Peter Scot

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Peter Scot
TypeIndian whisky
ManufacturerKhoday India Limited (KIL)
Country of originIndia
IntroducedMay 1968
Alcohol by volume42.8%
Related products

Peter Scot is a brand of Indian whisky, manufactured by Khoday India Limited (KIL), and launched in May 1968. It is a flagship brand of the company[1] and is manufactured at their Bangalore facility.[2] In Khoday Distilleries Limited vs. The Scotch Whisky Association and Others, Peter Warren, an employee of Khoday, told the Supreme Court of India that the brand name Peter Scot was made up using his father's first name, "Peter", and his nationality, "Scot". Another factor in choosing the name was due to the British explorer, Captain Scott, and his son Peter Scott. Although the name "Scott" is spelt with two t's, it is phonetically the same as the word Scot.[3][4] The brand's main competitors are Pernod Ricard's Blenders Pride and United Spirits Limited's Royal Challenge.[5][6]

History[edit]

Khoday India Limited (KIL) began producing Peter Scot whisky in May 1968,[7] and registered the trademark in 1974. In 1986, the Scotch Whisky Association (SWA) moved the Assistant Registrar Trademarks for cancellation of the Peter Scot trademark. The SWA claimed that the name was deceptively similar to 'Scotch', which allegedly lead consumers to believe that the product had a Scottish connection.[8] The Registrar ordered the deletion of the Peter Scot trademark in 1989. However, the decision was reversed several times, until a single-judge bench of the Madras High Court, followed by an identical order from the Division bench of the same Court ruled in favour of the SWA. The Court ruled that "the adoption of a name which indicates the geographical region even when the goods had no connection with that place, was itself dishonest". KIL appealed the 12 October 2007 high court order in the Supreme Court, arguing that SWA had knowledge about registration of the trademark as early as September 1974, but had waited for more than 12 years to move the Registrar. On 27 May 2008, the Supreme Court ruled in favour of KIL, allowing it to keep the Peter Scot trademark.[9]

In its judgment, the Supreme Court considered the tests applied by courts in England, Australia and the United States regarding the deceptive similarity of goods. The Court also referred to a passage in Kerly's Law of Trade Marks and Trade Names and ruled that, "the goods are expensive and not of a kind usually selected without deliberation and the customers are generally educated persons which are all matters to be considered". It also held that "where the class of buyers is educated and rich, the test to be applied is different where the product would be purchased by the villagers, the illiterate and the poor". The Court reached the conclusion that the trademark concerned a class of buyers who were expected to know the value of money, the quality and content of Scotch whisky and the difference in the process of manufacture, the place of manufacture and their origin.[3] The judgement also stated that "the Trademark Registrar as well as the high court failed to apply the consumer's knowledge test to the issue and hence arrived at a wrong conclusion".[10] The SWA described the Supreme Court verdict as "inexplicable".[11][12] The SWA petition seeking a review of the judgment was dismissed by the Supreme Court in February 2009.[13]

Khoday began exporting Peter Scot to Italy in October 2007.[14]

References[edit]

  1. ^ "Khoday's adds strength to liquor business". The Hindu. 2001-02-14. Retrieved 2013-08-11.
  2. ^ "Khoday Red Knight Whisky storms into south Indian markets". Fnbnews.com. 2007-12-08. Retrieved 2013-08-11.
  3. ^ a b "Scotch Whisky in Supreme Court". The Indian Express. 2008-07-06. Retrieved 2013-08-11.
  4. ^ "Khoday's". Khodaygroup.com. Retrieved 2013-08-11.
  5. ^ "UB expects CSD sales to boost Signature whisky". Business Line. 2004-02-05. Retrieved 2013-08-11.
  6. ^ Anil Urs (2002-10-03). "McDowell's Signature to enter defence canteen stores". The Economic Times. TNN. Retrieved 2013-08-11.
  7. ^ "SUPREME COURTS BARS CHALLENGE TO "PETER SCOT" ON PRINCIPLES OF ACQUIESCENCE AND/ OR WAIVER" (PDF). Retrieved 2013-08-11.
  8. ^ "No half measures for Scotch whisky". BBC News. 2008-06-26. Retrieved 2013-08-11.
  9. ^ Dhananjay Mahapatra (2008-05-28). "Scotch or not, 'Peter Scot' won't be banned: SC". The Times Of India. TNN. Retrieved 2013-08-11.
  10. ^ Dhananjay Mahapatra (2008-05-30). "'Made in India' tag can't fool Scotch whisky drinkers: SC". The Times Of India. TNN. Retrieved 2013-08-11.
  11. ^ Boby Kurian (2008-05-31). "Scotch body may take local Scot to WTO". The Economic Times. TNN. Retrieved 2013-08-11.
  12. ^ "Whisky lobbyists keep spirits up after 20 years in court". The Scotsman. 2008-05-31. Retrieved 2013-08-11.
  13. ^ "The Hindu News Update Service". The Hindu. 2009-02-04. Retrieved 2013-08-11.
  14. ^ Khoday to export whiskies to Europe - Economic Times. Articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com (2007-10-01). Retrieved on 2013-12-23.

External links[edit]