Jump to content

Tata Nano: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
Line 45: Line 45:
The car was scheduled to release in "B" Segments cities first, followed by other cities.
The car was scheduled to release in "B" Segments cities first, followed by other cities.


Critics of the car have questioned its safety in [[India]] (where reportedly 90,000 people are killed in road-accidents every year<ref>http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/driving/news/article3168303.ece</ref>), and have also criticised the [[pollution]] that it would cause<ref>http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/driving/article3164205.ece</ref> (including criticism by [[Nobel Peace Prize]]-winning [[scientist]], [[Rajendra Pachauri]]<ref>http://www.cbc.ca/consumer/story/2008/01/10/nano-tata.html</ref>). However, [[Tata Motors]] has promised that it would definitely release Nano's eco-friendly variants alongside the [[gasoline]]-variant<ref>http://www.engadget.com/2008/07/03/tatas-nano-to-begin-production-this-fall-eco-friendly-version/</ref><ref name="merinews.com">http://www.merinews.com/catFull.jsp?articleID=139838</ref>.
Critics of the car have questioned its safety in [[India]] (where reportedly 90,000 people are killed in road-accidents every year<ref>http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/driving/news/article3168303.ece</ref>), and have also criticised the [[pollution]] that it would cause<ref>http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/driving/article3164205.ece</ref> (including criticism by [[Nobel Peace Prize]]-winning [[scientist]], [[Rajendra Pachauri]]<ref>http://www.cbc.ca/consumer/story/2008/01/10/nano-tata.html</ref>). However, [[Tata Motors]] has promised that it would definitely release Nano's eco-friendly variants alongside the [[gasoline]]-variant<ref>http://www.engadget.com/2008/07/03/tatas-nano-to-begin-production-this-fall-eco-friendly-version/</ref><ref name="merinews.com">http://www.merinews.com/catFull.jsp?articleID=139838</ref>. There are also concerns that a massive rise in the number of petrol consuming vehicles would ruin India's petroleum industry, which is already financially crippled due to massive subsidies that it must enforce on all petrol, whether domestically produced or purchased at market prices on the world market.


Due to opposition to Tata's [[Singur]] car-factory by [[Mamta Banerjee]], Tata Motors decided to cease operations in Singur on 2 October 2008 and started manufacturing Tata Nano at its [[Pantnagar]] plant. On her protests and the consequent pullout, the media heavily criticised her and ''[[The Telegraph (Kolkata)|The Telegraph]]'' even said<ref>http://www.telegraphindia.com/1081007/jsp/opinion/story_9933949.jsp</ref>: "India is being raped by those who profess to be her soldiers, the guardians of peace." ''[[Financial Times]]'' reported<ref>http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/e68ab572-8a3e-11dd-a76a-0000779fd18c.html</ref>: "If ever there were a symbol of India’s ambitions to become a modern nation, it would surely be the Nano, the tiny car with the even tinier price-tag. A triumph of homegrown engineering, the $2,200 (€1,490, £1,186) Nano encapsulates the dream of millions of Indians groping for a shot at urban prosperity. That process has stalled...No big economy has prospered without undergoing a huge, often brutal, shift of labour from the countryside to cities and from farms to factories...There is a yawning gap with [[China]]. India’s [[information technology]] and service sector, no matter how dynamic, simply cannot absorb enough labour. To truly shine, India will need millions, perhaps tens of millions, more manufacturing jobs. Why has it not created them?"
Due to opposition to Tata's [[Singur]] car-factory by [[Mamta Banerjee]], Tata Motors decided to cease operations in Singur on 2 October 2008 and started manufacturing Tata Nano at its [[Pantnagar]] plant. On her protests and the consequent pullout, the media heavily criticised her and ''[[The Telegraph (Kolkata)|The Telegraph]]'' even said<ref>http://www.telegraphindia.com/1081007/jsp/opinion/story_9933949.jsp</ref>: "India is being raped by those who profess to be her soldiers, the guardians of peace." ''[[Financial Times]]'' reported<ref>http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/e68ab572-8a3e-11dd-a76a-0000779fd18c.html</ref>: "If ever there were a symbol of India’s ambitions to become a modern nation, it would surely be the Nano, the tiny car with the even tinier price-tag. A triumph of homegrown engineering, the $2,200 (€1,490, £1,186) Nano encapsulates the dream of millions of Indians groping for a shot at urban prosperity. That process has stalled...No big economy has prospered without undergoing a huge, often brutal, shift of labour from the countryside to cities and from farms to factories...There is a yawning gap with [[China]]. India’s [[information technology]] and service sector, no matter how dynamic, simply cannot absorb enough labour. To truly shine, India will need millions, perhaps tens of millions, more manufacturing jobs. Why has it not created them?"

Revision as of 03:45, 27 February 2009

Tata Nano
‎
Overview
ManufacturerTata Motors
Also calledThe People's Car
Production2008—present
DesignerGirish Wagh, Justin Norek of Trilix, Pierre Castinel[1]
Body and chassis
ClassCity car
Body style4-door hatchback
LayoutRR layout
RelatedOfficial website
Powertrain
Engine2 cylinder SOHC petrol Bosch multi-point fuel injection (single injector) all aluminium 623 cc (38 cu in)
Transmission4 speed synchromesh with overdrive in 4th
Dimensions
Wheelbase2,230 mm (87.8 in)
LengthTemplate:Auto mm[2]
WidthTemplate:Auto mm[2]
HeightTemplate:Auto mm[2]
Kerb weight580 kg (1,280 lb)-600 kg (1,300 lb)[3]
Chronology
Predecessornone

The Tata Nano is a proposed city car — a small, affordable, rear-engined, four-passenger car aimed primarily at the Indian market — first presented by India's Tata Motors at the 9th annual Auto Expo on January 10, 2008, at Pragati Maidan in New Delhi, India.[4]

Tata targets the vehicle as the least expensive production car in the world[5] — aiming for a starting price of Rs.100,000 (approximately US$2500).[6][7]. On February 26, Tata Motors announced that the commercial launch of Tata Nano will be on March 23.[8]

Newsweek identifies the Nano as a part of a "new breed of 21st-century cars" that embody "a contrarian philosophy of smaller, lighter, cheaper" and portend a new era in inexpensive personal transportation — and potentially, "global gridlock" [9]. The Wall Street Journal confirms a global trend toward small cars, which includes the Nano.[10]

The prefix "nano-" derives from the Greek root 'nanos', meaning dwarf. "Nano" also means "small" in Gujarati, the native language of the Tata family,[11] founders of the Tata Group.

Overview

The introduction of the Nano received media attention due to its targeted low price. The car is expected to boost the Indian Economy, create entrepreneurial-opportunities across India[12][13], as well as expand the Indian car market by 65%[14]. The car was envisioned by, Ratan Tata, Chairman of the Tata Group and Tata Motors, who has described it as an eco-friendly "people's car". Nano has been greatly appreciated by many sources and the media for its low-cost[15][16] and eco-friendly initiatives which include using compressed-air as fuel[17] and an electric-version (E-Nano)[18][19]. Tata Group is expected to mass-manufacture the Nano, particularly the electric-version, and, besides selling them in India, to also export them worldwide[20][21][22].

The car was scheduled to release in "B" Segments cities first, followed by other cities.

Critics of the car have questioned its safety in India (where reportedly 90,000 people are killed in road-accidents every year[23]), and have also criticised the pollution that it would cause[24] (including criticism by Nobel Peace Prize-winning scientist, Rajendra Pachauri[25]). However, Tata Motors has promised that it would definitely release Nano's eco-friendly variants alongside the gasoline-variant[26][27]. There are also concerns that a massive rise in the number of petrol consuming vehicles would ruin India's petroleum industry, which is already financially crippled due to massive subsidies that it must enforce on all petrol, whether domestically produced or purchased at market prices on the world market.

Due to opposition to Tata's Singur car-factory by Mamta Banerjee, Tata Motors decided to cease operations in Singur on 2 October 2008 and started manufacturing Tata Nano at its Pantnagar plant. On her protests and the consequent pullout, the media heavily criticised her and The Telegraph even said[28]: "India is being raped by those who profess to be her soldiers, the guardians of peace." Financial Times reported[29]: "If ever there were a symbol of India’s ambitions to become a modern nation, it would surely be the Nano, the tiny car with the even tinier price-tag. A triumph of homegrown engineering, the $2,200 (€1,490, £1,186) Nano encapsulates the dream of millions of Indians groping for a shot at urban prosperity. That process has stalled...No big economy has prospered without undergoing a huge, often brutal, shift of labour from the countryside to cities and from farms to factories...There is a yawning gap with China. India’s information technology and service sector, no matter how dynamic, simply cannot absorb enough labour. To truly shine, India will need millions, perhaps tens of millions, more manufacturing jobs. Why has it not created them?"

Currently, Tata Motors is reportedly manufacturing Nano at its existing Pantnagar (Uttarakhand) plant and a mother plant has been proposed for Sanand Gujarat.[2]. The company will bank on existing dealer network for Nano initially.[30] The new Nano Plant could have a capacity of 5,00,000 units, compared to 3,00,000 for Singur. Gujarat has also agreed to match all the incentives offered by West Bengal government.[31]

Introduction

Conception and design

The project to create the world's cheapest production car began in 2003, under the Chairman of Tata Motors, Ratan Tata, [32] inspired by the number of Indian families with two-wheeled rather than four-wheeled transport[33]. The Nano's development has been tempered by the company's success in producing the low cost 4 wheeled Ace truck in May 2005.[32]

Contrary to speculation that the car might be a simple four-wheeled auto rickshaw, The Times of India reported the vehicle is "a properly designed and built car".[34] The Chairman is reported to have said, "It is not a car with plastic curtains or no roof — it's a real car."[32]

To achieve its design parameters, Tata has refined the manufacturing process, emphasized innovation and sought new design approaches from suppliers.[34] The car was designed at Italy's Institute of Development in Automotive Engineering — with Ratan Tata requesting certain changes, such the elimination of one of two windscreen wipers.[32]

The Nano has 21% more interior space and an 8% smaller exterior, when compared with its closest rival, the Maruti 800. The car will come in different versions, including one standard and two deluxe variants. The deluxe version will have air conditioning, but no power steering. The initial production target set by Tata Motors is 250,000 units per year.

Expectations

According to one report, India as well as other nations, such as European nations[35], have great expectations from the Nano and are keenly and eagerly awaiting it, especially the electric version of the Nano[36],making it in all probability the "world's cheapest electric car" officially on record[37][38]. The car itself is expected to boost the Indian Economy as well as expand the Indian car market by 65%, according to rating agency CRISIL.[39]

Benevolent opportunities for local-entrepreneurs

Modular design

BusinessWeek says[12][40]:

The Nano is constructed of components that can be built and shipped separately to be assembled in a variety of locations. In effect, the Nano is being sold in kits that are distributed, assembled, and serviced by local entrepreneurs. As Ratan Tata, chairman of the Tata group of companies, observed in an interview with The Times of London: "A bunch of entrepreneurs could establish an assembly operation and Tata Motors would train their people, would oversee their quality assurance and they would become satellite assembly operations for us. So we would create entrepreneurs across the country that would produce the car. We would produce the mass items and ship it to them as kits. That is my idea of dispersing wealth. The service person would be like an insurance agent who would be trained, have a cell phone and scooter and would be assigned to a set of customers." In fact, Tata envisions going even further, providing the tools for local mechanics to assemble the car in existing auto shops or even in new garages created to cater to remote rural customers. With the exception of Manjeet Kripalani, BusinessWeek's India bureau chief, few have focused on this breakthrough element of the Nano innovation (BusinessWeek.com, 1/10/08).

Pricing strategy

Tata initially targeted the vehicle as "the least expensive production car in the world"[5] — aiming for a starting price of 100,000 rupees or approximately $2050 US[6][7] despite rapidly rising material prices.[41]

As of August 2008, material costs have risen from 13% to 23% over the car’s development,[42] and Tata now faces the choice of:

  • introducing the car with an artificially low price through govt-subsidies and tax-breaks, or
  • foregoing profit on the car, or
  • using vertical-integration, or
  • partially using inexpensive polymers or biodegradable plastics instead of a full metal-body, or
  • raising the price of the car

An increased price on the Nano will likely decrease demand.[42]

Others

Effect on Indian Economy

Economic Times quotes[43]:

Tata Nano’s launch could expand the Indian car market by 65%, according to rating agency CRISIL. The low price makes the car affordable for families with incomes of Rs 1 lakh per annum, the agency said. The increase in the market is expected to push up car sales by 20% over the previous year. “The unveiling of Tata Nano, the cheapest car in the world, triggers an important event in the car market. Based on the statement by company officials, CRISIL Research estimates the consumer price of the car at around Rs 1.3 lakh. This brings down the cost of ownership of an entry level car in India by 30%,” the company said in a report.

Thus, the Indian Economy is expected to remain strong and grow in 2008 and beyond, despite the temporary financial turmoil in the US, because the car will also lead to a boost in other sectors of the Indian Economy besides the auto-market.

However, due to the current Singur land dispute, the "Stalled Car Factory" is "Costing Jobs, Splitting Neighbors in West Bengal"[44]

VOANews quotes[44]:

Tata's problems in West Bengal are scaring off other industries hoping to locate here, including Infosys, a software maker that wants to build a business park that would provide 5,000 jobs.

Kartik Chandra Malik, 57, runs a tea shop near the boundary wall of Tata's Nano factory.

He says he is frustrated that the factory has been stopped. He says wants it to open, because when it is open he can do more business selling tea and biscuits. He is hoping his son, who just graduated from college, will get a good job at the factory.

Many of Malik's neighbors in Barispada are tight-lipped when it comes to talking about Tata's troubles. There is growing tension in the villages near the Tata factory as the protests continue and the plant remains closed. The Tata crisis pits neighbors against each other.

Malik says many of his neighbors are being pressured by opposition groups to protest against the carmaker. But many here already have jobs lined up at the factory or hope to.

A young man at Malik's tea shop said he got a job loading trucks at the Tata plant. For that, many of neighbors have called him a traitor.

Guinness Book of World Records

IBN mentioned[45]:

The ambitious Nano car has not rolled out of the assembly line of the makers Tata's plants yet. But it is already in the Guinness book as the world's cheapest car.

Comparison with Model T

Some news-sources have compared Ratan Tata's Tata Nano with Henry Ford's Model T that coincidentally was built around a century ago. Livemint said[46]:

Ford Motor Co. is rich because Henry Ford used the assembly-line to produce the Model T in 1908. Ratan Tata is a late entrepreneur, making the Nano in 2008. India is 100 years behind. But we are waking up to the possibility of catching up. I just hope our planners wake up soon.

Times of India mentioned[47]:

This raises the question: How have the Tatas accomplished such a task? Pursuing this question a fascinating story unfolds that reminds one of Henry Ford's Model T that was built exactly one hundred years ago (September 1908). Ford wanted to make a car for the multitude, not for the elite, with the best material and the best design that the technology of his time could devise, and he wanted to make it, above all, at a price that was affordable. This is the example that Ratan Tata has followed with determination. When he announced the price of his car in an interview to the ‘Financial Times’ during the Geneva Motor Show, his colleagues were 'aghast', but he had set his goal.

Although Ford wished to employ high quality materials, and the latest technology, the Nano instead is created from standard sheet metal, and does not offer superior materials.

Technical specifications

According to Tata Group's Chairman Ratan Tata, the Nano is a Template:Auto PS car with a 623 cc rear engine and rear wheel drive, and has a fuel economy of 4.55 L/100 km (21.97 km/L, 51.7 mpg (US), 62 mpg (UK)) under city road conditions, and 3.85 L/100 km on highways (25.97 km/L, 61.1 mpg (US), 73.3 mpg (UK)). It is the first time a two-cylinder non-opposed petrol engine will be used in a car with a single balance shaft.[48] Tata Motors has reportedly filed 34 patents related to the innovations in the design of Nano, with powertrain accounting for over half of them.[49] The project head, Girish Wagh has been credited with being one of the brains behind Nano's design.[49][50]

Much has been made of Tata's patents pending for the Nano. Yet during a news conference at the New Delhi Auto Expo, Ratan Tata pointed out none of these is revolutionary or represents earth-shaking technology. He said most relate to rather mundane items such as the two-cylinder engine’s balance shaft, and how the gears were cut in the transmission.

Though the car has been appreciated by many sources, including Reuters due to "the way it has tweaked existing technologies to target an as-yet untapped segment of the market", yet it has been stated by the same sources that Nano is not quite "revolutionary in its technology", just low in price[51]. Moreover, technologies which are expected of the new and yet-to-be-released car include a revolutionary compressed-air fuel system[52] and an eco-friendly electric-version[18], technologies on which Tata is reportedly already working, though no official incorporation-date for these technologies in the new car has been released.

According to Tata, the Nano complies with Bharat Stage-III and Euro-IV emission standards[53]. Ratan Tata also said, 'The car has passed the full-frontal crash and the side impact crash'.[54]. Tata Nano passed the required 'homologation’ tests with Pune-based Automotive Research Association of India (ARAI).This means that the car has met all the specified criteria for roadworthiness laid out by the government including emissions or noise & vibration and can now ply on Indian roads. Tata Nano managed to score around 24 km per litre during its ‘homologation’ tests with ARAI. This makes Tata Nano the most fuel efficient car in India. Nano will be the first car in India to display the actual fuel mileage figures it recorded at ARAI’s tests on its windshield. According to ARAI it conforms to Euro IV emission standards which will come into effect in India in 2010.[55]

Rear mounted engine

The use of a rear mounted engine to help maximize interior space makes the Nano similar to the original Fiat 500, another technically innovative "people's car". A concept vehicle similar in styling to the Nano, also with rear engined layout was proposed by the UK Rover Group in the 1990s to succeed the original Mini but was not put into production.[56] The eventual new Mini was much larger and technically conservative. The independent, and now-defunct, MG Rover Group later based their Rover CityRover on the Tata Indica.

Tata is also reported to be contemplating offering a compressed air engine as an option [57]

Engine: 2 cylinder petrol with Bosch multi-point fuel injection (single injector) all aluminium 33 horsepower (25 kW) 624 cc (38 cu in)
Value Motronic engine management platform from Bosch
2 valves per cylinder overhead camshaft
Compression ratio: 9.5:1
bore × stroke: 73.5 mm (2.9 in) × 73.5 mm (2.9 in)
Power: Template:Auto PS @ 5500 rpm[58]
Torque: 48 N⋅m (35 ft⋅lbf) @ 2500 rpm
Layout and Transmission Rear wheel drive
4-speed manual transmission
Steering mechanical rack and pinion
Performance Acceleration: 0-70 km/h (43 mph): 14 seconds
Maximum speed: 120 km/h (75 mph)[2]
Fuel efficiency (overall): 20 kilometres per litre (Template:L/100km)[3]
Body and dimensions Seat belt: 4[59]
Trunk capacity: 15 L (0.53 cu ft)[3]
Suspension, Tires & Brakes Front brake: disc[60]
Rear brake: drum
Front track: 1,325 mm (52.2 in)
Rear track: 1,315 mm (51.8 in)
Ground clearance: 180 mm (7.1 in)[3]
Front suspension: McPherson strut with lower A arm
Rear suspension: Independent coil spring
12-inch wheels[61]
Supplier [62] Product [62]
Bosch Gasoline injection system (diesel will follow), starter, alternator, brake system
HSI AUTO Static sealing systems (Weather Strips)
Caparo Inner structural panels
Continental AG Gasoline fuel supply system, fuel level sensor
Delphi Instrument cluster
Denso Windshield wiper system (single motor and arm)
FAG Rear-wheel bearing
Ficosa Rear-view mirrors, interior mirrors, manual and CVT shifters, washer system
Freudenberg Engine sealing
GKN Driveshafts
INA Shifting elements
ITW Deltar Outside and inside door handles
Johnson Controls Seating
Mahle Camshafts, spin-on oil filters, fuel filters and air cleaners
Saint-Gobain Glazing
TRW Brake system
Ceekay Daikin/Valeo Clutch sets
Vibracoustic Engine mounts
Visteon Air induction system
ZF Friedrichshafen AG Chassis components, including tie rods
Behr HVAC for the luxury version

Variants

Besides the regular and conventional gasoline-variant [27], the following variants are also expected:

Diesel

Together with Diesel Engine specialist FEV Tata Motors is developing a 684 cc diesel engine for the Nano. It was earlier reported by media that Tata was producing an 800 cc Common Rail diesel engine.Diesel Variant will be available in September, 2009. Diesel variant Nano will sell for Rs2 lakh (200,000 rupees). Nano will have the smallest Common Rail Turbocharged Diesel engine in the world and is expected to deliver sterling fuel economy figures.[63]

Eco-friendly variants and initiatives

Tata Motors is reportedly working on some very revolutionary and eco-friendly initiatives, some of which are personally-supported and appreciated by Mr. Ratan Tata. Other than their Gasoline engine, Tata Motors will offer following options:

Compressed-air engine

Tata Motors is working with a French firm on using compressed air as an energy source[52] which is eco-friendly and revolutionary in itself for a car of such large-scale. The company has tied up with Moteur Development International (MDI) for this purpose:[27]

Electric drivetrain or electric-version

Tata is also believed to be making an electric version of the Nano, called the E-Nano (reportedly with attached or sideby solar panels as well)[18][64] which might prove to be a boon for the society and the world, both in terms of cost and technology, as it might well turn out to be the "world's cheapest electric car"[65] which is more eco-friendly and has many enthusiasts and media for its support[66]. It's supposed to be as cheap as the conventional gasoline version. Tata is making the Nano compliant with export market regulations[67] and plans to export such a car worldwide, particularly to the UK and the rest of continental Europe[68][69], the US[70], and Australia[71][72][73][74].

Economic Times reported[75] that the "electric Nano" "would still make good sense for economic, clean and green personal mobility in countries around the world." According to the Hamburg-based newspaper, Auto Bild, the E-Nano would be built in cooperation with the Norwegian electric car specialist, Miljøbil Grenland AS [76] [77] [78][79].

Enthusiastic support

Tata Motors received preliminary enthusiastic-support in the media as well as in government circles (including Europe and other states) for the electric-variant of Nano.[80] The enthusiasm is reportedly even higher than that for the petrol-variant[81].

The Hindu quoted European Commission’s Director General for Energy and Transport, Matthias Ruete, as saying[82]:

I can say that alike other nations, entire Europe is also eagerly awaiting the commercial launch of Nano. But keeping in mind the adverse impact of carbon dioxide (CO2) on environment, it would be advisable to have Nano’s electric version. I hope Tata (Ratan) is working on it.

Hybrid

Some news-sources state that "a hybrid version [of Tata Nano] is also likely, although it is not yet known whether the electric motor will be paired with a gasoline or diesel version."[83] Other sources also favored it and argued that "India needs needs Tata Prius [similar to Toyota Prius] and not Tata Nano."[84]

Trim levels

The Nano will be available in three trim levels[citation needed]:-

  • Standard
  • Deluxe
  • Luxury

The base $2,500 getting no air conditioning[citation needed]. The Deluxe and Luxury variants will get AC and body colored bumpers. Luxury variant will also have alloy wheels, fog lamps and ICE[citation needed]. Tata Motors plans to sell more expensive version in order to keep product line profitable[citation needed].

Picture depicting Tata Nano's Variants, Trim Levels, Interiors and Dimensions.
  • Nano unveiled at Delhi Auto Expo 08.
    Nano unveiled at Delhi Auto Expo 08.
  • The interior of the Nano.
    The interior of the Nano.
  • Red Tata Nano : Standard Model.
    Red Tata Nano : Standard Model.
  • Rear of Tata Nano in Yellow.
    Rear of Tata Nano in Yellow.

Singur factory pullout

Singur car factory land dispute arose as Tata's planned manufacturing unit for the car in, Singur, where the state government of West Bengal had allocated 997 acres (4.03 km2) to Tata Motors.[85] The construction of the car factory on that tract of land began in January 2007 on fertile agricultural land and the expropriation and eviction of approximately 15,000 peasants and agricultural workers. The affected farmers have fears that they will receive inadequate or no compensation and therefore lose their livelihoods.[86]

Activists near Kolkata, where Tata's manufacturing unit is located, burnt the car effigy.[87] In New Delhi, a group of six women protested wearing T-shirts bearing slogans that said, "The Rs 1 lakh car has Singur people's blood on it." [88] The Trinamool Congress alleged that Tata motors usurped the agrarian land for the construction site and have threatened to stall the manufacture of the car.[89]

Relocation and pullout

On 2 October 2008, Ratan Tata officially announced that Tata Motors is pulling the Tata Nano project out of Singur and "evaluating options from Maharasthtra and Gujarat," as well as Karnataka to relocate the plant and machinery. The move is said to put up to Rs 80,000 cr at stake because there is no guarantee that Trinamool Congress would not be further emboldened by their success against the Tata's to launch similar agitations against land acquisition for other industrial ventures.[90] Narendra Modi's business-friendly Gujarat (of which Tata once commented "It is stupid if you are not in Gujarat [3]") is said to be a leading option.[91]

Ratan Tata announced on Oct. 7, 2008 that he is going to move his plant to Sanand in Ahmedabad district of Gujarat. Indian Prime minister Manmohan Singh commented that "it is certainly sad the way and the circumstances in which Ratan Tata had to move his project."[92]

Admitted mistake(s) in land-acquisition

In an interview, Ratan Tata admitted[93]: "I take the responsibility (for the Singur issue). They offered us the land in Kharagpur. We would have gone there. But, I rang up Buddhadev."

Tata motors on October 17, 2008 issued an advertisement in four newspapers in Kolkata which is an open letter by Ratan Tata. In it, he refers to the exit of the Nano from Bengal and asks if the people of the state want jobs or lawlessness. [4]

Comments by politicians

On 21 September 2008, West Bengal Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee ultimately said, "The project will go out of West Bengal, if there is further delay. Therefore without any more loss of time Tata Motors and ancillary units should be allowed to work at Singur. I appeal to the opposition parties to accept the government's package on the land acquisition at Singur for the Tata Motors factory and withdraw the agitation. If there is further delay, this project will leave West Bengal."[94] External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee said, “If a group like the Tatas leaves West Bengal it will be unfortunate … a major setback to industrialisation in the State.” However, on 22 September 2008, Mamata Banerjee (politician), virtually unperturbed by the warnings, threatened to resume her agitation again, asking indifferently for return of 300 acres (1.2 km2) or more, instead of 70 acres (280,000 m2) that the government offered.[95][96] According to The Times of India[97]: {{cquote| Mamata is sticking to her land-for-land demand, hoping that her stubborn stand will yield electoral dividends in rural Bengal it doesn't matter if Tatas exit Singur. Even her own colleagues in Trinamool have got fed up and are equally frustrated with didi's arrogance but they don't dare go against her. "I am fed up. Let the Tatas do whatever they want. The war of nerves is getting too much," a senior Trinamool leader said.

Mamata Banerjee of Trinamool Congress has reportedly been "voicing provocative speeches to instigate Trinamool supporters to cause vandalism in Singur", to improve her public-image and to get popularity for winning elections[98]. And as expected, the Tatas have moved out of West Bengal. Many economists consider the Tata move out of West Bengal the beginning of the end for the economic and industrial development of the state.

Failures

Of talks

"The talks between West Bengal Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee and Trinamool Congress chief Mamata Banerjee on Friday evening to settle the Singur imbroglio failed to bring out any positive results", Economic Times[99] as well as others[100] reported.

Of "package"

The "package" initially offered by Tata Motors was rejected due to which the land-dispute resulted. Again, an updated "package" was rejected and criticised as "unfair" by the people[101][102][103]. News-sources mentioned that the offer to get 50% more assistance for land-losers is simply not enough[citation needed].

Of Singur plant

IBNLive reported[104]:

Initially, it was being presumed that Singur would be delayed and the first Nano would roll out from some other Tata factory. Now it appears that Singur might lose the project completely.

The Telegraph reported[105]: "It is believed that the Tatas have told the government they will wait till September 22, the last date for registration of beneficiaries of the package".

Aftermath

No land-return

West Bengal Industry Minister Nirupam Sen has said that there was no legal provision under which the state government could return land to the farmers. This could result in lack of livelihood to protesting farmers and would become an utter failure for Mamata Banerjee (politician) and her Trinamool Congress political-party who opposed Tata's plant. Sen said[106]:

On the issue of returning the acquired land, we hold that there is no such provison in the Indian Constitution. The present owner of the land is the state government. There is no legal provison by which one can return the land to the farmers or to the previous owners. There is really no need now more than ever to enter into any dialogue with the opposition any longer. The court of law shall hold onto the cheques of those who had not accepted them for whatever reasons. Tata pullout has harmed industrialisation in the state. Politics would never allow any good to happen to Bengal. Trinamool Congress wanted exactly this to happen -- let blood be shed. The blood letting they would utilise shamelessly for political ends.

Corporate Rivalry

Tata Nano was envisioned as the four wheelers for those who can only afford two wheelers, due to its affordable price Nano's impact on two wheelers sales has been widely debated, Nano will also affect sales of higher priced Cars or will motivate competitors to reduce the prices resulting lowered margins for rest of the industry.

Due to Longevity of the protest by Trinamool Congress, many people in the media have hinted that rival Corporates have funded and provided logistics for TMC's protest to Sabotage the Nano project so that its launch can be delayed and costs can be increased. In a single day of the protest, food bill alone ran into millions of rupees.

It has been speculated that money to sustain such a prolonged protest involving thousands of TMC party workers came from rival Two/Four Wheeler lobby. Rahul Bajaj, the chairman of Bajaj Auto gave an interview in which he lauded Mamta Banerjee's effort and stated that what she is doing is for the welfare of poor farmers.[107], Bajaj auto is also developing a low cost car together with Renault-Nissan to rival Tata Nano [108] . In a debate show organized by NDTV a leading Business Magazine's editor in chief hinted that Bajaj Auto is financing Mamta Banerjee. After the telecast of this debate Rahul Bajaj denied the allegations and threatened to sue the editor of Businessworld magazine for defamation.

Mamta Banerjee's reaction towards the relocation package by West Bengal government also gave fuel to these theories. West Bengal government offered land to the displaced farmer nearby Tata Motors plant, Mamta Banerjee's refused to accept the package and asked for the land inside the project area to be returned.

Plant(s) and proposed manufacturing facilities

Nano will be produced at the Mother Plant in Sanand, Gujarat and the Satellite plant at Pantnagar where assembly lines of Ace Truck have been modified to produce Nanos[109].

After pullout from Singur Tata Motors decided to setup mother plant in the state of Gujarat due to proximity to major ports like Mundra and cities like Rajkot where 30% of Nano's components are manufactured and the proposed plant site is fully owned by the Government therefore there will be no issue in land transfer. Gujarat state is also known for Gujarati's positive attitude towards businesses.

It is not yet known when the first batch will be produced at the Sanand plant, meanwhile Tata Motors is producing Nano at its plant in Pant Nagar and Pune to meet its deadline for the launch.

Criticism, issues and problems

Questions of safety

The Times says[110]:

India has 8 per cent of the world’s vehicle fatalities and less than 1 per cent of its cars, with more than 90,000 people killed on the country’s roads every year. Introducing a million Nanos into the mix may bring more – and unwelcome – headlines.

Tata, which has the only crash-test facility in the country, said that the Nano "exceeds current regulatory requirements". And while it is not a deathtrap – it has crumple zones, seat belts and strong seat anchors – it is worth bearing in mind that total vehicle crash testing (rather than just frontal impact), airbags and antilock braking systems are not mandatory.

Without these, the Nano would not even be considered for approval in Britain. Adding them would double its price in India, which is why they have been omitted.

It is believed that Tata Motors will offer a version of the Nano with these safety-features, including an airbag system in its electric version[citation needed]. Tata said the Nano has an all sheet-metal body, with safety features such as crumple zones, intrusion-resistant doors, seat-belts, strong seats and anchorages, and the rear tailgate glass bonded to the body. Tires are tubeless.[111]

Mass motorization and climate change

As the Nano was conceived and designed around introducing the automobile to a sector of the population who are currently using eco-friendly bicycles and motorcycles, environmentalists are concerned that its extraordinarily low price might lead to mass motorization in countries like India and therefore possibly aggravate pollution and global warming as well as increase the demand for oil[112]. Rajendra Pachauri, an Indian and chairman of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, said he was "having nightmares" because of this car and added that the car represents bankruptcy of India's environmental policy[113][114]. The ecology focused German newspaper die tageszeitung feels that such concerns are "inappropriate" as the Tata Nano has lower emissions compared to the average Volkswagen, and that developing countries shouldn't be denied the right to motorized mobility when industrialized countries should be looking to reduce their emissions and usage of cars.[115] Die Welt reports that the car conforms with environmental protection, and will have the lowest emissions in India.[116]

In crowded metropolitan cities like Mumbai, Ratan Tata has conceived a scheme to only offer the Nano to those individuals who do not have an automobile already. The Nano will also replace many overloaded and worn-out two-stroke polluting vehicles, both two and three-wheeled. In the current policy and regulatory framework, Centre for Science and Environment consider that the economy cars will be disastrous. [52]

However, this can change if eco-friendly variants (cited above) are manufactured, instead of the conventional petrol and diesel based versions.

Used car market effects

The Nano is alleged to have severely affected the used car market in India, as many Indians opt to wait for the Nano's release rather than buying used cars, such as the Maruti 800 (a rebadged Suzuki Alto), which is considered as the Nano's nearest competitor. Sales of new Maruti 800s have dropped by 20%, and used ones by 30% following the unveiling of the Nano. As one automotive journalist summarises; “People are asking themselves – and us - why they should pay, say, 250,000 Rupees for a Maruti Alto, when they can wait and get a brand new Nano for less in a few months’ time, a car that is actually bigger”.[117]

Competitors

Bajaj Auto

Bajaj Auto-Renault-Nissan ULC (no prototype has yet been presented) [118]

Bajaj Auto says its $2,500 car, which it is building with Renault and Nissan Motor, will aim at a fuel-efficiency of 30 km/litre, or twice an average small car, and carbon dioxide emissions of 100 gm/km. [119]

The Bajaj venture will have an initial capacity of 400,000 units, while Tata expects eventual demand of 1 million Nanos.

Others

Rival car makers including Fiat, General Motors, Ford Motor, Hyundai and Toyota Motor have all expressed interest in building a small car that is affordable to more middle-class consumers in emerging markets. The bulk of demand there is for small cars because people are much more sensitive to fuel prices.[119]

Honda and Toyota are leading the way on so called cleaner gasoline-electric hybrids, and some environmentalists argue getting prices down on these technologies is where efforts should be concentrated.[119]

Inexpensive and eco-friendly electric-cars like Tara Tiny, Oreva Super (both reportedly even cheaper than Tata Nano) and REVA[120] pose even more significant danger to Nano.

See also

References

  1. ^ "Specifications of Tata's Nano". cardesignnew.
  2. ^ a b c d "Specifications of Tata's Nano". indiatimes.com. 2008-01-10. Retrieved 2008-01-10.
  3. ^ a b c d e "Nano Mania". Autocar India. February 2008. Retrieved 2008-02-05.
  4. ^ Mohanty, Mrituinjoy (2008-01-10). "Why criticising the 1-Lakh car is wrong". Rediff News. Retrieved 2008-01-10.
  5. ^ a b "Tata Nano - world's cheapest new car is unveiled in India". driving.timesonline.co.uk. Retrieved 2008-01-21.
  6. ^ a b "First Look: Ratan Tata unveils Nano". IBN. 2008-01-10. Retrieved 2008-01-10.
  7. ^ a b "Tata unveils Nano, its $2,500 car". MSN. 10 January 2008. Retrieved 2008-01-11. {{cite web}}: Check date values in: |date= (help)
  8. ^ "Tata Motors to launch 'Nano' on March 23". Press Trust of India. 2008-02-26. Retrieved 2008-02-26.
  9. ^ "Small, It's The New Big". Newsweek, Keith Naughton, Feb 25, 2008.
  10. ^ "Tata's High-Stakes Bet on Low-Cost Car". The Wall Street Journal, Eric Bellman, Jan 10, 2008.
  11. ^ Dawn News: The Nano: small is beautiful, by Rahul Singh
  12. ^ a b http://www.businessweek.com/innovate/content/feb2008/id20080227_377233.htm
  13. ^ http://www.businessweek.com/innovate/content/feb2008/id20080227_377233_page_2.htm
  14. ^ http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/articleshow/2694186.cms
  15. ^ http://driving.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/driving/article3164205.ece
  16. ^ http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/Investing/Extra/WorldsCheapestCarArrivesTomorrow.aspx
  17. ^ http://www.enn.com/sci-tech/article/37437
  18. ^ a b c http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/3386709.cms
  19. ^ http://www.hindustantimes.com/StoryPage/StoryPage.aspx?sectionName=&id=acf176cd-6f53-42b6-a47b-72e34341cfe1&&Headline=Tataplanningelectric-driveversionofNano&strParent=strParentID
  20. ^ http://www.autocar.co.uk/News/NewsArticle/AllCars/230103/
  21. ^ http://www.automotiveworld.com/AEM/content.asp?contentid=66287
  22. ^ http://www.financialexpress.com/news/Tata-may-export-Nano-to-promising-mkts/308955/
  23. ^ http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/driving/news/article3168303.ece
  24. ^ http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/driving/article3164205.ece
  25. ^ http://www.cbc.ca/consumer/story/2008/01/10/nano-tata.html
  26. ^ http://www.engadget.com/2008/07/03/tatas-nano-to-begin-production-this-fall-eco-friendly-version/
  27. ^ a b c http://www.merinews.com/catFull.jsp?articleID=139838
  28. ^ http://www.telegraphindia.com/1081007/jsp/opinion/story_9933949.jsp
  29. ^ http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/e68ab572-8a3e-11dd-a76a-0000779fd18c.html
  30. ^ http://www.financialexpress.com/news/Nano-dampener-for-Tata-dealers/363718/
  31. ^ http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/articleshow/msid-3571177,flstry-1.cms
  32. ^ a b c d "The Next People's Car". Yahoo Finance. 2007-04-17. Retrieved 2008-01-11. {{cite news}}: Check date values in: |date= (help)
  33. ^ "1 lakh car drives 1 billion dreams". Indian Express. 2008-01-11. Retrieved 2008-01-15. {{cite news}}: Check date values in: |date= (help)
  34. ^ a b "All eyes on Tatas' Rs 1 lakh car". Times of India. 2008-01-08. Retrieved 2008-01-14. {{cite news}}: Check date values in: |date= (help)
  35. ^ http://www.hindu.com/2008/09/14/stories/2008091455040700.htm
  36. ^ http://www.hindu.com/2008/09/14/stories/2008091455040700.htm
  37. ^ http://www.ecogeek.org/content/view/1943/69/
  38. ^ http://www.ibnlive.com/news/latest-guinness-book-celebrates-tata-nano-car/73807-2.html
  39. ^ http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/articleshow/2694186.cms
  40. ^ http://www.businessweek.com/innovate/content/feb2008/id20080227_377233_page_2.htm
  41. ^ "Materials prices could push up cost of Tata's Nano". Motor Authority, 7 July 2008.
  42. ^ a b "Rising costs could eat Tata Nano's profits". Motor Authority, Tuesday 5 August 2008.
  43. ^ http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/articleshow/2694186.cms
  44. ^ a b http://www.voanews.com/english/2008-09-17-voa45.cfm
  45. ^ http://www.ibnlive.com/news/latest-guinness-book-celebrates-tata-nano-car/73807-2.html
  46. ^ http://www.livemint.com/2008/09/14215403/The-car8230and-the-planner.html?h=B
  47. ^ http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/Opinion/Editorial/LEADER_ARTICLE_More_Than_Just_A_Nano/articleshow/3482989.cms
  48. ^ "Tata Nano, Unveiled!". Gawker Media. 2008-01-10. Retrieved 2008-01-10.
  49. ^ a b "It's a car, not an apology". Times of India. 2008-01-11. Retrieved 2008-01-11.
  50. ^ "The Next Peoples' Car". Forbes. 2007-04-16.
  51. ^ http://blogs.reuters.com/events/2008/01/15/detroit-auto-show-tatas-nano-is-talk-of-show/
  52. ^ a b c ENN: How green is my low-cost car? India revs up debate
  53. ^ "Ratan Tata unveils Rs 1-lakh 'Nano'". expressindia.com. Retrieved 2008-01-10.
  54. ^ "This is what the Tata Rs 1-lakh car looks like!". rediff.
  55. ^ "Nano passes Indian road test". indiatimes.com.
  56. ^ "Rover Mini 'Spiritual' project". austin-rover.co.uk. Retrieved 2008-01-13.
  57. ^ "Tata Nano To Offer Compressed Air Engine Optional, Make Electric Cars Look Silly". Retrieved 2008-07-22.
  58. ^ "Tata Motors unveils the People's Car". tatamotors.com. Retrieved 2008-01-10.
  59. ^ Ruth David (January 10, 2008). "Tata Unveils The Nano, Its $2,500 Car". Forbes.com.
  60. ^ "Here what Tata's Rs 1-lakh car - the Nano - looks like!". Rediff News. 2008-01-10. Retrieved 2008-01-10.
  61. ^ "India's £1,250 car". autoexpress.co.uk. Retrieved 2008-01-14.
  62. ^ a b "India's Tata low-cost Nano took a lot of high-tech". ae-plus.
  63. ^ [1]
  64. ^ http://www.hindustantimes.com/StoryPage/StoryPage.aspx?sectionName=&id=acf176cd-6f53-42b6-a47b-72e34341cfe1&&Headline=Tata+planning+electric-drive+version+of+Nano&strParent=strParentID
  65. ^ http://www.ecogeek.org/content/view/1943/69/
  66. ^ http://www.merinews.com/catFull.jsp?title=Let%20Tata's%20Nano%20be%20electric&articleID=141391
  67. ^ http://www.forbes.com/2008/01/11/tata-nano-competition-markets-equity-cx_rd_0111markets04.html
  68. ^ http://www.autocar.co.uk/News/NewsArticle/AllCars/230103/
  69. ^ http://www.automotiveworld.com/AEM/content.asp?contentid=66287
  70. ^ http://www.rediff.com/money/2008/may/13tata.htm
  71. ^ http://www.financialexpress.com/news/Tata-may-export-Nano-to-promising-mkts/308955/
  72. ^ http://autofix.com.au/blog/archives/492
  73. ^ http://lucire.com/insider/20080110/tata-nano%E2%80%94the-rs-1-lakh-car-revealed/
  74. ^ http://tatanano.inservices.tatamotors.com/tatamotors/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=228&Itemid=207
  75. ^ http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/Auto/Tatas_new_volt_colts_/articleshow/3524645.cms
  76. ^ http://www.miljobil.no/
  77. ^ http://www.domainb.com/companies/companies_t/Tata_Motors/20080820_tata_motors.html
  78. ^ http://www.autoindia.com/News/auto-news-india1296.html
  79. ^ http://www.domain-b.com/companies/companies_t/Tata_Motors/20080820_tata_motors.html
  80. ^ http://www.merinews.com/catFull.jsp?title=Let%20Tata's%20Nano%20be%20electric&articleID=141391
  81. ^ http://www.domain-b.com/companies/companies_t/Tata_Motors/20080820_tata_motors.html
  82. ^ http://www.hindu.com/2008/09/14/stories/2008091455040700.htm
  83. ^ http://www.leftlanenews.com/tata-nano-to-get-diesel-hybrid-engines-in-addition-to-gasoline.html
  84. ^ http://trak.in/tags/business/2008/09/30/india-needs-tata-prius-no-tata-nano/
  85. ^ Indian car factory faces 'siege' Rahul Tandon, BBC News, 23 August 2008. Retrieved 2008-08-24
  86. ^ Food First Information & Action Network: India: Right to food of 15,000 peasants threatened by a car manufacturing unit of Tata Motors
  87. ^ "Fiery protest over Tata's Nano". CNet News. 2008-01-11. Retrieved 2008-01-12.
  88. ^ "Singur protesters show up at launch, raise slogans". Times of India. 2008-01-11. Retrieved 2008-01-12.
  89. ^ "Trinamool Congress threatens to stall manufacture of Tata's Nano unless Tata distributed 100,000 Nanos for free". Indian Express. 2008-01-12. Retrieved 2008-01-12.
  90. ^ http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/For_Bengal_its_not_just_a_Nano_loss/articleshow/3558059.cms
  91. ^ http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/News/News_By_Industry/Auto/Automobiles/Nano_project_may_drive_into_Bhuj_say_industry_sources/articleshow/3558182.cms
  92. ^ http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/News_by_Industry/Nano_shiftover_a_sad_experience_PM/articleshow/3642330.cms
  93. ^ http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/articleshow/msid-3571177,flstry-1.cms
  94. ^ http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/Singur_row_Delay_will_result_in_Tatas_leaving_WB/articleshow/3509982.cms
  95. ^ http://www.hindu.com/2008/09/22/stories/2008092259861200.htm
  96. ^ http://www.expressindia.com/latest-news/Tata-threatens-Singur-pullout-Mamata-wont-budge/352052/
  97. ^ http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/India/Tata_rolls_equipment_out_of_Singur/articleshow/3519711.cms
  98. ^ http://verbalinspiration.wordpress.com/2008/08/29/does-mamata-banerjee-want-to-shutdown-tata-nano-singur-plant/
  99. ^ http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/Automobiles/Singur_row_Talks_between_Buddhadeb_Mamata_fail/articleshow/3477373.cms
  100. ^ http://www.hindu.com/thehindu/holnus/000200809122221.htm
  101. ^ http://www.reuters.com/article/rbssConsumerGoodsAndRetailNews/idUSDEL35390820080916
  102. ^ http://www.hindustantimes.com/Redir.aspx?ID=e5b15d82-d00b-4267-8f6f-eff6b6a48cf6&SectionName=Cricket
  103. ^ http://www.thestandard.com.hk/breaking_news_detail.asp?id=6127&icid=4&d_str=20080916
  104. ^ http://www.ibnlive.com/news/gandhigiri-over-singur-reaches-a-dead-end/73809-3.html
  105. ^ http://www.telegraphindia.com/1080918/jsp/bengal/story_9851374.jsp
  106. ^ http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/News/News_By_Industry/Auto/Automobiles/Post_Tatas_exit_will_the_Singur_land_be_returned/articleshow/3567262.cms
  107. ^ http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/News/News_By_Industry/Auto/Automobiles/Rahul_Bajaj_says_Mamata_fought_for_farmers_not_politics/articleshow/3456250.cms
  108. ^ http://www.autoexpo.in/news_jan_23.asp
  109. ^ http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/News_by_Industry/Nano_to_rollout_from_Pantnagar/articleshow/3523806.cms
  110. ^ http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/driving/news/article3168303.ece
  111. ^ http://in.reuters.com/article/topNews/idINIndia-35844720081007
  112. ^ 2008 Issues
  113. ^ http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/driving/article3164205.ece
  114. ^ http://www.cbc.ca/consumer/story/2008/01/10/nano-tata.html
  115. ^ Der Spiegel Online: India Delivers World's Cheapest Car
  116. ^ "Deutscher Konzern verdient am Tata kräftig mit" (in German). Die Welt. 10 January 2008. Retrieved 2008-03-22. {{cite web}}: Check date values in: |date= (help); Italic or bold markup not allowed in: |publisher= (help)
  117. ^ "Nanomania overwhelms Indian car market". Autocar.co.uk. 2008-02-07. Retrieved 2008-02-10.
  118. ^ Green Car Congress: Bajaj Auto and Renault-Nissan Form JV To Build Ultra Low Cost Car
  119. ^ a b c "Bajaj Auto and Renault-Nissan Form JV To Build Ultra Low Cost Car". Environmental News Network, June 19, 2008.
  120. ^ http://wheels.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/09/24/tiny-and-tax-free-the-electric-reva/
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Tata_Nano&oldid=273579530"