Taiwanese people

Taiwanese people
臺灣人 or 台灣人

Jay Chou Ang Lee Lien Chan Chien-Ming Wang Vivian Hsu Yani Tseng Kai-Fu Lee Lee Teng-hui
Total population
23,239,268
Regions with significant populations
United States	919,000[1]
Indonesia	208,000[2]
Canada	160,774[3]
Thailand	140,000[4]
Brazil	70,000[5]
Japan	61,000[6]
Singapore	60,000[7]
Vietnam	56,000[8]
Malaysia	45,000[9]
Brunei	30,000[10]
Australia	28,000[11]
Philippines	22,213
South Korea	20,981
Costa Rica	14,000[12]
France	10,000[13]
Argentina	10,000[14]
New Zealand	10,000[15]
South Africa	10,000[16]
Germany	7,000[17]
United Kingdom	6,000[18]
Languages
Taiwanese Mandarin • Taiwanese Hokkien • Hakka Indigenous Taiwanese languages
Religion
Buddhism • Christianity • Confucianism • Taoism non-religious and others
Related ethnic groups
Han Chinese people • Austronesian people Taiwanese aborigines

Taiwanese people (traditional Chinese: 臺灣人 also 台灣人; simplified Chinese: 台湾人; pinyin: Táiwān rén; Pe̍h-ōe-jī: Tâi-oân-lâng) may refer to individuals who either claim or are imputed cultural identity focused on the island of Taiwan and/or Taiwan Area which have been governed by the Republic of China (ROC) since 1945. At least three competing (occasionally overlapping) paradigms are used to identify someone as a Taiwanese person: a nationalist criteria, self-identification (including the concept of "New Taiwanese") criteria, and socio-cultural criteria. These standards are fluid, in keeping with an evolving social and political milieu. The complexity resulting from competing and evolving standards is compounded by a larger dispute regarding Taiwan's identity crisis, the political status of Taiwan, and its potential de jure Taiwan independence or political integration with the People's Republic of China.

According to official governmental statistics, 98% of Taiwan's population is made up of Han Chinese, while 2% are Taiwanese aborigines. The composite category of "Taiwanese people" is often reputed by many Taiwanese to include a significant population of at least four constituent ethnic groups: the Hoklo (70%), the Hakka (15%), Mainlander (13%), and Taiwanese aborigines (2%) (Copper 2003:12–13; Hsiao 2004:105). Although the concept of the "four great ethnic groups" was a deliberate attempt by the Hoklo-dominated Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) to defuse Taiwanese–Mainlander tensions, this conception has become a dominant frame of reference for dealing with Taiwanese ethnic and national issues (Makeham 2005:4–5). Despite the wide use of the "four great ethnic groups" in public discourse as essentialized identities, the relationships between the peoples of Taiwan have been in a constant state of convergence and negotiation for centuries. The continuing process of cross-ethnic mixing with ethnicities from within and outside Taiwan, combined with the disappearance of ethnic barriers due to a shared socio-political experience, has led to the emergence of "Taiwanese" as a larger ethnic group (Harrell & Huang 1994:14–15).

Definitions of Taiwanese

With President Chiang Kai-shek, the U.S. President Dwight D. Eisenhower waved hands to Taiwanese people during his visit to Taipei in June 1960.

Although group identity is often claimed on the basis of race and culture, for Taiwanese specifically, it is held together by a common socio-political experience.(Corcuff 2000) Any connection Taiwanese may have with one another is purely subjective, based on the shared belief in a common destiny stemming from the very real parameters of daily life, including government, economy, education, popular culture and mass media (Anderson 1983; Hsiau 2000:10–14). Political leaders often attempt to manipulate and fix identities for political gain, by assigning an essentialist identity to a community.

Identities are not fixed, but fluid and change with time and memory or in response to a changing environment rather than stemming from a primordial or authentic source.(Bhabha 1994:1; Brown 2004:5). New identities are continually emerging based on individuals’ perceptions of commonalities and differences as the patterns of local communities, kinship and language pattern usage change with economic, cultural and demographic change, and on the national experience (Harrell 1996:5).

The word "Taiwanese people" has multiple meanings and can refer to one of the following:

• the various ethnic groups living or born in Taiwan, its minor islands, Penghu islands today etc.
• All citizens of the Republic of China. Those who hold the citizenship (nationality) of the Republic of China, not necessarily those based in Taiwan or Penghu, but also include those living in Kinmen, Matsu Islands and other ruling territory of the Republic of China
• Ancestors who before the Japanese rule of Taiwan had moved to the island of Taiwan, its minor islands, Penghu islands etc. This includes the ancient Yue people, Han-Chinese, Taiwanese aborigines as well as Dutch people. In addition, this includes Japanese migrants from Japan to Taiwan during the Japanese rule of Taiwan and their descendents today.
• People living outside Taiwan before or after 1949, but are of Taiwanese ancestry or descent, who may live in other territories such as People's Republic of China and do not necessarily hold the nationality of the Republic of China. They may not necessarily be born or live in Taiwan. Outside Taiwan, they are typically known as "Overseas Taiwanese" or "people of Taiwanese descent" ("taiyi 台裔", "tairen 台人")
• Besides the factors as above for consideration, whether one identify oneself as a Taiwanese, depends also on how a person and another person (predominantly those of kinship)'s self-identification. Consideration of sets of Values are important as well.

The history of Taiwanese identity

The earliest notion of a Taiwanese group identity emerged in the form of a national identity following the Qing Dynasty's ceding of Taiwan to Japan in the Treaty of Shimonoseki in 1895 (Morris 2002:3–6). Prior to Japanese rule, residents of Taiwan developed relationships based on class solidarity and social connections rather than ethnic identity. Although Han often cheated Aborigines, they also married and supported one another against other residents of the same ethnic background. Taiwan was the site of frequent feuding based on ethnicity, lineage and place of origin (Lamley 1981; Harrell 1990; Shepherd 1993:310–323).

Japanese era

Taiwanese in the Japanese colonial era

In the face of the Japanese colonial hierarchy, the people of Taiwan were faced with the unequal binary relationship between colonizer/colonized. This duality between "one" and "other" was evident in the seven years of violence between the Japanese and groups of united anti-Japanese Han and Aborigines (Katz 2005). Only later did the Japanese attempt to incorporate Taiwanese into the Japanese identity as "loyal subjects", but the difference between the experience of the colonized and the colonizer polarized the two groups (Fujii 2006:70–73).

The concept of "race" was utilized as a tool to confirm and facilitate Japanese political policies. A system of household registers based on the notion of race to separate and define groups of subjects. From within the group of "non-Japanese" the government divided Han citizens into "Han" and "Hakka" based on their perception of linguistic and cultural differences. The Japanese also maintained the Qing era classification of aborigines as either "raw" or "cooked" (Brown 2004:8), which to the Japanese embodied the social ramification of ethnic origin and perceived loyalty to the empire (Wolf & Huang 1980:19).

Martial law era

Non-Kuomintang Taiwanese politician Wu San-lian (2L) celebrated his landslide victory (65.5%) in the first-time Taipei city mayoral election in January 1951 with his supporters. Taipei has been the capital of Taiwan since December 1949.

In 1945, Taiwan entered the political sphere of the Republic of China (ROC). Shortly following the Kuomintang's arrival, however, social conflict erupted in the midst of rampant government corruption, soaring inflation and an increasing flow of immigrants from China. The latter were preferred for jobs in the civil service as opposed to Taiwanese who were regarded as "untrustworthy"(Phillips 2003:8–9). Recurrent violent suppression of dissent also played an important role in enforcing a separate sense of "Taiwanese-ness" (Gates 1981:253–275).

Under the Kuomintang's structure, "Taiwanese" became a strong "regional" identity. The term has often been used synonymously with benshengren, a term which covered both Hoklo and Hakka whose ancestors arrived in Taiwan before the Japanese restrictions on immigration in 1895. "Taiwanese" was used in contrast with waishengren (mainlanders), who included the people who followed the KMT to Taiwan between 1945 and 1949 and their descendants. The government tended to stress provincial identities, with identification cards and passports issued until the late 1990s displaying one's ancestral province and county. During this period the terms "cooked" and "raw" Aborigines disappeared. The former "raw" Aborigines were termed Shandi Tongbao, Gaoshanzu (Mountain Race) or Gaoshan Tongbao (Mountain Compatriots).

Democratic era

With Taiwan's political liberalization in the 1970s and 1980s, encouraged by Taiwan's changing international status, the concept of a "Taiwanese people" became politicized by opponents of the KMT. The "tang wai" movement deployed concepts of "Taiwanese identity" against the authoritarian KMT government, often using extreme tactics to build a short-term ethno-centric opposition to the KMT (Edmunson 2002:34–42). The campaign saw resonance with the people of Taiwan and the term "Taiwanese" has been used by politicians of all parties to refer to the electorate in an effort to secure votes. The concept of a separate Taiwanese identity has become such an integral factor to the election culture in Taiwan, that identifying as a Taiwanese has become essential to being elected in Taiwan (Corcuff 2002:243–249).

New Taiwanese

The term "New Taiwanese" (新台灣人) was coined by former President of the Republic of China, Lee Teng-hui in 1995 to bridge the ethnic cleavage which formed following the February 28 Incident in 1947 and characterized the frigid relations between waishengren and benshengren during forty years of martial law. Although the "xin Taiwan guan" (新臺灣觀; New Taiwanese Concept) or "xin Taiwan lun" (新台灣論; The debate on the new Taiwanese identity) was originally aimed at the successive generations of Taiwanese with mainlander ancestry, it has been further articulated by Lee and other political and social leaders to refer to any person who loves Taiwan and is committed to calling Taiwan home. Although critics have called the "New Taiwanese Concept" a political ploy to win votes from benshengren who regarded the KMT as an alien regime, it has remained an important factor in the dialectic between ethnic identities in Taiwan. Despite being adopted early on by former Provincial Governor James Soong (1997) and later by, then Taipei mayoral candidate Ma Ying-jeou (1999), the term has since been dropped from contemporary political rhetoric (Corcuff 2002:186–188).

Multicultural present

In contemporary Taiwan the phenomenon of mixed marriages between couples comprising different ethnic groups has grown to include people from the Indian subcontinent, southeast Asia, the Philippines, Europe, the Americas and the Pacific Islands. The increasing number of marriages between Taiwanese and other countries creates a problem for the rigid definitions of ethnic identity used by both the ROC and the PRC when discussing Taiwan (Harrell 1995). In one-fourth of all marriages in Taiwan today, one partner will be from another country and one out of every twelve children is born to a family of mixed parentage. As Taiwan's birthrate is among the lowest in the world, this contingent is playing an increasingly important role in changing Taiwan's demographic makeup. By 2010, this social-cultural group of people is typically known as "Taiwan's new resident" (Taiwan Xinzhumin 台灣新住民）.

Self identification

Main article: Taiwan independence

In a 2002 poll by the Democratic Progressive Party, over 50% of the respondents considered themselves "Taiwanese" only, up from less than 20% in 1991 (Dreyer 2003). In a poll released in December 2006 by the Straits Exchange Foundation (SEF), 57% of people on Taiwan consider themselves to be Taiwanese. 23% Chinese and 20% both Chinese and Taiwanese (China Post, 2006). In June 2008, according to a poll from a Taiwanese mainstream media TVBS, when the respondents are not told that a Taiwanese can also be a Chinese, 68% of the respondents identify themselves as "Taiwanese" while 18% would call themselves "Chinese".

The sense of a collective Taiwanese identity has continued to increase despite fluctuations in support for pro-independence political parties. This has been cited as evidence that the concept of Taiwanese identity is not the product of local political manipulation, but an actual phenomenon of ethnic and sociopolitical identities (Corcuff 2002:137–149, 207; Hsiao 2003:157–170).

History of the major socio-cultural groups

According to the government, the majority of Taiwan's 23.2 million population consist of 98% Han Chinese (GIO 2004) with a minority Austronesian population of less than 500,000. Migration to Taiwan from southern Asia began approximately 12,000 BC, but large-scale migration to Taiwan did not occur until the 18th to the beginning of the 20th century as a result of political and economic chaos in Mainland China (Shepherd 1993; Bellwood 2000; Blust 1988). The first large scale migration occurred as a result of the Manchu invasion and conquest of China, overthrowing the Ming dynasty and establishing the Qing dynasty, which was established in 1644 and remained until 1911.

In 1624, the Dutch East India Company established an outpost in Tainan in southern Taiwan after expelling the Spanish. The Dutch soon realized Taiwan's potential as a colony for trading deer hide, venison, rice, and sugar. However, Aborigines were not interested in developing the land and transporting settlers from Europe would be too costly. Due to the resulting labor shortage, the Dutch hired Han farmers from across the Taiwan Strait who fled the Manchu invasion of Ming dynasty China (Andrade 2006). During the Guo Huaiyi Rebellion, the Dutch massacred these Hoklo settlers on Taiwan. Koxinga brought along many more Chinese settlers during the Siege of Fort Zeelandia in which he expelled the Dutch. Migration of male laborers from Fujian, steadily increased into the 18th and 19th century. In time, this migration and the gradual removal of ethnic markers (coupled with the acculturation, intermarriage and assimilation of plains Aborigines with the Han) resulted in the wide spread adoption of Han patterns of behavior making Taiwanese Han the ethnic majority.

It was not until the Japanese arrival in 1895 that Taiwanese first developed a collective Taiwanese identity in contrast to that of the colonizing Japanese (Morris 2002). When the Chinese Civil War broke out between Kuomintang nationalists and the Chinese communists in 1945, there was another mass migration of people from Mainland China to Taiwan fleeing the communists. These migrants are known as the Mainlanders. The descendants of Hoklo, Hakka and plains Aborigines who have lived together on Taiwan for over four hundred years and have come to be known as benshengren, or native Taiwanese.

Aborigines

A group of Taiwanese aborigines

Main article: Taiwanese aborigines

Taiwanese aborigines or Aboriginal peoples (Chinese: 原住民; pinyin: yuánzhùmín; Wade–Giles: yüan²-chu⁴-min²; Pe̍h-ōe-jī: gôan-chū-bîn; lit. 'original inhabitants') are the indigenous peoples of Taiwan. Their ancestors are believed to have been living on the islands for approximately 8,000 years before major Han Chinese immigration began in the 17th century (Blust 1999). Taiwan's Austronesian speakers were traditionally distributed over much of the island's rugged central mountain range and concentrated in villages along the alluvial plains. Today, the bulk of the contemporary Taiwanese aborigine population reside in the mountains and the major cities. The total population of Aborigines on Taiwan is around 458,000 as of January 2006, (CIP 2006) which is approximately 2% of Taiwan's population. The cities of Yilan, Hualien, and Taitung are known for their aboriginal communities. In the 1990s several groups of recognized indigenous tribes, which had traditionally viewed themselves as separate, united under the singular ethnonym '原住民' or 'Aborigines' (Stainton 1999).

A 2007 study found that 85% of Taiwanese Hoklo and Hakka have varying degrees of aboriginal genes.

Hoklo

The Hoklo communities in Taiwan originated from male refugees from Fujian, some of whom married into Lowland Taiwanese aborigine communities. They fled the Manchu invasion of China and revolved against the Dutch in the Guo Huaiyi Rebellion. More of them came over during the Siege of Fort Zeelandia in which they expelled the Dutch. Official statistics show that Aborigines make-up less than 2% of Taiwan's population, they are often referring to those citizens who the government identifies as Aborigines and may not reflect actual identification or hybridity. There are fragmented populations of lowland Aborigines who still acknowledge their identity and heritage throughout Taiwan. Others have assimilated to a degree where their descendants speak Taiwanese and identify with the Hoklo majority, and it is possible to find families where the older members still identify themselves as lowland aborigine, while the rest of the family may identify as Hoklo. Among the Hoklo, the common idiom, "has Tangshan father, no Tangshan mother" (有唐山公、無唐山媽, ū-tn̂g-soaⁿ-gong, bô-tn̂g-soaⁿ-má) refers how the Han people crossing the Taiwan Strait were mostly male, whereas their offspring would be through marriage with female Taiwanese aborigines. It is also called Min. The Hoklo were sometimes called "Chinese Formosans" by westerners.

Hakka

The Taiwanese Hakka communities, although arriving to Taiwan from Eastern Guangdong and the mountains of Fujian, have also likely mixed through intermarriage with lowland Aborigines as well. Hakka family trees are known for identifying the male ancestors by their ethnic Hakka heritage while leaving out information on the identity of the female ancestors. Also, during the process of intermarriage and assimilation, many of the lowland Aborigines and their families adopted Hoklo and Hakka family names. Much of this happened in Taiwan prior to the Japanese colonization of Taiwan, so that by the time of the Japanese colonization, most of the population that the Japanese classified as "Chinese" Hoklo and "Chinese" Hakka were in truth already of mixed ancestry. Physical features of both Taiwanese aborigine and Chinese can be found amongst the Taiwanese mainstream today. It is also believed by many scholars that the Hakka of Taiwan are mainly the descendants of Hakka assimilated ethnic She people from the mountainous area between Fujian and Guangdong, with linguistic relations to Min-nan speakers (Norman 1988).

Mainlander

The descendants of mainlanders settled first within the heart of large urban centers in Taiwan such as Taipei, Taichung, or Kaohsiung. High numbers of government officials and civil servants who followed the KMT to Taiwan and occupied the positions of the colonial government moved into the official dormitories and residences built by the Japanese for civil servants. The ghettoization of mainlander communities exacerbated the divisions imagined by non-mainlander groups, and stymied cultural integration and assimilation into mainstream Taiwanese culture (Gates 1981). Nationalization campaigns undertaken by the KMT established an official "culture", which reflected the KMT government's own preference for what it considered authentic Chinese culture. This excluded many of the local Taiwanese practices and local cultures, including the diverse cultures brought to Taiwan by the mainlanders from all parts of China (Wachman 1994). Unlike, the Hoklo and Hakka of Taiwan, who felt excluded by the new government, the mainlanders and their families supported the nationalists and embraced the official "culture" as their own, with "national culture" being taught in school (Wilson 1970). The mainlanders used their embrace of Nationalist culture to identify themselves as the authentic Chinese people of Taiwan. People identifying themselves as "mainlanders" can now be found in all parts of Taiwan, and through government agriculture and construction campaigns of the 1960s, "mainlander" communities or mixed marriage communities have been established in the high mountains and along the east coast.

New residents or immigrants

This group, known as Taiwan Xinzhumin (台灣新住民), consists of mainly new residents, originally from other nations, who have either migrated to Taiwan or inter-married with a local Taiwanese. The majority of new residents originated from Vietnam, Indonesia, Thailand, Philippine, Europe, America etc.

Genetic studies

Both Chinese and Taiwanese nationalists have often tried to validate their political claims based on biology and implied ancestry. Despite the advancement of genetic research and diaspora studies of human populations around the globe, there is no clear evidence to suggest any correlation between genetic or biological similarities or differences, and political or national identities.

The Hoklo and Hakka linguistic groups, which statistically make up the majority of Taiwan's population, can trace some of their historical cultural roots to Minnan- and Hakka-speaking peoples from what is now China, predominantly the southern provinces of Fujian and Guangdong. The original migrations from China were as male laborers under contract to the Dutch, so there was considerable intermarriage with local plains aboriginal groups. The human leukocyte antigen typing study and mitochondrial DNA analysis performed in recent years show that more than 88% of the benshengren population have some degree of aboriginal origin (Sim 2003). However, a 2009 study questioned such findings and indicated that "the great number of Han immigrants after the 18th century is the main reason to consider that the early genetic contribution from Plains Indigenes to Taiwanese Han has been largely diluted and no longer exists in any meaningful way." The lack of a totally complete and definite set of genetic record of plains Aborigines, or conclusive understanding of their proto-Austronesian roots, further complicates the use of genetic data (Blust 1988). A Mahalanobis generalized distance survey of 29 male groups categorized Taiwanese as a separate subgroup of Northern Asian different from Mongolia, Korea, Shanghai, Nanjing and Hangzhou, associating Taiwanese closer to groups from Hainan, Japan, Ainu and Atayal (Pietrusewsky 2000:400–409).

Notable Taiwanese people

Main article: List of Taiwanese people

See also

• Demographics of Taiwan
• Taiwanese aborigines
• Hoklo people
• Hakka people
• List of Taiwanese people
• List of ethnic groups in Taiwan
• Taiwanese nationalism

References

• Anderson, Benedict (1983), Imagined Communities, NY: Verso Press.
• Andrade, Tonio (2006), "The Rise and Fall of Dutch Taiwan, 1624–1662: Cooperative Colonization and the Statist Model of European Expansion", Journal of World History, 17 (4).
• Bellwood, Peter (2000), "Formosan Pre-History and Austronesian Dispersal", in Blundell, David (ed.), Austronesian Taiwan: Linguistics, History, Ethnology and Prehistory, Berkley, CA: University of California Press.
• Blust, Robert (1988), Austronesian Root Theory, Amsterdam: John Benjamin's Press.
• Blust, Robert (1999), "Subgrouping, circularity and extinction: some issues in Austronesian comparative linguistics", in E. Zeitoun & P.J.K Li (ed.), Selected papers from the Eighth International Conference on Austronesian Linguistics, Taipei: Academia Sinica, pp. 31–94.
• Brown, Melissa J (2004), Is Taiwan Chinese:The Impact of Culture, Power and Migration of Changing Identities, Berkley, CA: University of California Press.
• Bhabha, Homi K (1994), The Location of Culture, London, UK: Routledge.
• Council of Indigenous Peoples, Executive Yuan (2006), Statistics of Indigenous Population in Taiwan and Fukien Areas.
• Constable, Nicole (1996), "Introduction", in Constable, Nicole (ed.), Guest People:Hakka Identity in China and Abroad, Seattle, WA: University of Washington Press.
• Copper, John (2003), Taiwan: Nation State or Province? (Fourth Edition), Boulder, CO: Westview press.
• Corcuff, Stephane (2000), "Taiwan's "Mainlanders": A New Ethnic Category", China Perspectives no.28 April–June.
• Corcuff, Stephane (2002), "Taiwan's "Mainlanders", New Taiwanese?", in Stephane Corcuff (ed.), Memories of the Future:National Identity Issues and A New Taiwan, London: M.E. Sharpe.
• Crossley, Pamela Kyle (1999), A Translucent Mirror: History and Identity in Qing Imperial Ideology, Berkley, CA: University of California Press.
• Dikotter, Frank (1992), The Discourse of Race in Modern China, Berkley, CA: Stanford University Press.
• Dreyer, June Teufel (2003), "Taiwan's Evolving Identity", Paper presented at the Woodrow Wilson International Institute for Scholars, Washington, D.C., July 17.
• Ebrey, Patricia (1996), "Surnames and Han Chinese Identity", in Melissa J. Brown (ed.), Negotiating Ethnicities in China and Taiwan, Berkeley, CA: University of California
• Fujii, Shozo (2006), "The Formation of Taiwanese Identity and the Policy of Outside Regimes", in Liao Ping-Hui and David Wang Der-Wei (ed.), Taiwan Under Japanese Colonial Rule, 1895-1945:History, Culture, Memory, New York: Columbia University Press.
• Gates, Hill (1981), "Ethnicity and Social Class", in Ahern, Emily Martin and Gates, Hill (ed.), The Anthropology of Taiwanese Society, CA: Stanford University Press{{citation}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: editors list (link).
• Government Information Office, Republic of China (2004) (2006), A Brief Introduction to Taiwan, retrieved March 29, 2007{{citation}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link).
• Harrell, Stevan, ed. (1995), Cultural Encounters on China's Ethnic Frontiers, Seattle: University of Washington Press.
• Harrell, Steven; Huang, Chun-chieh (1994), "Introduction", Cultural Change in Postwar Taiwan, Boulder,CO: Westview Press.

• Hsiao, A-Chin (2004), Contemporary Taiwanese Cultural Nationalism, London: Routledge Press.
• Hsieh, Jolan (2006), Collective Rights of Indigenous Peoples: Identity Based Movement of Plains Indinenous in Taiwan, New York: Routledge Press.
• Lamley, Harry (1981), "Sub Ethnic Rivalry in the Ch'ing Period", in Ahern, Emily Martin and Gates, Hill (ed.), The Anthropology of Taiwanese Society, CA: Stanford University Press{{citation}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: editors list (link).
• Katz, Paul (2005), When the Valleys Turned Blood Red: The Ta-Pa-Ni Incident in Colonial Taiwan, Honolulu, HA: University of Hawaii Press.
• Lin, Marie (2001), "The origin of Minnan and Hakka, the so-called "Taiwanese", inferred by HLA study", Tissue Antigens, 57 (3), doi:10.1034/j.1399-0039.2001.057003192.x, PMID 11285126.
• Makeham, John (2005), "Introduction", in Makeham, John; Bentuhua, A-Chin Hsiau (eds.), Cultural, Ethnic, and Political Nationalism in Contemporary Taiwan, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
• Marsh, Robert (2002), "National Identity and Ethnicity in Taiwan", in Stephane Corcuff (ed.), Memories of the Future: National Identity Issues and A New Taiwan, London: M.E. Sharpe.
• Martin, Howard (1996), "The Hakka Ethnic Movement in Taiwan", in Constable, Nicole (ed.), Guest People:Hakka Identity in China and Abroad, Seattle, WA: University of Washington Press.
• Morris, Andrew (2002), Corcuff, Stephane (ed.), Memories of the Future: National Identity Issues and The Search for a New Taiwan, New York: M.E. Sharpe.
• Norman, Jerry (1988), Chinese:Cambridge Language Surveys, UK: Cambridge University Press.
• Peng, Ming-min (1971), A Taste of Freedom:Memoirs of a Formosan Independence Leader, Chicago, New York, London: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
• Pietrusewsky, Michael (2000), "Metric Analysis of Skeletal Remains: Methods and Applications", in Katzenberg, Anne; Saunders, Shelly (eds.), Biological Anthropology of the Human Skeleton, New York: Wiley-Liss, Inc..
• Phillips, Steven E. (2003), Between Assimilation and Independence: The Taiwanese Encounter Nationalist China, 1945-1950, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, ISBN 0-8047-4457-2.
• Said, Edward (1979), Orientalism, UK: Vintage Books.
• Sim, Kiantek (2003), Taiwan Xue Tong (Taiwan Blood Types), Taipei: Qian Wei Press.
• Shepherd, John R (1993), Statecraft and Political Economy on the Taiwan Frontier 1600-1800, Ca: Stanford University Press.
• Stone, Anne C (2002), "Ancient DNA from Skeletal Remains", in Katzenberg, Anne; Saunders, Shelly (eds.), Biological Anthropology of the Human Skeleton, New York: Wiley-Liss, Inc..
• Stainton, Michael (1999), "The Politics of Taiwan Aboriginal Origins", in Murray A. Rubinstein (ed.), Taiwan A New History, New York: M.E. Sharpe, Inc.
• Teng, Emma JinHua (2004), Taiwan's Imagined Geography:Chinese Travel Writing and Pictures 1683-1895, MA: The Harvard University Asia Center.
• Wachman, Alan A (1994), Taiwan: National Identity and Democratization, New York: M.E. Sharpe.
• Wilson, Richard W (1970), The Political Socialization of Children in Taiwan, MA: M.I.T. Press.
• Wolf, Arthur; Huang, Chieh-shan (1980), Marriage and Adoption in China, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
• Wu, David Y.H (2002), "The Construction of Chinese and Non-Chinese Identities", in Susan D. Blum and Lionel M. Jenson (ed.), China Off Center: Mapping the Margins of the Middle Kingdom, HA: University of Hawaii Press.

External links

• The Hakka People
• Taiwanese Hakka
• Taiwan, Bureau of East Asian and Pacific Affairs, U.S. Department of State