Wikipedia:WikiProject Songs: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
m move paras around to the information what is to be written is not split up with stubs inbetween. No change of wording
Geofferybard (talk | contribs)
4,601 edits
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 7: Line 7:
==Notability==
==Notability==
{{Main|Wikipedia:Notability (music)}}
{{Main|Wikipedia:Notability (music)}}
Most songs do not merit an article and should redirect to another relevant article, such as for a prominent album or for the artist who wrote or prominently performed the song. Songs that have been ranked on national or significant music charts, that have won significant awards or honors or that have been performed independently by several notable artists, bands or groups are probably notable. A separate article is only appropriate when there is enough verifiable material to warrant a reasonably detailed article; permanent stubs should be merged to articles about an artist or album.
Most songs do not merit an article and should redirect to another relevant article, such as for a prominent album or for the artist who wrote or prominently performed the song. Songs that have been ranked on national or significant music charts, that have won significant awards or honors or that have been performed independently by several notable artists, bands or groups are probably notable. A separate article is only appropriate when there is enough verifiable material to warrant a reasonably detailed article; permanent stubs should be merged to articles about an artist or album.

===Traditional songs===
Traditional songs (as well as tunes) will typically have a storied past and there will be an ample supply of lore, much of it in secondary sources such as academic articles on ballads and music journals. Beware of adding tidbits of knowledge you pick up from jam sessions if you can't find secondary sources. In such cases, it would be better policy to write an article somewhere such as a blog or website catering to a specific music genre. That article would be a secondary source and the specialist community which reads that journal will provide plenty of expert critique. You can then ask another Wikipedia editor to consider your article as a source which could be cited as a reference in a Wikipedia article. You are not prevented from citing your own article, but other editors may question your credibility with a higher level of scepticism than you might expect or welcome, and you might be required to submit COI (conflict of interest) information. If you opt for the strategy of requesting other editors to consider your article for incorporation as a reference, the members of this project would be a good place to seek that kind of potential collaborators. You might also invite people you know in the music community to create a Wikipedia account, provided you are not engaging in an [[Wikipedia:MEAT|attempt to unduly affect WP opinion]]. In any case, it will be your responsibility to demonstrate notability, even if you have existing secondary sources at your disposal.


===Articles for deletion===
===Articles for deletion===

Revision as of 02:42, 18 July 2011

"WP:SONG" and "WP:SINGLE" redirect here. For Wikipedia's notability guidelines for music, see Wikipedia:Notability (music). For songs about Wikipedia, see Wikipedia:Songs about Wikipedia.

WikiProject Songs is a project intended to improve articles on songs. The goal is to make the song articles provide basic information in a quick and easy-to-read fashion. This project is based on WikiProject Albums, and uses similar templates. Its 'parent' project is WikiProject Music. A lot of this project has been lifted directly from the Albums project.

Notability

Main page: Wikipedia:Notability (music)

Most songs do not merit an article and should redirect to another relevant article, such as for a prominent album or for the artist who wrote or prominently performed the song. Songs that have been ranked on national or significant music charts, that have won significant awards or honors or that have been performed independently by several notable artists, bands or groups are probably notable. A separate article is only appropriate when there is enough verifiable material to warrant a reasonably detailed article; permanent stubs should be merged to articles about an artist or album.

Traditional songs

Traditional songs (as well as tunes) will typically have a storied past and there will be an ample supply of lore, much of it in secondary sources such as academic articles on ballads and music journals. Beware of adding tidbits of knowledge you pick up from jam sessions if you can't find secondary sources. In such cases, it would be better policy to write an article somewhere such as a blog or website catering to a specific music genre. That article would be a secondary source and the specialist community which reads that journal will provide plenty of expert critique. You can then ask another Wikipedia editor to consider your article as a source which could be cited as a reference in a Wikipedia article. You are not prevented from citing your own article, but other editors may question your credibility with a higher level of scepticism than you might expect or welcome, and you might be required to submit COI (conflict of interest) information. If you opt for the strategy of requesting other editors to consider your article for incorporation as a reference, the members of this project would be a good place to seek that kind of potential collaborators. You might also invite people you know in the music community to create a Wikipedia account, provided you are not engaging in an attempt to unduly affect WP opinion. In any case, it will be your responsibility to demonstrate notability, even if you have existing secondary sources at your disposal.

Articles for deletion

Albums and songs that have been nominated for deletion are listed at Wikipedia:WikiProject Deletion sorting/Albums and songs

Style

Naming

Song article titles should be named after the song, without quotation marks, for example, Paranoid Android. If there is another article with that name use the format '<song name> (song)', for example, "Wonderwall (song)". If there is more than one song article with a title then disambiguate by putting the artist name in the title to make '<song name> (<artist name> song)', for example "Because (The Beatles song)". If the song is in a foreign language and titled using the Latin alphabet, then, unless the song is commonly known by a translated name in the English-speaking world, the original foreign title should be used. This may require using accented letters which are not used in English. Examples: "Ein bißchen Frieden", "Je n'ai que mon âme", "Fångad av en stormvind". If the single title does not use the Latin alphabet, the article name should be the transliterated form of the title using Latin characters. Examples: "Kaihōku" instead of 解放区 or "Liberated District", "Ya Soshla S Uma" not "Я сошла с ума" or "I've Lost My Mind", "Sanso Gateun Neo (Love Like Oxygen)" instead of "산소 같은 너 (Love Like Oxygen)" or "You're Like Oxygen (Love Like Oxygen)".

Formatting

When creating any music articles remember that song and single titles go in quotation marks "like this" and album titles are italicised like this. The song title should be in boldface in the first sentence and in infobox chronologies, but the surrounding quotation marks should not be in boldface.

When linking to song articles, use piping to conceal the disambiguation terms, for example use the syntax "[[Because (The Beatles song)|Because]]", to make the link simply appear as "Because".

Also, although piping is normally discouraged on disambiguation pages, song and album titles are an exception:

Capitalization

Further information: Wikipedia:WikiProject_Albums § Capitalization

Template

Project tag

WikiProject iconSongs NA‑class
WikiProject iconThis article is within the scope of WikiProject Songs, a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of songs on Wikipedia. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join the discussion and see a list of open tasks.SongsWikipedia:WikiProject SongsTemplate:WikiProject Songssong articles
NAThis article has been rated as NA-class on Wikipedia's content assessment scale.

Please add {{songs}} along with the quality of the article. You can do this by specifying |class=X, where X is Stub, Start, C, B, A, GA or FA (see Wikipedia:Version 1.0 Editorial Team/Assessment for explanation of terms). Note that the parameter and values are case sensitive. Not all song articles have been tagged with {{songs}}. Many articles still need to be graded based on quality.

The rating by importance is not currently implemented, as the project is currently rating articles based on their class for use by the Version 1.0 team and others, including this project itself. Importance is a parameter of potential use to the project itself, possibly in determining which articles are top contenders for future collaboration. However, as the specific importance of articles varies between projects, it is less of a priority right now than determining the quality of the articles which fall within the scope of this project.

Progress

Song pages by quality
Quality
Total
FA 127
FL 310
GA 2,657
B 1,025
C 6,041
Start 28,749
Stub 42,232
List 3,411
Category 25,190
Disambig 388
File 39,292
Project 30
Redirect 47,949
Template 541
Assessed 197,942
Unassessed 244
Total 198,186
WikiWork factors (?) ω = 429,696 Ω = 5.32


Infobox conversions

For single or song articles with old-style, subst'ed or incorrect infoboxes, please add {{newinfobox|type=single}} or {{newinfobox|type=song}} to the talk page. As a regular maintenance task, please convert the infoboxes to the new style. Check Category:Song articles needing single infobox conversion and Category:Song articles needing song infobox conversion for articles needing attention.

Categories

Song articles should be placed into the following categories whenever applicable :-

  1. a subcategory of Category:Songs by artist ("Category:<Artist name> songs"), and
  2. a subcategory of Category:Songs by year, and
  3. a subcategory of Category:Singles by year for singles.
  4. The songwriters should be placed in either Category:Songs by songwriter (“Category:Songs written by <songwriter>”), Category:Songs by lyricist("Category:Songs with lyrics by <lyricist>") or Category:Songs by composer ("Category:Songs with music by <composer>"). Only one category should be created for each songwriter, so if a songwriter contributes words and/or music then the category should be in songs by songwriter only.
  5. Other than Category:Songs by artist, "Category:<Artist name> songs" should be placed into at least two other subcategories, a subcategory of Category:Songs by country and one or more subcategories of Category:Songs by genre.

For example, "Just My Imagination (Running Away with Me)" by The Temptations was released in 1971, so it is in Category:The Temptations songs and Category:1971 singles, Category:Songs written by Barrett Strong, Category:Songs written by Norman Whitfield while Category:The Temptations songs is in Category:Songs by artist, Category:American songs, Category:Motown singles and Category:Rhythm and blues songs. It is also in the category Category:The Rolling Stones songs because the The Rolling Stones recorded a notable version which is referred to in the article.

Note: For consistency, the artist name in "Category:<Artist name> songs" should usually be the same as the name in the title of the article.

Note: Please do not place song articles directly in Category:Songs or Category:Singles.

Note: A song should only be categorised once in Category:Songs by year either by the year of first publication or release (whichever is earliest). Obviously if it is released as a single more than once it should be listed accordingly.

Note:Categories should only be created if there is a main article to support the article. i.e. do not create Category:Songs written by Foo if there is no corresponding article about Foo.

Infobox

Again, similarly to the Albums project, you can use {{Infobox single}} for singles (A- or B-sides) and use {{Infobox song}} for album tracks. For standards, use {{Infobox standard}}. There are also specialist infoboxes : {{Infobox anthem}} (national anthems), {{Infobox ESC entry}} (Eurovision entries) and {{Infobox hymn}}.

Infobox single

See: Template:Infobox single

Infobox song

See: Template:Infobox song

Article content

Main body

Write a description of the song. Write the basics first (this is often the information contained in the infobox). Then write about the music and lyrics, its influences and its effect on culture (with citations, of course). Because the entire article is about the song, it is recommended that there be no section headers with titles such as "Song information" or "About the song".

Stick to factual material. Do not include "original research" such as opinions about a song, or interpretations of the lyrics or even statements about what the song is "about", unless they can be provided in the form of quotes that can be cited from sources with some authoritative insight (such as the songwriter or a notable performer). Other websites are available for people who want to give subjective interpretations of songs.

Single track listings

If the song is a single include track listings for the single's different formats.

Lyrics and music videos

Shortcuts

Do not include the song's entire lyrics or embed the song's music video in the article unless you are certain they are in the public domain. Quotations of the work within the analytical framework can fall into the fair use provisions within US copyright law (and to a lesser extent fair dealing and related concepts within other jurisdictions). However, how much of a song you can quote is open to interpretation, but you should avoid copyright paranoia. Examples of works still under copyright can be found at Category:FA-Class song articles and should be used as guidelines. Lyrics and music videos that are in the public domain may be entered at Wikisource. Links to external websites that provide lyrics and music videos belong in the "External links" section.

Per Wikipedia policy, please do not link to websites that are in violation of the artist's own copyright. See Wikipedia:Copyrights#Linking to copyrighted works.

When linking to a music video on YouTube use only the videos that have been uploaded by the musician(s), the record companies, or Vevo. The official Billboard.com YouTube channel can also be used. Links can be incorporated into the infobox (via the Misc field) or the external links of the article using {{YouTube}}. Though the list of musician channels varies, a list of the acceptable record labels and distributors is presented below:

Chart performance and charts

Songs that are popular enough to appear on prominent record charts should have a "Chart performance" section. This section describes the song's history on the record charts and usually includes a table showing the song's peak chart positions. For help researching a song's chart history see the chart listings section below. For more information about displaying chart information in table format, see the Music Project's guidelines for chart tables.

Additional information to include

Articles about songs should contain information on important musical characteristics such as

  • structure (chorus/verse/bridge)
  • key. For traditional tunes if there is a reliable source indicating that there is a settled key or keys include this information.
  • time signature or signatures for tunes which have alternative versions in this respect, particularly those which may be in 3/4 vs 6/8 and those which have cut time variants which are verifiable.
  • Of lesser importance but possibly notable are recording techniques used, if there is a major recording or an original release for non-traditional songs.Other characteristics of specific recordings (or performances) may also meet inclusion criteria(musical techniques, etc).


External links

Include such things stated below on the external links:

  • chords
  • lyrics - Only officially licensed lyrics should be linked to per Wikipedia:Copyrights. Sites which provide officially licensed lyrics include MTV.com, CMT.com, and Yahoo Music.
  • parodies
  • tabs/sheet music
  • anything else relevant


Stubs

If the article is a stub, please use one of the following stub templates at the bottom of the page:

Models

The following is a list of featured articles on songs and singles. These are articles that the community as a whole have judged as being some of the best articles on Wikipedia. They can serve as excellent examples for articles on singles and songs.

The full list can be seen at Category:FA-Class song articles

Members

To add yourself as a member, put the userbox labeled {{User WikiProject Songs}} on your user page.

This user is a participant in WikiProject Songs.

To see who has joined the project, see Category:WikiProject Songs members.

See also

List of notable songs: an editable list created as part of the Missing encyclopedic articles WikiProject.

Requested Articles; an editable list of requested song articles , to fulfil or add your own.

Resources

Chart listings

Check the reliability of the chart for a specific country through WP:CHARTS. Some sources include:

  • Allmusic gives very incomplete (but somewhat helpful) information on some charting singles on Billboard charts including Hot 100 and other singles charts (ie; R&B, country) in its articles for the artist and their album(s). Other general information (credits) listed per artists and songwriters in Allmusic is quite incomplete, has many errors, and is difficult to correct. (For a much more reliable source on Billboard charts of all genres dating back to 1944, refer to Joel Whitburn's books published by Billboard Publications).
  • top40-charts.com has been listed in WP:BADCHARTS, and should not be used as a source.
  • ARIA has end-of-year Australian charts from 1989 onwards and a list of certifications at the end of each year for singles and albums (platinum and gold).
  • Oz Music Charts has a list of number-one hits in the U.S., UK, and Australia dating back to the 1950s.
  • everyhit.com has top-forty positions for UK singles from 1952.
  • the Database of Popular Music has an extensive database of songs and includes hits by year for both UK and U.S.
  • Randy Price has compiled the Cash Box magazine Best Selling Record charts from 1950 on.
  • Chartstats.com Archive of weekly UK singles charts runs since 1952.
  • aCharts.us is an unlicensed archive compiled by an anonymous source, and contains several charts listed on WP:BADCHARTS. WP:GOODCHARTS recommends against its use in featured or good articles. Archive from 2003.

Track listings

Subpages

Watchlist

Watch the 1500 most popular song pages!

Article alerts

Today's featured articles

Did you know

Articles for deletion

(4 more...)

Proposed deletions

Categories for discussion

(2 more...)

Redirects for discussion

Files for discussion

Featured article candidates

Featured list candidates

Featured topic candidates

Good article nominees

(29 more...)

Good topic candidates

(7 more...)

Peer reviews

Requested moves

(5 more...)

Articles to be merged

Articles to be split

Articles for creation

(11 more...)


Tools

Main tool page: toolserver.org
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:WikiProject_Songs&oldid=440049821"