrence (1990). The Army's nuclear power program : the evolution of a support agency. New York: Greenwood Press. pp. 99–107. ISBN 0-313-27226-3.
- Asimov, Isaac (1980). Worlds Within Worlds: The Story of Nuclear Energy. The Minerva Group, Inc. p. 139. ISBN 978-0-89875-001-0.