Jump to content

Talk:Fishing: Difference between revisions

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
Bu b0y2007 (talk | contribs)
Removed "squirrel fishing" section
Line 107: Line 107:
:You are absolutly right! [[User:Gaius Cornelius|Gaius Cornelius]] 13:31, 18 May 2007 (UTC)
:You are absolutly right! [[User:Gaius Cornelius|Gaius Cornelius]] 13:31, 18 May 2007 (UTC)
:Yeah that's true... [[User:Bu b0y2007|Bu b0y2007]] 04:54, 19 May 2007 (UTC)
:Yeah that's true... [[User:Bu b0y2007|Bu b0y2007]] 04:54, 19 May 2007 (UTC)

== Removed "squirrel fishing" section ==

I've deleted this section:


===Squirrel fishing===
{{main|Squirrel fishing}}
'''[[Squirrel fishing]]''' is the sporting practice of "catching" [[squirrel]]s and attempting to lift them into the air using a [[peanut]] tied to a string or [[fishing line]], and optionally some kind of [[fishing pole]].

In most cases, squirrels playfully tug and grapple with the nuts, while the human participant skillfully angles with his or her quarry. A delicate approach is required in squirrel fishing. Anyone can pull a nut from the hands of a squirrel, but the adept "squirrel fisher" must hone his craft, maintaining balance between himself and the squirrel, and eventually rewarding the squirrel for his valiant competition by ceding the nut. Ideally, great care is taken not to overfeed squirrels, not to hit them with nuts, and not to treat them roughly.



It is completely out of place with the rest of the article.

Revision as of 16:16, 22 May 2007

Template:V0.5 Template:Fishportal

WikiProject
Fisheries and Fishing
Main project talk
Assessment statistics
Traffic statistics
Articles talk
Proposals talk
Resources talk
Project subpages
Members
Requested fishing articles talk
Things you can do
To-do list
Assessment
Unassessed articles
Expand stub class articles
Other
Outreach
Newsletter
Recent updates
Featured/good articles
Categories
Templates
Articles for deletion talk
Subpages

Welcome to the Fisheries and Fishing WikiProject on the English Wikipedia! We are a group dedicated to improving Wikipedia's coverage of topics related to fisheries, aquaculture and fishing. If you would like to join us, please feel free to add your name to the list of project members!

Goals
  • To organize articles on fisheries, aquaculture and fishing in a way that is useful.
  • To improve coverage of these areas by creating, expanding, and maintaining articles that describe all of its aspects.
  • To provide guidelines and recommendations for such articles, and to serve as the central point of discussion for issues related to fisheries, aquaculture and fishing in Wikipedia.
Scope
The project generally considers articles related to historical or contemporary fisheries, aquaculture or fishing to be within its scope. At the end of September 2015, there were 2,039 articles within the project's scope. During September 2015, the top 1000 articles received 3,605,956 views, averaging 119,712 views per day.

Members

If you are interested, you are very welcome to join and help us with the Fisheries and Fishing Wikiproject. Just sign below and, if you like, you can say what area you are particularly interested in (the fish might bite, but we don't!).

Active

If you want to become a member, click the "edit" link to the right and add your username alphabetically by using the {{user|Username}} format. If you want to, you can add the {{User WProject Fishing}} userbox to your userpage. If you subsequently leave the project, please remove your name from the list.

  1. Billreid (talk · contribs) — joined 11 May 2008 - Deep sea fishing and fisheries, fishing communities
  2. Chefmikesf (talk · contribs) - joined 1 September 2017 - I'm involved with commercial fisheries and how they relate to the consumer market.
  3. Epipelagic (talk · contribs) — joined 26 February 2008 - general dogsbody
  4. Melanogrammus (talk · contribs) — joined 17 Octobter 2023 - Interested in commercial fisheries science and management
  5. Micromesistius (talk · contribs) — joined 10 March 2012 - interested in improving fisheries science coverage
  6. Mike Cline (talk · contribs) — joined 16 May 2007 - created Bibliography of fly fishing and actively contributes to Fly Fishing, Fly Tying and Related Articles.
  7. Stratocaster27 (talk · contribs) — joined 29 June 2013 - freshwater and surf fishing. Knowledgeable about equipment, rods/reels, and tackle.
  8. DrGvago (talk · contribs) — joined 19 February 2021 - interested in recreational saltwater fishing and associated boats/watercraft, but may be able to help with other boating and fishing related topics
  9. G._Moore (talk · contribs) — joined 26 February 2021 - Fly fishing and fly tying.
  10. 25Abhi7234 (talk · contribs) - joined 12 september 2022 - Finfish and fins
  11. jj1691 (talk · contribs) -joined 22 November 2022
  12. DMVHistorian (talk · contribs) - joined 3 October 2023 - Fisheries and aquaculture

Inactive

Names are manually moved here if no wikipedia edits have been made for at least six months (last updated 27 January 2023). If your name has been moved here, please feel free to move it back to the active list.

  1. AzCoy7 (talk · contribs) — Joined 25 May 2019 - Very enthusiastic fishing person.
  2. 4500Fish (talk · contribs) -Joined 7 September 2012 - interested in research to improve commercial recreational and indigenous fishing in Australia and around the world
  3. A-tron (talk · contribs) — joined 17 September 2009 - I'm a fisheries economist looking to edit and improve fisheries topics with links to economics.
  4. {{Barmbyrover}} I am a match and general angler in the UK, coaching experience.
  5. Diamonddannyboy (talk · contribs) — joined 29 March 2008 - Im a keen carp fisherman and all rounder, fish the famous sutton.
  6. Elnuko (talk · contribs) — joined 13 Dec 2007
  7. EWDes (talk · contribs) - joined 16 Jan 2010 - fishing in general, eager to help improve the entries around species and sport fishing on Wikipedia
  8. Fishingyoyito (talk · contribs) - I'm interested in expanding the handline fishing article. People have been handlining for thousands of years, I think we can come up with a little more content for this article. However, this will be my first contribution to Wikipedia, so please keep an eye on me and let me know if I do something wrong.
  9. Frankmoley (talk · contribs) — joined 12 March 2008 - Midwestern fly fisher and bass fisher....love all kinds of fishing and fish. I would like to look at updating the rivers that hold trout.
  10. GrinchPeru (talk · contribs) — joined 10 January 2011- Lifelong small stream flyfisher, and sporadic deep sea fisher. I have significant access to fishery experts, and interest, particularly but not limited to Engraulis ringens, and could contribute in English and Spanish.
  11. Habaneroman (talk · contribs) — joined 14 Sep 2007
  12. Hcberkowitz (talk · contribs) — joined 15 July 2007 - interested in commercial fishing, especially the monitoring, control, and surveillance thereof. I'm working with Vessel Management System and other maritime electronics.
  13. Kukulski (talk · contribs) — joined 31 August 2009 - Wish to distill the posts on the NANFA Forum into useful wiki information.
  14. kylek14 (talk · contribs) - joined 11 November 2010 - Active trout and bass fisherman. Would love to help out anyway I can to make individuals aware of the sport and species.
  15. Lilithmoon1 (talk · contribs) - joined 1 July 2012 - interested in North American freshwater fishing
  16. seacucumber06 (talk · contribs)- joined 4 March 2010 - presently involved in long term fisheries livelihood rehabilitation projects under World Bank aid.
  17. SeaNympho (talk · contribs) - joined 14 February 2010 - Avid fisherman with specialties in bass, stream trout, & catfish.
  18. Support.and.Defend (talk · contribs) - joined 17 October 2010
  19. Theirrulez (talk · contribs) - joined 17 May 2010 - created Trabucco and interested in Mediterranean historical fishing matters.
  20. Themcman1 (talk · contribs) — joined 20 April 2007
  21. Traveler7 (talk · contribs) — joined 15 June 2012 - all fishing fresh and saltwater, fly fishing.
  22. Ummagumma23 (talk · contribs) — joined 9 July 2007
  23. Venator48 (talk · contribs) — joined 9 February 2016 - much personal experience in freshwater game fishing, sporting book, and tackle collecting, have published monographs in Britain and the United States on angling authors, the literature of field sports, and salmon flies.
  24. oso162 (talk · contribs) - joined 13 September 2019- Interested in fishing for fun and the study of fish.
  25. Fishing TV (talk · contribs) — joined 17 June 2019 - Interested in recreational fishing TV programs, films, movies about the sport
  26. Erik Sulanke (talk · contribs) — joined 5 December 2019 - Fisheries ecologist with focus on North Atlantic and EU-fleet
  27. Bass fishing physicist (talk · contribs) — joined 4 May 2007
  28. Bu b0y2007 (talk · contribs) — joined 19 April 2007
  29. ChrisCotton (talk · contribs) — joined 3 June 2007
  30. cf38 (talk · contribs) — joined 17 December 2007
  31. Dusty.crockett (talk · contribs) — joined 7 January 2009
  32. Ebolred (talk · contribs) — joined 03 Jul 2008
  33. LaughingVulcan (talk · contribs) — joined 23 May 2007
  34. Majikfactory (talk · contribs) — joined 26 September 2007
  35. Medicellis (talk · contribs) — joined 4 August 2008
  36. OAS (talk · contribs) — joined 4 February 2008
  37. Steven130793 (talk · contribs) — joined 2 May 2007

Ways to contribute

To do list

Talk:Fishing/to do

Tasks

Talk:Fishing/tasks

Requests

Discussions

You can start a discussion on the projects talk page.

Proposals

To add a proposal, add it in the proposal page.

Assessment

For more info on our assessment system, see the assessment page.

Templates

For a list and explanation of our project templates see the templates page.

Categories

Please make sure to add articles to the appropriate categories. The fishing-related categories, as of 6 October 2024 are:

Please use the most specific category that is applicable (i.e., the most indented category). For example, the article B. H. Fisher should be under Category:American fishers (not Category:Fishers or Category:Fishing).

Some notable articles

Here is a list of some notable articles within the scope of WikiProject Fisheries and Fishing.

Featured : Shrimp farm

A class: Fly fishing, Krill fishery

GA class : Marine Harvest, Seamount, Esopus Creek

Did you knows (DYKs): Entries from these articles appeared on the main page Did you know? section.

Alerts

Talk:Fishing/Article alerts

Articles For Deletion

The below listed articles related to the Fisheries and Fishing Project are or have been subject to deletion proposals. Project members interested in contributing to the deletion discussion on active deletion debates should do so on the article's deletion page. Members aware of a deletion proposal on a fishing project related article not listed here, should list the article here so that other project members may become aware of it. Editors are reminded of the Wikipedia guideline on Canvassing WP:CANVASS and should not solicit biased contributions to the deletion debate from other editors.

Active

Results

  • Pawistik Lodge Proposed 26 June 2008. See deletion page. Result was Keep. The original author or others need to clean up this article and source it well for it to stay. Of particular importance is not to make it an Advertisment for the lodge.

WikiProject Fisheries and Fishing is a multidisciplinary WikiProject which is related to or has some overlap with many other WikiProjects:

See also
WikiProject iconSports Unassessed
WikiProject iconThis article is within the scope of WikiProject Sports, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of sport-related topics on Wikipedia. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join the discussion and see a list of open tasks.
???This article has not yet received a rating on Wikipedia's content assessment scale.
To-do list:

Here are some tasks awaiting attention:
Archive
Archives
Archive 1

Vandalism

I don't know how to revert pages, but someone has vandalized the "Recreational Fishing" portion of this article. Someone needs to fix this. Cereal Box Conspiracy 20:46, 3 January 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Featured Article Status

This article did not make it to featured article status. That is a pity, perhaps the application was a little premature. Still, Fishing does have the makings a very good and possible feature-quality article. Let us see it we can do it! Gaius Cornelius 22:15, 20 July 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Removal of Anglers Rest Image

Hi!

Anglers Rest, a popular recreational fishing destination on the Cobungra River - Removed image

I'm just a visitor to this article, and before I start a revert war I'd like to put it up for discussion: Should the Anglers Rest Image be included? Personally I feel it is valuable because it shows a popular recreational fishing river. But lets see what the community thinks. --Fir0002 22:35, 10 August 2006 (UTC)[reply]

The picture is not appropriate here. Removing it was the right thing to do. Gaius Cornelius 17:19, 11 August 2006 (UTC)[reply]
I agree with Gaius Cornelius, and support the removal. Arnejohs 19:56, 11 August 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Surf fishing

is missing. Or is it listed by another name, if so I missed it. Montara State Beach has surf fishing. meatclerk 05:57, 16 August 2006 (UTC)[reply]

I don't know what surf fishing is. If it is essentially and 'invented sport' then, if it belongs anywhere in Wikipedia, it would be more appropriate under angling or sport fishing. If it is a very popular sport, or is some other way notable, it might deserve an article of its own. Gaius Cornelius 07:33, 16 August 2006 (UTC)[reply]
Your note raises an interesting general point: what does and what does not belong in the fishing article. I would say that the article should reflect the practice of fishing throughout the world and throughout history and that the techniques mentioned should be economically or culturally significant to the people who practice it. To this might be added practices that are scientifically significant. Some feedback to establish the consensus would be helpful here. Gaius Cornelius 07:33, 16 August 2006 (UTC)[reply]

If this helps, Surf Fishing is essentially line fishing, but you are casting into the surf. I'm not sure what one will catch, as I've never done this. It would also fit under native american fishing, also oddities, like some movies show this, even tv shows. So, is it a valid fishing method? I'm not 100% sure, but I can bet State of California has laws for it. meatclerk 09:33, 16 August 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Surf fishing is a form of angling and, if it merits a home on Wikipedia, should probably live in the angling article. One might also argue that surf fishing really is a form of recreational fishing, since I'm not aware of any subsistence or commercial fisheries that use surf fishing. I think it's inappropriate to try to list every type of angling or every conceivable sort of net or, whatever, in the fishing article. In my opinion, the fishing article should be about fishing in the broadest sense of that word. There are, or should be, other articles to amplify specific kinds of fishing. See, the way I see the hierarchy is this: the fishing article is about the elements that are common to all types of fishing and not about any specific form of fishing. A descendant of the fishing article is the angling article which is about the elements common to all types of angling, whether that be commercial long-line angling fisheries or fly-fishing for sport or any other form of angling. A descendant of the angling article might be the recreationl fishing article which is about the elements that are common to all forms of recreational fishing, etc, etc, etc. Of course, this is only my vision so I'd welcome anyone to tell me I'm full of excrement. — Dave 13:31, 16 August 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Now, that I have had some sleep - I am fairly confident I could find a reference for commercial surf fishing, as well as native american surf fishing. I believe it does belong under the modern angling section for recreational fishing. Now that I've had some sleep on this, the things one could catch include eel, and salmon.

On that commercial surf fishing there should be some material. Eel on the surf is common. Some use "pokie poles" and local fishermen from Pillar Point (north of Half Moon Bay, CA) have been known for this and surf fishing. Chinese were known for all types of fishing on the coast, from Half Moon Bay to San Francisco. SF has a "China Beach" which was an early fishing village in a ravine. They used it to avoid being beaten up by white bigots - well known local history. They did surf fishing along with abalone and whaling.

To all this I'm sure there is commerial surf fishing from New Jersey (sp?) to Florida, however now mostly recreational - as is here now. meatclerk 16:36, 16 August 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Surf fishing is very popular in South East Queensland Australia. The majority of participants are recreational. Surf Fishing is undertaken regularly as a formal competitive sport - but most participants are undertaking fishing as a recreational past time. The opening line of this article presents the definition of fishing as hunting for fish. I don't associate fishing necessarily with hunting. We also have fishing here as part of indiginous livliehoods and also commercial surf fishing. We have people who undertake fishing from their surf boards - instead of casting. Sit around with a line while waiting for the waves to come through. Popular commercial surf fishing is for Sea Mullet. Recreational species for us that cause a frenzy are Tailor. When the tailor are running you can see 4WDs parked on the beach like a shopping centre and people standing shoulder to shoulder fishing into a gutter into the surf - how the lines don't tangle more often then they do is a mystery. Other fish that are commonly caught in the surf at any time of year include dart, bream, whiting and flathead. We often experience conflict between surf fishing, surfing and swimming all targeting the same beach at the same time. 22 December 2006 (SEQ Guest)

saltwater fishing.

This text was added to the article; it needs to be cleaned up before being included.

Saltwater fishing is classified in two groups. Group A inshore which includes canals, bays, beach, ... THe many variety of fish include snook, redfish, and sea trout as the most popular inshore fish in florida though there are many more. As for group B which is offshore that includes the Oceans and Gulfs. In Florida some of the popular fish include grouper, snapper, dolphin (mahi mahi) and more. Most offshore fishing takes larger boats inorder to counter act the high intensity of the waves. As for inshore fishing which takes a very boyant boat some are called a flats boat.Depending on the type of fishing and species of fish someone is targeting will depend on the tackle and bait needed. -- phoebe 07:23, 8 November 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Lists of fishing ports by country

Does this list exist? List of North American fishing ports, List of Brazilian fishing ports, List of Thai fishing ports, List of eastern Pacific ocean fishing ports? I live near New Bedford, Massachusetts and every year the port finishes in the top ten, for the USA. --McTrixie 21:01, 16 November 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Ask for translation

I have drawn this diagram, but I do not know the name of the parts in English, maybe somebody can provide a caption and a use for this image. Chabacano 23:52, 16 March 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Done. Thanks to the anonymous helper :) Chabacano 14:29, 17 March 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Cleanup necessary

The article needs some cleaning up. There's a lot of random bolding and redundancies in areas, while some sections require rewriting in a more encyclopedic tone. Isopropyl 04:30, 11 April 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Very true. The section on recreational fishing is disproportionately long. Part of this article's problems are caused by well-meaning but lazy contributors who do not seem to bother with reading the whole article before adding inappropriate content; and the article attracts vandals and spam linkers. Perhaps we could get it semi-protected? Gaius Cornelius 12:11, 11 April 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Merger from Sport fishing, potential for split along different lines

There had been a discussion to merge Sport fishing and Angling, but as sport fishing is not a subset of angling it does not make sense to merge them thus. I have therefore merged the info here under the "modern fishing" subsection.

However this article has become rather long, and already was before the addition of that information. Having "sport fishing" forked off on its own didn't seem to make a lot of sense, but a split somewhere else might be better. Perhaps fork out the entire "modern fishing" section into its own article? Arkyan • (talk) 21:08, 27 April 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Please see Fishing Proposal Page for more information about other things to be done regarding this project


Its about time to put this task which is the need to lessen the size of the Fishing article without loosing any of the important information in our priority list. This move is still apart of our move to objective to thoughtfully organize articles on fishing (see WikiProject Fishing). I would like to ask for your (each and everyone concerned) help, assistance, and approval for this move. I am planning to do the following revisions right after your approval:

  • Truncate the Fishing nets section and link it to its existing main article by placing the tag: Main article: Fishing net before the paragraph. The information that will be removed from this section will be transfered to Fishing net, in this way, the Fishing net article will be expanded. done as of 5/9/2007
  • The Dredging section will be connected to Dredging's Fishing section. Further expansion to Dredging's Fishing section will then be done.
  • Truncate the Fishing lines section and and link it to its existing main article by placing the tag: Main article: Fishing line before the paragraph. The information that will be removed from this section will be transfered to Fishing line, in this way, the Fishing line article will be expanded. done as of 5/17/2007
  • I am currently doing an article, Kite fishing. Right after this is done and approved. I am also planning to truncate the Kite fishing section and link it to the main article which I am currently creating by placing the tag: Main article: Kite fishing before the paragraph. The information that will be removed from this section will be added to Kite fishing.
  • I wish to create another article for Modern Fishing and shortly discuss Recreational fishing, Sport fishing, Commercial fishing, and other subcategories regarding Modern fishing. These subcategories will then be linking to there existing main articles.
  • I wish to add more fishing related sections and link them to their main articles using the Main article: <main article title>

Please let me know what you think. Thank you and more power to us all. Bu b0y2007 05:51, 2 May 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Un buen sitio de pesca

Pesca del Dorado en la Argentina / Fishing from Argentina

http://www.estancialabrava.com.ar —The preceding unsigned comment was added by 200.41.230.162 (talk) 14:26, 3 May 2007 (UTC).[reply]

Fishing revisions

First of all, I would personally like to thank you for actively guarding our Fishing Project. I've seen all your efforts of protecting the Fishing article from those harmful vandals. I've recently made a major revision from all those revisions/reverts that were made previously by bots and other wikipedians because some of the important information there were lost despite the effort of each and everyone to guard the said article. Let us continue to protect all those excellent articles. Thanks and more power! Bu b0y2007 02:04, 17 May 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Sport fishing versus angling

I just made an edit to the "Recreational fishing" section of the article to make the "main" point to Sport fishing, as it truly should. Recreational and sport fishing are very nearly synonymous. Angling, on the other hand, is a method of fishing that can be used for recreational, sport, commercial fishing, etc. The trouble, as I see it, is that there are two sections, "Recreational fishing" and "Sport fishing" that really talk about the same thing save for a slight semantic distinction. Those two sections, in my opinion, should be collapsed. — Dave (Talk | contribs) 12:57, 18 May 2007 (UTC)[reply]

You are absolutly right! Gaius Cornelius 13:31, 18 May 2007 (UTC)[reply]
Yeah that's true... Bu b0y2007 04:54, 19 May 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Removed "squirrel fishing" section

I've deleted this section:


Squirrel fishing

Squirrel fishing is the sporting practice of "catching" squirrels and attempting to lift them into the air using a peanut tied to a string or fishing line, and optionally some kind of fishing pole.

In most cases, squirrels playfully tug and grapple with the nuts, while the human participant skillfully angles with his or her quarry. A delicate approach is required in squirrel fishing. Anyone can pull a nut from the hands of a squirrel, but the adept "squirrel fisher" must hone his craft, maintaining balance between himself and the squirrel, and eventually rewarding the squirrel for his valiant competition by ceding the nut. Ideally, great care is taken not to overfeed squirrels, not to hit them with nuts, and not to treat them roughly.


It is completely out of place with the rest of the article.