Italian Brazilians: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
Paulista01 (talk | contribs)
mNo edit summary
Opinoso (talk | contribs)
Adding fact tags to conclusions that seem to be based on nothing. Moreover, one source claiming that 10% and another that 15% are of Italian descent doesn't seem to be a "contraditions" (only 5%)
Line 69: Line 69:
==Statistics==
==Statistics==


The Brazilian Censuses do not ask questions about "ethnic origin", so there are no systematically comparable data about the impact of Italian immigration. Varied entities, mainly the Italian diplomatic system and commercial associations that promote bilateral commerce between Brazil and Italy, make claims about the figures of ''oriundi'' in Brazil, but none links to any actual survey. Also, if they are extrapolations of actual data on the number of immigrants, the calculations are not explained anywhere.
The Brazilian Censuses do not ask questions about "ethnic origin", so there are no systematically comparable data about the impact of Italian immigration{{Citation needed|date=March 2010}} . Varied entities, mainly the Italian diplomatic system and commercial associations that promote bilateral commerce between Brazil and Italy {{Citation needed|date=March 2010}}, make claims about the figures of ''oriundi'' in Brazil, but none links to any actual survey. Also, if they are extrapolations of actual data on the number of immigrants, the calculations are not explained anywhere.{{Citation needed|date=March 2010}}


On the other hand, in 1998, the IBGE, within its preparation for the 2000 Census, experimentally introduced a question about "origem" (ancestry) in its "Pesquisa Mensal de Emprego" (Monthly Employment Research), in order to test the viability of introducing that variable in the Census<ref>http://www.schwartzman.org.br/simon/pdf/origem.pdf p.3</ref> (the IBGE ended by deciding against the inclusion of questions about it in the Census). This research interviewed about 90,000 people in six metropolitan regions (São Paulo, Rio de Janeiro, Porto Alegre, Belo Horizonte, Salvador, and Recife) <ref>/www.schwartzman.org.br/simon/pdf/origem.pdf Note 3, p.3</ref>. To this day, it remains the only actual published survey about the immigrant origin of Brazilians.
On the other hand, in 1998, the IBGE, within its preparation for the 2000 Census, experimentally introduced a question about "origem" (ancestry) in its "Pesquisa Mensal de Emprego" (Monthly Employment Research), in order to test the viability of introducing that variable in the Census<ref>http://www.schwartzman.org.br/simon/pdf/origem.pdf p.3</ref> (the IBGE ended by deciding against the inclusion of questions about it in the Census). This research interviewed about 90,000 people in six metropolitan regions (São Paulo, Rio de Janeiro, Porto Alegre, Belo Horizonte, Salvador, and Recife) <ref>/www.schwartzman.org.br/simon/pdf/origem.pdf Note 3, p.3</ref>. To this day, it remains the only actual published survey about the immigrant origin of Brazilians.{{Citation needed|date=March 2010}}


The results of this survey stand in contradiction with the claims of the Italian embassy to Brazil. While the later point to "Italian Brazilians" making up to 15% of the Brazilian population, with absolute figures varying between 25 and 30 million, and figures for the city of São Paulo as high as 60% or 6 million, the IBGE found actually a figure of 10%, which would correspond, at the time, to a total population of about 3.5 million people of Italian origin in whole set of metropolitan regions it researched, including São Paulo (and Porto Alegre, another metropolitan region with a high concentration of ''oriundi'').
The results of this survey stand in contradiction{{Citation needed|date=March 2010}} with the claims of the Italian embassy to Brazil. While the later point to "Italian Brazilians" making up to 15% of the Brazilian population, with absolute figures varying between 25 and 30 million, and figures for the city of São Paulo as high as 60% or 6 million, the IBGE found actually a figure of 10%, which would correspond, at the time, to a total population of about 3.5 million people of Italian origin in whole set of metropolitan regions it researched, including São Paulo (and Porto Alegre, another metropolitan region with a high concentration of ''oriundi'').{{Citation needed|date=March 2010}}


{| class="wikitable" style="margin: 1em auto 1em auto"
{| class="wikitable" style="margin: 1em auto 1em auto"

Revision as of 02:10, 1 April 2010

Italian Brazilian
Italo Brasiliano  · Ítalo Brasileiro

José Serra[1]  · Alessandra Ambrosio[2]  · Felipe Massa [3]  · Rodrigo Santoro[4]  · Fernanda Montenegro[5]  · Luiz Felipe Scolari[6]
Regions with significant populations
Brazil: Mainly Southern and Southeastern Brazil
Languages
Predominantly Portuguese. A minority also speak Talian.
Religion
Predominantly Roman Catholic
Related ethnic groups
White Brazilian, Italian people

An Italian Brazilian (Italian: Italo-Brasiliano, Portuguese: Ítalo-Brasileiro) is a Brazilian citizen of full or partial Italian ancestry. The Italian government claims there are 25 million Brazilians of Italian descent[7], which would be the largest population of Italian background outside of Italy itself[9]. According to demographer Miguel Ángel García[10] the estimate of Brazilians and Argentineans with Italian ancestry is not precise, he estimates that 15 to 18 million people in Brazil have Italian ancestry. Only a minority of Italian Brazilians are recognized by the Italian legislation as Italian citizens. The reason being that many Italians renounced their Italian citizenship to acquire the Brazilian citizenship and also Italian women did not transfer citizenship to descendants until 1948. Cite error: The <ref> tag has too many names (see the help page).

Italians in Brazil

Italian Brazilian ethnicity in Brazil

Italian-Brazilians or Brazilians of Italian descent are the 4th most populous group of Brazilians, just behind the descendants of Portuguese settlers, descendants of African slaves, and Amerindians[citation needed]. Italian surnames are common among Brazilians since up to 36 million Brazilians have Italian ancestors[citation needed].

Although victims of some prejudice in the first decades and in spite of the persecution during the Second World War, Brazilians of Italian descent managed to mingle and to incorporate seamlessly into the Brazilian society.

Brazilians of Italian descent tend to be very participant in all aspects of Brazilian public life. Many Brazilian politicians, artists, footballers, models and personalities are or were of Italian descent. Amongst Italian-Brazilian one finds: several States Governors, Congressmen, mayors and ambassadors. Three Presidents of Brazil were of Italian descent (though, curiously, and unfortunately, none of them were elected to such position): Pascoal Ranieri Mazzilli (Senate president who served as interim president), Itamar Franco (elected vice-President under Fernando Collor, whom he eventually replaced as the latter was impeached), and Emílio Garrastazu Médici (third of the series of generals who presided over Brazil during the military regime). Médici was also of Basque descent.

Citizenship

According to the Brazilian Constitution, anyone born in Brazil is a Brazilian citizen by birthright. In addition, many who were born in Italy have become naturalized citizens after settling in Brazil. In recent years, a considerable number of Brazilians of Italian descent have in turn acquired Italian citizenship becoming dual citizens, as they do not lose their Brazilian citizenship by doing so. Italian law grants citizenship to those of Italian descent, on some conditions, without requiring them to live in Italy or speak fluent Italian.

"To the Province of S. Paulo, in Brazil. Immigrants: read these hints before leaving. S. Paulo, 1886".
File:Panfleto imigrante.jpg
"In America - Lands in Brazil for the Italians. Ships leaving every week from the Port of Genoa. Come and build your dreams with the family. A country of opportunities. Tropical climate and abundance. Mineral wealth. In Brazil, you can have your castle. The government provides land and equipment to everyone".

History of Italian immigration in Brazil

Italian crisis in late 19th century

A family of Italian emigrants.

Italy only united as a sovereign national state in 1861. Before that Italy was politically divided in several kingdoms, ducates and other small states. It was mostly a geographic region, and a cultural-linguistic area, the Italian peninsula, more or less united by the same language. This fact influenced deeply the character of the Italian migrant. "Before 1914, the typical Italian migrant was a man without a clear national identity but with strong attachments to his town or village or region of birth, to which half of all migrants returned."[11] The feeling of a national Italian identity and of a united ethnic group was created later on for those emigrants, when they were already in Brazil.[12]

During the 19th century, many Italians fled the political persecutions in Italy, mainly after the failure of revolutionary movements in 1848 and 1861. Although very small, these well educated and revolutionary group of emigrants left a deep mark where they settled.[13] In Brazil, the most famous Italians of this period were Giuseppe Garibaldi and Líbero Badaró. Despite that, the mass Italian immigration that contributed to shape Brazilian culture after the Portuguese and the German migration movements started only after the Italian unification.

During the last quarter of the 19th century, the newly united Italy suffered an economic crisis. In the Northern regions, there was unemployment due to the introduction of new techniques in agriculture, while Southern Italy remained underdeveloped and untouched by modernization in agrarian structure. Italy as a whole was very unequal, industrialization, even in the worth was still in its initial stages and illiteracy was still common in Italy (though more in the south and islands than in the north).[14] Thus, poverty and lack of jobs and income stimulated the northern (and also southern Italians) to migrate to Brazil (as well to other countries, such as Argentina and the United States). Most of the Italian immigrants were very poor peasants, mainly farmers.[15]

Brazilian need of immigrants

The lack of workers

Italians getting into a ship to Brazil, 1910.

In 1850, under British pressure, Brazil finally passed a law banning the international slave trade. The enforcement of this law was very irregular or hardly enforced in the beginning (this being the origin of the Brazilian expression "para inglês ver" - for the Englishmen to see - meaning something a law that is not intended to be actually enforced). But the increased pressure of the abolitionist movement, on the other hand, made clear that the days of slavery in Brazil were coming to an end. Slave trade did in fact dwindle but the slavery system within the country still endured for a few years. So the discussion about European immigration to Brazil became a priority for Brazilian landowners. The latter claimed that such migrants were or would soon become indispensable for Brazilian agriculture. They would soon win the argument and mass migration would begin in earnest.

An Agriculture Congress in 1878 in Rio de Janeiro discussed the lack of labor and proposed to the government the stimulation of European immigration to Brazil. Immigrants from Italy, Portugal and Spain were considered the best ones, because they were white and, mainly, Catholics. Therefore, the Brazilian government started to attract more Italian immigrants to the coffee plantations.

The "Whitening Project"

A ship with Italian immigrants in the Port of Santos: 1907.Most migrants came to the State of São Paulo and its mainport, the entry gate of Brazil, was Santos. Thus most migrants from Italy regardless of their final destination in Brazil, entered through the port of Santos.

At the end of the 19th century, the Brazilian government was influenced by eugenics theories. According to some scholars, it was necessary to bring immigrants from Europe to enhance the Brazilian population. Brazil issued laws prohibiting the entry of Asian immigrants in 1889 and the situation changed only with the Immigration Law of 1907.

The large increase of European immigrants made some scholars believe that within a few decades black people would disappear from Brazil through miscegenation or be reduced in number by way of comparison.[16]

On July 28, 1921, representatives Andrade Bezerra and Cincinato Braga proposed a law whose Article 1 provided: "It is prohibited to Brazil immigration of individuals from the black race." On October 22, 1923, representative Fidélis Reis produced another project of law on the entry of immigrants, whose fifth article was as follows: 'It is prohibited the entry of settlers from the black race in Brazil and, to Asians, it will be allowed each year, a number equal to 5% of those existing in the country.(...)'.[17]

In 1945, the Brazilian government issued a decree favoring the entrance of European immigrants in the country: "The entry of immigrants comes from the need to preserve and develop, in the ethnic composition of the population, the more convenient features of their European ancestry".[17]

Beginning of Italian settlement in Brazil

A 19th century house built by Italian immigrants in Caxias do Sul, Rio Grande do Sul.
Stone house in Nova Veneza, in the State of Santa Catarina, landmark of Italian immigration.

The Italian immigration in Brazil increased after 1850 when the enforcement of the law proscribing the international slave trade created labor shortages. Then, the Brazilian government, headed by Emperor Pedro II, instituted an open-door immigration policy towards Europeans. The Brazilian government (with or following the Emperor's support) had created the first colonies of immigrants (colônias de imigrantes) in the early 19th century. These colonies were established in rural areas of the country, being settled by European families, mainly German immigrants that settled in many areas of Southern Brazil. Following the same project, colonies with Italian immigrants were also created in southern Brazil.

The first groups of Italians arrived in 1875, but the boom of Italian immigration in Brazil happened in late 19th century, between 1880 and 1900, when almost one million Italians arrived.

A great number of Italians was naturalized Brazilian at the end of the 19th century, when the 'Great Naturalization' conceded automatically citizenship to all the immigrants residing in Brazil prior to November 15, 1889 "unless they declared a desire to keep their original nationality within six months."[18]

During the last years of the 19th century, the denouncements of bad conditions in Brazil increased in the press. Reacting to the public clamor and many proved cases of mistreatments of Italian immigrants, the government of Italy issued, in 1902, the Prinetti decree forbidding subsidized immigration to Brazil. In consequence, the number of Italian immigrants in Brazil fell drastically in the beginning of the 20th century, but the wave of Italian immigration continued until 1920.[19]

Over half of the Italian immigrants came from Northern Italian regions of Veneto, Lombardy, Tuscany and Emilia-Romagna. About 30% emigrated from Veneto.[14] On the other hand, during the 20th century, Central and Southern Italians predominated in Brazil, coming from the regions of Campania, Abruzzo, Molise, Basilicata and Sicily.

Statistics

The Brazilian Censuses do not ask questions about "ethnic origin", so there are no systematically comparable data about the impact of Italian immigration[citation needed] . Varied entities, mainly the Italian diplomatic system and commercial associations that promote bilateral commerce between Brazil and Italy [citation needed], make claims about the figures of oriundi in Brazil, but none links to any actual survey. Also, if they are extrapolations of actual data on the number of immigrants, the calculations are not explained anywhere.[citation needed]

On the other hand, in 1998, the IBGE, within its preparation for the 2000 Census, experimentally introduced a question about "origem" (ancestry) in its "Pesquisa Mensal de Emprego" (Monthly Employment Research), in order to test the viability of introducing that variable in the Census[20] (the IBGE ended by deciding against the inclusion of questions about it in the Census). This research interviewed about 90,000 people in six metropolitan regions (São Paulo, Rio de Janeiro, Porto Alegre, Belo Horizonte, Salvador, and Recife) [21]. To this day, it remains the only actual published survey about the immigrant origin of Brazilians.[citation needed]

The results of this survey stand in contradiction[citation needed] with the claims of the Italian embassy to Brazil. While the later point to "Italian Brazilians" making up to 15% of the Brazilian population, with absolute figures varying between 25 and 30 million, and figures for the city of São Paulo as high as 60% or 6 million, the IBGE found actually a figure of 10%, which would correspond, at the time, to a total population of about 3.5 million people of Italian origin in whole set of metropolitan regions it researched, including São Paulo (and Porto Alegre, another metropolitan region with a high concentration of oriundi).[citation needed]

Arrival of Italian immigrants to Brazil by periods (source: IBGE)[19]
1884-1893 1894–1903 1904–1913 1914–1923 1924–1933 1934–1944 1945–1949 1950–1954 1955–1959
510,533 537,784 196,521 86,320 70,177 15,312 N/A 59,785 31,263