Wikipedia:WikiProject Middle-earth/Article alerts/Archive 1

Archives

This is an archive of previous Article Alert reports. This page is automatically updated by AAlertBot. Entries and content can be added/removed/changed manually, as long as {{anchor|archivebottom}} and the workflow anchors {{anchor|AfD}}/{{anchor|AfDbottom}}, {{anchor|GAN}}/{{anchor|GANbottom}}, etc. aren't removed.

GAN

19 Aug 2011 – Quenya GA nominated by De728631 was not promoted; discussion
10 Dec 2012 – Quenya GA nominated by De728631 was promoted; discussion
04 Dec 2014 – Beowulf: The Monsters and the Critics GA nominated by Chiswick Chap was promoted; discussion
11 Feb 2016 – Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor GA nominated by AdrianGamer was promoted by Jaguar; discussion
08 Aug 2016 – Cirth GA nominated by Asþont was not promoted by Sagecandor; discussion
26 Jun 2017 – Elf GA nominated by Alarichall was promoted by Farang Rak Tham; discussion
16 Apr 2018 – Dragon GA nominated by Katolophyromai was not promoted by Squeamish Ossifrage; discussion

AfD

11 Nov 2011 – The Black Book of Arda AfDed by StAnselm was deleted; discussion
28 Dec 2011 – Red Arrow (Middle-earth) AfDed by Anthony Appleyard was closed as redirect by Arbitrarily0 on 05 Jan 2012; discussion
30 Dec 2011 – Laiquendi AfDed by GimliDotNet was closed as merge by Armbrust on 06 Jan 2012; discussion
27 Feb 2012 – Ainulindalë AfDed by GimliDotNet was closed as keep by Tom Morris on 06 Mar 2012; discussion
05 Aug 2012 – Narsil AfDed by GimliDotNet was closed as merge by The Bushranger on 13 Aug 2012; discussion
11 Aug 2012 – Imrahil AfDed by GimliDotNet was closed as redirect by Mark Arsten on 18 Aug 2012; discussion
17 Sep 2012 – Nedaphadrimeru AfDed by De728631 was deleted; discussion
24 Sep 2012 – The Hobbit (1985 film) AfDed by Go Phightins! was closed as keep by Drmies on 01 Oct 2012; discussion
18 Nov 2012 – Music of The Hobbit film series AfDed by Razr Nation was closed as merge by MBisanz on 26 Nov 2012; discussion
09 Dec 2012 – Gothmog (Third Age) AfDed by GimliDotNet was closed as no consensus by Michig on 24 Dec 2012; discussion
01 May 2013 – Argon (Middle-earth) AfDed by GimliDotNet was closed as delete by Black Kite on 09 May 2013; discussion
13 Sep 2013 – Thangorodrim AfDed by TTN was closed as keep by Mark Arsten on 06 Oct 2013; discussion
05 Dec 2013 – Lalaith AfDed by Crisco 1492 was closed as no consensus by Sandstein on 30 Dec 2013; discussion
14 Mar 2014 – The Scouring of the Shire AfDed by GimliDotNet was closed as keep by Mojo Hand on 22 Mar 2014; discussion
07 Apr 2014 – Minas Morgul AfDed by GimliDotNet was closed as no consensus by King of Hearts on 23 Apr 2014; discussion
01 Jun 2014 – A Walking Song AfDed by Ricky81682 was closed as no consensus by Northamerica1000 on 25 Jun 2014; discussion
22 Dec 2014 – Elanor Gardner AfDed by GimliDotNet was closed as merge by Courcelles on 16 Jan 2015; discussion
14 Mar 2015 – Hithlum AfDed by AadaamS was closed as no consensus by Nakon on 07 Apr 2015; discussion
14 Dec 2015 – Halfling AfDed by Ceosad was closed as keep by Davey2010 on 27 Dec 2015; discussion
25 Mar 2016 – Fingon AfDed by AadaamS was closed as redirect by Sandstein on 16 Apr 2016; discussion
16 Apr 2016 – Finrod Felagund AfDed by AadaamS was closed as keep by MBisanz on 09 May 2016; discussion
16 Apr 2016 – Curufin AfDed by AadaamS was closed as keep by David Fuchs on 11 May 2016; discussion
14 Dec 2015 – Halfling AfDed by Ceosad was closed as keep by Davey2010 on 27 Dec 2015; discussion
16 Apr 2016 – Caranthir AfDed by AadaamS was closed as delete by Swarm on 14 May 2016; discussion
16 Apr 2016 – Caranthir AfDed by AadaamS was closed as delete by Swarm on 14 May 2016; discussion
16 Apr 2016 – Maglor AfDed by AadaamS was closed as no consensus by Sjakkalle on 14 May 2016; discussion
11 Jun 2016 – Halbarad AfDed by Quasihuman was closed as redirect by Northamerica1000 on 18 Jun 2016; discussion
06 Aug 2016 – The Two Towers (MUD) AfDed by Czar was closed as delete by Sandstein on 21 Aug 2016; discussion
12 Sep 2016 – Catherine Karina Chmiel AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 27 Sep 2016; discussion
06 Aug 2016 – The Two Towers (MUD) AfDed by Czar was closed as delete by Sandstein on 21 Aug 2016; discussion
07 Jan 2017 – Gift of Men AfDed by Joshualouie711 was closed as delete by King of Hearts on 14 Jan 2017; discussion
04 Apr 2017 – Farmer Maggot AfDed by Hijiri88 was closed as keep by Feminist on 20 Apr 2017; discussion
19 Apr 2017 – Minor battles in The Lord of the Rings AfDed by Izno was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 26 Apr 2017; discussion
15 Jul 2017 – Fountain guards AfDed by Moduin was closed as delete by Ritchie333 on 30 Jul 2017; discussion
29 Jul 2017 – House of Húrin AfDed by Sandstein was closed as delete by RoySmith on 06 Aug 2017; discussion
29 Jul 2017 – House of Bëor AfDed by Sandstein was closed as delete by RoySmith on 06 Aug 2017; discussion
29 Jul 2017 – House of Finwë AfDed by Sandstein was closed as delete by RoySmith on 06 Aug 2017; discussion
29 Jul 2017 – House of Telcontar AfDed by Sandstein was closed as delete by RoySmith on 06 Aug 2017; discussion
29 Jul 2017 – Hador AfDed by Sandstein was closed as delete by RoySmith on 06 Aug 2017; discussion
13 Mar 2018 – Ceorl (Middle-earth) AfDed by Mdwicker was closed as delete by Malcolmxl5 on 21 Mar 2018; discussion
09 Apr 2018 – Eärnil II AfDed by Yellow Diamond was closed as redirect by RoySmith on 17 Apr 2018; discussion
10 Apr 2018 – Fíriel AfDed by Yellow Diamond was closed as delete by Spartaz on 18 Apr 2018; discussion
13 Aug 2018 – Adventures in Middle-earth AfDed by Chetsford was closed as keep by SoWhy on 22 Aug 2018; discussion
09 Oct 2018 – Fëa and hröa AfDed by Joshualouie711 was closed as delete by RoySmith on 17 Oct 2018; discussion
25 May 2019 – Fredegar Bolger AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as redirect by ST47 on 02 Jun 2019; discussion
09 Oct 2019 – Eönwë AfDed by TTN was closed as redirect by Tone on 24 Oct 2019; discussion
28 Oct 2019 – Thuringwethil AfDed by Susmuffin was closed as delete by Tone on 12 Nov 2019; discussion
06 Nov 2019 – Anduin AfDed by Piotrus was closed as merge by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 13 Nov 2019; discussion
07 Nov 2019 – Paths of the Dead AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 14 Nov 2019; discussion
12 Nov 2019 – Dead Men of Dunharrow AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Premeditated Chaos on 19 Nov 2019; discussion
12 Nov 2019 – Forlong the Fat AfDed by Clarityfiend was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 19 Nov 2019; discussion
13 Nov 2019 – Fords of Isen AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by RL0919 on 20 Nov 2019; discussion
12 Nov 2019 – Wizard (Middle-earth) AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Scottywong on 20 Nov 2019; discussion
12 Nov 2019 – Radagast AfDed by Piotrus was closed as keep by Scottywong on 20 Nov 2019; discussion
14 Nov 2019 – Daughters of Finwë AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by RL0919 on 21 Nov 2019; discussion
14 Nov 2019 – Blue Wizards AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 21 Nov 2019; discussion
14 Nov 2019 – Werewolf (Middle-earth) AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Tone on 21 Nov 2019; discussion
14 Nov 2019 – Thain (Middle-earth) AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Sandstein on 21 Nov 2019; discussion
14 Nov 2019 – Middle-earth roads AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Tone on 21 Nov 2019; discussion
14 Nov 2019 – House of Elendil AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Bradv on 21 Nov 2019; discussion
15 Nov 2019 – Aulë AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Sandstein on 22 Nov 2019; discussion
17 Nov 2019 – The Scouring of the Shire AfDed by Piotrus was closed as keep by ST47 on 24 Nov 2019; discussion
17 Nov 2019 – Barliman Butterbur AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as redirect by Sandstein on 24 Nov 2019; discussion
18 Nov 2019 – Mouth of Sauron AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as redirect by Tone on 25 Nov 2019; discussion
20 Nov 2019 – Sun and Moon (Middle-earth) AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as delete by Malcolmxl5 on 27 Nov 2019; discussion
20 Nov 2019 – Queen Berúthiel AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as merge by Tone on 27 Nov 2019; discussion
27 Nov 2019 – Battle of the Hornburg (initially Gamling) AfDed by Johnpacklambert was closed as keep by Tone on 27 Nov 2019; discussion
14 Nov 2019 – Nandor (Middle-earth) AfDed by Piotrus was closed as merge by Sgeureka on 28 Nov 2019; discussion
18 Nov 2019 – Hithlum AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Sgeureka on 28 Nov 2019; discussion
21 Nov 2019 – Ælfwine of England AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as keep by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 28 Nov 2019; discussion
17 Nov 2019 – Minor places in Middle-earth AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Sgeureka on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Angband AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Bëor AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Caradhras AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Edain AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Eriador AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Finduilas of Dol Amroth AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Háma (Middle-earth) AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Huorn AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Nargothrond AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Manwë AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
22 Nov 2019 – Warg (Middle-earth) AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 29 Nov 2019; discussion
23 Nov 2019 – List of Middle-earth rivers AfDed by Clarityfiend was closed as delete by Barkeep49 on 01 Dec 2019; discussion
23 Nov 2019 – List of Middle-earth animals AfDed by Clarityfiend was closed as delete by Lord Roem on 01 Dec 2019; discussion
23 Nov 2019 – Middle-earth plants AfDed by Clarityfiend was closed as delete by Lord Roem on 01 Dec 2019; discussion
24 Nov 2019 – Ulmo AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Sgeureka on 01 Dec 2019; discussion
24 Nov 2019 – Vampire (Middle-earth) AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by BD2412 on 01 Dec 2019; discussion
25 Nov 2019 – White Council AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by RL0919 on 02 Dec 2019; discussion
25 Nov 2019 – Half-elven AfDed by Piotrus was closed as merge by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 02 Dec 2019; discussion
25 Nov 2019 – Round World version of the Silmarillion AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 02 Dec 2019; discussion
28 Nov 2019 – Easterlings (First Age) AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Malcolmxl5 on 05 Dec 2019; discussion
28 Nov 2019 – Easterlings AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Sgeureka on 05 Dec 2019; discussion
28 Nov 2019 – Melian AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Ritchie333 on 06 Dec 2019; discussion
28 Nov 2019 – Esgaroth AfDed by Piotrus was closed as no consensus by Ritchie333 on 06 Dec 2019; discussion
28 Nov 2019 – Caras Galadhon AfDed by Piotrus was closed as merge by Ritchie333 on 06 Dec 2019; discussion
28 Nov 2019 – Celeborn AfDed by Piotrus was closed as merge by Ritchie333 on 06 Dec 2019; discussion
28 Nov 2019 – Varda AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by RL0919 on 06 Dec 2019; discussion
29 Nov 2019 – Uinen AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 06 Dec 2019; discussion
29 Nov 2019 – Glaurung AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Czar on 06 Dec 2019; discussion
30 Nov 2019 – Minor places in Beleriand AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as delete by Czar on 07 Dec 2019; discussion
30 Nov 2019 – Ecthelion of the Fountain AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Czar on 07 Dec 2019; discussion
30 Nov 2019 – Pelendur AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Malcolmxl5 on 08 Dec 2019; discussion
01 Dec 2019 – Malbeth the Seer AfDed by Johnpacklambert was closed as delete by RL0919 on 08 Dec 2019; discussion
01 Dec 2019 – Maeglin AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Sandstein on 08 Dec 2019; discussion
01 Dec 2019 – Mardil Voronwë AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 08 Dec 2019; discussion
01 Dec 2019 – Vorondil AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 08 Dec 2019; discussion
01 Dec 2019 – House of Haleth AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Tone on 08 Dec 2019; discussion
02 Dec 2019 – Turgon AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 09 Dec 2019; discussion
02 Dec 2019 – Aerin AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 09 Dec 2019; discussion
02 Dec 2019 – Dorlas AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 09 Dec 2019; discussion
02 Dec 2019 – Manthor AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by AustralianRupert on 09 Dec 2019; discussion
02 Dec 2019 – Boldog AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 09 Dec 2019; discussion
02 Dec 2019 – Wise (Edain) AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 09 Dec 2019; discussion
02 Dec 2019 – List of Middle-earth Lego sets AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 10 Dec 2019; discussion
02 Dec 2019 – Men of Twilight AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Malcolmxl5 on 09 Dec 2019; discussion
02 Dec 2019 – Elfhelm AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Malcolmxl5 on 09 Dec 2019; discussion
03 Dec 2019 – Tirion AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by RL0919 on 10 Dec 2019; discussion
03 Dec 2019 – Stewards of Gondor AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Tone on 10 Dec 2019; discussion
04 Dec 2019 – Avranc AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by AustralianRupert on 11 Dec 2019; discussion
04 Dec 2019 – Húrin the Tall AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Sandstein on 11 Dec 2019; discussion
08 Dec 2019 – Amrod AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 15 Dec 2019; discussion
09 Dec 2019 – Curufin AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Tone on 16 Dec 2019; discussion
09 Dec 2019 – Amras AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Malcolmxl5 on 16 Dec 2019; discussion
09 Dec 2019 – Erkenbrand AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Czar on 16 Dec 2019; discussion
11 Dec 2019 – Tilion AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Malcolmxl5 on 18 Dec 2019; discussion
13 Dec 2019 – White Tree of Gondor AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Sgeureka on 20 Dec 2019; discussion
14 Dec 2019 – Gothmog (Third Age) AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as redirect by Spartaz on 22 Dec 2019; discussion
15 Dec 2019 – Forodwaith AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as delete by Sandstein on 22 Dec 2019; discussion
16 Dec 2019 – Middle-earth wars and battles AfDed by Jack Upland was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 23 Dec 2019; discussion
16 Dec 2019 – Of the Rings of Power and the Third Age AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as redirect by RL0919 on 23 Dec 2019; discussion
17 Dec 2019 – Rhûn AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Sgeureka on 24 Dec 2019; discussion
17 Dec 2019 – Arvedui AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by Sgeureka on 24 Dec 2019; discussion
17 Dec 2019 – Battle of Dale AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by Eagles247 on 25 Dec 2019; discussion
18 Dec 2019 – Dagor Dagorath AfDed by Piotrus was closed as delete by RL0919 on 25 Dec 2019; discussion
19 Dec 2019 – Lindon (Middle-earth) AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 26 Dec 2019; discussion
19 Dec 2019 – Ithilien AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by RL0919 on 26 Dec 2019; discussion
19 Dec 2019 – Avari (Middle-earth) AfDed by Piotrus was closed as redirect by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 26 Dec 2019; discussion
19 Dec 2019 – Rangers of Ithilien AfDed by Clarityfiend was closed as delete by Jo-Jo Eumerus on 26 Dec 2019; discussion
22 Dec 2019 – Middle-earth armies and hosts AfDed by Clarityfiend was closed as delete by BD2412 on 29 Dec 2019; discussion
23 Dec 2019 – Eluréd and Elurín AfDed by Johnpacklambert was closed as delete by RL0919 on 30 Dec 2019; discussion
24 Dec 2019 – Grimbold AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 31 Dec 2019; discussion
24 Dec 2019 – Dior Eluchíl AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as delete by RL0919 on 31 Dec 2019; discussion
30 Dec 2019 – Hareth AfDed by Hog Farm was closed as keep by Hog Farm on 30 Dec 2019; discussion

CfD

20 Oct 2011 – Category:Works inspired by J. R. R. Tolkien CfDed by Mike Selinker was closed; discussion
23 Aug 2012 – Category:Middle-earth video games CfDed by The Bushranger was closed; discussion
23 Aug 2012 – Category:Middle-earth games CfDed by The Bushranger was closed; discussion
23 Jul 2013 – Category:Films in The Lord of the Rings (film series) CfDed by Armbrust was closed; discussion
13 Feb 2014 – Category:Characters in The Lord of the Rings CfDed by Liz was closed; discussion
19 Feb 2014 – Category:Original characters and objects in The Lord of the Rings (film series) CfDed by Safiel was closed; discussion
17 Sep 2015 – Category:Middle-earth food and drink CfDed by DexDor was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Works based on Middle-earth CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Middle-earth parodies CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Games based on Middle-earth CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Middle-earth music CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Radio programmes based on Middle-earth CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Middle-earth theatre CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Middle-earth films CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Board games based on Middle-earth CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Miniatures games based on Middle-earth CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Role-playing games based on Middle-earth CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
16 Feb 2016 – Category:Video games based on Middle-earth CfDed by Roscelese was closed; discussion
11 Jul 2016 – Category:Middle-earth rivers CfDed by Od Mishehu AWB was closed; discussion
11 Jul 2016 – Category:Middle-earth rivers CfDed by Od Mishehu AWB was closed; discussion
09 Dec 2017 – Category:Middle-earth materials CfDed by 165.91.12.221 was closed; discussion
21 Dec 2017 – Category:Middle-earth regions CfDed by 108.210.216.40 was closed; discussion
22 Dec 2017 – Category:Rulers of Númenor CfDed by Marcocapelle was closed; discussion
11 Apr 2018 – Category:Middle-earth theology CfDed by Marcocapelle was closed; discussion
12 Sep 2018 – Category:Elves in film CfDed by Doniago was closed; discussion
03 Jun 2019 – Category:Miniatures games based on Middle-earth CfDed by Marcocapelle was closed; discussion
06 Mar 2019 – Category:Middle-earth horses CfDed by Woodensuperman was closed; discussion
05 Dec 2019 – Category:Middle-earth Dragons CfDed by TTN was closed; discussion

PROD

27 Dec 2011 – House of Isildur PRODed by 80.2.95.0 was deproded by GimliDotNet on 29 Dec 2011
31 Dec 2011 – Quenta Silmarillion PRODed by Bajazeth was deproded by Colonel Warden on 31 Dec 2011
31 Dec 2011 – Akallabêth PRODed by Bajazeth was deproded by Colonel Warden on 31 Dec 2011
31 Dec 2011 – Ainulindalë PRODed by Bajazeth was deproded by Colonel Warden on 31 Dec 2011
31 Dec 2011 – Valaquenta PRODed by Bajazeth was deproded by Colonel Warden on 31 Dec 2011
27 Dec 2011 – Warning beacons of Gondor PRODed by 80.2.95.0 was redirected to Gondor
09 Aug 2012 – Imrahil PRODed by GimliDotNet was deproded by Arentol Gellor on 11 Aug 2012
09 Aug 2012 – Bill Ferny PRODed by GimliDotNet was redirected to List of Middle-earth animals#Bill
09 Aug 2012 – Freca PRODed by GimliDotNet was redirected to Helm Hammerhand
16 Sep 2012 – Beyond Bree PRODed by De728631 was deleted
18 Dec 2014 – Elanor Gardner PRODed by GimliDotNet was deproded by 151.227.5.112 on 21 Dec 2014
15 Jan 2015 – Aredhel PRODed by AadaamS was deproded by Cryptic on 23 Jan 2015
25 Apr 2015 – Fountain guards PRODed by Neutrality was deproded by Andrew Davidson on 04 May 2015
09 Jul 2017 – Fountain guards PRODed by Moduin was deproded by Kvng on 13 Jul 2017
08 Jul 2017 – Music Inspired by The Lord of the Rings (Mostly Autumn album) PRODed by 68.151.25.115 was redirected to Mostly Autumn
31 May 2018 – Tower Guard of Gondor PRODed by Reyk was deleted
12 Nov 2019 – Blue Wizards PRODed by Jack Upland was deproded by Andrew Davidson on 12 Nov 2019
13 Nov 2019 – Werewolf (Middle-earth) PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by *Treker on 13 Nov 2019
13 Nov 2019 – Daughters of Finwë PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Ausir on 13 Nov 2019
12 Nov 2019 – House of Elendil PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 14 Nov 2019
12 Nov 2019 – Half-elven PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 14 Nov 2019
12 Nov 2019 – White Council PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 14 Nov 2019
12 Nov 2019 – Maia (Middle-earth) PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 14 Nov 2019
12 Nov 2019 – Goldberry PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 14 Nov 2019
12 Nov 2019 – Aulë PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 14 Nov 2019
13 Nov 2019 – Thain (Middle-earth) PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by 2601:444:380:8C00:29EF:3923:6CB9:42D9 on 14 Nov 2019
13 Nov 2019 – Nandor (Middle-earth) PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 14 Nov 2019
13 Nov 2019 – Vampire (Middle-earth) PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Goustien on 15 Nov 2019
15 Nov 2019 – Ulmo PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 15 Nov 2019
15 Nov 2019 – Manwë PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 15 Nov 2019
12 Nov 2019 – Round World version of the Silmarillion PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Spinningspark on 17 Nov 2019
12 Nov 2019 – Ornendil PRODed by Piotrus was deleted
13 Nov 2019 – Siege of Angband PRODed by Piotrus was deleted
13 Nov 2019 – Battle of Mirkwood PRODed by Piotrus was deleted
13 Nov 2019 – Haldir (First Age) PRODed by Piotrus was deleted
13 Nov 2019 – Hallas (Steward) PRODed by Piotrus was deleted
13 Nov 2019 – Cirion PRODed by Piotrus was deleted
13 Nov 2019 – Exiles (Middle-earth) PRODed by Piotrus was deleted
18 Nov 2019 – Dunharrow PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Goustien on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Háma (Middle-earth) PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Finduilas of Dol Amroth PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Warg (Middle-earth) PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Huorn PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Edain PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Bëor PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Nargothrond PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Angband PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Eriador PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Caradhras PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – White Mountains (Middle-earth) PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 21 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Easterlings (First Age) PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Goustien on 23 Nov 2019
18 Nov 2019 – Troll-man PRODed by Piotrus was redirected to Troll (Middle-earth)
18 Nov 2019 – Took clan PRODed by Piotrus was redirected to List of hobbit families#T
18 Nov 2019 – Dorthonion PRODed by Piotrus was redirected to Realms of Arda#Noldorin realms
18 Nov 2019 – Nan Elmoth PRODed by Piotrus was redirected to Realms of Arda#Avarin and Nandorin realms
25 Nov 2019 – Melian PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 27 Nov 2019
26 Nov 2019 – Caras Galadhon PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 27 Nov 2019
26 Nov 2019 – Esgaroth PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 27 Nov 2019
26 Nov 2019 – Tirion PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by DGG on 28 Nov 2019
22 Nov 2019 – Nienna PRODed by Piotrus was redirected to Vala (Middle-earth)#Nienna
22 Nov 2019 – Yavanna PRODed by Piotrus was redirected to Vala (Middle-earth)#Yavanna
29 Nov 2019 – Lonely Mountain PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Hog Farm on 29 Nov 2019
02 Dec 2019 – Elladan and Elrohir PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Necrothesp on 04 Dec 2019
29 Nov 2019 – Iron Hills PRODed by Piotrus was redirected to Middle-earth#The Second, Third and Fourth Ages
30 Nov 2019 – Sador PRODed by Hog Farm was redirected to List of Middle-earth characters#S
30 Nov 2019 – Hardang PRODed by Hog Farm was redirected to Húrin#Appearance and history
30 Nov 2019 – Rían PRODed by Hog Farm was redirected to List of Middle-earth characters#R
30 Nov 2019 – Gorlim PRODed by Hog Farm was redirected to Barahir
30 Nov 2019 – Elwing PRODed by Hog Farm was redirected to List of Middle-earth characters#E
01 Dec 2019 – Erendis PRODed by Hog Farm was redirected to List of Númenóreans#Erendis
01 Dec 2019 – Celegorm PRODed by Hog Farm was redirected to Fëanor
01 Dec 2019 – Angrod PRODed by Hog Farm was redirected to List of Middle-earth characters#A
05 Dec 2019 – Eldarion PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Screechybird1 on 07 Dec 2019
02 Dec 2019 – Marach PRODed by Piotrus was redirected to Man (Middle-earth)#Edain
02 Dec 2019 – Brandir PRODed by Piotrus was redirected to List of Middle-earth characters#B
02 Dec 2019 – Brandybuck Clan PRODed by Piotrus was redirected to List of hobbit families
21 Dec 2019 – Ranger (Middle-earth) PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Goustien on 22 Dec 2019
17 Dec 2019 – Dagor-nuin-Giliath PRODed by Hog Farm was deleted
17 Dec 2019 – Dagor Aglareb PRODed by Hog Farm was deleted
17 Dec 2019 – Dagor Bragollach PRODed by Hog Farm was deleted
17 Dec 2019 – First Battle of Beleriand PRODed by Hog Farm was deleted
21 Dec 2019 – Tol Eressëa PRODed by Piotrus was deproded by Nemo bis on 27 Dec 2019

PR

07 Jan 2012 – The Hobbit put up for PR by De728631 was closed; discussion

FAC

04 Feb 2012 – The Hobbit FA nominated by De728631 was not promoted; discussion

FLC

02 Mar 2012 – List of accolades received by The Lord of the Rings film trilogy FL nominated by Ruby2010 was closed; discussion

RfC

08 Jul 2012 – The Lord of the Rings film trilogy RfC by GimliDotNet was closed; discussion
16 Dec 2012 – The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey RfC by Tenebrae was closed; discussion
29 Dec 2013 – The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey RfC by Betty Logan was closed; discussion

FfD

04 Aug 2012 – File:JRR Tolkien signature - from Commons.svg FfDed by De728631 was closed; discussion
05 Sep 2012 – File:TheHobbitFilm13Dwarves.jpg FfDed by Bulwersator was closed; discussion
06 May 2013 – File:"Crist", by Cynewulf, translated into Quenya, written in Tengwar.png FfDed by Jay8g was closed; discussion
04 Dec 2014 – File:Jrrt lotr cover design.jpg FfDed by Stefan2 was closed; discussion
08 Jan 2015 – File:TheHobbit.png FfDed by Safiel was closed; discussion

RM

04 Aug 2012 – The Lord of the Rings film trilogy move request by Betty Logan was closed; discussion
04 Aug 2012 – The Hobbit film trilogy move request by Silvergoat was closed; discussion
04 Aug 2012 – The Hobbit (2012 film) move request by Silvergoat was closed; discussion
16 Oct 2012 – Rohan move request by Tamfang was closed; discussion
26 Feb 2013 – Middle-earth in film move request by Evanh2008 was closed; discussion
24 Mar 2013 – Mythopoeia (genre) move request by Florian Blaschke was closed; discussion
01 May 2013 – The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring move request by George Ho was closed; discussion
18 Jun 2013 – The Lord of the Rings Online: Shadows of Angmar move request by Augsburgbeliever was closed; discussion
25 Jul 2013 – Gimli (Middle-earth) move request by BDD was closed; discussion
04 Sep 2013 – The Lord of the Rings move request by George Ho was closed; discussion
20 Oct 2013 – Ainur (Middle-earth) move request to Ainu (Middle-earth) by Thu was closed; discussion
06 Jan 2014 – Eye of Sauron move request to Eye of Sauron (disambiguation) by BD2412 was closed; discussion
10 Apr 2014 – The Hobbit (film series) move request to The Hobbit: There and Back Again by AdamDeanHall was closed; discussion
15 Feb 2015 – Hobbiton film set move request to Hobbiton Movie Set by Ben MacDui was closed; discussion
25 Sep 2015 – Aman (disambiguation) move request by Zanhe was closed; discussion
19 Apr 2018 – Fall of Gondolin move request by Anthony Appleyard was closed; discussion
29 Apr 2018 – The Tale of Beren and Lúthien move request by Lawrence King was closed; discussion

TfD

21 Sep 2012 – Template:ME-disambiguation TfDed by De728631 was closed; discussion
12 Nov 2012 – Template:LotR navbox TfDed by Izno was closed; discussion
08 Feb 2013 – Template:Middle-earth Labelled Map TfDed by Gadget850 was closed; discussion
28 Feb 2013 – Template:ME-importance TfDed by Alan Liefting was closed; discussion
02 Feb 2014 – Template:Fellowship of the Ring TfDed by Matt Deres was closed; discussion
06 Mar 2014 – Template:Infobox LOTR place TfDed by Pigsonthewing was closed; discussion
06 Mar 2014 – Template:Infobox Middle-earth place TfDed by Pigsonthewing was closed; discussion
12 Oct 2015 – Template:Middle-earth weapons TfDed by Izno was closed; discussion
12 Oct 2015 – Template:Arda Rivers TfDed by Izno was closed; discussion
14 Oct 2015 – Template:Kings of Rohan TfDed by Izno was closed; discussion
29 Oct 2015 – Template:IsildurHeirs TfDed by Izno was closed; discussion
29 Oct 2015 – Template:AnarionHeirs TfDed by Izno was closed; discussion
09 May 2016 – Template:Isildur family tree TfDed by Magioladitis was closed; discussion
09 May 2016 – Template:Tookclan family tree TfDed by Magioladitis was closed; discussion
09 May 2016 – Template:Húrin family tree TfDed by Magioladitis was closed; discussion
09 May 2016 – Template:House of Eorl TfDed by Magioladitis was closed; discussion
25 Nov 2016 – Template:Tolkien-sectstub TfDed by KATMAKROFAN was closed; discussion
25 Nov 2016 – Template:ME-fact TfDed by KATMAKROFAN was closed; discussion
10 Jun 2017 – Template:Middle-earth dragons TfDed by TenPoundHammer was closed; discussion
09 Jul 2018 – Template:Anarion family tree TfDed by 2601:2C4:C480:946:FC71:F76:5CFA:4ECB was closed; discussion
07 Aug 2018 – Template:Anarion family tree TfDed by Hhkohh was closed; discussion
25 Dec 2019 – Template:Campaignbox Wars of Beleriand TfDed by Hog Farm was closed; discussion

RfD

22 Nov 2012 – The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (film) RfDed by De728631 was closed; discussion
03 Jul 2016 – Great Darkness →Treebeard RfDed by Patar knight was closed; discussion

MfD

13 Apr 2016 – User:APclark/Frodo Simpsins MfDed by Ricky81682 was closed (deleted) by Xaosflux on 01 May 2016; discussion
12 Nov 2019 – Portal:Middle-earth MfDed by Guilherme Burn was closed as delete by Scottywong on 19 Nov 2019; discussion

MRG

12 Jul 2018 – A Guide to Middle-earth proposed for merging to The Complete Guide to Middle-earth by Dyolf87 was closed; discussion
18 Aug 2019 – Blue Wizards proposed for merging to Wizard (Middle-earth) by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
15 Nov 2019 – Vampire (Middle-earth) proposed for merging to Middle-earth peoples by Goustien was closed; discussion
18 Nov 2019 – Dáin II Ironfoot proposed for merging to Middle-earth dwarf characters by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
19 Nov 2019 – Eru Ilúvatar proposed for merging to Cosmology of Tolkien's legendarium by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
20 Nov 2019 – Déagol proposed for merging to Gollum by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
20 Nov 2019 – Old Man Willow proposed for merging to Old Forest by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
23 Nov 2019 – Farmer Maggot proposed for merging to List of hobbits by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
24 Nov 2019 – Goldberry proposed for merging to Tom Bombadil by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
26 Nov 2019 – Gondolin proposed for merging to The Fall of Gondolin by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
28 Nov 2019 – Ælfwine (Tolkien) proposed for merging to Tolkien's legendarium by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
02 Dec 2019 – Ghân-buri-Ghân proposed for merging to Drúedain by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
15 Dec 2019 – Children of Ilúvatar proposed for merging to Cosmology of Tolkien's legendarium by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
16 Dec 2019 – Rangers of Ithilien proposed for merging to Ithilien by Jack Upland was closed; discussion
06 Nov 2019 – Sting (Middle-earth) proposed for merging to Middle-earth objects by Piotrus was closed; discussion

AAlertBot is coded by Hellknowz and co-operated with Headbomb. Discuss? / Report bug? / Request feature?